Disposed

Ameena begum , S. Madhavi Lata v. Mr. Ubedulla Shareef

Telangana HC12 Feb 2021FCA/10/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court recorded a Memorandum of Compromise executed between the parents and custodial daughters settling maintenance claims via cash payment and property transfer. The appeals filed against the maintenance decree and interpleader matters were disposed of in terms of the compromise.

What did the court decide?

The Memorandum of Compromise was recorded, binding parties to terms of Rs. 1 Crore payment, property transfers, and withdrawal of pending litigations; appeals disposed accordingly.

Ameena begum , S. Madhavi Lata Vs Mr. Ubedulla… — Writ and Judicial Review | Telangana HC (2021)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

¶2

FRIDAY ,THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE

¶3

PRESENT

¶4

THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI AND THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY

¶5

t.A. NO. 10F 202',1 rN/& F.C.A. NO i 10 0F 2017

¶6

AND F.C.A. NO. 187 OF 2016

¶7

F.C.A. NO. 10 OF29l7

¶8

Appeal Under Section 19 of Family Court Act against^{the order and Decree} dated 17-09-2016 in FCOP No. 883 I 2011 on^{the file of the Court of the Judge'} Family Court at Hyderabad.

¶9

Between

¶10

Ameena Begum @ S. tt/adhavi Lata, W/o. Ubedullag Shareef,^{A/a.40 years, Occ:} Student FUo. f tat No.t t¹ , Sri Tarajeet^{Residency, H..No.3-5-1083,Narayanguda,} Hyderabad.

¶11

tr/iss. Ayesha Neeha, D/o. Ubedulla Sharef,^{Aged1B.years,Occ: Student, R/o.} Flat No.i 11, Sri Tarajeet Residency, H..No.3-5-1083,^{Narayanguda,Hyderabad}

¶12

Baby Rida Shams, D/o. Ubedulla^{Shareef,Aged 13 years, R/o.Flat No.111,Sri} Tara'jeet Residency, H.No.3-5^-1083, Narayanguda,^Hyderabad

¶13

...APPELLANT/ Petitioners

¶14

AND

¶15

Ir/r. Ubedulla Shareef, S/o lr,4ahaboob.^{Aged 48 years, Occ: Business, Fl/o102, Pine} Residency, Opp; Federation House, Red^{Hills, Hyderabad.}

¶16

...RESPONDENT/ ResPondent

¶17

IA NO :1 OF 2021

¶18

Petition under Order XXlll Rule 3 of C.P.C.^{praying that in the} circumstances stated in the affidavit^{filed in supportof the petition,the HighCourt} may be pleased to^permit the^petitioners and^{respondentto record the terms of the} memorandum of compromise^.

¶19

lA NO: 1 OF 2019

¶20

Petition under Section 151 CPC Under^{Order Vl Rule 17 of CPC prayingthat} in the circumstances stated in the affidavit^{filed in supportof the petition,the High} Court may be^pleased to^{permit the} 1't^{Petitionerto amend the prayer in above} appeal as the maintenance amount of^{Rs. 2,00,000/-per month to 2nd and 3rd} Peiitioners instead of Rs. 50,000/-^{per month including arrears fromthe dated of} application filed by the Petitioner's^{pending disposalof the above appeal.}

¶21

Counsel for the Appellants/ Petitioners^{in both :SRl' DR.J. VIJAYALAXMI}

¶22

Counsel for the Respondent in both :^{SRI M. A' K. MUKHEED}

¶23

Al^rrre-'-'

¶24

FAMILY COURT APPEAL^{{FCA)NO:187 0F2016}

¶25

Appeal Under section^{19 of Familycourt Act against the order and Decree} dated 17-09-2016 in^{FCOP No. 883 I 2011 on the file of the court of the Judge'} Family Court , City^{Civil Courtat Hyderabad.}

¶26

Between:

¶27

Ubedulla shareef,^{S/o.Mahaboob,Aged 45 years,occ: Business, Fl/o. Flat No. 102,} Fine*ood nesidency,^{Opp: Federation House, Red Hills,Hyderabad'}

¶28

...APPELLANT/ ResPondent

¶29

AND

¶30

Ameena Begum @^{Madhavi Latha, W/o. Ubedulla Shareef, aged 40 years,Occ:} Pvt. Service,

¶31

tVliss. Ayesha Neeha,^{D/o. Ubedulla Shareef, aged17 years, Occ: Student,}

¶32

Miss baby Rida Shams,,^{d/o. UbedullaShareef} ,^aged .12^years,Occ: .Student, - in"ipona6nt no.Z a a 5eing minors represented by their natural mother and natuial^guardian i.e., respondent^no.1)

¶33

All are r/o. Flat No.111,^{Sri Tarajeet Residency, H.No. 3-5-'1083, Narayanaguda,} Hyderabad. ...RESPONDENTS/ Petitioners

¶34

Counsel for the Appellant:^{SRI M' A. K' MUKHEED}

¶35

Counsel for the Respondent:^{DR.J. VIJAYALAXMI}

¶36

The Court delivered the^{following: CommonJudgment}

¶37

THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI

¶38

AND

¶39

I.A.No. I OF 2021 in/& F.C.A.No. t0 of 2017

¶40

and F.C.A. No. 187 of 2016

¶41

COMMONJ UDGMENT : (Per the Hon'ble the Chief Justice Hima Kohli)

¶42

1 . LA.No.1 of 2021 has been moved by the appellants in F.C.A.No.10 of 2017 (respondents in F.C.A.No. 187 of 20t6) seeking to place on record the Memorandum of Compromise dated 29.08.2020, wherein the parties have arrived at a comprehensive settlement.

¶43

Learned counsel for the appellants states that under the Memorandum of Compromise, the respondent (father of the appellants No.2 and 3 and appellant in F.C.A.No.187 of 2016) has paid a sum of Rs.1 Crore collectively to his daughters in full and final settlement of their maintenance and any future claims against him. Besides the sum of Rs.1 Crore, the respondent has executed and registered two separate gift settlement deeds dated 05.01.2021 in favour of the respondents No.2 and 3 respectively in respect of the agricultural land situated in Tadipatri Village, Bhootpur Mandal, Mahabubnagar District, as detailed in para 1 of the Memorandum of Conrpromise and a sale deed dated 02.09.2020 in favour of the respondent No.1 in respect of a flat situated in Red Hills, Hyderabad, as detailed in para 6 tl.rereof. The parlies have also agreed that the

¶44

Poge I of3

¶45

F-.C.A.Nos.10 of 2017 & 187 of 2016

¶46

appellant No.l (wife of^{the respondent)shall remainthe absolute} owner of the agricultural^{land admeasuringAcs.15'04guntassituated} in Tadipatri Village,^{Bhootpur Mandal,Mahabubnagar District'} Further, the parties have^{already'withdrawn a1l theirpendinginter se} litigations.

¶47

Leamed counsel for^{the appellantsstates that in view of the} aforesaid comprehensive^{settlement, nothing survives for adjudication} in the present appeals.

¶48

the 4, Mr. M.A.K.Mukheed, leamed^{counsel for} respondent/husband, on^{instructionsfrom his client, who is present in} the virtual hearing, confirms^{the terms and conditions recorded in the} said Memorandum of Compromise^{and statesthat he has no objection} to the same being taken on^{record and the present appeais being} disposed of in terms thereof.

¶49

We have heard the^{iearned counsel for the parties.The} appellants No.1 to 3 and^{the respondentshave logged into the hearing} and confirmed the settlement^{recorded in the Memorandum of} Compromise dated 29.08.2020^{out of their own free will and volition} and without any undue^{pressure or coercion from any quarlers.They} state that they shall^{abide by the terms and conditionsof the} settlement and request that^{the present appealsmay be disposed of in} terms thereof.

¶50

Accordingly, I.A.No. I of 2021^{is allowed, the Memorandumof} Compromise is taken on^{record while binding the parties to the}

¶51

F.C.A.Nos.10 of 2017 & 187 of²⁰¹⁶

¶52

Page 2 oJ 3

¶53

conditions recorded thereit.r. Both the^{appealsare disposedof along}

¶54

with the pending applications. if any.

¶55

sd/-K. SREENIVASA^RAO JOINT REGIS

¶56

//TRUE COPY//

¶57

SECTIO FFICER

¶58

To 1. The.Judqe,^{Family Court, City CivilCourt' at Hy!91abqQ( withrecords)} i. ci;; Cci;'^{bHi. 6nl viinvArnxvtt,AdvocatetoPUCl}

¶59

One CC^{to SRl. M. A. K MUKHEED' AdvocateIOPUCI}

¶60

Two CD^CoPies

¶61

( along with a copy^{of Memoof Compromtse} ')

¶62

¶63

Page 3 of 3

¶64

F.C.,l.Nos.l0 0J'2017 &^{187oJ 2016}

HIGH COURT

HCJ & BVRJ

DATED:1210212021

COMMON JUDGMENT

l.A. NO. 1 OF 2021 lN / &^{F.C.A.NO: 10 OF 2017}

¶70

AND F.C.A. NO.^',|87 0F 2016

¶71

DISPOSINC OF BOTH^{THE APPEALS} AND ALLOWING THE I.A.^{NO. 1 OF 2O2I} WITHOUT COSTS

¶72

1 dE S7A
t
4
2 7 FEB 2021
;) {,)
<br>*
t

¶73

0 2Ci,4

¶74

¶75

IN-T'HE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA

¶76

AT:]{YDERABAD

¶77

Ir.C.A.No. l0 ol20l 7

¶78

Betwccn

¶79

I) Mrs. Ar-nccrra Bcguru t0 S.Madhavi [.ata. I)io pentaialt Agcd: 45 ycars. Occ: E.ntplovcc

¶80

1. Ms.Aycsha Nccha @ S.Ayeshrvalyaa Neha D/tr Ubeduilah Shareef AgerJ: 22 ycars Occ: Student

¶81

1. Baby Ridha Shams @) S.Sai Riddi D/o Ubedullah Shareef Aged: l7 years, Occ: Student

¶82

(bcing minor she is represented by her rnother and natural guardian )

¶83

All R/o Flat No.l I l, Sri Tarajeet Residency, H.No.3-5-1083 Narayanguda Hyderabad.

¶84

...APPELLANTS

¶85

AND

¶86

Mr'.Ubcdullah Sharecf S/o Mahboob Sharcef.

¶87

Agecl: -50 years. Occ: Busirress

¶88

R/o Flat No. 102. Pinervood [tesidencl,, H.No I -5-40_s & 405/l Itcd Ilills, Nanrpally. Flyderabad.

¶89

.,RE,SPONDENT

¶90

MEMORANpUM OF COMPROMISE

¶91

It is subnrittcd that the appellanr No.l has rnarried the respondent on l4.l t.1996 as pcr thc custortls of Musliln Larv. rvhich is inter-rcligion and love marriage and out of the ivcd-lock. they have been blessed r.vith trvo daughters i.c. appellants No.2&3. In the year 2009. some disputes arosc bctr'veen thc appellant No.l and respondent, as such they arc living separately since April. 2009 and the appellants No.2&3 are in the custody and care o l'appcllant No.l.

¶92

That the lcspondent l.ras filed O.P. No.725 of 2010 on the file of Hon'ble Farnily Court. City Civit Court, Hyderabad, against the appellant No.1 for custody of his daughters and subsequently said OP was r,vithdrawn by hirr-r as not pressed. Thereafter, thc appcllant No. I has filed O.P.No.883 ol 20 I I sceking nrainrenance for herself and her daughters.^'l hc rcsponclent has also filed O.l'.No.1485 ol20l1 against the appellant No.l,, tslut, f)-*^o^{o'n )b'<^^} /L-=-

¶93

I <sup>/Y.(ln l^16 ifr8r'^ f.lt.l, o)

¶94

J.^o-o-.^-[-Xo^-

¶95

¶96

herein for cancellation of Deed of cancellation deetl No. I g66 ol'2009 lbr cancelling the Gift Deed No.2850 of 2004 by respondent in respecr of flar No.l04, Ma.ior I{esidency in Premises No. l0-5-19, 21,21/1,2,4&4/1, siruared ar Masab'l-ank Ilyderabacl. During the pendency of said cases, appellant No.1 has flled a divorce petition vicle o.lr.No. I 342 ol' 2014 against the respondent and all the cases were filed befbre the Hon,ble Judge, Family court, Hyderabad. In these cases the respondent has contestecl lhe matters and all the cases were decreed. In oP No.883 of 2011 the Hon'ble Family court was pleased to award mainten anca at the rate of Rs.25,000/- each per month vide order clated: 1'7 .9 .2016 in fhvour of appellants No.2&3 and dismissed the claim of appellant No. I .

