Disposed

Veronica Mary. a v. State of Tamil Nadu

Madras HC16 Dec 2022WP(MD)/21623/2022

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

A PIL challenging high infant mortality at Madurai's Government Rajaji Hospital sought court direction to construct a dedicated Institute of Child Health comparable to Chennai's facility. Relying on Supreme Court precedent, the High Court noted the State's constitutional duty to provide health services. Upon the Second Respondent submitting that upgrades and a new Institute of Child Health centre

What did the court decide?

Directed respondents to take speedy action to complete the proposed construction of an Institute of Child Health and Research Centre with modern facilities and equipment.

Veronica Mary. a Vs State of Tamil Nadu — Pension and Retirement Benefits | Madras HC (2022)

¶1

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶2

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

¶3

Reserved On : 24.11.2022

¶4

Delivered On : 16.12.2022

¶5

CORAM

¶6

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE R.MAHADEVAN and

¶7

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE J.SATHYA NARAYANA PRASAD

¶8

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶9

A.Veronica Mary .. Petitioner

¶10

Versus

¶11

1.State of Tamil Nadu represented by, The Principal Secretary, Health and Family Welfare Department,

¶12

State of Tamil Nadu,

¶13

Fort St. George, Secretariat,

¶14

Chennai - 600 009.

¶15

2.The Director, Directorate of Medical Education, 162, Periyar E.V.R.High Road, Kilpauk, Chennai - 600 010.

¶16

3.The Dean, Government Rajaji Hospital, Panagal Road,

¶17

Madurai - 625 020.

¶18

.. Respondents

¶19

PRAYER: Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to issue a Writ of Mandamus, or any other writ of direction or order in the nature of writ, to take appropriate action to reduce the infant mortality rate at Madurai and other southern Districts of Tamil Nadu as like facilities available at Institute of Child Health and Hospital (ICH)-Chennai by directing the respondents,

¶20

1/12

¶21

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶22

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶23

(a) to construct 'Institute of Child Health and Hospital for Children' at the premises of Government Rajaji Medical College Hospital, Maadurai or at any alternative location in Madurai City with the facilities for performing the 227 biochemical surgeries equivalent to the Institute of Child Health and Hospital (ICH)Chennai in accordance with the law within the time to be stipulated by this Court.

¶24

(b) To set up the modern state of medical equipments and operation theatres in the pediatric surgery unit at Government Rajaji Medical College Hospital, Madurai with adequate number of Pediatric Surgeons and Anaesthesiologists in accordance with law within the time to be stipulated by this Court.

¶25

(c) To constitute 'State Level Medical Committee' to study and report about the child deaths in pediatric surgery unit at Government Rajaji Medical College Hospital, Madurai in accordance with law within the time to be stipulated by this Court.

¶26

For Petitioner : Mr.P.Alagumani

¶27

For Respondents : Mr.P.Thilak Kumar Government Pleader for R1 to R3

¶28

O R D E R

¶29

R. MAHADEVAN, J.

¶30

The petitioner in the larger public interest, has preferred this writ petition for issuance of a writ of mandamus, directing the respondents to take appropriate action to reduce the infant mortality rate at Madurai and other southern Districts of Tamil Nadu like that of the facilities available at Institute of Child Health and Hospital (ICH), Chennai.

¶31

2/12

¶32

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶33

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶34

It is the grievance of the petitioner that due to lack of medical facilities at the Government Rajaji Medical College & Hospital, Madurai (hereinafter referred to as “the subject Hospital”), the infant mortality rate has been above 50%, when compared to the Institute of Child Health and Hospital, Chennai. In support of the same, the petitioner referred to statistical data, as per which, between 2018 and 2021, 4,432 surgeries were conducted in the Paediatric Surgery Unit at the subject Hospital and out of these, 261 infants died due to inadequate medi-care. Whereas, 137 infants died, out of 45,401 surgeries conducted in the Institute of Child Health and Hospital, Chennai.

¶35

The petitioner further pointed out that 86 types of biochemical surgeries are being carried out in the paediatric surgery unit at the subject Hospital, but 227 biochemical surgeries are being carried out at the Institute of Child Health and Hospital, Chennai. Further, the benefit of the Government Medical Insurance Scheme, provided to the paediatric surgery unit at the subject Hospital was to the tune of Rs. 3,68,79,274, whereas, the Institute of Child Health and Hospital, Chennai has received the benefit of Rs.11,85,96,650/-. It is also submitted that the Paediatric unit of the subject Hospital has only with a professor, an associate professor, and four assistant professors, besides two or three anaesthesiologists, but, there are sixteen faculty members working in shifts around the clock at the Paediatric Department of Chennai Egmore Hospital, in addition to twelve anaesthesiologists. As a consequence, Paediatric surgeries could only be performed on a predetermined date and time,

¶36

3/12

¶37

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶38

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶39

leading to a minimum number of surgeries and delay in the said process and therefore, the Chennai Egmore Hospital is recommended for major paediatric surgeries, which cause great hardship and irreparable prejudice to the poor people. Thus, according to the petitioner, it is just and necessary to upgrade the paediatric department of the subject hospital, but there are several departments functioning in the same building and hence, a separate building should be established away from the subject hospital with all the latest medical equipments, staffs and infrastructure like that of the Institute of Child Health and Hospital, Chennai. In this regard, he made a representation to the respondent authorities on 20.03.2022, which yielded no response. Therefore, this writ petition, as a public interest litigation.

¶40

Upon notice, the second respondent filed a detailed counter affidavit, wherein, it is inter alia stated that the Department of Paediatric Surgery at the subject Hospital is one of the oldest surgical speciality departments in Tamil Nadu. It has 38 bedded ward with 100% occupancy and post operative children and other sick surgical patients (children) are taken care of in special Paediatric Intensive Care Unit with 10 beds. The Paediatric Out-Patient Department opens every day at 8:00 a.m., and around 100 to 150 children are treated daily. That apart, the Institute of Child Health and Research Centre, Madurai is having 9 beds/warmers especially for neonatal intensive surgical care. The counter affidavit further proceeds to state that the Department of Paediatric Surgery at the subject Hospital provides treatment for paediatric burns and scalds and emergency surgeries are conducted 24x7, including

¶41

4/12

¶42

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶43

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶44

trauma situation. Further, a large number of Laparoscopic, Thoracoscopic, Paediatric Oncological, Hepatopancretico-biliary surgeries, corrective surgeries for congenital malformations, disorders of sexual differentiation, and other major urological operations are regularly performed. They purchased special instruments required for Paediatric surgery department under the Chief Minister's Comprehensive Health Insurance Scheme. It is also stated that the Institute of Child Health and Research Centre receives referrals of preterm babies, low birth weight babies, and children with terminal illnesses who have already been treated in other government and private hospitals, which require surgical intervention. The Paediatric Surgery Department of the subject hospital has 1 professor, 1 Associate Professor, 4 Assistant Professor and 6 Maternity and Child Health Post Graduates totalling to 12 Specialists. Thus, according to this respondent, the qualified Paediatric Surgeons are handling the Patients and performing surgeries and the increase of infant mortality is due to late referrals and complicated issues and that, the Paediatric department of the subject Hospital is functioning on par with the ICH, Chennai, and hence, there is no requirement to pass any order in this writ petition.

¶45

Heard the learned counsel on either side and perused the materials available on record.

¶46

At the first instance, this court feels it appropriate to refer to the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity v. State of

¶47

5/12

¶48

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶49

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶50

West Bengal and another [(1996) 4 SCC 37], wherein, after referring to various earlier decisions, it was held that right to health is a fundamental right in-built in Article 21 of the Constitution of India as right to life and ultimately, certain directions were issued, one such direction is that Hospitals at the District level and Sub-division level should be upgraded, so that, serious cases can be treated there. Further, the need of financial resources for medical facilities, was also emphasised by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. For better appreciation, the relevant passage of the said decision is extracted below:

¶51

“9.The Constitution envisages the establishment of a welfare state at the federal level as well as at the state level. In a welfare state the primary duty of the Government is to secure the welfare of the people. Providing adequate medical facilities for the people is an essential part of the obligations undertaken by the Government in a welfare state. The Government discharges this obligation by running hospitals and health centres which provide medical care to the person seeking to avail those facilities. Article 21 imposes an obligation on the State to safeguard the right to life of every person. Preservation of human life is thus of paramount importance. The Government hospitals run by the State and the medical officers employed therein are duty bound to extend medical assistance for preserving human life. Failure on the part of a Government hospital to provide timely medical treatment to a person in need of such treatment results in violation of his right to life guaranteed under Article 21. ...

¶52

It is no doubt true that financial resources are needed for providing these facilities. But at the same time it cannot be ignored that

¶53

6/12 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶54

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶55

it is the constitutional obligation of the State to provide adequate medical services to the people. Whatever is necessary for this purpose has to be done. In the context of the constitutional obligation to provide free legal aid to a poor accused this Court has held that the State cannot avoid its constitutional obligation in that regard on account of financial constraints. [ Khatri (II) v. State of Bihar, 1981 (1) SCC 627 at p. 631]. The said observations would apply with equal, if not greater, force in the matter of discharge of constitutional obligation of the State to provide medical aid to preserve human life. In the matter of allocation of funds for medical services the said constitutional obligation of the State has to be kept in view. It is necessary that a time-bound plan for providing these services should be chalked out keeping in view the recommendations of the Committee as well as the requirements for ensuring availability of proper medical services in this regard as indicated by us and steps should be taken to implement the same. The State of West Bengal alone is a party to these proceedings. Other States, though not parties, should also take necessary steps in the light of the recommendations made by the Committee, the directions contained in the Memorandum of the Government of West Bengal dated August 22, 1995 and the further directions given herein.

