Ms Maa Bhuvneshwari Ice and Coldstorage v. State Bank of India

DRT24 Nov 2022SA/546/2022

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This judgment records the proceedings in a writ petition challenging a warrant issued by the High Court questioning the remand of a detenue charged with murder. The judgment outlines the procedural history, including the detention order, the High Court's order to produce the detenue, and the petitioners' contentions regarding the jurisdiction and validity of the trial court's remand order.

What the court decided

AI extract

Ms Maa Bhuvneshwari Ice and Coldstorage versus State Bank… — Criminal Trial and Appeal | DRT (2022)

¶1

qH. q. ;rN-s46/2022

¶2

¶3

xrr eqft oTBfivur sedgr F^{q yq ud-srra} nw)

¶4

(ffi{ orBmrfr - qrf,{q afr vrq ft-qrw c}d)

¶5

Yfl.^{q. q6rt} - 546/2022

¶6

1 fu-$^q 5-{ffi snf-s Vrs oieetto. ffifr.W. so7rr,^qH Eod5qr, ilE-{ftd s fudT^qrq, q.q- 4s4773 2 fr^qro frE dTer fr-dT fr g,rq fti-a o-q{, Tq. c-{r or, tR-q^qdq ft.rgE.-i, Tg, {dr q.g.- 4s2011 slrf{6'rtur F$E 1 ra_c to dm. sBqr, gm olexr{'w 3lrfu"€y, qcre-d F-fls t-s, gdr, q.g. 4520011 ercrtffi'rm

¶7

3rTi-{6rruT d ft\ sfi qrfur errqE orD--{frT r s-d-{qrfr }fi d ftq * E-fi-d dr vE &fi rrfuq S-{ 3rBq-ffi1

¶8

eill3T

¶9

(ffi-6 24.,t1.2022 o) dFo)

¶10

r. 3riffi-{q gT{r q6 qT-{fi rrm rz (r) wtrtfi T{e 2oo2 d^qTstrmr{e.x ft-flo 27.062022 !6} s{r Grfuo-roT d r+qel rirr qa-tr, 3rfuq-.q {srT \rq fic,ilfi Wil^{ft-flzF22.08.22} ffi-a' 1e.s722 o] srqTqg frrd qri +1 vrarqoi tg ryd fo-qr rTqT B t

¶11

w.^{g. q{t-546/2022}

¶12

¶13

eqd fu-d Ti^q-m-rrT o-r €e)q q-rT tr6R B fu w{ oil'fifr o-qro r d ftr 3,B5,oo,ooo/- (fi-{ ots q-sr$ clq) rrqd or xq qd zorz d lilqr q'mr eiriro o-qro r d rqp-- o1 erqa {Tqk s{t{ {q{ 62/2/2 d^qs{' rqq 62/2^q.E.q. 56111 qlrr \oe-gcT (fo-dTq) ilf,Sd Ts fu-dr ern T6-qT +rao qrfite{ Vq g.-rr{T qq-r 438/3/2,43e/s/2 flq qHqrq ilefid rqf+wa +zso qrifi"{, fumr E-& qem sfi .r$ ,fi, fug g-dq-qrfi il6 Ersr cn-flr t 1,2o,ooo/- (go erq fi=s run) w-i q,BH-S d w fr qlR fi o-q ft..qr^..lsT B yq or ots $m o-0-s) sqn fi^plE fi t fu-{ rft orri{6-,Tq d aiT ftir+ 23.11.2020 -1 'iffir /2 .q 16 g{d rrqlqm !-kilq 2,4e,oo,ooo / - (d EDi-c wqRr drrs) s!-d oT nrgo fuur .rqt ffi B-trrsrfr d'o d An gi@r ,/3 d qtqq t. f{+ro zorozozo o) {fr-mn fr fuq rrqTt eil+{o i s qftyrd rtfrr ,fr qrrT o-r fr, fu-i ff fr-rT mr rp-+ offi-a fr,t fr orcrms wrr ga-lr qarqd: H-.F 23.0s.2022 (g}@r ,/4) ft{ ffio rg.oz.zozz^q-6'rRrf, oq fr G qqfu onq To^qqs'Bqk or qrdfuo 3rftrdq g_f,t-qrfr }-o aqr T€l fuqt^.Tqr t qfu SE) ffi oTffi q-{il-h-a o{ fi Tg, d tuD ft-w tr