¶97

The respondent has preferred appeals belore the Ilon'ble lligh corLrt against the Maintenance order dated: l'/.9.2016 passecl try thc llon,blc lranrily ceurt 'icle F.c.A.No.187 of 2016 and also llled an inrerlocurory applioarion vicle I.A.No.467 ol 2016, seeking to stay all lurther proceedings ol'above saicl orcjcr. Alier hearing both sides, the Ilon'ble High court u,as pleascd to disnriss rhe I.A.No. 467 ol 2016. Alicr disnrissal ollhe saure, the appelltrnts No.2&3 have filetl [.lr.No.2 ol'2017 lilr.recoverv of. arrears of llltlinlenance ol I{s.3I,60,000r'-. tlorvevcr, the siricl .trlcurs were paitl bv thc respondent in several phases and the saicl l, P. Lvas closecl in the :rurnlh ol.luly, 20I13. During the pendency ol the said E.P.No.2 o1'2017, rhe respontlcnl iailcd to p1y poprhly maintenance, r.vhich were accumulated to Ils.9.00,000/-fbr.rvhich rhe appellants No.2&3 have also tlled E.I'].No.12 of 2019 which is srill penriing ad juclication. Irufiher rhe respondent has pref'erred an appeal vide F.c.A.No. l8tt ol'20i6 seeliing to set nside the order and decreetal order passed by the LIon'b]e Farnily court in o.p.No. l4g5 ol 20l l. This appeal was also rvithdrawn by the responclent herein as not pressed. Ileing aggrievecl by the order passec'l in o.P.No. BB3 of 201 1, the appellanrs hereirr have also prel'e1.e4 the present appeal against tl-re respondent lor enhancemenl oi'monthlt, rnaintenance, as th-e said OP was partly allowed. /1

¶98

t. (e ,+1ru *%4^{{^} U/^") J ,&

.1 '1.

k)I

t. lhe resp()n(lclll has^{liletl a srritin (l.S.No.llll ol2()17 oll the llle ol XVll Scntor} Civil :J16ge, Citr^{C'ivil(lrLrr1. ll;tlerlbad.firr erncellatiorl ol' above said (jiliI)ecrl} bear.ing Docunte llt No.2850^{ol'10()-larrrlrrlso l'ilccl artothelstrit in ().S.No l i llol l0 I7} on the llle Ol'I^{Senior Civil Judg.c. (iirl t'iyilClorirt.lllclc|ubitd, scekitrg tleclaratiottto} cjcclare the resporrLlenl^{lrercinits lrtrsolrrtc ()\ncr.)1lllr1 Ntt.l0l.in l)incrvtlotl I{c>itlerlcl'.} Itcci Hills, I-h.^cier.ii brrrl.^{tc saidsuits lre still pendirrgaditrdicatiorr ls the ilppcllarliNo.1} is contesting.

¶104

i, lt is srrbnrillctl lhtri^{rvhitclnlltt.rs rird hcirtg so. ilt thc illlcr'cnti()ll ()l cl(l('1'siill(l} r.,,eli-uishCrs ol'ltitth^{sirlcs. the rr;sptltltlcltl:trltllllllellatlts llllt'e cotlla to iitt tlntlerstantlittg} to pu1 il.l entl^{to lhe ahor,erelcrredclisllrrtes aluicalll.rin orcler to hltve peace tll-rnind} for.ever. I1^{prltsrliyt0eof this unclersiantlirrp. and atier several mtttual tliscttssiOlls attd} cieiibentions b1^{the apltelluuts ancl Iespon(lell1.have etllet'eclinto a Nlettlorall(lun I o1'} unclerstanding,^{rlatecl: 29.08.2020antl in ptrrsu rce o1'thc clause4 ol lhe siulle. thc} appellants and^{respondent arc tllinP, the present Memoranclutnol' colrprr'risebclbre} this Hon'ble Cottrt.

¶105

TERMS ANI) CON^{r)tl loNs ol.*llllsMEMORANI)LI M Ol-'c OMt)ROMIStT:}

¶106

l ,fhat tite r,cslltlnr.lctl t Illrs itLr.-ltill' crcctttt.d antl registerctl t\'() Separatc tiili scttlcment^{cleeclstllrlerl: 05,01.202 Iin litvortr o1' appellatrtsNo.l&ircspccliVe l)i u.} l][tmel)'Ms'A,csltltNechl(rt)S.r\1,cslrrla11'ltaNchlrlrrrtlNls.ItidhrrSlralrrs[DSei Itiddi, in the^{ofliceol' the'lahs iltiar-crrnr-.loirtt Sub-Rcgistrar"[]hootpurMandirl'} N4 alrabtrbnag.ar.^{l)i:tr.ict. irle clLraIsltat.tlsi,t. Ac 5-04 gts each in rcspectol- agriculltrr.al} Lincl in sr',Nos:^{l(r0i2. l6l /1. 16-i li'16(i} "'^{l66rl:l/2'161)i3' l6lil'162r'3' l6 ii A'} 1(t6lEi3. i6i/A.^{16()i l. l6lll.l6l'1. l(rill.l(r(ri[')'totalll adnreisurirrr]Ac l0-02gts} situated at l^{atlipirrtiVillage.13lrootpLrllv'lanilill"MahlrtrbnaqrrDistrrct.torvarcls lLrllanti} linal settierlerrt^{ol thcir lllairltenan0c. 'lhe l'rhs ild llr-cttrlr-'loint Sub-[{egistlar'[]hootpLtr} Mandal.^{has or.tlcrr-il t() issrle paitaditrpitss boolisvide'r010300407t33antl 1-010'100'+l)781} / ' /-.{-t'I'r'r'',--D- | l' (c ,1i1 o,l^'''-'"'{ 'ⁱ ''rt!'-')

datcd:05.0l.202l..lhcrespotrdetrtshallharrcloverallthetlrigirraldocutrrentsperttrlnlrtg m the said^{landto appellantsNo'2&3 '}

