Dismissed

Ramanand Paswan v. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary Deparmtent of Education

Patna HC4 Feb 2022CWJC/5873/2021

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This petition challenged the decision not to absorb ex-Instructors of Non-Formal Education in permanent service. The court held the petition non-maintainable as petitioners failed to establish a legal right or make a demand before the authority.

What did the court decide?

Writ petition dismissed; liberty granted to prefer detailed representation within eight weeks.

Ramanand Paswan Vs The State of Bihar through the… — Service and Employment | Patna HC (2022)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.5873 of 2021

¶2

======================================================

¶3

Ramanand Paswan S/o Late Parmeshwar Paswan, resident of village and P.O.-Piroi, P.S. and Block-Goraul, District-Vaishali.

¶4

Manoj Kumar Singh, Son of Baidhnath Singh, resident of village Malhanma, Block-Raj Nagar, District-Madhubani.

¶5

Ram Parikshan Rai, Son of Ghuran Rai, resident at Bhariya, P.S. and BlockRaj Nagar, District-Madhubani.

¶6

Rajesh Kumar, Son of Late Laxman Prasad Rai, resident of Village-Budhan Jha Tola Pandaul, Block and P.S.-Pandaul, District-Madhubani.

¶7

Ram Bharos Singh, Son of Late Ram Lakhan Singh, resident of VillageBharia, Block-Raj Nagar, District-Madhubani.

¶8

Kinkar Kumar Das, Son of Late Radheshyam Das, resident of VillageBangrora, P.O.-Gowal Tola, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶9

Shankar Prasad Rajbhar, Son of Bikram Prasad Rajbhar, resident of VillageRaghunathpur, P.O.-Barsoi Gumti, Block and P.S.-Warsoi, District-Katihar.

¶10

Ranjeet Kumar Sarkar, Son of Dinesh Sarkar, resident of village-Bansgaon, P.O.-Gwal Toli, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶11

Babul Kumar Das, So of Kalicharan Das, resident of village-Kusiar Moda, P.O.-Gunjan, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶12

Rakesh Kumar Basak, son of Mrinal Kanti Basak, resident of villageSarswati Pada Barsoi, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶13

Satish Thakur, son of Ramsewak Thakur, resident of village-Sultanpur, P.S. and Block-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶14

Sheikh Mojibur Rahman, son of Sheikh Majlur Rahman, resident of villageBhawanipur, P.O.-Gwal Toli, P.S.-Aawadpur, District-Katihar.

¶15

Md. Motiur Rahman, son of Md. Hakimuddin, resident of village-Keshfor, P.O.-Sankola, Block-Barsoi, P.S.-Aadpur, District-Katihar.

¶16

Md. Ataur Rahman, son of Late Md. Rafijuddin, resident of villageDogachh, P.O.-Bichhor Hat, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶17

Navin Kumar Gautam, son of Sri Nawal Kishor Prasad, resident of villageVillage and P.O.-Sagrath, P.S.-Kadwa, District-Katihar.

¶18

Md. Jamshed Alam, son of Late Shekh Pannaullah, resident of VillageKotahar, P.O.-Sankola, P.S.-Aawadhpur, District-Katihar.

¶19

Md. Abdur Rahman, son of Late Khurshid Ali, resident of Village-Nazrabari, P.O.-Batna, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶20

Md. Reyaz Alam, S/o Late Md. Matiur Rahman, resident of VillageNisarpatti, P.O.-Gwaltoli, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶21

Atanul Islam, son of Pasuruddin Ahmad, resident of Village-Chandpara, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶22

Awadh Kumar Pandey, son of Abani Kumar Pandey, resident of VillageKhanua, P.O.-Balupara, District-Katihar.

¶23

Patna High Court CWJC No.5873 of 2021 dt.04-02-2022 2/5

¶24

Abdur Razzaque, Son of Abdul Zabbar, resident of Village-Burhakamat Lagua, P.O.-Sankola, P.S.-Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶25

Narayan Chandra Das, Son of Shashi Bhushan Das, resident of VillageKhidirpur Jalkumar, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶26

Md. Afsar Didar, Son of Shekh Bakhash, resident of Village-Sankola, P.S.Abadpur, District-Katihar.

¶27

Md. Zubair Alam, son of Md. Mustafa, resident of Village-Khairan, P.O.Fatehpur, P.S.-Balrampur, District-Katihar.

¶28

Md. Shahriyaz Alam, son of Md. Noorul Hasan, resident of Village-Sitalpur, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶29

Mojibur Rahman, son of Bajlur Rahman, resident of Village and P.O.-Gwal Toli, P.S.-Bhawanipur, District-Katihar.

¶30

Prasad Chandra Basak, son of Haripad Basak, resident of Village-Kusiar Murha, P.S.-Gunjan, District-Katihar.

¶31

Surendra Nath, son of Shivraj Choudhary, resident of Village and P.O.Thepaha, P.S.-Jiradei, District-Siwan.

¶32

Rakesh Rawat, son of Mukhlal Rawat, resident of Village-Gordha Kothi, P.S. and District-Katihar.

¶33

Anand Shankar, son of Awadhesh Kumar Singh, resident of VillageHariharpur, P.S.-Hariharpur Kalan, District-Siwan.

¶34

Rajani Kumari, wife of Sanjeev Ray, resident of Village-Dhebwa, P.S.Banjaria, District-Gopalganj.

¶35

Umesh Kumar Singh, son of Rajmangal Singh, resident of Village-Kateya Tola, Tekanavas, P.S.-Sidhwalia, District-Gopalganj.

¶36

Munna Kumar Ram, Son of Hawaldar Ram, resident of Village-Baishakhi, Block-Panchrukhi, District-Siwan.

¶37

Madan Ram, S/o Horil Ram, resident of Village-Sultanpur, P.S.-Bhagwanpur Hat, District-Siwan.

¶38

Jitendra Mishra, son of Bharat Mishra, resident of Village-Barhoga, PostFatehpur, P.S.-Jama, District-Siwan.

¶39

Ramesh Ram, Son of Jagan Ram, resident of Village-Gopalpur, P.S.Bhagwanpur Hat, District-Siwan.

¶40

Sarvjeet Kumar, son of Haricharan Prasad, resident of Village-Sisai, Laxmiganj, P.S.-Goriakothi, District-Siwan.

¶41

Dilip Kumar, son of Bangali Ram, resident of Village-Sisai, Laxmiganj, P.S.Goriakothi, District-Siwan.

¶42

Harinandan Ram, son of Kamal Ram, resident of Village and P.O.Habibnagar, P.S.-Hussainganj, District-Siwan.

¶43

Babul Kumar, son of Mantu Kumar Thakur, resident of Village-Pomar Tajpur, P.S.-Barsoi, District-Katihar.

¶44

Md. Juned Alam, Son of Md. Sajjad Alam, resident of Village-Patalwa, P.O.Surjapur, P.S. and District-Kishanganj.

¶45

Shankar Lal Yadav, son of Girilal Yadav, resident of Village-Talgachh

¶46

Patna High Court CWJC No.5873 of 2021 dt.04-02-2022 3/5

¶47

Kamat, P.O.-Kodhbari, P.S.-Dighal Bank Lohagarha, District-Kishanganj.

¶48

Aday Kumar Yadav, Son of Girilal Yadav, resident of Village-Talgachh Kamat, P.O.-Kodhbari, P.S.-Dighal Bank Lohagarha, District-Kishanganj.

¶49

Kiran Kumar, Son of Girilal Yadav, resident of Village-Talgachh Kamat, P.O.-Kodhbari, P.S.-Dighal Bank Lohagarha, District-Kishanganj.

¶50

Sanjay Kumar Suman, son of Subhash Chandra Yadav, resident of VillageMaujala, Bhargama, P.O.-Maujaha, P.S.-Bhargama, District-Araria.

¶51

... ... Petitioner/s

¶52

Versus

¶53

The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary Deparmtent of Education, Government of Bihar, Patna.

¶54

The Principal Secretary Department of Education, Government of Bihar, Vikash Bhawan, Patna.

¶55

The Director, Primary Education, Department of Education, Govt. of Bihar, Vikash Bhawan, Patna.

¶56

The Director, Mass Education, Government of Bihar, Vikash Bhawan, Patna.

¶57

... ... Respondent/s

¶58

====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : Mr. Abhishek Kumar, Kumar For the Respondent/s : Mr. Lalit Kishore (AG) ====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. B. BAJANTHRI ORAL JUDGMENT

¶59

Date : 04-02-2022

¶60

This matter is heard via video conferencing due to circumstances prevailing on account of COVID-19 Pandemic.

¶61

Heard learned counsel for the parties.

¶62

In the instant petition, the petitioners have prayed for

¶63

the following reliefs:

¶64

“That this writ application is being filed for issuance of an appropriate writ preferably in the nature of Mandamus commanding and directing the Respondents concerned to absorb the petitioners on suitable posts in permanent service under the Respondent State as the petitioners is Ex-Instructor of

¶65

Patna High Court CWJC No.5873 of 2021 dt.04-02-2022 4/5

¶66

Non-Formal Education on several grounds including that the State Government has decided to absorb the Non-Formal Educational Supervisors in permanent service and services of several similarly situated persons/Non-Formal Ex-instructrs have been absorbed in the light of several Judicial pronouncements of this Hon’ble Court as weel as Hon’ble Court. And/or any other relief or reliefs for which the petitioners is found to be entitled in the facts and circumstances of this case.”

¶67

For issuance of a writ of Mandamus, the petitioners have to satisfy two ingredients, namely, establishing statutory/legal right followed by demand before the competent authority, both the ingredients are not forthcoming from the petition. Therefore, in the light of the Apex Court decision in the case of Mani Subrat Jain V. State of Haryana & Ors ., reported in (1977) 1 SCC 486 . Para 9 reads as under:

¶68

"9. The High Court rightly dismissed the petitions. It is elementary though it is to be restated that no one can ask for a mandamus without a legal right. There must be a judicially enforceable right as well as a legally protected right before one suffering a legal grievance can ask for a mandamus. A person can be said to be aggrieved only when a person is denied a legal right by some one who has a legal duty to do something or to abstain from doing something (See Halsbury's Laws of England 4th Ed. Vol. 1, paragraph 122; State of Haryana v. Subash Chander Marwaha & Ors. (1) Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v. Roshan Kumar Haji Bashir

¶69

Patna High Court CWJC No.5873 of 2021 dt.04-02-2022 5/5

¶70

Ahmed & Ors. (2) and Ferris Extraordinary Legal Remedies paragraph 198."

¶71

The present petition is not maintainable.

¶72

Accordingly, writ petition is dismissed reserving liberty to the petitioners to prefer detailed representation along with judicial pronouncements, if any, within a period of eight weeks from today. If such representation is submitted, the concerned respondent-authority is hereby directed to decide the petitioners’ representation/appeal within a reasonable time.

¶73

(P. B. Bajanthri, J)

¶74

uday/-

¶75

AFR/NAFR	NAFR
CAV DATE	NA
Uploading Date	19.02.2022
Transmission Date	NA

Ramanand Paswan v. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary Deparmtent of Education

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Ramanand Paswan v. The State of Bihar through the Principal Secretary Deparmtent of Education

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Kiran Devi Vs The State of Bihar

Shashi Kumar Singh Vs The Union of India

Julekha Khatun Vs The State of Bihar

Arbind Mallik @ Arvind Mallik, Vs The State of Bihar

Rekha Kumari Vs The State of Bihar

Sunil Prasad Yadav Vs The State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary