Dismissed

The Registrar/Director ,Indira Gandhi National Open v. The Government of Andhra Pradesh

Telangana HC25 Jan 2022WA/571/2010

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Common judgment dismissing multiple Writ Appeals and Writ Petitions barring off-campus distance education. The Court held that degrees issued by approved deemed universities are valid. It rejected the argument for interference and directed appellants to file independent petitions regarding the specific RTI response.

What did the court decide?

Liberty given to appellants to pursue grievances to validate degrees independently in accordance with the Single Judge's findings.

The Registrar/Director ,Indira Gandhi National… — Education and Admissions | Telangana HC (2022)

¶1

¶2

HIGH COURT^{FORTHE STATEOF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD.--}

¶3

TUESDAY ,THE^{-IWENTY FIFTH DAY OFJANUARY} TWO THOUSAND^{ANDTWENTY TWO ,-.}

¶4

PRESE NT

¶5

HONOURABLE^{THECHIEFJUSTICE SATISH CHANDRASHARMA} - AND THE HONOURABLE^{SRIJUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI}

¶6

1 193 23 261 2 268 27 4 28 0 2 4 575 7 578 0 6 s89 59 93 5 597 OF

AND

1342 AND 1345^0F2016

AND

WRIT PETITION^{No.8206 of 2009}

¶11

¶12

WA NO:^{168 OF 2010}

¶13

Writ Appeal^{underclause 15 of the Letters Patentfiled againstthe order dated} 02 12 ioo;^{p;;;;din WPNo. ss4 ol 2oo7 and batch on thefile of the Hiqh Caud' /-}

¶14

Between:

¶15

Vinavaka l,4ission's^{Research FoundationDeemed UniversityRep byits} ii,';tli;? s;il;;^{M.i; R;;dArivanoorN H 47 saren63630BramilNaidu --}

¶16

.6th RESPONDENT/APPELLANT -

¶17

AND

¶18

1 Nannaouneni^{Aiay Kumar,Sio NageshwarRaoHanumanpetH No l0-150} Nannabaneniva'ri^{St.KanchikacherlaKrishna urstrlcl''-}

¶19

.,.,WRIT PETITIONER/RES^PONDENT

¶20

2.TheAndhraPradeshStateCouncilofHigherEducation,saifabad,Hyderabad represented^{by its secretary.} -.

¶21

The Principal,^{Nimra College of Engineering and TechnologyAffiliated to JNTU} University,^{Jupudi (V), lbrahimpatnam'Krrsnnaurslrlcl}

¶22

¶23

The Registrar,^{JawaharlalNehruTechnology University'Hyderabad -}

¶24

5' The Universities^{Grants Commission, Bahadur ShahZafar lvlargh, New De|hi110} 002, represented^{bY its Secretary.,-}

¶25

The District The District^{Education Council, lndira Gandhi National' Open University}

¶26

The District The District " M""d;;r;h;N;.Delhi 110 068, rep. bv its Director'

¶27

...RESPONDENTS^{1 to S/RESPONDENTS}

¶28

. NO: 10F 10

¶29

Petition^{under Section 151 CPCprayingthat in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed^{in supportof the petition,the High Court may be pleased lo} Judgment dated^{02 12'2009 madein w'P'} ;;.p;;;l;; oferation oi th" "omnon r.ro.'s9+ ot z00z^{and batch and all proceedings pursuant thereto'pendingdisposal} of the above^{writ APPeal.} '-

¶30

Counsel for^{the Appellant:SRl.S SRINIVAS REDDY}

¶31

counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 1: SRI' DAMMALAPATI SRINIVAS}

¶32

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo.2: SRI'C SUDESH ANAND <}

¶33

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 4: SRIK RATNA PRABHAKAR} "'

¶34

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SRI DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE '/}

¶35

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo. 6: SMT A CHAYADEVI '/}

¶36

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 3: NONEAPPEARED ''-}

¶37

WAN O: 193^{OF 2010}

¶38

Writ Appeal^{under clause'15 of theLetters Patent preferred againstthe order} oateo oz iz zoos^{passed in wp.No.27100 of 2006 andbatch on the file of theHigh} Cour1...-

¶39

Between:

¶40

Vinavaka^{[,4ission s, ResearchFoundationDeemed'-Univ-e-rsityrPP: py its} RUii;;;- saniuii^{ni"in ioJd, Arivanoor, NH-47 salem -636 308' Tamil Nadu'} -

¶41

...3'd RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT --

¶42

¶43

AND

¶44

'1. P.L. Sujatha, D/o. P. Satyanarayana Raju Rla 5-17812'^{Chandra Nagar'Chintal,} HMT Road, Hyderabad-s4.

¶45

¶46

.,,,WRIT PETITIONEFYRESPONDENT

¶47

The A.P. State Council^{of Higher Education,, Saifabad, Hyderabad, rep. byits} Secretary. /'

¶48

The Osmania University,^{Tarnaka, Hyderabad, rep- byits Registrar.} -

¶49

University Grants Commission,^{Bahadurshah Zafar marg, NewDelhi-110 002,} rep. byits secretary. /

¶50

Distance Education^{Council, lndira GandhiNationalOpen University,} l.4aidangarhi, New Delhi-110^{068, repbyits Registrar.} -

¶51

Priyadarshini Degree^{and PG College,,Ameerpet, hyderabad, rep. by its}

¶52

Secretary, l,4. Krishna Rao.^//

¶53

...RESPONDENTS 1,2,4,5^{& o/RESPONOENTS} -

¶54

Counsel for the^{Appellant:SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY} "

¶55

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: SRl.M PRASADARAO} ,

¶56

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 2: SRl.C. SUOESHANAND} '-

¶57

Counsel for the^{RespondentNos.3 & 4:SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE--}

¶58

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SMT.A CHAYADEVI -}

¶59

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 6: NONEAPPEARED} '

¶60

WA NO: 232 OF 2010

¶61

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the Letters Patent being aggrievedby the} common order dated^{o2-12-2OOgpassed in wPNo.1003 of 2007and batchon the file} of the High Courl. ,-

¶62

Between:

¶63

Vinavaka lvlission's Research Foundation^{Deemed, University, Rep by is} negiiiir, Sankari^{l\4ain Road,Ariyanoor,N H. 47,Salem-636308,TamilNadu} -

¶64

...3Td RESPONDENT/APPELLANT

¶65

¶66

AND

¶67

P. Bayappa Reddy,^{S/o.P. Nagi Reddy, R/o, D.No 16-'11-511/O/95,Shalivahana} Nagai. Dilsukhnaga',^HYderabad.

¶68

,.,WRIT PETITIONEPJRESPONDENT,-

¶69

2.TheA.P.StateCouncilofHigherEducation.saifabad,Hyderabadrepresentedby its Secretary. .

¶70

3, Jawaharlal^{NehruTechnology University, Kukatpally, Hyderabad' Rep byits} Registrar ,/

¶71

University Grants^{Commission, Bahadurshah Zafar Marg'NewDelhi-110 002'} represented bY^its Secretary ...

¶72

- Dlstance^{Education Council,IndiraGandhi National OTenUniversity'}

¶73

l,,f JiJanguil.]i^{New Delhi-110 068, represented byits Registrar'} --

¶74

Nova Colleqe of^{Enqineering andTechnology, Jafferguda' Batasingaram Village'}

¶75

Hayathnagir^{[,4andrl,Ranga Reddy District} /,

¶76

..,RESPONDENTS^{1, 2, 4, 5 & 6} ,,

¶77

WA P. NO: s33 0F²⁰¹⁰

¶78

PetitionunderSectionlslCPcprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin tnu in support of the^{petition, tre Higir Court mav be n]eqs9!sY-q9ng} "rfiOuuii-tir"o in" 200T.andbatchandallproceedin,gspursLJanttheretopendingdisposaloftheabove"p"iriir" olthe^{commonjudgement daledo2-12-2oo9.madein WP No' 1003 of} writ appeal. -

¶79

Counsel for^{the Appellant:SRl' S SRINIVASREDDY,--}

¶80

Counsel forthe^{RespondentNo. 1: SRI'A' SANJEEVKUMAR' -}

¶81

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 2: SRIC SUDESH ANAND' SC FORAPSCHE'-"} Counsel forthe RespondentNo.3:^{KRATHANGAPANI REODY' SC FOR JNTU --} Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 4:SRl. OEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE' SC FOR UGC} Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SMT.A CHAYADEVI} -- Counsel for^{the RespondentNo 6: NONEAPPEARED -'}

¶82

¶83

WA NO: 233 OF 2010

¶84

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order daled 02.12.2009^passed in WP. No.201 of 2007 and batch on the file of the Hiqh Court.

¶85

Between:

¶86

Vinayaka Mission s Research Foundation, Deemed University, rep. by ts Registrar, Sankari Main Road, Ariyanoor, NH-47, Salem 636 308, Tamil Na du

¶87

...6ih RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT

¶88

AND

¶89

1, Gunda Sandya Rani, D/o. Chandra Sekhar Occ: l\4BA Stuctent, C.V.R. College of Engineering, R/o. H.No. 1-1-141313, Ptot No.3l3, Bataji Colony, lr,4ohan Nagai, Kotha^pet, Hyderabad. ,-

¶90

,.,,WR]T PETiTIONER/RESPONDENT -

¶91

The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Saifabad, Hyderabad. rep. by its Secretary ,-

¶92

The Principal, C.V.R. College of Engineering Vasthunagar, lVangalpally viliage,lbrahimpatnam, R.R.District Affiliated to JNTU, Hyderabad z^'

¶93

The Registrar, Jawaharlal Nehru Technology University, Hyderabad

¶94

5- The Universities Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah, Zafar Margh, New Delh^j I 10002 rep.by its Secretary.,-

¶95

The Distance Education Council, Indira Gandhi, National Open University,

¶96

Maidangarhi, New Delhi 1^'10068 rep. by its Director.-.

¶97

...RESPONDENTS 1 TO 5iRESPONDENTS .-

¶98

P N : 538 OF 201

¶99

Petition under Section 151 CPC prayinq that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the operatjon of the common judgment daled A21Z.2OOS made in WPNo.201 of 2007 and batch and all proceedings pursr:.rant thereto, pending disposal of the above writ appeal _-

¶100

counsel for the Appellant:sRl. s sRlNlvAS REDOy

¶101

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. P PANOURANGA REDDy

¶102

¶103

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2:SRl. SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE} -.

¶104

counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRl. K RATHANGA PANIREDDY -} Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE} Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 6: SMT.A. CHAYA DEVI /}

¶105

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: NONEAPPEARED/}

¶106

WA NO: 23I OF 2010

¶107

Writ Appeal under clause¹⁵ of the^{Letters Patent preferred againstthe order} dated 02.12.2009^{passedin WP.No.632/2007 and batch on the file of theHighCourt} -

¶108

Between:

¶109

Vrnavaka l\ilissron s Research^{Foundation,DeemedUniversity,rep byits} Regiitrar, Sankari l,4ain Road, Ariyanoor,^{NH-47,Salem 636 308,TamilNadu.} ,- ...3.d RESPONDENT/APPELLANT -

¶110

AND

¶111

P. Shekar, S/o. P. Vittal^{No.13-13, Prakash nagar Colony, Bhoodan} Pochampally, Nalgonda District. /-

¶112

The Andhra Pradesh State Council^{of Higher Education, Saifabad,Hyderabad} rep.by its Secretary ,,

¶113

The Registrar, Jawaharlal Nehru^{Technology University, Hyderabad--}

¶114

Universities Grants Commission,^{Bahadur Shah} ,^{Zalar Margh,New Delhi1 10002} rep.by its SecretaU. _

¶115

Distance Education Council,,^{rep. by its Director, IGNOU, Maidangarhi,New} Delhi 1^'10068 .,/

¶116

St. l\4ary's College of Engineering^{& Technology,, Survey No 187, Deshmukhi} Village, Pochampally Mandal,^{Nalgonda District.}

¶117

,..RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶118

WAMP, NO : 547 OF 2010

¶119

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying thatⁱⁿ the^{circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High^{Court may be pleasedto}

¶120

¶121

suspend the operation of the common^judgment dated 02.12.2009 made in WPNo.632 of 2007 and batch and all proceedings pursuarit thereto, pending disposal of the above writ appeal --

¶122

counsel for the Appellant:sRl. s sRlNlvAS REDDY .'

¶123

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. A- SANJEEV KUMAR '

¶124

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE

¶125

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SRl. K RATHANGA PANI REDDY '--

¶126

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE -

¶127

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SMT.A CHAYA DEVI -

¶128

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: NONE APPEAREO -

¶129

WA NO: 242 OF 2010

¶130

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order dated 02.12.2009 passed in WP,No.10919 of 2008 and batch on the file of the High Court. ._

¶131

Between:

¶132

Vinayaka l,4ission's Research Foundation, Deemed University, rep. by Its Registrar, Sankari Main Road, Ariyanoor, NH-47, Salem 636 308, Tamil Na du

¶133

...6th RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT -

¶134

AND

¶135

Ravilla Nagajyothi, D/o. R. NageswarRao Student RJo. D.No. 8-134,32 Street, Lawyerpeta, Ongole, Prakasam District. -

¶136

WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT

¶137

2, The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Saifabad, Hyderabad. rep. by its Secretary

¶138

The Convenor, Ed.Cet-2007, Andhra University, Vishakapatnam, Sanketika Vidya Pitam, Masabtank, Hyderabad^.-

¶139

The Principal,, A.K. College of Education, Ongole, Prakasam District. --

¶140

Universities Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah, Zafar l,4argh, New Delhi 110002 rep.by its Secretary.

¶141

¶142

6 D.islance Ed.ucatlon Council,, Indra Gandhi Natjonal Open University, lr,4aidangarhi, New Delhi^'l 10068 rep. by its Registrar. /-

¶143

...RESPONDENTS 1 TO s/RESPONDENTS ,,-

¶144

WAMP. NO: 554 0F 2010

¶145

Petition under section 1s1 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend the operation of the common judgment dated O2.1,.ZOO9 made jn WPNo.10919 of 2008 and batch and all proCeedings pursuant thereto, pendjng disposal of the above writ appeal ".,

¶146

counset for the Appe ant:sRt. s sRlNtvAS REDDY .-

¶147

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. p RAJESWARA RAO

¶148

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRt. C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHL

¶149

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SRl. M V RAJA RAAM /-

¶150

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SRl. DEEpAK BHATTACHARJEE *

¶151

Counsel for the Respondent No, 6: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI -

¶152

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: NONE APPEARED -.-

¶153

O: 246 O F 2010

¶154

writ Appear under crause.15 of the Letters patent preferred against the order daled 02.12-2009 passed in wp.No. 1 190/2007 and batch on the fire otine High cou(

¶155

Between:

¶156

Vtnayaka l/ission's Research .Foundation, Deemed Universjty, rep. by its Registrar, Sankari l,4ain Road, Ariyanoor, trlH_+2, SJfem 636 308, t'amlf"Naal

¶157

...6th RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT

¶158

AND

¶159

IVlula Chandra Shekar Reddy, S/o. Guruva Reddy Vatsalya lnstitute of Science & Technology, FIat No.303, yjdhasri Aparrments, ,iioya Nigai, iiyl;;b;i^""' _-

¶160

,...WRIT PETITIONERYRESPONDENT

¶161

¶162

2, The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Opp. l,4ahavir Hospital, I,4ahavir [,4arg, l,4asabtank, Hyderabad, rep by its Secretary -

¶163

The Principal,, Vatsalya lnstitute of Science & Technology, Anantharam (V), Bhongir (Nl), Nalgonda District. -

¶164

The Registrar, Jawaharlal Nehru Technology Universlty, Hyderabad --

¶165

Universities Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah , Zalar ltrargh, New Delhi 1 10002 rep.by its Secretary. ,.

