Disposed

Bokka Sree Rama Krishna v. The State of Telangana

Telangana HC26 Aug 2021WP/10648/2019

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Petitioner, an ex-corporal of the Army, filed a writ petition seeking a direction to issue an Ex-Serviceman Identity Card and a CAP Quota Certificate for his daughter for admission under reservation facilities. The court found that respondents had no orders on the application submitted in 2016 and directed them to consider it and pass appropriate orders. Petition disposed without costs.

What did the court decide?

Directed respondents to consider the application submitted on 25.07.2016 and pass appropriate orders within eight weeks.

Bokka Sree Rama Krishna Vs The State of… — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Telangana HC (2021)

¶1

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF^{TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD} (Special Original Jurisdiction)

¶2

THURSDAY. THE TWENTY^{SIXTH DAY OF AUGUST}

¶3

TWO THOUSAND AND^TWENTYONE

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE^{ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI}

¶6

WRIT PETITION^{NO. 10648 0F 2019}

¶7

Between:

¶8

Bokka 5id.''i.i" Sree^-sii Rama^{a.n V.Sjivanaravana, Krishna, ServiceNo.731 Hindu, 194.S, Ex.Corporal, lndian Asgq} -50^vears' .occ^Air ,^Force,Lesal F'rl.titii"Lrr, ruo. )-z-aihatlD,'sharada^{Nagar,-cEcolony, Bagh Amberpet'} Hyderabad-500013. ...'ET'T,ONER

¶9

...'ET'T,ONER

¶10

AND

¶11

1 The State of Telangana,^{Rep by its Principal Secretary,jD^"^q1*'"nt of Higher} Education, Secretariat^{Buildings, Secretariat, Hyderabad - 5ouazz'}

¶12

2 ih;-C;;;,;*;oner,^{retang;ia' Stat"council' for Higher Education(TS.CHE)'} jr.il;nir" ijriioi.],i,'lh rrioil uurr-veer rvrarg, opp.Ma-haveer Hospital - l/asab Tank. Hvderabad-500028.

¶13

J. +fi ;"di;;;;;, is^{Enrr,1ter_201 e, Jawahart-at Nehrurechnolos icar un iversity-} iLrftui^{nvo"ribad,Kukatpallv, Hvderabad-500085, (TS)'}

¶14

1. i;;"*;;-$tite sainit,^{Weir'aid-eo;ro, Rep. bv its Director' somajisuda} HvdeEbad-500482^{TelanganaState.}

¶15

5 it;'liil, s;;It-w"rriiu 6tri&i1zswot,^{Hyderabad District, Teranganastate} srini[ W"iiur" Board.^{Somaiiouda Hvderabaii-500482TelanoanaState}

¶16

6 in! 2rij sJrir, w"rij*^{oir,'"E'.izswoi nansq ceooy Disrridt, relansana state} Surt w"rfai"^{eoarO,Som jlquoi,nyOeraOaO--500482'TelanganaS!?i",.,}

¶17

7 X""O|.ri-Sri" I AoarO.^{ne6]nV its bfficer-in-Charge, West Block-lV, Wing7.} R K PJram, New Delhi^{- 1} "0066

¶18

B if'," Odrn..r^i, University,^{Rep UV its Registrar,Osmania University' Hyderabad-} 500007.

¶19

¶20

The Union The Union Union^{of lndia, Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l lndia, Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l Secretary, lylillgtry.9l lylillgtry.9lD€fence'Government of} "

¶21

The Union The Union Union^{of lndia, Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l lndia, Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l Rep. by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l by its Secretary, lylillgtry.9l Secretary, lylillgtry.9l lylillgtry.9lD€fence'Government of} " f nOla, Souin^{AtoCt<, Cenirat Secretariat, New Delhi-110011'}

¶22

1 0. The Union ot^{tnora,iiep. -uy it.Secretary,} .^{tr,4inistry of Personnel,Publrc} Grrevances anO^{pensions]"Coi6rn*en-tof inOi6.Nortn Biock. Central Secretariat} New Delhi^{- 1 10011.}

¶23

ll.TheDirectorateGeneralResettlement,ZePartmentofEx-servicemen,Ministryof Oeienie, West^{Block-4, RKPuram, New D-elhi} -^{1 10066'}

¶24

tz.Si"reiioiit" oi lir^{vet.ilini,n"p.'nv-it.oirector,Air Ha (sP), First Floor,sMC} Building, Subroto^{Park, New Delhi} -¹¹⁰⁰¹⁰ ..

¶25

13.The officer-in-cnarge'^{Ai;-F-;; RecordOffice, (AFRO)' Subroto Park' New} Delhi - 110010.

¶26

RRBtol3areimp|eadedasperCourtorderdated02.0T.20lginI.A.Nos,2and 3 of2019' "'RESP.NDENTS

¶27

Petition under Article^{226 of the constitutionof lndia prayingthat in the} circumstances stated^{in the affidavitfiled therewith,the High court may be pleased} toissueaWR|T'oRDERoRDlREcTloN'moreparticularlyoneinthenatureof WRlToFIVANDAMUSdeclaringtheinactionoftheRespondents.4toTin consideringtheRepresentations,dated0l.03-2018,12-05-2018,18-05-2019and 21-05-2019 and^{inaction in granting the Ex-serviceman ldentitycardin favour oi the} petitioner and cAP^{(Childrenof Armed Forces Personnel) ouota certificatein favour} ofpetitioner,SdaughterenablingherinavailingthereservationfacilityaSaVailablein Degree admissions^{through Degree Online Services' Telangana(DOST)' 20'1 9' and} in B.Tech./8.E.^{admissionsthroughTSEATUCET(TelanganaState Engineerinq'}

¶28

Agriculture, Medical, Common^{Entrance Test),2019, as illegal, arbitrary, violative of} Articles 14, 15, i6 and 21 of the Constitution of lndiE^{and also violativeof Principles} of Natural Justice, Equity and^{Conscience besidesalso being in violation of Office} Memorandum No.36034/5/85-Estt^(SCT), dated^{14.04.1987, as publishedby the} Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievance and^{Pensions (Departmentof Personnel and} Training), New Delhi, and consequently^direct the^{respondents consider the} Representations, dated 01-03-2018, 12'05-2018,^{1B-05-2019and 21-05-2019for} issuance of Ex-Serviceman ldentity Card in favour of^{the petitionerand Children of} Armed Forces Personnel^(CAP) Quota Certificate in favour of the^petitioner's daughter, enabling her in availing^{reservationfacility as availabre to the childrenof} the Ex-servicemen in admissions for B.Tech/B.E. course through TSEAMCET, 2019 and for admissions in Degree Course through DOST, 2019^{in Telangana State for} which the verification of CAP quota certificate and Ex-Serviceman ldentity Card is scheduled to be conducted on 01-06-2019.

¶29

lA NO:^'l OF 2019

¶30

Petition under Section 151 CPC^praying that in the circumstances statedⁱⁿ the affidavit filed in support of the^petition, the High Court may be^pleased to direct the respondents 1 to 3 in keeping one seat under CAP^quota in favour of the petitioner's daughter in admissions for B.Tech/B.E. course through TSEAMCET, 2019 and for admissions in Degree Course through DOST, 2O19 in Telangana State for which the verification of CAP quota certificate and Ex-Servicriman ldentity Card is scheduled to be conducted on 01-06-2019 and during TSEAN/CET, 2019 counseling as may be scheduled to be held in the month of June, 2019, in the interest of^justice.

¶31

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI B. SREE RAMA KRISHNA, PAFITY lN PERSON

¶32

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 & 2: GP FOR HIGHER EDLICATION

¶33

Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI V. RAMCHANDER GOUD,

¶34

S.C. FOR J.N.T.L

¶35

Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 4 to 6: GP FOR WELFARE

¶36

Counsel for the Respondent Nos.7, I to^'13:

¶37

SRI NAMAVARAPU RA.JESHWAR RAO, ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL

¶38

Counsel for the Respondent No.8: SRI CH. JAG,ANNATHA RA.O,

¶39

S.C. FOR OSMANIA UNIVERSITY

¶40

The Court made the following: ORDER

¶41

IHE HON BI,E SRI JUSIICE AEHINAND KUMAR SHAVItI WR II PETI I'ON N o. I 064 ot2 019

¶42

ORDER;

¶43

This writ petttion is filed seeking ihe following relief :_

¶44

,,....... to issue a **'''

