Allowed

In the matter of Dmb Paper Mills Private Limited [IA-1339 & 1367(AHM)-2023 in CP(IB)-25(AHM)-2019]

NCLT15 Feb 2024IA-1339 & 1367(AHM)-2023 in CP(IB)-25(AHM)-2019

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The National Company Law Tribunal adjudicated on applications challenging an auction sale by an applicant who failed to deposit the required bid amount despite assurances. The Tribunal held the applicant guilty of wasting time and dismissed the applications with a penalty.

What did the court decide?

Applications dismissed and Applicant directed to deposit Rs. 2,00,000 in the Prime Minister's National Relief Fund within 7 days.

In the matter of Dmb Paper Mills Private Limited… — Insolvency and Bankruptcy | NCLT (2024)

¶1

IN THE NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL AHMEDABAD DIVISION BENCH COURT – 1

¶2

ITEM No.301.- IA/1339(AHM)2023 and ITEM No. 302.- IA/1367(AHM)2023 in CP(IB) 25 of 2019

¶3

Order Under Section 60(5) IBC r.w Rule 11 of NCLT Rules, 2016

¶4

In the matter of : IA/1339(AHM)2023

¶5

Pinakin Engineers and Contractors …..Applicant V/s Shreyansh Jain Liquidator of DMB Paper Mills Pvt Ltd. ….Respondent And Order Under Section 60(5) IBC r.w Rule 11 of NCLT Rules, 2016

¶6

In the matter of : IA/1367(AHM)2023

¶7

Pinakin Engineers and Contractors …..Applicant V/s Shreyansh Jain Liquidator of DMB Paper Mills Pvt. Ltd. & Anr. ….Respondents

¶8

Order delivered on: 15 /02/2024

¶9

Coram:

¶10

Mr. Shammi Khan, Hon’ble Member(J) Mr. Sameer Kakar, Hon’ble Member(T)

¶11

PRESENT:

¶12

For the Applicant : For the Respondent :

¶13

ORDER

¶14

The case if fixed for pronouncement of order. The order is pronounced in open Court, vide separate sheet.

¶15

-SDSAMEER KAKAR MEMBER (TECHNICAL)

¶16

-SDSHAMMI KHAN MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

¶17

BEFORE THE ADJUDICATING AUTHORITY NATIONAL COMPANY LAW TRIBUNAL, DIVISION BENCH - I, AHMEDABAD

¶18

IA/1339(AHM)2023 & IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019

¶19

IA/1339(AHM)2023 in CP(IB) No.25(AHM)2019

¶20

[An application filed under Section 60(5)(c) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 r.w. Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules, 2016]

¶21

PINAKIN ENGINEERS AND CONTRACTORS

¶22

Having office at: Plot No. 249, 2^nd Phase, GIDC, Vapi, Valsad – 396195

….Applicant

Versus

SHREYANSH JAIN

Liquidator of DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Having office at: 505 Silver Coin apartment, Behind Aakashwani, Paota C Road, Jodhpur – 342001

¶27

….Respondent

¶28

AND

¶29

IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019

¶30

[An application filed under Section 60(5) of the IBC, 2016 r.w. Rule 11 of the NCLT Rules, 2016]

¶31

PINAKIN ENGINEERS AND CONTRACTORS,

¶32

Having Office at: Plot No. 249, 2^nd Phase, GIDC, Vapi, Valsad-396195

¶33

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

1 of 9

… Applicant

Versus

1. SHREYANSH JAIN

¶38

LIQUIDATOR OF DMB PAPER MILLS PVT. LTD.

¶39

Having Office at: 505 Silver Coin Apartment, Behind Aakashwani, Paota C Road, Jodhpur- 342001

¶40

2. KRISHKAN INVESTMENT PVT. LTD.

¶41

Having Office at: 7/1A, Grant lane, 2^nd Floor, Chambers Room No. 2, Kolkata-700012

¶42

3. SARVESHWARI PAPER MILL LLP

¶43

Having Office at: Shop No. 14, Plot No. 195, GIDC Pandesara, Surat- 394221

¶44

… Respondents

¶45

In the matter of

¶46

CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019

¶47

DMB Paper Mills Private Limited

¶48

….Corporate Applicant

¶49

Versus

¶50

Union Bank of India

¶51

….Respondent

¶52

Order Pronounced On: 15.02.2024

¶53

CORAM:

