Dismissed

Dr. Vikram Reddy Masani, Nizamabad Dist and 31 Others v. Prl Secy, Health, Medical and Family Welfare Dept, Hyd and 63 Ot

Telangana HC10 Oct 2022WA/723/2014

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court dismissed the writ appeal as infructuous because the learned counsel informed the Court that the cause ventilated in the writ appeal no longer survives for adjudication.

What the court decided

AI extract

Dr. Vikram Reddy Masani, Nizamabad Dist and 31 Others Vs Prl Secy, Health, Medical and Family Welfare Dept, Hyd and 63 Ot — Telangana HC (2022) — LawSathi Research

¶1

HIGH COURT rcR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYOERABOO[.,N'I

¶2

a,/ ?

¶3

MONDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY TWO

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE UJJAL BHUYAN AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE C.V. BHASKAR REDDY

¶6

WRITAPPE AL NO:.723 OF 2014

¶7

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters patent preferred against the order

¶8

r
n

¶9

dt.25.04.2014 in W.p.No.1082B of 2O14 on the file of the High Cou(.
I. Dr.Vikiam Reddy Masani, S/o.santosh Reddv- ..l
Aged,,2( gcary HNo;456, .LD:Baoswedai yifl'agg,,, :,
Bhnsue(a.MaadaL iNizamabad,Ej&niai,. sOj GZi.il,.,,
2. Dr Leelaprasad Betha, S/o.Satyanarayan a
AgddizSrilcars;.Dqor No: 6,125, V,.irnyak Ndfiar,r r, , .i,: | . . -
Elti44,Wesr/Godavari Districr_532100 i' . -::." ' r
3. Dr.ChEugfuira&etldy, D/o Ch., Mshder Reddv
Aged'atorr25:yearsi H.No. 3 _9:2 [0"R6edi1,1o.;: '
Cenkat Bank Colorry,L.B Xue.., Flyde.i.iad.j0bOi+
4 DrS.Tejaswi, D/o.B;Rami Reddy,,Age{ 24 years,
H. No..l-2-l I2ll , Degree College Ro"ad',
Shanthin agar, Adilabad - 504001
5i,

¶10

1,;r; i,
6
t3/7
L.B
7 .
Dr.MCr{othica, D/o:M.Vykr,rntapathi.
Aget 26 yea$, H.No:4-3-2 i 3/A,
Dwaraka.ilagar Street No.4, Adilabad.,50400 I
8 Dr.Goutam.K, S/o KCopalaRao, Aged 26 years,
H.NO.9-2-t00, Old club police euaiers,
Near Vinodha Mahal, Khammam
9 !r {. firan Raju. S/o A.p.Ramaraju,
Kakinada, Aged abom East 27 Godavari years, D.No2_60A_g",Venkat Nagar,Olstrict _S::OOj. - '
l0 Dr.T.Sravanthi, D/o T.Sudhakar, Aged about 26 yeats,
Flat 201, Shiva Ganga Apartments, Opp.Viayr*, fo*Lr=.
L,eela Nagar, Begumpet. Hyderabad. ' '