¶166

Distance Education Council,, lndira Gandhi National Open University, Ivlaidangarhi, New Delhi 1 10068 rep. by its Registrar. -

¶167

RESPONDENTS 1 TO s/RESPONDENTS

¶168

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY,-

¶169

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1 :SRl. P PANDURANGA REDDY

¶170

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C. SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE^z

¶171

Counsel forthe Respondent No.4: SRl. K. RATHANGA PANI REDDY-

¶172

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE

¶173

counsel for the Respondent No. 6: sMT. A CHAYA DEVI -

¶174

Counsel for the Respondent No, 3: NONE APPEARED .-

¶175

WA NO: 247 OF 2010

¶176

Wrjt Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent preferred agatnst the Common Order dated 02.12.2009 passed in W.P.No.636 of 200 and batch on the file of the Hlgh Court. -

¶177

Between:

¶178

Vinayaka Nlission's Research Foundation Deemed Unlversity, represented by its Registrar, Sankari l,4ain Road, Ariyanoor, N.H.47, Salem 630 308, Tamil Nadu. .--

¶179

...6Ih RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT -.

¶180

AND

¶181

lvl.Vikram Simha Reddy, S/o. Chennakeshava Reddy, Ronalds Ross P.G. College, Affiliated to Osmania University, R/o. SRT 97/A, Jawahar Nagar, RTC X Roads, Hyderabad. -

¶182

a^;t@L,i^A",h!'J'

¶183

¶184

,,,..WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT,,.

¶185

The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Sajfabad, Hyderabad, rep.by its Secretary _-.

¶186

The. Principai, Ronairjs Ross^{p.G..College,-Koheda} Road, lr,4angalpally vi age, lbrahimpatnam, R.R. District, Affiliated io Osmania University,^"tf ViieriUaJ ?

¶187

The Registrar, Osmania University, Hyderabad. //

¶188

Ihe Universities Grants Commissionr-Bahadurshah Zaf ar Marg, New Delhi_ 1 ,10 002. represented by its Secretary. z

¶189

The Distance Education council, rndira Gandhi Nationar open University, Maidan Garhi, New Delhj 1^.10 068, represented by its RegistrJi. ,,--

¶190

...RESPONDENTS 1 to S/RESpONDENTS -.-

¶191

Counsel for the Appettant:SRt. S SR|NIVAS REDDy .,

¶192

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. KTRAN PALAKURTHI _-

¶193

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRt. C. SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE -

¶194

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 4 & 5: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE ---

¶195

Counsel forthe Respondent No.6: SMT. A CHAyA DEVI -

¶196

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: NONE APPEARED ;

¶197

O:253 F 2010 .-

¶198

writ Appear under crause 15 of the Letters patent fired against the order dated 02.12.2009 in W.P.No. 4B of 2OOZ and batch on the file of the Higi Court .-.^{-- -''--}

¶199

Between:

¶200

yinayaka l,,1ission's Research Foundation, Deemed University, rep. by its Registrar Sankari t,4ain Road, Ariyanoor tt.H.az, Sife,n oiO eOA, ii,ntilfui,i --]

¶201

...7TH RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT *

¶202

AND

¶203

1 B,Rakesh Kumar, S/o.B.Ramesh No. S_3-18.1, Shanti Nagar, Kukatpally _ Hyderabad

¶204

. ...WRIT PETITIONERYRESPONDENT .

¶205

¶206

2 The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Educatjon, Saifabad, Hyderabad, Represented by its Secretary.

¶207

Osmania University, Tarnaka, Hyderabad, represented by its Registrar. -

¶208

lndira Gandhi National Open University represented by, its Director, [,4aidan Garhi, New Dethi-t 10 06b, tndia.

¶209

Distance Educatjon Council, IGNOU, Maidan Garhi, New Delhi-j .10 068, rep., by its Director. ,,

¶210

University G-rants Commission, Bahadur Shah Zafat |.Iarc, New Delhi_1 10 002. Rep. by its Secretary ,

¶211

Church PG Colleoe. reDresented by its Princjpal, Gagillapur Village, eutbullapur l/andat, R.R.Distiici. -

¶212

RESPONDENTS 1 to O/RESPONDENTS -..,

¶213

counset for the Appe ant:sRl. s sRlNtvAs REDDy,_

¶214

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. p pANOU RANGA REDDY ._ Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C SUDESH ANAND Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 3 & 6: SRl. OEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE -_ Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 4 & 5: SMT. A CHAYA DEV| Counsel for the Respondent No. 7: NONE AppEARED .,

¶215

WA NO: 256 OF 2010 y'

¶216

writ Appear under crause 15 0f the Letters patent against the order dr.2-12_ 2009 rn WP No. 1801 of ZOOT on the fite of rhe Hrgn Court. /-

¶217

Between:

¶218

Vinayaka Mission's Research .Foundation, Deemed University, Rep. bv its Resistrarsankari Main Road, nrivanooir.r.Hl 4;, s;l;; o"iil'Jo"aTl,iiifiliil '"

¶219

,..6TH RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT

¶220

AND

¶221

T. Rakesh Kiran, S/o T. Dora.swamy -Jesus p.G. College , Keesara C/o Ravi Kishore Kumar, H.No. 9_1-1l47lA, o6reniJc,iriv'I;;"s;; ri;rru. Hydercbad ,.

¶222

,WRIT PETITIONER/RES PONDENT -,--

¶223

¶224

The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Saifabad, Hyderabad represented by its Secretary. ,,

¶225

The Principal, Jesus P.G.College, Temple Road, Keesara Village, R.R.District,

¶226

The Registrar, Osmania University, Hyderabad. -.

¶227

University Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah Zafar, lvlargh, New Delhi, represented by its Secretary

¶228

The Distance Education Council, Indira Gandhi National Open University, l,4aidan Garhi, New Delhi. Rep, by its Registrar ,..

¶229

...RESPONDENTS 1 to 5/RESPONDENTS

¶230

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY -

¶231

Counsel forthe Respondent No. 1: SRl. Y. RAMATIRTHA ,-

¶232

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C. SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE -

¶233

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 4 & 5: SRl. K RATHANGA PANI REDDY Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI ,-

¶234

Counsel forthe Respondent No. 3: NONE APPEARED .-

¶235

WA NO: 261 OF 2010

¶236

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the order dated 02-122009 passed in WP No. 3648 ol 2007 and batch on the file of the High Corrt.. ,-

¶237

Between:

¶238

Vinayaka^-l,4issions Research Foundation, Deemed University, Rep. by its Registrar, Sankarl l,4ain Road, Ariyanoor, N.H.47, Saleem 636 308, Tamil Nddu,-

¶239

.,.3RD RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT --

¶240

ANO

¶241

G. Bhavsingh, S/o. Ramja, R/o. Tekula Thanda Village, Penjaramadugu Post, Kamepally l,4andal, Khammam District. -

¶242

2 Vankudoth Hathiram, S/o. Harisingh, R/o. Bhagyanagar Thanda Village, Yellendu, Singareni l,4andal, Khammam District. .,

¶243

¶244

Guguloth Sakaram,, S/o. Pulya,^{Ryo. H.No. 1-8-111,Kakatjyanagar, Yellandu,} Khammam District. /.

¶245

M. Ramulu, S/o.^l,4. Harya, R/o. Jayanthipuram,^{Jaggaiahpettt4andal,Krishna} District /

¶246

,...WRIT PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS --

¶247

The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education, Opp:^N/ahavir Hospotial, l\4ahavir Margh, I,4asabtank Hyderabad rep by Secretary..--

¶248

The Convenor Ed. CET-2006 conducted by Sri Venkateshwara University, Ttupati5lT 502. .

¶249

The Universlty Grants Commission Bahadursha Zaf ar \Aarg, New Delhi-1 10-002 rep by its Secretary. ,.-

¶250

The Distance Education Council lndira Gandhi, National Open University l,4aidangarhi, New Delhi rep by Director.

¶251

RESPONDENTS 1, 2, 4 & s/RESPONDENTS

¶252

WAMP. NO: 592 OF 2010

¶253

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that n the circumstances stated ln the affidavil filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be^pleased suspend the operations of the common^judgment darcd A2-12-2A09 made in WP No. 364812007 and batch and all^{proceedings pursuant} thereto^pending disposal of the a bove Writ Appeal,-

¶254

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDoY -

¶255

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4: SRl. NAMAVARAPU RAJESWARA RAO

¶256

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SRI.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE -

¶257

counsel forthe Respondent No.6: SRl. KASA JAGANMoHAN REDDY,-.

¶258

Counsel forthe Respondent No.7: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE -

¶259

Counsel for the Respondent No. 8: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI

¶260

¶261

WA NO: 266 OF 2010

¶262

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent filed against the order dated 2.12.2009 and made in WP.No.21987 of 2008 and batch and pass on the file of the High Court, /,

¶263

¶264

Between:

¶265

Vinavaka Mission s Research Foundation^{Deemed, University, rep.by its} Regiltrar, Sankari^{l,4ainRoad,Ariyanoor, N.H.47, Salem 636308,TamilNadu} -

¶266

,..3RD RESPONOENT/APPELLANT

¶267

AND

¶268

1 Sultana Begum,^{D/o. Naeeroddin,R/o.Kodad, Nalgonda District,.-} 2 lVld.Myjabeen, D/o, l,4d.Aziz Ali,^{R/o. Kodad, Nalgonda District, -'} 3 lvlahamad l,4asarath Parveen,^{D/o. naimuddin, R/o. Kodad, Nalgonda District,.-}

¶269

4 Raheemunnisa Begum, D/o.^{ltlirza Kareemulla Baig, R/oKodad, Nalgonda-'} District, _

¶270

5 Dhiravath Saiduiu, S/o.^{Halchya, R/0. Kodad, NalgondaDistrict.} --

¶271

WRIT PETITIONERSi RES PONDENTS

¶272

6, The Government of^{lndia, rep.by its Secretary,N,'1inistryof Human Resources} Development, Department^{of Secondary and Higher Education, Sastry Bhavan} New Delhi/

¶273

University Grants Commission,^{Bahadurshah Zafatlllarg, New Delhi-} 1 10002,rep.by its Secretary ,-

¶274

Distance Education Council,^{lndira Gandhi National, openUniversity,}

¶275

lvlaidangarhi, New Delhi-1 100068^{rep.by its Director ,-}

¶276

The Osmania University,^{Tarnaka,Hyderabad, 'rep.byits Registrar} -

¶277

10.The AP State Council of^{Higher Education, rep.by its,Secretary' Mahavir lrilarg,} I,4asab Tank, Hydercbad ,-

¶278

11.The Principal, Sana^{College of Education, Kodad, Nalgonda District} -

¶279

...RESPONDENTS

¶280

WAM . NO: 598 OF 2010

¶281

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that^{in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^{petition,the High Court may be pleasedto} suspend the operation of the^{common Judgmentdaled 2.12.2005 madein} WP.No.21987 of 2008 and batch and all^{proceedings pursuant theretopending} disposal of the above Writ Appeal. ,.-

¶282

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl.^{S SRINIVASREDDY --}

¶283

I l t. t.

¶284

¶285

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 to Sr SRl. S A K t/,lyNUDDlN ,. Counsel for the Respondent No. 6; M/S, KO|MIVINEN| MANI DEEPIKA ,- Counsel for the Respondent Nos, 7 & 9: SRt. DEEpAK BHATTACHARJEE -- Counsel for the Respondent No. B; SIVIL A CHAYA DEVI -,.. Counsel for the Respondent No. 10: S Rl, SUOESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE Ol 268 0F 2010 /

¶286

¶287

lYri Appeal u.dei.arse i5 ci the Leliers Faie:i i :a alta isi lhe ..,.. _ ale. i A2 122AAg passed n^y,i p\o 22559.,:r - J-.,..r,tf ; l"tie-.: :,e jrr C:rt _ ] Between:

¶288

Vinayaka N,4ission's Resea.ch Forr|datron, Deer,red Un ve.stty rep. by 1s Registrar Sankari l\4atn Road Ariyanoor r.r.t al 5a enl 6"3; :;d 'ir.;!";,,. ..,3.d RE S PON DE NT/AP P E LLANT

¶289

1. Pagdala Jaya Swathi O/o P.Rama Mohan R/o Tuririilla post, Cumbum Mandal Pral.asam Dtstr ct

¶290

2 Pattr Rajani Radhika Swapna pandLr, D/0. p. pandu R/o Tur milja posl Cun bum Mandal, Prakasam Dtstrrci ,,,,WRIT PETITIONERSiRESPONDENTS

¶291

1. Ihe^Governnent^{of lndia, Rep by its Secretary. lvlinisrl of iJ.ranResources.} ueveropment IJeDarlmenl of Secondary and Higher EdJcatioa. Sist1, S,]iuun, New Delhi /.

¶292

4 Un iversity Gra nts Commission, Bahadurs hah Zaf a( l,lae, New Delhi - 1 1 O 002 REp. by its Secretary / Reqistrar - The Dislance Education Council. ,n.lira Gandhi National Open University New Delhi, Rep. by its Oirector /.

¶293

6 The A.P. State Council of Highe. Education,, Saifabad, Rep. by its Secretary / 7 Ihe Principal, Adarsa College of Educalion, Giddatur prakasam District. , B Il:.L!ir,f/,^{Nagarju.a U.ivers,tv \aga,jLr.a NaqarGLril-. feo} o, :s Keqrstrar.

¶294

AND

¶295

,..RESPONOENTS

¶296

P. NOI 600 0 F 2A1a

¶297

¶298

Pelition under Section 151 CpC praying that in the ci.cumstances stated in lhe affldavit filed tn support of the petitio;, tne High Coun may Oe pteaseO to suspend the operation oi the common Judgment dalJ OZ.ij io"Os mro" in W P.No. 22s59 of 2oo7 and batch. and a proieeoingilrrisuunr'Gir""ro , p"noing d.sposa' of the aoove wr,t Apped.

