Gurjant Singh v. Union of India & Anr.

Punjab & Haryana HC21 Oct 2015RFA/4170/2001

Download

Case brief

from the order text

What is this about?

of 2001 [1] IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND…

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

Gurjant Singh Vs Union of India & Anr. — Punjab & Haryana HC (2015) — LawSathi Research

¶26

-!�)&!"�#�?&%!3��)� 1!�3�&"�0&!)%�%?(2$ !"� 1� � 1!�3!�)&!" #�?) �(!3�0�1�%��$3!"� ��88)!#$� !� 1!�!/$"!&#!�3!"�(>� 1!�3�&"�0&!)%��& )!#�)"�$&� 1!��)2�� 0��%�3!�"!!"%��C��D;B��&"��C��D=B��5$"!�%�3! "!!"��C��D;B��"� !"��=<<�83� �2!�%?)$&7��%@?�)!�>�)"%�0�% %�3"�� &��/!)�7!�8)$#!��B9�8!)�%@?�)!�>�)"�01!)!�%�/$"!�%�3!�"!!" ��C��D=B��"� !"��=��=<<�83� �2!�%?)$&7��%@?�)!�>�)"%�0�%�%�3"�� &��/!)�7!�8)$#!��B9�8!)�%@?�)!�>�)"��1!�3�&"�"!�3 �0$ 1�$&�(� 1� 1! %�3!�"!!"%�$%��)2$&7�8�) �� 1!��#@?$)!"�3�&"��%?(% �& $� !� 1!�83!� 3!�)&!"�#�?&%!3�)!�!))!"� ��61�%)��&?2(!)��%�2!& $�&!"�$&� 1!�%�3!�"!!"% 3$&6$&7� 1!�%�2!� �� 1!��#@?$)!"�3�&"��%�2!& $�&!"�$&� 1!��0�)"�� 1! ��33!# �)��1!��#@?$%$ $�&�� 1!)0$%!�0�%��3%��)��%2�33�#1?&6��4��#)!% ��3�&"��)� 1!�8?)8�%!��%! $&7�?8��&��$)��)#!��3�&>��1!��#@?$)!" 3�&"�$%�%$ ?� !"��&�� 1$&"�9�$($0�3�9�� 1�&��)��"��&� 1!��) 1�%$"!�� 1!��#@?$)!"�3�&"� 1!)!�$%��283!CE��&� 1!��% �� 1$&"�9�$($0�3�9 �� 1�&��)��" ��&" �(!>�&" � 1� ��& �&2!& ��)!�% ��&" ��& �$ % �%�? 1 �$% ��3> !#1&$#��33!7!�� 1$&"��%�0!33��%�� 1!)�)!%$"!& $�3�#�3�&$!%��1! �#@?$)!"�3�&"�$%�3�#� !"�� "$% �&#!��4�6$3�2! !)%��)�2��?) ��283!C �%�0!33��%��!&!)�3��?%�. �&"�� 1$&"��&"��32�% � 1!�%�2!�"$% �&#!��)�2 ��$30�>�. � $�&��1!)!��)!�&?2(!)��#�22!)#$�3�!% �(3$%12!& %�$&#3?"$&7 %1�8%�2�))$�7!�8�3�#!%�$#!��# �)$!%*�% �)!%�! #��&"�!/!&�%�2!�� 1! #�&#!)&% �1�/! �#�&% )?# !" � 1!$) �7�"�0&% ��&" �% �)!% �2?#1 �(!>�&" � 1!

¶29

�#@?$)!"�3�&"�� 1�"�7)!� ��? ?)!�8� !& $�3��D1$3!�)!�!))$&7� �� 1!�:?"72!& % ��&,(3!� 1!�.?8)!2!��?) �$&�.2 ��.1�6?& �3�(�$��&"�� 1!)%�/��. � !�� 1�)�%1 )�* ��==;��.��+��&" �5��.?()�12�&>��/��-�&" �#@?$%$ $�&�F�&!��$#!)��.��;���$ �0�%�%?(2$ !"� 1� � 1! 3!�)&!"�#�?) �(!3�0�1�"�#�22$ !"��&�!))�)�$&�2!)!3>�83�#$&7�)!3$�&#!�?8�& �&�!�)3$!)��0�)" �8!) �$&$&7 � ��#@?$%$ $�& ��3�&"��)�#�&% )?# $�& �� /!)&2!& ��3> !#1&$#��&% $ ? !�� 1$&"��&"�7)�& $&7�$&#)!�%!� 1!)!�& ��) �� $2! �7�8 ��(�? �=9�B��>!�)% �A ��G �8!) ��&&?2��/!& � 1� #�3#?3� $�&�0�%�&� �#�))!# 3>�2�"!��&#!� 1!�%�3!�"!!"%�8!) �$&$&7� �� 1! �#@?$)!"�3�&"�0!)!��/�$3�(3!� 1�%!�"!%!)/!"� ��(!�)!3$!"�?8�&��)� 1! 8?)8�%! ��%%!%%2!& ��#�28!&%� $�&��! ��?) 1!) �)!�!))!" � �� 1! ��33!# �),%�)� !��C��$&� 1!��)!��01$#1�0�%��4*�+��B9�8!)��#)!��! �?) 1!)�%?(2$ !"� 1� �!/!&��? �� 0��%�3!�"!!"%�8)�"?#!"��&�)!#�)"�(>� 1! 3�&"�0&!)%��&!�%1�0$&7�1$71!% �/�3?!�$�!��%�3!�"!!"��C��D=B��%1�?3" (!�)!3$!"�?8�&��D1$3!�7)�& $&7�$&#)!�%!��)� 1!� $2!�7�8�A��G�8!)��&&?2* #�28!&%� $�&�(!��%%!%%!"�(>��883>$&7��)!�%�&�(3!�#? �#�&%$"!)$&7� 1! 8� !& $�3$ >�� 1!�3�&"��!��?) 1!)�%?(2$ !"� 1� � 1!��# � 1� � 1!)!�0!)!�+4 3�&"�)!�!)!&#!%��)��#@?$%$ $�&��4��#)!%��3�&"�%1�0%� 1� �1�3"$&7�� 1! 3�&"�0&!)%�0�%�@?$ !�%2�33��.2�33�83� %�0!)!�(!$&7�%�3"�$&� 1!��)!��) #�&% )?# $�&��1�?%!%�

¶36

*��53��!��!��!��+�� -��!��53��6�� 8��-��+��6��!��!�5�� :;��#��3��2��+��5��6��!�� /��@�� 6��+��+��5��6��3��3��!�� !��A-��6��-��!��!��!��3�� 6��!��5��!��53��!�� 5��+��!��+��6��5��+�� !��!�� !��!�� +��!��5��+��-��5�� !��!��4��6�� 6��#��5��5��#��3��!��!#�� +��+�!��8��53��!��>�6�� 3��+��5��-��!#��!�5�� ,��:;��!��6��!��,��:;��!��

Gurjant Singh v. Union of India & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Krishna Agricultural Steel Works Vs Haryana Tube Manufacturing Co. Ltd.

Fun Multiplex Private Limited and Anr. Vs --------------------------------------------

Gursem Singh Vs Sudarsh Kumar

Amity International School Sec 46 Gurgaon Vs Kumari Varsha Dalal and Ors.

Gurjant Singh v. Union of India & Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Krishna Agricultural Steel Works Vs Haryana Tube Manufacturing Co. Ltd.

Fun Multiplex Private Limited and Anr. Vs --------------------------------------------

Gursem Singh Vs Sudarsh Kumar

Amity International School Sec 46 Gurgaon Vs Kumari Varsha Dalal and Ors.

Jagir Singh Vs State of Punjab

Satpal Vs Ut of Chandigarh