¶56

The Union of India is a party to these proceedings. Since it is the joint obligation of the Centre as well as the States to provide medical services it is expected that the Union of India would render the necessary assistance in the improvement of the medical services in the country on these lines."

¶57

Thus, it is manifest that the right to health is a fundamental right envisaged under Article 21 of the Constitution of India and that, it is the bounden duty of the Government to provide adequate medical facilities timely, to the public.

¶58

7/12

¶59

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶60

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶61

In the present case, the petitioner compared the medical facilities available in the Paediatric department of the subject Hospital with that of the ICH, Chennai and sought the following directions to the respondent authorities, to minimise the infant mortality:

¶62

¶63

(b) To set up the modern state of medical equipments and operation theatres in the paediatric surgery unit at Government Rajaji Medical College Hospital, Madurai with adequate number of Paediatric Surgeons and Anaesthesiologists; and

¶64

(c) To constitute 'State Level Medical Committee' to study and report about the child deaths in paediatric surgery unit at Government Rajaji Medical College Hospital, Madurai in accordance with law within a time frame to be stipulated by this Court.

¶65

8.1. Earlier, this court, upon considering the petitioner's grievances, directed the learned counsel appearing for the respondents, to file a written response, after getting proper instructions. Accordingly, a detailed counter affidavit has been filed by the second respondent, wherein, it is categorically stated that,

¶66

8/12 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶67

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶68

(i) The Government has taken steps to construct a full-fledged Institute of Child Health and Research Centre in Madurai, containing a general Paediatric Ward, Paediatric Intensive Care Unit, wards for Paediatric Super Specialities, such as Paediatric Cardiology, Neurology, Nephrology, Gastroentrology, Hemato Oncology, and Respiratory Medicine, as well as a New Born Ward and a Paediatric Surgery Unit. Besides this, the respondent authorities planned to install a State-of-the-Art Bone Marrow Transplant Unit, Cardiac Catheterisation Lab, Dialysis Unit, and Rental Transplantation Unit.

¶69

(ii) The Institute of Child Health, Madurai will be in a better position to offer State-of-the-Art Medical facility to the paediatric patients and more modern equipment are being proposed to be procured based on the need from time to time and with the establishment of modern building, more sophisticated equipment would be made available to the Institute of Child Health and Research Centre, Madurai.

¶70

(iii) The death audit of various departments of Government Medical College Hospital in Tamil Nadu is being conducted every month by the concerned Medical College Deans, Resident Medical Officers and Head of various Departments of Medical Colleges. These audits carefully examine the deaths occurring in Paediatric and Paediatric surgical departments and take necessary steps to prevent occurrence of such incidents in future.

¶71

9/12

¶72

https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶73

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶74

8.2. It is also submitted by the learned counsel appearing for the respondent authorities that the Government proposed to upgrade the Institute of Child Health and Research Centre as Centre of Excellence at a cost of Rs.20 crores and the sanction of initial amount of Rs.4 crores for 2022-23 for the construction of 400 bedded, G + 2 floors is under consideration.

¶75

In view of the present factual position as stated above, which has addressed the petitioner's grievances, this court, by recording the averments made in the counter affidavit filed by the second respondent, direct the authorities to take speedy action and complete the same as expeditiously as possible. Needless to state that the Government should approve the proposal with respect to Medicare issues, if any, with immediate effect as observed in Paschim Banga Khet Mazdoor Samity (supra).

¶76

This writ petition stands disposed of, with the aforesaid direction. No costs.

¶77

16.12.2022

¶78

Internet : Yes. Index : Yes / No

¶79

r n s

¶80

10/12 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶81

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶82

¶83

1.The Principal Secretary, Government of Tamil Nadu, Health and Family Welfare Department, State of Tamil Nadu, Fort St. George, Secretariat, Chennai - 600 009.

¶84

2.The Director, Directorate of Medical Education, 162, Periyar E.V.R.High Road, Kilpauk, Chennai - 600 010.

¶85

3.The Dean, Government Rajaji Hospital, Panagal Road, Madurai - 625 020.

¶86

11/12 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

¶87

W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶88

R. MAHADEVAN, J. and J.SATHYA NARAYANA PRASAD, J.

¶89

r n s

¶90

Pre-delivery order in W.P.(MD)No.21623 of 2022

¶91

16/12/2022

¶92

12/12 https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis

Veronica Mary. a v. State of Tamil Nadu

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Veronica Mary. a v. State of Tamil Nadu

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

M. Mohamed Jamil, Vs The District Collector

Thangamshiri Pr Vs The Chief Manager

B Anbarasan Vs the Secretary

Kumar .P Vs The District Collector

Jawaharlal Nehru, Vs the State of Tamil Nadu

Dr.C.Subramanian Vs The Registrar