¶299

¶300

¶301

Counsel for^{the Appellant:SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY} /' Counsel for the^{Respondent Nos. 1 & 2: SRIS A K MYNUDDIN /} Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 3: M/S' KOMMINENI MANI DEEPIKA/}

¶302

Counsel forthe^{RespondentNo' 4: SRI' DEEPAKBHATTACHARJI} ,/'

¶303

Counsel for^{the Respondent No' 5: SMT'A CHAYADEVI} "'

¶304

Counsel for^{the Respondent No' 6: SRIC' SUDESH ANAND'z}

¶305

Counsel for^{the RespondLent No' 8: SRI'P' HARNATHGUPTAz}

¶306

Counsel for the^{Respondent No' 7: NONEAPPEARED /}

¶307

WA NO: 271 oF²⁰¹⁰

¶308

writ Appeal^{under clause 15 of the Letters Patent appeal against the iudgement} passei;; wFir;.^{1 190 of 2007,dt' 02-12-200son the file of the Hish court'}

¶309

Between:

¶310

The Distance^{EducationCouncil, lndira Gandhi NationalOpen University' New} Delhi, ReP^{bY lts Director}

¶311

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^NO.5 -

¶312

AND

¶313

The Andhra^{Pradesh State Council} -of^{Higher Education" Opp:Mahavir Hospital'} tr]aiaOtant<^{Hyderabad rep , by its Secretary',.}

¶314

The^{Prrncipal,Vatsalya lnstitute of Science and Techno|ogy,, Anantharam(V),} Bhongir^{(N/l), Nalgonda District'} -

¶315

3.TheRegistrar,JawaharlalNehruTechnologyUniversity,Hyderabad.,.

¶316

4.tjniversitiesGrantsCommission,rep',byitsSecretary,BahadurShahZafar, Margh,^{NewDelhi-1 10 002} -

¶317

Vinavak^{Mission,S Research Foundation (VMRF), Deemed University, Rep byits} Regi3trar^{Salem,Tamilnadu /}

¶318

(R2 is not necessary^{in this WA)} ./

¶319

..,.RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS,-

¶320

¶321

Mula Chandra Shekar Reddy,^{S/o.Gurva Reddy,Occ:N,4BA Student, Vatsalya} lnstitute of Science and Technology,^{R/o, Flat No. 303,Yashari Apartments,} Vidyanagar, Hyderabad.

¶322

,..RESPONDEN IF /ot;l"'-

¶323

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYADEVI} ,''

¶324

counsel for the Respondent No.^{1: SRl. C SUDESHANAND, SC FORAPSCHE.-}

¶325

Counsel for the Respondent No.^{3: SRl. K, RATHANGA PANI REDDY'-}

¶326

Counsel for the Respondent No.^{4: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE-}

¶327

Counsel for the Respondent^No. 5:^{SRl. S SRINIVASAREDDY..'}

¶328

counsel for the Respondent^No. 6:^{SRl.P PANDU RANGAREDDY--}

¶329

WA NO:27 10

¶330

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of} the^{Letters Patent Appeal preferred againstthe} Order dated 0;2.12.2009^{passedin W.P.No.3614of 2007 and batchon the file of the} High Court, ,-

¶331

Between:

¶332

Vinavaka Mission's Research^{Foundalion, Deemed University, representedbyits} Regiltrar, Sankari l,4ain^{Road,Ariyanoor, N.H.47, Salem 636 308,TamilNadu} -

¶333

...6th RESPONDENT/APPELLANT -.

¶334

AND

¶335

1, V.C.Rajesh, S/o.V.C.^{BangarappaR/o,D. No.1-3-497, RangaswamiNagar, Vth} Road, Anantapur. -

¶336

,,,.WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT.

¶337

The Andhra Pradesh State^{Councilfor Higher Education, Opp:lVahavir Hospital,} Mahavir lvlargh, Masab^{Tank Hyderabad, rep.by its Secretary._}

¶338

The Principal, C,S,l.RD.lnstitute^{of l\4anagement and,Technologyu, Ananthapur} District ,,"

¶339

The Registrar, Sri Krishna^{Devaraya University,,Ananthapur}

¶340

The Universities Grants Commission,^{Bahadur Shah,Zafarl,4argh,New Delhi,} rep, by its Sectelary. /.

¶341

g\8

¶342

The Dislance Education Council, lndira Gandhi National, Open University, Nlaidan Garhi, New Delhi. represented by its Director. ..-

¶343

.,,RESPONDENTS --

¶344

WAMP. NO: 608 OF 2010

¶345

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased suspend the operation of the common Judgment dated 02.12.2009 made in W.P.No.3614 of 2007 and batch, and all proceedings pursuant thereto, pending disposal of the a bove Writ Appeal.

¶346

,.-

¶347

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY

¶348

,,_

¶349

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. KIRAN PALAKURTHI --

¶350

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C. SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE _

¶351

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: SRl. J UGRA NARASIMHA, SC FOR SKU _

¶352

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5:.SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE

¶353

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI

¶354

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: NONE APPEARED /.

¶355

WA NO: 274 OF 2010

¶356

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent filed against the order dated 2.12.20A9 and.made in WP.No.s182 of 2009 and batch on the file of the High Cou(.

¶357

Between:

¶358

Vinayaka l\ilission's Research Foundation Deemed, University,rep by its Regjstrar, Sankari l\ilain Road,Ariyanoor, N.H.47,Salem 636308, Tamilnadu ..-

¶359

...7th RESPONDENT/APPELLANT --

¶360

AND

¶361

V.Raghu, Si.o.Sri Vasram, Occ: Employee Ryo. H.No.31-3-69, Vengala rao colony Pa loncha, Khammam District ,-

¶362

WRIT PETITIONEFYRESPONDENT

¶363

¶364

2 The AP State^{Council of HigherEducation'Mahavir l\rlarg' MasabTank} Hyderabad,^{repbYits Secretary} ,

¶365

Kakatiya^{University, rep,by itsRegistrar'P'yderabad '}

¶366

3 lndiraGandhiNationalOpenUnrversityrepbyitsDrreclor'iGNOU'N/aldan Garhi. New^{Delhi'110068 .}

¶367

Drstance Education^{Councillndira G^andhi National' Open UniversilyMaidan}

¶368

6iini iG* oiinit^{t0068rep bv itsRegrstrar} "

¶369

University^{Grants Commission' Bahadurshah Zafarlu4arg'New Delhi-'1 10002'}

¶370

6 fep.by its Secretary^,'

¶371

7 lMotherTheresaCollegeofEducation'rep'byits'Correspondent'Paloncha' Khammam^District '

¶372

...RESPONDENTS^{1 TO 6iRESPONDENTS '--}

¶373

MP, NO:⁶¹⁰ F20¹⁰

¶374

,r,," susoend "riio:jiil PetitionUnderSectionl5lCPcprayingthatlntheclrcumslancesstated]nthe^{iir"Ji" operation supporr of rn" ot tnu torri'on- o"titioi, i'Jg.neni in" Hish o't"d coun 2'12'2009 made mav-be} pleased to^rn proc'eeoings^{pursuanttheretopend'ng} wP.No.5'182^{of 2OOgand out"n' uno} "'i disposal^{of the aboveWrit APPeal ,'}

¶375

Counsel^{ior the Appellant:SRl'S SRINIVASREDDY} "

¶376

Counsel^{for the RespondentNo 1: SRI' NAMAVARAPU RAJESWARARAO'} Counsel^{for the RespondentNo 2: SRIC SUDESH ANAND' SC FORAPSCHE/}

¶377

Counsel^{for the RespondentNos3 to 6: SRI DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE-}

¶378

Counsel^{for the RespondentNos4 & 5: SMTA CHAYADEVI}

¶379

Counsel^{for the RespondentNo7: NONEAPPEARED}

¶380

¶381

oF 20 10

¶382

Writ Aooeal^{under clause1 5 of the Lellers PatentAppeal} -p-referred against the c"rr;;, bfiJ;;;iozizoos^o"tul '^{wp,*"2714dor 2oooand batchonthe} file of lhe^{High Court} "

¶383

Between:

¶384

Xi;lf,:?^{Eff i"J;'^[:i"-: [:'i33:?:^P':"'l]ig;i"Xi3!"i'l'!'lE:]:iL*ll :}

¶385

7TH RES^{PONDE NT/APPE LLANT}

1,p ,"t

AND

Shaik Khajavali, S/o.Sk.Rahim Nloinabad, Hyderabad. /

¶390

WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT

¶391

Andhra Pradesh State Council for Higher Education,, Saifabad, Hyderabad, represented by its Secretary, Mahaveer lvlarg, l,4asab Tank, Hyderabad,,,

¶392

Osmania Univeristy, Tarnaka, Hyderabad, rep.by its Registrar. ,-,

¶393

lndira Gandhi Natioanal Open University, rep.by its Director, Maidan Garhi,^New Delhi-1 10068, lndia /

¶394

Distance Education Council, lndira Gandhi National, Open University, Maidan Garhi, New Delhi-1 10068, represented by its Registrar. 7

¶395

University Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhi-1 10002 Rep.by its Secretary. z

¶396

Azad College of Clmputers, rep.by its Principal, Peddamangalaram, Moinabad, R.R.District

¶397

...RESPONDENTS 1 to 6/RESPONDENTS

¶398

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY .--

¶399

..-

¶400

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. P PANDU RANGA REDDY

¶401

../-

¶402

Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRl. C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE

¶403

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 3 & 6: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE

¶404

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.4 & 5: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI⁽

¶405

Counsel for the Respondent No. 7: NONE APPEAREo

¶406

WA NO: 28 5 0F 2010

¶407

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent against the Judgment^passed in WP No. 1422 al 2007 , dt. 02-12-2009 on the file of the High Court.

¶408

Between:

¶409

lndira Gandhi National Open University,,^Rep by^{Registrar, MaidanGarhi, New} Delhi - 110 068

¶410

The Distance Education Council, lndira Gandhi^National, Open^{University, New} Delhi, rep by its Director ..

¶411

ffalt^{a*t/ &"/"^ a^tt sk4 .-}

¶412

,^t\z /3

¶413

AND

¶414

Andhra Pradesh State Council^{for Higher Education, Opp: lviahavir Hospital,} Masab Tank, Hyderabad,^{rep.by its Secretary,} .,

¶415

Acharya Nagarjuna University,^{rep.by its Registrar, Nagarjunanagar, Guntur} District ./

¶416

University Grants Commission,^{rep.by its Secretary, Bahadursha Zafar Marg,} New Delhi-1 10002 ,.

¶417

Shams-Ul-Uloom College^{of Education, rep.by its Principal, Podili, Prakasam} District ,,

¶418

Vinayaka [,4ission's^{Research Foundation (VMRF), Deemed University, rep.by its} Registrar, Salem, Tamilnadu ,

¶419

.,.,RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS --

¶420

6, P. Shaheda Khanam,^{D/o, P. SyedKhan, R/o. Podili,Prakasam District}

¶421

(R4 is not necessary in this WA.) -

¶422

...RESPONDENT/PETITIONER-

¶423

counsel for the Appellant:sMT.^{A CHAYADEVI} ----

¶424

Counsel for the Respondent^{No.1: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND' SC FOR,APSCHE'-} counsel for the Respondent^{No- 2: SRIPHARINATHGUPTA}

¶425

counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 3: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶426

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl,S SRINIVASA REDDY--.}

¶427

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 6: SRl.S NIRANJAN REDDY} --'

¶428

WA NO: 300 OF 2010

¶429

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the LettersPatentagainst the order dated02-12-} 2OOg passed in WP No. 63212007^{on thefile of the High Court.} -

¶430

Between:

¶431

The Distance Education^{Council,lndira Gandhi National,Open University,New} Delhi. Rep. by its Director. ..-

¶432

-..APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO.^5,,--

¶433

¶434

AND

¶435

The A.P.State Council of Higher Education, Opp: l,4ahavir Hospital, l,4asab Tank, Hyderabad represented by its Secretary. -.

¶436

The Registrar, Jawaharlal Nehru Technology University, Hyderabad. -

¶437

Vinayaka l,4ission's Research Foundation^(VMRF) Deemed, Universlty represented by its Registrar, Salem, Tamil Nadu. -

¶438

The University Grants Commission, rep., by its Secretary, Bahadurshah Zafar l,4arg, New Delhi-1 10 002. ,.

¶439

St.lVary's College of Engineering & Technology, Survey No.1 87, Deshmukhi Village, Pochampally l,4andal, Nalgonda District. -,

¶440

,,.RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶441

P. Shekar, S/o. P. Vittal, Rio. 13-13, Prakashnagar Colony, Bhoodan Pochampally, Nalgonda District.

¶442

(sth Respondent not necessary in the WA) .,.

¶443

...RESPON DENTS

¶444

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT. ACHAYADEVI

¶445

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1:SRl. C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE _ Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. K RhTHANGA PANI REDDY --.-

¶446

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SRl. S^SRINIVAS REDDY^"--

¶447

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE

¶448

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 6:SRl. A. SANJEEVKUMAR} -

¶449

WA NO: 568 OF 201 0

¶450

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal against^{the Judgment} passed in WP No 636 of 2007 dt 02-12-2009 on the file of the High Caui. ,.

¶451

Between:

¶452

Distance Education Council Rep.by its Director, lndira^{Gandhi NationalOpen} University K.'18 Hauz Khas lt,4aidan Garhi New Delhi 110068 ,-

¶453

,..APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. 5

¶454

tu) ,'g

¶455

AND

¶456

The Andhra Pradesh^{StateCouncil of HigherEducation, Opp:MahavirHospital,} Masab Tank Hyderabad,^{rep.by its SecretarY} ,

¶457

The Principal, Ronalds^{RossP.G.College, Koheda Road, lvlangalpally village,} lbrahimpainam R.R.District Affiliated to Osmania^{Universlty, Hyderabad} -

¶458

The Registrar, Osmania University,^Hyderabad. ,' 4. The Universities Grants Commission,^{Bahadur ShahZafarl,4argh,New Delhi-} 1 10 002, rep.by its Registrar ,-

¶459

The Vinayaka Mission's^{Research Foundation, Deemed University, SankarilVlain} Road,,^(NH-47), Ariyanoor,Salem^{Tamilnadu-636308} ,.,.RESPONDENTS

¶460

6 Nil.Vikram Simha Reddy, Si o.Chennakeshava^{Reddy I\4CAStudent Ronalds Ross} P.G.College, Affiliated^{io Osmania University R/o,SRT97/A, Jawaharnagar,RTC} X roads, Hyderaba9-

¶461

(R2 not necessary in tnis WA.;^/

¶462

RESPONDENT lrr&* WAMP, NO:^{1 392} 0F²⁰¹⁰

¶463

Petition under Section^{151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in^{support of the petition, the High Court maybe pleased suspend} the operation of the^{judgment dl.2'12'2005 made in WPNo.636/2007,pending} disposal of the WA. ,.-

¶464

counsel for the Appellant:sMT.^{A CHAYADEVI /}

¶465

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No. 1: SRl.c SUDESH ANAND,Sc FORAPSCHE} -

¶466

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos' 3 & 4: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶467

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY}

¶468

Counsel forthe Respondent No.6:^{SRl. KIRANPALAKURTHI} "

¶469

WA NO: 56I OF 2010

¶470

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of^{the Letters Patent appeal againstthejudgement} in WPNo. 26848 of 2006, dl,2'12'2009^{on the fileof the HighCourt.} -

¶471

Between:

¶472

The Distance Education Council, rep by its Director, lndira Gandhi National Open University, K-18 Maidangarhi, New Delhi - 110 068 ,,.

¶473

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. 6 _-

¶474

AND

¶475

1 Osmania University, rep by Registrar, O. U, Campus, Hyderabad-s00 007. ,-

¶476

2 Andhra Pradesh State Council for Higher Education, rep by its Secretary, Mahavir N4arg, Masab Tank, Hyderabad-500 008 _

¶477

3 Hyderabad School ol Management. rep by its, Secretary/Principal Survey No.81 Bandlaguda Khalsa^(V), Quba Colony, Near Pahadi Shareef Road, Hyderabad500 005. ,-

¶478

Vinayaka lvlission's Research Foundation, Deemed University, rep by its Registrar, Sankari Main Road, Ariyanoor Salem-636 808, Tamil Nadu. .-

¶479

The University Grants Commission, rep by^its Secretary,^{Bhaadurshah Jaffar} marg, New Delhl-1 10 002. /.

¶480

...,RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶481

Faiza Begum, D/o. [,4.A. Bari, Rlo 16-1-2412115. New Greenland Colony, Saidabad, Hyderabad-500 059,

¶482

(R3 not necessary in this WA) ,,2

¶483

...RESPONDENT/wRIT PETITIONER

¶484

WAMP. NO: 1393 0F 2010

¶485

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying thatⁱⁿ the^{circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support^of the^{petition, the HighCourt may be pleased suspend} the operation of the common^{judgmentdated02-12-2009 made in WPNo. 26848 of} 2006 pending disposal of the above^writ appeal^.--

¶486

counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^A CHAYA^{DEVI .-}

¶487

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. I^{& 5:} SRl.^{DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} -

¶488

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRl. C.^{SUDESH ANAND,SC FORAPSCHE} -

¶489

Counsel for the Respondent^No. 4:^{SRl.S SRINIVASAREDDY} .--

¶490

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 6: SRl. A K JAYAPRAKASHRAO *}

¶491

tl,, /

¶492

WA NO: 57 0 0F 2010

¶493

Writ Appeal under^{clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal filed against the order} dated 02.12.2009 in WP^{No. 201ol 2007 on the file of theHigh Court}

¶494

Between:

¶495

Distance Education^{Council,, Rep.by its Director, lndira Gandhi NationalOpen,} University, K-18, Hauz^{Khas, Maidan Garhi, New Delhi- 1 10 068} ,,

¶496

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. 5^/

¶497

AND

¶498

The Andhra Pradesh State council^{of Higher Educatlon, Opprl,4ahavlrHospital,} l,4ahvir Marg, masab^{Tank Hyderabad, rep.by its Secretary} ,

¶499

The Principal, C.V.R.co'lege^{of EngrneeringVastl^Jnagar l\4angaloally} vil,age.lbrahimpatnam, R.R.D,strict^{Affil'aled lo JNTU. Hvde'abad}

¶500

The Registrar, Jawaharlal^{NehruTechnology University,I'ydeat)ad} /

¶501

The Universities Grants^{Commission, Bahadur Shah,ZaIat Margh'New Delhi,} rep. by its Registrar

¶502

Vinavaka Mission's^{Research Foundation Deemed University,Sankari[i1ain} Road,⁽ NH^{- 47),Ariyanoor Salem,Tamilnadu- 636 308} -

¶503

- -.RESPON DENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶504

Gunda Sandya^{Rani, D/o.Chandra Sekhar C V.R.College of Englneering Ryo} H.No. 1-1-1473/3, Plot^{No. 3/3,Balaki Colony, l,4ohanNagar'Kothapet,} Hyderabad. z

¶505

(R2 not necessary in this WA.) .'

¶506

.RESPONOENT/}VRIT PETITTONER,-

¶507

WAMP- NO: 1394 OF 2010

¶508

Petition under Section^{'151 CPCpraying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of^{the petition,the HighCourt may be pleasedto} suspend the operation of the^{Judgment daled. 2.12.209 made in WP 2A1 of 2047,} pending disposal of the above writ appeal .

¶509

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYADEVI --}

¶510

counsel for the Respondent^{No. '1: SRl. C SUDESHANAND,SC FORAPSCHE} --

¶511

;{

¶512

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 3 &^{4: SRl. DEEPAK} BHATTACHARJEE _-

¶513

counsel forthe Respondent No. 5: SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY-

¶514

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: SRl. KIRAN PALAKURTHI -

¶515

WA NO: 571 OF 2010

¶516

,,.

¶517

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters^{Patent filedagainstthe order dated} 2122009 and made in WP.No.s167 of^{2009 and pass on thefile of the High Coui...'}

¶518

Between:

¶519

The Registrar/Director ,lndira Gandhi^National Open,^{Universily,K-18,Maidan} Garhi,New Delhi-1 10068 -

¶520

...APPELLANT/RESPONOENT NO. 6 .-

¶521

1. The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Rep. by^its Secretary^{Higher Education} Department, Secretariat,^Hyderabad. -

¶522

1. The Secretary, A.P. State Council of^{Higher Education Hyderabad..'} 3. The Secrta ry/Correspo ndent, Sri^{KollaAppalaNaiduCollege of Education} Sarada Nagar, Galapathi^{Nagaram Vlzianagaram DistricL}

¶523

1. Vinayaka l,4ission Research Foundation, Deemed University,^{Sankari,lvlain} Road,^(NH-47) Ariyanoor, Saleem,^{Tamil Naidu ,-}

¶524

1. The Secretary/Registrar, University^{Grantes CommissionBahadurshaZafar} Marg, New Delhi. /

¶525

AND

¶526

....RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS-

¶527

P.Vijaya Raju, S/o.Venkata^{opala Raju R/o.Vizianagaram, Vizianagaram District}

¶528

...RESPONDENT/PETITIONER

¶529

WAMP. NO: 1395 OF 2010

¶530

Petition under Section¹⁵¹ CPC^{praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^{petition,the HighCourt may be pleased to} suspend the operation of the Judgment daled^{2.12.2009made in WP.No.5167of} 2009 pending disposal of the above^{Writ appeal./-.}

¶531

Counsel forthe Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYADEVI z}

¶532

,t1,

¶533

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos.1 & 2: GP FOR EDUCATION} ,. Counsel forthe Respondent No.4:^{SRl.S SRINIVASREDOY} ,- Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE'-} Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 6: SRl. KARRI SURYANARAYANA}

¶534

counsel for the Respondent No.^{3: NONE} APPEARED -

¶535

WA NO: 572 OF 2010

¶536

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the^{Letters Patent appeal against the judgement} passedinWP.No. 19753of 2008,dt. 02-12-2009 onlhefileof the High Coud'. 7

¶537

Between:

¶538

District Education Council,^{Rep byits Director IGNOU, Maidan Garh,New Delhi -} 110 068 ,z ...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. 3/-

¶539

AND

¶540

'1. University Grants Commission, Rep. by its Secretary, Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg, New Delhl - 110 002. ,-

¶541

1. Vinayaka Mission's Research Foundation,^{Deemed University, NH 47 Sankari} N/ain Road, Ariyanoor, Salem,^{Tamilnadu- 636308, Rep, by its Registrar} --

¶542

1. Acharya Nagarjuna University,^{Nagariunanagar, Guntur,Rep. by its Registrar} (Controller of Examinations). ,-

¶543

1. The A.P. State Council of Higher^{Education, Opp: Mahavir Hospilal,N,4asab Tank} Hyderabad. Rep. by its Secretary. ..-

¶544

1. Andhra Muslim College^{of Educalion, Ponnuru Road,Guntur Rep. by its} Secreta ry/Correspondent. , RESPONDENTS .

¶545

1. P. Srilatha, D/0. Narasimha^{Reddy, R/o.H.No. '19-15-31, 1st Lane,} Sangadigunta, Guntur, Guntur^District. - (R5 not necessary in this W4)-

¶546

... RES PON D E NT/WRIT PETITIONER ,-

¶547

""9. 4 WA,W^{tlc' )3't *)'to}

¶548

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that^{in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filedⁱⁿ support^of the^{petition,the HighCourt may be pleased suspend} the operation of the common Judgment^{daled 02-12-2009 made in WP No. 19753 of} 2008 pending disposal of the above writ appeal ,,'

¶549

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYA} DEVI^/'

¶550

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶551

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2: SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY} "

¶552

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: SRI. SRINIVAS MANTHA} -

¶553

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FORAPSCHE}

¶554

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 6: SRl. J SRINIVASARAO} /

¶555

A NO: 573 F

¶556

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of} the^{Letters PatentAppeal preferred againstthe} order dated 02.12.2009^{passed in WPNo.68/2007 on the fileof the HighCourt, .-}

¶557

Between:

¶558

Distance Education Council,^{lndira GandhiNationalOpenUniversity,K-18,} l\4aidan Garhi, New Delhi-1^{10 068, rep. by its Director. /'}

¶559

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^{NO. 4} -.

¶560

AND

¶561

A.P.State Counsel^{of Higher Education, Opp : lvlahavirHospital, Masabtank'} Hyderabad Rep by^{its Secretary} ,-

¶562

Osmania University,^{University Campus,Rep by its Registrar,(Controller of} Examination)^Hyderabad

¶563

Holv Marv lnslrlule^{of Tecnnology& Science,, B K Guda, S R. Nagar,} Hyo'erab6o. Rep by,ts Secretat/Correspondent -

¶564

The University Grants^{Commission, Bahadur ShahZafarMarg,New Delhi-110} 002, rep. by^its Registrar. ./

¶565

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS^-

¶566

5 B.Shvam Sunder^{Rao, S/o.B. Narsimha Rao R/o. Flat No.101,Aashrita} Apar[ments. Vrdyanagar.^Hyderabad. --

¶567

(R3 not necessary in this WA) ,..

¶568

...RESPONDENT/WRITPETITIONER'/

¶569

62A

¶570

WAMP. NO 1397 0F 010

¶571

PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin the affidavit filed in^{supportof the petition,the High Court may be pleased to} srspend the operation^{of the judgmenldaled212'2009 madein WP No 68 of} 2007,^pending disposal^{of the aboveWrit Appeal,,.}

¶572

Counsel for^{the Appellant:SMT.A CHAYADEVI} -/

¶573

Counsel forthe^{RespondentNo. 1: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND' SC FORAPSCHE} -

¶574

Counsel forthe^{RespondentNos.2& 4: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE-}

¶575

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SRl.CH RAMESH BABU} "'

¶576

WAN O:.574 OF²⁰¹⁰

¶577

WritAppeaIunderclausel5oftheLettersPatentAppealpreferredagainstthe orderdated ciz.tz.zoos^{passed inwpNo.10919 of 2008 on the fite of theHighcourr. ,.}

¶578

Between:

¶579

Distance^{Education Council,rep. by its Regislrar, lndrra Gandhi NationalOpen}

¶580

U^u"riitv, K78,^{HauzKhas, Mardan Garhr, NewDelhr-'1 10068} ,

¶581

,..APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^{NO. 5-}

¶582

AND

¶583

l.TheAndhraPradeshStetCouncilofHigherEdUcatlon,opp,MahavirHospital, lvlahavir l\ilargh,^{Masabtank, Hyderabad, repby its Secretary'/}

¶584

The Convenor,^{Ed.Cet'2007, AndraUniversity,Visakhapatnam,' Sanketika Vidya} Pitam, Masab^{Tank, HYderabad} .

¶585

The Principal,^{A.K. Collegeof Education, Ongole, Prakasam District -}

¶586

The University^{of GrantsCommission, Bahadur ShahZalarMaQh' NewDelhi'} rep.by its Registrar,.

¶587

STheVenavakMission.sResearchFoundationDeemedUniversity,SankariMain - Road ( Nti-+71, Ariyanoor, Salem, Tamil Nadu 636 308 ,--

¶588

...,RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶589

Ravilla Nagajyothi,^{D/o. R. Nageswar Rao FUo. D No S-134, 32 Street'} '/'

¶590

" L;,;,y#;r;;'6;s;re, F;aki;fr-Distri+

¶591

tSel$^{w,Ury*tl"^} /k'^{^c-} u'r1 i^.-.

¶592

U.1L*4

¶593

¶594

WAMP. NO: 1398 OF 2010

¶595

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying thatⁱⁿ the^{circumstances statedin} lhe affidavit filed in support of the^{petition,the HighCourt maybe pleased to} suspend the operation of the^judgment daled^{02.12.2009 made in WPNo.10919ol} 2008,^pending disposal of the above^Writ Appeal .-

¶596

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT. A CHAYA DEVI -

¶597

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: SRI.C SUDESH ANAND,SC FORAPSCHE} -

¶598

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2: SRl.M V RAJA RAAM}

¶599

Counsel forthe Respondent No.4:^{SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE-}

¶600

Counsel forthe Respondent No.5:^{SRl.S SRINIVAS REDDY} "'

¶601

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6:^{SRl.P RAJESWARARAO -"'}

¶602

WA NO: 575 OF 2010

¶603

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of^{the Letters Patent Appeal against the Judgment} passed in WP No. 1 801/2007 dt O2-12-2OO7^{passedby the Learned singleJudge for the} following among other on the^{file of the High Court.} -

¶604

Between:

¶605

Distance Education Council^{Rep.byits Director, lndira Gandhi National Open} University K18Hauz^{Khas Maidan Garhi NewDelhi 110068'--}

¶606

,..APPELLANT/RESPONOENT^NO.5

¶607

AND

¶608

The Andhra Pradesh State^{Council of Higher Education, Opp:lvlahavir Hospital} ,Mahavir^{Marg, MasabTank Hyderabad, rep.by its Secretary,-}

¶609

2, The Principal,^{Jesus PG College,Temple Road, KeesaraVillage, Ranga Reddy} District, Affiliated to^{OsmaniaUniversity} --

¶610

The Registrar,^{Osmania University, Hyde@bad,} "

¶611

The Universities Granls Commission,^{Bahadur ShahZafar, Margh, New Delhi,} rep.by its Registrar ,-

¶612

¶613

The Vinayaka^{Mission.SResearch Foundation Deemed University,SankariMain} Road^{(NH-47), Ariyanoor,SalemTamilnad u-636308} ".'

¶614

. -..RESPONDENTSiRESPONDENTS^.,'

¶615

T.Rakesh Kiran,^{S/o.T.Dora Swamy Jesus P.G College, Keesara,C/oRavi} - kisirtiJkumar it.tto g-t -t lazn, Dbfence colonv Langer House,Hyderabad '-

¶616

(R2 not necessary in this WA) ,,

¶617

...RESPON DENT/vVRIT^{PETITIONER .}

¶618

waMP. NO: 1399 OF 2010

¶619

petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances^statedin the affidavit filed^{in support of the petition, the High Cou11may be pleased suspend} theoperationoftheJudgmentdated2.l2-2009madeinWP1801of2007,pending disposal of the^aboveWA " -'

¶620

Counsel for the^{Appellant:SMT. A CHAYADEVI} -

¶621

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 1: GP FORHIGHER EDUCATION} "

¶622

Counsel for^{the RespondentNos.3 & 4: SRl, DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE'/}

¶623

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SRl. SRINIVASREoDY-'-}

¶624

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo, 6: SRl. K. SATYANARAYANAMURTHY'}

¶625

WA NO: 577 OF 2010

¶626

writ Appeal under^{clause 15 cjt the Letters Patent Appeal preferred againstthe} order dt. o2.i2.2}Og^{in w.P.No.1 026 of 2007 on the fileof the Highcourt -}

¶627

Between:

¶628

DistanceEducationCouncil,,lndiraGandhiNationalOpenUniversity,K-l8'Hauz Khas, Maidan^{Garhi,New Delhi- 1 10 008.}

¶629

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^NO.s -

¶630

AND

¶631

A.P. State^{Counselof Higher Education, Opp: lr,'lahaveerHospital, Masab Tank,} Hyderabad Represented^{by its Secretary.} -

¶632

The Registrar,^{JawaharlalNehruTechnological University,, Kukatpally,} Hyderabad. /-

¶633

3ns<

¶634

ThePrincipal, DRK lnstitute of Science^{& Technology, Bowerampet,(Via)Air} Force Academy, Hyderabad. .

¶635

The University Grants Commission, Bahadur ShahZalat^{Ma'g, New Delhi} 110002 Represented by its Registrar.^,z

¶636

..,.RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶637

5, V.Satish Kothapalli, S/o.K.Bangara^{Raju(Late), Presently residing at Plot No.49,} H.No.4-35-22, Madhava Rao Nagar Colony,^{Kukatpally, Hyderabad.} ,,

¶638

(R3 not necessary this WA)^/

¶639

... RES PON OENT/ryvRIT PETITIONER ..

¶640

A[4P. NO: 1401 OF 2010

¶641

Petition under Seclron 151 CPC^{praying that in} the^{circumstances stated in} the aff davit liled in support of^{the petilion,the High Court may be pleased suspend} the operation of the Judgmenl dated^{2-12-2009 made in W.P.No1026 ol 2007} ' pending disposalof the above Writ Appeal.,-

¶642

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYADEVI} '-

¶643

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: GP FORHIGHER EDUCATION} --

¶644

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2: SRI.V.RAMCHANDER GOUD, SC FORJNTU ,-}

¶645

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No.4:SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} -

¶646

counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl.K SAWANARAYANAMURTHY}

¶647

WA NO: 57 8 0F 2010

¶648

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the LettersPatentAppeal against the Judgement} passed in WP No. 34 ol 2oo7 dt 02'12'2009^{passed by theLearnedsingle Judge forthe} following among other on the^{file of the High Court.,-}

¶649

Between:

¶650

The lndira Gandhi National Open^{University'rep by its, Director,l\ilaidan} Garhi,New Delhi-1 10068^,-

¶651

Distance Education^{Councilrep.by its Director,lndira Gandhi NationalOpen} University^{premisesl,4aidanGarh} ,New^Delhi-110068

¶652

.,.APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS^NO.3&4 --

¶653

,2/

¶654

AND

¶655

TheAndhra Pradesh State^{Council of HigherEducation, Rep.by its Secretary} [,4ahavir Hospital Masab Tank^{Hyderabad-500028"-}

¶656

Andhra Pradesh, rep.by its Registrar^{Visakhapalnarn} ,-

¶657

University Grants Commission^{Rep.by its Secretary, Bahadur ShahZalar\ltarg} New Delhi,110002 rep.by its Secretary ,

¶658

DNR College PG Course Rep.by^{its Pr ncpal,B heemavara m,West Godavari} District ,_-

¶659

Viswa Bhrathi University^{Deemed University,Rep,byits} Registrar. RajpLr Chattisga rl' _-

¶660

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS^.-

¶661

P.N V.S Suresh, S/o^{NagabhushnamNaiduKaikaram,Polla(i.4)West Godavari} District //

¶662

(RR 4 & 5 are not necessary.)^/"

¶663

... RESPO N DE NT/WRIT PETITIONER

¶664

WAMP. NO: 't402 0^{F 2010}

¶665

Petition under Section^'151 CPC^{praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support^{of the petition, the HighCourt maybe pleased suspend} the operation of the^{Judgment daled 2-12-2009 made in WPNo.34of 2007,pending} disposal of the above WA .,

¶666

Counsel for the Appellants:SMT.^{A CHAYADEYI} "

¶667

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: SRl.C. SUDESH ANAND, SC FORAPSCHE} --

¶668

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2: SRl.M V RAJA RAAM --}

¶669

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶670

Counsel for the Respondent^{No, 6: SRl.S NIRANJAN REDDY, SC FORUCIL}

¶671

WA NO: 580 F 010

¶672

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the LettersPatentAppeal against the Judgement} passed in WP No 8472 of 2008 dt A2-12'2009^{on thefi e of theHigh CouL .-}

¶673

3. sa

¶674

Between:

¶675

The Distance Education and lnidra Gandhi National^{Open University, rep.by its} Registrar,Hyderabad. /

¶676

(lmpleaded as per Court order dated 05-03-2009.) 7

¶677

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO' 4 "

¶678

AND

¶679

The Registrar, Kakatiy University, Vidyaranaypuri^{Warangal'506009AP} -

¶680

The Principal, Vagdevi Degree &^{P.GCollege, Ramnagar,Hanumakonda,} Warangal Dist ,.

¶681

The University Grant Commission,^{rep.by its Registrar New Delhi ..-}

¶682

(Note: Respondent NO. 3 impleaded as epr Court Order dated 05/03/2009.) -

¶683

, . .. RES PONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶684

Firdos Afreen, D/o.lVld.Ahmed Vajoodi,6-2-100^{KaKji Colony} Hanumakonda,Wa ra nga I Districl ,_

¶685

(R2 is not necessary in th s apPeal.l -

¶686

RESPONDENT/wRIT^PETITIONER

¶687

WAMP. NO: 1404 0F 2010

¶688

Petition under Sectlon^{151 CPC prayingthat in the circumstances stated in the} affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the^{High Court may be pleased suspend the} operation o{ the Judgment^{daled2-12-2OOgmade in WP No8472 of 2008,pending} disposal of the above WA/

¶689

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYA} DEVI ,'-

¶690

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos.1 & 3: SRI' DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} --

¶691

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRI.T. KOTESHWARA PRASAD}

¶692

L>i6

¶693

WA NO: 583 OF 2010

¶694

Writ Appeal under clause 1 5 of the Letters Patent against the order dated 02-122009 in WP No.2255912007 on the file of the High Court.

¶695

Between:

¶696

Distance Education Council, Rep. by lts Registrar, lndira Gandhi National Open University, K78, Hauz Khas, l\y'aidan Garhi, New Dehl -1 10 068.

¶697

..APPELLANTS/RESPONDENT NO. 4 /..

¶698

AND

¶699

1, The Government of lndia, rep. by its Secretary,, IVinistry of Human Resources Development, Department of Secondary and Higher Education, Sastry Bhavan, New Delhi. ,,,

¶700

The Secretary/Registrar, University Grants Commission,, Bahadursha Zafar Marg, New Delhi - 110002. a

¶701

Vinayaka lvlission Research Foundation, Deemed, University, Sankari l,4ain Road (NH-47) Ariyanoor, Salem, Tamil Nadu, lndia. -

¶702

The Acharya Nagarjuna University,, Nagarjuna Nagar, Guntur, Rep. by its RegistrarT

¶703

The Secretary, A.P. State Council of Higher Education,, Opp: l/ahavir Hospitai, l,4ahavir l,4arg, Masab Tank, Hyderabad. .

¶704

The Principal, Adarsa College of Education,, Giddalur,^Prakasam Distrlct .--'

¶705

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶706

Pagidala Jaya Swathi,, D/o. P. Rama lvlohan Rao,^{R/o. TurimallaPost, Cumbum} l,4andal, Prakasam District. -

¶707

Patti Rajani Radhika Swapna Pandu,^{D/o. P. Pandu, FJo. TurimallaPost,} Cumbum Mandal, Prakasam District. ,-

¶708

(R6 not necessary in this WA.)-

¶709

... RESPON DE NTS,ryVRIT PETITIONERS -,

¶710

WAMP. NOr 1407 OF 2010

¶711

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the c rcumstances statedⁱⁿ the affidavit f iled in support of the^petition, the High Coufi may be^{pleased suspend} - the operation of the common^judgment dated^{O2-12-2OOSmade in W.P.No.} f2529 t of 2OO7^pending disposal of the above^Writ Appeal - -!r (1:4 l "'-r t I ?- I

¶712

¶713

Counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYA} DEVI '/

¶714

counsel for the Respondent^No. 1:SRl.^{N RAJESHWAR RAO, ASST SOLICITOR} GENERAL -

¶715

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 2: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE,/}

¶716

Counsel for the Respondent^No. 3:^{SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY -"}

¶717

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRl.P HARTNATHGUPTA-"}

¶718

Counsel for the Respondent^No. 5:^{SRl. c SUDESH ANAND,Sc FOR APSCHE"--}

¶719

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos' 7 & 8: SRl.S A K MYNUDDIN} ''/

¶720

WA NO: 584 oF 2010

¶721

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the Letters Patent appeal against the judgement} passed in WP No. 48 of 2007, dt. A212-2009^{on thefile of theHigh Court} -.

¶722

Between:

¶723

lndira Gandhi^{National Open University, Rep by its Director, l\4aindan Garhi, New} Delhi -^'1 10 068. -

¶724

Distance Education^{Council, Repby its Director, Indira Gandhi NationalOpen} University, l\laidan Gardhi,^{New Delhi- 1 10 068} -

¶725

..,APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS^{NO.3 & 4} --

¶726

AND

¶727

Andhra Pradesh State^{Councilfor Higher Education, Represented by its} Secretary, lVahavir^{Marg, lrlasab Tank, Hyderabad-500 028.} -"

¶728

Osmania University,^{representedby lts Registrar, Hyderabad} -

¶729

University Grants^{Commisslon,Rep by its Secretary, Bahadur Shah Zafar Marg,} New Delhi-1 10 0002. -

¶730

Church P.G. College,^{Rep byits Principal, Gagillapur Villge, Quthbullapur} I,'landal. ,?.R.R. District.

¶731

Vinavaka lr/issions Research^{Foundation Deemed, University Rep byits} Regi'strar, Salem, Tamilnadu. ,-

¶732

B. Rakesh Kumar, s/o.^{B. Ramesh,R/o.H.No.5-3-181, Shanthinagar,} Kukatpally, Hydetabad. /-

¶733

( Lort. /^,".(9 ?c rKqvrla P& a*q) \ ,-Vtp,aw

¶734

01 ,t{

¶735

P NO: 1408 O

¶736

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying thatⁱⁿ the^{circumstances stated in} the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the^{HighCourt may be pleased suspend} the operation of the common^judgment dated^{02-12-2009made in WPNo.48 of} 2007^pending disposal of the above writ appeal -

¶737

Counsel for the Appellants:SMT.^{A CHAYA} DEVI ,-

¶738

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No. 1:SRl.C SUDESHANAND, SC FORAPSCHE} .-

¶739

Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.2 &^{3: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} .--

¶740

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl.S SRINIVASREDDY} -/'

¶741

Counsel forthe Respondent No.6:^{SRl.P PANDU RANGAREDDY---}

¶742

WA NO: 5 oF 2010

¶743

Writ Appeal under clause^'15 of the^{Letters Patentfiled againstthe orderdated} 2.12.2009 and made in wP.No.364B^of 2007 onthefileof^theHighcoun.

¶744

Between:

¶745

Distance Education Council, rep.by its^{Registrar,lndira GandhiNationalOpen} University, K78, Huaz Khas,l.4aidan^{Garhi,New Delhi-110068} .-

¶746

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. s -

¶747

AND

¶748

The Andhra Pradesh State^{Councilof HigherEducation, Opp: l,4ahavirHospital,} l,4asabtank Hyderabad rep^{by Secretary.} ,-

¶749

Convenor Ed. CET-2006 conducted^{by Sri VenkateshwaraUniversity,Tirupati-} 517 502. ,-

¶750

Vinayaka lvlission's Research^{Foundation Deemed University, Sankari Main} Road( NH-47), Ariyanoor^{SalemTamilnadu- 636 308.}

¶751

¶752

748

¶753

The University Grants^{Connmlssion,rep by its Registrar, Bahadursha Zafar'} l,4arq, New Delhi-1^'10-002

¶754

,,,,RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶755

G.Bhavsingh,^{S/o.Ramja R/o.Tekula thanda village PendjaramaduguPost,} Kamepally [,4andal^{Khammam District} -

¶756

Vankudoth^{Hathiram, S/o.Harisingh R/o.Bagyanagar} 'Thanda^{village & Post} Yellandu Singareni^{l,4andal,KhammamDislrict} -

¶757

Guquloth Sakram, S/o.Pulya^{R/o H No 1-8-111,KakatiyanagarYellandu} Sin6areni^{rMandalKhammamDistrict -'-}

¶758

lr,4.Ramulu,^{S/o.lr,4.HarryaR/o.Jayanthipuram ,Jaggaiahpetl\4andalKrishna}

¶759

District -..

¶760

...RESPONDENTSM/RIT PETITIONERS .'

