Disposed¶115

American Eagle Overseas Private Limited v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Another

Bombay HC8 Aug 2025AO/462/2025

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Keywords: Appeal From Order 2025; Bombay High Court Appellate Side Civil Jurisdiction; Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai / The Mumbai Municipal Corporation / Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation; Designated Officer / Executive Engineer / Assistant Municipal Commissioner (L-Ward, P/North Ward); State of Maharashtra; Madhukar Mehta (since deceased); Justice Milind N. Jadhav; Maulik Chheda; stand over to 20/11/2025 (F.O.B.). Procedural adjournment only - usable solely for procedural history (existence and pendency of these appeals on 13-11-2025); contains no ruling, ratio or precedent treatment.

What the court decided

AI extract

American Eagle Overseas Private Limited vs Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Another — Bombay HC (2025) — LawSathi Research

¶1

Board Sr.No.:-68

¶2

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY APPELLATE SIDE CIVIL JURISDICTION

¶3

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 199 OF 2025

¶4

Chandrika Chunilal Shah And Another ....APPELLANT V/S

¶5

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Others

¶6

WITH

¶7

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 13569 OF 2025

¶8

Bharat Hardev Yadav And Another ....APPELLANT V/S

¶9

Designated Officer,asst.engineer (b And F) ....RESPONDENT

¶10

WITH

¶11

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 176 OF 2025

¶12

Nandkumar Jayram Bhandari And Others ....APPELLANT V/S

¶13

The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai....RESPONDENT Thr. P/north Ward Office

¶14

WITH

¶15

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 203 OF 2025

¶16

Amarlal Narayandas Vasyani Alias Amar ....APPELLANT Naraindas Batria And Another

¶17

V/S

¶18

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Others

¶19

Page 1/6

¶20

WITH

¶21

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 200 OF 2025

¶22

Kamlesh Lingayya Mungala Alias Kanakiya ....APPELLANT Lingayya Mungala

¶23

V/S

¶24

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Others

¶25

WITH

¶26

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 202 OF 2025

¶27

Pradeep Chandrakant Shirke And Another ....APPELLANT V/S

¶28

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Others

¶29

WITH

¶30

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 218 OF 2025

¶31

Ronges Gonsalves ....APPELLANT V/S

¶32

The Municipal Corpoaration Of Gr. Mumbai A....RESPONDENT Body Corporate M.m.c. Act, 1888. And Ors.

¶33

WITH

¶34

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 239 OF 2025

¶35

Abdul Rahim Abdul Rashid Shaikh ....APPELLANT V/S

¶36

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr... RESPONDENT . The Executive Engineer (designated Officer)

¶37

WITH

¶38

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 241 OF 2025

¶39

Page 2/6

¶40

Mr. Abdul Wahab Qureshi S/o. Abdul Razzak ....APPELLANT Qureshi

¶41

V/S

¶42

The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai....RESPONDENT And Another

¶43

WITH

¶44

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 456 OF 2025

¶45

Shri. Abhiman Mariba Kamble ....APPELLANT V/S

¶46

The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai....RESPONDENT Thr. Asst. Municipal Commissioner L-ward Office

¶47

WITH

¶48

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 12936 OF 2025

¶49

Tejinder Kaur Saini W/o. Takdir Singh Saini ....APPELLANT V/S

¶50

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation Greater ....RESPONDENT Mumbai And Another

¶51

WITH

¶52

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 13087 OF 2025

¶53

Dinkar Kisan Chavan ....APPELLANT

¶54

V/S

¶55

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And ....RESPONDENT Another

¶56

WITH

¶57

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 124 OF 2025

Jadavji Deraj Chheda

....APPELLANT

Page 3/6

V/S

Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation And ....RESPONDENT Another

¶63

WITH

¶64

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 182 OF 2025

¶65

Anil Amardev Rajbhar ....APPELLANT V/S

¶66

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr... RESPONDENT . Its Commissioner And Others

¶67

WITH

¶68

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 201 OF 2025

¶69

Premji Ladha Shah ....APPELLANT V/S

¶70

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Others

¶71

WITH

¶72

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 209 OF 2025

¶73

Bhagwati Laxmansingh Parke ....APPELLANT V/S

¶74

The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai....RESPONDENT

¶75

WITH

¶76

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 217 OF 2025

¶77

Ejaj Sattar Ahmed Qureshi ....APPELLANT

¶78

V/S

¶79

The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai....RESPONDENT

¶80

WITH

¶81

Page 4/6

¶82

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 240 OF 2025

¶83

Smt. Tarannum Firoz Shaikh ....APPELLANT V/S

¶84

State Of Maharashtra Thr. Add.government ....RESPONDENT Pleader And Others

¶85

WITH

¶86

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 13092 OF 2025

¶87

Milind Suryakant Mukadam ....APPELLANT V/S

¶88

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And ....RESPONDENT Another

¶89

WITH

¶90

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 13095 OF 2025

¶91

Sanjay Shamrao Patil ....APPELLANT V/S

¶92

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And ....RESPONDENT Another

¶93

WITH

¶94

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 14852 OF 2025

¶95

Sunil Murlidhar Bhagat ....APPELLANT V/S

¶96

Madhukar Mehta (since Deceased) Thr Its Mrs.....RESPONDENT Jayshree Mehta

¶97

WITH

¶98

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 11865 OF 2025

¶99

Shri. Santosh Paraji Yoge

....APPELLANT

Page 5/6

V/S

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr... RESPONDENT . Executive Engineer (designated Officer)

¶104

WITH

¶105

APPEAL FROM ORDER STAMP NO. 13089 OF 2025

¶106

Bharat Ramchandra Redkar ....APPELLANT V/S

¶107

The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And ....RESPONDENT Another

¶108

WITH

¶109

APPEAL FROM ORDER NO. 462 OF 2025

¶110

American Eagle Overseas Private Limited ....APPELLANT V/S

¶111

Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And....RESPONDENT Another

¶112

Mr.Maulik Chheda for Petitioner

¶113

CORAM : HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE MILIND N. JADHAV J DATE : 13th November, 2025

¶114

P.C. :

¶115

S. O. to 20/11/2025 ( F. O. B.).

¶116

( FOR REGISTRAR JUDICIAL - I )

¶117

Page 6/6

Parties & counsel

AI extract

appellant
Chandrika Chunilal Shah And Another¶4
Maulik Chheda
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Others¶5
appellant
Bharat Hardev Yadav And Another¶8
respondent
Designated Officer,asst.engineer (b And F)¶9
appellant
Nandkumar Jayram Bhandari And Others¶12
respondent
The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr. P/north Ward Office¶13
appellant
Amarlal Narayandas Vasyani Alias Amar Naraindas Batria And Another¶16
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Others¶18
appellant
Kamlesh Lingayya Mungala Alias Kanakiya Lingayya Mungala¶22
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Others¶24
appellant
Pradeep Chandrakant Shirke And Another¶27
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Others¶28
appellant
Ronges Gonsalves¶31
respondent
The Municipal Corpoaration Of Gr. Mumbai A Body Corporate M.m.c. Act, 1888. And Ors.¶32
appellant
Abdul Rahim Abdul Rashid Shaikh¶35
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr. The Executive Engineer (designated Officer)¶36
appellant
Mr. Abdul Wahab Qureshi S/o. Abdul Razzak Qureshi¶40
respondent
The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Another¶42
appellant
Shri. Abhiman Mariba Kamble¶45
respondent
The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr. Asst. Municipal Commissioner L-ward Office¶46
appellant
Tejinder Kaur Saini W/o. Takdir Singh Saini¶49
respondent
The Mumbai Municipal Corporation Greater Mumbai And Another¶50
appellant
Dinkar Kisan Chavan¶53
respondent
The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And Another¶55
appellant
Jadavji Deraj Chheda¶58
respondent
Brihan Mumbai Municipal Corporation And Another¶62
appellant
Anil Amardev Rajbhar¶65
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr. Its Commissioner And Others¶66
appellant
Premji Ladha Shah¶69
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Others¶70
appellant
Bhagwati Laxmansingh Parke¶73
respondent
The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai¶74
appellant
Ejaj Sattar Ahmed Qureshi¶77
respondent
The Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai¶79
appellant
Smt. Tarannum Firoz Shaikh¶83
respondent
State Of Maharashtra Thr. Add.government Pleader And Others¶84
appellant
Milind Suryakant Mukadam¶87
respondent
The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And Another¶88
appellant
Sanjay Shamrao Patil¶91
respondent
The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And Another¶92
appellant
Sunil Murlidhar Bhagat¶95
respondent
Madhukar Mehta (since Deceased) Thr Its Mrs. Jayshree Mehta¶96
appellant
Shri. Santosh Paraji Yoge¶99
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai Thr. Executive Engineer (designated Officer)¶103
appellant
Bharat Ramchandra Redkar¶106
respondent
The Mumbai Municipal Corporation And Another¶107
appellant
American Eagle Overseas Private Limited¶110
respondent
Municipal Corporation Of Greater Mumbai And Another¶111

Coram

AI extract

Milind N. Jadhavauthor¶113

American Eagle Overseas Private Limited v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

American Eagle Overseas Private Limited v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Another

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

Asha Sudhakar Ghodke vs Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai (through the Municipal Commissioner) and Ors.

Jagannath Tatoba Rupnar vs Radhabai Tatoba Rupnar Since Deceased and Ors.

Vilas Enterprises and Anr. vs L and W Building Solutions Pvt. Ltd.

Transcon Developers Private Limited vs Anchor Point Developer Private Limited

Ganesh Sukhdev Aghav vs Vijaya Prakash Dongre and Anr.

Shri Ankush Balasaheb Bande and Anr. vs Shri Tukaram Shivram Pote and Anr.