Disposed

D.Kuramaiah Goud, s/o Kistaiah Goud, v. The Executive Director (Collector)

Telangana HC1 Apr 2008WP/19609/2005

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

In multiple writ petitions, individuals challenged the failure of the A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd. and revenue officials to release house construction funds. The court adjourned the hearings, directed the Collector to conduct a fresh survey to determine eligibility under the new scheme, and listed the matter again after four weeks.

What did the court decide?

Lists the matter after four weeks and directs the District Collector to conduct a fresh survey and file an inspection report regarding petitioner eligibility under the new scheme.

D.Kuramaiah Goud, s/o Kistaiah Goud, Vs The… — Company and Corporate | Telangana HC (2008)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT HYDERABAD

¶2

(SPECIAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION)

¶3

WEDNESDAY THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHT

¶4

: PRESENT :

¶5

THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE : N.V. RAMANA

¶6

W.P. Nos. 19609, 19619, 21622, 21657, 21654, 21655, 21656, 21658, 21659, 8814, 20065, 20078, 20264, 20650, 20654, 20705, 20739, 21660, 21728, 25605, 25623, 25625, 25545 and 20812 of 2005

¶7

WP.NO. 19609 OF 2005

¶8

Between:

¶9

1. D. Kuramaiah Goud, S/o Kistaiah Goud

¶10

2. Kammari Narasimhulu, S/o Kashanna

¶11

3. Boya Devamma, W/o Bichaiah

¶12

4. Narayana Reddy, S/o Kista Reddy

¶13

5. Tirupathi Reddy, S/o Kista Reddy

¶14

6. Dagadapalli Ramudu, S/o Kistaiah

¶15

7. B. Edayya, S/o Bichaiah

¶16

8. Madhavi, W/o Narasimha

¶17

9. Ch. Venkataiah, S/o Ramulaiah

¶18

10. M. Venkataiah, S/o Papaiah

¶19

( All are agriculturists and R/o Bollaram Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶20

Petitioners

¶21

AND

¶22

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶23

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶24

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶25

Respondents

¶26

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Bollaram Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶27

WP.NO. 19619 OF 2005

¶28

Between:

¶29

1. M. Srinivasulu, S/o Shankaraiah

¶30

2. D. Nagaraju, S/o Bhagawanthu

¶31

3. C. Chandrayudu, S/o Pedda Earanna

¶32

4. C. Chandramouli, S/o Ramulu

¶33

5. Venkataiah, S/o Peda Kistaiah

¶34

6. Nagendram, S/o Pedasailu

¶35

7. M. Satyanna, S/o Pentaiah

¶36

8. Nagarala Nagamma, D/o Chandraiah

¶37

9. Kotamma, W/o Seshanna

¶38

10. Sheshamma W/o Kurumaiah

¶39

( All are agriculturists and R/o Kothapeta Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

Petitioners

..2…

AND

1. The Executive Director, (Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶44

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶45

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶46

Respondents

¶47

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Kothapeta Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶48

WP.NO. 21622 OF 2005

Between:

1. K Devamma

2. T. Radhamma

3. C. Haritha

4. T. Maheshwaramma

¶54

5. Kunti Krishnaiah

¶55

6. Bala Kistamma

¶56

7. P. Lakshmidevamma

¶57

8. M. Gopalamma

¶58

9. N Radhamma

¶59

10. N. Kalavathi 11. B. Bichamma 12. Ch. Padma 13. Easwaramma 14. Sankaramma 15. K. Sayamma 16. V. Kavitha 17. S. Laxmidevamma 18. T. Narayanamma 19. S. Balamma 20. S. Sasikala

¶60

( All are agriculturists and R/o Velgonda Village, Weepanagandla Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶61

Petitioners

¶62

AND

¶63

1. The Executive Director, (Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶64

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶65

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Weepanagandla Mandal, Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District

¶66

Respondents

¶67

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Dagadapally Village, Weepanagandla Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶68

..3..