¶761

WAMP . NO: 1409^{OF 2010}

¶762

PetitionunderSectionl5lcPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin the affidavit filed^{in supportof the petition,the High Court may be pleasedto-} .r.p"nJ the operation^{oi the} ludgment^{daled2.12.2009 made in WP'No'3648of} 2OO7^pending disposal^{of the above Writ Appeal}

¶763

Counsel for the^{Appellant:SMT' A CHAYADEVI} ,-

¶764

Counsel for the^{Respondent No'1: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE ,-}

¶765

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 2: SRl. KASAJAGANMOHAN REDDY} --

¶766

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 3: SRI. S SRINIVASAREDDY'-}

¶767

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 4: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶768

Counsel for the^{RespondentNos.5 to 8: SRl. NAMAVARAPU RAJESWARARAO}

¶769

A NO: 586 OF 2010

¶770

Writ Appeal under^{clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal against the Judgment} passedinWP'No21987of2008dt02-12-2oogpassedbytheLearnedsingleJudgeon the file of the^HighCourl. ,-

¶771

b^ , ,x

¶772

Between:

¶773

Distance Eudacation Council^{rep.by its Director IGNOU, [,4aidanGarh,NewDelhi-} 't 10068

¶774

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO. 4

¶775

AND

¶776

Govt of lndia Rep.by^{its Secretary l\4inistryof Human, Resource Development} Department of S'econdary & Higher^{Education,Sastry Bhavan,New Delhi} ,-

¶777

The SecretaryXegistrar University^{Grants Commission, Bahadursha,Zafar} t\4arg,New Ddlhi ,,

¶778

\ 3. Vinayala lvlission's^{Research Foundation, Deemed University N H 4T,Sankari} N,4ain Road, Ariyanor,Salem,^{Tamilnad u-636308 Rep.by Registrar}

¶779

The Osmania University Hyderabad,^{rep.by its Registrar} .,

¶780

The A.P State Council^{of Higher Education, Opp.l\4ahavirHospital l\4ahavit lVarg} l\4asab Tank,Hyderabad Rep.by^{its Secretary} ,-

¶781

The Principal Sana College^{of Education, Kodad,NalgondaDist} "

¶782

,. ,, RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS^"-

¶783

Sultana Begum, D/o. Naeeroddin,^{Kodad,NalgondaD stt} '

¶784

l\4d lVyjabeen, D/0.^{Md AzizAli, Kodad,NalgondaDlstf-}

¶785

L i\4ahamad Arath^{Parveen,, D/o.Naimuddin Kodad,NalgondaDist} '-

¶786

l0,Raheemunnisa^Begum, Dlo.Miza^{Karemulla BaigKodad,NalgondaDist} -

¶787

1^'1 . Dhiravath Saidulu,^{S/o,Hatcha, Kodad,NalgondaDist} -/

¶788

(R6 not necessary in this WA) --

¶789

...RESPONDENTSMRIT PETITIONERS L--

¶790

WAMP. NO: 410 0F 2010

¶791

Petition under Section¹⁵¹ CPC^{praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support^{of the petition, the HighCourt may be pleased suspend} the operation of the Judgment^{daled2-12-2009 made in WP No,21987of} 2008,pending disposal^{of the above WA} .-

¶792

Counsel forthe Appellant:SRl.^{A CHAYA OEVI} "'

¶793

q! 2r

¶794

Counsel for the Respondent^{No.1:SRI' N' RAJESHWARRAO' ASST' SOLICITOR} GENERAL

¶795

,,,

¶796

Counsel for the^{RespondentNos.2 & 4: SRl. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE .-}

¶797

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: SRI' S SRINIVAS REDDY}

¶798

Counsel for the Respondent^{No, 5: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND' SC FORAPSCHE}

¶799

Counsel for the^{RespondentNos.7 to 11:4029iS A K MYNUDDIN} ..'

¶800

WRIT APPEAL NO: 588 OF 2010

¶801

Writ Appeal under clause¹⁵ of^{the Letters PatentAppeal preferred againstthe} orderdated 2.12.20A9^{passed ln WP.No.27008 of 2006 onthefileofthe HighCourt'.}

¶802

Between:

¶803

lndira Gandhi^{National Open University, rep by its,Director, New Delhi} '-

¶804

The Distance^{Education Council, Indira Gandhi National Open University, K-18'} l,4aidan Garhi, New Delhi-1 10068 /-

¶805

(lmpleaded as per Court Order dated^{11-04-2008 in WPMPNo 10610of2008 )}

¶806

.,.APPELLANTS/RESPONDENT^{NO. 5 & 6}

¶807

AND

¶808

1 , The Andhra^{Pradesh State Council of Higher Education,, Rep. by its Secretary,} lvlahavir tr/arg, Masabtank,^{Hyderabad-500 008.'-}

¶809

The Principal, Vishwabharathi^{PG College of Engineering and L4anagement'} - nffitiateA tir Osmania University, Nizampet Road, Kukatpally, Hyderabad' .-

¶810

Osmania University,^{Rep. by its Registrar' O.U. Campus, Hyderabad-500 007} --

¶811

lnstitute of Advance Studies^{in Education Deemed, University, rep. by Registrar'} Sardar Shaster, Rajasthan.^,-

¶812

The University Grants^{Commission,Rep by its Secretary, Bahadurshah Zafar} [,4arg, New Delhi,^{1 10} 002.,_r^rry"d,,.t] I^Wrh"/-tt,

¶813

(Note: 3 to 5 impleaded as^per Court Order dated^{1110412008 inWP[/PN01060} of 2008) /'

¶814

Kanagala Swapnika,^{D/o.K.V. Rathna PrasadVishwabharathiPG--Collgeof} Enginlering and l\lanagement,^{R/o. LIG,Plot No.75,2ndRoad, KPHB'} Hyderabad. .--

¶815

...RESPONDENT/vvRIT PETITIONER I

¶816

¶817

u,, *

¶818

WAMP. No: 1412 OF 2010

¶819

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that^{in the circun'rstancesstatedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^{petition,the HlghCourt may be pleasedto} suspend the operation of the^{judgment daled 2.12.2009 made ln WP.No.27008ol} 2006,^pending disposal of the above Writ Appeal . ,-

¶820

Counsel for the Appellants:SMT. A CHAYA DEVI ...

¶821

Counsel for the Respondent No.^'1: SRl. C SUDESH^{ANAND, SC FORAPSCHE} ...

¶822

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 3 & 5: SRl. DEEPAK^{BHATTACHARJEE} ./

¶823

Counsel for the Respondent No.^4: SRl.^{S SRI} RAM^'-

¶824

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: SRl.^{P PANDU RANGAREDDY}

¶825

WA NO: 589 OF 2010

¶826

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters^{Patentagainst the atdet dt.2-12-2049} in WP No. 20636 of 2008 on the file of the High^Court. ./

¶827

Between:

¶828

District Education Council, Rep. by^{its Director IGNOU, Maidan Garh NewDelhi} -

¶829

,,.APPELLANT/RESPONDENT NO, 4 -.

¶830

AND

¶831

I The Osmania University, Hyderabad, Rep.^{by its} Registrar -

¶832

2 The A.P.State Council of^{HigherEducation, Opp. l.4ahavirHospital, lvlahavir} Marg, tt4asab Tank Hyderabad, Rep.^{by its} Secretary ,-

¶833

3 Vinavaka Mission's Research^{Foundation, Deemed University,N.H47, Sankari} N,'lain Road Ariyanoor. Salem, Tamilnadu,^{Rep. by it Registrar} -

¶834

4 The Principal , Nagarjuna College^{of Education, Rajampet Road, Sanga Reddy,} Medak District. -

¶835

5 The Principal , St. Thomas College^{of Teacher Education, Gadwal,} .- I\4 a h a boo bna^ga r Di strict.

¶836

6 The Principal, Aurora's School Educatron,^{Near Railway Station, Bhongir,} Nalgonda District. ..

¶837

t*1'2 tl

¶838

The Principal lvlallreddy^{B.Ed College, Suraram X Roads' Qutubullapur tt/andal'} Ranga Reddy District. /,

¶839

.....RESPONDENT/RESPONDENTS

¶840

Arroiu Satvanaravana,^{R/o Rama Swamy C/o. R. SatyanarayanaH No' 7-3-85'} Mankamm'a Thotl.^{Karimnagar Karimnagar District.} -

¶841

K. Bhaskar, S/o^{Adenna R/o H.,No3-1-37, Gadwal, RajaVeedhi} N.4ahaboobnagar District.

¶842

¶843

l,4. Satyanarayana, S/o Laxmaiah^{R/o lvlahadevuniGudem Village, Kothagudem} li,4anda l, Warangal District. 7

¶844

B. Shanthi KUmar, S/o^{Ramaiah R/o H.No. 1-12-21L,Jambi Kunta, IriledakTown,} Nledak District. /

¶845

(RR 5 to 7 are not necessary^parties in WA)^/

¶846

... RESPOND^E NTSrVVRIT^{PETITIONERS ,/}

¶847

WAMP . NO: 1413 O F²⁰¹⁰

¶848

Petition under Section^'151 CPC^{praying thalin the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support^{of the petition,the HighCourt may be pleased to} suspend the operation of^{the Judgment dt. 2-12-2009made in WP No 20636 of} 2O0B^pending disposal^{of the abovewrit Appeal.} ,

¶849

Counsel for the Appellant:^{SMT'A CHAYADEVI}

¶850

¶851

counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 1: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶852

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No. 2: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FORAPSCHE}

¶853

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: SRl.S. SRINIVASA REDDY,'-}

¶854

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRI'G JAGADEESWAR} --

¶855

Counsel for the Respondent^Nos. I^{to ',t1: SRl. CHANDRAIAH SUNKARA}

¶856

WA NO: 59 F 2010

¶857

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of^{the Letters Patentagainst the otdetdt. 2-12-2009} in WP No. 3614 of 2007^{on thefile of theHighCourt} .-

Between:

Distance Education Council,^{Rep.by its Secretarylndira Gandhi NationalOpen} University K78, Hauz^{Khas, Maidan Garhi, NewDelhi-110 068} -

¶863

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^NO. 5 ---

¶864

AND

¶865

The Andhra Pradesh^{State councilfor Higher Education, Opp:N'4ahavirHospital,} lvlahavir l,4argh, lMasab^{Tank Hyderabad,rep by its Secretary} --

¶866

The Principal, C.S.l.R.D.lnstitute^{of l\4anagement and,Technology, Ananthapur} District Affiliated^{to SKU University} .,

¶867

The Registrar, Sri^{Krishna Devaraya University,Ananthapur} -

¶868

The University^{Grants Commission,Rep by its Registrar, Bahadur ShahZafar}

¶869

[,4arg, New Delhi-^{1 10} 002. ",

¶870

The Vinayaka^{Mission's Research Foundation Deemed, University, SankariIVlain} Road^(NH-47) Ariyanoor,^{Salem,TamilNadu-636308} ---

¶871

.,.RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS,,

¶872

6 V.C. Raiesh. S/o V.C.^{Bangarappa CSl, RD lnstitute of Managen ent&} Technotogy Gooty,^{Anantapur Dlstrict,RJo D No l-3-497.Rangaswa minagar'} Vth Road, Ananlaput, /'

¶873

., RESPONDENT/VVRIT^PETITIONER "--

¶874

WAMP. 1414 0 0

¶875

PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatintheCircumstancesstatedin the affidavit filed in^{support of the petition,the High Court maybe pleasedto} suspend the operation^{of the Judgemenldl. 2-12-2009made in WP No' 3614 of} 2007^pending disposal^{of the aboveWrit Appeal.} .-

¶876

Counsel for the^{Appellant:SMT.A CHAYAoEVl /--}

¶877

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 1: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE} -

¶878

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: SRl. J UGRA NARASIMHA,SC FORSKU} -

¶879

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 4: SRt. OEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE} .-

¶880

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 5: SRl.S SRINIVASREDOY} _

¶881

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 6: SRl. KIRAN PALAKURTHI}

¶882

+\ .*q-

¶883

WA NO: 591 OF 2010

¶884

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters^{Patent filed againstthe orderdated} 2122009 and made in WP.No.2810 of 2007^{and pass on the file of theHighCoufi.} -

¶885

Between:

¶886

The lndira Gandhi National Open University, rep.by its, Director,^Maidan Garhi,New Delhi-1 10068 ,.

¶887

Distance Education Council rep.by its Secretary,^{lndira Gandhi NationalOpen} University^premises [/aidan Garhi, New Delhi-1 10068 ..--

¶888

,..APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS NO. 5 & 6,2

¶889

AND

¶890

The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education,,^{Nampally, Hyderabad,} Rep. by its Secretary. ,.

¶891

The Convener, Ed-Cet 2006, Sri Venkaleswara University^{Tirupathi-517} 502.^..

¶892

Union of lndia, Rep. by its Secretary to the Government^{of lndia, Department of} Secondary & Higher Education, l',4inistry of Human^{Resource Development,} Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi. "-

¶893

4 Universlty Grants Commlssion, Rep by its Secretary,^{Bahadurshah Zalar Marg.} New Delhl, 110 002

¶894

, , ., RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS

¶895

P.l,4adhukar, S/o.Shtivaiah R/o.flat^{No.26,Near Aurobindo College lVlathalaxmi} Nagar, Kothapet, H yderabad-8) a.

¶896

RESPONDENT/WRIT PETITIONER .--

¶897

WAMP. NO: 14'15 OF 2010

¶898

Petition under Sect on 151 CPC^praying that^{in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the^{HighCourt may be pleased to} suspend the operation of the Judgment daled^{2.12.2009made in WP.No.2810of} 2007^pending disposal of the^{aboveWrit Appeal.} --

¶899

Counsel for the Appellants:SMT. A CHAYA DEVI^/-'

¶900

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 1: SRl.C SUDESH ANAND, SC FORAPSCHE} -

¶901

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: SRI.^{KASAJAGANMOHAN REDDY}

¶902

(

¶903

*s ,r{

¶904

Counsel forthe Respondent^{No. 3: SRl.N. RAJESHWAR RAO, ASST' SOLICITOR} GENERAL ,/

¶905

Counsel for the Respondent^{No.4:SRI' DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE-'-}

¶906

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRl. CHANDRAIAH SUNKARA}

¶907

WRIT APPEAL NO: 593^{OF 2010}

¶908

Writ Appeal under clause^{15 of the Letters Patent appeal against the judgement} passed in WP No. 4055 of 2009, dt. 02-12'2009 on the file of^theHigh Courl. --

¶909

Between:

¶910

The Distance Education Council,^{lndira Gandhi National, OpenUniversity} Campus, Maidan Garhi,^{New Delhi- 68 Rep by its Director,-}

¶911

...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT^NO. 5 -.

¶912

AND

¶913

The Osmania University^{OUCampus, Hyderabad Rep by its Director Distance} Education Courses,^{Pr6f. G,Rami Reddy, Bhavan, O U. Hyderabad-7} -

¶914

Vinayaka Missions Research^{Foundation Deemed University, Sankari,t\4ain} Road, NH 47, Ariyanoor,^{SaleemTamilnadu} ,-

¶915

The University Grants^{Commission,, Bahadursha Zafar l,4arg,New Delhi-110} 002, Rep by its Secretary ,,-

¶916

....RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS _--

¶917

G Yadagiri, S/o.^{Late Narsaiah, FJo. H No. 3-2-80, Boigally,Siddipet,Medak}

¶918

District^- 502 103 -

¶919

Kadurla Srihari,^{S/o. Pochaiah LingareddypallyPost andVillage, Siddipet,lvledak} District.

