Dismissed

The State Of Bihar and Anr. v. Upendra Yadav and Ors.

Patna HC8 Jul 2019CWJC/14409/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The Patna High Court dismissed multiple writ petitions filed by workers who had their claims for arrear wages rejected by the Labour Court. The Court held that since the State conceded the employment relationship and the Labour Court properly found the claimants failed to substantiate their specific allegations, the dismissal stood. References were made to Supreme Court precedents supporting subst

What did the court decide?

All writ petitions are dismissed without costs. The orders of the Labour Court rejecting specific claims are affirmed as they failed to substantiate the claims.

The State Of Bihar and Anr. Vs Upendra Yadav… — Labour and Industrial Disputes | Patna HC (2019)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.14409 of 2017

¶2

1.	====================================================== The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Upendra Yadav Son of Late Chaudhary Yadav R/o Village - Balha, P.O. Balha, District - Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ======================================================
	with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14419 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Sadanand Paswan Son of Shri Ramjee Paswan, resident of Village- Maheshkutt, P.O.- Maheshkutt, District- Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14427 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Dasrath Yadav Son of Late Awadh Lal Yadav, resident of Village- Ekania, P.O. Mansi, District- Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai.

¶3

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 2/13

¶4

... ... Respondent/s

¶5

	====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14432 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Arun Paswan Son of Bhahujan Paswan, resident of Village- Rampur, P.O.- Allowli, District- Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14439 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Gangadhar Yadav Son of Upendra Prasad Yadav, R/o Village- Balha, P.O.- Balha, District- Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14521 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Kundan Yadav Son of Biro Yadav, resident of Village- Shaurba, P.O. Thutthi, District- Khagaria.

¶6

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 3/13

¶7

2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14462 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Prabhu Yadav Son of Bindreshwari Yadav, R/o Village- Tartar, P.O. Durgapur, District- Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14473 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Envieonment and Forest Department, Khagaria ... ... Petitioner/s Versus
1.	Brahmdev Mandal Son of Sattu Mandal, R/o Village-Telia Bathaan, P.O.Solwara, District-Khagaria.
2.	The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria
3.	The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai ... ... Respondent/s ====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14442 of 2017 ======================================================
1.	The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.
2.	The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus

¶8

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 4/13

¶9

Chakardhar Mahto Son of Ram Dev Pd. Mahto, R/o VillageRambhaddarpur, P.O.- Allowli, District- Khagaria.

¶10

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶11

====================================================== with

¶12

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14516 of 2017

¶13

======================================================

¶14

The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶15

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶16

Versus

¶17

Anil Kumar Mandal Son of Satnarayan Mandal R/o Village - Morkahi, District - Khagaria.

¶18

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶19

====================================================== with

¶20

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14551 of 2017

¶21

======================================================

¶22

The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶23

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶24

Versus

¶25

Bhupdev Paswan Son of Gorakh Paswan, R/o Village- Kamthan, P.O.Amba, District- Khagaria.

¶26

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶27

====================================================== with

¶28

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14464 of 2017

¶29

======================================================

¶30

The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶31

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶32

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 5/13

¶33

... ... Petitioner/s

¶34

Versus

¶35

1. Nilesh Kumar Son of Ramesh Singh, R/o Village- Yogapur, P.O. Durgapur, District- Khagaria.

¶36

1. The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶37

====================================================== with

¶38

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14410 of 2017

¶39

======================================================

¶40

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶41

1. The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶42

Versus

¶43

1. Jagdish Yadav Son of Late Govind Yadav R/o Village - Kumarchakki, P.O. Rahimpur, District - Khagaria.

¶44

1. The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶45

====================================================== with

¶46

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14417 of 2017

¶47

======================================================

¶48

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagari.

¶49

1. The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶50

Versus

¶51

1. Lal Paswan Son of Parmeshwar Paswan R/o Village - Parmanandpur, P.O. Komi College, District Khagaria.

¶52

1. The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶53

====================================================== with

¶54

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14474 of 2017

¶55

======================================================

¶56

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest

¶57

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 6/13

¶58

Department, Khagaria.

¶59

1. The Range Officer, Envieonment and Forest Department, Khagaria ... ... Petitioner/s

¶60

Versus

¶61

1. Dhaneshwar Mandal Son of Late Bal Govind Mandal R/o Village-Kolbara, P.S. Pasraha, District-Khagaria.

¶62

1. The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai ... ... Respondent/s

¶63

====================================================== with

¶64

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14819 of 2017

¶65

======================================================

¶66

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶67

1. The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶68

Versus

¶69

1. Smt. Shilo Devi Wife of Munni Lal Mahto, Resident of Village- Hajipur, P.O. Khagaria, District- Khagaria.

¶70

1. The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶71

====================================================== with

¶72

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14498 of 2017

¶73

======================================================

¶74

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶75

1. The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶76

Versus

¶77

1. Ramchandra Sah Son of Chote lal Sah R/o Village- Thatha, P.O. Thatha, P.S. Mansi, District- Khagaria,.

¶78

1. The labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria. 3. The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai. ... ... Respondent/s

¶79

====================================================== with

¶80

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14576 of 2017

¶81

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 7/13

¶82

======================================================

¶83

The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶84

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria

¶85

... ... Petitioner/s

¶86

Versus

¶87

Ranjeet Yadav Son of Laljee Yadav, R/o Village- Santosh, P.O. Santosh, District-Khagaria.

¶88

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria

¶89

The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai

¶90

... ... Respondent/s

¶91

====================================================== with

¶92

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14443 of 2017

¶93

======================================================

¶94

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶95

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶96

... ... Petitioner/s

¶97

Versus

¶98

Hasan Imam Son of Abibur Rahman, R/o Village- Bachuata, DistrictKhagaria.

¶99

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.

¶100

The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai.

¶101

... ... Respondent/s

¶102

====================================================== with

¶103

Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15200 of 2017

¶104

======================================================

¶105

1. The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶106

1. The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria. ... ... Petitioner/s

¶107

Versus

¶108

Ashok Mandal Son of Mathur Mandal R/o Village- Maheshkhutt, P.O. Maheshkhutt, District- Khagaria.

¶109

... ... Respondent/s

¶110

====================================================== with Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14413 of 2017

¶111

======================================================

¶112

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 8/13

¶113

The State of Bihar through the Range Officer, Environment & Forest Department, Khagari.

¶114

The Range Officer, Environment and Forest Department, Khagaria.

¶115

... ... Petitioner/s

¶116

Versus

¶117

Nunu Lal Paswan Son of Late Palak Dhari Paswan R/o Village - Maheshkhutt, P.O. Maheshkhutt, District - Khagaria.

¶118

The Labour Enforcement Officer, Khagaria.

¶119

The Presiding Officer, Labour Court, Begusarai.

¶120

... ... Respondent/s

¶121

===================== Appearance : (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	================================= No. 14409 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr. Sarvesh Kumar Singh, AAG13 Mr. Shakib Ayaz, AC to AAG13
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram, Adv.
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14419 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Lokesh Kumar Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14427 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Lokesh Kumar Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14432 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Lokesh Kumar Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14439 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Lokesh Kumar Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14521 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Tej Pratap Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14462 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Sunita Kumari
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14473 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Tej Pratap Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14442 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Tej Pratap Singh
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14516 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Sunita Kumari
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14551 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Sunita Kumari
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case	No. 14464 of 2017)
For the Petitioner/s :	Mr.Sunita Kumari
For the Respondent/s :	Mr.Bishweshwar Ram
(In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case For the Petitioner/s :	No. 14410 of 2017) Mr.Ravi Kumar

¶122

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 9/13

¶123

For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14417 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Ravi Kumar For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14474 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Sunita Kumari For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14819 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Tej Pratap Singh For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14498 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Tej Pratap Singh For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14576 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Ravi Kumar For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14443 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Tej Pratap Singh For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 15200 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Ravi Kumar Ac To Aag 13 For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram (In Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No. 14413 of 2017) For the Petitioner/s : Mr.Ravi Kumar For the Respondent/s : Mr.Bishweshwar Ram ======================================================

¶124

CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVAJI PANDEY ORAL JUDGMENT

¶125

Date : 08-07-2019

¶126

Heard learned counsel for the parties.