¶14

3ri-e6^qeT 61 3ry) ffi5qq t fb fiarfi E"ril^{ofiil{o]Tur d qkrrd} rrl i) orfra fr Tfr o1^.r$ I Tm'^{q? .rrqrsr{ ql} T$ fiqr ft-rTo 23os.zo22 t gi-flr q,/5 d w fr s-firRrd ol G ffi frqq^it en}ro^qa eRT Gil-qfu^,fr E-d tnrr$ G, fu-g^g-rrwrfr i.o d am ot{^q-qrq r-€l ftsT^rrqT, f6-g wrr q*+r nRd frd ft-rT 3lfuqs q++ o1 o.rffi ftrd fr-rT of w rS ffi o.ffi Wf-o, qfuo t r .'rqfu frE-o w t oil-iEo seT Eh-T Eq^qrcT Wfrq .fr orX-* +Sr fuqr Tqr erT, ae Gn.) of of$ 68ffi fu-qr GrlT fAB nB( rS t r f$r qtr+ qqfu furqld q-fu a M d fr qfr erfr, Eu oxq

¶15

gtl. . rq-{-546//2022

¶16

¶17

s-cilq-qt-fr d-o' o) 3{rd-{firrq d ft-w rrffi rqd d crqqrfr d strn oTffi fttd qri of erffior ff Tfi t t f€l enqrt w^{qifu-o qsrqor} c-il{ frrd sri or ergtv flo-qr^.rqr t t

¶18

BRrqTfr^qer o1 ef< t u-go ffi .ri q-+-s d^qrErq t^qft-Er< fu-qf rqr t fu 3nlcf, qel rrqT '6 5{d^{qqErrqTftTlrt o-[ q-onq ftqfR-drrqq} frfl d 3r{i o-{qr^erT, fuE rffi qr ftTi6 20.10.2020 qfr pTd d ot5T{rq 10^q.frpTd so fufll d erE{ arqr ori o1 pTd g$ i-fr o1 G fuql^.b-r-{nT vm g{d qrqtLrj q{flrs 3xtq,d iEr ffi r1;++ vie.r srn,/8 d qnsq + 3ni<o ceT o) ffiozoozzozr o)frwgottr

¶19

snt^qfterE fu-ql lqr B fu onilffi s&T cr em qa;Tr of fqEq-d ilffi o1 .r$ t H.rq fr oTfuq-.q T*qrflft oTffi fr ol G t. ffi'ftq-q q gqr erfuo_qnT d errr^qrftd Gilt.v ffio oo oe zozz I Td qod *fr fu,irr ur gor dr rlrq fr 4ErTfi rpn ft=+o zsoszozz, fd,rrh 1s.07.2022 o1 alffi q-< siln-{fi qer rfiorq ra' t Tq fitilfr oTffi ffio gooozozz Uq ld-416 22e62ozz d Td^{s<{qrfr d'o} an rrft fuBfi cfutrrcr) ol qim fuql 'rqT^{t, ffi} rrqq t^qrflra-q G-iffi oirt/ . s1.{,/5 gq oilr,/6) q-crq t t

¶20

vmrqffi^qeT o'f s-6 fi cft-flq t fu ord<o e-d d mq ert s) fqfuTd s{fiq. M q q.ftqn frd q.d d qrqro esrfi qqfu d ft!-q i x.q erlm sT+Erfi e-tilIF{d o1 G e I qrrlq-S-s (Tt@r cn<7s) erffiv w uigf, B I qra, E l6-rfi-{ qfrnfi gier 31R,zz) qrq. fo-qr^.rqT t r

¶21

smrqrfr^qer sfr sf{ t Grqi qqrq d qrwq rl qe fi wE fu-qT rror t fu {clfi qq-{r R-rTo rc.07.2022 d s-6IqT ii qero qqfu o1 +dT:fi "*= of ur gofr B

¶22

¶23

Vg.^q. r6[{-s46.//2022

¶24

Va sq Hqfu 2,1s,66,000/- (d o-ts q-q6 dr8r fuqrqE E-utq) $q-d d gq Wrt wqfu z,zs,so,ooo7_ (d o-t-s i-f,tri drrr qqrrr rw*) w-d q fErr o1 Broq s@cfq F+w Am zs cfryrd ol qrRT srqr frrd qri qs fr-6s gfu^qe frqrfi 23.08.2022 ffi dat d cej t ft-qT iiT goT B gq zs qft$d o1 p)q vrRi q.r ori tg flpr+ qrsqr+ d.srgvn 1q-iq"r GTR/10) d qmBr l} rrrq $l,l f4RTRd ol G t, gq wff enun) w q-{gfl 3rTtfi fr.wd frrd^qd or er-5iu fuq1 nq1 g;

¶25

sqq^qd s) tj-'ri d qeqro noqur i fqq q{r fr.n-rutq d:-

¶26

¶27

TsJ v;dt-qrfr ceT Erqr rl-qq of rrg qalfi o-rffi ffio zzoazozz <iq Wf Efor erqrw frd q.ri qt-"q t ?

¶28

EuT s-f,rqrfr to arr iBd qrq {qrT rq 3rDq-.q qan fi-+o 1202201s sis W1 et+r erqRrl frtd Gri rtrq t ?

¶29

Vil-mTI Tq arq ?

¶30

frq,r+rfr frznquhq fr-q1s,flq q5i) q'i -.F etar fr-qR^q 6q ftcpg kqr qT rrr tr

¶31

n-d d +in B-m-{qrfr qer of GN t fta ol eqrr Sq 3lfumyuT d Am qTR-d 3lrtyr ffio oo og z 022 q\ orr-offid Ex ur6 ad rer rrsl d lm 3{farrr-cq qa+ d Ew q olrd'eo ca 01 qrfusT 3r.TD qrf*a t t w +Tiur 3tq {{J f+5 w 5l: ffi o1 enqqq-rdt rfi t r 3ilArT Rflq' o6.os.zo22 o1 o-BmT s i fud qt M r\ srD!-rq tlafl T{ttrr tzozzors d Eq-q^q i{qro zzoozozz o) urgrr fu-qr rql^q6 Gil-iqc or-qtr qrBd qr{r r?TI t vq fr-oq erqT fo.i GTi or o)-g rrdq v-{6 orqn Tfr drt t fuq erqT 3nnfi {fr-mn c-€t fuqr .Tqr t oreTlf, ccE t fu 3rfuq-.q

¶32

\RI.^{g. ;r.N-546/2o22}

¶33

¶34

{+Tr^{fr-{612.02.201s} d^frs-q t^{qt{r qeT} o1^qrfu+T Td^{n fr GrqDErfud ftfRd} of w gd t r elq fi srTtyT ffio ooogzozz fr o-fr-{T rs ii o{q{ fu-or susrB-firfi erR grcr qrR-d sn+{r ffio rsozzozz q\ g_+-fr +i d ro r\ eriq z fr+q z $frqfr d eryx q-6 g{d rt-qTqm q-R[q ffi6 23.11.2020 d frsq i q-{flrfua o1 G s-eruor fr {o.ri +1^qr g+1 B vq fia d r+qer on}<o qer o1 frq t^{qa *fr q-$r} o-er.Tqr i fu E-s erEo-sur d srdvr e+o 06.0s.2022 of errn{6.rrr d av qmfrq o]ffiq 3{fuo-{q d^qqer 3ret-.tt srq Hers^{qrqtdq q} g+fr fi G d n-q c15qn fumrdTr urfin 6 sntsT fuflo. 06.0s.2022 3{frq E} g.-+T B, {t{ cr{6 t1^q-5 ffi fuqr^qTaT t fu eniEo^qer 3lEq-iq rpm fu+ro e.o22ois 3rqs fufl <'efffii trtq HrI^{qftd on+yr} f{flo 1s.02.2022 d, g-+fr ti i} ffid d gor t^gs v6 gsfl vqrqrq^q-.{rs ftq|-6 23.12ozo qr a.n+ va-i t)^q-fud s) gor B r

¶35

ilT il{6 t wr^q-s-{ot t ottt^{qn q6} oes fusri"fi'q t fu aqr sf,rqrfr t-o arr i&r qrq W+cT ftqro or rz.2o18 vq ffi o-rffi ftirq zz.oazozz erqw ftrd qd fiq t ?