¶920

B. Shanthi Kumar,^{S/o. Ramaiah, Fyo.H.No, 1-12-21L,Jambikunta,l'4edakTown,} Medak District.

¶921

...RESPONDENTS/PETITIONERS

¶922

WAMP. NO: 417 0F 2010

¶923

Petition under Section¹⁵¹ CPC^{praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of^{the petition,the HighCourt may be pleased to} suspend the operation of^{the judgment dated 02-12-2009 made in WP No 4055 of} 2009 pending disposal of the^{abovewrit appeal}

¶924

¶925

counsel for the Appellant:SMT.^{A CHAYA} DEVI^'/

¶926

Counsel forthe Respondent Nos.'l^{& 3: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE}

¶927

Counsel for the Respondent No.^{2: SRl. S. SRINIVAS REDDY}

¶928

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.⁴ to^{6: SRl. CHANDRAIAH SUNKARA--}

¶929

WA NO: 594 oF 2010 ,.-

¶930

Writ Appeal under clause¹⁵ of the^{Letters Patent Appeal being aggrievedby the} Common o"de( dl 02-12-2009^passed in^WP No.^{19753 of 2008and batch for the} following among other on the^{file of theHighCourt,} ,-

¶931

Between:

¶932

Vinayaka l,4ission's Research^Foundation, Deemed^{University,rep, bylts} Regiltrar, Sankari lt4ain Road,^{Ariyanoor, NH 47, Salem, Tamilnadu- 636 308,} Tamil Naidu 7

¶933

...2Nd RESPONDENTiAPPELLANT

¶934

AND

¶935

P.Srilatha, D/o.Narasimha^{Reddy H.No19-15-31 1st Lane,Sangadigunta,Guntur} Guntur District-

¶936

..,.WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT

¶937

University Grants Commission,^{Bahadursha Zafar Marg, New Delhi- 110 002,} Rep. bY its Secretary.-

¶938

The Distance Education^{Council, IndiraGandhi National, Open University, New} Delhi, 1 10068 Rep. by^its Director -

¶939

Acharya Nagarjuna University,^{Nagarjunanagar, Guntur, Rep'by its Registrar} (Controller of Examinations). .--

¶940

The A.P. Stale Council^{of Higher Education, Opp: lvlahavirHospital, MasabTank,} Hyderabad. Rep.^{by its} Secretary. .-

¶941

Andhra Muslim College^{of Education, Ponnuru Road, Guntur Rep. by its} Secretary/Correspondent.

¶942

..,RESPONDENTS 1,^{2, 4, 5 & 6}

¶943

.dtt1

¶944

Zo)o \rtlt lv\0 AJo.^){lf !

¶945

Petition under^{Section151 CPCpraying thatin the circumstances stated in} i" support^{of the pet tion, theHrgrr coun may be pleased suspend} il; ;;;;ii;; tne "riio""liliieJ ;i^i;u "5Lron Judsment a"t'a^{ai-tz-zoagmade in wP No 1e753} ;i ,068 ;;ii^{batch,and all proceedings pursuant theretopending disposalof the} above'N A^r'r'

¶946

Counsel forthe^{AppellantrSRl.S SRINIVAS REDDY} //

¶947

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo 2: SRI DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} /"

¶948

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo 3: SIMT'A CHAYADEVI} ,/

¶949

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo4: SRI' SRINIVASI\4ANTHA /"-}

¶950

Counsel for^{the RespondentNo 5: SRI C SUDESH ANAND'SC FOR APSCHE} Counsel for^{the RespondentNo 1: NoNE APPEARED} -,

¶951

NOr 59 5AF2⁰¹⁰

¶952

WritAoDealunderclause,l5oftheLettersPatentagainsttheordeldal€da2.l2. 2009 in WP No^{1r'22i2oo7 01 lhe fie o'thel'ig" CoLrt /'}

¶953

Between

¶954

vinavaka Missron's^{Research Foundaliro"Dee'neo U,1iversly-Reo.byils} i;;li;: d';;i;;i^il" "^{iioJi, r.;v""oor'N r-J 47,sareem 636 308' ra".rr \adu}

¶955

7TH RESPO^{N DENT/APPELLANT} .-

¶956

AND

¶957

P. Shaheda^{Khanam, D/o.Syed Khan'Fyo Podili' Prakasam District'-}

¶958

....WRIT^{PETITIONEFVRESPONDENT}

¶959

,An.]hr,PradeshstatecouncilforHigherEducation'rep'byitssecretary,Mahavir - ftfarq, MasaU fank. Hyderabad-500028 '-

¶960

Acharya^{Nagarjuna University, rep by itsRegistrar' Nagariunanagar' Guntur} District ,-

¶961

lndira Gandhi^{NationalOpen University'rep by ltsDlrector'MaidanGarhi New} Delhr-110068^lndia ,-

¶962

Dislance^{Educational councll, rep by its Director IGNOUMaidanGarhi'New} DelhF110068 lndia '-

¶963

University Grants Commiss^{jon, BahadurshahZaf at Marc' New Delh -110002,} rep.by its Secretary^/

¶964

7 Shams-UL-Uloom College of^{Education, rep by its Pr nc pal Podl i Prakasarn} D strict /.

¶965

RESPONDENTS I to 6/RESPONDENTS^/-

¶966

N ,t{

¶967

WAMP. NO: 1419 OF 201 0

¶968

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumslances^statedin the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the^{HighCourtmaybe pleased suspend} the operation of lhe common^judgment dated 02-12-2009^{made in W.P.No. 1422 of} 2007 and batch and all^{proceedingspursuant} thereto^{pending disposalof the above} Writ Appeal /.,,

¶969

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY 7

¶970

Gounsel forthe Respondent No. 1: SRl. S NIRANJAN^REDDY/-

¶971

Counsel forthe Respondent No.2: SRl. C SUDESH ANAND, SC^FOR APSCHE^--

¶972

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SRl. P HARINATH GUPI A .,''

¶973

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 4 & 5: SMT. A CHAYA^DEVI ,,'

¶974

Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE^'--

¶975

WA NO: 596 OF 20'10

¶976

Writ Appea under clause 15 of the Letters^{PatentAppeal preferred agajnstthe} order dated 02.12.2aa9^passed in WPNo.'19606 of 2008 on^{thefile of theHigh Court.} --

¶977

Between:

¶978

Vinayaka l,4ission s Research Foundation, Deemed^{University,rep. byits} Regiltrar, Sankari l\4ain Road,^{Ariyanoor, NH-47, Salem 636308, Tamil Nadu.} -

¶979

.....2No RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT

¶980

ANO

¶981

J. Gnaneshwar, S/o. J, Mohan Oc: Student^{R/o. KolurThanda, Tanurl\ilandal,} Adilabad District, /-

¶982

....WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT,.

¶983

Universities Grants Commission, Bahadurshah ,^{Zafat Marc,NewDelhi1 10002} rep.by its Secretary. ,-

¶984

Distance Education Council, lndira Gandhi National Open^University, Ivlaidangarhi, New Delhi 1 10068 rep. by its Director. .-

¶985

uA P<

¶986

The Osmania University,^{rep. by its Registrar(Controller of Examinations)} Hyderabad,

¶987

The Andhra Pradesh State Council^{of HigherEducation, Saifabad,Hyderabad.} rep. by its Secretary /

¶988

lvloghal College of Education,, # 8'5'2118,^{lt4oghalCampus,Near} Chandrayanagutta X Roads, Bandlaguda,^{Hyderabad, rep. by its Secretary/} Correspondent ,,'

¶989

RESPONDENTS 1, 3, 4, 5 & 6/RESPONDENTS

¶990

WAMP. NO: 1420 OF 2010

¶991

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that^{in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^{petition, the High Court may be pleasedsuspend} the operation of the common Judgment^{daled 02.12.2009 madein W.P.No,'19600} of 2008 and batch, and all^{proceedings pursuantthereto, pending disposalof the} above Writ Appeal. .

¶992

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S^{SRINIVASREDDY}

¶993

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl.^{J SRINIVASARAO --}

¶994

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.^{2 &} 4:^{SRt. DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE .-}

¶995

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 3: SMT.A CHAYAOEVI}

¶996

Counsel for the Respondent^No. 5:^{SRl. C SUDESHANAND,SC FOR APSCHE}

¶997

NO 597 0F 10

¶998

Writ Appeal under clause 15^{of the Letters Patent against the Order dt 20636 of} 2OOB in WP No. 2-12-2009^{on the file of the High Coufi.} --

¶999

Between:

¶1000

Vinayaka l,4ission's Research^{Foundation,Deemed Universty,-Rep.. by its} Regi'strar, Sankari l\4ain Road,^{Ariyanoor,N.H 47,Saleern 636 308 TamilNaidu-}

¶1001

...3RO RESPoNDENT/APPELLANT --

¶1002

AND

¶1003

Arroju Satyanarayana,^{S/o. RamaSwamy C/o R. SatyanarayanaH No T-3-85,} A,4ankamma Thota, Karimnagar,^{Karimnagar District. ,-}

¶1004

K. Bhaskar, S/o Adenna^{RyoH.No.3-1-37, Gadwal, Raja Veedhi,} Mahaboobnagar District.

¶1005

,'d<o

¶1006

tvl. Satyanarayana,^{S/o Laxmaiah R/o. l,4ahadevuniGudem Village, Kothagudem} lvla nda l, Warangal^Dlstrict.,2

¶1007

B. Shanthi Kumar, S/o^{RamaiahR/o H.No.1-12'21L, Jambi Kunta' l,4edak} District. /.

¶1008

,,.,WRIT PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS .-.-'

¶1009

The Osmania University,,^{Tarnaka, Hyderabad, Rep. by its Registrar' ,--}

¶1010

6, The A.P. State Council^{of Higher Education,, Nampally, Hyderabad'Repby its} Secretary. /

¶1011

The Distance Education^{Council, lndira Gandhi National Open University} Campus, lr/aidah Garhi,^{New Delhi} '68,^{Rep. byits Registrar} ,,.

¶1012

The Principal, Nagariuna^{College of Education, Rajampet Road,Sanga Reddy,} l,4edak District. /

¶1013

The Principal, St.^{Thomas College of Teacher Education, Gadwal,} It4ahaboobnagarDistrict. .,

¶1014

'10. The Principal, Aurora's School of Education, Near Railway Station, Bhongir, Nalgonda District.,-

¶1015

1'1.The Principal, N,4allareddy^{B.Ed College, Suraram X Roads, Qutubullapur} Mandal, Ranga Reddy District. ,/

¶1016

...RESPONDENTS 1,2,4,5 to^{8/RESPONDENTS} /'-

¶1017

WAMP. N O: 1421 OF²⁰¹⁰

¶1018

Petition under Section^{151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin} the affidavlt filed in^{supportof the petition,the HighCourt maybe pleasedto} suspend the operation of^{the CommonJudgmentdl. 2-12-2005made in WP No} 20636 of 2008 and^{batch and all proceedings pursuant thereto pending disposalof} the a bove writ Appeal.,-

¶1019

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl.^{S SRINIVASREDDYz-}

¶1020

Counsel for the Respondent^{Nos. 1 to 4: SRl. CHANDRAIAHSUNKARA} -

¶1021

Counsel for the Respondent^{No. 5: SRI' DEEPAKBHATTACHARJEE} .--

¶1022

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo. 6: SRIC SUDESH ANAND'SC FORAPSCHE}

¶1023

Counsel for the^{RespondentNo, 7: SMT.A. CHAYADEVI}

¶1024

Counsel for the Respondent^{No, 8: SRl.G JAGADEESWAR}

.g'

WA NO: 598 OF 2010

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the^{Letters PatentAppeal preferred against the} order dated 02j22009^passed in WPNo.4055 of 2009^{on thefile of the High Courl.} ,

¶1029

Between:

¶1030

Vinayaka Mission's Reaserach Foundation, Deemed University, rep. by its Registrar, Sankari lt/ain Road, Ariyanoor,^{NH-47,Salem 636 308,Tamil} Nadu. ,,,

¶1031

...2NDRESPoNDEAPPELLANT --

¶1032

AND

¶1033

G. Yadagiri, S/o. Late Narsaiah R/o. H.No. 3-2-80, Bio Gally, Siddipet, [,4edak District. /

¶1034

Kadurla Srihari, S/o. Pochaiah Lingareddy Pally Post and Village, Siddipet Mandal, Medak District. ,.

¶1035

3, B. Shanthi Kumar, S/o. Ramaiah Fyo.^{H.No. 1-12-2ll,Jambikunta, l'4edak District}

¶1036

WRIT PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS .-

¶1037

The Osmania University, O.U. Campus, Hyderabad,^rep. by^{its Director} of Distance Education Courses, Prof. G. Rami Reddy^{Bhavan, O.U., Hyderabad,} rep, by its Director. ,-

¶1038

Distance Education Council,^lndira Gandhi,^{NationalOpen University,} l/aidangarhi, New Delhi 1 10068 rep. by its Director.

¶1039

Universities Grants Commission, Bahadur Shah, Zafar^{Margh,New Delhi1'10002} rep.by its Secretary. .''

¶1040

...RESPONDENTS 1, 3 & 4/RESPONDENTS _-

¶1041

WAMP. NO :^'1422 OF 2010

¶1042

Petition under Section^'l51 CPC^praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be^pleased to suspend the operation of the common^judgment dated 2,12.2009 madeⁱⁿ WP.No.4055 of 2009 and batch, and all^{proceedjngs pursuant} thereto,^pending disposal of the above Writ Appeal //

¶1043

counsel for the Appellant:sRl. s sRlNlvAS REDDY --.'

¶1044

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 3: SRl. CHANDRAIAH SUNKARA ..'

¶1045

¶1046

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.^{4 & 6: SRl. DEEPAK} BHATTACHARJEE .-

¶1047

counsel for the Respondent No. 5: sMT. A CHAYA DEVI

¶1048

..-

¶1049

WA NO:1342 0'l 6

¶1050

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent^{Appeal preferred againstthe} order dated 02.12.2009^{passed in} WP.No.26888^of 2007^{on the file of theHighCourt.} .-

¶1051

Between:

¶1052

Vinayaka Mission s Reaserach Foundation, Deemed University,^rep. by^its Registrar, Sankari N,4ain Road, Ariyanoor, NH-47, Salem^{636308, Tamil Nadu.__}

¶1053

...RESPONDENT/APPELLANT

¶1054

AND

¶1055

J, Anandam, S/o. Chandraiah R/o,^{Pothgal village, Mustabad lt4andal,} Karimnagar District.

¶1056

A. Krishna, S/o. Balaiah RJo. H.No.^{12-2-161,Mohinpura street, Siddipet, Medak} District. ../

¶1057

M. Kavitha, W/o.^{B. KrishnamurthyFyo. H.No. 11-1-59/16/1, Near MLA's House,} Shivaji Nagar, Siddipet,^lvledak District. ,_

¶1058

L4d. Alimoddin, S/o. Jani Rl/o. Mirdoddy Post, Mordoody^{Mandal, Medak Dishict.} .WRIT PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS -'

¶1059

The Osmania University,^{rep.by its Registrar, Hyderabad.} '

¶1060

lslamia College of Education,^{Siddipet, Medak District, rep. by its Principal} -

¶1061

The Andhra Pradesh State Council^{of Higher Education, rep.by its Secretary,} [,4ahavir [,4arg, Masab Tank, Hyderabad-500008.^/

¶1062

RESPONDENTS

¶1063

WAMP. NO: 695 OF 2010

¶1064

Petition under Section^'1 51 CPC^praying that^{in the circumstances statedin} the affidavit filed in support of the^{petition,the HighCourt may be pleasedto} dispense with filing of the^{certified copyof the order in the abovewritpetitionNo.} 2688812007dt.02.12.2009^/'

¶1065

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS^REDDY

¶1066

9\ a*'

¶1067

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 to 4: SRl. CHANDRAIAH SUNKARA ,--

¶1068

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE ,.-.Counsel for the Respondent No. 7: SRl. C SUDESH ANANO. SC FOR APSCHE Counsel for the Respondent No. 6: NONE APPEARED^/' ,..

