Disposed

Sudheena.S., v. Dr. Anusree.M.

Kerala HC27 Oct 2023OP(KAT)/107/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The court set aside the Tribunal's order directing reservation from 1996, holding that the PSC need only advise based on vacancies in the present notification and the additional statement filed. The OPs were disposed of accordingly.

What did the court decide?

The impugned judgment of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal was set aside; PSC to advise only based on the present notification with reference to vacancies mentioned in the additional statement.

`12`	`DR. KARTHIKA.K.B.,` `AGED 29 YEARS` `KURUVOKKEVELI, VARANAM.P.O., CHERUVARANAM,` `CHERTHALA, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 688555`
`13`	`DR. MAHESH.S.,` `AGED 35 YEARS` `SIVAPADMAM, THONALLOOR, PANDALAM.P.O.,` `PATHANAMTHITTA, PIN - 689501`
`14`	`DR. AKHILA.S.,` `AGED 30 YEARS` `MANAKKATTU PUTHUVAL, MUTHUKULAM SOUTH.P.O.,` `MUTHUKULAM, ALAPPUZHA, PIN - 690506`
`15`	`STATE OF KERALA,` `REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT,` `GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN -` `695001`
`16`	`SECRETARY,` `AYUSH DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,` `THIRUANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001`
`17`	`SECRETARY.` `SOCIAL JUSTICE DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,` `THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001`
`18`	`DIRECTOR,`
	`INDIAN SYSTEM OF MEDICINE, AROGYA BHAVAN, M.G.` `ROAD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001`
`19`	`KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION,` `REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, THULASI HILLS,` `PATTOM, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004` `BY ADVS.` `VISHNU NAIR`
	`ACHUTH KYLAS`
	`SREEDEVI KYLASANATH`
	`R.MAHESH MENON`
	`SACHIN.P.K` `VARGHESE XAVIER`
	`ANANTHU R.S.`
	`ADV. SAIGI JACOB PALATHY, GOVERNMENT PLEADER`

	CATEGORY	RANK LIST	IDENTIFIED	NUMBER OF	UNFILLED
	NUMBER	PUBLISHED	VACANCIES	PERSONS	VACANCI	REMARKS
SI NO		DATE		ADVISED	ES
1	206/2007	15.06.2009	11	6	5	Kerala Public Service Commissionhad converted these08 unfilled vacancies to the general quota. These08 vacancies
2	223/2012(3% DA BACKLOG FROM 2004 TO 2007)	01.01.2013	7	4	3	were reported as backlog vacancies for persons with disabilityto Kerala Public Service Commissionfrom this department on29.12.2022.Out of these08 vacancies. 04 DA-LD/CP candidates and03 DA-Low Vision candidates were advised by Kerala Public Service Commissionfrom the rank list, which came intoeffect from 08.07.2020.01 vacancyset apart to be filled from the nextrank list due to no Low Vision candidate is remained in the said ranklist.
3	268/2011	19.11.2014	5 (3+5) 8 (DA)	NIL 8	5 0	These 05 vacancies, which is already filled up from the next rank list pursuant to notification No. 541/2017, which came into effect from 08.07.2020 3 newly identified vacancy along with05unfilledvacancies mentioned in SI. No. 3.
4	541/2017 08.0	7.2020	(2+8) 10 (DA Backlog)	9	1	Two new vacancies reported including 08 converted vacancies mentioned in SL No. 1 & 2.01 unfilled vacancy set apart to be filled from the next rank list due tono Low Vision candidate isremained in the rank list

`PETITIONER ANNEX` `Annexure RA1`	`URES` `TRUE COPY OF THE` `TRIBUNAL IN OA.NO` `10.09.2022`	`ORDER OF THE HON'BLE` `.1439/2021 DATED`
`Annexure RA2`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `PUBLIC SERVICE CO` `DIRECTOR OF INDIA`	`LETTER OF THE KERALA` `MMISSION TO THE` `N SYSTEM OF MEDICINES`
`Annexure RA3`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `NO.148/2020 DATED`	`JUDGMENT IN OP (KAT)` `06.10.2020`
`AnnexureRA4`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `OF SOCIAL JUSTICE` `27.05.2019`	`NOTICE OF THE DIRECTOR` `DEPARTMENT DATED`
`AnnexureRA5`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `GO.NO.15/2020/SWD`	`GOVERNMENT ORDER` `DATED 14.08.2020`
`AnnexureA1`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 29/03/2010` `BY RAJIV GANDHI U` `SCIENCES, KARNATA`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `ISSUED TO THE APPLICANT` `NIVERSITY OF HEALTH` `KA`
`Annexure A2`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DISABILITY DATED` `THE APPLICANT BY` `MEDICAL COLLEGE H`	`CERTIFICATE OF` `12/09/2019 ISSUED TO` `THE, MEDICAL BOARD,` `OSPITAL, CALICUT.`
`Annexure A3`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BEARING NO.36035/` `07/01/2015 ISSUED` `SECRETARY TO GOVE`	`OFFICE MEMORANDUM` `4/22013 DATED` `BY THE DEPUTY` `RNMENT OF INDIA`
`Annexure A4`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `NO.8/17/SJD DATED` `THE FIRST RESPOND`	`ORDER BEARING NO.GO(P)` `06/05/2017 ISSUED BY` `ENT.`
`Annexure A5`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `NO.79/D1/178/SJD` `BY THE 1ST RESPON`	`CIRCULAR BEARING` `DATED 07.02.2018 ISSUED` `DENT.`
`Annexure A6`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `(MS)NO.29/11/SWD` `ISSUED BY THE 1ST`	`ORDER BEARING G.O.` `DATED 07.05.2011,` `RESPONDENT.`
`AnnexureA7`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `HON'BLE KERALA AD` `IN OA.(EKM) 76 OF`	`ORDER PASSED BY THE` `MINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL` `2020 DATED 12/02/2020`
`Annexure A8`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `NO.A2/322/2019/AY` `ISSUED BY THE 2ND`	`PROCEEDINGS BEARING` `USH DATED 27.03.2020` `RESPONDENT.`

`Annexure A9`	`TRUE COPY OF THE ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION` `DATED 29/01/2021 BEARING` `NO.SSVI/AY.MED.OFFICER/(ISM&IMS)RL/2020` `ISSUED BY KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE` `COMMISSION.`
`Annexure A10`	`TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BEARING NO.D3-` `90887/2020/ISM DATED 29/09/2020 ISSUED` `BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT`
`Annexure A11`	`TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY DATED 05/11/2020,` `ISSUED BY THE 3RD RESPONDENT UNDER THE` `RIGHT TO INFORMATION ACT. 2005.`
`Annexure A12`	`TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BEARING NO.GO(P)` `NO.11/2021/SJD DATED 26/06/2021 ISSUED` `BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT.`
`Annexure A13`	`TRUE COPY OF THE GOVERNMENT ORDER` `BEARING G.O.(P) NO.18/2018//SJD DATED` `18/11/2018 ISSUED BY THE 1ST RESPONDENT`
`Annexure A14`	`TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEARING` `NO.D1/120/2021/SJD DATED 16/07/2021` `ISSUED BY 1ST RESPONDENT.`
`Exhibit P1`	`TRUE COPY OF RA.NO.33/2022 IN` `OA.NO.1439/2022`
`Exhibit P2`	`TRUE COPY OF THE O.A 1439/2021 FILED` `BEFORE THE KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE` `TRIBUNAL, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.`
`Exhibit P3`	`CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER OF KERALA` `ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,` `THIRUVANANTHAPURAM IN RA.33/2022 IN` `OA.1439/2022 DATED 29.11.2022`
`Exhibit P4`	`CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE` `KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,` `THIRUVANANTHAPURAM IN OA.NO.1439/2021` `DATED 19.09.2022`
`Exhibit P5`	`TRUE COPY OF GOVERNMENT ORDER, G.O.` `(RT)NO.579/2022/AYUSH DATED 20.12.2022`
`Exhibit P6`	`TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT CHART BY` `THE SECRETARY OF PUBLIC SERVICE` `COMMISSION NO.RFI(2)11200/2018/GW` `CATEGORY NO.541/2017`
`RESPONDENT EXHIBITS`
`Exhibit R-1(j)`	`A true copy of the Order No. 36012/ 24/` `2009-Estt(Res) dated 03.12.2013 issued` `by Ministry of Personnel, Public` `Grievaces and Pensions`

`Exhibit R-1(a)`	`A true copy of the judgment in O.P.(KAT)` `No. 148 of 2020 passed by this Hon'ble` `Court.`
`Exhibit R-1(b)`	`A true copy of the said Order No. D 3-` `42643 / 2018 DISM Thiruvananthapuram,` `dated 28/12/2022.`
`Exhibit R-1(c)`	`A true copy of the proforma ID No: 32531` `dated 29-12-2022 reporting 8 Back log` `vacancy for Differently abled persons to` `Kerala Public Service Commission`
`Exhibit R-1(d)`	`A true copy of the revised proforma ID` `No: 35520 dated 26-04-2023 reporting 12` `Back log vacancy for Differently abled` `persons to Kerala Public Service` `Commission`
`Exhibit R-1(e)`	`A true copy of the Office Memorandum` `bearing No. 36035/3/2004-Esst (Res)` `dated 29 December 2005, issued by the` `Government of India.`
`Exhibit R-1(f)`	`A true copy of the Office Memorandum` `bearing No. 36035/02/2017-Esst (Res)` `dated 15/01/2018, issued by the` `Government of India`
`Exhibit R-1(g)`	`A true copy of the said report bearing` `No. D3 42643/2018 dated 25/10/2022` `issued by the Director, Indian Systems` `of Medicine to the AYUSH Department`
`Exhibit R-1(h)`	`A true copy of the order bearing No.` `G.O.(Rt)No.579/2022/AYUSH` `Thiruvananthapuram dated 20-12-2022` `issued by the AYUSH (A) DEPARTMENT`
`Exhibit R-1(i)`	`A true copy of the Appointment Chart No.` `RIF (2) 11200/2018/GW Category` `No.541/2017 of Medical Officer` `(Ayurveda), Indian Systems of Medicine,` `issued by Kerala Public Service` `Commission, Dated 06/05/2023`
`Exhibit R-1(k)`	`A true copy of the G.O.(P) No.` `119/2005/SWD dated 06.08.2005`
`Exhibit R-1(l)`	`A true copy of the G. O. (P) No. 32/` `2007/ SWD dated 28.06.2007`
`Exhibit R-1(m)`	`A true copy of the said Order G.O. (P)` `No. 31/2008/SWD dated 19.05.2008`
`Exhibit R-1(n)`	`A true copy of the G.O.(P) No.`

`Exhibit R-1(o)`	`46/2008/SWD dated 19.07.2008` `A true copy of the said Kerala Public` `Service Commission Circular No. 21/ 2008` `dated 19.08.2008`
`Exhibit R-1(p)`	`A true copy of the RTI Application dated` `05.10.2020 before Indian System of` `Medicine`
`Exhibit R-1(q)`	`A true copy of Reply No. G3/108508/2020` `dated 05.11.2020 issued by Indian System` `of Medicine under the Right to` `information act`
`Exhibit R-1(r)`	`A true copy of the rank list of Category` `No. 206/ 2007 dated 15.06.2009`
`Exhibit R-1(s)`	`A true copy of the Appointment Chart of` `Category No. 206/ 2007 advised on` `30.12.2013`
`Exhibit R-1(t)`	`A true copy of the GO (P) No.` `07/2011/SWD dated 24.01.2011`
`Exhibit R-1(u)`	`A true copy of the rank list of` `physically handicapped back log in` `Category No. 223/2012 with effect from` `01.01.2013`
`Exhibit R-1(v)`	`A true copy of the appointment chart of` `physically handicapped in Category No.` `223/2012 advised on 18.02.2013`
`Exhibit R-1(w)`	`A true copy of the Appointment Chart of` `Cat. No: 268/ 2011 advised on 24.12.2014`
`Exhibit R-1(x)`	`A true copy of the Appointment Chart of` `Cat. No. 268/ 2011 advised on 12.06.2015`
`Exhibit R-1(y)`	`A true copy of the Appointment Chart of` `Category No. 268/ 2011 advised on` `25.01.2018`
`RESPONDENT EXHIBITS`
`Exhibit R6(a)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 06.05.2023` `OF THE SECRETARY, KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE` `COMMISSION TO NOUSHIDA.A`
`Exhibit R6(b)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 22.06.2023` `ISSUED BY NOUSHIDA TO THE DIRECTOR OF` `INDIAN SYSTEM OF MEDICINES`
`Exhibit R7(a)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE RANK LIST` `NO.213/2020/SSVI CAT.NO.541/2017`
`Exhibit R7(b)`	`TRUE COPY OF GO(MS) NO.9/2023/AYUSH` `DATED 07.07.2023`