¶54

SH. SHAMMI KHAN, MEMBER (JUDICIAL) SH. SAMEER KAKAR, MEMBER (TECHNICAL)

¶55

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶56

2 of 9

¶57

Appearance:

¶58

For the Applicant : Mr. Monaal Davawala, Adv. For the R-1 : Mr. Mohit Gupta, Adv. For the R-2 Mr. Jaimin Dave, Adv. aw. Ms. Hirva Dave, Adv. For the R-3 : None

¶59

O R D E R

¶60

[Per: Bench]

¶61

IA/1339(AHM)2023 & IA/1367(AHM)/2023

¶62

In IA/1339(AHM)2023 and IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB) No. 25 of 2019 a detailed order was given by this Tribunal on 22.01.2024. The operative portion of the said order is produced below:

¶63

(A) The Applicant herein shall give an unconditional bid to the Liquidator within a period of three working days from the date of pronouncement of this order.

¶64

(B) The entire bid amount should be deposited by the Applicant herein in the liquidation account of the Corporate Debtor which is under the control of the Liquidator within a period of seven working days from the date of this order. The details of liquidation account are as under:-

¶65

*“DMB Paper Mills P*	*rivate*	*Limited Liquidation Account*
*Account No.*	:	*923020051338691*
*Name of Bank*	:	*Axis Bank, Mumbai*
*Branch*	:	*Vile Parle Branch*
*IFSC Code*	:	*UTIB0000064”*

¶66

(C) In case, the Applicant fails to adhere to the directions given in (A) and (B) above, this Tribunal will assume that the Applicant is not interested to pursue the matter and the

¶67

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶68

3 of 9

¶69

Liquidator will be free to take further steps in pursuance of the Sale Certificate already issued by him in favour of R-3. (D) In case the Applicant is able to satisfy (A) and (B) above, R-3 – the Successful Resolution Bidder will have an option to match the bid of the Applicant herein of course subject to payment of balance consideration within seven working days from the date of submission of the revised bid.

¶70

(E) It is made clear that in no circumstances this Tribunal will accede to any requests of either of the parties for seeking extension of time as specified in this order.

¶71

(F) The Liquidator is permitted to issue fresh sale certificate and to cancel already issued sale certificate to comply with the directions given under this order.

¶72

(G) The liquidator is directed to strictly adhere to the above directions and file an additional affidavit giving the subsequent development on record within two weeks from the date of this order.

¶73

(H) List the matter for compliance on 12.02.2024 .

¶74

This matter was posted for reporting the compliance on 12.02.2024. The Learned Liquidator has filed compliance additional affidavit under Inward Diary No. D993 dated 08.02.2024. Perusal of the same reveals that the Liquidator received an unconditional bid offer of Rs.25.5 crores from the Applicant vide email dated 24.01.2024 which is annexed as Annexure-P1.

¶75

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶76

4 of 9

¶77

It is stated that as per the order dated 22.01.2024, the Applicant had to deposit the entire bid amount in the liquidation account of the Corporate Debtor within a period of seven working days from the date of the order. However, no bid amount was received within the time period envisaged or even afterwards.

¶78

Pursuant to the above, the Liquidator has written an email dated 02.02.2024 regarding non-receipt of the bid amount to the Applicant and informing the Applicant that he is going to take steps as per the order dated 22.01.2024. A copy of the email exchanged between the Liquidator and the Applicant is annexed as Annexure P2.

¶79

The said email was responded by the Applicant on 02.02.2024 and is reproduced below:-

¶80

“Dear Sir

¶81

Yes Sir, I am extremely sorry for not submitting the bid amount, because at the last moment the bank refuse to make the payment which the bank was suppose to pay and already has been sanctioned my payment was ready.

¶82

So I was helpless and cant able to do the payment, as the Honorable NCLT order was to make full payment, so there was no any sense of making part payment.

¶83

Please guide if there is any way.

¶84

Sorry for the same.

¶85

with Regards

¶86

for Pinakin engineerings Pvt Ltd Hasmukh Patel.

¶87

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶88

5 of 9

¶89

Pursuant to receipt of said email, the Liquidator issued a sale validity letter in favour of Sarveshwari Paper Mill LLP which is dated 02.02.2024 and handed over the possession of the factory premises to such person.

¶90

It is seen that both the IAs were kept for reporting compliance and were not disposed off.