t U, a

a t t I I LIIIr

i i I

	4	.,;w
11.	Dr.V.Siddkaith,,S/o:V-li{tnkateshvarRao,i : Agedraboutf25iyedrs,T'lgu.T2,'Lrguwa'^Apartments, Pa&iiarao Nagar,Secun&abad. J	t
12,	,. BrV,HvanJliuda,.$ged^{about'25years;.,}'i . H.No.6-I8-S,7-286,^VaradaRajaNagar,Tirupathi	I
13.	Er.Jk$'ltldlhi;D/o^{iK,Naraydra,iAge26 years,} tr{il*te{E=29i,NailalBe[y(t!6);^Warangal.
14.	flr.SrDi.1',yaYarrlhi;^Agedabout29^years, Nddr*rltrrialitHifih,Sdrdol.Beside Petorlbunk, Medak
l5	Dr.TV.IGishnaNarayan,Age 24^years,H.No:16-9-820, Shiiaa{E*aicCare.RaceCourse Road,OtdMalahet, I{ydtirdid:5O0O36
16. r'lii	Er..P:Ravikiran, Age^{25 years,H.no 6-3-55, Flatno401,} SEi:I.&irshaApartment,Bar*Coiony, Khamrnam
'',,..\7. .,1	: DriSDqrgaPrasad, S/o S.NarsimhaItao S9tana,tcE&,ao:Nqg4r,
18.	t dliout25 years, -Gimaai
19.	Dr.D.Rririkumar,Age26 years,H.No2-ld-I, Opp.trVDofficeGudhurpost,Prakasham-523281^:
20.	Dr:S:[ifrad'PlakaC1,S/o.S.KrishnaMohanRao, t{gpC$btu30yeats; SKM'Street, Door.No. 1,78/V, Gopatlrliurarr, Krishna.
21	.Dr,Vi$aSagarMadhavaranr.S/o M.Balasundaram Age&about30 years, D.No.45124K-25-l, Srirl(ri'slma colony,AshokNagarKumool-518005
22	.Dr.B:VeinkatKiranReddy, Agedabout ?7years. D.No.1l-31-368,PullaReddyNagar, Kavali,Nellore
-zs	Dr.K.Teja, S/o.Dr.K.SivaDurgaPrasad, Agedabout 26 years,VaralakshmiMemorialEyeHospital, Pothuraju gandi,Addanki,Prakasham-52320 I
24	.Dr.Ch.Sowjanya. D/o Late Ch.Maheshwarrao Agedabout 25ycars.D.No36-97-l05lA, Kapparada 2,Kanchara Pallem, Vishakapahram

¶15

¶16

25	. Dr.R.Nithin'I(urnar-Reddy, Age:24years,H.No:l-4-l54, New:town;, Rajendra Nagar, Mahaboob nagar
26	Dr.VarunAkinapally,Age24years,FIat no.304, Sudhashini.Residency,Naimnagar, Hanrnakbnda,Warangal. t
21.	Dr.D.Sowmya,Aged about:25years PIot.no-439,H.No.05-05-I99,prasanth Nagar, Vanasthalhiuram,,Hyderzibad.
28 '' D	.DrM;trljuaala,Ageitatiopt25 years, IiIiNe16r5.79.5/A,A$bdkBazar, Gurunand<MargAfzulgunj,Flyderabad ..tr. '. :lr''-ⁱt. , -i r Erre$dfrq{hji,Sy'orRrMarutlii Rao, Agedi{irfit26years,H.No.3-7-69I/t, \raVil:ild&ytKarimnagar
30.	Ei.B-Aqiiueyult,Aged,42 years,ESIDiagnosticGenke, DSPBungalowLane,Adoni, Kumool.
3I-	BRbtldy,.Prasad.D,.Agd, 37years,Zl4U2, $-l^{CiSiIGhurch,Jr.Iagaehjupeta,,R,SRoad,,,} Kadagg:4FQOI. :::i .:
32'.	ry,B4BP"I4lttl${,otrar,i,n^{o;,gaaahutA}Veurs;l} Maru'tii&gar;.Narzisahirdrptita,Srikakulhm_53242L
I	TheSrdto6f^.Andkapradesh, Rep.by its PrincipalSecretary, HealthN,ftadical&FamilyWelfare(E2)Depanment, Secretarid., Hyderabad ArP.ll",cl ...Petitioners/,{rop&s-r tir.r/.r-,o.loyzzf/g AND
2	The,State,of Andhra^pradesh, Rep. byitsPrincipalSecretary, Horne,Depatment,Secretariat, Hydcrabad
3	TheMedical,Council of lndia,pocketNo.14, Sector-S;Dwaraka^phase-I,NewD;lhi_ll0,W7, Rep:.,byits Secretary

¶17

4 Dr. NIR University of Health Sciences, Gunadala, Vijayawada, Krishna Dstrict, Rep. by its Registrar

¶18

5 Additional Director General of police, C-rime I nvestigation Department (CI D). 3'o Floor, DGP Office, Lakdikapul, Flyderabad

