Suryakant Govind Kengale vs Zilla Parishad Pune Anr.

¶1

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶2

Digitally signed GAYATRI by GAYATRI RAJENDRA RAJENDRASHIMPI SHIMPI Date: 2026.04.30 09:56:56 +0530

¶3

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

¶4

WRIT PETITION NO. 14383 OF 2025

¶5

Bajarang Shankar Supe Age. 60 years, Occ. Retired as a Principal R/at. Post Wada, Taluka Khed, Rajgurunagar, District Pune 412402 … Petitioner

¶6

Versus

¶7

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶8

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶9

WITH

¶10

WRIT PETITION NO. 14131 OF 2025

¶11

Dnyaneshwar Punaji Mormare Age. 61 years, Occ. Retired as Primary Teacher R/at. Post Tokawade, Taluka Khed, Rajgurunagar District Pune 412402 … Petitioner

¶12

Versus

¶13

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶14

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶15

Gayatri Shimpi

¶16

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶17

1

¶18

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶19

WITH

¶20

WRIT PETITION NO. 14443 OF 2025

¶21

Raghunath Shantaram Kavale Age. 63 years, Occ. Retired as Primary Teacher R/at. Post Nayphad, Taluka Khed, Rajgurunagar District Pune 412402 … Petitioner

¶22

Versus

¶23

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶24

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶25

WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 13951 OF 2025

¶26

Gangaram Mahadev Damse Age. 61 years, Occ. Retired as a Primary Teacher R/at. Panchale Khurd, Taluka Ambegaon, District Pune 412402 … Petitioner

¶27

Versus

¶28

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶29

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶30

Gayatri Shimpi

¶31

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶32

2

¶33

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶34

WITH

¶35

WRIT PETITION NO. 13962 OF 2025

¶36

Tarachand Devram Talpe

¶37

Age. 61 years, Occ. Retired as a Primary teacher R/at. Torne Khurd, Post Amboli, Taluka - Khed Rajgurunagar, Pune 410505 … Petitioner

¶38

Versus

¶39

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 2. Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan

¶40

1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶41

WITH

¶42

WRIT PETITION NO. 14149 OF 2025

¶43

Suryakant Govind Kengale

¶44

Age. 61 years, Occ. Retired as Primary Teacher R/at. Post Jambhori, Taluka Ambegaon, District Pune - 410509 … Petitioner

¶45

Versus

¶46

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶47

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶48

Gayatri Shimpi

¶49

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶50

3

¶51

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶52

WITH

¶53

WRIT PETITION NO. 14293 OF 2025

¶54

Maruti Vitthal Phalke

¶55

Age. 61 years, Occ. Retired as a Primary Teacher R/at. Goregaon, Post Aavhat, Taluka Khed Rajgurunagar, District Pune - 412402 … Petitioner

¶56

Versus

¶57

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶58

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶59

WITH

¶60

WRIT PETITION NO. 14124 OF 2025

¶61

Dattatray Panghaji Milkhe

¶62

Age. 63 years, Occ. Retired as a Primary Teacher R/at. Post. Nayphal, Taluka Rajgurunagar, Khed District Pune 412402 … Petitioner Versus

¶63

Zilla Parishad, Pune Through Chief Executive Officer Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001

¶64

Deputy Chief Accounts and Finance Officer Zilla Parishad, Yashwantrao Chavhan Bhavan 1, Wellesley Road, Camp Pune 411001 … Respondents

¶65

Gayatri Shimpi

¶66

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶67

4

¶68

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶69

****

¶70

Mr. Sandeep Dere a/w Ms. Tanvi D., Ms. Sonali Pawar, Ms. Pooja Mankoji, Advocates for the Petitioners in WP Nos. 14383 of 2025, 13951 of 2025, 13962 of 2025, 14293 of 2025, 14149 of 2025, 14443 of 2025, 14131 of 2025, 14124 of 2025.

¶71

Mr. Ashwin R. Kapadnis, Advocate for Respondents in all matters.

¶72

¶73

CORAM : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE AND ASHWIN D. BHOBE, JJ.

¶74

DATE : 10^th DECEMBER, 2025

¶75

ORAL JUDGMENT : (PER : RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.)

¶76

Leave to correct the prayer clause (a), in all the matters.

¶77

Correction be carried out forthwith.

¶78

Call for papers in Writ Petition No. 14124 of 2025, which is

¶79

not listed in this group, though ordered on 5^th December, 2025.

¶80

Rule . Rule made returnable forthwith and heard finally, with

¶81

the consent of the parties.

¶82

A short issue emerges from this Petition, for our consideration. The Petitioners were appointed as Primary Teacher - class-III on the dates mentioned in the pleadings (1986 onwards). They

¶83

Gayatri Shimpi

¶84

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶85

5

¶86

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶87

were promoted to the post of Principal and posted at Valad College, Khed, Pune on 16.10.2009 (the first Petitioner) and on similar dates. As per the verification exercise conducted under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education Act, 2009, 389 posts of Principals were sanctioned as against 424 candidates already working as Principals as in June, 2014. 35 Principals were found to be in excess of the sanctioned posts. The Petitioners were some of them. The first Petitioner claims that his willingness for demotion was forcibly obtained and the same was approved by the Zilla Parishad on 01.08.2014. Similar are the submissions of the other Petitioners.

¶88

On 14.08.2014, the first Petitioner was transferred from Valad School to Dagadiwadi School as a Primary Teacher. The other Petitioners were also similarly transferred as Primary teachers at various locations. While working as Primary Teachers, all were inadvertently paid the salary of a Principal. The first Petitioner continued to draw the salary of a Principal until his retirement on 30.04.2024. On 28.05.2024, his service book was verified by the Pension Department and a query was raised that he was inadvertently paid excess salary of Rs.3,21,200/-. Without a hearing, post retirement, an order was passed by the Deputy Chief Auditor and Finance Officer, Zilla Parishad, Pune directing

¶89

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶90

Gayatri Shimpi

¶91

6

¶92

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶93

deduction of Rs.3,21,200/- from the retiral benefits towards the gratuity amount. All the other Petitioners are similarly affected by the impugned action initiated after their retirements.

¶94

The learned Advocate for the Zilla Parishad has strenuously opposed these Petitions and submits that the same deserve to be dismissed with heavy costs. The Petitioners ha indulged in unjust enrichment and if they are permitted to retain the amount of Rs.3,21,200/- and similar amounts, it would amount to a grave loss to the State exchequer, which is the tax-payers money.

¶95

The learned Advocates for the Petitioners rely upon Sayed Abdul Qadir v/s. State of Bihar¹ and State of Punjab and Ors. v/s. Rafiq Masih (White Washer)² . They also rely upon a judgment dated 23^rd March, 2023 delivered by this Court at the Aurangabad Bench in Writ Petition No.3320 of 2023 (Shaikh Amir Shaikh Kadar V/s. The State of Maharashtra Through its Secretary And Others) and connected group of cases, wherein this Court has dealt with the aspect of extracting an affidavit or an undertaking from an employee post retirement for permitting the employer to deduct excess amounts from the retiral

¶96

1 (2009) 3 SCC 475

¶97

2 (2015) 4 SCC 334

¶98

Gayatri Shimpi

¶99

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶100

7

¶101

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶102

benefits.

¶103

The learned Advocate for the Zilla Parishad submits that the Petitioners have voluntarily executed undertakings after their retirements. However, this Court has concluded that if an undertaking is not taken from the concerned employee at the time of making the excess payment or granting increments, though inadvertently, the act of extracting an affidavit post retirement or at the time of retirement would amount to duress and coercion.

¶104

In view of the above, and considering the law laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Sayed Abdul Qadir v/s. State of Bihar and State of Punjab and Ors. v/s. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) (supra), all these Writ Petitions are partly allowed . The amounts deducted from the gratuity amounts, shall be returned to all these Petitioners without interest, if they are repaid within 45 days, failing which the amounts would gather interest @ 5% p.a. from the dates they were deducted from the gratuity amounts of these Petitioners.

¶105

In the event the pension of these Petitioners is wrongly calculated on the quantum of the last drawn salary which was inadvertently of the scale payable to the Principal, or as the case may be,

¶106

Gayatri Shimpi

¶107

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶108

8

¶109

907-WP-14383-2025(speaking).odt

¶110

we grant liberty to the Zilla Parishad to issue individual notices to these Petitioners, call for their explanations within 15 days from the receipt of the notices and thereafter pass appropriate orders for re-fixation of the pension as per the actual salary payable. This order shall apply prospectively and the correction of the pension emoluments would be applicable prospectively from the date of this Judgment. In short, there would be no recovery of the pension amounts already paid, though inadvertently. Needless to state, that the above directions will not be applicable, if the above exercise is already concluded.

¶111

Rule is made partly absolute in the above terms.

¶112

(ASHWIN D. BHOBE, J.) (RAVINDRA V. GHUGE, J.)

¶113

Gayatri Shimpi

¶114

This Judgment is corrected/modified as per Speaking to the Minutes of order dated 24^th April, 2026.

¶115

9

Suryakant Govind Kengale v. Zilla Parishad Pune Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Suryakant Govind Kengale v. Zilla Parishad Pune Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Why is it important?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

K Raheja Corp Real Estate Private Limited vs Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai

Sayyad Shabbir Ahmed Ibrahim vs Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai through the Municipal Commissioner

Bhisbmanarayan S Yadav vs State of Maharashtra

Harsh Sharma vs Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies

Jindal Buildmart Limited vs Municipal Corporationof Greater Mumbai

Kavita Bhupesh Yadav vs Vidyanidhi Junior College of Science