Disposed

A. Murali Mukund v. The State of Telangana and 2 others

Telangana HC3 Feb 2022WP/19598/2021

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

In these appeals against various writ petitions regarding the management of a cooperative housing society, the Court found that proceeding with the writ appeals and petitions was infructuous. The matter was disposed of accordingly without costs.

What did the court decide?

The Writ Appeals and Writ Petitions were disposed of as infructuous. All miscellaneous applications pending were closed.

A. Murali Mukund Vs The State of Telangana and 2… — Cooperative Societies | Telangana HC (2022)

¶1

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA^{AT HYDERABAD}

¶2

THURSDAY ,THE THIRD DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO

¶3

PRESENT

¶4

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE UJJAL^BHUYAN AND THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE^{P.SREE SUDHA}

¶5

WRIT APPEAL NOS: 456.457^{AND 458 OF2021} AND WRIT PETITION NOS.^{19597 AND 19598 OF2021}

¶6

WA,No. 456 of 2021:

¶7

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the Letters Patent Appeal Preferred Againstthe} Order Dated 18l}gl2o?1,^{Passedin lA.No. 1 of 2021 in W.P No 19597 of 2021on the} file of the High Court.

¶8

Between:

¶9

The Managing^{Commrttee, M/s.Jubilee.Hills Cooperative House Building Society} Ltd., Offic;aiRoad^{ruo.'ii-A,Jubilee Hills, Hvdeiabad - 500171 Repbv its Vice} President, Ms. Suneela^Reddy

¶10

...APPELLANTS

¶11

AND

¶12

1 A.Murali Mukund,^{S/o. A.Shiva Rama Krishna, Aged 62 years',OccBusiness} ;#;1.; $;;i;,v, M/s^{JubileeHills cooperativ6 Housabuilding soclelv-!!0-,} tir""iiiiitJn6,iiliJ|.L,j lnic"linoro^{t'to ti-n, Jubilee Hilrs, Hvderabad-500171} 'd[,, Pili I'i.is"i: Ro"o-r1". rz, Mithila Nagar, Banjara Hills, Hvderabad-34'

¶13

....WRIT PETITIONEFYRESPONDENT^NO.1

¶14

2 The State of Telanqana,^{Rep by rts PnncipalSecretary' Department of} Cooperation,^{Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad}

¶15

3 TheReoistrarcumcommissionerofCooperativesocieties'StateofTelangana' Ciunjxiipu^{Building. NampallyHvderabad}

¶16

.RESPONDENTS

¶17

IA NO:2^oF2021

¶18

petition under section^{151 cpc praying thatin. the,circumstances statedin} tr," "tiiol uii^rir Ld^{r n} .^{sup port ol,} i",l,l:['jlil!l*,^{?""ill r,"il ?"n'B';Xi"rU?} dispense^{with filingof the ortgtt} and Pass

¶19

IA NO 3 F 0 1

¶20

umstances^{stated in} petition under 5s61ien^{151CPC prayingthat in the circ} mav be Pleased^to 2t^{passedin I A No'} utii o"j,ii^i,r "i"ⁱⁿ " , n " u^{p po,.t} :i ; [: "ff: t:; :^;,: r' i'i.1Yl, : {ttli,,'i;'ilg"l,"""l^|1?,}"3i,0,,

¶21

Counsel^{forthe Appellant:SR|K S MURTHY}

¶22

couNSEL^FoR counser^{for the RespondentNo 1:sRr'} Rir?[iY&liiNroR

¶23

¶24

dounsel forthe Respondent^{Nos.2 & 3: ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL/} AGP FOR COOPERATION

¶25

WA NO: 457 oF 2021

¶26

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of} the^{Letters PatentAppeal Preferred Against the} order Dated. 1810812021, Passed^{in IA.No.1 0f 2021 in wP.No.19598 0f 2021 0n the} file of the High Court.

¶27

Between:

¶28

The lvlanaging Committee, M/s. Jubilee Hills Cooperative House Building Society Ltd., Office at Road No. 17-A, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad - 500171 Rep. by^{its Vice} Pres,dent, Ms. Suneela Reddy

¶29

-,.APPELLANT

¶30

AND

¶31

1- A. Murali Mukund, S/o, A. Shiva Ramakrishna, Aged about 62^years, Occ. Business and Also Secretary, M/s. Jubilee Hills Cooperative House Building Society Limited, Ryo. Plot No. 5'1, Rd. No. 12, N4ithila Nagar, Banjara Hills, Hyderabad, Telangana - 500034.

¶32

RESPONDENT NO. l^,^/RIT PETITIONER

¶33

The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Prl. Secretary, Dept. of Cooperation, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad, Telangana

¶34

The Registrar-cum-Commissioner of Cooperative Societies, St. of Telangana, Gruhakalpa Building, Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana

¶35

B. Ravindranath, S/o. B. Rajgopal Naidu, Aged about 46 years,^president, M/s. Jubilee Hills Cooperative House Building Society Ltd., Ryo. H.No. B-2-293t921A, Flat No. 1343, Road No.67, Jubilee Hi ;, Hydeiabad - 500 033

¶36

...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶37

lA NO: 3 OF 2021

¶38

Petition under Sectjon 151..CpC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fired rn support of the petition, tne il ig"n coua mJy-oe pr"aseo to suspend the ;,,8",1"""1JHJT.!B!,1,"o'"^{..rlose oateo ttioatiiz\ o,l."o ," r A No1} "irori i;

¶39

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. K S MURTHY

¶40

Counset for the Respondent No. 1:SRt. O. SR|N|VAS SENTOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. ROHIT POGULA

¶41

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2 & 3: AODL. ADVOCATE GENERAU AGP FOR COOPERATION

¶42

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: NONE AppEARED

¶43

NO 458 0F

¶44

Writ Appeal under claus ,e-1S^^{of the Letterspatentappeal preferred} against the ;i',r":i.1"^Jfi:8-2021^{passedinlA.No2"ri6z,i"rip,i5'inrnuor2021} onrherrre

¶45

Between:

¶46

itl,}ffiiH'i",x{l[i1?{1i",#iJL"i,?ll."is:t""#x":#sy??R:,il[?if i,i..J

...APPELLANT

)

ANO

1 A. Irrlurali Mukund,^{S/o.A. Shiva Ramakrishna, Aged about62, years.b99} aGi,;;;; ;;d iiiil^{sJcreta.y,M/s.Jubilee Hills.cboperative House Building} S"iiliiv LiriGo,^{rvo- Ftot No 5'1,Rd. No. 12, llithila Nagar' Baniara Hirls'} Hyderibad,^{Telangana - 500034.}

¶51

,.RESPONDENT NO, l/vVRIT^PETITIONER

¶52

2 The State of Telanqana,^{Repby its Prl.Secretary, Depto{ Cooperation'} Secretariat^{Buildrngs,SaifabadHyderabad,Telangana}

¶53

3 TheReolStrar.cUm-CommrssionerofCooperativeSocieties.St.ofTelangana' CirnriStpu^{Building, Nampally'Hyderabad,Telangana}

¶54

4 B. Ravindranath,^{S/o.B. RajgopalNaidu,Aged about 46 years' President'M/s} iruiri" i'ilir^{cJ"purat,veH6-usb guito'g sdc'etv Ltd} '^{Fv6 HNo S-2'29318214'} Eii'r..t" iiis.-R,;rt^ruo. oz^{Jrlrit"" Hill; Hvderabad - 500 033}

¶55

...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶56

IAN O: 2^{OF ?021}

¶57

Petition^{underSection 151 CPC prayrng that in the clrcumstances statedin the} affidavit filed^{in support ot tne petition, tne irsn Court may be pleasedto.9ispel:e} with filing of^{the original oro""dut"o'tatoatioztin l A No 2 of 2021 in w'P No'} 19598 of^2021.

¶58

IA NO:³ 0F²⁰²¹

¶59

Petition under^{Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin the} affidavit^{filed in support ot tn" p"tiilonline iiigi court may be,oleased to suspend the} orders of^{the learned si,gr" L"i';;i!tHi';id87'?o'zi;;'t""0'intR uo 2 ot 2021in} WP No.^{19598 of 2021.}

¶60

Counsel^{for the Appellant:SRl' K S MURTHY}

¶61

Counsel for^{the Respondent No' 1:SRl' D' SRINIVAS.SENIOR COUNSELFOR} SRI. ROHIT^POGULA

¶62

Counsel^{for the Respondent Nos'2 & 3: ADDL' ADVOCATEGENERAU} AGP FOR^COOPERATION

¶63

Counsel^{for the RespondentNo 4: NONEAPPEARED}

¶64

N :1 s97 0F 021

¶65

BeWeen:

¶66

l.y{iJtti;[i*i"t"nlo,'?Ill3i1pjllfl'ft^{1AE]'{'"'5ipli'}i;3}} li,it"ilh.i,oNeti;l^Jjl,l"""^l:lf |-llf ",fi :3g;x:.Jobo.o Road^{No'12' NilithrlaNagar'Dd.larqr """' r}

...PET|T|ONER

AND

padment^of

1 ::fJijij]tJ?H,??eiE:i'P^"S:SjlL?:3''-"':'::3#'* ,^{Stateof Telangana'} 2 :li;tUu,''n3",uffi^{:i;"'ry'i::333:i5:f'""''l3l}

¶71

...RESPONDENTS

¶72

.PetitionunderArticle226oftheConstitutionoflndiaprayingthatinthe circumstances stated^{in the affidavitfiled therewith.the Highcourtmay be pleasedto-} irar" rn appropriate^{Writ,order or direction, more particularly one in thenature of} Writ of Mandamus:

¶73

to^grant an order, direction^{or wril moreso in the nature of Writ of Mandamus:}

¶74

(a)Directing the 2nd Respondent to^{appoint a specialofficer to manage,control and} iupervise i-he affairs of^{the Jubilee Hills Co-operative House BuildingSociety Limited,} Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad.

¶75

(b)Directing the 2nd Respondent to inquire into the^{matter regarding appointingMr.} Jetti Kusum Kumar as the^{'HonoraryChairman'aslhe same being contraryto the} Bye-laws of the Society^{and consequently take necessary action againstthis act}

¶76

(c)Directing the 2nd Respondent to ensure that there^{is no third party interference with} regards the affairs of the management^{committee and the society}

¶77

lA NO: 1 OF 2021

¶78

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumstances^{stated in the} affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be^pleased to direct the 2nd Respondent to appoint a Special Officer to^{manage, controland supervise the} affairs of the Jubilee Hills Co-operative House^{BuildingSocietyLimited,Jubilee Hills,} Hyderabad^pending disposal of writ^petition, in the interest of^justice

¶79

lA NO: 2 OF 2021

¶80

Between:

¶81

N//s. Jubliee Hills Cooperative House building Society Ltd, Having its Registered office at Road No. 17-A, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad- 500171 Being Represented by its Authorised Signatory, Vice President, N4s. Suneela Reddy.

¶82

...PETITIONER/PROPOSED RESPONDENT NO. 3

¶83

AND

¶84

A. Mu.rali M,ukund, Son of A. Shiva Ramakrishna, Age. 62 years, Occ.. Business and Also Secretary, The Jubilee Hills Co-operative Holse Buildino Societv Ltmired, Road No.17-A, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad-S0o171 , Resident of plot No.51', Road No.'12, Mithita Nagar, Banjara Hitis, Hyderabad-S00034.

¶85

....WRIT PETITIONEFYRESPONDENT NO. 1

¶86

The State of T_elangana.. Rep. by its principal Secretary. Department of

¶87

Cooperation, Secre-tariat Buitoin'sJ, sdiiriiSi, fii"',"Jri,";

¶88

The Reoistrar cum Commissioner of Cooperative Societies, State of Telangana, Gruhakatpa Building. Nampirt. iy;";;d.;' -' """*.,

¶89

,..RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENT NO. 2 & 3

¶90

Petition under section 15i cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit fited in support of the petition, ir,e H,s1 C;r;;;;;; pteased ro implead the 2021, Miscellaneous Petitioner as Respondent petilions.No.i in the "nor""wri p"riii"i i"i"g w.p. No. 19597 of

¶91

Counsel for the petitioner: SRt. D. SR|N|VAS SENTOR COUNSEL FOR

¶92

SRI. ROHIT POGULA

¶93

Counsel for the Respondents: Gp FOR COOpERATION

¶94

counsel for the proposed Respondent: sRl. p. RAJA SRI.ATHt RAO

WP NO: 19598 OF 2021

Between:

A. l,4urali l\4ukund,^{Sonof A.Shiva Ramakrishna,Age62 years, Occ Business} ;;i;[; S;;;"kry, Tne^{JuoileeHilrs co-operative-.H9us9,Build-ingSocietv} lirit"J, noia^{ruo.17]n,Luoitee Hills, Hyderabad-soo17-1-,} -Resident^{of Plot No51,} Road No.12. Mrthila^{Nagar. BanJaraHills, Hyderabad-500034}

¶99

...PETITIONER

¶100

AND

¶101

The State of Telangana,^{Repbyits Principal} 99cleta.ry,^{Department of}

¶102

Cooperation,^{Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad}

¶103

2 TheReqistrarCUmCommiSsionero{Cooperativesocieties,StateofTelangana, d'rrn"iifpu^{Building. Nampally. Hyderabad, Telangana}

¶104

3 B.Ravindranath,^{The President' The Jubilee Hills Co-opergliYetlouseBuilding} 3.;;,"tyi];i6i]^{noairuorz-n'JubireeHills, Hvderabad-soo171'}

¶105

RESPONOENTS

¶106

Petition under^{Article226 of the Constitutionof lndia prayingthat in the} circrm.tanle.^{statedin tne ariolvitllteotherewith,the High Court may be pleasedto} issue an^{appropriate wr.it, oroJlot Jn""iion'moiepartiJularlv one in the nature of} Writ of Mandamus^setting '"i0"^{ti"'i'p"'S-;eOt-etterlruotice lrio'JHCHBSL/1 14/2021} dated 12.08.2021^{issued by th"" i;R;;;;"Jent revoking.thepowerand authoritvof} the^{petitioner who is the s""r"iriyot t-r,u society in the i;terestof justice. pleasedto} pa ss

¶107

IAN O:1 oFz^2',|

¶108

the^aFf PetitionUnderSectionl5,lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin^{idavitf itedin support or ir," -pui,t,oi.tne"Hign Court.maybe pleasedto direct} the 2nd^{Respondentto restrarntiu-gtJn"tponoentand other Managing Committee} Members^{frominterferingwitn tne-} 'igf'tt^{oi tn" Petitionersas the Secrelaryof the} Society^{in dischargingnis Out'esl rotZ"'-and responsibitities provided in theSociety} Bve_laws inctuding^{rhe access i"" r;;;fGe- [ilan'agingcommitteeMeetings, pending} ii'.p"""iof^{the wrii petitron,in the rnterest of iustice'}

¶109

IA NO: 2^{oF 2021}

¶110

Petition^{undersection151 cPC praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit^{filed in supportor tn"e p-eiit'on'"tne Hign Court may be pleased to suspend} the lmpugned^{Notice/Letter rtr" iriCi'aU1i 4t2621 dared 12 08'2021 issued by the} 3rd Respondent^{revokingth" p";;;';;;;'tn"atv} "t the Petitioner'^{pending disposal} of writ^{petition,in the interestof justice'}

¶111

IA NO:³ oF²⁰²¹

¶112

Between:

¶113

B Co-ooeratrve Ravindranath,^{House s/o Buildlng. B Rajsopar 5o} ),?th[:ed: *tJ]J1le 'J-Blt3.TJi?A,^{Frat No} i5+!f "i J, o N -o-7^{J u bI I e eHrII sH virerab a d- 5 0 0 0 3 3'} "

¶114

...PETITIONER/RESPONDENT^NO'3

¶115

(

¶116

AND

¶117

A. MUrali Mukund, Son of A.Shiva^{Ramakrishna,Age. 62 years,Occ. Business} and Also Secretary, The Jubitee Hills^{Co-operativeHouse BuildingSociety} Limited, Road No.17-A, Jubilee Hills,^{Hyderabad-Soo171} ,^{ResidentofPlot No.s1,} Road No.12, Mithila Nagar, Banjara Hills,^{Hyderabad-500034.}

¶118

,,..RESPONDENT/PETITIONER

¶119

The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Department of Cooperation, Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad, Hyderabad.

¶120

The Registrar cum Commissioner of Cooperative Societies, State of Telangana, Gruhakalpa Building. Nampally, Hyderabad, Telangana.

¶121

,..RESPONDENTS

¶122

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the interim orders dated 1810812021 in lA No. 1 of 2021 and tA No. 2 of 2021 in WP No. 19598 of 2021.

¶123

lA NO: 4 OF 2021

¶124

Between:

¶125

M/s. Jubliee Hills Cooperative House building Society Ltd, Having its Registered office at Road No. 17-A, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad- 500171 Being Represented by^jts Authorised Signatory, Vice President, Ms. Suneela Reddy.

¶126

...PETITION E R/PROPOSED RESPONDENT NO. 4

¶127

AND

¶128

A. Mu.rali Mukund, Son of A. Shiva Ramakrishna, Age. 62 years, Occ.. Business and Also Secretary, The Jubilee Hills Co-operative Hoilse Buildinq Societv Limited, Road No.17-A, Jubilee Hills, Hyderabad-s0o17i , Resident of^pTot No.51'. Road No.12, Mithila Nagar, Banjara Hitls, Hyderabad-500034.

¶129

.,..WRIT PETITIONEFYRESPONDENT NO. 1

¶130

The State of T_elangana, Rep. by its^principal Secretary, Department of

¶131

Cooperation, Secretariat Bulldin'gs, Saifabad, Hyderabad.

¶132

The. Registrar cum Commissioner of Cooperative Societies, State of Telangana, Gruhakatpa Building, Nampally, Hyderabbd, Tetangana.

¶133

B.Ravindranath, The^president, The Jubilee Hills Co-operahve House Burldino Society Limited, Road No 17-A, Jubitee nirrs, irvOJraO5J_SOOiZ i .^{'*-- '" ,}

¶134

... RESPONDE NTS/RESPONDENT NO.2 & 3

¶135

Petition under Rule 16-4 of CpC praying that in the crrcumstances stated rn the affldavit filed in support of the petition, th" ff ,gn Court ."y be pteased to implead the-Petilioner as Respondent No.4 in the above .drit petition being W.p. No. 19598 of 2021, Miscellaneous^petitions,

¶136

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRt. D. SRIN|VAS SENTOR COUNSEL FOR SRI. ROHIT POGULA

¶137

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2: cp FOR COOPERATION

¶138

Counsel forthe Respondent No. 3: SRl. M. PRATHEEK REDDY

¶139

Counsel for the proposed Respondent: SRl. p. RAJA SRIPATHI RAO

¶140

The Court made the following:

¶141

THE IION'BLE SRI JUSTICE U.,JAL BHUYAN

¶142

AND

¶143

THE HON'BLE SM?. JUSTICE P. SREE SUD HA

¶144

w RiT AP PEAL NO S,4 56 45 7A ND 4 80F2 0 1

¶145

AND

¶146

j I I

¶147

WRITP trTtTION NO s. 19 s97 AND] 59 F 0 i COMMON JUDGMEN?:

¶148

(Per the Hon,ble Sri Jusrice Ujjal Bhuyan) Heard Mr. D. S rlnrvas, learned Senior Counsel for the petttioners in W.p.Nos 19597 and 19598 of 2021 and for the responden ts in W.A.Nos 456, 4SZ and 4S8 of 2021

¶149

We have also hea rd Mr. E. Venkata Siddartha, learned counsel for the appellants in W.A.Nos.456, 457 and 45a of 2021 and for the respondents in W.p.Nos.19597 and l9S9g of2021.

¶150

Learned counsei lor the parties submit that the Writ Appeals and the Writ petitions have become infructuous.

¶151

That being tlt. posirion, thc Writ Appeals and the Writ Petitions are clisposerl o1.as inlructuous.

¶152

There shall bc no order .ts lo costs.

¶153

Miscellancous applicatlons, if ar.ry, pendir.rg, shall stand c lo se,l .

".JLX'.j+}TE8'I?{TR

I i I

To,

,\t /

//TRUE^COPY//

SECTION^OFFICER

The^{Principal Secretary' Department of Cooperation'State of Telangana'} i".*iriLi^{e'ildinss'sarrabad'HI?"J33i3,.r,r"} societies,^{state or}

¶162

, The Reqistrar^cumcommlssl ' +.L;;;;: t;akalpa^{Buildins' Nampallv'Nvderabad'}

¶163

3 ;;;';;'i;^{sri x s r",r''tnvAdvocate IoPUCI}

¶164

i[l:!!Ii,#,;i*t'i,i#i"ffi i. fwo^{ccs to GP for CoopertrtFJ:,i,i","h,e.rreansana} Jourl ^^--:ral, High^{courtfor theStateof relangana loUTl}

¶165

lwo^{CCsto Advocate Gen€}

9.^{1r,'loCD Cop\es}

PM sv{

HIGH^COURT

DATED:03102/2022

COMMON^JUDGMENT @

ffiNos.^{1e597 & 1e598 of 2021}

¶172

'( i{"- S IA r€:
(
3 23 FIB 2t??
,. ',-.,''. ^,,:-.?

¶173

Disposing^{of the Was & WPs} Without^costs.

A. Murali Mukund v. The State of Telangana and 2 others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

A. Murali Mukund v. The State of Telangana and 2 others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Maraboina Ajay Kumar Vs Union Bank of India

M/s a. Krishna yadav Khowa Merchant and 2 Others Vs M/s Shriram City Union Finance Limited

M/s N Shine Industries Vs Bank of Baroda

Momin Mahaboob Liaquath Ali Vs Karnataka Bank Ltd. and 5 Others

A. Murali Mukund Vs The State of Telangana

The Managing Committee Vs a. Murali Mukund and 3 Others