`Annexure R4(b)`	`A true copy of the Details of` `Differently Abled candidates joined duty` `in the Open Category turn.`
`Annexure R4(e)`	`True copy of the order dated 29.03.2023` `in CP-221/2022 in OA 1439/2021`
`Annexure R4(c)`	`True copy of vacancies reporting` `proforma ID: 32531 dated 29.12.2022.`
`Annexure R4(d)`	`True copy of e-vacancy proforma ID:` `34121 on 23.02.2023.`
`Annexure R4(f)`	`True copy of e-vacancy proforma ID 35520` `26.04.2023.`
`Annexure R4(a)`	`A true copy of Details (dated` `27.02.2023) of candidates those who` `received appointments through` `Differently Abled reservation turn from` `1996 to 29.09.2020`
`Annexure R4(g)`	`Appointment details of medical officer` `(Ayurveda )through differently abled` `reservation from 08.07.2020`
`Annexure R4(h)`	`True copy of the Government Order dated` `07.07.2023`
`RESPONDENT EXHIBITS`
`Exhibit R8(a)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT EXTRACT OF THE` `NOTIFICATION PUBLISHED IN THE EXTRA` `ORDINARY GAZETTE DATED 14-12-2017 AS PER` `CATEGORY NUMBER 541/2017`
`Exhibit R8(b)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE RELEVANT EXTRACT OF THE` `DRAFT RANK LIST NO.213/2020/SSVI` `CAT.NO.541/2017 OF KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE` `COMMISSION`
`Exhibit R8(c)`	`TRUE COPY OF THE NUMBER VACANCIES THAT` `HAD BEEN REPORTED DURING THE TENURE FROM` `28/01/2022 TO TILL 07/07/2023`

`Annexure A1`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `DATED 29/03/2010 : ISSUED TO THE` `APPLICANT FROM THE RAJIV GANDHI` `UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCE, KARNATAKA.`
`Annexure A2`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE OF` `DISABILITY DATED 12/09/2011 ISSUED TO` `THE APPLICANT BY THE MEDICAL BOARD,` `MEDICAL COLLEGE HOSPITAL, CALICUT.`
`Annexure A3`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE OFFICE MEMORANDUM` `BEARING NO. 36035/4/2013 DATED` `07/01/2015 ISSUED BY THE DEPUTY` `SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT OF INDIA.`
`Annexure A4`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER BEARING NO.` `GO (P) NO. 8/17/SJD DATED 06/05/2017` `ISSUED BY THE FIRST RESPONDENT.`
`Annexure A5`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE SAID CIRCULAR` `BEARING NO. 79/D1/18/SJD DATED` `07/02/2018 ISSUED BY THE FIRST` `RESPONDENT`
`Annexure A6`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE SAID ORDER BEARING` `G.O.(MS) NO. 29/11/SWD DATED 07/05/2011,` `ISSUED BY THE FIRST RESPONDENT.`
`Annexure A7`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER PASSED BY THE` `HONOURABLE KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE` `TRIBUNAL IN OA (EKM) 76 OF 2020 DATED` `12/02/2020.`
`Annexure A8`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE PROCEEDINGS BEARING` `NO. A2/322/2019/ AYUSH DATED 27/03/2020` `ISSUED BY THE SECOND RESPONDENT.`
`Annexure A9`	`THE TRUE COPY OF THE ADDENDUM` `NOTIFICATION DATED 29/01/2021 BEARING` `NO, SS` `VI/AY.MED.OFFICER/(ISM&IMS)RL/2020` `ISSUED BY KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE` `COMMISSION`
`Annexure A10`	`TRUE COPY OF ORDER BEARING NO. D3-` `90997/2020/ISM DATED 29/09/2020 ISSUED` `BY THE THIRD RESPONDENT.`
`Annexure A11`	`THE TRUE COPY F THE REPLY DATED` `05/11/2020, ISSUED BY THE THIRD` `RESPONDENT UNDER THE RIGHT TO`

	`INFORMATION ACT,`	`2005.`
`Annexure A12`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `GO(P) NO.11/2021/` `ISSUED BY THE FIR`	`THE ORDER BEARING NO.` `SJD DATED 26/06/2021` `ST RESPONDENT`
`Annexure A13`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `BEARING G.O.(P) N` `18/11/2018 ISSUED` `RESPONDENT.`	`THE GOVERNMENT ORDER` `O. 18/2018/SJD DATED` `BY THE FIRST`
`Annexure A14`	`TRUE COPY OF PROC` `D1/120/2021/SJD D` `BY FIRST RESPONDE`	`EEDINGS BEARING NO.` `ATED 16/07/2021 ISSUED` `NT.`
`Annexure RA1`	`CERTIFIED COPY OF` `2022 IN O.A. NO.` `HON'BLE TRIBUNAL.`	`THE ORDER DATED 19-09-` `1439/2021 PASSED BY THE`
`Annexure RA2`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 14/12/2017.`	`EXTRAORDINARY GAZETTE`
`Annexure RA3`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `THE KERALA PUBLIC` `CATEGORY NO. 541/`	`SHORTLIST PUBLISHED BY` `SERVICE COMMISSION ON` `2017 DATED 07/08/2019`
`Annexure RA4`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BY KERALA PUBLIC` `DATED 06/01/2020.`	`ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION` `SERVICE COMMISSION`
`Annexure RA5`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `ADMINISTRATIVE TR` `IN OA (EKM) 76/20`	`JUDGEMENT OF KERALA` `IBUNAL DATED 12/02/2020` `20.`
`Annexure RA6`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BY KERALA PUBLIC` `DATED 22/04/2020`	`ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION` `SERVICE COMMISSION`
`Annexure RA7`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `APPLICATION DATED`	`RIGHT TO INFORMATION` `23/08/2022.`
`Annexure RA8`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `RESPONSE FROM KER` `COMMISSION DATED`	`RIGHT TO INFORMATION` `ALA PUBLIC SERVICE` `22/09/2022.`
`Annexure RA9`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BY KERALA PUBLIC` `DATED 29/01/2021`	`ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION` `SERVICE COMMISSION`
`Annexure RA10`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `HON'BLE HIGH COUR` `NO. 148 OF 2020.`	`JUDGEMENT OF THE` `T OF KERALA IN OP (KAT)`
`Annexure RA11`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `PHYSICALLY HANDIC` `CATEGORY NO. 541/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `APPED BACKLOG IN` `2017 DATED 06/08/2021.`
`Annexure RA12`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `CATEGORY NO. 541/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2017 DATED 07/03/2022.`

`Annexure RA13`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `541/2017 DATED 20/10/2022.`
`Annexure RA14`	`TRUE COPY OF` `ADMINISTRATIV` `629/2018 DATE`	`THE ORDER OF KERALA` `E TRIBUNAL IN OA NO.` `D 19/09/2022`
`Annexure RA15`	`TRUE COPY OF` `DISABILITIES`	`THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH` `ACT 2016.`
`Annexure RA16`	`TRUE COPY OF` `DISABILITIES`	`THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH` `RULES, 2017`
`Annexure RA17`	`TRUE COPY OF` `HANDICAPPED B` `223/2012`	`THE LIST OF PHYSICALLY` `ACKLOG IN CATEGORY NO.`
`Annexure RA18`	`TRUE COPY OF` `PHYSICALLY HA` `223/2012 ADVI`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `NDICAPPED IN CATEGORY NO.` `SED ON 18/02/2013.`
`Annexure RA19`	`TRUE COPY OF` `NO. 206/2007`	`THE RANKLIST OF CATEGORY` `DATED 15/06/2009`
`Annexure RA20`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `11/07/2007.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `206/2007 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA21`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `30/12/2013.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `206/2007 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA22`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `24/12/2014.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `268/2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA23`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `12/06/2015.`	`THE : APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `268/2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA24`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `25/01/2018`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `268/2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA25`	`TRUE COPY OF` `JUSTICE DEPAR`	`THE ORDER OF SOCIAL WELFARE` `TMENT DATED 14/08/2020.`
`Exhibit P1`	`TRUE COPY OF` `BEFORE THE KE` `TRIBUNAL THIR` `29.07.2021`	`THE O.A NO. 1439/2021` `RALA ADMINISTRATIVE` `UVANANTHAPURAM DATED`
`Exhibit P2`	`TRUE COPY OF` `19/09/2022 IN` `O.A. NO. 629/`	`THE COMMON ORDER DATED` `O.A. NO. 1439/2021 AND` `2018.`
`Exhibit P3`	`TRUE COPY OF` `O.A. NO. 1439` `PETITIONERS D`	`THE R.A. NO. 36/2022 IN` `/2021 FILED BY THE` `ATED 05.12.2022`

`Exhibit P4`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `IN R.A. NO. 36/20` `1439/2021 OF THE` `THIRUVANANTHAPURA`	`ORDER DATED 13/02/2023` `22 IN O.A. NO.` `HON'BLE TRIBUNAL,` `M.`
`Exhibit P5`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `675/14/SSIV, CAT.` `POST OF MEDICAL O` `EFFECT FROM 19/11`	`RANKED LIST NO.` `NO..268/2011 FOR THE` `FFICER (AYURVEDA) WITH` `/2014`
`Exhibit P6`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `675/14/SSIV, CAT.` `POST OF MEDICAL O` `EFFECT FROM 19/11`	`RANKED LIST NO.` `NO..268/2011 FOR THE` `FFICER (AYURVEDA) WITH` `/2014`
`Exhibit P7`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `APPOINTMENT CHART` `11200/2018/GW, CA`	`RELEVANT EXTRACT OF THE` `NO. RIF (2)` `TEGORY NO. 541/2017`
`EXHIBIT P8`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 29.12.2005.`	`OFFICE MEMORANDUM OF`
`EXHIBIT P9`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `G.O.(P) 07/2011/S`	`ABOVE GOVERNMENT ORDER` `WD DATED 24.01.2011`

`Annexure A1`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 23/04/2011`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 1ST APPLICANT`
`Annexure A2`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 30/11/2016`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 2ND APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A3`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 03/12/2013`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 3RD APPLICANT`
`Annexure A4`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 20/04/2017`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 4TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A5`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 25/10/2016`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 5TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A6`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 07/04/2016`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 6TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A7`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 05/05/2015`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 7TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A8`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 25/03/2014`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 8TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A9`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 25/06/2015`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE NINTH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A10`	`TRUE COPY OF ORDE` `DATED 27/04/2015`	`R D` `OF`	`EGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 10TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A11`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 28/03/2016`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 11TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A12`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 07/10/2017`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 12TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A13`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATED 02/01/2022`	`THE` `OF`	`DEGREE CERTIFICATE` `THE 13TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A14`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `07/09/2016 OF THE`	`DEG` `14`	`REE CERTIFICATE DATED` `TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A15`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `25/09/2017 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`THE` `BY` `1S`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `T APPLICANT`
`Annexure A16`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `22/10/2016 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDE` `BY` `2N`	`NTITY CARD DATED` `THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `D APPLICANT`
`Annexure A17`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `03/10/2013 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`THE` `BY` `3R`	`IDENTITY CARD DAD` `THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `D APPLICANT`
`Annexure A18`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `ASSESSMENT BOARD`	`THE` `CER`	`STANDING DISABILITY` `TIFICATE DATED`

	`20/10/2017 ISSUED` `QUARTERS HOSPITAL` `TO THE 4TH APPLIC`	`FROM THE TALUK HEAD` `, KARUNGAPPALLY, KOLLAM` `ANT`
`Annexure A19`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `11/10/2010 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL WELFARE` `5TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A20`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `15/07/2014 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `6TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A21`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `15/05/2015 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `7TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A22`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `02/01/2015 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL JUSTICE` `8TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A23`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `30/09/2010 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL WELFARE` `9TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A24`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 21/08/2015` `BOARD, GOVERNMENT` `APPLICANT.`	`MEDICAL CERTIFICATE` `ISSUED BY THE MEDICAL` `OF KERALA TO THE 10TH`
`Annexure A25`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 06/07/2017` `MEDICAL BOARD, ER` `APPLICANT.`	`DISABILITY CERTIFICATE` `ISSUED FROM THE DISTRICT` `NAKULAM TO THE 11TH`
`Annexure A26`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `04/02/2012 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL WELFARE` `12TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A27`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `21/09/2015 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DATED` `BY THE SOCIAL WELFARE` `13TH APPLICANT.`
`Annexure A28`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `04/04.2012 ISSUED` `DEPARTMENT TO THE`	`IDENTITY CARD DARTED` `BY THE SOCIAL WELFARE` `14TH APPLICANT`
`Annexure A29`	`TRUE COPY OF JUDG` `SUPREME COURT IN` `FOUNDATION V. UNI`	`EMENT OF THE HONOURABLE` `JUSTICE SUNANDA BHANDARA` `ON OF INDIA & ANOTHER.`
`Annexure A30`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `2015 IN O.A.(EKM)`	`FINAL ORDER DATED 20-5-` `959 OF 2014.`
`Annexure A31`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `SUPREME COURT OF` `AND ANOTHER V NAT` `BLIND AND OTHERS.`	`JUDGEMENT OF THE HON.` `INDIA IN UNION OF INDIA` `IONAL FEDERATION OF`

