Disposed¶106

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi

Bombay HC23 Sept 2025IA/4882/2025

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Bombay High Court, Ordinary Original Civil Jurisdiction; Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits Nos. 29, 244, 360 and 431 of 2025; Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd.; Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd; Gangotri Natural Water; Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi; Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya; interim applications and lodging numbers; leave petition lodgings 35455/2023 and 24950/2024; Court Receiver Report No. 76 of 2024; consent terms; stand over to 24/11/2025; Sharmila U. Deshmukh J; commercial IP disputes between beverage/water companies (per party names); Atmaram Patade; Manashvi Parikh.

What did the court decide?

Stand-over direction only: all listed matters adjourned to 24/11/2025 for settlement/filing of consent terms; no substantive order passed on the merits. ¶106

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi — Bombay HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

¶1

Board Sr.No.:-2

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

¶3

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 29 OF 2025

¶4

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

¶5

WITH

¶6

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 22715 OF 2024 In

¶7

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 244 OF 2025

¶8

Gangotri Natural Water ....PETITIONER V/S Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

¶9

WITH

¶10

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 360 OF 2025

¶11

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶12

Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi ....RESPONDENT

¶13

WITH

¶14

INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 4881 OF 2025

¶15

¶16

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶17

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

¶18

Page 1/6

¶19

WITH

¶20

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 431 OF 2025

¶21

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶22

Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya ....RESPONDENT

¶23

WITH

¶24

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 12088 OF 2024 In

¶25

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶26

Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

¶27

WITH

¶28

INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 4882 OF 2025

¶29

¶30

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 360 OF 2025

¶31

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S

¶32

Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi ....RESPONDENT

¶33

WITH

¶34

LEAVE PETITION LODGING NO. 35455 OF 2023

¶35

¶36

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 360 OF 2025

¶37

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S

¶38

Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi ....RESPONDENT

¶39

WITH

¶40

Page 2/6

¶41

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 24916 OF 2024

¶42

¶43

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 431 OF 2025

¶44

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶45

Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya ....RESPONDENT

¶46

WITH

¶47

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 35432 OF 2023

¶48

¶49

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 244 OF 2025

¶50

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S Gangotri Natural Water ....RESPONDENT

¶51

WITH

¶52

LEAVE PETITION LODGING NO. 24950 OF 2024

¶53

¶54

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 431 OF 2025

¶55

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶56

Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya ....RESPONDENT

¶57

WITH

¶58

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS NO. 244 OF 2025

¶59

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶60

Gangotri Natural Water ....RESPONDENT

¶61

WITH

¶62

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 12088 OF 2024

¶63

Page 3/6

¶64

¶65

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶66

Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S

¶67

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

¶68

WITH

¶69

INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 4881 OF 2025

¶70

¶71

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶72

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S

¶73

Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

¶74

WITH

¶75

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 17135 OF 2025

¶76

¶77

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶78

Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd ....PETITIONER V/S Flora Beverages Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

¶79

WITH

¶80

COURT RECEIVER REPORT NO. 76 OF 2024

¶81

¶82

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶83

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶84

Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd ....RESPONDENT

¶85

WITH

¶86

Page 4/6

¶87

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 22456 OF 2024 In

¶88

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶89

Flora Beverages India Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S

¶90

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

¶91

WITH

¶92

INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 21946 OF 2024

¶93

¶94

COMMERCIAL INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS SUITS 29 OF 2025

¶95

Flora Beverages India Pvt. Ltd. ....PETITIONER V/S Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. ....RESPONDENT

¶96

Adv. Atmaram Patade a/w Adv. Bhagawan Kasture, Adv. Pranav Manjrekar and Adv. Akshay Adivarekar i/b Adv. Atmaram Patade for the Applicant/Plaintiff in IA/4882/2025. Adv. Atmaram Patade a/w Adv. Pranav Manjarekar and Adv. Bhagawan Kasture i/b Atmaram Patade for the Plaintiff in IA(L)/24916/2024.

¶97

Adv. Atmaram Patade a/w Adv. Pranav Manjarekar and Adv. Bhagawan Kasture i/b Atmaram Patade for the Plaintiff in IA(L)/12088/2024.

¶98

Adv. Atmaram Patade a/w Adv. Bhagawan Kasture, Adv. Pranav Manjrekar and Adv. Akshay Adivarekar i/b Atmaram Patade for the Applicant/Plaintiff in IA(L)/35432/2023.

¶99

Adv. Manashvi Parikh for the Defendant.

¶100

Mr. Deepak Bhalerao Second Assistant to the Court Receiver present.

¶101

CORAM : HON'BLE JUSTICE SHARMILA U.

¶102

Page 5/6

¶103

DESHMUKH J

¶104

DATE : 7th November, 2025

¶105

P.C. :

¶106

Stand over to 24/11/2025 for settlement/ for filing consent terms.

¶107

( ASSOCIATE )

¶108

Page 6/6

Procedural history

How this case reached the court

AI extract

Prior proceeding
Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suit No. 29 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd (lead suit on the board).¶4
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 22715 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 244 of 2025: Gangotri Natural Water v/s Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd.¶8
Prior proceeding
Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suit No. 360 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi.¶12
Prior proceeding
Interim Application No. 4881 of 2025 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd v/s Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd.¶17
Prior proceeding
Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suit No. 431 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya.¶22
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 12088 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025: Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd v/s Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd.¶26
Prior proceeding
Interim Application No. 4882 of 2025 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 360 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd v/s Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi.¶32
Prior proceeding
Leave Petition Lodging No. 35455 of 2023 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 360 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd v/s Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi.¶38
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 24916 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 431 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya.¶45
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 35432 of 2023 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 244 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd v/s Gangotri Natural Water.¶50
Prior proceeding
Leave Petition Lodging No. 24950 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 431 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Harshit Dhirubhai Aslaliya.¶56
Prior proceeding
Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suit No. 244 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Gangotri Natural Water.¶60
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 17135 of 2025 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025: Energy Beverages Pvt Ltd v/s Flora Beverages Pvt Ltd.¶78
Prior proceeding
Court Receiver Report No. 76 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025 (Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v/s Flora Beverages India Pvt Ltd).¶80
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 22456 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025: Flora Beverages India Pvt. Ltd. v/s Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd.¶90
Prior proceeding
Interim Application Lodging No. 21946 of 2024 in Commercial Intellectual Property Rights Suits 29 of 2025: Flora Beverages India Pvt. Ltd. v/s Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd.¶95

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Procedural history

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

Shree Shantinath Steels vs the Board of Directors of Abhyudaya Co. Op Bank Ltd.

The Supreme Industries Limited vs Moorthi Rabeha

Asian Paints Limited vs Ramamurthy

Neon Laboratories Limited vs Elder Laboratories Ltd.

Neon Laboratories Limited vs Elder Laboratories Ltd.

Energy Beverages Pvt. Ltd. vs Rinkalben Kerulkumar Lukhi