Allowed

P. Advaiah (Died) per LRs a- 2 to 8 v. The Public and Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housing

Telangana HC15 Sept 2023AS/1964/1999

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court of Telangana allowed an appeal filed under Section 96 of the CPC against a decree of the Additional Subordinate Judge. The court set aside the impugned judgment and ordered the refund of sale consideration and cancellation of the sale deed.

What did the court decide?

The impugned judgment and decree dated 02.09.1996 is dismissed. The learned Additional Subordinate Judge is directed to refund the sale consideration and revoke the sale deed. No order as to costs.

P. Advaiah (Died) per LRs a- 2 to 8 Vs The Public and Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housing — Telangana HC (2023) — LawSathi Research

¶1

[³²¹⁶ ]

¶2

¶3

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶4

FRIDAY. THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF SEPTEIVBER

¶5

TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE

¶6

PRESENT

¶7

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE M.LAXMAN

¶8

APPEAL SUIT NO: 1964 oF 1999

¶9

Appeat under Section 96 of CPC against the Judgment and decree dated 2.9.1996 made in O.S.No.96 of 1989 on the file of the Court of the ll Additional Subordinate Judge, Ranga Reddy District at Saroornagar.

¶10

Between:

¶11

P. Advaiah (Died) per LRs A- 3 to 8, S/o lvlallaiah Agril. Ryo Miskipet^(V), Balanagar (M), Ranga Reddy District.

¶12

2 P. Balaiah (Died) per LRs A- 9 to 15, S/o Mallaiah Agril. R/o 3-13, Ivloosapet, Balanagar (lrrl), Ranga Reddy District.

¶13

3 Smt. P.Sukkamma, Wo P. Adavaiah

¶14

4 Sri P. Krishna, S/o P. Adavaiah Smt. A. Chittari, D/o P. Adavaiah

¶15

6 Smt. T. Sakkubai, D/o P. Adavaiah

¶16

7 Sri P. Suresh, S/o P. Adavaiah

¶17

8 Smt- C. Jana Bai, D/o P. Adavaiah (Appellant Nos.3 to 8 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased Appellant No.1 vide court order dated 18/09i2003 in cMP No.19435/03)

¶18

I\4. Varamma, D/o. P. Balaiah

¶19

10 M. Pochamma, D/o. P. Balaiah

¶20

11 K. Lakshmi, D/o. P. Baldiah

¶21

12 P. Venkatesh, S/o. P. Balaiah 13 P. Mallesh, S/o. P. Balaiah

¶22

14 P. Giyanesh, S/o. P. Balaiah, aged 14 years,

¶23

15 P. Raja Lakshmi, D/o. P. Balaiah aged^'13 years Appellant - 14 and 15 are Minors rep. by their guardian P.Venkatesh Appellants I to 15 are R/o.H.No.12-7-6313, Janathanagar, Moosapet, Balanagar (M), Hyderabad.

¶24

Appellants'9 to'15 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased 2"d Appellant as per C.O. dt.6.2.13 in ASII/P-173113. .....Appellants/ LRs of 2nd Apellant

¶25

16.P.Venkatesh, S/o. Late P.Krishna, Aged about 43 years, Occ. Business, FJo. H.No.12-7-1341285, Road No.6, Street No.2, Anjaneya Nagar, Moosapet, Kukatpally, Hyderabad.

¶26

(Appellant No.16 is impleaded as per Court order dated 14lOBl2O23, vide lA No.S of 2022 in AS No.1964/1999)

¶27

...APPELLANT NO.16

¶28

AND

¶29

'l . The Public & Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housrng, Sociell Ltd., rep. by President Dr. A. Venkata Appayya S/o.Alaqpati Ramayya, RloT-1-644159, Sundernagar, Hyderabad

¶30

Sri Lal ltrlohammad (Died) per LR R-3, 4-12, S/o Shaik lt4adar Saheb R/o. H. No. 8-4-4 221 7, Er t agadd a, Hyd era bad-l 8

¶31

t/ohd. Habeeb, S/o. Late Lal [,4ohammed Rlo. 8-4-42217, Erragzrdda, Hyderabad. (R-4 to 12 are LRs)

¶32

Mrs Ayesha Begum, Wo. late Lal [,4ohammed, r/o. 8-3-167/R/6', Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶33

lvlrs. Ameena Sultana, D/o. late Lal lr,4ohammed, rlo. 12-2-38613,'4, Ali Nagar,

¶34

l Asif Nagar, Hyderabad.

¶35

Mrs. Farzana Begum, D/o.late Lal l\4ohammed, RJo. B-4-544lS/3, Sultan Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶36

Rizwana Begum, D/o.late Lala l,4ohammed, r/o. 8-3-167/R/65/8, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, hyderabad.

¶37

Mrs. Razia Banu, D/o-late Lal f/ohammed, rlo. 8-3-228167 8/147{), Sri Rama Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶38

Khaja Moinuddin, S/o.late Lal Mohammed, Fl/o. r/o. 8-3-167/R/5.1, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶39

Mrs. Zareena Begum, D/o.late Lal Mohammed, No.9-4-2913, HakeemPet, Tolichowki, Hyderabad.

¶40

11.Mohd Ahmed, s/o.late Lal l,4ohammed, Rt/o H.No.8-3-167/R/61 , Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶41

12.Mrs. Shameem Begum, D/o.late Lal Mohammed, R/o.8-3-167/R/49 & 50/503, Chistiya Estates, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad. (RR 4 to 12 are brought on record as LRs of deceased r-2 as per the Hon'ble C.O. dt 26-4-16 made in ASMP-807/16.)

¶42

...RESPONDENTS NO.4 TO 12

¶43

For the Appellants : SRI M.A.MUJEEB, Advocate

¶44

For the Respondent No.1 : SRI MOHD MAZHAR ALl, Advocate

¶45

For the Respondent No.2 : SRI MUDDU VlJAl, Advocate

¶46

For the Respohdent Nos.4 to 15 : SRI PRAVEEN KUMAR V., Advocate For the Respondent No.17 : SRI V.SRINIVASA RAO, Advocate

¶47

The Court delivered the following : JUDGMENT

I II

THE HON'BLE^{SRI JUSTICEM.LAXMAN}

¶52

APPEAL SUIT^{No. 1964 of 1999}

¶53

JUDGMENT:

¶54

1-his ,\llpcal^{Sr-rit is filed against the judgment and decree} dated 02.0(l.^{l996irr O'SNo 96 of l9B9 on the file of the learned[[} AdrlitionalsLlborcllrrittc.ltrclgc.RarrgaRcddyDistrict'r'r'hercrtlthe suir lilctl^{b,rI-cspotldt'lltNos l and 2 hercin [orsllcciftc} pcrfornrtttlct'^{s'as :rlloivcd ;\ggricrredby the same' the defendants} havc pl-cli'r|Ccl^tht l)r'cscllt^arllllcal.

¶55

[,cittrlccl cottrlscl^{lor rcspondcntNo 1 has liled a memo} stating tlrat^{l-i elrir:; no objection toallow thcappeal ald} conscqLlcrrll\tociistr-lissthesuit,sincethcrespondents/plait-rtiffs \vanL to crit^{ll-om tltc t ransactionand alsorcque stcd to rcfundthc} amount^{rvhichs as clcposited in pursuanceof the decree' whichis} lying w'ith thc^{Cor-rrt bclou' f'urther'he has also requested that} documcllts^{cxccr:tcdbY thc Court below may be cancelled'}

¶56

3 Noticc^{given,no objcction reported}

¶57

Rc<:orclil-rg^{lhc samo, this AppealSr-rit is allowcdand the} impugrrcd .jr-rdgrncnt^{and dccrec datedO2 09' 1996 in O S No 96 of} 1989 orr^{Lhc file ol' thc learncdtl Additional Subordinate'Iudge'}

\ '?.r

is ch:,tnissilil.^{[''''trti-r'-'l} '^{tltr: r']c'r tl-i b':il"'ts} fial3lr^{I?.ecid-r'District '} s?lic^{CotlSiair'i;'lt-iot'. 1r::ir'fil'' illi';ll)ilii"'\ ol-:i} dilrcLccl^{1-o rc{ilnd} ';ht: hr:r'.-it.l r/^{rlr:le ird anLs consr:ci."l(r1tt1o itlc' clrri:tti-- :Ll'lci :ri:''r-' t-il-('' l(ld to} takc stcpti^{to icvoke st.lieclccd't"-hlr-:iru ''s "rt'i:t tlt:d itri,-';tl-:-;'tatti:e} of r.lccrr:c.^{N<l costs|'illsct:litlricous PUlilir)ir:-lrclrclttlri' ifi'nr 'l;httll}

¶62

st:rnr-l^closc<l

¶63

srj/-K.SftlNlVASA^RAO JOINr^REGIflRAR //TRUE^COPYi/ U SECTION^OFFICER

¶64

To 1 The ll^{AdditionalSubordinate Judge' Ranga Reddy Districtat Slaroornagar'}

¶65

¶66

,) 4 5 6 ffiffiu*'u*r$ffitr}fri'ffi 7 Two CD^CoPies

')'

--1

HIGH COURT

DATED:1 5/09/2023

JUDGMENT

/.i:<br>t. ;- lr
l9 SEP 2M

¶75

AS.No.1964 of 1999

¶76

ALLOWING THE APPEAL WITHOUT COSTS.

¶77

[³²¹⁶ |

¶78

¶79

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶80

FRIDAY, THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF SEPTEIVBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY THREE

¶81

PRESENT

¶82

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE M.LAXMAN

¶83

APPEAL SUIT NO: 1964 OF 1999

¶84

Between:

¶85

1 P. Advaiah (Died)^per LRs A- 3 to 8, S/o Mallaiah^{Agril. R/o Miskipet(V),} Balanagar (M), Ranga Reddy District.

¶86

2 P. Balaiah (Died)^per LRs A- I to 15, S/o l/allaiah^{Agril. R/o 3-13, Moosapet,} Balanagar (M), Ranga Reddy District.

¶87

3 Smt. P.Sukkamma, W/o P. Adavaiah

¶88

4 Sri P. Krishna, S/o P. Adavaiah

¶89

5 Smt. A. Chittari, D/o P. Adavaiah

¶90

6 Smt. T. Sakkubai, D/o P. Adavaiah

¶91

7 Sri P. Suresh, S/o P. Adavaiah

¶92

8 Smt. C. Jana Bai, D/o P. Adavaiah (Appellant Nos.3 to 8 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased Appellant No.'l vide Court Order dated 18/09/2003^{in Cli4PNo.19435/03)}

¶93

L lvl. Varamma, D/o. P. Balaiah

¶94

10 M. Pochamma, Dio. P. Balaiah

¶95

11 K. Lakshmi, D/o. P. Balaiah

¶96

12 P. Venkatesh, S/o. P. Balaiah

¶97

13 P. Mlallesh, S/o. P. Balaiah

¶98

14 P. Giyanesh, S/o. P. Balaiah, aged 14^years,

¶99

15 P. Raja Lakshmi, D/o. P. Balaiah aged^{1 3 years} Appellant - 14 and 15 are lVlinors^rep. by^{their guardianP.Venkatesh} Appellants I to 15 are Fyo.H. No.12-7-6313, Janathanagar,^Moosapet, Balanagar (M), Hyderabad.

¶100

eppeiriiris'e'io iS ire brought on record as^LRs of^{the deceased2nd} Appellant as per C.O. dt.6.2.13 in ASMP-173/13. .....Appellants/ LRs of 2nd Apellant

¶101

'16. P.Venkatesh, S/o. Late P.Krishna, Aged about 43 years, Occ. Business, R/o. H.No.12-7-1341285, Road No.6, Street No.2, Anjaneya^{Nagar,Moosapet,} Kukatpally, Hyderabad. (Appellant No.16 is impleaded as per Cou( order dated 1410812023, vide lA No'5 of 2022 in AS No'1964/1999)

¶102

...A,'ELLANT No.16

¶103

AND

¶104

The Public & Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housing, Society Ltd., rep. by President Dr. A. Venkata Appayya S/o.Alaqpati Ramayya, No 7-1-644159, Sundemagar, Hyderabad

¶105

Sri Lal Mohammad^{(Died) per} LR R-3, 4-12, S/o Shaik Madar Saheb Ryo. H. No.8-4-42217, Eff agadda, Hyderabad-1 8

¶106

Ir/ohd. Habeeb, S/o. Late Lal Mohammed^{PJo. 8-4-42217,Erragadda,} Hyderabad. (R-4 to 12 are LRs)

¶107

¶108

Ivlrs Ayesha Begum, W/o. late Lal lt4ohammed, r/o. 8-3-167iR/61. Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶109

I.4rs. Ameena Sultana, D/o. late Lal Mohammed,rlo. 12-2-38613,A, Ali Nagar. Asif Nagar, Hyderabad.

¶110

Mrs. Farzana Begum, D/o.late Lal Mohammed, Rl/o. 8-4-54415/3, Sultan Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶111

Rizwana Begum, D/o.late Lala lVlohammed, rlo. 8-3-167lRl/65/8. Raleev Nagar, Yousufguda, hyderabad.

¶112

B. lvlrs. Razia Banu, D/o.late Lal lvlohammed, rlo. 8-3-22816781147 ?, Srr Rama Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶113

Khaja t\4oinuddin, S/o.late Lal Mohammed, Rl/o. r/o. 8-3-167/R/54, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶114

'l0.Mrs. Zareena Begum, D/o.late Lal Mohammed, R/o.9-4-2913, HakeemPet, Tolichowki, Hyderabad.

¶115

Mohd Ahmed, S/o.late Lal lr,4ohammed, F/o. H.No.8-3-1671R161, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad.

¶116

12 Mrs. Shameem Begum, D/o.late Lal Mohammed, Rl/o.8-3-167/Ft/49 & 50/503, Chistiya Estates, Rajeev Nagar, Yousufguda, Hyderabad. (RR 4 to 12 are brought on record as LRs of deceased r-2 as perr the Hon'ble C.O. dt 26-4-16 made in ASMP-807/16.)

¶117

...RESPONDENTS NO.4 TO 12

¶118

Appeal under Section 96 of CPC against the Judgment and decree of the Court of the ll Additional Subordinate Judge, Ranga Reddy Diskict at :laroornagar in O.S.No.96 of 1989 dated 2.9.1996.

¶119

Order. This Appeal coming on for hearing upon perusing the grounds of appeal, the Judgment and decree of the Lower Court and the material papers in the suit and upon hearing the arguments of Sri M.A.Mujeeb, Advocate for the Apoellants and of Sri Praveen Kumar V., Advocate for the Respondent Nos.4 to 15 and of Sri l/azahar Ali, Advocate for the Respondent Nos. 1 and of Sri Muddu Vijai, AcLvocate for the Respondent No.2 and of Sri V.Srinivasa Rao, Advocate for the Resporrdent No.1 7.

¶120

This Court doth Order and decree as follows

¶121

'1 . That the Appeal Suit be and hereby is allowed.

¶122

That the impugned judgment and decree dated 02109/1996 in OS No.96/1 989 on the file of the leamed ll Additional Subordinate Judge, Ranga Reddy District be and hereby is dismissed.

¶123

That the ll Additional Subordinate Judge, Ranga Reddy District be and hereby is directed to refund th€ sale consideration paid by the appr:llants herein / defendants consequent to the decree and also directed to take steps to revoke sale deed which was executed in pursuance of the decree and

¶124

There shall be no order as to costs in this Appeal Suit.

¶125

Sd/.K.SItINIVAS RAO JOINT REGI TRAR

¶126

/iTRUE COPYII

¶127

SEC-ION FFICER

¶128

¶129

'1 . The ll Additional Subordinate Judge, Ranga Reddy District at Saroornagar 2. Two CD Copies

t-6

{ i

HIGH COURT

DATED:15/09/2023

DECREE

AS.No.1964 of 1999

ALLOWING THE APPEAL WITHOUT COSTS.

P. Advaiah (Died) per LRs a- 2 to 8 v. The Public and Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housing

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

P. Advaiah (Died) per LRs a- 2 to 8 v. The Public and Private Sector Employees Co-op. Housing

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

N. Chandrasekhar Vs J. Madhukar and Anr.

Kanaka Laxmi Vs U. Yellaiah

Krishnaiah Vs Ramayya Tadiboina

G.Anand Vs The Assistant Commissioner,and 8 others

Mohammad Abdul Moheed Vs Abdul Khariq and 3 Others

Kandakurthi Gangadhar Vs S.Sajjad Pasha and Anr.