`Annexure A32`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BEARING NO. 36035`	`O.M. DATED 7-1-2015` `/4/2013 - ESST (RES.).`
`Annexure A33`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `(P) NO. 8/17/SJD`	`GOVT. ORDER BEARING GO` `DATED 6-5-2017`
`Annexure A34`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `BEARING NO. 79/D1`	`CIRCULAR DATED 7-2-2018,` `/18/SJD.`
`Annexure A35`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `ISSUED UNDER THE` `ACT.`	`REPLY DATED 11-12-2017` `RIGHT TO INFORMATION`
`Annexure A36`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `12-2017.`	`NOTIFICATION DATED 14-`
`Annexure A37`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `3-2018, SUBMITTED` `RESPONDENT.`	`REPRESENTATION DATED 27-` `BEFORE THE SECOND`
`Annexure A38`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `3-2018, SUBMITTED` `RESPONDENT.`	`REPRESENTATION DATED 27-` `BEFORE THE THIRD`
`Annexure A39`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `3-2018 SHOWING TH` `A37 REPRESENTATIO`	`POSTAL RECEIPT DATED 27-` `E DISPATCH OF ANNEXURE-` `N.`
`Annexure A40`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `3-2018 SHOWING TH` `A38 REPRESENTATIO`	`POSTAL RECEIPT DATED 27-` `E DISPATCH OF ANNEXURE-` `N`
`DOCUMENT`	`MISCELLANEOUS APP` `TOGETHER`	`LICATION FOR JOIN`
`Annexure A41`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `SAID PROVISIONAL` `10.11.2017.`	`RELEVANT PAGES OF THE` `SENIORITY LIST DATED`
`Annexure A42`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `ISSUED BY THE 5TH` `APPOINTMENT OF DR` `GENERAL QUOTA AND` `SC QUOTA IN THE P` `AYURVEDA.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART` `RESPONDENT SHOWING THE` `. LITTY TOM UNDER THE` `DR. SUMA A.P. UNDER THE` `OST OF MEDICAL OFFICER`
`Annexure A43`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `DATES 7.8.2019 BE` `541/2017.`	`THE SAID SHORT LIST` `ARING CATEGORY NO.`
`Annexure A44`	`THE TRUE COPY OF` `30.8.2019 IN OA (`	`THE ORDER DATED` `EKM) 1501/2019.`
`Annexure RA1`	`CERTIFIED COPY OF` `2022 IN O.A. NO.` `HON'BLE TRIBUNAL.`	`THE ORDER DATED 19-09-` `629/2018 PASSED BY THE`
`Annexure RA2`	`TRUE COPY OF THE` `DATED 14/12/2017.`	`EXTRAORDINARY GAZETTE`

`Annexure RA3`	`TRUE COPY OF` `THE KERALA PU` `CATEGORY NO.`	`THE SHORTLIST PUBLISHED BY` `BLIC SERVICE COMMISSION ON` `541/2017 DATED 07/08/2019.`
`Annexure RA4`	`TRUE COPY OF` `KERALA PUBLIC` `06/01/2020.`	`THE ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION BY` `SERVICE COMMISSION DATED`
`Annexure RA5`	`TRUE COPY OF` `ADMINISTRATIV` `IN OA (EKM) 7`	`THE JUDGEMENT OF KERALA` `E TRIBUNAL DATED 12/02/2020` `6/2020.`
`Annexure RA6`	`TRUE COPY OF` `KERALA PUBLIC` `22/04/2020.`	`THE ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION BY` `SERVICE COMMISSION DATED`
`Annexure RA7`	`TRUE COPY OF` `RESPONSE ON A` `FROM KERALA P` `DATED 22/09/2`	`THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION` `PPLICATION DATED 23/08/2022` `UBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION` `022.`
`Annexure RA8`	`TRUE COPY OF` `RESPONSE ON A` `FROM KERALA P` `DATED 22/09/2`	`THE RIGHT TO INFORMATION` `PPLICATION DATED 23/08/2022` `UBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION` `022`
`Annexure RA9`	`TRUE COPY OF` `KERALA PUBLIC` `29/01/2021.`	`THE ADDENDUM NOTIFICATION BY` `SERVICE COMMISSION DATED`
`Annexure RA10`	`TRUE COPY OF` `HIGH COURT OF` `OF 2020.`	`THE JUDGEMENT OF THE HON'BLE` `KERALA IN OP (KAT) NO. 148`
`Annexure RA11`	`TRUE COPY OF` `PHYSICALLY HA` `CATEGORY NO.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `NDICAPPED BACKLOG IN` `541/2017 DATED 06/08/2021.`
`Annexure RA12`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `541/2017 DATED 07/03/2022.`
`Annexure RA13`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `541/2017 DATED 20/10/2022.`
`Annexure RA14`	`TRUE COPY OF` `ADMINISTRATIV` `1439/2021 DAT`	`THE ORDER OF KERALA` `E TRIBUNAL IN OA NO.` `ED 19/09/2022.`
`Annexure RA15`	`TRUE COPY OF` `DISABILITIES`	`THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH` `ACT 2016`
`Annexure RA16`	`TRUE COPY OF` `DISABILITIES`	`THE RIGHTS OF PERSONS WITH` `RULES, 2017`
`Annexure RA17`	`TRUE COPY OF` `HANDICAPPED B` `223/2012.`	`THE LIST OF PHYSICALLY` `ACKLOG IN CATEGORY NO.`
`Annexure RA18`	`TRUE COPY OF`	`THE APPOINTMENT CHART OF`