¶69

WP.NO. 21657 OF 2005 Between:

1. R. Bojjayya

2. M. Seetharam

3. M. Ramudu

4. Y. Vijayamma

5. Y. Nagamma

6. D. Chittamma

7. P. Balaswamy

8. M. Kurumaiah

9. M.Chinna Bheemaiah

¶79

10. M. Bojjanna 11. B. Ramudu 12. J. Ramaswamy 13. M. Manthaiah 14. E. Hanumanthu

¶80

15. D. VEnkatswamy

¶81

( All are R/o Nagulapalli Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶82

Petitioners

¶83

AND

¶84

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶85

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶86

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶87

Respondents

¶88

¶89

without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Nagulapalli Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶90

WP.NO. 21654 OF 2005

¶91

Between:

¶92

1. B. Narayana,

¶93

2. H. Balashantaiah

¶94

3. H. Pedda Yellaiah

¶95

4. H. Balamashaiah

¶96

5. B. Balapeer

¶97

6. Bayya Shanthaiah

¶98

7. M. Krishnaiah

¶99

8. K. Nagaseshaiah

¶100

9. S. Umadevi

¶101

10. Kummari Chendraiah

¶102

11. A. Bangaraiah

12. A. Rangamma

13. D. Kurmaiah

14. K. Chittamma

15. Vadla Santosh

¶107

( All are R/o Pasupula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶108

Petitioners

¶109

AND

¶110

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶111

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶112

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶113

Respondents

¶114

..4…

¶115

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Pasupula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶116

WP.NO. 21655 OF 2005 Between:

¶117

1. G. Ramudu

¶118

2. R. Venkateswara Reddy

3. K. Venkatiah

4. S. Sivaiah

5. J. Narsimha

6. Satyamma

7. T. Venkataswamy

8. K Ramudu

9. Jeeraiah

10. G. Balaswamy

11. N. Babu

12. G. Alivelu 13. Chandraiah 14. G. Lokanna

¶129

15. A. Ramakrishna Reddy

¶130

16. G. Laxmaiah

¶131

17. O.Chinna Hanmanthu

18. G. Devamma

19. G. Satyanna

20. M. Nagaraju

21. Md. Akbar Basha

¶136

22. P. Easwaraiah Goud

¶137

23. A. Vijay Bhaskar Reddy

¶138

24. G. Satyam

¶139

25. J. Vishnu

¶140

( All are agriculturists and R/o Miyyapuram Village, Weepanagandla Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶141

Petitioners

¶142

AND

¶143

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶144

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶145

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Weepanagandla Mandal, Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District

¶146

Respondents

¶147

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in DDRC scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Dagadapally Village, Weepanagandla Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶148

WP.NO. 21656 OF 2005 Between:

¶149

1. G. Alivelu

¶150

2. Jikki Devamma

¶151

3. Jogu Eshwaramma

¶152

…5…

¶153

4. Gunti Bhagyamma

¶154

5. Gunti Neelamma

¶155

6. Uppari Jyothi

¶156

7. N. Balaswamy

¶157

8. A. Laxmi Devamma

¶158

9. P. Pushpavathi

¶159

10. Jikki Parvathamma

¶160

11. Moddu Husenamma 12. J. Prameela 13. Cherla Devamma

¶161

14. Jogu Padamma 15. K. Balamma 16. Asper Begum

¶162

17. Jikki Eshwaramma

¶163

18. G. Devamma

¶164

19. Cherla Bakkamma

¶165

20. M.Venkataswamy

¶166

21. Y. Balachandremma

¶167

22. Laxmi Devamma

¶168

23. Pullasi Alivela

¶169

Petitioners

¶170

AND

¶171

1. The Executive Director, (Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶172

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶173

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Weepanagandla Mandal, Weepanagandlal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶174

Respondents

¶175

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in DDRC scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Pedda Bikku ( Bekkem) Village, Weepanagandal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District. WP.NO. 21658 OF 2005