¶1069

WA NO: 1345 OF 2016 ./

¶1070

Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent appeal being aggrieved by the Common order dated 02-12-2009^passed in WPNo. 5167 of 2009 on the flle of the High Co u rt. ,.

¶1071

Between:

¶1072

Vinayaka I,4ission's Research Foundation Deemed University, Rep by its Registrar, Sankari l,4ain Roa, Ariyanoor, N.H. 47 Salem 636 308, Tamil Nadu

¶1073

...4thRESPoNDENT/APPELLANT^.-

¶1074

ANO

¶1075

1, P. Vijaya Raju, S/o. Venkata Vilaya Gopala Raju, Vizianagaram, Vizianagaram Dlstrict. /'

¶1076

....WRIT PETITIONER/RESPONDENT

¶1077

The Government of Andhra Pradesh, Rep by its Secretary, Higher Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. f

¶1078

The A.P. State Council for Higher Education, Bep by^its Secretary, Mahavir

¶1079

Marg, Masab Tank. Hyderabad - 500 008^.-

¶1080

The Secretary/Correspondent, Sri Kolla Appala Naidu College of Education, Sarada Nagar, Gajapathi Nagaram, Vizianagaram district .-

¶1081

University Grants Commission,, Bahadurshah Zafat Marc, New Delhi^- 110 002, Rep by its Secretary

¶1082

lndira Gandhi Natiooal Open University,, Maidangarhi, New Delhi - 1'10 068 Rep by its Registrar

¶1083

RESPONDENTS 1, 2, 3, 5 & 6/RESPONDENTS

¶1084

WAMP. NO: 2873 OF 2016

¶1085

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be^pleased suspend

¶1086

the operation^{of thecommonjudgment dl. 02 12 2AOgmade in WP'No 5167 of} 2009 and batch and^att froceeOl"ngs^{pursuant lhereoto pending disposalof the} above writ aPPeal. -'

¶1087

¶1088

{t /(

¶1089

Counsel for the Appellant:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY^-'-

¶1090

Counset forthe Respondent No. 1: SRl. KSURYANARAYANA^"'

¶1091

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 2 & 3:GP FOR EDUCATION (AP),'-

¶1092

Counsel for the Respondent No. 5: SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEE

¶1093

Counsel forthe Respondent No.6: SMT. A. CHAYADEVI ,'

¶1094

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4: NONE APPEARED "-

¶1095

WP NO: 8206 OF 2009

¶1096

Between:

¶1097

Vinayaka N/issions University, (A University under Sec. 3 of the U.G.C. Act) Rep by its Registrar, Sankari Main Road, N.H.47, Ariyanoor, Salem^- 636,908

¶1098

...PETITIONER ,z---

¶1099

AND

¶1100

The Andhra Pradesh State Council for Higher Education, Rep by its SEcretary/Registrar, Hyderabad. -

¶1101

The State of Andhra Pradesh, Rep by its Secretary, Higher Education Department, SecretariatBuildings, Hyderabad. -

¶1102

The Distance Education Council, Rep by its Director^- D.E.C.^{(IGNOU),l/aidan} Gurhi, New Delhi - 1 10 068. ,-

¶1103

The University Grants Commission, Rep by its Secretary,^{Bahadursha Zafar} marg, New Delhi^{- 'l} 10 002 ,-

¶1104

The Union of lndia, Rep by its Secretary,^{Ministryof humarn Resources} Development, Department of Secondary &^{Higher Educatuion,Sastry Bhavan,} New Delhi - 110 001 ..'

¶1105

...RESPONDENTS

¶1106

Petition under Anide 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that High Court I in the circumstances stated in the affidavit nf "J ifr"r"itf,,^-ihe may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus. declarino the. actioi of the 1st respondent jn addressing ,rritt"n "orrini""if"". ,f ii,X various Departments of the 2nd respondent tJthe effect that ihe degrees and certificates issued by Deemed Universities under oiii"n."' education made are invalid and that the Deemed Universities can only off Oi.irna" education on On-campus Sites, in spite of the 3rO and +h ,Lsponaents granting approval to the distance educa on programs offered by the petitioners, as

¶1107

¶1108

s7 .a2

¶1109

arbitrary, illegal, unjust, withut jurisdiction, violative of Article^'14 of the Constittuion of lndia, contrary to the provisions of the University Grants Commission Act and the Indira Gandhi Open University Act and issue a consequential direction to the^.1st respondent not to indulge in such activities, thereby interfering with the imparting of education through distanced mode, contrary to the provisions of the aforesaid Acts

¶1110

WPMP. NO: 10730 OF 2009

¶1111

Petition under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the 1st respondent not to interfere with the activities of the petitioner in imparting education through Distanc€i Education mode,pending disposal of the above Wnt Pelilion. Z/

¶1112

Counsel for the Petitioner:SRl. S SRINIVAS REDDY ,_-

¶1113

Counsel for the Respondent No. 1: SRl. C SUDESH ANAND, SC FOR APSCHE

¶1114

Counsel for the Respondent No. 2: GP FOR EDUCATION /-

¶1115

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3: SMT. A CHAYA DEVI^-/'

¶1116

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4:SRl. DEEPAK BHATTACHARJEEⁿ

¶1117

counsel for the Respondent No. 5: sRl. N. RAJESHWAR RAO, ASST. SOLICITOR __, GENERAL

¶1118

The Court delivered the following:

¶1119

C C

¶1120

N'BLE c AND THE HON'BLE^SRI CE AND KUMAR SHAVILI

¶1121

NOs.1 8 193 233 239 24 47 25 267 264 4 274 5 30 570 571 574 57 577 7 580 583 584 585 86 58 589,5 90.⁵⁹¹ .593,594^{. 595,596.597,5980F 2010,} AND 1342 AND 134s^{OF 2016} AND WRIT PETITION^{No.82O6 of 2OO9}

¶1122

COMMO N JUDGMENT: /i,tr. H.rt'Lre.jri.,ir-sirre.,:;i.rr,rrr,ii^(r,,r S;rcrriil

¶1123

The issue raiscd^{in all these cascsis o:le rnrl ihc sane and'} ihcrelore, all^{tl'rcse cascs !1:eie he :rrCLoqcihcrand i'Lrerbeing} disposed ol^{b.vr,vay ol this common orCcl '}

¶1124

Heard learned counsel^{tor both parties}

¶1125

For the sake of^{convenience,the facts in W A No 168 oi 20iO} are discussed^hereunder:

¶1126

(a) W.A.No. 168^{of 20 10 is arising out ol the judgmentdated} A2.l2.2AOg rendered^{by the learned SingleJudge in W P'No 994 of} 2007, rvhich^{was disposed ol alongwith W P Nos 22922 ol 2006&} batch.

¶1127

(b) The appellant^{is Vinayaka Mission'sResearch Foundation'} ,,r,hich is a Deemecl University^{Someol these writ appealsare filed} by the Distance^{Education Council, lndira Candhi NationalOpen} University.

¶1128

The grievance^{of the anpelLalt:is r:hat lhe clegrees arvardedb1} lc) t]lem i.e..^{Vina."'elkaMlsslol'r's Rescufcii FottnclaLioll eire not beit.tg} '.Le:ited as valid degrees Challcnging tl'rc:rc'ron^{ol ille respondcnr:s} irr not recogllizing^{the ciegr-ees arllt'ccrll;v /ln:"i'al<l'' 'lissioll's} Research Foundation^{anci ccitllln orherc'ecrcrl} '-lniver-s!tits'^sotrl'- ol rhe students^{lilecl W.P.No 22922 ol 2aa6 ard b::tch beioretl.ris} Court. The^{learnedSingle Judgeof this Court was Pleased to}

¶1129

C] & A\S..r w A \o 168 ol20l0 & harcl

¶1130

dispose ol the said batch of writ petitions uide orders dated

¶1131

02.12,2009 with the following directions:

¶1132

"(a) only such courses imparted by the deemed universities through distance mode, as are approved under the letter jointly signed by the Secretary U.G,C., Member Secretary, A.LC.T.E. and Dilector D.E.C. or by any independent authority under the releva-rrt enactment conferred with the power to grant approva.l prospectively, shall be treated as lega1 and valid; and

¶1133

(b) such of the petitioners who have studied the courses through distance mode from AISE, Rajasthan are not entitied for conferment of degrees, since the examinations were not conducted as per the procedure prescribed by that university. "

¶1134

Counsel lor the appellants had contended that the appellants have obtained information under Righr to lnformation Act, 2005 lrom the Indira Gandhi National Open University (for short'the Open University) and the Open University had clarihed uide letler dated 04.09.2008 rhat the Member Secretary, A.l.C.T.E, Director D,E.C. and Secretary U.G.C have jointly signed and approved the courses offered by Vinayaka Mission's Research Foundation, and in view of the same, the degrees awarded by Vinayaka Mission's Research Foundation are to be held valid, therefore, appropriate orders be passed in this batch of cases clarifying that the degrees awarded by Vinayaka Mission's Research Foundation should be declared as valid by taking into account the letter dated 04,09.2008 issued by the Open University.

¶1135

This Court, having considered the submissions made by Iearned counsel lor the appellants, is ol the considered view that the aforesaid batch ol writ petitions were disposed of making it very clear that only such courses imparted by deemed Universities

¶1136

¶1137

¶1138

HCJ & AKS'J W A.No 168 ol20l0 & barch

¶1139

through distance^{mode, as are approvedunderthe letterjointly} signed by the Secretary^{U.G C., Member Secretary,A I C T E and} Director D.E.C or by any^{independentauthority underthe relevant} enactment conferred with the^{power to grantapproval} prospectively, shall be treated as^{legal and valid. ll the appellants} are claiming that in^{view of the letterdated 04 09.2008 issuedby} the Open University,^{the degreesawardedby them are to be} declared as valid, then^{they must independently file writ petitions} by relying on the letter^{dated04.09 2008 furnished by Open} University under Right to^{InformationAct. Thereis no adverse} {inding recorded against the^{appellants by the learnedSingle} Judge. Therefore, this^{Court is not inclinedto interferewith the} order^passed by the learned^SingleJudge'

¶1140

Accordingly, these writ^{appealsand writpetition are} dismissed. However,^{Iiberty is given to the appellantsto pursue} their independent^{grievancestovalidatetheirdegreesin} accordance with^{the lindrngs recordedin para (a) ol the directions} given by the learned Single^Judge.

¶1141

Pending miscellaneous^{petitions,il any, shall standclosed}

¶1142

¶1143

SD/-M,RAIVANA^{KRIS HNA} * DEPUTY REGISTRAR //TRU E COPY' & SECiION^OFFICER \

¶1144

To,

¶1145

1 . One CC to Sri.^{S Srinivas Reddy,AdvocateIOPUCI'/}

¶1146

One CC^{to Sri.DammalapatiSrinivas,Advocate IOPUC) z} 5. One CC^{to Sri.C.Sudesh Anand,SCforAPSCHEIoPUC]'-}

¶1147

¶1148

1. One CC to Sri. K.^{Ratna Prabhakar,Advocate[OPUC]} " .

¶1149

One CC to Sri.^{Deepak Bhattacharjee, Advocate[OPUC]}

¶1150

One CC^{to Smt. A. Chaya Devi,AdvocateIOPUC] r} 7. One CC to^{Sri.M. Prasada Rao,Advocate[OPUC] r}

¶1151

A. One CC^{to Sri. A. Sanieev Kumar,Advocate [OPU-C]'--} -. ^ S. One CC^{to Sri.A. Rathangapani Reddy'SC for JNTU IOPUC]/-}

¶1152

ib On" CC t"^{Sri. P PanduiangaReddy,AdvocateIOPUCf}

¶1153

i i. one cc^{to Sri.P. Rajeswara Rao,Advocate [oPUC]-}

¶1154

i 2. One CC to Sii.M.V.^{Rama Raam,Advocate} IOPUC] - 13.One CC to Sri,^{Kiran Palakurthi,Advocate} IOPUC]14.One CC to Sri. Y. Ramatirtha,^Advocate [OPUC]^,- 15.One CC to Sri. N. Rajeshwar^{Rao,Asst. Solicitor General} [OPUC] '' 16. One CC to Sri. Kasa Jaganmohan^{Reddy,Advocate} IOPUCI^, 17. 18. One CC one CC to Sri.S.A.K, to M/s. Kommineni l,4ynuddin, Mani Deepika,^Advocate IOPUCI^Advocate -IOPUC]^/ 19.One CC to Sri.P. Harinath^{Gupta,Advocate} [OPUQ] '- 20. One CC to Sri.A.K. Jayaprakash^{Rao, Advocate} IOPUCI^' 21. One CC to Sri.Srinivas^{Manlla,Advocate} IOPUCI " 22.One CC lo Sri. J. Srinlvas Rao,^Advocate IOPUC]^/- 23. One CC to Srl. Ch. Ramesh^{Babu,Advocate} IOPUCI - 24. One CC to Sri. K. Satyanarayana^{I,4urthy, Advocate} IOPUC]^- 25.One CC to Sri.V. Ramchander^{Goud, SC forJNTU} [OPUC] ' 26. One CC to Sri. S. Niranjan^{Reddy,Advocate} [OPUC]^r 27. One CC to Sri. T. Koteshwara^{Prasad,Advocate} IOPUC] - 28.One CC to Sri. P, Pandu Ranga^{Reddy,Advocate} IOPUCI ' 29. One CC to Sri.G. Jagaseeswar,^Advocate [OPUC]^z 30. One CC to Sri.Chandraiah^{Sunkara, Advocate} [OPUC] ' 31 .One CC to Sri.J. Ugra^{Narsimha,SC forSKU} [OPUC]^," 32. One CC to Sri^{S. Nlranjan reddy, Advocate} [OPUC] ,. - 33,One CC to Sri.^{K. Suryanarayana, Advocate} tOPUCI^' 34.Two CCs to GP^for Educal^{on, HlghCourt for the State of Telangana.} IOUTI 35. Two CD Copies. -

PN/

HIGH COURT

DATED:04/0212022

-_-/

-{ 2I^t'4ffi2022

COMMON JUDMGMENT

WRIT APPEAL NOs.168. 193.232. 233,239. 242. 246, 247. 253. 256. 261, 266, 26A. 271, 272. 274, 27a. 245, inn <6a <60 <7al <71 e <ra <r1 <r, 7 1 134s OF 2016 & .No.8206 o 2009

¶1162

DISMISSING THE WAs^{& WPs}

¶1163

Without Gosts.

¶1164

The Registrar/Director ,Indira Gandhi National Open v. The Government of Andhra Pradesh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

The Registrar/Director ,Indira Gandhi National Open v. The Government of Andhra Pradesh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Fernandez Hospital Vs The State Government of Telangana

K. Lalitha Vs The Joint Director

L. Ganesh Vs Nayee Brahmin Co-operative Society

District Education Council Vs The Osmania University

Vinayaka Missions Research Foundation Vs Pagidala Jaya Swathi

Ejjagiri Raju and another Vs The State of Telangana and 14 others