¶116

II 'l'hat the respondent ltas already^{paitla sunl ol Rs'1} '00'00'000/-^{(Rupees oneCrore} N ehn only) to^{thc appellantsNo'2&3namely NIs.Aycsha Neeha(4) S'Aycsltwaryaa} antlMs'l].itllraSharrrsCa)S"SaiIlid<li.bvrra.l,rll-r:aslrtrt.l{s.10.00.0()0/.Locaciroltlrerl-t ancl l{s.40.00.000/-^{1o cach' viclc cheiiuesNos: '1i)492 | & 104923 clatcd: 02 09'2020} respeotivcly.^{clrawn on M/s Axis Bank Ltd ' to*'ards full and final scttlcnlcntof thcir} lnaintcnanccirrallrcspcctsanclthcrcslrallnotbeanl,tutureclaimagairtsttlrcrespotlderrt.

¶117

I1l.^{'fhat tlie appcllant No'l shall coutitiuc hcr absolute orvnership and rightsin and} over trre^{agricurturar ra,d adrneasuringAc15 -04g:ts i, sy.N o. I 9 olEl2' | 5sll,,12'19olrtl2 '} 190/EE/3.^{158/EE.158/L'B/l' l6l/l'162ll' l(r3il' t66/l-11'1(r6iAz'sitr-rateci at} .I.arliparliVillagc.Bl.tootpurMandlrl.Maltallubrlagarl)istrict.rvlricilstantlsinlrcrtranto bl,l,lrttrcofrcgistcrcclsa[eclcetlsbearitlgdocurrletrtNo.i)8s2/2007.ii)8lt3/2007' iii)884/2007.iv)8135/2007arlclv)BB6/2()()Tclatcrl:25.l,ll007.rcgistercrlirrtheo1l]ceof Sub-Registrar'.Iaclcharlaatldtlrcrcspotrdctltlrcrcit-tshallnotinterltrcittherposscssiort and enioyment^{of lhe saicl lancl in any-lranner^thc respotldcntshall hiinrl over all the} origirraltitledeedsarrcllinkdocumerrtspertairringtothesaidlandtotheappellantNo.l and the respondent^{shall obtain the acknowledgementfionlher'}

¶118

lV.^{That the rcspondentshall lvithdrarv I C A No l ST ol 2016 pcnding bslbrethis} ]]on.bleCotrrt.sirrrilar.lytheappollantsNo'2&3shirllwithdrarvtlreE.P.N0.l2ol20l9in O.P.No.883^{ol 2019 pencling bclbrcthe [-lon'ble FamilyCour:t'Cit)'CivilCourt'} I-lydcrabad.

¶119

V.^'that thc^{rcspontlcntsirall ivith<lras'O'SNo tIltol 20l7 ancl O S No l ll2 of 20 l7} clgc. ClitY^CivilCourt, pending bctbre^{thc XVllSenior Civil Judgc and I Senior Civil Ju} e|s;.rtc PtlsLctl .n Flyderabad,^{on 19.012021 &29'01'2021rcspectivelyas thesemalt} l,llt-

¶120

, (- *5t-'rL'-'a^tX'^^{Mri^")} W

¶121

¶122

That as pcr rhe craLrse 7 01- the MOU Datc,: 2g.0g.2020, the appellant No. r has alreatly 'executed aud rcgistcred a salc tieerl be:rr.ing docunient No.357() of 2020 dated:02 09.2020 regisre're<r in the olfice or- Sub-Registrar, Gortonda, Ilyrierabad, in lil\ ()uf or' rcsporrtrerrl irr resncct .l rrrirt btu.inq N.. ruJ. pirte wo.tr Rcsitreacr. in prernises No l l-5-405 & 405^, Red Hilrs, l r1'trerabaci. The apperant No.l shalr hand o'er all the originar d.cunrents pertaining to trrc- said flar to the responcrent antr sha obtain acknorvleclgernent ol the sarnc liorn hini.

