Partly allowed

Sakubai Rajaram Manore v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Bombay HC19 Apr 2017FA/4100/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Group of first appeals against compensation awarded for house properties and open land acquired on account of submergence under the Waghur Dam project. Following an earlier judgment on the same project, the court allowed the appeals in part, awarding compensation for house properties as per the Valuer's report less 10%, and Rs.600 per square metre for open land.

What did the court decide?

Compensation for house properties as per the chart (10% deduction from valuer's report) and Rs.600 per square metre for open land, with statutory benefits; no interest on enhanced compensation for the

Sakubai Rajaram Manore Vs the State of Maharashtra and Ors. — Land Acquisition | Bombay HC (2017)

¶1

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶2

¶3

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY,

¶4

BENCH AT AURANGABAD

¶5

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13664 OF 2017

¶6

Sau. Vimalbai Madhav Shirsath ... APPELLANT VERSUS The Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶7

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶8

WITH

¶9

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13592 OF 2017

¶10

Pandit Vithoba Patil ... APPELLANT

¶11

VERSUS

¶12

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶13

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶14

WITH

¶15

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13662 OF 2017

¶16

Prabhavati Sambhaji Patil ... APPELLANT

¶17

VERSUS

¶18

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶19

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶20

¶21

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶22

WITH

¶23

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13654 OF 2017

¶24

Dinkar Madhukar Patil, Died L.Rs. Ratnabai Dinkar Patil & others

¶25

... APPELLANTS

¶26

VERSUS

¶27

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶28

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri G.O. Wattamwar, A.G.P. for State

¶29

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶30

WITH

¶31

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13660 OF 2017

¶32

Sakubai Rajaram Manore ... APPELLANT VERSUS

¶33

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶34

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri R.B. Bagul, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶35

WITH

¶36

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13631 OF 2017

Pralhad Bhika Patil

... APPELLANT

VERSUS

The Collector, Jalgaon & others

¶41

... RESPONDENTS

¶42

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶43

¶44

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶45

WITH

¶46

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13608 OF 2017

¶47

Trambak Motiram Patil

¶48

... APPELLANT

¶49

VERSUS

¶50

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶51

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State

¶52

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶53

WITH

¶54

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13646 OF 2017

¶55

Ramesh Ramdas Koli & ors.

¶56

... APPELLANTS

¶57

VERSUS

¶58

The Collector, Jalgaon & others

¶59

... RESPONDENTS

¶60

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶61

WITH

¶62

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13634 OF 2017

¶63

Bhikari Ziparu Patil ... APPELLANT

¶64

VERSUS

¶65

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶66

¶67

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶68

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶69

WITH

¶70

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13658 OF 2017

¶71

Ashok Motiram Patil ... APPELLANT

¶72

VERSUS

¶73

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶74

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶75

WITH

¶76

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13642 OF 2017

¶77

Geetabai Shamrao Patil, Died L.Rs. Ananda Shamrao Patil & others ... APPELLANTS

¶78

VERSUS

¶79

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶80

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri G.O. Wattamwar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶81

WITH

¶82

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13648 OF 2017

¶83

Shivaji Narayan Baviskar & ors.

¶84

... APPELLANTS

¶85

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶86

¶87

VERSUS

¶88

The Collector, Jalgaon & others

¶89

... RESPONDENTS

¶90

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri R.B. Bagul, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶91

WITH

¶92

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13650 OF 2017

¶93

Mango Dhanu Nhavi, Died L.R. Vasant Mango Nhavi, Died L.R. Ravindra Vasant Nhavi ... APPELLANT

¶94

VERSUS

¶95

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶96

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶97

WITH

¶98

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13692 OF 2017

¶99

Atmaram Vedu Johare, Died L.Rs. Ahilyabai Atmaram Johare, Died Mukunda Atmaram Johare & others

¶100

... APPELLANTS

¶101

VERSUS

¶102

The Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶103

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶104

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶105

¶106

WITH

¶107

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13696 OF 2017

¶108

Bhagwan Natthu Chaudhari & anr. ... APPELLANTS

¶109

VERSUS

¶110

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶111

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶112

WITH

¶113

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13698 OF 2017

¶114

Baburao Kacharu Patil & anr. ... APPELLANTS VERSUS The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶115

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶116

WITH

¶117

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13694 OF 2017

¶118

Janardan Daulat Patil, Died L.Rs. Sulochanabai Janardan Patil & ors.

¶119

... APPELLANTS

¶120

VERSUS

¶121

The Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶122

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State

¶123

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶124

¶125

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶126

WITH

¶127

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13688 OF 2017

¶128

Raosaheb Bapu Patil ... APPELLANT VERSUS The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶129

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri G.O. Wattamwar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶130

WITH

¶131

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13685 OF 2017

¶132

Arjun Damu Patil ... APPELLANT VERSUS The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶133

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri R.B. Bagul, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶134

WITH

¶135

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13652 OF 2017

¶136

Subhapatti Dudh Utpadak Society ... APPELLANT VERSUS The District Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶137

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶138

¶139

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶140

WITH

¶141

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13730 OF 2017

¶142

Bhagwat Raghunath Patil ... APPELLANT

¶143

VERSUS

¶144

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶145

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶146

WITH

¶147

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13724 OF 2017

¶148

Prabhakar Chago Patil, Died L.Rs. Vimalbai Prabhakar Patil & others

¶149

... APPELLANTS

¶150

VERSUS

¶151

The Special Land Acquisition Officer (2) & ors.... RESPONDENTS

¶152

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶153

WITH

¶154

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13704 OF 2017

¶155

Savitribai Pandhari Patil ... APPELLANT

¶156

VERSUS

¶157

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶158

¶159

The State of Maharashtra & others

¶160

... RESPONDENTS

¶161

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶162

WITH

¶163

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13701 OF 2017

¶164

Shivlal Mansaram Patil & others ... APPELLANTS

¶165

VERSUS

¶166

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶167

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶168

WITH

¶169

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13709 OF 2017

¶170

Kasabai Rajaram Patil, Died L.Rs. Ashabai Rupchand Patil & ors.

¶171

... APPELLANTS

¶172

VERSUS

¶173

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶174

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri G.O. Wattamwar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶175

WITH

¶176

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13741 OF 2017

¶177

Prabhakar Rajaram Chaudhari & anr. ... APPELLANTS

¶178

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶179

¶180

VERSUS

¶181

The Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶182

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri R.B. Bagul, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶183

WITH

¶184

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13747 OF 2017

¶185

Ramesh Keshav Bavaskar ... APPELLANT

¶186

VERSUS

¶187

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶188

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶189

WITH

¶190

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13736 OF 2017

¶191

Pandurang Madhav Sonar ... APPELLANT VERSUS

¶192

The State of Maharashtra & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶193

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶194

WITH

¶195

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13644 OF 2017

¶196

Narayan Ramkrishna Patil

¶197

APPELLANT

¶198

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶199

¶200

VERSUS

¶201

The Collector, Jalgaon & others

¶202

... RESPONDENTS

¶203

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶204

WITH

¶205

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13770 OF 2017

¶206

Damu Dhanji Patil, Died L.Rs. Ramdas Damu Patil & anr.

¶207

... APPELLANTS

¶208

VERSUS

¶209

The Collector, Jalgaon & others ... RESPONDENTS

¶210

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State

¶211

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶212

WITH

¶213

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13772 OF 2017

¶214

Kokilabai Lotan Chaudhari & ors.

¶215

... APPELLANTS

¶216

VERSUS

¶217

The State of Maharashtra & others

¶218

... RESPONDENTS

¶219

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶220

WITH

¶221

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13602 OF 2017

¶222

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶223

¶224

Dattu Nathu Kulle, Died L.Rs. Ushabai Dattu Kulle & ors.

¶225

... APPELLANTS

¶226

VERSUS

¶227

The State of Maharashtra & others

¶228

... RESPONDENTS

¶229

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶230

WITH

¶231

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13777 OF 2017

¶232

Raghunath Narayan Patil ... APPELLANT

¶233

VERSUS

¶234

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶235

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶236

WITH

¶237

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13492 OF 2017

¶238

Navnath Raghunath Patil & anr. ... APPELLANTS

¶239

VERSUS

¶240

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶241

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶242

WITH

¶243

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶244

¶245

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13827 OF 2017

¶246

Ambadas Kashinath Mule & ors. ... APPELLANTS

¶247

VERSUS

¶248

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶249

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶250

WITH

¶251

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13681 OF 2017

¶252

Sanjay Hiraman Patil ... APPELLANT

¶253

VERSUS

¶254

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶255

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶256

WITH

¶257

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13732 OF 2017

¶258

Gangaram Narayan Koli, Died L.Rs. Anjanabai Gangaram Koli & ors. ... APPELLANTS

¶259

VERSUS

¶260

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶261

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶262

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶263

¶264

WITH

¶265

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13788 OF 2017

¶266

Bhika Hari Patil (Pawar)

¶267

... APPELLANTS

¶268

VERSUS

¶269

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶270

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶271

WITH

¶272

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13782 OF 2017

¶273

Eknath Vidtoba Kolhe ... APPELLANTS VERSUS

¶274

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶275

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶276

WITH

¶277

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13786 OF 2017

¶278

Tukaram Ramdhan Patil (GPA) & anr.

¶279

... APPELLANTS

¶280

VERSUS

¶281

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶282

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State

¶283

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶284

¶285

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶286

WITH

¶287

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13585 OF 2017

Bhika Hari Patil

... APPELLANTS

VERSUS

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶292

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶293

WITH

¶294

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13629 OF 2017

¶295

Ratan Ramdhan Patil ... APPELLANTS

¶296

VERSUS

¶297

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶298

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶299

WITH

¶300

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13834 OF 2017

¶301

Ramdas Namdev Lohar, Died L.R. Shivaji Ramdas Lohar

¶302

... APPELLANTS

¶303

VERSUS

¶304

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶305

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶306

¶307

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶308

WITH

¶309

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13814 OF 2017

¶310

Natthu Damu Sonar & ors. ... APPELLANTS

¶311

VERSUS

¶312

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶313

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶314

WITH

¶315

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13811 OF 2017

¶316

Tapiram Tukaram Patil, Died L.Rs.

¶317

Kalabai Tapiram Chaudhari, Died L.Rs.

¶318

Ananda Tapiram Patil, Died 1A) Nirmalabai Ananda Chaudhari & ors. ... APPELLANTS

¶319

VERSUS

¶320

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State

¶321

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶322

WITH

¶323

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13750 OF 2017

¶324

Rajendra Pandurang Patil ... APPELLANT

¶325

VERSUS

¶326

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶327

¶328

The District Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶329

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶330

WITH

¶331

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13720 OF 2017

¶332

Devram Dhanu Chaudhari, Died L.Rs. Indravatibai Devram Patil & ors.

¶333

... APPELLANTS

¶334

VERSUS

¶335

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶336

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶337

WITH

¶338

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13806 OF 2017

¶339

Ravindra Pandurang Patil ... APPELLANT VERSUS The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶340

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶341

WITH

¶342

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13850 OF 2017

¶343

Bhagwat Totaram Nhavi (G.P.A.) & anr. ... APPELLANTS

¶344

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶345

¶346

VERSUS

¶347

The State of Maharashtra & ors.

¶348

... RESPONDENTS

¶349

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶350

WITH

¶351

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13848 OF 2017

¶352

Aniruddha Raghavrao Patil ... APPELLANT

¶353

VERSUS

¶354

The Special Land Acquisition Officer (2) & anr.... RESPONDENTS

¶355

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶356

WITH

¶357

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13803 OF 2017

¶358

Dhanraj Pandurang Patil ... APPELLANT

¶359

VERSUS

¶360

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶361

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶362

WITH

¶363

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13640 OF 2017

¶364

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶365

¶366

Sanjay Waman Patil ... APPELLANT

¶367

VERSUS

¶368

The Special Land Acquisition Officer & anr. ... RESPONDENTS

¶369

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.P. Sonpawle, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶370

WITH

¶371

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13656 OF 2017

¶372

Surastabai Raghavrao Patil ... APPELLANT VERSUS

¶373

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶374

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶375

WITH

¶376

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13757 OF 2017

¶377

Shivaji Parshuram Patil & anr. ... APPELLANTS

¶378

VERSUS

¶379

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶380

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶381

WITH

¶382

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶383

¶384

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13760 OF 2017

¶385

Anil Pandhari Patil & ors.

¶386

... APPELLANTS

¶387

VERSUS

¶388

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶389

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶390

WITH

¶391

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13764 OF 2017

¶392

Arun Ramdas Patil, Died L.Rs. Vandanbai Arun Patil & ors.

¶393

... APPELLANTS

¶394

VERSUS

¶395

The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶396

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶397

WITH

¶398

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13762 OF 2017

¶399

Pundlik Dhanji Chaudhari, Died L.Rs. Ushabai Pundlik Patil & ors.

¶400

... APPELLANTS

¶401

VERSUS

¶402

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶403

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri C.V. Dharurkar, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶404

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶405

¶406

WITH

¶407

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13838 OF 2017

¶408

Vitthal Raghunath Patil ... APPELLANT VERSUS The State of Maharashtra & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶409

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri B.V. Virde, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶410

WITH

¶411

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13852 OF 2017

¶412

Shriram Natthu Chaudhari ... APPELLANT

¶413

VERSUS

¶414

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶415

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri A.M. Phule, A.G.P. for State Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶416

WITH

¶417

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13840 OF 2017

¶418

Baliram Madhav Sonar, Died L.Rs. Bharat Baliram Randhir (Sonar) & ors.

¶419

... APPELLANTS

¶420

VERSUS

¶421

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors. ... RESPONDENTS

¶422

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellants Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State

¶423

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶424

¶425

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶426

WITH

¶427

FIRST APPEAL STAMP NO.13844 OF 2017

Bhagwat Keshav Patil

... APPELLANT

VERSUS

The Collector, Jalgaon & ors.

¶432

... RESPONDENTS

¶433

Shri A.B. Kale, Advocate for appellant Shri S.S. Dande, A.G.P. for State

¶434

Mrs. Chaitali Chaudhari - Kutti, Advocate for acquiring body

¶435

CORAM: V.K. JADHAV, J. DATED: 19th April, 2017.

¶436

ORAL ORDER :

¶437

All these appeals deal with acquisition of the house properties of the claimants on account of submergence of area under Waghur Dam.

¶438

A group of First Appeals bearing First Appeal No.3060 of 2013 with connected First Appeals came to be disposed of this Court (Coram : S.V. Gangapurwala, J.) vide judgment and order dated 19/12/2013, thereby upholding the valuation made by the Reference Court in respect of the land at Rs.600/- per R, however, had granted enhancement of compensation in respect of the structures, wherein the Valuer's report was considered by this Court and had deducted 10% from the said Valuer's report. In para 7, 8 and 9, it was observed as under :

¶439

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶440

¶441

"7. The Court has appreciated the evidence on record and had come to the conclusion that he accepts the valuation report. But then no reason is given for deducting the amount in some of the matters upto 60% to 75% and in majority of matters 25%.

¶442

There may be some error. To work out the said margin of error, some deduction would be permissible from the amount as suggested by the Valuer. Considering the fact that. the properties acquired are lands and small houses the margin of error would also be less.

¶443

In the light of the above, it would be appropriate to deduct 10% from the valuation as shown by the expert.

¶444

In a group of First Appeals bearing First Appeal No.2745/2015 with connected First Appeals, this Court (Coram : S.V. Gangapurwala, J.), vide judgment and order dated 21/10/2015, disposed of the said Appeals arising out of the same project and the judgment and award passed by the Reference Court in the light of the observations made earlier as referred in para No.2 of this order, bearing First Appeal No.3060/2013 with connected First Appeals.

¶445

In light of the above, I pass the following order :

¶446

(i) The claimants in all these appeals would be entitled for the compensation of the acquired land at the rate of Rs.600/per square meter for open piece of land as given by the

¶447

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶448

¶449

Reference Court and for house properties acquired as per the chart given below along with the statutory benefits as awarded by the Reference Court.

¶450

Sr. No.	Name of the parties	First Appeal/ St.No.	L.A.R. No.	10% deduc- tion (Rs.)
1	Sau. Vimalbai Madhav Shirsath	13664/2017	390/2009	5400
2	Pandit Vithoba Patil	13592/2017	371/2005	3150
3	Prabhavati Sambhaji Patil	13662/2017	559/2005	2880
4	Dinkar Madhukar Patil, Died L.Rs. Ratnabai Dinkar Patil & others	13654/2017	454/2005	1530
5	Sakubai Rajaram Manore	13660/2017	249/2005	900/-
6	Pralhad Bhika Patil	13631/2017	919/2007	4950
7	Trambak Motiram Patil	13608/2017	679/2005	6075
8	Ramesh Ramdas Koli & ors.	13646/2017	378/2009	5850
9	Bhikari Ziparu Patil	13634/2017	718/2005	4950
10	Ashok Motiram Patil	13658/2017	738/2006	990
11	Geetabai Shamrao Patil, Died L.Rs. Ananda Shamrao Patil & others	13642/2017	443/2005	4500
12	Shivaji Narayan Baviskar & ors.	13648/2017	247/2005	3060
13	Mango Dhanu Nhavi, Died L.R. Vasant Mango Nhavi, Died L.R. Ravindra Vasant Nhavi	13650/2017	519/2006	990
14	Atmaram Vedu Johare, Died L.Rs. Ahilyabai Atmaram Johare, Died Mukunda Atmaram Johare & ors.	13692/2017	366/2009	1170
15	Bhagwan Natthu Chaudhari	13696/2017	649/2005	5400
16	Baburao Kacharu Patil	13698/2017	707/2005	7290
17	Janardan Daulat Patil, Died L.Rs. Sulochanabai Janardan Patil & ors.	13694/2017	592/2005	5850
18	Raosaheb Bapu Patil	13688/2017	682/2005	4950 + 4950
19	Arjun Damu Patil	13685/2017	582/2005	4950

¶451

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶452

¶453

20	Subhapatti Dudh Utpadak Society	13652/2017	2398/2005	5400
21	Bhagwat Raghunath Patil	13730/2017	528/2005	4950
22	Prabhakar Chago Patil, Died L.Rs. Vimalbai Prabhakar Patil & others	13724/2017	664/2005	6075
23	Savitribai Pandhari Patil	13704/2017	741/2005	2070
24	Shivlal Mansaram Patil & others	13701/2017	555/2005	4950
25	Kasabai Rajaram Patil, Died L.Rs. Ashabai Rupchand Patil & ors.	13709/2017	680/2005	5400
26	Prabhakar Rajaram Chaudhari & anr.	13741/2017	509/2005	4950
27	Ramesh Keshav Bavaskar	13747/2017	530/2005	(Open plot)
28	Pandurang Madhav Sonar	13736/2017	2405/2005	3510 + 4770
29	Narayan Ramkrishna Patil	13644/2017	352/2009	4950
30	Damu Dhanji Patil, Died L.rs. Ramdas Damu Patil & anr.	13770/2017	355/2009	5400
31	Kokilabai Lotan Chaudhari & ors.	13772/2017	2299/2005	1350
32	Dattu Nathu Kulle, Died L.Rs. Ushabai Dattu Kulle & ors.	13602/2017	705/2005	5850
33	Raghunath Narayan Patil	13777/2017	631/2005	4050
34	Navnath Raghunath Patil & anr.	13492/2017	630/2005	4950
35	Ambadas Kashinath Mule & ors.	13827/2017	2301/2005	7290 + 2250
36	Sanjay Hiraman Patil	13681/2017	726/2005	4950
37	Gangaram Narayan Koli, Died L.Rs. Anjanabai Gangaram Koli & ors.	13732/2017	734/2005	2610
38	Bhika Hari Patil (Pawar)	13788/2017	702/2005	1170
39	Eknath Vidtoba Kolhe	13782/2017	725/2005	3420
40	Tukaram Ramdhan Patil (GPA) & anr.	13786/2017	790/2005	3330
41	Bhika Hari Patil	13585/2017	701/2005	4950 + 2610
42	Ratan Ramdhan Patil	13629/2017	432/2005	1440
43	Ramdas Namdev Lohar, Died L.R. Shivaji Ramdas Lohar	13834/2017	433/2005	4320

¶454

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶455

¶456

44	Natthu Damu Sonar & ors.	13814/2017	798/2005	900
45	Taparam Tukaram Patil, Died L.Rs. Kalabai Tapiram Chaudhari, Died L.Rs. 1. Ananda Tapiram Patil, Died 1A) Nirmalabai Ananda Chaudhari & ors.	13811/2017	792/2005	3420
46	Rajendra Pandurang Patil	13750/2017	2399/2005	5400
47	Devram Dhanu Chaudhari, Died L.Rs. Indravatibai Devram Patil & ors.	13720/2017	657/2005	5850
48	Ravindra Pandurang Patil	13806/2017	552/2005	720
49	Bhagwat Totaram Nhavi (G.P.A.) & anr.	13850/2017	252/2005	450
50	Aniruddha Raghavrao Patil	13848/2017	661/2005	6075
51	Dhanraj Pandurang Patil	13803/2017	538/2006	5850
52	Sanjay Waman Patil	13640/2017	535/2006	5400
53	Surastabai Raghavrao Patil	13656/2017	1132/2006	5400
54	Shivaji Parshuram Patil & anr.	13757/2017	1137/2006	5400
55	Anil Pandhari Patil	13760/2017	1136/2006	5400
56	Arun Ramdas Patil, Died L.Rs. Vandanbai Arun Patil & ors.	13764/2017	1139/2006	4230
57	Pundlik Dhanji Chaudhari, Died L.Rs. Ushabai Pundlik Patil & ors.	13762/2017	1135/2006	3510 + 5310
58	Vitthal Raghunath Patil	13838/2017	450/2005	4860
59	Shriram Natthu Chaudhari	13852/2017	369/2009	5310
60	Baliram Madhav Sonar, Died L.Rs. Bharat Baliram Randhir (Sonar) & ors.	13840/2017	284/2006	5400
61	Bhagwat Keshav Patil	13844/2017	537/2005	2880 + 4140

¶457

(ii) The respondents shall pay the compensation amount to the claimants as per the above chart in respect of the house properties and at a rate of Rs.600/- per square meter for

¶458

First Appeal St. No.13664/2017 with connected appeals

¶459

¶460

open land along with all statutory benefits as held by the Reference Court.

¶461

(iii) In respect of enhanced compensation amount, the claimants would not be entitled for the interest on the enhanced compensation amount for the delayed period as per the undertaking given by them.

¶462

(iv) First Appeals stand partly allowed, however, with no order as to costs.

¶463

( V.K. JADHAV ) JUDGE

¶464

fmp/fa13664.17

Sakubai Rajaram Manore v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Sakubai Rajaram Manore v. the State of Maharashtra and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

The State of Maharashtra Vs Kisan Khandu Bade and Anr.

Pandhari Hari Mang Died Thr Lrs Chandrakant and Others Vs the State of Maharashtra and Others

The State of Maha. Vs Krishna Dhondiba Nagargoje

The State of Mah and Ors. Vs Sukalal Rajaram Patil

The State of Mah Thr Collector and Ors. Vs Bhagwan Pandhari Patil

The State of Mah Thr Collector and Ors. Vs Zhipru Bhika Chambhar Died Thr Lrs Indubai Zhipry Chambhar(Nimbalkar) and Ors.