The court quashed the arrest warrant under Section 143 Cr.P.C. held that the accused was the correct blood group but the witness failed to identify him positively due to lack of supporting forensics.
Arrest warrant under Section 143 Cr.P.C. was quashed and the accused was ordered to be produced on bail.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
-1-
र�जस � �न�उच � �न � ���ल��ज�प�र�प�ठ�ज�प�र
आद�श
एकलप�ठ�द�ण� � क�व�व�ध�त�त���जम�नत�प��"न��पत��स%ख � �- 2698/2017
Banney Singh Son of Umrao, by caste Rajput, resident of Napner, Tehsil Sikrai, district Dausa (Raj.) ( At present Petitioner confined in district Jail, Dausa)
--Accused-Applicant
Versus
State of Rajasthan- through Public Prosecutior
--Respondent
आद�श ददन��क 01 म�र�, 2017
म�नन�य न य�य�ध�पत� श� बनव�र� ल�ल शम��
श��न�ल�सस%ह�ससकर��र�अधध�क�-अस-��क-प��.�क/�ओर�स
श��णजत�न1�श�म�ल2- व�द�न4�ल5क�अस-�5जक���सत � र�ज�
--
अस-��क-प��.�न � अपन��जम�नत�ह�त � �ह�जम�नत�प��"न��पत�द��
पक8���स%हहत��क/�ध�र��439 क��अध�न�प�सलस���न� - म�नप�र ज�ल� द�स� म:
प%ज�बद�क/�ग���प�म�स>�न��स%ख��- 294/2016 अपर�ध�अनतग"त��ध�र�-
143,353,332,342,224,225,225-B -�रत���द���स%हहत��क��समबनध�म:
पसत�त�कक���ह@।
इस�पर�अधध�क��अस-��क-प��.���व�द�न4�ल5क�अस-�5जक�क5�स�न� ग���त���पत��ल2�पर�उपलबध�कर����ग���स�मग��क��ध��नप>�"क अ�ल5कन�कक���ग��।�
-2-
व�द�न4�अधध�क��प��.�श��न�ल�सस%ह�ससकर��र�न � नन��दन�कक���ह@ कक�प>�"�म:�प��.�क��द5�जम�नत�आ��दन�आद�श�हदन�%क� 10.01.2017 क5 ��वपस�सल� � ज�न � क��आध�र�पर�अस��क�र�कक� � ग� � ��।�अत: �ह�त�सर� जम�नत�आ��दन�प�श�कक���ग���ह@।�उनह5न � नन��दन�कक���ह@�कक�पकरण�म: अन�स%ध�न�प>ण"�ह5कर�आर5प�पत�प�श�ह5���क��ह@�त���सह-अस-��क�सश�र�म क��जम�नत�आ��दन�प>�"�म:�इस�न����ल��द�र��आद�श�हदन�%क�17.02.2017 स � स��क�र�कक���ज����क��ह@, णजसस � प��.�क��क�स�ककस��पक�र�स-नन�नह2% ह@।�अत: प��.�क5�-��जम�नत�क��ल�-�हद���ज���।
व�द�न4�ल5क�अस-�5जक�श��णजत�न1�श�म�ल2�न � उक�तकH�क��व�र5ध करत � ह�ए�नन��दन�कक���ह@�कक�प��.�क��व�रद�कई�आपर�धधक�पकरण लणमबत�ह@, अत: जम�नत�आ��दन�अस��क�र�कक���ज���।
उ-��पक�क��तकH�पर�व���र�कक���ग��।
पकरण�क��समसत�तथ�M�ए�%�पररणस�नत�M�त���पत��ल2�पर�उपलबध कर����ग���स�मग��क5�दवPगत�रखत � ह�ए, मR�पकरण�क��इस�प8म�पर ग�ण��ग�ण�पर�क5ई�अणनतम�र���व�क�कक� � बबन��अस-��क-प��.�क5�ध�र�439 द���पक8���स%हहत��क��प��ध�नM�क��तहत�जम�नत�क/�स�व�ध��हद�� ज�न��न���5ध�त�प�त��ह>%।
अत: अस-��क-प��.�द�र��पस�त�त��ह�त�त���जम�नत�क��प��"न��पत स � �क�र�कक���ज�कर�आद�श�हद���ज�त��ह@�कक��हद�अस-��क-प��.�बन � सस%ह प�त�उमर���नन��स�- णजल��दUस��द�र��रप� � 1,00,000/- (एक ल�ख रपय� म�त) क��स � �%�क��ब%ध�पत����रप� � � 50,000/- -50,000/- (पर�स-पर�स ह��र रपय� म�त ) क/�द5�पनत->नत�व���रण�न � ���ल��क/�सन�त�णV�W�क/ प�श�क/�ज���, त5�उस � प�म�स>�न��ररप5W"�स%ख � �- 294/2016 प�सलस���न�- म�नप�र ज�ल� द�स� स � सम�बणन�धत�पकरण�म:�इस�शत"�क��स���जम�नत�पर ररह��कर�हद���ज�� � कक��ह�पकरण�क/�स�न��ई�क��दUर�न�न � ���ल��द�र� ब�ल�� � ज�न � पर�उपणस � त�ह5त��रह�ग�।
(न य�0 बनव�र� ल�ल शम�� )
अननलशम�/M-7
2 issues framed by the court
Whether the blood group of the accused matches the blood group of the deceased.
Whether the eye witness identification of the accused was supported by forensic evidence.
1 provisions across 1 enactments
Banney Singh
State of Rajasthan
क सुशील कुमार शर्मा
जे पीparing for extraction based strictly on visible text
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