¶36

3nn{fr^qer of etrq r} elra-+c d qrtqq t fu,i rri orftf,eq +1 6E-6r s o ii qe oen fu-qj q-qr t fu B-f,rdTfl to aqr o$ ,fr entEo qer o) il{r tz(z) s.{ffi V+e of w q4+ ilq-d r-S 6G .r$ qf@ {ir) ffi otffi^qqf,rfr-d ov fi G I Eq frsq d s-d{qrfi qer efi eir r\ rqo frrn ,T-q q-+rq 01 o-ftET z d qrqq r)^gcl ora o) {6Ti or-d gq, u-qo ftd .rd ilTrilq G'ier^alr/ 1) fr ond-q-o'^qa of si-i rt u-qo frrn fd-ms eTql Gltfi d q-qre {n6 22.66.2022 d w*r Tid.{ frrS ,ri d, w fta or earq 3rroff-d o-q q6 a-d rqr .rqT t fu t=,^{qa qi mrr q++ h1 ft-Er{d orffi o_G qg} d, (qiffi 311/1) mr rp-+ o1 q.fr t, furi 3nd-@ qrd

¶37

Yfl.^{(. qR-s+6/2o22}

¶38

¶39

lw arEv ErT furT6 03.122018 d vm rrrr rplr E:T(RI Hk. O{i 6T tr+o yts ql E{drerq f?,-ql ,Tqr B, ir) we t fu onil{6 qqrq z u) sd 3{ri{f, oqio r d xur 4-T et]-m-m-af Ts q-qlTilEr-q d, u-$ rr,r r{.rql o1 fqfte-d arffi g$ B r e.Isr fi qrei{Trrfi nuq o) ?fi qFT tT{cr nB_d +1 ,T$ B, fu-{r+l qft B-m-{fl-{r qa o1 ei-q g. u-ttro fr,t^rT-n $itrr alt/1) d gso. oqro i6 gs 17 fr rid.{ t vq r+s +€ t sro i&-o m qri t {trD-f, vro-fr ge oqw zo Vq zr w {Iil.{ t I Sq Tr-6 t 3rid-q-6 seT or s'6 6al-q ft{qrq qrqt c.ril t fu s-orqrfi to am 3nilc-o. qer o) mrr rlam dH-d frrd fr-rT fi gil.) sfr ordErfr nrEd o1 ,rg t r

¶40

i3 3rfUq.q q+fl ot us 5d n F,uqo fuqr qr gor t | 3r< q-61 66 froffi qqn fiT qa.r B iil s,-r{sTfl qer +1 srk t ffi W-cT^{funo,rc.07 2022} +t cfr (qiwy otl/4) q-s-iur t sf,.c o1 G t qi s{ d qrEo fu-e d-€{ \rq To erq qret qTfi cp-q dr ryrq rt-s^qk€ t nRd fu-qi qrir !-wrBn B r q,qnq-r-+c {fs 1ffi6 2e.67.2022 fr E[rn qfr ge. oqro sz w q-d-{ t, fust gc ffi d -Tq sq olTE+E n6-d frrd qri or f,++qnT cd t r ffi ffid yE orrrE 34 vq ss ,\ ir-f,.r t I^qwmrfr of urql rfr ge 6qtin 38 r\ s+ d qta {Tm-{ d :q tw e-+-Tvr{ 1q-+-fi[i Gr{,/s) tB-o qrrs-r qqrsn qz fu{is os.ol.2o22 gq r$ gfl+qT ftno os oa zozz I {-ffi furo zz oe zozz I fiqq d fiardl g+-+ noftm gil qqT qror B t

¶41

stcl^{q6l, q-6} fr s-de-fiq t fu ft-fl6 22.08.2022 oi frqfR-d o1 .T-g +m+ orffi qrqra-c-fi 6rffi fr r T-4 n ffi rpn fu<ro 23.0s.2022 1q-+@r oIR,/6) d- o{TErR q{ fq-fl6 30.06.2022 6) frcrffi qa-+ fl+tfR-o of ?fr, fr-rToT tw rorpr.q-g gfrql fu+6 29.0s.2a22^q,t cfr yE oqTo 5e q{ {{ctT-.J i f qfr-oqn

¶42

w^g. rql-s46/2022

¶43

¶44

r)trfl nft-d ftrd qri sfr i-o ffid Yg Erqiqr 62 * oa d ftq smt-{ B d rqe t fu calq ffi otffi tg so fr{ Xd +es dffi-d orTqT rrqT sTr, ilf,trqrd ilT w-qmq-fi ordqrfr tg ffi f{flo 22.0a.2022 tg rs fr+e $ A-qm 0s.08.2022 6] o1 G dfffi frqq e (r) d. wg6 d q-sty i ffirRrd rpcl qqiw i r qqB qfrillo q++, |o fmd d egm l|fl6 2807 20222, fo1-6' 25.672022, m6 26.07.2022 q-q fuflo zlo7.2oz2 o) {ffid^qer+r* o} qrw E} G efrr

¶45

15 3tat q6 daq f,fqr+frs t fu qqT ffi orf+r$ d $ B-m-wrfr to d am snd-dlflTur o1 ermq-Eqfu ol sfro s-q t Tsto-{ orro-t entltro Xe f+fRH fuqr rqT sr, gs frqq t rdt-qrfi cer o1 si-i t rtlo ffi .rn orffir E (+@r sTR/7), Tqmc qFdn{r, fu,nn ge aqr.D oa r\ oz d qsq rl-d cqt az / z R) on'{<-6 oqw z qrro R{e arEv d {flfus efi Eq-fu d,, or lsro-< tfu qq$ sm t+a nq-q{ d gxr furrd 04.12.2021 d fu-qr qil fi<ld etltlr Rcrgrroo dq 1,52,50,000//- (-o. OtS qlcFT dlq qsni EGI{) rqd rq RiT d-q t,zs,so,ooo/- (t-+' o.ts ffi-q mq qanr ron) sqn f+rfkd fuqT Tqr Ts^qrd-c tq 1,6s,52,000/- (-6 4tE S€m{ dr€r el_ct{ run) rui ftErfRd fo-qr rrqr t I vcrqrfr qer o1 sfr r) qqrs d r+rpt u-tgo H^.rn Grmqt d erg-wm noe e)-or B fu onildm qqrq z d v<Ths o1 sw eqfu or enritro T@ ffi r1s+ r{{rfr osolzo22 d e6nn 2)s,66,ooo/_ (<} ovts c'<6 drq fuqrird rurv) w-d fufRd fu-ql rqT er 3r?Tffl {drm-6 dRT^fl+rfftd 3rB6-d.q {Qq^1,6e,s2,000/ (vf o-ts s€iilr rTrB erq{ E-qR )^sq-d r)^3rD-m {@^q{ sTt<_o <6n6 2 d rqp--- 6' rrE-fu 2,1s,66,000/- (E) o-t-s^q-{d ere fuora-a wn) Fqd^q +flfr tg rffirB-d fuqr^rfqT an t

¶46

vs. c. +{r-546/2022

¶47

¶48

16 ilT trs-{q'^q T6 ts-c+{e-fis n.Q4 t fu Bd{qrfr to. qfr 3{h rt c-51.h-d o1 G ffi orffi ffio zo.oe.zo22 d c-eq q c-o-rRra of G fiilfi tTil{r q+ffi sTrc/ 4 r\ qc wE B fu +dlfi fu q-wlBd ot G^{q-fi qrqfu} t+{ r-E{ 62/2/2 qTq Tm-mgrr d qrd Rte arqr d'rqp- ol t, or onyis-d Te z,rs,oo,oool_ (Ei 6-ts qq6 dr€r fuqnr-d E-qTr) swd rqT rrsr nt fu-i ffi srffi Hqq 6-gd erru qfffi 3fffi m) qr tq-{r +dT d fu flqftd xnq * orDro ,1oa qnr hl-i .rq fr, ffi o) orftq fu-qr qr ito-.iT d erqrlT qnkr q@ w sqfu f{6q m qri tg vngn$ (ssH+c) s-@ zooz d ftw e1r; d BfiTm ur-go d ur+mrgcn uun qFm vq M dfs--t ol r€qfr t fi 3nilfrf, {@ w Eq'fu ff6q +1 qr rro.-fr t I 17. s{T e?Dwr^q str{qrfr i-6 of ei)r rt u-qo m^{.T-d q-qre} ffi6 zsos2o22 d eTel rl.e' Eq-qrTq d-er^qqT6 2208.2022 Tq eE 6qdv{ [sqr{-q furr+ 23.08.2022 tra.-{ fril .T-d dr F eol- zo w d.wd v:i ww.fr o) nR-d t-d +d osdyrq -s{rf,q Tq yE qqrq zt ql rre{ r}a gn+cn dzq rl rq€ d fu gst sq-fr d eRfu @qr{. 62/2/2 q-r!. Tf,f,grT dE-{}d eTr{ r6-qr algo qrffiev "il qiro fu-d 6r€i d qqtft-d o1 i z,rs,oo,ooo /- (d ori-s qq6 drs fu-qrrd rwx) rui. +a eq-qpTq +er pa- 22.08.22 fr ge oqro za w sd.{ B, d 3ilqrq qr erSgw fid-sr d w fi rfion o-t ft-o-q A^,T-g t, orartd qrro ftfe a-qr d wfr-G o1 rrqfu^qtrq c_fi 62/2/2 qrq qm-flgil ot erci*_o X.,u 2,1s,66,000 / - (d oqle q<E c4Rq fuurqle turr) rur) rqT Tqr^pr rE ilfr Fq w -*r+o qrqRr-fr-orq os f,l .tr$, 16-g EUfr qk. o1 e.gqfr GrTyft-a {il q{ sffi rtqfu 6) ft-o-q o-{i tg HR.rfr o1 ,Tg, oq uufi qk qrro ftra eqr d rerF-d +t Eqft d Aqq fr rrqq qfi

¶49

¶50

G +drfr ft-w e1r; rl{ffi ftqs zooz d Efi'o v-rg6 d ergw rS +i d orqq eri-<o lTRn- fil-6 dter +1 rtEqfr^qi 3lqrs fr W ftnd qri +.q rfr t r

¶51

oirleo^qer +1 Grlq t q6 dd rql qqr B fu onn{o^qel 3rrq rfr ro I{d Hqrqm rr<irq ft=+o 23.11.2020 (q-i@r /z) d n+rsr fr ft-qrs fl ftq-crir srrdr t Vq Vfi gyd scETrc q-wrq r+mt-r ori o1 qBqm q-{ ild rcd gv qn# q.g.BEI Rlrqrilq 91$ qIfusrr q,qltr. zz'127 / 2021 il crfud sTrtcr 21.02.2022 +f,{ ura^qrfiEx f{s-q d-6 sfEF T6rqrE, qrrfiq qf,Nr BEr qrqr q exr qrfuor o-rTrm l€qq 1_2-1 V \ssg71/2g21 q, qrE i4sTs-14slg/zozt I qmfrq sqd--q qrqrafq em ffio oz 03.2022 o-) crRd onH d q+l-d fuqT TsT B I Eqtrd^q-rqgErd qr T{r sneq sqfi Eq fits oT qo t fu gs ertr+_qq gm qftd ordyr fuflo 06.0s.2022 +t ofufrr 21 d mqq ri w gro rr-nm foqr6 23.11.2020 d frsq^q qr& G e-dTs-dT o) s-oTr fuqr qr T6-r^{B, dct} 5tl^oe{ ol^orq sdrrrf,r^qfi M i srq T+6R sfr fuqT^qT {JrDdT l gqfr o-nnT orri+6 qer o} -6 E{d Hqtlrc d Ass i ot$ s-srqor l-S fr ur rrofi r

¶52

1e. d-fl5l-JTr zuft qm orTt<o o-q.6 2 q-E6 ftro ai-g d' rqrfrE o1 sqfu u,Iir,n az/z/z .,Tq qoiltrT (B,-orql fu-or un-t q) rrqq q 3flrfhd L@ qt ,1) H.qq 01 q{ +drfr or-dqrfr x!fr qfu +1 1T6qfr d ort+rs t dq {rf qr+r eniqo sef o-T 3{r}en gq frqT ilo. enRro w t Tfiori o-r vqd oniyr frqr qr+ qrq Fo tsfuodr

¶53

g.s il{E t orfuo-{rr EH M w qgqT B fu smrqrfr +fi d em srieo q-,qrq z ofi rqq-s 6, sqfu o) Gil-n<-6 q'qrq z o1 rlEqft ftrd fr-fl qtvB_d T@^{c{ fr-dq} fuqT^q) w3r( (gqNiel r;eq zooz d

¶54

Vfr.^{q. ;iiN-546/2o22}

¶55

¶56

F-w e1r; d E-fi-q q-tEo. d orietr rfi t n-c aTri{6 E-qrf,, 2 o) sil{Bd T@ d er-il€ qrRr q-qT o-{i of $d w v$ orqfr qqfu d-qri 6T y+. orsrn t+ sfuo t r 21 1.Iffi g.rc 2002 o1 qnr rz (r) d erorlo nqo ffi ud enieaTsrfr-m !fr g=rqrg o1 cfusl Sfi olDftqq o1 qnr rz (z) d crqurcrTqT( {S q-f,r$ ,Tg d +sT fu erx.S.fr. vcrc 1ee3 n qrqErTfud t q.q qRT rs (zs) em.Sfr. vf,c 1ee3 qa qrqtTrF-d o-{fi t fu arr aq$ 3IE-+{uT qrq +t qffi d fuq *{fl ff BFdd qq-d, of$ ,fi GilteT qTftd o-r rro:nr t, cTRd enier 6r q,Trfi a.r t foq<-q-q fu enovuo fq-fqT t tro-or d r

¶57

glfrq orr+cr

¶58

22 s-d-Ersq Bq..r)fr 01 .Tg Aa-qfl d n+-rer { 3nl<-6 qqrq z qro ftn arqs 01 3rtr ri nrgn wd-cr 3riRr6 uq t r$-orv o-{d Eq ftq.illtr 3rfdq 3{repT qlftd fu-qrqralit,-

¶59

r.^qR orr+{+. otTrnfr 02 qr6 d 3ifl olqfd fudo 24.01.2s drn- 2,15,66,000,/- (s) o-t-s^q;E-6 drq fu-qrrd rwv) uu-n erv| aor^qri ti 62 slqrc ffii.q ql yo gca qqr o-r t d ffi dor d.w.d. vfi w. Td fr-og^qiq-+t r-w, il+i d^qer E r{qq afr^q-i nflq offi 3{w{n qi w6 d r

¶60

2.^qR GilA-{o'^qeT sftr f+rfRd 3{sE i vw rtfrr^qrrT o-r tor t o-s Err ffi dar gRI HqT 01 .r$ vrRr smrqTfr ilm ffi df,r El rz^qfteln 11TEnrur qrq d eTar Glrilf,o^qer d eRT rtRT qcT +vi d qeqro vm'^qt-E d^srE{ elqs s-{ +lt I 3.^qR ofln{6^qeT sfi fqqtRd GrqE ftrlo 24.01.2023 ro eftRrn qW^qtfrT

¶61

¶62

Yg. Y. T+s-s+6/2o22

¶63

2,15$6p00/- (E) 6-tg q{d d.rs fuqRrd E-dn) $!-d^q-qr r-SI 6rdT, Tq friilfi ddr dwd. vfi w.wfi - 6e qr++l rqq, sdrq d uer i 1E^q{r{ .ifl 62/2/2 srq Tod-g-rT d frqq d ge 01 G ffi o.rffi d nom d vcrqrfr ilo. ffi dm si f{o-q^qrrm q;{ q-ET;r o-{ ffir{ s-ni tg rqoa rtqr r

¶64

Grar s6rrrf,T d Aq-q q qT-iw qeT g1-{l, q{gd qrfuor GrrqrFrd qr+r ftrw +1 qr-fi d r

¶65

srrq^qe{ 3rq.-qT<IqqT qq rdq .[tt I 3tTfn g-d qrqrolq i srq f{rTo 24.11.2022 o) EIE-o fuqr r

¶66

TalE:-^qcrf,g{

¶67

tc.1Ict,:_24.11 .2022

¶68

'r^.r 6H^{fq-drs qld)} {-onfl-{ ffi. O.qnO q.c.G Effisrrd

Ms Maa Bhuvneshwari Ice and Coldstorage v. State Bank of India

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

Ms Maa Bhuvneshwari Ice and Coldstorage v. State Bank of India

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Case details

Similar cases

Ms Bal Bahadur Singh Construction Co. versus State Bank of India

Hdfc Bank versus M/S Jai Bajrang Drilling and Construction

Poonam Chopra versus Icici Bank Limited

Shri Sayed Wajid Ali versus Shsubham Housing Development Finance

Saket Kumar versus PNB Housing Finance Ltd.

Shri Dinesh Chand Sharma versus Mahindra Rural Housing Finance Ltd.