Writ petition declared meritless and infirctuous by the bench. The petition was dismissed. Interim relief granted earlier stood discharged.
Petition dismissed as infirctuous; earlier interim relief discharged.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
i ktsudteli 'tt-:-L
HIGH COURT OF CHH^TTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WRTT PETmON No. 1422 of2001
| 's'Ba. |
|---|
r'"9s ^
PETITIONERS
| 1. B.S.P. Kannehari SaUkari Upbhokta Bhandar |
|---|
| Maryadit, Khursipar, Zone-2 (K.L.C.)& Zone- 3,Bhilai.Rsgn.No.2143 |
| Throu^i Its President Sht-i R.B.Sin^i, aged |
| about 61 years, S/o Late Shri R.K.Singh R?'o |
| Khursipar,Bhilai,Distt.Durg(ChlMttig^rh)„. |
2. Jai BajrangPrathmik SahkariUpbhdcta Bhandar |
| Maryadit, Balaji Nagai, Klnirsipar, Sector -11, |
| Bhitai,Distt.Dure,Reai.No.2/239& . : , |
| Tlu-ou^i Shri BuddanTliakur, aged 51 years,S/o |
| Shri Dilochand Thakur, R/o Khursipar, Bhilai, ' |
| Distt.Durg(Chhattisarii); > ^ |
| g. „ 3. Jai Dursa Prathmik Upbhokta Sahkari Bhandar |
| Maryadit,PaehariPara,Durg,Regi.No.2/2385 |
| Throu^i Anil gjunar Shau, aged 31 years, S/o |
| Shri Kundanlal Sahu, R/o Pachri Eara, Diu-g, |
| t. Durg(Chhattisgarii) r |
4. Apna Prathmik Sahkari Upbhokta Bbgnte |
| Maryadifc, Ward No. 10 Slwiiti Na^r,^Supela, |
Bhilai,Distt.Durg(CBiattis8arii).,^ j |
| Thraigh Manager Awadhbihari' Shali, aged 42 |
| years S/o Shri Moticfaaud; Sha^ RA> ,A{$roac |
| , Road,Camp-1,Bhilai,Kstt.Durg(ehhattisgarh) |
5. Shakti Prathmik Upbhokta Sahfcari Bhandar, |
| Sharda Para- Ward No 23, Hiilai, Regi.No. ": "'" " |
| 2212, ,.,, • , -:: . : :• .;:::::, ;'!! ;::: - |
| Throu^i Its president Jai Kumar Gupta, aged |
| years, SA> Shn Juglal Guptc R/o SiiaidaPata, |
| Camp-2,BhilatDigtt.Durg(e.G.) i |
| 6. Adarsh Pratliamik,Upbho!flta SaUkaii Bhatidar, |
| Bhilpara,DurgRsgi;No.2404. p j a |
| Through Manager R,ajjeiidr^Jau^,agea 4%,}Eears, |
| S/oMotilalJam,R/oGanjpara,Darg,©istt.Dure : |
| (C.G.) ;;.::' :. . :•:.' r ;,;;:<,, |
| 7. Mamta Prathniik Upbhokta Sahkari Bhandar |
| Maryaflit, WaniNo. 25, Durg.Distt. IVrg,Regi; |
No.2/2396 .' -.• .. -..:i-. ..i:.:--.,- .- |
| Through Shiv Kumar Tamrakar, aged 45 years, 'Tik^R^ |
| S/o Late Shri Ramswaroop awaaa SsSw |
| BazarWardDwg,Distt. Durg^'.O.) •. , |
8. Shri Santosh Pi-aftauk tyA<Ato SdAari |
| Bhandar Maiyadit, Sheetal-Nagai, Wani No. 3, |
| Durg,Distt.Dwg,'Regft.~No^2/'i414_^"jy:' |
| Through Shatru^ian Patel, aged 33 years, S/o |
| Sfari Kisl ilal Patel,R^Baigipara^JNg,DStt. 'Dwg(C.G.) 1 |
| - . ,. :..' ;'::., |
| 9. Deepak Prathimk U{*hokta Sdkari phassdw, |
| S^dcari Bhandar Maryadit, DeepakNaggr, Wanl |
| No. 15,Durg. Reg. No. 2/2399; |
| Through Vijay Jaikare, %ed 29 years, S/o Stari |
-2-
i^?
Ramadhir Jaikare, R/o Deepak Na^r, Ehirg, Distt.Durg. , lO.Teen Darshan Mandir Pratfamik SaUori Upbhokta Bhandar Maiyadit, Camp-l,Bhiiai, ;: 1:, Regn. Na 2/2394, ::, ' ::.,::-:L ,,ii!"s^ Through Maimu Mishra, aged 48 years, S/o Late Shri RameshwMi Mi^lra, R/o Caaip-l,;JaleW , Chowk, Bhilai, Distt. Durg (CUiattisgaAl 11. The Consuniersl Co-op. Stoere IA1, KtoRipar, Zone-2,Bhilai, Rsgp. No. 1838. ,. Thtw^i Shri V.V.SSurtoman^m,' aged 51 S/o Shri B.Kainesbwati»Rao, " R/a years, Khursipar, BhUai, Distt. Dufg (Chhaftisgarh^ ; 12.0um Ghasidas Nagar Pratlmak Sahkai Upbhokta Bhandaf Maryadtt, Quru Bhasiflas Nagar, Bhilai, Distt. Durg, Regn. No.2/2593. Thraigh Bharat Bhushan Pandey^a^d ^S ypare, &/o Late Shri Setu BaB<lhuPandey,i;{yo<3hasidas Nagar, Housing Board, Bhilai,»j.Efett. Qurg < - • • (Chhattisgarh) IS.Prathmik Vpbhdktsi SaMcari ,BhandM» Supela, BhilM, Regn No. 2207. ? i Through Its pr^ident Mohd, Oliaus, .ag^l 43 yesas, S/o Mohd. lyakoob R/o SuMash ChwA, Supela, BUN, Distt. Durg(C.G,):",. ' 14.Laxnii Prathmik Upbhokta Satdari Bhaadar, Charoda, TTnpu^i QmprAaA Ayxw^, aj^d 'Sf years, SA> Matadeen AgrawaI,-RA) CSiaroda,i Distt.Durg(C.G.) . , ' * ;° 15.Prathmik Upbhokta Sahkari Hiandar (Model Town), WardNo. 1, Bhilai. , Throu^hi Ishwar Sao. aged 42 yesss, S/o Late Hari Sao, RA> Ea^ Ndiru Na^r>(8(09, JEhilai,' » . Distt.Durg(C.G.) VERSUS ,,' ; RE8PONDENTS : 1 State ofCUhattisgarh Throu^i its &cretary, & Civil Supplies Departmetit,. GgPt. of Chhattisgarh, Raipur(ClA.)-.* ;« s < 2. Director, Food i^ CjyiB Supplies IRepartpie Govt.ofChhattisgarh.Rayur (GUi.) • ;. 3. Food CotitroUerCoUectQra^!t)urg,DiStHietE)uri ^^^^^^^^ (Chhattisprh) ^ 4. Viiiod Sin^i, Zone 1, Sector,ll,^Bhna, W^d No. 29 Bhaai,Du^(Chh.) , i: . ,;, 5. Ku. Kiran Tiwari, New Khursipacjyariset,, Ward * No. 36, Bhilai, DistOut^; , a 6. Shankar Lal Bachor, Polsapara^ W^! N% 23,;; s Durg(Chh.) 7. Baba Sin^i Ward No. 19, Vriada N^at, 0hilai, -. DisL Durg. ::,::,,„..,„ ,,„(;;( ,.,.;. 8. Kapil Dev and Ranwshadiw SundwNagpr W^-d No.22,Bhilai,DistDurg. . . ; t s
-3.
WMT PETmON UNDER ARTICLES 226/227 OFTHE CONSTrTUTION OF - •/-1; • '* -: --A — wm/e:
SB: Hon'Ue Shri Sattsh K. AenfhoW. J.
fll1-;:-.:«
Present: Shri Siashank Thakw, Advoeate Eq>pearingonbehaB'o£SIm," B.D.Guru.Advocatefifftitepetitibners.; 7; Shri Rajendra Ag-awal, Panel Lawyer for'fiie KateA-espondent' No. lto3. : ^ :- - ;;! .! .;!:
ORALORDER ' (Passed on 02"' day of Septeni^er, 2008) .
C—3
Sd/-
Anril
Satish K. AgBlhatri Judge
B.S.P. Kannehari SaUkari Upbhokta Bhandar and 14 others
State of Chhattisgarh
Director, Food and Civil Supplies Department
Food Controller Collector Durg
Satish K. Agnihotri
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