	`PHYSICALLY H` `223/2012 ADV`	`ANDIC` `ISED`	`APPED IN CATEGORY NO.` `ON 18/02/2013`
`Annexure RA19`	`TRUE COPY OF` `206/2007 DAT`	`THE` `ED 15`	`RANKLIST OF CATEGORY NO.` `/06/2009.`
`Annexure RA20`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `11/07/2007`	`THE` `206/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2007 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA21`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `30/12/2013.`	`THE` `206/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2007 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA22`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `24/12/2014`	`THE` `268/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA23`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `12/06/2015`	`THE` `268/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA24`	`TRUE COPY OF` `CATEGORY NO.` `25/01/2018`	`THE` `268/`	`APPOINTMENT CHART OF` `2011 ADVISED ON`
`Annexure RA25`	`TRUE COPY OF` `JUSTICE DEPA` `G.O.(PRINTIN`	`THE` `RTMEN` `G) 15`	`ORDER OF SOCIAL WELFARE` `T DATED 14/08/2020 NO.` `/2020/SJD`
`Annexure RA26`	`TRUE COPY OF` `NO.213/2020/` `08/07/2020`	`THE` `SSVI`	`RANK LIST` `NO.541/2017 DATED`
`Annexure R1-a`	`TRUE COPY OF` `HON'BLE COUR` `FOR PERSONS` `OP (RPWD)NO.`	`THE` `T OF` `WITH` `744/`	`ORDER PASSED BY THE` `THE STATE COMMISSIONER` `DISABILITIES, KERALA IN` `S2/2022 DATED 30/06/2022`
`Annexure R1-b`	`TRUE COPY OF` `BEARING NO.` `DATED 15/01/` `OF INDIA`	`THE` `36035` `2018`	`OFFICE MEMORANDUM` `/02/2017-ESST (RES)` `ISSUED BY THE GOVERNMENT`
`Exhibit P1`	`TRUE COPY OF` `THE KERALA A` `THIRUVANANTH`	`THE` `DMINI` `APURA`	`O.A. NO. 629/2018 BEFORE` `STRATIVE TRIBUNAL,` `M DATED 24.04.2018.`
`Exhibit P2`	`TRUE COPY OF` `19/09/2022 I` `NO. 1439/202`	`THE` `N O.A` `1.`	`COMMON ORDER DATED` `. NO. 629/2018 AND O.A.`
`Exhibit P3`	`TRUE COPY OF` `NO.629/2018` `DATED 05.12.`	`THE` `FILED` `2022.`	`R.A. NO. 35/2022 IN O.A.` `BY THE PETITIONERS`
`Exhibit P4`	`TRUE COPY OF` `IN R.A. NO.`	`THE` `35/20`	`ORDER DATED 13/02/2023` `22 IN O.A. NO. 629/2018`

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

S.Lekha Vs Union of India

Prof. A.S. Thomas (Retd) Vs Manager, B.A.M. College

Syama Krishnan.R Vs University of Kerala

Sudheena.S., Vs Dr. Pradeep Sankar. S.

Institute of Hotel Management & Catering Technology Vs Dr.J.Premchand

K.Rajsekhar Vs Dr.J.Premchand