Radheyshyam and Anr. v. State of Rajasthan and Anr.
Case brief
What is this about?
Misc. Petition No. 1625/2017 1.Radhey Shyam…
Misc. Petition No. 1625/2017 1.Radhey Shyam…
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
-1-
र�जस � �न�उच � �न � ���ल��ज�प�र�प�ठ�ज�प�र
आद�श
S. B. Criminal Misc. Petition No. 1625/2017
2. Sita Ram S/o Laxminarayan by caste yadav Both resident of Hathoj , P.S. Kardhani, Distt. Jaipur west ...Accused-petitioners
Versus
आद�श�ददन��क: 18 मई� , 2017
म�नन����न � ���ध�पत���श��बनव�र"�ल�ल�शम�#
श��श�र�म���दव�अध�वक������गण�क(�ओर�स
श��जज��न,�श�म�ल"��ववद�न/�ल0क�अभ2�0जक�व�स� � र�ज�
--
����-अभ2��कगण�न �ह���ध�क����र�-482 दण6�पक9���स�दह���क� प�व��न:�क���ह��पस� � �कर�उनक��ववरद�प�भलस���न�- कर�न��जजल��ज�प�र पज=म�अन�ग#����र�-143,323,447 2�र����दण6�स�दह���एव � ��र�-3(1)(D) अन�स?ध���ज�त�/जन�ज�त�� (अत����र�तनव�रण� ) अध�तन�म�क0�तनरस��कक�� ज�न � क(�प��#न��क(�हA।
पकरण�क��स�कDप��थ��इस�पक�र�हA�कक�अ�����स�ख��-2 पररव�द"�श� प�म��नद�वम�#�न � ददन��क� 18.1.2007 क0�एक�भलखK��ररप0र#�प�भलस���न�कर�न�, ज�प�र�पज=म�मM�इस�आश��क(�दज#�करव����कक�:-
-2-
''स�व��मM�श�म�न/���न�ध�क�र"�मह0द��प�भलस���न�कर�न���ज�प�र�पज=म�ववष��ररप0र#�दज#�कर�न� ब�ब�।�मह0द�, उपर0क�ववष��न�ग#��तनव�दन�हA�कक�मO प�म�नद�वम�#�प�त�श��पहल�द�र�म�वम�#�तनव�स��ब�-90 ग�ऊण6�फल0र�कर�न���0जन��क�लव�ड�र0ड, ज�प�र�मM तनव�स�कर���ह?�।�म�र��एक�पलVर�न�.58 आदश#�ववह�र क�लव�ड�र0ड�ज�प�र�पर�जस���हA।�उक�पलVर�मOन� जरर� � रजजसW"�श��जगम0हन�भस�ह�ब�द"�प�त�सव. श��ज� एस�ब�द"�स � Kर"द�कक����������मXक��पर�कबज� स�2ल��भल�����।�उक�पलVर�क(�मO�सम��सम��पर स�र�स�2�ल�कर���आ�रह��ह? � ।�मO�उम�र � उक�पलVर�पर आज�ददन��क� 18.1.17 क0�सम��कर"ब� 10.30 ए�एम पर�तनम�#ण�क��#�करन � क��भलए�अपन � स���स � 0श�ज� ��दव�बल2�र�मज����दव�क�र"गर�व�म�ह��#�क��भलए�द0 प�ड6�0�क��स���ग������जह� � पर�मOन � पल�र�क��म�ह?�# लग�न � क��भलए�न�व�K0दन����ल?�कक����0�वह� � पर अ��नक�ल�दठ���ल�कर�स���र�म�प�त�लकम�णन�र��ण व�स���र�म�क��लडक��मन�ष�एक�र���ह0कर�म�र� पल�र�पर�आ� � और�ग�ल"�गलX��करन � लग��व�कहन� ललग � कक�उक�सक(म�मM���र��क���ल�न��द�न��हA�कह�� ह�ए�म�र � स���ग�ल"�गलX��करन � लग � व�म�र � धगर�ब�र पकडकर�म�रप�र�करन पर�उ��र�ह0�ग� �0�मOन� उउनक0�समझ�� � ह�ए�ब�����कक�उक�पलVर�मOन � जरर�� रजजसW"�Kर"द�कर�रK��हA�व�क�गज���ददK�� � �0 स���र�म�व�र���श��म�न � क�गज���पढकर�ध�लल��� ह�ए�कह��कक�� �0�रAगर, बल�ई�:�क��हO, इसक0 कVल0न��मM�नह" � रहन � दMग � व�म�र क0�ज�त��स?�क ग�भल�� � द�न � लग � व�म�रप�र�करन � पर�उ��/र�ह0�ग�� व�क0र#�सर पल�र�क��क�म�रकव� ब��� � ह�ए�म�र दद��।�म�र"�ज�नक�र"�मM�म�र � पल�र�क��Kसर��नमबर पर�क0ई�क0र#�सर � नह" � हA।�झगड � क��बढ���द�Kकर श0र�शर�ब�स�नकर�आस�पडXस��म�र � पल�र�पर�आ�ग�� व0�कहन � लग � कक�म�र उक�पल�र�क��क�श�क�र�व Kसर��नमबर�अलग�हA�इस�पर�क0र#�सर � नह" � हA�हम
-3-
