Allowed

Mohammad Shafi Qureshi v. State of U.P.

Allahabad HC30 Oct 2023ABAIL/11186/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Application for anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC filed by Mohammad Shafi Qureshi admitted for perusal. Applicant relied on Supreme Court order (Nallan Naidu case). Court noted allegations of arbitrariness by Noida Authority and substantial denial of representation. Application allowed with specific conditions.

What did the court decide?

Application for anticipatory bail admitted. Applicant on bail subject to conditions of appearing outside jurisdiction and ensuring facts do not warrant arrest.

Mohammad Shafi Qureshi Vs State of U.P. — Anticipatory Bail | Allahabad HC (2023)

¶1

Neutral Citation No. - 2023:AHC:206613

¶2

Court No. - 71

¶3

Case :- CRIMINAL MISC ANTICIPATORY BAIL APPLICATION U/S 438 CR.P.C. No. - 11186 of 2023

¶4

Applicant :- Mohammad Shafi Qureshi Opposite Party :- State of U.P. Counsel for Applicant :- Salman Ahmad Counsel for Opposite Party :- G.A.

¶5

Hon'ble Shekhar Kumar Yadav,J.

¶6

1- आववदककवववददनअधधवकदककओरसवपपरकशपथ-पतपसत वकयदगयद, धजसवपतदवललममरखदजदए।

¶7

2- यहपककररअवगमजमदनतपदथरनदपत, आववदकककओरसववददससखयद 2591 वरर 2000, मत०अ०सस० 1068 वरर 1998, अनतगरतधदरद 409, 420, 467, 468, 471 भद०दस०सस०थदनदककतवदललउरई, धजलदजदललनममअवगम जमदनतककमदमगकरतवहहएइसयदचनदकवसदथपसत वकयदगयदहहवक वगरफतदरलककदशदममआववदकककजमदनतपरररहदवकयदजदसकव।

¶8

3- आववदककवववददनअधधवकदएवसरदजयककओरसवववददनअपरशदसककय अधधवकदककसतनदएवसपतदवललकदअवलककनवकयद।

¶9

4- ससकवपममअवभयकजनकथदनकइसपकदरसवहहवकवरर 1991-92 सव 199798 धजसममसमदजकलयदरववभदग ममछदतववधतययममअवनयवमततदएसपदईगई, ददरदअनतसपवचतजदवत, वपछडलजदवतएवसअलपससखयकजदवतकवबचचयकक छदतववधतवदयवजदनवकदपदवधदनहह।शदसनकववनदरशदनतसदरवरर 1991-92 सव छदतववधतययकदववतररववददलयसतरसवहकनवलगदऔरछदतववधतववतररहवतत ववददलयकदपधदनदचदयरएवसअनतसपवचतजदवतकववररषअधयदपककवससयतक हसतदकरयसवछदतववधतकवखदतयकदससचदलनवकयदजदतदहहऔरअनतसपवचत जदवतकदअधयदपकउपलबधनवहकनवककदशदममवपछडलजदवतकदवररष अधयदपकभलसह-खदतवददरहकसकतदहहपरनततजदसचकवदलरदनपदयदगयदवक ववददलयममवरर 1991-92 सव 1997-98 तककतलछदतववधतरपए 4,43,210/ककधनरदवशववददलयकववववभनखदतयममजमदहहई, धजसममववददलयददरद 1,63,257/- रपएकदववतररहकनदबतदयदगयदवकनततजदमचअवभलवखपसत नहहवकयवगयव।इसपकदरसवशवर 2,79,953/- रपएककधनरदवशनतकछदतककक ववतररतवकयदगयदऔरनहलउकधनरदवशकदयदरलयममवदपसजमदककगयल। जदमचकवदलरदनतथयपकदशममआएवकपधदनदचदयरऔरसह-खदतवददरददरदकतछ वयवकययकवनदमसवचवककदटकरधनरदवशकदगबनकरधलयदगयदहह।

¶10

5- आवदवककवववददनअधधवकदददरदयहतकरपसत वकयदगयदवकआववदक वनदररहह, उसवइसपकररममझपसठदफमसदयदगयदहह।यहभलतकररखदगयदवक आववदकववददलयकवपबनधसवमवतकदअधयकहहऔरउसवउकछदतववधत

¶11

ववतररकरनवकदककईअधधकदरनहहथद, यहअधधकदरपधदनदचदयरऔर अनतसपवचतजदवतकववररषअधयदपकककहलपदपथदऔरउकपशगतछदतववधत सवउसकदककईसमबनधनहहहहऔरशदसनदवशकवअनतसदरछदतववधतपधदनदचदयर वएकसह-खदतवददरकवखदतवममआतलहहनवकअधयककवखदतवमम।छदतववधतकक दवखरवखववददलयकवपबनधकददरदककजदतलहहनवकअधयकददरद।आववदककव ववददनअधधवकदकदयहभलकथनहहवकचपमवकआववदकववददलयकदअधयकहह, वहनतकलककस व कहहऔरनहललककस व कककपररभदरदककपररधधममआतद हह।इसआधदरपरधदरद 409 भद०दस०सस०कदअपरदधनहहबनतदहह।छदतववधत कदजकववतररहहवहपधदनदचदयरददरदवररषअधयदपककवमदधयमसवछदतयकक पददनवकयदजदतदहह, इसआधदरपरजकगबनकदआरकपहहवहआववदकपर नहहबनतदहह।आववदक 87 वररयववदवयवकहहऔरपहरदलदइधससबलमदरलसव गधसतहह।वहचलनववफरनवममअसमथरहह, धजसकदइलदजववददनतदअसपतदलमम चलरहदहह।आरकपपतददधखलवकयदजदचतकदहह।आववदकककआशसकदहहवक उसवउपरककववररतमदमलवममवगरफतदरवकयदजदसकतदहहजबवकउसकव ववरदककईववशसनलयसदकयनहहहह।यहभलकहदगयदवकआववदकववचदरर औरजदमचकवदलरदनसहयकगकरनवकदवचनदवतदहहवकवहजदमचएजमसलयद नयदयदलयददरदअप व कतसमयपरउससथतरहवगद।यहभलकहदगयदवकयवद आववदकककअवगमजमदनतदलजदतलहहतकवहजमदनतककसवतसततदकद दतरपयकगनहहकरवगद, जदमचममसहयकगकरवगद, नयदयदलयकव आदवशयकद अनतपदलनकरवगदतथदजमदनतककसभलशतरसकदअनतपदलनभलकरवगद।

¶12

6- इसकवववपरलतववददनअपरशदसककयअधधवकदददरदअवगमजमदनतकद पबलववरकधवकयदगयद।

¶13

7- मदननलय उचचतम नयदयदलय ददरद अगवदल पवत रदजय सतशललद ( एन०सल०टल०वदलल ) 2020 एस०सल०सल०ऑनलदइनएस०सल० 98 ममएक बदरअवगमजमदनतवमलनवकवपशदतसतपरलकरसमदपहकनवतकपभदवलरहतद हहइसधसददनतककदवषगतरखतवहहएऔरपककदरयकवववददनअधधवकदओसकव कथनय, आरकपयककपकववत, आववदकककभपवमकदऔरमदमलवकवसभलतथययएवस पररससथवतययककधयदनममरखतवहहएमदमलवकवगतर-दकरपरवबनदककईववचदर वयकवकयवअवगमजमदनतककपदथरनदसवलकदरवकयवजदनवयकगयहह। 8- तदनतसदरआववदकमक०शफककतरहशलकदअवगमजमदनतपदथरनदपतसवलकदर वकयदजदतदहह।

¶14

9- उपरककमतकदमदअपरदधससखयदममआववदकककवगरफतदरलककदशदममउसव समबसनधतनयदयदलयककससततवषपररपयदपचदसहजदरकदवयवकगतबसधपत एवसउसलधनरदवशकवदकपवतभपपसत करनवपरवनमनशतरसकवअधलनअवगम जमदनतपरररहदवकयदजदएगदग-

¶15

(I) आववदकववचदररकवदलरदनसमबसनधतनयदयदलयकवसमकउपससथतहकगद। (II) आववदकगवदहदनककवकसलभलपकदरसवपभदववतनहहकरवगद। (III) आववदकववचदररकवदलरदनसदकयसवककईछवडछदडनहहकरवगद।

¶16

10- उपरककशतरसककउलसघनककदशदममववववचनदधधकदरल/अवभयकजनपककक, आववदकककपदतअवगमजमदनतकववनरसतलकररहवततउपयतकआववदनदवनवकक सवतसततदरहवगल।

¶17

Order Date :- 30.10.2023 Rahul

¶18

Digitally signed by :- RAHUL KUMAR High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

Mohammad Shafi Qureshi v. State of U.P.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Mohammad Shafi Qureshi v. State of U.P.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Keshav Prasad Pandey Vs State of U.P.

Nitin Kumar Yadav Vs State of U.P. and Another

Akhilesh Kumar Vs State of U.P. and Another

Reena Verma Vs State of U.P. and Another

Ravi Sharma Vs State of U.P.

Nathuram Yadav and 4 Others Vs State of U.P. and Another