Dismissed

Mohamed Thajudeen @ Thajudeen(Died) v. Ummakollusu

Madras HC21 Nov 2024CMP(MD)/10948/2017

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Applications seeking dispensation of notice to numerous unserved respondents in a civil revision petition against an interlocutory order in a partition suit. The Court, applying a Division Bench decision holding that notice must issue to all defendants even if ex parte at earlier stages, dismissed the applications and directed service of notice on all respondents.

What the court decided

AI extract

Mohamed Thajudeen @ Thajudeen(Died) Vs… — Civil Procedure and Limitation | Madras HC (2024)

¶1

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶2

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT ( Civil Appellate Jurisdiction )

¶3

Thursday, the Twenty First day of November Two Thousand and Twenty Four

¶4

PRESENT

¶5

The HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. SENTHILKUMAR

¶6

CMP(MD) Nos.10948 and 10949 of 2017 IN CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶7

1 MOHAMED THAJUDEEN @ THAJUDEEN(DIED),

¶8

2 MOHAMED NAZEEBUN NISHA @ PATHAMUTHU

3 KADAR SULTHAN ALI

4 AYISA GANI

5 JALAMUTHU NISHA

6 RAHUMANI BEEVI

¶13

... Petitioners / Petitioners / Plaintiffs in both petitions

¶14

7 ABDUL SALAM

¶15

8 AL AMAAN

¶16

9 MOHAMED MAHADHEER

¶17

10 SALAMUL RAHUFANIYA

¶18

... Petitioners 7 to 10 in both petitions

¶19

(Petitioners 7 to 10 are brought on record as LRs of the deceased 1^st petitioner vide Court order dated 29.07.2022 made in CMP(MD) No.10523 of 2018 in CRP(MD) No..2247 of 2017)

¶20

(6^th petitioner and 57^th respondent who are already on records are recorded as LRs of the deceased 1^st petitioner vide Court order dated 29.07.2022 made in CMP(MD) No.10523 of 2018 in CRP (MD) No.2247 of 2017)

¶21

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶22

1/12

¶23

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶24

¶25

1 UMMAKOLLUSU

¶26

2 SHAHUL HAMEED

¶27

3 MOHAMAD ABUBUKAR

¶28

4 NOORIN JAMILA

¶29

5 SHYTHUN BEEVI

¶30

6 HABIBU AYSHA

¶31

KATCHU IBRAHIMAMMAL (DIED)

¶32

7 KUBURAMMAL

¶33

SUHARAAMMAL (DIED)

¶34

8 ABU HANIFA 9 RAHMADULLA 10 HIMMADULLA 11 ROOKULLA 12 AARIBBA 13 HAKULLA

¶35

ABDUL RAHIM (DIED)

¶36

14 UVAISOOL KARUNAI 15 UMMAL ARIBA 16 MASOOTHU 17 MASILLA 18 MUMINA BEEVI

¶37

19 UMMUL BHASIRA

¶38

20 PEER IBRAHIMSHA

¶39

PEER NAINA MOHAMMED (DIED)

¶40

MOHAMED MARIYAMMAL (DIED)

¶41

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶42

2/12

¶43

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶44

21 ALIMA BEEVI

¶45

22 AJISHA BEEVI

¶46

23 KAJA MAIDEEN @ PAATTALI 24 SYED ABTHAHIR 25 RAMZAN BEEVI

¶47

26 SYED ALI FATHIMA W/O.SHAHUL HAMEED

¶48

27 MEERA MAIDEEN 28 SEENI MOHAMMED 29 SULAIKAL BEEVI

¶49

30 SYED ALI FATHIMA W/O.PEER MOHAMED

¶50

31 MOHAMED AYSHA 32 SHALIKA BEEVI 33 TAJUN BEEVI 34 BAHUDHATHU 35 UMMAL RUKIYA 36 THANSHILA 37 HABIBU RHAMAN 38 UMAR FAROOK 39 REKHAN BEEVI 40 SHARINA BEEVI 41 BHAHARUDEEN 42 MINOR SIRAJUDEEN 43 MINOR BHAHABUDEEN (Minor respondents 42 and 43 herein represented by their mother and natural guardian Rekhan Beevi 39^th respondent herein

¶51

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶52

3/12

¶53

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶54

44 MINOR ABSAL NISHA (Minor 44^th respondent herein represented by their mother and natural guardian Sharina Beeni 40^th respondent herein

¶55

45 SHAHARUN JAMILA 46 JAMALUDIN 47 SAHABUDEEN 48 CHITHI JEMILA 49 SHAHUL HAMEED

¶56

50 MAHARATAMMAL 51 HABASIYA

¶57

52 NAINA ALI KHAN

¶58

53 KHALIL RAHMAN

¶59

54 AYSHA MARIYAM

¶60

55 SAMSU NISHA 56 SHABIULLA 57 THENUL MAHARIBA

¶61

58 JALALUDEEN 59 MINNAL BOWSIA 60 UKAS 61 KUDTHUSH

¶62

FATHIMA BEEVI (DIED).

¶63

62 SYED AHAMED 63 MAHARASIAMMAL 64 HAYARUN NISHA 65 SALIMA BEEVI

¶64

MAHARIBU (DIED).

¶65

66 KANI IBRAHIM 67 ABDUL LATHIF 68 MOHAMED FATHU 69 BASARIYAL

¶66

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶67

4/12

¶68

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶69

70 PEER MOHAMED

¶70

71 MAHUTHUN BEEVI

¶71

72 AHMED KABEER

¶72

73 HABIBU AYSHA 74 MINNISHA 75 MOHAMMED ALI JINNA 76 JAFER SHADICK 77 CHINA BEEVI

¶73

78 RIYAS KHAN

¶74

79 RAVIYATH BEEVI

¶75

80 MATHINA BEEVI 81 ABDULRAZAK 82 SYED RAVIYATH 83 MAHATHUN BEEVI 84 MAJITHA BEHAM 85 MARIYAM BEEVI 86 SYERA BANU 87 AHAMED 88 ABDUL SALAM 89 SEHU HASAN 90 SYED ISAK 91 MAIDEEN KANI 92 FATHIMA 93 MOHAMMED YASIN 94 MOHAMMED BASHA 95 MOHAMMED BUHARI 96 MEERA MAIDEEN 97 KAATTUN BEEVI 98 ALIYAR 99 AMEER ALI 100 THANUSHILAL BEEVI 101 ALI BOOTTO 102 SAHARBAN BEEVI 103 RAMZAN BEEVI 104 KABILA BEEVI 105 SUBUHAANI

¶76

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶77

5/12

¶78

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶79

106 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADAR (CHINNAVAR)

¶80

107 MOHAMMED MAIDEEN (UMAI) 108 SYED IBRAHIMSA @ NANDU KUNJU 109 PEER MOHAMMED @ CHINNA NANDU KUNSU 110 MARIYAM BEEVI 111 SHAHUL HAMID 112 AYSHAMMAL 113 MOHAMMED FATHU @ POOMALAI 114 FATHU MUTHU 115 SEVU USAN 116 KANIMUTHU BEEVI 117 KAMARUDEEN 118 FATHARUN NIZHA BANU 119 JENNATH BEEVI 120 ABUSAL ETHIRIS 121 BISMILLA BEHAM 122 PEER MOHAMMED 123 KATCHU IBRAHIM AMMAL 124 SAGUBAR SADIQ 125 SHAHUL HAMEED 126 MOHAIDEEN ABDUL KHADAR 127 SHAJAHAN BEEVI 128 JAFARULLA KHAN 129 FAROOQ 130 BARAKADULLA 131 ASANALLABBAI 132 SULTHAN IBRAHIM 133 KATHIJA BEEVI 134 AMMANULLA 135 SEENI MAIDEEN 136 PEER MOHAMMED 137 RAHUMANI 138 FAHIR MUSTAN 139 MOHAMMED ABUBAKKAR 140 MEERA MAIDEEN

¶81

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶82

6/12

¶83

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶84

141 VAHABKHAN 142 AMEENA BEEVI 143 SEHU ABDUL KADAR 144 SYDUN BEEVI 145 MOHAMMED RAFICK 146 AMANULLA 147 KURAISA BEEVI 148 SULAIMAN

¶85

MOHAMED AMINAMMAL(DIED)

¶86

149 MAIDEEN IBRAHIM 150 VAHITHA BEEVI 151 NOOR JAHAN 152 MUMTAJ 153 BAKKULAM RASUL 154 SAHILA @ RAJATHI 155 ALAVUDEEN 156 DHAYAR SULTHAN 157 KHAJA MAIDEEN 158 KALIMA BEEVI 159 MOHAIDEEN ABDUL KADAR 160 SHARBAN BEEVI 161 KANIMUTHU SUHARAL 162 KARIM KANI

¶87

SEHU MAIDEN(DIED)

¶88

163 PEER MOHAMMED 164 REHANI 165 KADAR 166 ABDUL KADAR 167 PEER IBRAHIM 168 FATHU MUTHU 169 BAKIR MASTAN 170 (MINNAL)BOWSIA

¶89

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶90

7/12

¶91

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶92

171 KULAM SHARIF 172 NOOR BEEVI 173 SEENI 174 MOHAMMED MITHARSHA 175 MEERAMMAL 176 MOHAMMED MIRASHA 177 ABDUL AJEES(LABBAI) 178 RAHUMATH NISHA 179 ABDUL KADAR 180 MAIDEEN BEEVI 181 SEENI NAINA MOHAMMED 182 SEENI ADIMAI 183 NOORUL HASAN 184 MUMTHAJ 185 NIZAR ALI 186 KALIMA BEEVI 187 SEENI ASANA 188 SYED ISAK 189 SEENI MAIDEEN 190 MUMTHAJ BEHAM 191 FATHU MUTHU 192 MARIANBU BEEVI 193 ANIAS FATHIMA 194 SEENI MYDEEN 195 AKBAR 196 MAHARBANU BEEVI 197 ASHIKA BEEVI 198 SAIURA BANU 199 ABITHA 200 MARSHAN BEEVI 201 SHEIK SADHAKATULLA 202 SHEIK SADHAKULLA 203 NOOR FATHIMA 204 NOOR IBRAHIM 205 LAILATHU GATHARIYA 206 MUTHU BEEVI

¶93

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶94

8/12

¶95

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶96

207 BEERHABEEBA 208 BEERNOOL ARIBHA 209 MOHAMED RABEQU 210 BEER SULTHAN 211 BAHANATHU VALA 212 MARIYAMBU AYSHA 213 SEENI ADIMAI 214 FATHIMA BEEVI 215 FATHUMUTHU 216 RAJABHAWNISHA 217 MOHAMED HANIBA 218 JANNATH 219 KATCHI MOHAMED 220 NOORUL PHIKARA 221 NAJMA BEGUM 222 AYATHDULLA 223 FASHARIYA BEGAM 224 MOHAMED SIDDHIQ 225 NASRUTH NIKKARAA BEGAM 226 BAKRUDEEN 227 KADAABUDEEN 228 HAJUBUNISHA 229 MEERAMOHAIDEEN 230 KADAR FATHIMA 231 DHARVESH MOHAIDEEN 232 THEENUL MAHARIBHA 233 SABAIYULLAH 234 MENNAL HABIBA 235 GUBHURAAL BEEVI 236 SHAJAKAHAN 237 JAHIR HUSSIN 238 MOHAMED KASIM 239 SEENI MOHAMED 240 RAHAMADULLA 241 MEERA MAIDEEN 242 MARISIYA BEGAM

¶97

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶98

9/12

¶99

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶100

243 AMJATH ALI

¶101

244 JAINULLABHUDEEN

¶102

245 NAJURUDEEN

¶103

246 ISHMATHJAHAN 247 SYED IBRAHIM 248 SHIBANA

¶104

249 NASIR

¶105

... Respondents / Respondents / Defendants in both petitions

¶106

250 NOORUL AMEEN

¶107

... Respondent / Petitioner / Plaintiff in both petitions

¶108

Prayer in CMP(MD). 10948/ 2017 :

¶109

To dispense with to serve the notice to the respondents 10,108,109,155,156,163,173,187 this civil revision petition.

¶110

Prayer in CMP(MD). 10949/ 2017 :

¶111

To dispense with to serve the notice to the respondents 1 to 9, 11 to 107, 110 to 154, 157 to 162, 164 to 172, 174 to 186, 188 to 250 this Civil Revision Petition.

¶112

Prayer in CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017:

¶113

To prefer this memorandum of grounds of civil revision petition against the fair and decreetal order in I.A.No.55 of 2017 in O.S.No.111 of 2007, on the file of District Munsif Court, Mudukulathur dated 02.03.2017.

¶114

ORDER : These civil miscellaneous petitions coming up for orders on this day, upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and upon hearing the arguments of M/S.S. RAMESH, Advocate for the petitioners, the Court made the following order:-

¶115

These petitions are filed to dispense with to serve the notice to the respondents

¶116

10, 108, 109, 155, 156, 163, 173 and 187 and respondents 1 to 9, 11 to 107, 110 to 154,

¶117

157 to 162, 164 to 172, 174 to 186 and 188 to 250, respectively.

¶118

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶119

10/12

¶120

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶121

2.The Division Bench of this Court C.M.P.No.11577 of 2022 and batch in Gnanasoundari and another vs G.Vijayakala and others, dated 20.10.2023, has held that once the parties are made as defendants in the suit, notice has to necessarily go, even if they remained ex parte at the first appellate stage or before the second appeal.

¶122

3.In view of the categorical judgment of this Court, taking note of the amended CPC, these applications are dismissed and the petitioners are directed to take notice to all the unserved respondents in the Civil Revision Petition. The petitioners are directed to take notice through Court as well as privately.

¶123

4.Post the main Revision Petition on 03.12.2024 for compliance.

¶124

sd/21/11/2024

¶125

/ TRUE COPY /

¶126

/11/2024 Sub-Assistant Registrar (C.S.I /II /III /IV ) Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, Madurai - 625 023.

¶127

CMR

¶128

¶129

The District Munsif, Mudukulathur.

¶130

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶131

11/12

¶132

CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017

¶133

ORDER IN CMP(MD) Nos.10948 and 10949 of 2017 IN CRP(MD) No.2247 of 2017 Date :21/11/2024

¶134

ED/ VR /SAR- (26/11/2024) 12P / 2C

¶135

Madurai Bench of Madras High Court is issuing certified copies in this format from 17/07/2023

¶136

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶137

12/12

Mohamed Thajudeen @ Thajudeen(Died) v. Ummakollusu

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

Mohamed Thajudeen @ Thajudeen(Died) v. Ummakollusu

Case brief

What is this about?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Parimalam Vs Thangavel

N.Illakkiya Vs P.Sethu

V.Eswaran Vs OCHAMMAL(Died).1).E.Maheswaran

Sesadimai Vs Hassan Kannu

Subbaiah Vs Mariammal

M.Muthukumar, Vs Balakrishnan