Single Judge disposed of multiple connected Writ Petitions by consent, referring to a common judgment in W.P. Nos. 4810/2012 and 4806/12 regarding linked facts and provisions.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
1
dgm
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
APPELLATE SIDE CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 4814 OF 2012
Ramesh Krishna Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.4820 OF 2012
Meghnath Krishna Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.4822 OF 2012 Bijendra Satbir Khairalia .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6142 OF 2012 Sharad Kashinath Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd.
2 wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6144 OF 2012
Narayan Ganpat Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6145 OF 2012
Ramesh Narayan Mhatre .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6147 OF 2012 Suresh Gopal Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6151 OF 2012 Ramesh Krishna Mhatre .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6152 OF 2012
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
3
S. Irudayaraj .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6153 OF 2012
Jaywant Kashinath Bhoir .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6154 OF 2012 Dattatray Madhukar Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6155 OF 2012 Kisan Rajaram Dhanawade .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6157 OF 2012 Dilip Vishnu Madhavi .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd.
4 wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION NO.6158 OF 2012
Kisan Arjun Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6159 OF 2012
Chandrakant Raghunath Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 6163 OF 2012
Ganpat Hira Mhatre .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6164 OF 2012
Haridas Jayram Patil .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO.6165 OF 2012
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
5
Raghu Sesu Bangera .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 6166 OF 2012
| Dnyaneshwar Gorvrya Dalvi | .... Petiti | oner |
|---|---|---|
| vs | ||
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. | ||
| Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai | .... | Respondent |
| ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 6167 |
OF 2012 | |
| Bhimrao Damodar Khadse | .... | Petitioner |
| vs | ||
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. | ||
| Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai | .... | Respondent |
| ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 7680 |
OF 2012 | |
| Pandharinath S. Patil | .... | Petitioner |
| vs | ||
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai |
.... | Respondent |
| ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 7681 |
OF 2012 | |
| Mahendrasingh Ram Thakur vs |
.... | Petitioner |
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. | ||
| Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai | .... | Respondent |
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
6
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 7682 OF 2012
Naresh Daulat Mahadik .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 7684 OF 2012
| Arun Laxman Kulkarni .... vs |
Petitioner |
|---|---|
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | |
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... |
Respondent |
| ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 7689 OF 2012 |
|
| Bhushan Govind Parab .... vs |
Petitioner |
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | |
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... |
Respondent |
| ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 7690 OF 2012 |
|
| Raghunath Maruti Dhone .... vs |
Petitioner |
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | |
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... |
Respondent |
ALONG WITH
WRIT PETITION NO. 7693 OF 2012
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
7
Madhukar Shivram Dhanawade .... Petitioner vs M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai .... Respondent
ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 8360 OF 2012
| Suresh Shivram Dhanawade | .... | Petitioner |
|---|---|---|
| vs | ||
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. | ||
| Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai | .... | Respondent |
AND ALONG WITH WRIT PETITION NO. 8361 OF 2012
| Narayan Dhaku Shigwan | .... | Petitioner |
|---|---|---|
| vs | ||
| M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd. | ||
| (M/s.Reliance Corporate IT Park Ltd. | ||
| Thane Belapur Rd, TTC, Navi Mumbai | .... | Respondent |
Mr. A.D. Kango for the Petitioners in Writ Petition Nos. 4814/12, 4820/12, 4822/12, 6142/12, 6144/12, 6145/12, 6147/12, 6151/12, 6152/12, 6153/12, 6154/12, 6155/12 and 6157/12, 6158/12, 6159/12, 6163/12, 6164/12, 6165/12, 6166/12, 6167/12.
Mr. Suresh M. Sabrad with Mr. D.R. Patekar and Mr. Yuwraj D. Patil for the Petitioners in W. P. Nos. 7680/12, 7681/12, 7682/12, 7684/12, 7689/12, 7690/12, 7693/12 and 8360/12 and 8361/12.
Mr. Chander Uday Singh, Senior Advocate along with Mr. Kiran S. Bapat and Ms. Malanie D'souza i/by Mr. A.S. Dayal and Associates for the Respondents in all the matters.
wp-4814-12 third group.sxw
8
CORAM: ANOOP V. MOHTA, J.
JUDGMENT RESERVED ON : September 06, 2012 JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON: September 12, 2012
JUDGMENT.:
By consent, heard finally along with all other connected matters.
2 In view of the common Judgment passed today in Writ Petition No.4810/2012 and Writ Petition No.4806/12 along with companion matters, based upon the connected and common facts, provisions of law, the judgments, the common arguments and the settlement and the related aspects, apart from their respective claims, so referred by the learned Industrial Court, the present Writ Petitions are also disposed of/dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(ANOOP V. MOHTA, J.)
Ramesh Krishna Patil
M/s. Relene Petrochemicals Ltd.
Anoop V. Mohta
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