¶45

oRDER oR DIRECTION more particu(arty one jn the nu,

¶46

rhe inaction o,,n" o",olll""llT7i'#::"ni.:;: Representarions dated 0i.03.2018, 12.05.2018, 18.05.20i9 and

¶47

21 .05.2019 and inaction in Card in ravour or the petitsi:::::1ff ffiill,iil:: Forces personnet) Quota certificate in favour of petitioner,s daughter enabting her in avaiting the reservation facitity as availabte in Degree admissions through Degree Ontine Services Tetangana (DOST), 2Oi9 and in B.Tech./8.E. admissions through TSEAMCET (Tetangana State Engineerjng Agriculture Medicat Common Entrance Test) 20.19 as ittegal, arbitrary, violatjve of Artictes 14, 15, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia and atso violatjve of principtes of NaturaI Justice, Equtty and Conscience

¶48

besjdes atso being in viotatjon of Offjce Memorandum tio. 36034/5/85-Estt (SCT) dated 14.A4.1987 as pubtished by the Mlnistry of Personnel pub[c Grievance and penslons {Department of Personnei and Training), New Dethi, and consequently direct the respondents to consjder the Representatjons dated 01.03.2018, 12.05.2018, 18. 05.2019 and 21.05.2019 for issuance of Ex-Servjceman ldentjty Card jn favour of the petitioner and Chitdren of Armed Forces personnet (CAp) euota Certificate jn favour of the petitioner,s daughter enabting her in avaiting reservation facility as avajtab{e to the chiidren of the ExServrcemen in admissions for B.Tech/B.E. course through TSEAMCET, 2019 and for artmissions in Degree Course through DOST, 2019 in Tetangana State for which the verification of CAp quota certificate and Ex-Serviceman ldentity Card is scheduted to be conducted on 01.06.2019.......,,. Heord Sri B.Sree Romo Krishno, porty-in-person ond the eorned Assisiont Soliciior Generol of lndio oppeoring for the respondents

¶49

¶50

¶51

, i,.s cee' corrlended^{by ihe petiiionerii(rt he 1s on} Er-Cotolrroj^{l.c orr Air Forcet'l e hos submiilecl on ':p'plicotionfor} rssronce^{of ex-servi':en-'orr rdent ty cord cn 25 C7 2A't 5'}

¶52

.f he grrevcnce ct the petrlioner is^{ihol lho} 'rgh^{ne hos} submrlted^{on opplrcolion on 25'O7 20l6' the respond€'nts hove not} possed ony^{orderson the soid opplicotionTherefore'oppropriote} orders be^{possed in the wrrt petition direciingthe respondents to} consider^{his opplicotionsubmittedon25 A7 2016 ondposs} oppropriole^{orders in occordoncewilh low'}

¶53

Leorned^{Assistoni SolicitorGenerol of lndio oppeoringfor the} responcJents^{hod contended thol since the petitione-'s opplicotion} s perd ng^{with the respondents, the respondents u'ould consider} l' e 5cr.l'e irt cl r,crss iloprcpl cie^{orders rr occordo"€} "vilh^low'

¶54

irrl: Ccu' i r(lv rlcr corls^{cierec.i the t vcl s!brr I 5: lcns lrodeby} irru p-,.'1es, s,tl ln,: acT''sa,letec^{vew tl'ci ills wii Delrt orl cot.oe} Lr^jt)'.),r-'al oi o reci rr!^{if 6- lg56ruadenls io consicler1re opp collorl} !i,Lrir ileci bv iire^pel tcner on^{25.A7.2ai6 ond poss crppropriole} orders ln occordonce with low, within o^{reoscnableperiod,} pref erobly wiihin o per od of eight weeks from the dote of receipt of a copy of this order.

¶55

Accordingly, ihe writ petition is disposed of . \o order os to

¶56

c osls.

¶57

Pendrng miscelloneous petitlons, if ony, sholl slond closed.

¶58

SD/.K.ONESIM ASSlsrANr REf\lsrRAR ,rRUE copy//

¶59

SECTION OYFICER

¶60

To, 1 il:-lll:,lSl^{Secretary, Departmentof Higher} Education,^{Stare of Tetangana,} secrelanat Burtdrngs, Secretariat. Hyderabad - 500022. 2 The commrssioner,. Terangana stite councir for Higher Education (TSCHE), {NSAV.^{Euilding, 1't Ftoor]IVtahaveer trrtarg. Opp} Mairre"ifftsbiirf^'- Mrr;6 Tank, Hydera bad -500028,

Coi-rtd""

I ,

The Convener, TS EAI.4CET-2o19, Jawaharlal^{Nehru Technological University-}

¶65

(JNTU). Hyderabad, Kukatpally. Hyderabad-500085,^(TS).

¶66

4 The Direcior, Telangana Stari: Sjinit^{Welfare Board,Somajrguda. Hyderabad-} 500482. Telangana State.

¶67

S fne Zitta Sainik Welfare Officer^{(ZSWO), Hyderabad District, TelanganaState} Sainik Welfare Board, Somajiguda,^{Hyderabad-500482, Telangana State}

¶68

1. The Zilla Sainrk^{WelfareOffi'c6r} TZSWO).^{RangaReddy District. TelanganaState} SainikWelfareBoard,somajiguda'Hyderabad-5004E2'lelanganaSlale..

¶69

z i[e otricei-r-if,utge,-^{k.intriya Sainik Board WestBlock-lV' Wing 7'} R.K.Puram, New^{Delhi - 110066.}

¶70

Til h;gi;iiai,-osm-ania^{univJrsity, osmaniaUniversitv. Hvderabad-500007.}

¶71

- The secretary,^{Minrstry;i'ij;i;;6;,u;ion oirnoiu,Goveinment of lndia, south} .10.The Block, Central Secretaiiat, Secretary, trlinistry?i^{New Delhi-110011 'd;;J#i} qr"oiit Cri"u"nces - and^{Pensions, Union of} lndia, Government^{oI i;di;r'r6''tii' abCL' bentral Secretariat'New Delhi-}

¶72

't't . ll3oJlr;o"rate G eneral Resettlement'^{D-eq?1m9!t of Ex-s ervicemen' Mini stry of} iltft;, W;ielocx-a^{nKp"am'New Delhi -i'10066iirst} Ftoor, sMC Buitdins,

¶73

rz.i[e ol''i,cioi,^{Directoraie of Air Veterans' Air HQ (} '- SuUroio Park, New Delhi - 1 I 0010'

¶74

13.The officer-in-cnrrg"l"hi''rXi'ce"R"coro^{office' (AFRo)' subroto Park' New} Delhi^- 110010

¶75

l4.oneCCtoSriB.SreeRamaKrishna.PartyinPersontoPUCl'15 rwo ccs to GP ror HiliiJtiffiiiii''^{iliiin co"t ior'Ge st6teor relansanaat} t6.Oire Hvderabad. CC to^Sri [OUT]^{V Ramchander Goud'S C for J N,T U (OPUC)} 17 rwo ccs to^{GP for w:ii;;;'"i';;Ar-iriJor ttre si;i;df r"lt"sanaat Hvderabad}

¶76

t8 IOUTIbne CC to^{Srr NamavarapuRaieshwarRao' AssstantSolicitor General (OPUC)} 's c l"i osmania Universitv (oPUC)

¶77

19 20.Two one cc^{CD CoPies'to sri ch} "glXI]ti''XR"i

¶78

One^{SPare CoPY}

t\i1P

?-z/n

HIGH COURT

i l

DATED:2610812021

ORDER

WP.No.10648 of²⁰¹⁹

T; I €
F
o
k
z
a)o 2 7 S EP 20?l c)
F
-t
l'. ,:: - .-

¶87

DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS.

¶88

t&.,7$<br>f'
@

Bokka Sree Rama Krishna v. The State of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Bokka Sree Rama Krishna v. The State of Telangana

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Sri Sama Veera Venkta Satyanarayana Murthy Vs The State of Telangana

G. Naveen Reddy Vs The State Of Telangana

A. Rahaman Vs State of T.S.

Sri Siva Sai Agencies Vs The Food Corporation of India and Another

M/ s Lakshmi Narasimha Warehousing Partnership Vs Union of India

M/s. Lakshmi Narasimha Warehousing, Partnership Vs Union of India and 2 Others