Boota Singh and Anr. v. State of Punjab

Punjab & Haryana HC20 Aug 2015CRA-S/494/2008

Download

Case brief

from the order text

What is this about?

-1- IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA…

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

��

�� !" !#�" !�$%&'!(!)"�* +%,&�-!�#!.+#"!&�/)�" !�&/'!"0� �!

¶11

��1��2�1�� 1��1��

¶12

��

¶13

�� !��"#��$�%��$�� &��'�(�� )��)�� '�(�� ��)��))��!����+�� !��)�,�� )� ��!�� ,'�-�-�#�-��.&&#��!��./�0�.&��

Boota Singh and Anr. Vs State of Punjab — Punjab & Haryana HC (2015) — LawSathi Research

¶19

��)�� )�� ))�� 3�� )�� ))��3�)��)�� !��&-,-"�/��+��+��))��5�� )� 6�� )��/&��+� !��)��+�� +��3.�� ) �� )��)��6��+�� )�� !��6��)�� !��3.��1� ��7��!�� 6��

¶20

0� �3.�� +��8��+��)�� )��)�� +��3.��)��!�� 9��3��%��:�� )��3.�+�� 0��!�� /��6��+ )��.&&��+�� +��!��)�� )�� )��6�� !�)�� )�� 6��+ )��!�)�� )�� )��)��6�� )�� 1��;�� )��+��)��!*��3.� �� )��<8��0��)��))�� !��3.��1��/�2�.&��3.� �� )��<8��.�!��

¶26

2� 6��) �,�� )�� 0��!�� /�� >� �3.��))�� )�� +��!��&-,"�/��+��+ �� +��)�� )�� 6�� 6��)��!� �3.�� 3��6��0��!�� /��6��+ )��!�� 8�+��6��=��;�!�� )��)�� ))��+ )��6��=�;�� )��)�� + )�� 3/�� !� �3.�� 30�� + )�� +�� +�)�� =��;�!��

¶37

7/#7%("9)7!�5+%,&�'+�"+�!"9-,/ �" 9"�977%!&��++"9��/)' �9)&�� 9'59) �/)' �5!#!�/)�7+)7/+%�.+!/+)�+8�" !�.+..;� %:�"#9).+#"!&�" #+%' " !�"#%7:�5 /7 �59�!/<!&�-;�� "�/*�"#%!�" 9"�)+�=%!*"/+)�59*�.%"�"+�" !�977%*!&�%)&!#��!7"/+) 3�3 ��#��9* �"+ �" ! �7+)*7/+%* �.+**!**/+) �+8 �" ! �.+..; � %*:�� ! 5/")!**!*� 96!�*.+:!)�5 9"�" !;� 96!�.!#7!/6!&�9)&�5/")!**!&�9"�" !�.,97! 5 !#!�" !�"#%7:�59*�#!7+6!#!&�� !�5/")!**!*�79))+"�*.!9:�9-+%"�" ! 7+)*7/+%*�.+**!**/+)�+8�" !�7+)"#9-9)&�-;�" !�977%*!&��"�/*�+),;�" !��+%#" 5 /7 � 9*�"+�&!7/&!�5 !" !#�" !�977%*!&�5!#!�/)�7+)*7/+%*�.+**!**/+)�/) " !�897"*�9)&�7/#7%(*"9)7!*�*.+:!)�"+�-;�" !�5/")!**!*�� !�"#/9,��+%#"�/* )+" �*%..+*!& �"+ �=%!*"/+) �5 9" �59* �)+" �*.+:!) �"+ �-; �" ! �5/")!**!*� � !#!8+#!��" !�"#/9,��+%#"� 9&�)+�+779*/+)�"+�.%"�9);�=%!*"/+)�9*�#!'9#&*�" ! 7+)*7/+%*�.+**!**/+)�+8�" !�977%*!&�� !�977%*!&�79))+"�"9:!�9&69)"9'!�+8 *%7 �9�*/"%9"/+)��(+#!�!*.!7/9,,;�5 !)�" !#!�/*�6+,%(/)+%*�!6/&!)7!�"+ !*"9-,/* �" 9"�" !;�5!#!�/)�7+)*7/+%*�.+**!**/+)�+8�" !�7+)"#9-9)&�� "�59*�8%#" !#�*%-(/""!&�-;�,!9#)!&�7+%)*!,�9..!9#/)'�8+#�" ! 9..!,,9)"*�" 9"�/)&!.!)&!)"�5/")!**��9: 5/)&!#��/)' �59*�)+"�!>9(/)!&�-; " !�.#+!7%"/+)��!�8/)&�" 9"��9:5/)&!#��/)' �59*�7/"!&�9*�9�5/")!��-%" )+"�!>9(/)!&�-;�" !�.#+!7%"/+)�� !�.#+!7%"/+)� 9�!>9(/)!&��3�� 9*59)"��9/�9�9�5/")!�"+�" !�#!7+6!#;��/�!6/&!)7!�/�8+%)&�"+�-! 7#!&/-,!�9)&�"#%"5+#" ;��!)!#9,,;��" !#!�/�*+(!�#!,%7"9)7!�+)�" !�.9#"�+8 " ! �/)&!.!)&!)" �5/")! �"+ �7+(! �9)& �&!.+! �9'9/)" �" ! �+88!)&!#* �+8 )9#7+"/7*�&#%'�9)&�.;7 +"#+./7�%-"9)7!��)&!#�" !�9-+6!�897"�9)& 7/#7%("9)7!��9(�+8�" !�7+)/&!#!&�6/!5�" 9"�" !�79!�+8�" !�.#+*!7%"/+)

Boota Singh and Anr. v. State of Punjab

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Tarlochan Singh Vs State of Punjab

Pardeep Kumar Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

Saudagar Mahto @ Saudagar Vs State of Punjab & Ors.

Lekha Ram Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

Boota Singh and Anr. v. State of Punjab

Case brief

What is this about?

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Tarlochan Singh Vs State of Punjab

Pardeep Kumar Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

Saudagar Mahto @ Saudagar Vs State of Punjab & Ors.

Lekha Ram Vs State of Haryana & Ors.

Chander Bhan Vs Presiding Officer Industrial Tribunal & Anr.

Gurmeet Singh & Anr. Vs Alok Nigam & Ors.