¶91

The order dated 22.01.2024 records that the Applicant herein has filed 3 IAs being IA/1293(AHM)2023, IA/1339(AHM)2023 and IA/1367(AHM)2023. Through these IAs, the Applicant was assailing the auction sale of the impugned property. IA/1239(AHM)2023 was already disposed off vide order dated 07.11.2023 recording the following directions:-

¶92

“ This is an application filed by the intending auction bidder seeking the following prayers:-

¶93

i. Your Lordship may be pleased to allow the present application;

¶94

ii. Your Lordshp may be pleased to quash the advertisement dated 19.10.2023 published in Gujarat Guardian News Paper and Financial Express News Paper, Surat edition with regards to auction to be held on 15.11.2023 for property of DMB Paper Mills Private Limited and be further pleased to direct that the liquidator for fresh advertisement

¶95

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶96

6 of 9

¶97

be published in news-papers having wide circulation and with proper description, rescheduling the auction.

¶98

iii. Pending hearing admission and final disposal of this petition, Your Lordship may be pleased to stay the auction which is to be held on 15.11.2023 of property DMB Paper Mills Private Limited.

¶99

iv. Your Lordship may be pleased to grant any other/ further relief(s) as may be deemed fit in the interest of justice.

¶100

The matter was heard in the first round when the nobody was present for the liquidator and in the second round learned liquidator along with Mr. Hiten Parikh appeared.

¶101

Both counsel for liquidator state that still the auction has not happened and is schedule for 15.11.2023, though the time for depositing the EMD has elapsed.

¶102

It was further stated by the learned liquidator that he is ready to give one chance provided this Tribunal directs the Applicant herein to deposit the EMD and to participate in the auction process.

¶103

At this stage counsel for the Applicant states that he is ready to deposit the EMD latest by 09.11.2023, provided copies of the information be given by the learned liquidator.

¶104

In view of the above, position explained by both the parties. We direct the Applicant to approach the learned liquidator through a valid expression of interest on the E-mail as provided in the auction notice latest by 08.11.2023 by 12 hours and EMD be deposited latest by 5 P.M. on 09.11.2023.

¶105

Learned Counsel for the Applicant states during the hearing today that if the above remedies are made available to him, he is not pressing for the prayers as per the application.

¶106

In view of this above directions, the present application is dismissed with liberty to re-agitate the matter, if orders are not complied by any of the sides.

¶107

Accordingly, IA/1293(AHM)2023 is disposed of in above terms.”

¶108

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶109

7 of 9

¶110

However, the directions were not complied by the Applicant.

¶111

Para 32 of the order dated 22.01.2024 records as under:-

¶112

“32.During the hearing on 17.01.2024, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Applicant, upon a question from the Bench regarding proof of funds, stated that “upon instruction from the clients he says that the client is ready and willing to deposit the entire amount of Rs.25.5 Crore”…”.

¶113

It is seen that based upon the representations made by the Applicant, this Tribunal considered the request of the Applicant and the said order was passed for the reasons stated in the order.

¶114

After having obtained favourable order for the second time, the Applicant has not deposited any amount despite assurances made across the Bar.

¶115

It appears that the Applicant has filed these IAs to scuttle the auction process. Through the act of the Applicant, the Applicant has wasted the precious time of this Tribunal. In view of the same, the Applicant is directed to deposit a

¶116

sum of Rs.2,00,000/- (Rupees Two Lakh Only) in the

¶117

Prime Minister’s National Relief Fund (“PMNRF”)

¶118

within a period of 7 days from the date of this order.

¶119

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶120

8 of 9

¶121

List the matter for reporting compliance on 06.03.2024.

¶122

In view of the above directions, IA/1339(AHM)2023 and IA/1367(AHM)2023 are hereby disposed off.

¶123

A certified copy of this order may be issued, if applied for,

¶124

upon compliance with all requisite formalities.

¶125

-SD-SD- SAMEER KAKAR SHAMMI KHAN MEMBER (TECHNICAL) MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

¶126

Rajeev Kr. Sen/P.S.

¶127

IA/1339(AHM)2023 AND IA/1367(AHM)/2023 in CP(IB)/25(AHM)/2019 DMB Paper Mills Private Limited Vs Union Bank of India

¶128

9 of 9

In the matter of Dmb Paper Mills Private Limited [IA-1339 & 1367(AHM)-2023 in CP(IB)-25(AHM)-2019]

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

In the matter of Dmb Paper Mills Private Limited [IA-1339 & 1367(AHM)-2023 in CP(IB)-25(AHM)-2019]

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases