Rajesh Mishra Vs the Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Anr.

¶1

$~ 54 to 62and73
* IN THEGCOURFDLAW
Date ofcisn: 09.25
+ P(C) 3 52 9/ . W & 4/0 52 6L. P CM A
RTSIGH N P LY A K onrP eti.
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L Gau K. tam, Ms. Vshl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
TFDEH&. NICPAL OR MU
dtR e spo n. s
roug: h T Mr. Tusha u,C n r S a - MCD
916 Mob:
M s. a kTn i pthy,SC foR r - A D
with Mr. Gutm Y a a dv and Mr.
Mor,dv. ash k A
813 Mob: 9
Email: @ ohy rp ma n ti k
+ /05&P(C) 3 72. W CM A 51 6L. P 05 2
KMRIJ A P U onr . P eti
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver

¶2

Page 1 of 17

¶3

dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
njy S a it, ash V
rt Goswami, Ms. G dha Si njli e t a
y and Mr. Aditya SRe d chdev, a
Advs. forR - D
7538 9 Mob:
Email:
@lk. comuni a t v10
56
+ 05&P(C) 37 2 / .6 W /0 25 61L. P CM A
H GOW&R. MANIS onrsP eti.
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU dt es po n
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
njy S a it, ash V
rt Goswami, Ms. G dha Si njli e t a
y and Mr. Aditya SRe d chdev, a
Advs. forR - D
7538 9 Mob:
Email:
v10co @lk. municto a
57
+ 05&P(C) 3 72 6/ . W /0 562 L. P CM A
GR AI LUH S onrP eti.

¶4

Page 2 of 17

¶5

roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Re khi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
njy S a Vash ta, h is
rt Goswami, Ms. G dha Si njli e t a
y and Mr. Aditya SRe d chdev, a
Advs. forR - D
7538 9 Mob:
Email:
@lk. comuni a t v10
58
+ 05&P(C) 3896/ 2. W / 05 61L. P CM A
SUMAN P eti onr .
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: riyl1289@gm a n il.com
s ver
dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
Ms. Ltik M a lhotr, Adv. for R a
D
562 981 Mob:
Email: lati tr@gic a.ml h o k

¶6

Page 3 of 17

¶7

njy S a it, ash V
rt Goswami, Ms. G dha Si njli e t a
y and Mr. Aditya SRe d chdev, a
Advs. forR - D
7538 9 Mob:
Email:
@lk. comuni a t v10
59
+ P(C) 3972 . W 05 & 2 / 2 614/ 5 L. P CM A
SDIL P AR HO onr . P eti
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
. AnilSh a M r a nd t e Pun
a dvY , Adv s. f or R - D DA (Troug h
VC)
Mob : 4 938
Email:
il.@g madvocet ypun
60
+ 05&P(C) 42 9/ . W 7/0 52 6L. P CM A
N LI A SHJ E onr . P eti
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver

¶8

Page 4 of 17

¶9

dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
Throu gh: ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
,AdvfR or iklh at L M s .
D
562 981 Mob:
r@gch o.mail k t : E
61
+ 7/0&P(C) 4 52. W /0 52 6L. P CM A
DEV I KHPT A L onrP eti.
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU dt es po nR.
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
,AdvfR or iklh at L M s .
D
562 981 Mob:
Email: r@gch o.mlati k
62
+ /&P(C) 502. 6W /0 52 6L. P CM A
RMAT DE VI onrP eti.
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, Ms. V a shl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:

¶10

Page 5 of 17

¶11

Email: a riyn i.co1289@g mla
s ver
dt .es po n TFDEH& NICPAL OR MU
roug: h T ,C aSn sh u . TM r - MCD
916 Mob:
njy S a it, ash V
rt Goswami, Ms. G dha Si njli e t a
y and Mr. Aditya SRe d chdev, a
Advs. forR - D
Mob 7538 9 :
Email:
@lk. comuni a t v10
73
+ /&P(C) 5 1 02. W 2 3/ 56 L. P CM A
SH JE RA onrP eti.
roug: h T Mr. Vinay Kr. Garg, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. L G K. utm, a Ms. Vshl ai
riyl, Mr. Sumit and Mr. K a N S .
Rekhi, Advs.
35 1 7 96 Mob:
Email: .co1289@g mla r i ny
s ver
FD&. NICPALORTHE MU
dtR es po n.
roug: h T ,C Sn sh ua r T - MCD
916 Mob:
,AdvfR or iklh at L M s .
D
562 981 Mob:
Email: r@gch o.mlati k

¶12

Page 6 of 17

¶13

CORAM:
HON'BLE MS.JUTICPKAR
MIN PUSHKAR,J.( ORAL
CM APL.5 6524/0, CMAPL.1
CM APL.562/0,14
CM APL.5627/0,
& CMAPL.563/20
1. Th e psnta reco hveb i l n fildon behalf of e the onrs eti p
g prmo in k se to run and s e lih , c f n kead mu tn oithe sta s in
question , ahe t i Mo r Dab FgblMk. e ndV t a ui r
2. d S e a rn L io Cuslng f aperot hp s nr ei ubmae th
onr have b eti p n e ad in the b ge n ine of se s u ing fish, l hiken and c
mu t o n i rnt sfe dhopat the Dabi Mo r Pocket 20C , Plm Rod,New a
Delhi. It is submied t ha the p t onrs are the eti ega owners of the l
nil , wcv thads/ u ebly ud t ao he Dl ivopmnt
Authority (—DDA“) to the petitione
3. It is submied t t ha in terms of the Master Plan of Delhi 01, 2 a
Licns e oh te mathop ru s igo theg n und rof lo l, dnt aresi
up to axiu of 20 sq. m m e trs, are aowed. Thus, l it is submied t ha t
Muni cipal Corporation of Delhi (—MC
20 th Dcmbr, e 03, in terms of w 2 h ic licns is granted to se e l meat
y. ahrd f ect omplin ubj s
4. d Si e a rn L o apr sCu e l n igfo h et pi ers on i tlupon the
th
Policy of the MCD, w h ic has bn i e ued s vide Oice O f de r ate 20 d
b r , 2e cmD03y t h Dparmnof e nay Svcs rie tV , ad r n lisupo e
Clause C of the said Policy . By relyi n g upothe a foresid Policy , larnd e
i o S en r Cus l aper ingf ot h pnr sei ubm eth asa on ri p
rd under the said cov e Policy, and fo, mus h ert be aowed to l un thei r
W.P(C) 359/20andothercms Page 7 of 17

¶14

respctiv bunfomhald.
5. Learnd SioCuslaperng fothpeinrsubmthae petionrs are ready toaproch the MCD				, and shalcomply with althe
directons agvbyhMCD,wl.
6. Learnd SioCuslaperng fothpeinrsubmthae
petionrsalyhd		Licens	from theDA andthe		MCD, forunig
their businefrom their respctiv units. Howevr,					the same	wer
subeqntlywihdra			Policy	prevailngthofm.
7. Learnd SioCuslaperng fothpeinrsubmthae
petionrs have deposit		ed fes of Rs. 750		- , towards grant of	Licens	on
variousocasin	, howevr, the		aplictons of the petionrs have ben
rejctd. Hsubmittha epetionrs arpor peol					, thus , in case	, the
petionrs are toaproch the respondt, they may					beexmptd from
filng the fes.
8. Learnd SioCunsel forthepionrsel uponthe					judgment
date 12 thAugst, 205paedbyhiCorn				W.P(C)1260/5		,tiled
as — Umar Sarif Versu Governmt of NCT of Delhi and Ors.					“,	to su
tha t the case ofthpinrlvdby					judgment	.
9. Isuenotic.Naceptdbylrnous					sapering	for the
respondt,i.hMCD			DA	.
10. Learnd counsel		sap	ring for the respondt submit		tha action
wa s taken forcanelig the			Licens	of the petionrs, in terms of the
directons fhCu.
1 Learndcouslpigfthae letr focainwshDGCvA,
seking clariftons.

¶15

Page 8 of 17

¶16

12. At this stage, learnd Senior Counselapering for the petionrs submittha the petionrs are ready to comply with althe requist directonsubythe MCDin thsregad,fothpurse ofde			- sealing.
He furthesubmith at thepetionrs ar wilngtosubjecthemlv o
therms , as may be putbyheMCD		,in thsregad.
13. Learnd Senior Cuslapering fothepionrs			furthesbmi
tha epionrslugymba,whc e
prohibted under Rule 91 of the Aircaft Ru		les, 1937. Hesubmit	tha the
petionrs halcmywit alhecompinsterof Rul91of the
Aircaft Rule,1937.
14. Having heard learnd counselapering for the parties, this Court
notes haRul 91oftheAircaRuls,37dn:
— *Prohibtn fslaugend fyioanmls, depitg* *of rubishand otherplud orbnxius materin thevicny of* *aerodm* .œ Nopersnhalugt orflaynimordepst o rdopanyubish,fltgeod rbnx *mater includgshfo,p - procesing mlwhic atrsoislkeytoarc vultesor other birds and*animls withn a radius of aerodm fncpit:		ten kilometrs from the
ProvidethaeDircto of CivlAatnorDeputyircoGnalfCivAatonmy, if he issatifedthaproe andadequtarngemts have ben e by the owners of hotels, meatshop, fishshop and bone procesing mlso ato prevnatciofvultresother andimls,havng redto hevicnty ofplace ofslaughter		- Genral, JointDrecGnal
mls,h*g r*cnty ofplace ofslaughte the a*erodm,arn*gemts for dispoal or deposit of rubishandoteplu andobxismter, ganpiso writng fohepus.	“		cars
15. Perusaloftharesid	Rule	categorilyshwnopersha
slaughter ofynim	deposit ranyubh,fl		,garbe o
a ny other poluted orobnxius mat atrcs or islikey toatrc vultres or other birds andanimls withn a		,includg , such materil whic

¶17

Page 9 of 17

¶18

radius ofn kil teomr sf the dm f ero a n cpoit. The said Rule
rthe f udsathpov ie Dir tor calhJ en G oit cGnalf re D
vl AvC i aton or Deputy Di i ecto G r nral of C e vl Av i aton, as the case i
may be, is at fedh pr oe and etar qungmshv bnmad e
/ic.,v ap theorsf mbywn rci ont a
es ltv ruo the r s d bi an i mlsh gr vn a ed ohe v t cntyof placein i
question from the adm, then perm ero is on in wrtng for i t ha urose p
grtd. b e c an
16. This Cur to s n et hlr de at20 th Sptmbr , 2018 e iued bythe s
A, Coercial Es m ae Branch, wh t rin e , with egad to r omplianes in c
f 91 Rul h it dn e w acor s w: ol edf itsa, 1937
—xxx xxx xxx
as Pl e f to your l re et r d ate 3 0.8 21 on the subject
note d abv. I h i s, amt con inf orm yu thae for
ru nig /se l of F n Mu t o in Dabri Mori Fruit & Ccke h/i s
gtabl Market has bV e n consi e r by the Comp de et n Au t horiy
and h s g r t e pm ion fsel g o n Mu t CckF ih/ e
ground t ha the a w l o te r e doing the same buine p s r io to
n it a l o t me h s i e aft r e - n si te madf urt h e sbjcto f u li
ca37.hAi rof Rule91t
2. In aditon to above, the said permison for seling of
Chicken/MutoFs bjto furnishga n IdemityBo
for cmplianeo thefolwing acordne with eRul 91of
Aircaft Rule1937:
The draingsytmoulbp.
i). The dispoal bins/drum are complety coverd indvualy
aprt from the whole are being c overd with proe covering
materil.
i). No slaughterfcikn/bdp.
iv). The Dispoal of cars,othe wast, mteril isto be stored
proely indumsgthae ni.fr
9.0 pmthey are tobdispyhcvl.
v). Ther should be no scope of any vultres or any other birds

¶19

Page 10 of 17

¶20

*being atrced by any sort of waste materil from the busine* *caried outbyhl/pn* .
It is also informed youtha a periodcal su condute bytheamconsitgfOicers ofDA,TCSDM & Asociatn by the Fruit & Vegtabl Market, Dabri More to Check forcmplianeof Rule91 byal conerda incaseofvilaton, the alomnwudbi ed.		rvey would be
4. The Asociatn namely M/s Shiv Market Phal *MainDbro,Newlhiudnsrtapoegm if furthe nedfor dispoal or deposit ofcars/ny other pol and*obnxius mater toensurtha no vultres/bid are towardshimke.		- Subzi Mandi, atrced
xxx xxx xxx“	(EmphasiSuled)
17. Perusal ofthidbyDAsowtaheri
clearrequimnttha no slaughter ofchiken/fs is to be done in open
are. Furthe, the dispoal of thecarsand other waste mterial is to be
storedplyindrumsing thedaynoly inthe nigafter 9p.m,
thesaid wtemarilis to bedispo d of, bycoverdhil.Tus, the
petionrs wuldbqtocmplywiha	l thesdirconaeu
tha edispoal f carsndother wasmterilstoredplyand
no slaughterfcikn/ sdoein aoper. Futh,epionrs
would also have toensurtha ther is no scope of any vultres or o			ther
birdsengatrcd oany sortf wastemril fothe busineg
cariedoutbyhl/pns.
18. Therfo,tpinsajduo tcmlywihaes
directonswhpmla s in termsofRul91		Aircaft Rule	s ,
1937.
19. This Court also notes the letrdate 29 Ofice othDrGnalCvA,wdsu:	thMay, 2018, isued bythe

¶21

Page of 17

¶22

Perusal of the foresid l a r et how s t ha the Cvl Av i aton i
rtmn , G e paD o vfInd a ihs lred yc tai f the hterin slau g
of a ml s i n edu bt i ohp r n Rle91 ofhe Ai t cafRule r, 1937wthn a i
radius of 10 kilomtrs from a e dm. Fu ero the, the C r vl Av i aton i
mn h te pD a r sal o crfe dthini dvual pwer so , wh o d buine s
smali n e ,ydc po wt frsh , i na mer as quid byth re
caft Ai r Rule , 1937 . Thus, the Oice of the Di f ecto G r nral of C e vl i
sc dhf IG rme pD lAviaton, C

¶23

Page 12 of 17

Rajesh Mishra v. the Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Rajesh Mishra v. the Municipal Corporation of Delhi & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M/S. Smart World Communications Vs Commissioner of Central Tax and Cgst Delhi North Commissionerate

Union of India & Ors. Vs Sh Harish Chander Raheja

Indian Newspaper Society Vs Union of India & Anr.

P.M. College of Education Vs National Council for Teacher Education and Anr.

Mohd. Shafir Vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Ors.

Shri Ghanaram Niranjan College of Pharmacy Vs Pharmacy Council of India

Gautam Properties (Delhi) Pvt. Ltd. Vs Delhi Developement Authority

Save India Foundation (Regd) Vs Govt of NCT of Delhi & Ors.

Uma Shokeen Vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Others

Sh Aman Kapasiya Vs University of Delhi & Ors.

Punjab National Bank Vs North Delhi Municipal Corporation & Ors.

Meera Goyal Vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi, & Ors.

Indraprastha Medical Vs South Delhi Municipal Corporation

Abdul Nasir and Anr. Vs Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Anr.