Between:

1. Erla Chenama

2. Nakka Chenama

3. P. Sarojamma

4. G. Sarojamma

5. Kola Ushama

6. S. Ramulamma

7. K Chandramma

8. Laxmi Devamma

9. G.Shanthamma

10. Vijayavani

11. K. Laxmi

12. K.Kashama 13. S. Yellamma 14. B. Naramma 15. D. Vanaja

16. M Devamma

17. B. Chenamma

18. Yelamma

19. P. Bojjanna

20. Boya Venkatswamy

¶194

21. Golla Saruja 22. P. Dasharathamma

…6…

23. Ramanamma

24. Mahaboob

25. Laxmi Devamma

¶199

26. B. Krishnamma

¶200

27. B. Janamma

¶201

28. E. Ramulamma

¶202

29. S. Chandramma

¶203

Petitioners

¶204

AND

¶205

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector), A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶206

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶207

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶208

Respondents

¶209

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Sathapur Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶210

WP.NO. 21659 OF 2005

¶211

Between:

¶212

1. Goddigopula Yellamma

¶213

2. Usala Kistamma

3. Bagi Balamma

4. K. Nirjanamma

5. Beda Saroja

6. Pathireddy Jayamma

¶218

7. Midde Niranjanamma

¶219

8. Nijanapally Nagamma

¶220

9. Midde Nagamma

¶221

10. P. Vallaiah

¶222

11. Midde Bojjamma

¶223

12. Telugu Mashamma

¶224

13. Kavali yellamma

¶225

14. Jagala Ramulu

¶226

15. Gaddam Narsimha

¶227

16. Sale Nagulamma

¶228

17. Teegalapally Laxmaiah

¶229

18. Chakali Bhagavanthu

¶230

19. Katike Thirupathaiah

¶231

20. J. Sai Shanker

¶232

21. Vennacherla Venkataiah

¶233

22. Bagi Balavanthaiah

¶234

23. Vaddepd Anjaiah

¶235

24. A. Balaswamy

¶236

25. Sala Boddaiah

¶237

26. A. Sesha Chary

¶238

27. E. Konda Reddy 28. P. Swamy 29. S. Srinivasulu

¶239

30. V. Prabhakar 31. V. Shankaraiah

¶240

…7…

¶241

32. B. Nagaiah

¶242

33. M. Narasimha Reddy

34. K. Thikkaiah

Petitioners

AND

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector), A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶247

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶248

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pedakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶249

Respondents

¶250

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Devaltirmalapur Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶251

WP.NO. 8814 OF 2005

¶252

Between:

¶253

1. Golla Balaiah

¶254

2. Golla Venkataiah

¶255

3. Golla Manyam

¶256

4. Golla Laxmaiah

¶257

5. Vadde Chandraiah

¶258

6. Golla Buchanna

¶259

7. Golla Balaiah

¶260

8. Golla Kothakota Ramulu

¶261

9. Golla Srinivasulu

¶262

10. Yapachettu Nagaiah

¶263

11. Chakali Murali

¶264

12. Golla Manyam

¶265

13. Telugu Kishtaiah

¶266

14. Kummari Rangaswamy

¶267

15. Eda Shivaiah

¶268

16. Guvali Narsaiah

¶269

17. Enkali Venkataiah

¶270

18. Vadde Venkataiah

¶271

19. Vadde Manyam

¶272

20. Bathini Balaiah

¶273

21. Battini Narsimha

¶274

22. Adi Laxmaiah

¶275

23. Pyata Yeasaiah

¶276

24. Mangaduddi Balaiah

¶277

25. Mangali Galenna

¶278

26. Balaswamy Reddy

¶279

27. Vadde Buddaiah

¶280

28. Golla Nagendram 29. Ramulu, S/o Bangariah

¶281

30. Ramulu, S/o Mashanna

¶282

Petitioners

¶283

AND

¶284

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶285

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶286

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District Respondents

¶287

…8….

¶288

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPH scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Pangal Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶289

WP.NO. 20065 OF 2005

¶290

Between:

¶291

1. Telugu Satyam

¶292

2. Chakali Govind

¶293

3. B. Narasimha

¶294

4. P. Thariya

¶295

5. Telugu Krishnaiah

¶296

6. Mangali Satyam

¶297

7. Peda Devamma

¶298

8. Lambadi Lalamma

¶299

9. Sevya

¶300

10. Lambadi Laxma

¶301

Petitioners

¶302

AND

¶303

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶304

4. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶305

5. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶306

Respondents

¶307

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Korlakunta Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶308

WP.NO. 20078 OF 2005

Between:

1. Narsamma

2. Nirmalamma

3. Yelamma

4. Balamma, W/o Yerranna

¶314

5. Balamma, W/o Sayanna

6. Danamma

7. Bichimma

8. Pochamma

9. Nagamma

10. Chinna Balamma

¶320

Petitioners

¶321

AND

¶322

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶323

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶324

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶325

Respondents

¶326

…9…

¶327

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Shakapur Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶328

WP.NO. 20264 OF 2005

Between:

1. J. Gopalu

2. J. Narayana

3. Mangali lalu

4. J. Buddaiah

5. J. Swamy

6. Chittemma

7. M. Ramudu

8. Chinnaiah

9. M. Lokaiah

10. M. Narasimha

Petitioners

AND

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶343

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶344

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶345

Respondents

¶346

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶347

WP.NO. 20650 OF 2005 Between:

¶348

1. H. Kurumaiah

¶349

2. H. Narsimha

¶350

3. Peerla Kashanna

¶351

4. Jajala Kurumaiah

¶352

5. Boya Bojjaiah

¶353

6. Jajala Narasimha

¶354

7. Pudda Sailu

¶355

8. Mahankali Hanmanth

¶356

9. Pedha Balaiah

¶357

10. Ediga Sheshamma

¶358

11. Thirumalaiah

¶359

12. C. Bakki Reddy 13. H. Ramulu 14. H. Nagasheshaiah 15. Boya Venkataiah 16. V. Ramulu 17. B. Govindamma 18. T. Prabahkar 19. K. Nilakantam 20. M. Hussainamma 21. Kurva Buddaiah

¶360

…10….

¶361

22. M. Yellamma 23. V. Krishnaiah 24. T. Nagaiah 25. K. Beeraiah 26. A. Narasimha Reddy 27. C. Suvarnamma 28. A. Indiramma 29. M. Beeraiah 30. K. Nagamallaiah 31. V.S.Ramulu 32. Veeranna Goud

¶362

Petitioners

¶363

AND

¶364

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶365

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶366

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶367

Respondents

¶368

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Remaddula Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶369

WP.NO. 20654 OF 2005 Between:

¶370

1. G. Bala Kistaiah

¶371

2. T. Venkataiah 3. Golla Ramudu

¶372

4. Golla Hanmanth

5. S. Chandraiah

6. G. Thikkanna

7. Kommulaiah

8. V. Laxmaiah 9. Yerkali Bhagavanth

¶377

10. B. Ranganna 11. Boring Swamy 12. Madaru Buddaiah 13. G. Chandraiah 14. Gollabingi Nagaiag 15. V. Avenna 16. B. Buchanna 17. B. Shanthaiah 18. V. Yellamma 19. Nagamma 20. G. Venkataiah 21. N. Narsimha 22. V.Venkataiah 23. V. Buchanna 24. Golla Kurumaiah 25. G. Pentaiah 26. T. Lalaiah 27. T. Laxminarayana 28. Golla Jayalamxi Petitioners

¶378

..11..

¶379

AND

¶380

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶381

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶382

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District Respondents

¶383

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM & SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Gopulapuram Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶384

WP.NO. 20705 OF 2005

Between:

1. H. Subadramma

2. H. Sarojamma

3. M. Niranjanamma

¶389

4. M. Sarojamma

¶390

5. M. Santhamma

¶391

6. M. Tirupathamma

¶392

7. M. Nagendramma

¶393

8. N. Rathnamma

¶394

9. R. Balakistaiah

¶395

10. R. Srinivasulu

¶396

11. M. Krishnaiah

¶397

12. M. Venkataiah

¶398

13. Putta Balaswamy

¶399

14. H. Narsimha

¶400

15. Mannem

¶401

Petitioners

¶402

AND

¶403

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶404

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶405

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District Respondents

¶406

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Madhavaravupalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶407

WP.NO. 20739 OF 2005

¶408

Between:

¶409

1. G. Balaiah

¶410

2. Harijana Padmamma

¶411

3. Harijana Nagamma

¶412

4. Kummari Laxmidevamma

5. Md. Kasim

6. H. Shekhar

Petitioners

..12..

AND

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶419

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶420

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶421

Respondents

¶422

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Vallabhapuram Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District. WP.NO. 21660 OF 2005

Between:

1. Kamalamma

2. Indiramma

3. Venkatamma

4. Krishnamma

5. Boya Chittemma

¶429

6. Amruthamma

¶430

7. Satturu Madhavi

¶431

8. Kummari Balamma

¶432

9. Thumkunta Nagamma

¶433

10. Boya Shanthamma

¶434

11. V. Bharathi

¶435

12. Golla Alivelamma

¶436

13. Laxmidevamma

¶437

14. Sakali Parvathi

¶438

15. Sakali Nagamma

¶439

16. Madduru Laxmidevamma

¶440

17. Golla Nagamma

¶441

18. Vadde Sheshamma

¶442

19. Vadde Balakistamma

¶443

20. Golla Savithramma

¶444

21. Chandrakala

¶445

22. Sukanya

¶446

23. Vadde Jayamma

24. Chinna Khaja

25. Kurumaiah

Petitioners

AND

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶452

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶453

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Weepanagandla Mandal, Weepanagandla Mahaboobnagar District

¶454

Respondents

¶455

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased

¶456

t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Golapuram Village, Weepanagandla Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶457

,,,13…

¶458

WP.NO. 21728 OF 2005

¶459

Between:

¶460

1. Yerukala Laxmi Devamma

¶461

2. P. Bakkamma

¶462

3. Bhagyamma

¶463

4. K. Bokkalamma 5. P. Ramulamma 6. Ch. Vallamma 7. A. Laxmi Devamma

¶464

8. Eshwaramma 9. Ranimma 10. Pagadala Alivelamma 11. D. Venkatamma 12. Sarojamma 13. Beeramma 14. M.Gangamma 15. Gangamma 16. Gunti Vijaya 17. G. Neeranjanamma 18. G.Ramulamma 19. B. Chennamma 20. M. Yellamma 21. Telugu Balamma 22. B. Nagamma 23. G. Sugunamma 24. Pedda Neeranjanamma

¶465

25. Kakam Bakkamma

¶466

Petitioners

¶467

AND

¶468

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶469

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶470

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶471

Respondents

¶472

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in SRQ scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Gantraopally Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶473

WP.NO. 25605 OF 2005

¶474

Between:

¶475

1. K. Rangaswamy

¶476

2. M. Chinna Narasimha

¶477

3. Ramudu

¶478

4. Chinna Narsimha

5. Shashanna

6. Balamma

7. Balaiah

8. Eerta Satyam

9. Narasimha

10. Chinna Chandraiah

11. Balakistaiah

12. Sahadevudu

13. Krishnamma

14. Lilavathi

15. Putta Balaswamy

¶490

…14…

¶491

16. Katam Manyam

¶492

17. Katam Nagisetty

¶493

18. Putta Ramudu

¶494

19. Putta Balaswamy

¶495

20. Putta Krishnaiah

¶496

Petitioners

¶497

AND

¶498

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶499

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶500

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District Respondents

¶501

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPH scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Rainipally Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶502

WP.NO. 25623 OF 2005 Between:

¶503

1. Boya Jambulamma

¶504

2. Bokkalamma

¶505

3. Kammari Eeswaramma

¶506

4. Vadde Yellamma

¶507

5. Telugu Parvathamma

¶508

6. Balakistamma

¶509

7. Boya Channamma

¶510

8. Saddala Channamma

¶511

9. Chetikala Channamma

¶512

10. Boya Pullamma

¶513

11. Boya Lakshmi

¶514

12. Kesham Balakistamma

¶515

13. Boya Venkatamma

¶516

14. Golla Kurvamma

¶517

15. Golla Chittamma

¶518

16. Golla Balamma

¶519

17. Golla Manthamma

¶520

18. Vadda Krishna

¶521

19. Telugu Chandramma

¶522

20. Ghousia Begum

¶523

Petitioners

¶524

AND

¶525

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶526

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶527

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Koodair Mandal, Koodair, Mahaboobnagar District

¶528

Respondents

¶529

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPH scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Rajapoor Village, Koodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶530

..15…

¶531

WP.NO. 25625 OF 2005

¶532

Between:

¶533

1. Yerrolla Jallaiah

¶534

2. Sevakutla Kistaiah

¶535

3. Telugu Parvathalu

¶536

4. Yerrolla Seshaiah

¶537

5. Gajjala Ramudu

¶538

6. Singalpau Balamma

¶539

7. Kammari Achari

¶540

8. Kodeti Peddaramudu

¶541

9. Gajjala Sayanna

¶542

10. Kavaal Nagendram

¶543

11. Kavali Manthaih

¶544

12. Yedurinti Kurmaiah

¶545

13. Remuddula Kistaiah

¶546

14. G. Balaswamy

¶547

15. Golla Nadipanna

¶548

16. Golla Yellamma

¶549

17. Golla Chinnaiah

¶550

18. Golla Balaiah

¶551

19. Golla Chandraiah

¶552

20. Kotte Chennamma

¶553

21. Golla Seshaiah

¶554

22. Pedda Bhagavanthu

¶555

23. H. Thirupathaiah

¶556

24. H. Gangaiah

¶557

25. H. Mantharalaiah

¶558

26. Godugu Ramulu

¶559

27. P. Bhagyalaxmi

¶560

28. Kavali Sheshaiah

¶561

29. Kavali Hanmanthu

¶562

30. Golla Bhagvanthu

¶563

31. Chakali Srinivasulu

¶564

32. Chakali Venkataiah

¶565

33. Chakali Venkataswamy

¶566

34. Kummari Yerra Nagaiah

¶567

Petitioners

¶568

AND

¶569

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶570

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶571

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Koodair Mandal, Koodair, Mahaboobnagar District

¶572

Respondents

¶573

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPH scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Janumpalli Village, Koodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶574

WP.NO. 25545 OF 2005

¶575

Between:

¶576

1. Dussa Narsimha

¶577

2. Pittala Beeraiah

3. Sakhinabee

4. Yeturu Laxmi

5. Mule Laxmi

6. Ninala Sri Ramulu

¶582

…16…

¶583

7. Noorajaha Begum

¶584

8. Sarojamma

¶585

9. P. Naganna

¶586

10. Battina Narsaiah

¶587

11. Devanna

¶588

12. Mala Krishnaiah

¶589

13. Md. Jafar

¶590

14. Md. Jahangeer

¶591

15. Khutubaddin

¶592

16. Shabaddin

¶593

17. Boya Poshanna

¶594

18. Basurun Begum

¶595

19. Sunnapu Jambulu

¶596

20. Telugu Srini

¶597

21. Boya Narsimha

¶598

22. Boya Krishnaiah

¶599

23. Malleshwaram Ramudu

¶600

24. Kammari Pushpavathi

¶601

25. Ninala Beesamma

¶602

26. Boya Chandraiah

¶603

27. Natti Bichanna

¶604

28. Mule Chandraiah

¶605

29. M. Srinu

¶606

30. Boya Krishnaiah

31. Manikyam

32. Nagarajamma

33. Sadiq Pasha

34. Kothapeta Ramudu

¶611

35. Surendra Chary

¶612

36. Sogara Bee

¶613

37. Pula Venkateswarlu

¶614

38. Adem Baleeshwari

¶615

39. Marrikanti Alivela

¶616

40. Khajabanu

¶617

41. Boya Chittamma 42. Venkata Laxmi 43. Laxmi Kalvatamma 44. Nayani Balaswamy 45. Avula Kistaiah 46. Boya Balaswamy 47. Balapari Chinna Ramudu 48. Shaheda Begum 49. Telugu Pedda Balamma 50. K. Saroja 51. Md. Yousuf 52. Kuruva Mallaiah 53. B. Eashwaramma 54. Nagamma 55. Boya Baleshwari 56. S. Laxmi Devamma 57. B. Jambulaiah 58. K Sayamma 59. Mayakapogula Balamma 60. B. Chinna Yellaiah 61. M. Eashwaramma 62. Jilani Begum 63. Sharada Bai 64. Kotla Laxmi Devi 65. Md. Moinu 66. Riksha Pasha 67. Md. Moinu 68. Krishnaiah

…17…

69. Boya Ravi

70. Krishnaiah

71. Boya Nagaraju

¶622

72. Kothapeta Ramudu

¶623

73. Kothapeta Venkataswamy

¶624

74. Boya Nageseshi

¶625

75. Bajjila Ramudu

¶626

76. Ahmed Hussain

77. Nagaseshi

78. Shanthamma

79. Seshi Goud

80. Kavali Chinna Chinnamma

¶631

81. Md. Moinuddin

¶632

82. Md. Saleem

¶633

83. Jangam Nagamma

¶634

84. P. Shanthanna

¶635

85. Chinthakunta Narsimha

¶636

86. K Venkataswamy

¶637

87. Rama Krishna

¶638

88. Md. Saleema

¶639

89. Pooru Balaswamy

¶640

90. Laxmi

¶641

91. Alakunta Manikyamma

¶642

92. Boya Venkatamma

¶643

93. Md. Khaja Bee

¶644

94. Khajabanu

¶645

95. Venkataswamy

¶646

96. Neelam Venkateswarlu

¶647

97. Jam Saraswathamma

¶648

98. Bicha Bai

¶649

99. Boya Narayanamma 100. Krishnaiah 101. Byagari Kumaraswamy 102. M. Bhaskar Goud 103. Manikyamma 104. M. Syamala 105. P. Venkatesh Goud 106. Telugu Anjaneyulu 107. Boya Narasimha 108. Bhaskar Goud 109. A. Krishnaiah Goud 110. Narsipalli Krishnaiah 111. Kothapeta Dharmaiah 112. Guri Pullaiah 113. Boya Ramakrishna 114. K. Venkatesh Goud 115. K. Shankar Goud 116. Bandari Niranjan Goud 117. Vadla Narayana 118. Alkunta Laxmidevamma 119. Kothapeta Venkataiah 120. Eashwaramma

¶650

Petitioners

¶651

AND

¶652

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶653

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶654

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Kollapur Mandal, Kollapur, Mahaboobnagar District

¶655

Respondents

¶656

…18…

¶657

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPH scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Pentlavalli Village, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶658

WP.NO. 20812 OF 2005

Between:

1. Aggaramma

2. K. Kurmanna

3. K. Danaiah

4. M. Devaiah

5. M. Venkataiah

Petitioners

¶666

AND

¶667

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar

¶668

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboohbnagar

¶669

3. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶670

Respondents

¶671

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the Affidavit filed herein, the High Court will be pleased t o issue a writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of mandamus declaring the action of the respondents in not paying the amounts for the construction of houses in RPM scheme to the petitioners as illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction and direct the respondents to release the amounts allotted to the construction of houses to the petitioners situated at Bahudoorgudeum Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.

¶672

These petitions coming on for hearing, upon perusing the petitions and the affidavits filed herein, and the order of the High court dated 29-01-2008 made herein and upon hearing the arguments of Sri V. Maohar Rao, Advocate for the Petitioners in all the Petitions, and of Sri P. Uday Bhaskar Rao, S.C. for A.P.State Housing Corporation Ltd., for the respondents 1 and 2 in all the petitions, and of G.P for Revenue for the Respondent No.3 in all the Petitions, the Court made the following:

¶673

ORDER:

¶674

Pursuant to the orders of this court dated 29-1-2008 the 1^st

¶675

respondent-District Collector, Mahbubnagar appeared in person and filed the counter affidavit.

¶676

Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners as well as the learned Govt. Pleader for Revenue.

¶677

The learned Govt. Pleader requests four weeks time to conduct fresh survey and to file an inspection report about the eligibility of the petitioners for granting under the new scheme in view of cancellation of the old scheme.

¶678

List after four weeks. The presence of the 1^st respondent-District Collector is dispensed with for the present.

¶679

ASSISTANT REGISTRAR // TRUE COPY //

¶680

for ASSISTANT REGISTRAR

¶681

¶682

1. The Executive Director, ( Collector) A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., District Branch, Mahaboobnagar ( BY SPEED POST)

¶683

2. The District Manager, A.P. State Housing Corporation Ltd., Mahaboobnagar

¶684

3. The Mandal Revenue officer, Weepanagandala mandal, Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District

¶685

4. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Kollapur Mandal, Kollapur, Mahaboobnagar District

¶686

5. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶687

6. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶688

7. The Mandal Revenue Officer, Pangal Mandal, Pangal, Mahaboobnagar District

¶689

8. Two CC’s to G.P for Revenue, High Court of A.P., Hyderabad ( BY SPECIAL MESSENGER)

¶690

9. One CC to Sri V. Manohar Rao, Advocate (OPUC)

¶691

10. One CC to Sri P. Uday Bhasker, Advocate (OPUC)

¶692

11. One Spare Copy

¶693

HIGH COURT

¶694

NVR,J

¶695

DATED : 13-02-2008

¶696

LIST AFTER FOUR WEEKS.

¶697

ORDER

¶698

W.P. Nos. 19609, 19619, 21622, 21657, 21654, 21655, 21656, 21658, 21659, 8814, 20065, 20078, 20264, 20650, 20654, 20705, 20739, 21660, 21728, 25605, 25623, 25625, 25545 and 20812 of 2005

DIRECTION

HIGH COURT

NVR,J

DATED : 13-02-2008

¶703

POST AFTER FOUR WEEKS.

¶704

ORDER

¶705

W.P. Nos. 19609, 19619, 21622, 21657, 21654, 21655, 21656, 21658, 21659, 8814, 20065, 20078, 20264, 20650, 20654, 20705, 20739, 21660, 21728, 25605, 25623, 25625, 25545 and

¶706

20812 of 2005

¶707

DIRECTION

D.Kuramaiah Goud, s/o Kistaiah Goud, v. The Executive Director (Collector)

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

D.Kuramaiah Goud, s/o Kistaiah Goud, v. The Executive Director (Collector)

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

V. Uma Maheswar Rao S/o nageswar Rao Vs Special Officer and Competent Authority, Urban Land Ceiling

Bariki Babu Vs The Govt of Andhra Pradesh, rep.by its Secretary to

B.Athawullah, Vs The Government of Andhra Pradesh represented by its

M/s. Sahara Travels, Rep. by Smt. Kaneez Fathima, Vs The Secretary, State Transport Authority

Narsamma, Vs The Collector and Executive Director

Sri R.a.Sukumar, Vs National Shiop Design and Research Centre