¶123

VI] l'hat the appellants No. I tol. ol. lr1\ pe rs()n or pcrsorls itctiltg ol. clain.rirr-e throLrgh iirenl' shall llot raisc ltttv clitint ol'\lralsric,,cI irr lirltric irgirinst the resl:rontlcnl. Sirrilar.lv thc Iesponclent ol ltll,\ ilels(,n or ilersons lrcling r'rr ellrigrinp rhrouglr htrrr. shali .ot rilisc :rnv clainr ol n,hatsoer rr. in lirtrrrc itgaitrst lhe appeliu:trs No.lrol.

¶124

/lll fhat appcllrnt No l :rititli u ilhilirru' tlie p'rlit'c corrrplrrint dirteti:l-i.06.1020. peritlirle belbrc' the l)tllie e ttl llltoolpLrr'. Nlahbubnrr-rar l)isLr.ict, i. vierv .i'*,rce ll.tioir o1. rc'sislered sale deed beari,g docLr.rerr No.r(;70 o1'l0 r 5 crarcd:07.03.20r5.

¶125

l'\ 'l'h.t both the pariic's shair bear rirci'ri* n cosls ol'r'c ,roceetrings.

¶126

It is thercfbre. pr;tvetl thllt this lkrn'blc ('orrr[ nrn ire pleaseci to rccor.(l tlrc a5.r.c tetllls altcl cortditiotts lvlcltl ol:i tltlttttt o1 f'ornPrr!risLr irrtl tlecrec the lr[roVe ntirlier.in ternr.; c'[:liie sanle altd llso l.lriss sttcli t;llrer o]1lcI ll,]rJ or(l(r's irr lliis Ilo|r.t;lc Llorrr.t rleerIs 1lt itntl piopcl in the circLrntslanc(rs of'tl)c citse.

¶127

ir '',,,-,r 1^ il .r 1 1.. .) APP}I II.-\Nl \1.1

¶128

n l!tu\ iIESI'jONI)r..!E l

¶129

,.,/. (-' (Aclost^t,-''.'1-., lr,u" ) Ai'l'til-LAN'l' No.2

¶130

l /'-,t., \l,i,iil,L.AN-l- No -) lrcirrg utinor', rep. bv Appellanl No. l)

¶131

bN'-I.uYr]OUNSEL FOR'|I.IL AI'PEI.-LANTS

¶132

ctouNsitt_ Foti Tllll RIISP ENl'

¶133

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA

¶134

AT HYDERABAD

¶135

FRIDAY ,THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE

¶136

PRESENT THE HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE HIMA KOHLI AND THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE B.VIJAYSEN REDDY

¶137

l.A. NO. 1 OF 2021 lN / & F.C.A. NO: 10 OF 2017

¶138

AND F.C.A. NO. 187 0F 2016

¶139

l.A..NO. I OF 2021 l[/ & F.C.A. NO: 10 OE 2017

¶140

Between

¶141

Ameena Begum @ S. IVadhavi Lata, W/o. Ubedulla Shareef, A/a.40 years, Occ: Student Rl/o. Flat No.111, Sri Tarajeet Residency, H..No.3-5-1083, Narayanguda, Hyderabad.

¶142

Ir/iss. Ayesha Neeha, D/o. Ubedulla Sharef, Aged 1B years, Occ: Student, R/o. Flat No.'1^{'1 '1} , Sri Tarajeet Residency, H..No.3-5-1083, Narayanguda, Hyderabad

¶143

Baby Rida Shams, D/o. Ubedulla Shareef, Aged 13 years, R/o. Flat No.111, Sri Tarajeet Residency, H.No.3-5 -1083, Narayanguda, Hyderabad

¶144

...APPELLANT/ Petitioners

¶145

AND

¶146

Mr. Ubedulla Shareef, S/o Mahaboob. Aged 48^years, Occ: Business, R/o102, Pine Residency, Opp; Federation House, Red Hills, Hyderabad.

¶147

...RESPONDENT/ Respondent

¶148

F,C.A. NO .187 0F 2016

¶149

Appeal Under Section 19 of Family Court Act against the order and Decree datedlT-09-2016 inFCOPNo.883 12011 onthefileoftheCourtofthe Judge,Family Court at Hyderabad.

¶150

Between:

¶151

Ubedulla Shareef, S/o. Mahaboob, Aged 45 years, Occ: Business, R/o. Flat No. 102, Pinewood Residency, Opp: Federation House, Red Hills, Hyderabad.

¶152

...APPELLANT/ Respondent

¶153

AND

¶154

Ameena Begum @ N/adhavi Latha, W/o. Ubedulla Shareef, aged 40^years, Occ: Pvt. Service,

¶155

I/iss. Ayesha Neeha, D/o. Ubedulla Shareef, aged 17 years, Occ: Student,

¶156

Miss baby Rida Shams,, d/o. Ubedulla Shareef, aged 12^years, Occ: Student, (Respondent no.2 & 3 being minors represented by their natural mother and natural guardian i.e., respondent no.1)

¶157

AII are r/o. Flat No.1'l 1 , Sri Tarajeet Residency, H.No. 3-5-1083, Narayanaguda, ...RESPONDENTS/ Petitioners Hyderabad.

¶158

2.- -

¶159

l.A. No. 1 of 2o2'l in^{F.C. A.No.10 of 2ou: ..petition under Order XXlll Rule3 of C'p'C'} proying thot the High court moy be^{pleoredto porso decreein termlof the Memorondumof} compromise filed therewith^{or between the oppellonts ond respondentsin the soid} l.A. No. 1 of 2021 on the^{file of theHigh Court.}

¶160

Theoppeolondmis<elloneouspetitioncomingthisdoyforordersosto settlement in the^{presence of 5ri Dr. t, Viioyolshshmi, Advocote for the oppellonts in F'C'A' No'} to ol 2c,17 ond Respondent^{Nos1 to 3 in F.C.A.No.187 of2o',16 ond of sri. M.A.R. Muhheed ,} Advocote for the rspondent^{in F.C.A.No. 10 of 2Ol7ondAppellontin F.C'A. No. 187 of 2016} Appellont ond respondent^{through theirretpectiveAdvocotelhovingfiled in l.A. No. I of} 2021 requerting the^{Court tO pO$O decreein terms the memorondum of compromiseentered} into between them ond^{upon perusing the ground:oppeol,judgment onddecreeof thelower} court ond the memo of compromile^{purporting to hovebeen signed by the portietond their} Advocotes ond filed with the^{soidl.A.No. t ol ZOZI ond it oppeoring fromthe soid} memorondum of compromire^{thot the portie:herein hove enteredinto compromise ond} seHled the motter out of^{court in termr memorondum of compromisefiled herein.}

¶161

This court DoTH RECORD the^{termr of the soidmemorondumof compromise} in originol where of is filedⁱⁿ the roid^{l;A. No. t of 2021 ond o copywhereof is onnexed} hereto ond DoTH in termr^{of the :oid memorondum of compromise decloreoRDER} ond DECREE os followr:

¶162

t. Thot the oppeol be ond hereby^{is disposed of in terms of} Memorondum of Understonding doted 29-o8-2o2o'

¶163

Thot the respondent hos^{olreody executedond registered two seporote cift} Settlement deeds doted^{OStOlt2OZl in fovour of oppellonts No.2& 3 rerpectiuelyi.e.} nqmely Ms. Ayerho Neeho^@ S.Ayerhworyoo^{Neho ond Ms.Ridho Shoms@ SoiRiddi, in} the office of the Tohsildqr-cum- loint^Sub -Reghtror,^{Bhootpur Mondol, Mohobubnogor} District, in equol shores i.e. Ac 5-o4^{gtr eoch in respect of ogriculturollond in} sy.Nos.l6o/2, 161t2, 163tR,^{1661A, 1661E12,160/3,161/3 ,16?.13, 1631A, t66lEl3,1631A.' 16011,} 161t1, 162t1, 1631t, 166tE, totolly odmeqruring^{Ac.lo-o2 gts :ituoted ot Todiporti Villoge,} Bhootpur Mondol, Mohbubnogor^{District,towords full ond finol settlement of their} mointenonce. The Tohtildor-cum- ,oint 5ub-Reghtror,^{Bhootpur Mqndol,hos ordered to} irrue pottodor^pors boohs uide Tolo3oo4o783^{ondTo1o3oo4o784doted: O5/ol/2O21.}

¶164

)

¶165

The respondent sholl hond over oll the originol^{documentr pertoiningto thesoid lond to} oppellonts No.2 & 3.

¶166

Thot the respondent hor olreody^{poido sumof R5.l,oo'oo,ooo/- (RupeesOneCrore} only) to the oppellonts^No.2 &³ nomely^{Ms. Ayesho Neeho@ S'Ayeshoworyoo Nehoond} Ms. Ridho Shoms @ S.Soi Reddi, by woy of^{coshof Rs.to,oo,ooo/-to eochof them ond} Rs.4o,oo,ooo/- to eoch, vide cheques^Not.4o4921 &^{4c'4923doted:o2lo9/2o2o} respectively, drown on M/:. Axis Bonh^{Ltd.,towords full ond finol settlementof their} mointenonce in oll respectr ond there^{sholl not be ony future cloim ogoinstthe} respondent.

¶167

4, Thot the oppellont No.l lholl continue^{her obsolute ownershipond rightl in ondouer} the ogriculturol lond^{qdmeosuring Ac l5-o4gts in 5y.No.19o/E/2,1581E12,19olel2,} 1gotEEt3,158/EE,^{t58/EE/l,t61lt,162fi,163tl, 1661Ell,166/44,situotedot TodiportiVilloge,} Bhootpur Mondol, Mohobubnogor^{District,which ltondsin her nome by virtue of} registered sole deeds beoring^{document No.} D^{882/2OO7, iD883/2OO7,iiD884/2OO7,} iv)885/2OO7, ond v)886/2OO7^{doted25IO1/2OO7, registered in the officeof Sub-Regktror,} todchorlo ond^{the respondent herein sholl not interfere in herpossession ond enioyment} of the soid lond in ony^{monner,therespondentsholl hond over oll the originol title deeds} ond linh documents^{pertoining to the soid londto the oppellont No.l ond the respondent} sholl obtoin the ochnowledgement^fromher.

¶168

Thot the respondent^{sholl withdrowF.c.A.No.187of 2016pendingbeforethk Hon'ble} court. similorly the oppellonts^{No.2 & 3 sholl withdrow the E.P.No.l2of 2019in} o.P.No.883 of 2Ol9^{pending beforethe Hon'ble Fomily court,city ciuil court,} Hyderobod.

¶169

Thot the^{respondentsholl withdrow o.s.No.rtll of zotT ond o.5.No.11I2 of 2017 pending} before the XVll Senior civil ludge^{ond I Seniorcivil ,ludge, city civil court, Hyderobod,} on 19tc)ll2021 & ?:9toltzo2l^{respectiuely ot there motters ore posted'}

¶170

Thot os^per the^{clouse 7 of the MoU doted 29lo8/2o2o, the oppellont No.t hosolreody} executed ond registered o^{soledeed beoring document No.357Oof 2O2Odoted} o2lo9l2)2} registered^{in theoffice of sub-Registror, Golhondo,Hyderobod,in fovour of} respondent in respect of^{Flot beoringNo.1o3, pine WoodResidency,in premises No'} 11.5.405 & 405/1, Red^{Hills, Hyderobod.The Appellont No.l shollhond overoll the} originol documentr^{pertoining to the soid flot to the respondentondsholl obtoin} ochnowledgement^of the^{somefrom him.}

¶171

.-'v-

¶172

Thot^{the oppellontsNo.l to 3, or ony perronor personsocting or cloiming through} them, sholl^{not roite ony cloim of whotsoeuer in future ogoinstthe rerpondent'Similorly} the respondent^{or ony pertonor pertont octing or cloiminsthrough him'sholl not roise} ony cloim^{of whotsoever in future ogoinstthe oppellonts No'l to 3'}

¶173

Thot^{oppellont No'lsholl withdrow the police comploint doted 25/06/2020' pending} before^{the policeof Bhootpur, Mohbubnogor District,in view of concellotion of} regittered^{lole deedbeoring documentNo'267oof 2ol5 dotedo7lo3l2o15'}

¶174

Thot^{both theportiesshollbeortheirowncostsof the proceedings'}

¶175

5d/-K.SREENIVASA^RAO loINT^REGI R

¶176

//TRUE^COPY//

¶177

s ON OFFI^CER

¶178

to ,. ,nu ,rone, Fomily Court' City Civil Court' Hvderobqd' 2. Two^{CD Copies}

HIGH COURT

HCJ & BVRJ

DATED:1210212021

DECREE FOR MEMORANDUM OF COMPORMISE t.A. NO.'t OF 2021 tN / & F.C.A. NO i'lO OF 2017

¶183

AND F.C.A. NO. 187 0F 2016

¶184

DISPOSING OF BOTH THE APPEALS AND ALLOWING THE I.A. NO. 1 OF 2O2I WITHOUT COSTS

¶185

a2
7p1<br>

Ameena begum , S. Madhavi Lata v. Mr. Ubedulla Shareef

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Ameena begum , S. Madhavi Lata v. Mr. Ubedulla Shareef

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Persika Srinivas Vs State of Telangana and Another

G Rmamana and 128 Others, Vs Prl.Secy., Finance Dept., Hyd., and 2 Others

Sk Confectionery and General Stores Vs The State of Telangana

Padmavathi Reddy Nalamada Vs The Chief Electoral Officer

Addanki Dayakar Vs Election Commission of India

Kaidala Bala Raju Vs The Land Acquisition Officer