¶127

All the cases, being identical in nature, are disposed of by this common order.

¶128

In all the cases, the private respondents have claimed the payment of arrear of wages and the authority has directed for payment of arrear of salary and has granted compensation of Rs. 25/- to each of the worker. The court below has also clubbed together all such cases and disposed of all the cases being P.W. (Payment of Wages) Case No. 1 to 43/1996 by a common order.

¶129

Altogether 43 persons have filed their respective claims for the payment of arrear of wages having claimed that they were

¶130

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 10/13

¶131

working in the Fores Department but, the salary has not been paid to them. It will be relevant to quote the claim of each of the worker

¶132

which is as follows:-

¶133

Sl. No.	Case No.	Name of Parties	Name of Respondent (Labour	Lower Court Case No.	Period of work (As alleged)	Post of work (As alleged)	Rate of payme @ per day	nt Amount of Payment (Rs.)
1	CWJC No. 14409/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Upendra Yadav & Ors.	Upendra Yadav	28/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	-----------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
2	CWJC No. 14410/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Jagdish Yadav & Ors.	Jagdish Yadav	04/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	Animal saver / Protector	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
3	CWJC No. 14413/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Nunu Lal Paswan & Ors.	Nunu Lal Paswan	32/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
4	CWJC No. 14417/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Lal Paswan @ Shri Lal Paswan & Ors. & Ors.	Lal Paswan @ Shri Lal Paswan	06/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	Gardener (Maali)	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
5	CWJC No. 14419/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Sadanand Paswan & Ors.	Sadanand Paswan	31/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	----------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
6	CWJC No. 14427/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Dasrath Yadav & Ors.	Dasrath Yadav	10/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
7	CWJC No. 14432/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Arun Paswan & Ors.	Arun Paswan	20/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
8	CWJC No. 14439/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Gangadhar Yadav & Ors.	Gangadhar Yadav	17/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
9	CWJC No. 14442/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Chakradhar Mahto & Ors.	Chakradhar Mahto	16/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
10	CWJC No. 14443/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Hasan Imam & Ors.	Hasan Imam	15/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
11	CWJC No. 14462/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Prabhu Yadav & Ors.	Prabhu Yadav	22/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
12	CWJC No. 14464/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Nilesh Kumar & Ors.	Nilesh Kumar	21/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
13	CWJC No. 14473/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Brahmdev Mandal & Ors.	Brahmdev Mandal	24/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
14	CWJC No. 14474/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Dhaneshwar Mandal & Ors.	Dhaneshwar Mandal	11/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
15	CWJC No. 14498/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Ramchandra Sah & Ors.	Ramchandra Sah	02/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-

¶134

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019

¶135

11/13

¶136

16	CWJC No. 14516/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Anil Kumar Mandal & Ors.	Anil Kumar Mandal	03/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	Security Guard	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
17	CWJC No. 14521/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Kundan Yadav & Ors.	Kundan Yadav	38/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (450 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (450X30.50) Rs. 13,725	Rs. 8235/- requested for payment
18	CWJC No. 14551/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Bhupdev Paswan &@ Bhudeo Yadav & Ors.	Bhupdev Paswan &@ Bhudeo Yadav	39/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (450X30.50) Rs. 13,725	Rs. 8235/- requested for payment
19	CWJC No. 14576/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Ranjeet Yadav & Ors.	Ranjeet Yadav	37/96	Period not mentioned	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/- requested for payment
20	CWJC No. 14819/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs.Smt. Shilo Devi & Ors.	Smt. Shilo Devi	07/96	01.10.1994 to 30.06.1995 (270 days)	------------	Rs. 30.50 (270X30.50)	Rs. 8235/-
21	CWJC No. 15200/2017	The State of Bihar & Anr. Vs. Ashok Mandal & Ors.	Ashok Mandal	36/96	01.08.1994 to 30.06.1995 (330 days)	Animal saver / Protector	Rs. 30.50 (330X30.50) Rs. 10,065	Rs. 8235/- requested for payment
							Total	Rs. 1,72,935/-

¶137

(Total comes to Rs. One Lakh Seventy Two Thousand Nine Hundred and Thirty Five Only)

¶138

The aforesaid claim is in tabular form and arrear amount

¶139

has been mentioned therein save and except Rs. 25/- to be added with the amount as has been mentioned against each worker and the Court, after discussion, allowed claims of certain worker and also rejected the claim of some of workers, which are as follows:-

¶140

^^bl izdkj bu nkok i=ksa dh flf) ugha gks ldh gSA vr% nkok i= la[;k 1/96, 5/96, 9/96, 12/96, 13/96, 14/96, 18/96, 23/96, 25/96, 26/96, 27/96, 33/96, 34/96, 41/96 ,oa 42/96, [kkfjt fd;s tkus ;ksX; gSA**

¶141

The claim of P.W. Case No. 1/96, 5/96, 9/96, 12/96, 13/96, 14/96, 18/96, 23/96, 25/96, 26/96, 27/96, 33/96, 34/96, 41/96 and 42/96 have been rejected by the Labour Court as they failed to substantiate their respective claim.

¶142

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 12/13

¶143

It appears from the order that the notice of the case was not sent to Forest Department but, the Forest Department did not take any step, ultimately, the Court passed the ex-parte order.

¶144

The cases of workers were pursued. The Labour Enforcement Officer, respondents workers came to dock and asserted their respective claim which has not been contradicted by the petitioner. Even in the writ application, nowhere the State has disputed the employment of respondents whose cases have been allowed and they have claimed salary as per minimum rate of wages fixed by the State of Bihar.

¶145

In that view of the matter, when a substantial justice has been given in connection with payment of salary to the workman, even if some error is there, that has to be ignored. Reliance in this connection may be made to the judgment passed in the case of A.M. Allison & H.P. Brigg. Vs. B.L. Sen & Ors. reported in AIR 1957 SC 227, para-17, Om Prakash Goel Vs. Committee of Management, Kunwar R. C. Mahila Degree College, Mainpuri Vs. Vice Chancellor, Agra University & Anr. reported in 1991 LIC 1493, in the case of Krishna Chandra Pallai Vs. Union of India & Anr. reported in 1992 LIC 2023 and in the case of Chandra Singh & Ors. Vs. State of Rajasthan & Anr. reported in 2003 (6) SCC 545 para-43.

¶146

Patna High Court CWJC No.14409 of 2017 dt.08-07-2019 13/13

¶147

Accordingly, this Court does not find any merit in all these writ applications and the same are dismissed without any

¶148

cost.

¶149

(Shivaji Pandey, J)

¶150

rishi/-

¶151

AFR/NAFR	NAFR
CAV DATE	NA
Uploading Date	16.07.2019
Transmission Date

The State Of Bihar and Anr. v. Upendra Yadav and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

The State Of Bihar and Anr. v. Upendra Yadav and Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Rahul Muzaffarpuri Vs The Union Of India and Ors.

Executive Director East , Food Corporation Of India Vs The Union Of India and Ors.

Rakesh Kumar Singh Vs the State of Bihar

The State Of Bihar and Anr. Vs Sadanand Paswan and Ors.

The State Of Bihar and Anr. Vs Dasrath Yadav and Ors.

The State Of Bihar and Anr. Vs Arun Paswan and Ors.