Disposed

P. Usha Goud and 5 Others v. The State of Telangana and 7 Others

Telangana HC14 Dec 2020WP/17632/2020

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Writ petition filed requesting disposal of O.P. 18 of 2015 by Cooperative Tribunal and striking down election proceedings. Court noted elections were subsequently held and disposed of the petition by directing the Tribunal to expeditiously decide the reserved matter.

What did the court decide?

Directing the Cooperative Tribunal to list O.P. 18 of 2015 on 22.12.2020 and dispose of the matter expeditiously.

P. Usha Goud and 5 Others Vs The State of… — Writ and Judicial Review | Telangana HC (2020)

¶1

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE^{OF TELANGANA} (Special Original Jurisdiction)

¶2

IUONDAY, THE FOURTEENTH DAY OF^DECEIUBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY

¶3

PRESENT

¶4

HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE^{P. NAVEENRAO}

¶5

WRIT PETITION No. 17632 OF 2020

¶6

Between:

¶7

P. Usha Goud, S/o. Gopal^{Goud,Aged about 65 Years, Occ. Tapper,} R/o. lr/larepally Village,^{Konilapurlt4andal, Sanga Reddy (lVedak} )

¶8

Ch. Suresh Goud, S/o. Asha^{Goud, Aged about 50 Years, Occ.Tapper,} R/o, IVarepally Village,^{KondapurlVlandal,Sanga Reddy (N/edak} )

¶9

A. Anjaneyulu Goud, S/o.^{l,4alta Goud Aged} lboyl 1.5.^{years' Occ Tapper,} R/o. tviare[ally Village, Kondapur^{l,4andal,Sanga Reddy(lVedak} )

¶10

P, Ramulu Goud, S/o.^{Bala Goud, Aged about45 Years, Occ Tapper,} R/o. l,4arepally Village, Kondapur^{l,4ancini,Sanga Reddy (tt/edak)}

¶11

P. Vishnu Goud, S/o.^{Usha Goud, Aged about 43 Years, Occ Tapper'}

¶12

R/o. IVlarepally Village, Kondapur^{l,4andal,Sanga Reddy (tt/edak)}

¶13

G. Mallesh Goud, S/o.^{lVlogulaiahGoud,Agedabout 47 Years, Occ Tapper,} R/o. tr/arepally Village, Kondapur^{lVlandal,Sanga Reddy(lt/edak)}

¶14

...PETITIONERS

¶15

AND

¶16

The State of Telangana,^{Rep. by its Principal Secretary, ProhibitionExcise} Department, Secretariat Buildings,^Hyderabad

¶17

2 The Hon'ble Co-operative Tribunal,^{Rep.by its Registrar, Hyderabad.}

¶18

3 The Commissioner for Prohibition^{and Excise,Telangana State, Nampally} Station Road Hyderabad

¶19

4 The District Collector/ Election^{Authority, Jaherabad, Sanga Reddy( lVedak)}

¶20

5 The Superintendent Prohibition^{and Excise, SangaReddy( It/edak )}

¶21

Cr The Person^- lncharge / Senior^{lnspector, Sri I/l Sham Rao' O/o. Superintendent} Prohibition and Exciie, Sanga^{Reddy( lVedak)}

¶22

7 The Election Officer/ lnspector^{Prohibition and Excise, Toddy Tappers} Co-operative Society,^{l,4arepally, Sanga Reddy( tVedak} )

¶23

B tt4areoallv Toddv Taopers Co-operative^{Society Limited,lVlarepallyVillage} Kond'apui l,4andal. Sanga^{Reddy District{ lvledak)}

¶24

-..RESPONDENTS

¶25

Petition under Article 226 of^{the constitution of lndia prayingthat in the} circumstances stated in the affidavit^{filedtherewith, the HighCourt may be pleasedto} issue an appropriate writ, order^{or direction more particulariyone in the nature of} wRlT oF vnruonuus^{i) directingthe 2nd respondent herein to disposeof the oP} No. 18 of 2015 on the^file of^{the court of the Hon'ble cooperative Tribunalat} Hyderabad. ii) declaring^{the actionof the respondents 4 to 7 herein to proceed with} thl elections to be conducted to^{the 8th respondentsociety without following the} procedure of issuance of notification and^{publish the same withinthe stipulated time} as illegal, arbitrary unreasonable^{and violative of constitutionalmandates guaranteed} under the constitution^{and contrary to the provisions contemplatedunderthe} cooperatives act and^{rules made there under}

¶26

¶27

IAN O:¹ o^{F 2020}

¶28

affidavit PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatintheCircumstancesstatedinthe^{filed in supportot if'" i"tition'tne Uighr Court maybe pleased to directthe} 2nd respondent^{herein t".""tri"t} ""d^{iis;o;;off the oP No lB of 2015 on the file} of the court^{of the Hon,bre"cJoJ"iutiu" rribunar at Hyderabad, as expeditiousrv as} po..inf",^{p"nOingdisposal of the main writ petition'}

¶29

lA NO: 2^{oF 2020}

¶30

Petition under^{Section 151 CPC prayingthat in the circumstances stated in the} p"titi""'"tn6 Uigf',^{Court may be pleased to directthe} affidavit^{filed in support} "t'ii'" respondents^{No. 3 to 7 h"t;i;;oi'i;pioceed} 'iitn^{tn" elections to the Bth respondent} lollp"iutiu"^{society, pendingdisposal of the main writ petition.}

¶31

Counsel^{for the Petitioners:SRI KOPPULA GOPAL}

¶32

Counsel^{for the Respondent Nos' 1'3'5'6&7: GP FORPROHIBITION& EXCISE}

¶33

Counsel for the^{Respondent No'2: AGP FOR COOPERATION}

¶34

Counsel^{for the Respondent No'4: GP FORREVENUE}

¶35

Counsel^{for the Respondent No'8: "'-"-}

¶36

The Court^{madethe following:ORDER}

¶37

HONOURABLB^{SRI JUSTICE P. NAVEENRAO}

¶38

WRIT PETI^{TIONN0.17632of 2020}

¶39

ORAL ORDER:

¶40

Heard both^sides'

¶41

This writ^{petition is filed praying to grant two reliefs' First} limb of the^{prayer is to direct the Cooperative Tribunalat Hyderabad to} dispose of^{o.P. 18 of 2o15 expeditiously and secondlimbof prayer is to} declare^{the action of respondents4lo 7 in not conducting the elections} to 8s respondent^{society as illegal'}

¶42

However,^{when the matter is taken up' learned counselfor} petitioners^{fairlYsubmittedthat subsequentlyelections were held to} Bfi respondent^{society,therefore petitionersare not prosecuting the writ} petition with^{referenceto second limb of the prayer'}

¶43

On the issue^{of pending case before the Cooperatrve} Tribunal,^{learned AssistantGovernment Pleaderfor Cooperat'ion'on} instructions^{submittedthat earlier matter was heard by the Tribunal and} reserved^{for pronouncementof the orders' but as the Chairman of the} Tribunal^{was transferred,the casewas reopenedand it is now directedto} be listed on^{22.12.2020 and if parties appear on the dates of hearing and} maketheirsubmissions,thecasecanbedecidedexpeditiously.

¶44

Having^{regard to the above submission' writ petitionis} disposed^{of directing petitioners and respondents in O P 18 of 2015 on} thefileoftheCooperativeTribunal,Hyderabadl2"drespondenttoappear in person or^{throughcounsel on record on 22'72'2020 and make their} submissionsandsubjecttopressureofwork,theCooperativeTribunal may consider^{hearing the case on day-today basis and decide the matter} expeditiously.^{No costs Miscellaneous petitions' if any pending'are}

¶45

closed. SD/-K.AM AJI ASSISTANT^REG RAR

¶46

//TRUE COPY// SECTI OFFICER

¶47

To, 1 . The Principal Secretary,^{ProhibitionExciseDepartment'S} tate of Telangana, Secretariai Buildings,^HYderabad

¶48

The Registrar,^{Hon'ble Co-operative Tribunal, Hyderabad'}

¶49

The Commissioner^{for Prohibition and Excise' Telangana} State, NamPallY Station Road^HYderabad

¶50

.*)

¶51

¶52

The District Collector/ Election Authority, Jaherabad, Sanga Reddy (lt/edak)

¶53

The Superintendent Prohibition and Excise, Sanga Reddy (Medak).

¶54

The Person - lncharge / Senior lnspector, Sri tr,4 Sham Rao, O/o. Superintendent Prohibition and Excise, Sanga Reddy (lVedak)

¶55

The Election Officer/ lnspector Prohibition and Excise, Toddy Tappers Co-operative Society, l\ilarepally, Sanga Reddy (lVedak)

¶56

B, One C.C. to Sri.Koppula Gopal, Advocate [OPUC]

¶57

L Two CCs to GP for Prohibition and Excise, High Court for the State of Telangana. [OUT]

¶58

10.Two CCs to GP for Cooperation, High Court for the State of Telangana. [ouT]

¶59

11.Two CCs to GP for Revenue, High Court for the State of Telangana. [OUT] 12.Two C.D. Copies

¶60

Prk t A,\ I N/'.,,V ,'

HIGH COURT

DATED:1411212020

ORDER

WP. No.17632 of 2020

'l'j
1 l{ e S IA
o
o 0 5 J A N 20 21 o
.L
t'
tt
P.ra

¶67

Disposing of the WP.

¶68

S$'I \b eop^ied )v^r-a [+"^

P. Usha Goud and 5 Others v. The State of Telangana and 7 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

P. Usha Goud and 5 Others v. The State of Telangana and 7 Others

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

C.B.Chandrakala Vs Smt. Chitra Ramachandran, Ias.

Hussain Bin Ali Vs The State of Telangana and 9 Others

G. Naganna Vs The State of Andhra Pradesh and 20 Others

V.A.S. Padma Latha Vs The State of Telangana and 4 others

Banala Sanjeeva Reddy and another Vs The State of Telangana and 6 others

Kasipurarn Narayana Goud Vs State of Telangana and 7 others