Radhey Shyam Sharma and Another Vs U.P. Real… — Writ and Judicial Review | Allahabad HC (2024)

Radhey Shyam Sharma and Another Vs U.P. Real… — Writ and Judicial Review | Allahabad HC (2024)

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

Direction to U.P. Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Lucknow to conclude disposal of the petitioners' representation in Complaint No. LKO162/03/87803/2022, along with the final order, expeditiously and without unnecessary adjournments to any party, in view of the directions issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.

Issue for consideration

Whether the U.P. Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Lucknow should be directed to expeditiously dispose of the petitioners' representation filed in respect of Complaint No. LKO162/03/87803/2022. +1 more

Court's answer

The writ petition is disposed of with a direction to U.P. Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Lucknow to conclude disposal of the representation filed by the petitioners in Complaint No. LKO162/03/87803/2022, along with passing of the final order.

Ratio / Principle

No notice need be issued to respondent no. 2, assurance having been given during the course of arguments.

Key takeaways

The disposal is to be completed expeditiously, without granting unnecessary adjournments to any party, and keeping in view the directions issued by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.ratio¶14

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

Matters Under Article 227 No. 4349 of 2024 (Allahabad High Court, Lucknow Bench; Subhash Vidyarthi, J.; decided 11.9.2024) — Mandamus — Delay by U.P. Real Estate Regulatory Authority, Lucknow in disposing of the petitioners' representation in Complaint No. LKO162/03/87803/2022: representation filed 14.04.2023; first hearing 06.10.2023; next date fixed beyond six months (12.04.2024) on the respondent's request for time to file a compliance report; non-compliance of the order dated 06.10.2023 recorded on 15.04.2024 and again on 04.07.2024; final opportunity granted and hearing fixed for 12.09.2024. Held: no notice was required to respondent no. 2, assurances having been given during arguments; petition disposed of with a direction to U.P. RERA, Lucknow to conclude disposal of the representation and pass the final order expeditiously, without granting unnecessary adjournments to any party, keeping in view the Supreme Court's directions reported at (2021) 4 S.C.R. 279 that a representation be decided within six months of filing, extendable only for cause recorded.

Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC-LKO:62681

Court No. - 19

Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 4349 of 2024

Petitioner :- Radhey Shyam Sharma And Another Respondent :- U.P. Real Estate Regulatory Authority Thru. Chairman Lko. And Another

Counsel for Petitioner :- Avdhesh Shukla,Prateek Tewari Counsel for Respondent :- Shobhit Mohan Shukla

Hon'ble Subhash Vidyarthi,J.

1

1. ययाचचिकयाकरयाቔኋगण कके चविदयान अधधिविकया शቦኍ ्ቚरቦኍक चरवियारቦኍ रथया चविपकቦኍ ससंख्यया उ०्ቚ० भभ-ससंपदया चविचनययामक ्ቚयाधधिकरण, लखनऊ कके चविदयान अधधिविकया शቦኍ शशोचभर मशोहन शशुक्लया ककी ररफ सके उपससथर चविदयान अधधिविकया शቦኍ अरूण कशुमयार पयाण्डकेय कशो सशुनया रथया पतयाविलቦኍ कया अविलशोकन चकयया।

ययाचचिकया मम मयासंगके गयके अनशुरशोष कके दृचቖኌगर चविपकቦኍ ससंख्यया 2 कशो नशोचटिस चनगቔኋर चकयके जयानके ककी आविश्यकरया नहीሻ हहै।

भयाररቦኍय ससंचविधियान कके अनशुच्छकेद 227 कके असंरगቔኋर ्ቚसरशुर इस ययाचचिकया दयारया ययाचचिकयाकरयाቔኋगण नके उ०्ቚ० भभ-ससंपदया चविचनययामक ्ቚयाधधिकरण, लखनऊ कके पररवियाद ससंख्यया LKO162/03/87803/2022 कके ससंबसंधि मम ्ቚसरशुर चनष्पयादन ्ቚयाथቔኋनया-पत कके शቦኍ्ቈ चनसरयारण कया चनदरश चदयके जयानके कया अनशुरशोधि चकयया हहै।

उपरशोक ्ቚयाथቔኋनया-पत ययाचचिकयाकरयाቔኋगण नके चदनयासंक 14.04.2023 कशो ्ቚसरशुर चकयया थया, धजस पर पहलቦኍ बयार सशुनवियाई चदनयासंक 06.10.2023 कशो हहई। चविपकቦኍ कके अधधिविकया दयारया अनशुपयालन आख्यया ्ቚसरशुर करनके हकेरशु समय ककी मयासंग करनके पर 6 मयाह सके अधधिक कके बयाद ककी अगलቦኍ चरधथ चदनयासंक 12.04.2024 चनयर ककी गयቦኍ थቦኍ। चदनयासंक 15.04.2024 कशो यह असंचकर कररके हहए चक चविपकቦኍ दयारया आदकेश चदनयासंक 06.10.2023 कया अनशुपयालन नहीሻ चकयया गयया हहै , अगलቦኍ चरधथ चदनयासंक 04.07.2024 ककी चनयर ककी गयቦኍ। चदनयासंक 04.07.2024 कशो भቦኍ यह असंचकर चकयया गयया चक चविपकቦኍ दयारया आदकेश चदनयासंक 06.10.2023 कया अनशुपयालन नहीሻ चकयया गयया हहै रथया चविपकቦኍ कशो असंचरम अविसर दकेरके हहए सशुनवियाई ककी चरधथ चदनयासंक 12.09.2024 चनयर ककी गयቦኍ।

ययाचचिकयाकरयाቔኋ कके चविदयान अधधिविकया नके रयहहल एस ा . शयह बनय ा म धजरक ा े न ् कश ु मयर गय ा स ं ध ा ቦ ि और ኍ अनय ् (2021) 4 S.C.R. 279 कके चनणቔኋय मम मयाननቦኍय उच्चिरम न्ययाययालय दयारया चनगቔኋर चनदरशोሸ कशो इस न्ययाययालय कके सयामनके ्ቚसरशुर चकयया गयया, धजसमम यह भቦኍ चनदरश चदयया गयया

हहै चक चनष्पयादन कयायቔኋवियाहቦኍ चनष्पयादन ्ቚयाथቔኋनया -पत ्ቚसरशुर करनके कके 6 मयाह कके असंदर चनसरयाररर ककी जयानቦኍ चियाचहए रथया यह समय मयात दकेरቦኍ कया कयारण असंचकर कररके हहए हቦኍ बढयायया जया सकरया हहै।

उपरशोक रथ्योሸ रथया चविधधि व्यविसथया कशो दृचቖኌगर रखरके हहए, यह ययाचचिकया इस चनदरश कके सयाथ चनसरयाररर ककी जयारቦኍ हहै चक उ०्ቚ० भभ-ससंपदया चविचनययामक ्ቚयाधधिकरण, लखनऊ पररवियाद ससंख्यया LKO162/03/87803/2022 मम पयाररर चनणቔኋय एविसं आदकेश कके चनष्पयादन हकेरशु ययाचचिकयाकरयाቔኋगण दयारया ्ቚसरशुर ्ቚयाथቔኋनया-पत कया चनसरयारण शቦኍ्ቈरयापभविቔኋक, चबनया चकसቦኍ पक कशो अनयाविश्यक सथगन चदयके हहए, मयाननቦኍय उच्चिरम न्ययाययालय दयारया चनगቔኋर उपरशोक चनदरशोሸ कके दृचቖኌगर करनया सशुचनसश्चिर करमगके।

[Subhash Vidyarthi,J.]

Order Date :- 11.9.2024 Ankit

Digitally signed by :- ANKIT SHARMA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench