chal l enge and af t er t he depar t ment al exami nat i on was hel d by AMD, Jai pur on 15. 03. 2002 cer t ai nl y t he pet i t i oner al so had an oppor t uni t y t o appear i n t he wr i t t en exami nat i on but i f he has not chosen t o appear , he f or go hi s cl ai m and t he pr omot i on whi ch was of f er ed t o Sh. T. Anj aneya Menon vi de or der dt . 01. 02. 2007 cer t ai nl y cannot be consi der ed t o be a f r esh cause of act i on and t hat apar t we al so do not f i nd any subst ance i n t he submi ssi on made f or t he r eason t hat once t hese ar e t wo separ at e const i t uent s of DAE, af t er bei ng t r ansf er r ed f r om one const i t uent uni t t o t he ot her on hi s own r equest wher e he l ost hi s seni or i t y but t he depar t ment al qual i f yi ng exami nat i on bei ng separ at el y conduct ed/ hel d by bot h t he t wo separ at e const i t uent uni t s and af t er bei ng t r ansf er r ed t o AMD, Jai pur cer t ai nl y t he empl oyees of AMD, Jai pur const i t ut e homogeneous cl ass of empl oyees t o be consi der ed f or pr omot i on agai nst 25% quot a r eser ved f or depar t ment al qual i f yi ng exami nat i on and despi t e oppor t uni t y bei ng avai l abl e t o t he pet i t i oner t o appear i n t he depar t ment al exami nat i on hel d by AMD, Jai pur at l east he cannot have any l ocus t o say t hat wi t hout qual i f yi ng t he depar t ment al qual i f yi ng exami nat i on conduct ed by AMD, Jai pur he i s el i gi bl e t o be consi der ed f or pr omot i on agai nst 25% quot a t o be f i l l ed by depar t ment al qual i f yi ng exami nat i on on t he basi s of hi s one t i me empanel ment f or t he post of St enogr apher Gr ade- I I whi l e bei ng post ed i n BARC at Sr i nagar and t hi s what t he Ld. Tr i bunal al so consi der ed whi l e r epel l i ng hi s cont ent i on vi de or der