¶19

1^les7--lent=f Rc?>"rdr,.fs^, "r tup lotztflg

¶20

¶21

It I

¶22

,6	6 Dr.B,Vijaykirrritr,SIOrB:RaiiiBabu. Aged,4btirJt-27,vyearsit{rNor_..16_}_g95lt, Bhau&iRefiielicy,IFortRoar4:Wat:rngaj
7
	i'.t:.fi-Ii. IiJi. ''t:
9.	Jagairnaickpur,Kakin I.r, tl;rj ;Slt8/ol8rEst{aru Rao,;69"2:byears, ada !)rl;.Sr.ir i1r-itr
i0.	E$d-SHA&fl4:trb.V.tJagadeswaraRao, '{${pb6^ui(6y6ars.^{Ht No.}56_6-611.^p IorNo.3t, IkJugtijcglony,^{Near HighSchool Road.patamar,} ryd:i$,fdddt .::;l'nl'
1i.	.,,,. @huvaran, SroD.Singaraiah,Aged2iyears, $.Y.,8:&.81-9een^{parkCilo,y.xor:manci;;"'} va6iirnegB[r,Ffydtii{Xtl:..:..r
12	_l{ged:24^years,H.No Sdtfurdt*Jyderaba8 Dr.A t6-2t1E,
13.	;-DloA.SityaNarayana Reddy, years;DoorNo4l-l/4_3 7 jr';i.1rB4i d{,i.6i1alKnishna.Lank4 .#ijayhivada .520013
14, :i.	S/s Ram reddy, Ageda!,qrt25 years, Pur,^Kariinnagar-S05504
.15. -:'^j	eep, S/o,R.uvi pradeep years,H.No.l5-12-6g l*tga-,;@d666-522691
16.	Dr,TRffilieiRdinyd,,.D/o,T.Raana,Raj,rI.,. Agedabout26 years,Flatno.l5l,S.inir^"pr-,Colony, NGOs,oolbhy,,Vanasrhalipmam, Hyderabad.
17.	!1!hls1tosn,^{Agedabour 25 years,} H.No.6-373, C/o.R.S.ClothStores,MarketRoad, Manchiryala, Adilabad
l8	Dr.S.Prashanth, S/o S.prabakar,Agedabout26 years, D.No:102, SaiSnehaResidency,BinkColonyi Ameerpur,Patancheru, Medak -502032

I I

t: : i t

i. I i

19.	Dr.Ktsrik+he;Pfl-ya,rDloJ(iBhaathsr,varoo'pc-i. Aged,AErii.flr24ifebrsir[Ior.nctia0T;J(ausaulyacTowers, rcaraaa'ntea4tE€tr iElyderabad-5o0062,: ,:. . i.-.ri-,,!ii^.C,ti:'
20	Dr.SrihariSiddhartha.P, S/o P.Vasu, Aged abour23 years, Sri*I&fu@pt$!ds;BRTRoadl.rtlijayawada..
21.	Eritfii;i.A$hilayaDasi, S/oRajaMohanRao, Agedabout26years, D.No.I l/89-I6, I,1^{q:v0ar'4i6tditada}Krishna.
22	Dr.M.Geethika,Agedabout25ycars, Hnln,6-€5il+lotnol0i,VijayaShanryHornes, BleivaaiUHgfrr;lDilShuknagar,,Hyderabad i,.,..l'i:,;.,:,rr,i:.
23	Dr,N;srivapi-, D/o.Brahnraiah, Iteed&}s-iip+)€ar$,rH;No:I-2-53i5, Fdfrp*lifKnrihnagar-505I72.
	Dr.N.Triveni,D/o.Shrinivasareddy, fued^{a!bdt25years, Kondapalkala,} Ii{r*oodrsa)Karlmnagar-505I72.
z5-	coionyi.GociErtliribad-50006I Ageil94tyaars,
ffi-	S{e€riudd{n Atnrtsdi; ,111,,4.336Chilkalguda, ';..1
2?.	Dr:B&ed*ldS/rlErchinfta; Aged25years,323,I7BF, Sin@ffidrffiny;@hampaper.IHyderaba&50o059 ',.i,t,:.,,.,r'..
28.	Dr.B;Ra:rindar,S/o.RatanSingh, .Agi*CilbOrat28 years, GurrampetaMandal, \renka{apri4Warangal-506I68
29.	Dr.BJRamjiBabu, S/oprasadRao, fued^{abott24years,}H.Nol-80/1, NearAPSRTC Rajole,EastCodavari-533242
30.	Dr.NiloferSeema,D/oMd.Ghouse.pasha, .Agedabout 24years,FIat.No:I,AnilaApartments, Dr.Krishna CollegeRoad,Maddi Iapalem,Vishakaparnam.
31. .	Dr.NehaKumari, D/oAwadeshKumarSingh Aged about 23 years,H.nol-104/ll.plotno2l AravindNagarColony,Naagaram,ECIL,Hyderabad-5000g3
32.	Dr.B.Srihari,9oLachaiah, Aged about 25yearg Beebigudemvillage,ChiwemlaMandal,Nalgonda_50g2I3

¶28

l t E T I ;, :' I I I I I I't '). I

¶29

i I

¶30

a 33 I-l\4.^{Vinay"S/o:M.vasudev,Agdd}about24 years, DN.o-t.2/t01587/42,Ftatno302,I<PR..iJ#;,'"' MedibavirSeethaphalmandi,Secunderabad, I-IydbraQad-50006 t
34. Dr.RrSitrdeepRdtnanqhari,, Aged >aboul2 7yea55, I'.iffiftilffi^{NuiE'"n u'c"r i,i"'}
35.Dr.S-SipirnrhMadtry,ifued*ert24 years, x'8rrY/Iifh&,cri,i.rasi,,nn'rl"-d;lub".d,
36 Dr.K.Yashwantb, Agedaboui24years, H,ISo:tritlgo7ffdilqq.E l€.Crdi, LRrd$t*-ifiydeitbad; t.:t t:
31 ". ..,., ,.., , .?:l{qt^{Ahmad Abbasi,Aged aboru}26years, HNdiISTali8;rMouldiStreer, Waranagal
-r6_ Dr.A.As$aladra Naik, Agedabour 25 years, HrNdn-4A39/G/t0l,La'i6hrninesiaan.y,' Balesdd{ldram,Hanumakonda, Wuruogai.'
39. P.P:.h:l^{Kumar.Banoth, Agedabout}28 years, Rathnhgiri,,Eheendcurzapily.Ktryrreu.3-dsaSZ
40 ?:.f$lllo*,r,^{Er'o.,A.Bheskar Rao,} :g:o3tut^{26years,H.no_7-1-4t/3,} Jakkatdriistreet,,Chirala,pnakasam.I
4l P1
42 fr,f.ftvasankirrh,^{Agedabout2gyears,} H.No:451@4K,25_IAsIokNagar,Kumool.
43. 19,",91byo2s^{years,HNo:3_4_s37,} ruonaNagar, Hanumakonda,Warangal_50600l.
Dr.Sunil; Kumar.Badawath, S/o.B.Balaji,Age:25, PoosalThanda,Arjerla,Marripea",Wr'r-eiiioilrs 44
45 Dr.T.Yeswandr,S/o. Saidulu,Aged 25years, 3.":l-1y.:r:_1,^{vijayanagarCotony,} rypassRoad,Khammam_507002.
DrS.Srikanth, Agedabout 36 years, PHC.Perur, Khammam 46

¶31

47	9 Dr.K.IilakKomar, Agedabout30.years, C/o.B'SudhaksqBahLFtat.nbi2a,rKaveriEstates, Near Bezawada Gopal ReddyStaure, ,^{Mirii,bYpass,Roail,}Nellorb, I
4&.	ttesrir RimrGai*thi,Agedabout35 years, Flatno-lIl,SivaSaiResidency, :j'.; ,
49.	, Dr,A.MeqldtarRedily,Aged,about38 years, Plot nol8;19;Kalavancha,ShanthiNagarColony, FlalathrnAgar.50l505
50 .,.	.Er,AStidlrar,Birbu,Aged&our37,1oars;,: H:No.87-14O2-5, Danalakshmi nagar, :@p..Centiil6ehool, Kumool.
5t.	Dr.G.GracpEsther,Agcdabout29yrears, lnCross, Chzrndramouli Nagar,Nellore.
52	.Dr.G.Radhika,Aged about27years, I{-.No-LIG10,APHBColony, ALrbasNagarKumool-2
53:	.Dr.A.Sindhbora, Agedabout.30yoars, H.lrLo;206; Brizvasi.Apartmeirts,NearNlndiniCircle, K.T.Rbad,firupati,Chiuoor District.
54.	Dr.Srihari.K,S/o.K.Laxmaiah,A[e28years, Arutla(v),Sangareddy(m), Medak-502296
55.	Dr.M.PerxaGpud, Agedabout 30 years, H.No.I{-547i I,J.N.Road, Medak:502Ii'0.
56.	Dr.Karunakar.G,S/o RarnaSwamy,Aged3Iyears, 'H.No.7:. I36,Rayaparthi,Warargal
57.	Dr.S.Kavitha,Aged)2years,H.No.26-2-t487, Venkatareddy Nagar, Vedayapalem,Neliore.
58.	Dr.M.Pravecn,Aged 34years,H.No.26-2-I487, Venkatareddy nagar,Vedayapa lem,Nellore
59.	Dr.G.Uma, Agedabout33 years,LIC-225, BharathiNagar, Ramachandrapuram, Hydcrabad.
60.	Dr.AnilKumarReddy,Agedabout3Iycars, H,No.2/I20,OppNarasaReddyHouse, MaheswarNagar,Yerragurrtla-5I6109

¶32

¶33

Dr.Ramu.K, Aged about 34 years,3-72, Nacharam post, Vargal(M), Medak.

¶34

62.^- Dr.Ravi kumar.T, Aged about 3lyears, G-2, Gayathri Enclave, Gokule Nagar, Ramanthapur, Hyderabad.

¶35

lDrztrGBheixdesw.hta; Raq,9o.tdkdisd.NarFyt4asi i :.'. :1: r.i,':-: Aged about 36Yeam, It.No.2r4L246r^I 'i'': " .:.'.,^(,,. '' Park Line, Jagityala, Karirtsragat,

¶36

Dr.Mekala Ahusha, D/o. M.Ramesh, 25 Yebrs, H.No.304, Renuka i(esidency, Road No,1, Cross No.6, Rock Town Colony, L.B.Nagar, Hyderabad

¶37

65 The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Health lvledical & Family Welfare (E2) Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.

¶38

66 The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Home Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad-

¶39

¶40

(Respondents 6 to 64 are not necessary parties)

¶41

(RR 65 and 66 are impleaded as per Court Order, dated 12.06.2014 in W.A. lvl P'No'1953 of 2014 )

¶42

...Respondents/Respondents

¶43

l.A. NO: 1 OF 2014(WAMP. NO: 1564OF 2014)

¶44

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased direct the respondents to defer all further actions in furtherance of the PGMET2014 held on 27.4.2O14 as the same is in violation of judgment of this Hon'ble Court pending disposal of the above writ appeal.

¶45

l.A. NO: 2 OF 2014(WAMP. NO: 1565 OF 2014)

¶46

Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pteased direct the respondents to call the petitioners for counseling for being taken to pG Courses based on their ranking obtained in PGMET-2014 held on 2.3.2014, pending disposal of the above writ appeal. Counsel for the Appellants: SRl. K.R. PRABHAKAR

¶47

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 65: GP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE

¶48

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.z, 5 & 66: Gp FOR HOME

¶49

Counsel for the Respondent No.3: THE ADVOCATE GENERAL

¶50

Counsel for the Respondent No.4: SRI A. PRABHAKAR RAO,

¶51

SC FOR NTR UNIVERSITY

¶52

The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT

¶53

¶54

¶55

TIIE HON'BLE THE CHIEF IUSTICE UIIAI BIIUYAN

AND

,fHEH N',u tl

W.A.No. 723 of 2014

UDGMENT. (Per the tlon'blt rbc Cbi;fJustice Ujlal Bhayn)

¶60

Fleard Mr. K.RPrabhakar, learned counsel for the appellants

¶61

and Mr. APrabhakar Rao, Ieamed counsel for respondent No.4Univeniry.

¶62

Leamed counsel for the panies have informed the Court that

¶63

the cause ventilated in the writ appeal no longer survives for adjudication.

¶64

In view of above, this \7rit Appeal is dismissed as

¶65

infructuous. No costs.

¶66

fu a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand

¶67

dismissed

¶68

¶69

SD/- T. SRINIVAS DEPUT2f ,REGISTRAR //rRUEcoPY// (1U'r;,lrr l: r- SECTIOI{ OFFIOER

¶70

To,

¶71

One CC to Sri. K.R. Prabhakar, Advocate IOPUC]

¶72

Two CCs to GP for Medical Health and Family Welfare,^{High Court for the} State of Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]

¶73

Two CCs to the Advocate General, High Court^{for the State of Telangana at} Hyderabad. [OUTt[OUTt 4. Two CCs to Two CCs to^'GP for Home, High Court Home, High Court for the State the State State of^{Telangana atat}

¶74

Hyderabad. [OUTt[OUTt 4. Two CCs to Two CCs to^'GP for Home, High Court Home, High Court for the State the State State of^{Telangana atat} Hyderabad. [OUT]

¶75