कVल0न��व�ल:�क0�2��क0ई�आपवc�नह" � हA�।�इस�पर उक�स2��न म�र स���ज�त��स?�क�शबद:�स� अपम�तन��कर� ह�ए�ग�ल"�गलX��करन लग व कVल0न�व�भस�:�क��स���2��ग�ल"�गलX��करन � लग � व कहन � लग � ��म�कVल0न��व�ल:�क0�2���Aन�स � नह"� रहन � दMग � व�इस�पल�र�मM�मक�न�नह" � बनन � दMग � व स���र�म�व�इनक��पररव�र�व�ल:�न � म�झ � �मक(�द"�कक �?�इस�पल�र�पर�मक�न�बन�ओ�ग � �0���मह�र � ह���प��व �0ड�दMग � व�ज�न�स � म�र�दMग�।�ररप0र#�कर���ह? � क�न?न� क��#व�ह"�करन � क(�कd प��कर�।''
उक�ररप0र#�पर�आलXच��एफ�आई�आर�स�ख��-47/2017 अन�ग#����र�143,323,447 2�र����दण6�स�दह���एव ��र�-3(1)(D) अन�स?ध���ज�त�/जन ज�त�( अत����र�तनव�रण) अध�तन�म�मM�दज#�क(�ज�कर�अन�स � �न�प�रम2 कक���ग��।�पकरण�व�#म�न�मM�अन�स � �न���न�हA।
ववद�न/�अध�वक������गण�श��एस�आर���दव�न � तनव�दन�कक���हA�कक प�म�स?�न��ररप0र#�मM�अ�����स�ख��-2 पररव�द"�न � कह" � पर�2���ह�नह"� ब�����हA�कक�वह�अन�स?ध���ज�त��क��सदस��हA�।�म�रन � प�रन � क��क0ई आर0प�नह" � लग����ग���हA�।�कफर�2��प�भलस�न � उक��थ�:�पर�प�म�स?�न� ररप0र#�दज#�क(�हA, ज0�तनरस��कक� � ज�न � �0ग��हA।�उनह0न � तनव�दन�कक���हA�कक प�म�स?�न��ररप0र#�मM���न�व�डक�:�क��ब�र � मM�ब�����ग���हA�जबकक�प�भलस न � न�म�प� � �व�डक�:�क��भलK � हO, ��न�क��आग � अन��व�डक�:�क��क0ई�कd त� नह" भलK��हA।�अ�: ��ध�क��सव�क�र�क(�ज�कर�����गण�क��ववरद�दज# आलXच��एफ�आई�आर�क0�तनरस��कक���ज�व�।
उक��कh�क��ववर0��कर� � ह�ए�ववद�न/�ल0क�अभ2�0जक�श��जज��न, श�म�ल"�न � तनव�दन�कक���हA�कक�����गण�क��न�म�पररव�द"�न � अपन � प�भलस ब��न:�मM�ब�����हA�����क��#व�ह"�प�भलस�मM�पररव�द"�न � अपन��ज�त��बल�ई ब�����हA, ज0�अन�स?ध���ज�त��क��ह0न��पकर�ह0���हA।�उनह0न � तनव�दन�कक�� हA�कक�����गण�पर�पररव�द"�क��पलVर�पर�म�ह�#�करन � क��भलए�ज�न � पर आपर�ध�क�अत����र�कर�उसक��गल��पकडकर�उस � अपशबद�कहन � क��गम2�र आर0प�हA।�अ�: प�म�स?�न��ररप0र#�क0�तनरस��कक� � ज�न � क��क0ई�आ��र�नह"� हA।
-4-
उ2��पD�क���कh�पर�वव��र�कक���ग��।
म�नन���सवiच��न���ल��न � हरर��ण��र�ज���बन�म��X�र"�2जन�ल�ल एव � अन��ए.आई.आर. 1992 एस.स�. 604 मM�प�म�स?�न��ररप0र#�क0�तनरस� कक� � ज�न � क��तनमन�स���आ��र�ब��� � हO�:-
“ 108. In the backdrop of the interpretation of the various relevant provisions of the Code under Chapter XIV and of the principles of law enunciated by this Court in a series of decisions relating to the exercise of the extra-ordinary power under Article 226 or the inherent powers Under Section 482 of the Code which we have extracted and reproduced above, we give the following categories of cases by way of illustration wherein such power could be exercised either to prevent abuse of the process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice, though it may not be possible to lay down any precise, clearly defined and sufficiently channelised and inflexible guidelines or rigid formulae and to give an exhaustive list of myriad kinds of cases wherein such power should be exercised.
1. Where the allegations made in the First Information Report or the complaint, even if they are taken at their face value and accepted in their entirety do not prima-facie constitute any offence or make out a case against the accused.
2. Where the allegations in the First Information Report and other materials, if any, accompanying the F.I.R. do not disclose a cognizable offence, justifying an investigation by police officers Under Section 156(1) of the Code except under an order of a Magistrate within the purview of Section 155(2) of the Code.
3. Where the uncontroverted allegations made in the FIR or complaint and the evidence collected in support of the same do not disclose the commission of any offence and make out a case against the accused.
-5-
4. Where, the allegations in the F.I.R. do not constitute a cognizable offence but constitute only a non-cognizable offence, no investigation is permitted by a police officer without an order of a Magistrate as contemplated Under Section 155(2) of the Code.
5. Where the allegations made in the FIR or complaint are so absurd and inherently improbable on the basis of which no prudent person can ever reach a just conclusion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding against the accused.
6. Where there is an express legal bar engrafted in any of the provisions of the Code or the concerned Act (under which a criminal proceeding is instituted) to the institution and continuance of the proceedings and/or where there is a specific provision in the Code or the concerned Act, providing efficacious redress for the grievance of the aggrieved party.
हस�ग��पकरण�मM�जह� � �क�ज�त��क��पश�हA, क��#व�ह"�प�भलस�मM अ�����पररव�द"�न � अपन��ज�त��बल�ई�सपष�रप�स � दज#�क(�ह�ई�हA�।�पररव�द" न � पलVर�पर�अपन��कबज��ह0न��ब�����हA�����उसक��कबज � क��पलVर�पर अभ2��कगण�द�र��आपर�ध�क�अत���र�करन � पर�उसक��गल��पकडकर�व�ज�त� स?�क�शबद:�स � अपम�तन��करन � क��आर0प�लग����हA।���र�-161 दण6�पक9�� स�दह���क��क�न:�मM�उसन � ����गण�क��न�म�2��ब�����हA।
ऐस��जस�त��मM�उक�न��त�क�दष�न��क��पररप�क��मM�उक�स��:�आ��र0 मM�स � एक�2��आ��र�प�म�स?�न��ररप0र#�क0�तनरस��कक� � ज�न � क��पकर�नह"� ह0���हA।
-6-
ल�ककन��दद�����गण�क(�ओर�स � आज�स � दस�ददवस�क��2��र�अन�स � �न अध�क�र"�क��समD�पत�व�दन�म��दस��व�ज�क��प�श�कक���ज����हA, �0 अन�स � �न�अध�क�र"�स � अप�D��क(�ज����हA�कक�व � उक��थ�:�पर�अन�स � �न�क� दXर�न�वव��र�कर�पकरण�क��सवचn�व�तनषपD�अन�स � �न�प?ण#�कर�अपन� तनषकष#���र�-173(2) दण6�पक9���स�दह���क��प�व��न:�क���ह��श�घ समबजन���न����ल��मM�प�श�करMग�।
�दन�स�र���ध�क��क��तनस��रण�कक���ज����हA।�उक�जस�त��मM�स�लगन स�गन�प��#न��पत�2��ए�दन�स�र�तनस��रर��कक���ज����हA।�
( न � � 0 बनव�र"�ल�ल�शम�#� )
अतनलशम�/-M-46
Radhey Shyam S/o Laxminarayan
Sita Ram S/o Laxminarayan
State of Rajasthan
Prem Chand Verma
榮譽法官
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court