Phool Jahan Vs Addl. Civil Judge Court No. 29… — Writ and Judicial Review | Allahabad HC (2024)

Phool Jahan Vs Addl. Civil Judge Court No. 29… — Writ and Judicial Review | Allahabad HC (2024)

What the court decided

AI extract

Outcome

Name of the Additional Civil Judge, Court No. 29, Sultanpur ordered deleted from the array of parties; petitioner permitted to move the trial court with an application for early decision of the interim temporary injunction application and speedy disposal of the suit, the trial court to pass appropriate orders expeditiously; no notice to the respondents in the memo of parties.

Issue for consideration

Whether the High Court should direct early/expeditious disposal of Original Suit No. 1344 of 2017 pending before the Additional Civil Judge, Court No. 29, Sultanpur. +2 more

Ratio / Principle

Following the Supreme Court's deprecation of the practice of impleading the court/presiding officer as a party, the name of the Additional Civil Judge, Court No. 29, Sultanpur is to be deleted from the array of parties.

Key takeaways

No notice needs to be issued to the respondents shown in the memo of parties.ratio¶10
The petition is disposed of with the direction that the petitioner shall file an application before the trial court for early decision of the interim temporary injunction application and for speedy disposal of the suit, upon which the learned trial court shall pass appropriate orders expeditiously.ratio¶13

Detailed headnote1 paragraphs

Phool Jahan v. Addl. Civil Judge, Court No. 29, Sultanpur (Matters Under Article 227 No. 4065 of 2024, High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench, Subhash Vidyarthi, J., order dated 29.8.2024; Neutral Citation 2024:AHC-LKO:58697). Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution sought early disposal of Original Suit No. 1344 of 2017 (partition and injunction, instituted 23.09.2017) pending before the Additional Civil Judge, Court No. 29, Sultanpur. Applying the Supreme Court's deprecation of the practice of impleading the court/presiding officer as a party ((1999) 2 SCC 577), the Court ordered the judge's name deleted from the array of parties and held no notice to the other respondents necessary. Noting the suit had been pending over seven years, that the written statement was filed on 09.04.2019 and issues framed on 26.10.2021, yet the temporary injunction application remained undecided (an application on the death of defendant No. 2 also pending), the petition was disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to move the trial court for early decision of the interim injunction application and speedy disposal of the suit, the trial court to pass appropriate orders expeditiously.

Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC-LKO:58697

Court No. - 19

Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 4065 of 2024

Petitioner :- Phool Jahan Respondent :- Addl. Civil Judge Court No. 29 Distt. Sultanpur And 4 Others

Counsel for Petitioner :- Ravi Shanker Singh

Hon'ble Subhash Vidyarthi,J.

ययाचचिकयाकरᮄᯚ कके चविदयान अधधिविकया शቦኍ अजय ्ቚतयाप धसिሺह कको ससुनया तथया परयाविलቦኍ कया अविलकोकन चकयया।

भयारतቦኍय सिሺचविधियान कके अनसुच्छकेद 227 कके अिሺतररत ्ቚस्तसुत इस ययाचचिकया दयारया ययाचचिकयाकरᮄᯚ नके अपर धसचविल न्ययाययाधिቦኍश, क्ቌ सिሺख्यया 29, ससुल्तयानपसुर कके सम्ቌ लिሺचबित ममूल सिሺख्यया 1344 सन 2017 कया शቦኍ्ቈ चनस्तयारण चकयके जयानके कया अनसुरकोधि चकयया हहै।

ययाचचिकया मम अपर धसचविल न्ययाययाधिቦኍश, क्ቌ सिሺख्यया 29, ससुल्तयानपसुर कको चविप्ቌቦኍ बिनयायया रयया हहै, जबिचक सयचव ा ि रቦ दक ኍ े व ि ቦ ब ኍ ि नयम धजलय ा जज, रक ा रखपस ो ु र (1999) 2 SCC 577 मम मयाननቦኍय उच्चितम न्ययाययालय नके आलकोच्य आदकेश पयाररत करनके वियालके न्ययाययालय कको प्ቌकयार बिनयानके ककी ्ቚथया कको चनरुत्सयाचहत (Deprecate) चकयया थया। अतत ययाचचिकयाकतयार कके चविदयान अधधिविकया कको चनदरचशत चकयया जयायात हहै चक अपर धसचविल जज , क्ቌ सिሺख्यया 29, ससुल्तयानपसुर कया नयाम चविप्ቌቦኍरण सके हटया दम तथया वियािሺचछत सिሺशकोधिन तसुरन्त हቦኍ समयाविकेचशत चकयया जयाय।

ययाचचिकया मम मयािሺरके रयके अनसुतकोष कके दृचቖኌरत चविप्ቌቦኍरण कको नकोचटस चनररत करनके ककी आविश्यकतया नहीሻ हहै।

उपरकोक ममूल वियाद ययाचचिकयाकरᮄᯚ तथया उसककी बिहन नमूरजहय नके दयानपर कके चनरस्तቦኍकरण ा तथया चनषकेधियाजया हकेतसु चदनयािሺक 23.09.2017 कको ्ቚस्तसुत चकयया थया। उसቦኍ चदन वियादቦኍरण कके अस्थयायቦኍ चनषकेधियाजया ्ቚयाथरनया-पर पर ्ቚचतवियादቦኍरण कको नकोचटस जयारቦኍ हहई थቦኍ। चदनयािሺक 09.04.2019 कको ्ቚचतवियादቦኍरण ककी तरफ सके विकयालतनयामया ्ቚस्तसुत हहआ तथया्ቚ चतउ्ቈर ्ቚस्तसुत हकोनके कके पश्चियात चदनयािሺक 26.10.2021 कको वियाद चबिन्दसु चविरचचित चकयके रयके चकन्तसु अस्थयायቦኍ चनषकेधियाजया ्ቚयाथरनया-पर कया चनस्तयारण अभቦኍ तक नहीሻ हहआ हहै। इस बिቦኍचि वियाचदनቦኍ सिሺख्यया 2 ककी ममृत्यसु हको रयቦኍ और उनकके उ्ቈरयाधधिकयाररयोሱ कके ्ቚचतस्थयापन कया्ቚ याथरनया भቦኍ लिሺचबित हहै।

ऊपर विचणरत पररसस्थचतयोሱ मम जबिचक वियाद लरभर 7 विषर सके लिሺचबित हहै तथया अस्थयायቦኍ

चनषकेधियाजया ्ቚयाथरनया-पर कया चनस्तयारण नहीሻ हहआ हहै, यह ययाचचिकया इस चनदरश कके सयाथ चनस्तयाररत ककी जयातቦኍ हहै चक ययाचचिकयाकरᮄᯚ चविचियारण न्ययाययालय कके सम्ቌ अिሺतररम अस्थयायቦኍ चनषकेधियाजया ्ቚयाथरनया-पर तथया वियाद कके शቦኍ्ቈ चनस्तयारण कके धलए एक ्ቚयाथरनया-पर ्ቚस्तसुत करमरके, धजस पर चविदयान चविचियारण न्ययाययालय चविधधिन स ुयार उचचित आदकेश पयाररत करकेरቦኍ।

[ Subhash Vidyarthi,J.]

Order Date :- 29.8.2024 Ankit

Digitally signed by :- ANKIT SHARMA High Court of Judicature at Allahabad, Lucknow Bench