Dismissed

Ginder Singh @ Mandar Singh and Others v. Jasbir Singh

Punjab & Haryana HC22 Apr 2022RSA/293/2020

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This is a Regular Second Appeal against a First Appellate Court judgment dismissing a suit for injunction challenging a Gift Deed. The Court dismissed the appeal, upholding the finding that the grantor had exclusive possession and acknowledged the donee's possession via a decree.

What did the court decide?

The Second Appeal was dismissed. All pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were disposed of.

Ginder Singh @ Mandar Singh and Others Vs Jasbir Singh — Partition | Punjab & Haryana HC (2022)

¶1

�� 

¶2

��

¶3

�� !�"#��$%!$&��'�('��

¶4

GINDER SINGH @ MANDAR SINGH AND OTHERS ''�))!�+ ,**

¶5

-!$,.,

¶6

JASBIR SINGH ��''�!,)"+%!+

¶7

��&��/�0��'��0�1��0 Present: Mr. Ashdeep Singh, Advocate for the Appellants.

¶8

��0�1��02��$�*�

¶9

While assailing the findings of fact arrived at by the First Appellate Court, the defendants have filed the present Regular Second Appeal. In fact, the parties to the litigation are members of a family. In order to understand their �� relationship, a small pedigree table is being drawn:-

¶10

Sh.Atma Singh ↓

¶11

————————————————————— ↓ ↓ ↓ Ginder Singh @ Gurjant Singh Baljinder Kaur Mandar Singh ↓ ↓ Jasbir Singh

¶12

Satnam Singh

¶13

Sh. Atma Singh gifted 26 kanals and 15 marlas of land comprised in Khewat No.66, Khatauni No.81, Khasra Nos.36//14/2(1-7), 17(8-0), 36//24(8-0), 25(8-0) and 37//21/1(1-8) to Jasbir Singh, vide registered gift deed No.4508 dated 01.03.2013. Thereafter, Sh. Atma Singh delivered possession of the land gifted to Jasbir Singh vide Civil Court decree dated 20.04.2013. As per the jamabandi for the year 2010-11, Sh. Atma Singh was exclusive owner of the suit property who had gifted that property to his grand-children.

¶14

The defendants denied the execution of the gift deed by Sh. Atma Singh. It was also asserted that Sh. Atma Singh has filed a suit MOHD AYUB 2022.04.26 11:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document.

¶15

��

¶16

��

¶17

challenging the gift deed. The learned trial Court dismissed the suit for grant of decree of injunction on the ground that the parties are co-sharers. The learned First Appellate Court after re-appreciating the evidence found that Sh. Atma Singh was in exclusive possession and thereafter, it is Jasbir Singh who is in exclusive possession of the property which was a subject matter of gift deed.

¶18

It may be noted here that the suit filed by Sh. Atma Singh challenging the gift deed has already been dismissed, though, an appeal is pending.

¶19

This Bench has heard the learned counsel representing the appellants at length and with his able assistance perused the paperbook.

¶20

The learned counsel representing the appellants contend that the parties are co-sharers and therefore, the suit for injunction was not maintainable. The learned First Appellate Court has, on appreciation of evidence, found that Sh. Atma Singh was in exclusive possession of the land which is the subject matter of the gift deed and he acknowledged the possession of Jasbir Singh, the donee, in Civil Court vide judgment and decree dated 20.04.2013.

¶21

In such circumstances, the plaintiff is entitled to protect his

¶22

possession.

¶23

Hence, no ground to interfere is made out. Dismissed.

¶24

All the pending miscellaneous applications, if any, are also

¶25

disposed of.

¶26

�)$3��*^+% 2�� 0�1��0� �� �� ��  MOHD AYUB ��  2022.04.26 11:03 I attest to the accuracy and authenticity of this document.

Ginder Singh @ Mandar Singh and Others v. Jasbir Singh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Ginder Singh @ Mandar Singh and Others v. Jasbir Singh

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M/S Nishant Enterprises & Anr. Vs Harvinder Singh

Gurdeep Kaur Vs Jagsir Singh

Sukhchain Kaur @ Sukhcharan Kaur Vs Charan Dass Saluja

M/S Sanghi Distributors Vs Hemkunt Infratech Pvt. Ltd.

Manjit Singh Vs Karamjit Singh

Sunil Kapoor Vs Parkash Rani and Others