Dismissed

Nazeemudeen v. Mohammed Abdul Khader

Kerala HC7 Feb 2019RSA/190/2009

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The High Court at Ernakulam dismissed the regular second appeal. The court held the appeal was barred by limitation and abated due to the failure to implead legal representatives of deceased respondents, with the delay in filing not condoned.

What did the court decide?

The second appeal was dismissed as barred by limitation and abated due to non-impleadment of legal representatives of deceased respondents.

Nazeemudeen Vs Mohammed Abdul Khader — Civil Procedure and Limitation | Kerala HC (2019)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶2

PRESENT

¶3

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P.SOMARAJAN

¶4

THURSDAY ,THE 07TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2019 / 18TH MAGHA, 1940

¶5

RSA.No. 190 of 2009

¶6

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 27-08-2008 IN RFA 137/2003 & A.S.75/07 of ADDITIONAL DISTRICT & SESSIONS COURT (ADHOC)-II,

¶7

KOLLAM

¶8

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 09-04-2002 IN OS 39/1971 of ADDITIONAL SUB COURT,KOLLAM

¶9

APPELLANTS/APPELLANTS/COUNTER PETITIONERS 31 & 32::

¶10

¶11

NAZEEMUDEEN, S/O SALI, THEKKEPUTHEN VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY, PARAVUR VILLAGE,

¶12

KOLLAM DISTRICT, REPRESENTED BY HIS POWER OF, ATTORNEY HOLDER NAZEEMA BEEVI.

¶13

2 NAZEEMA BEEVI D/O.AMINA UMMAL THEKKEPUTHEN VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, PARAVUR

¶14

VILLAGE, KOLLAM DISTRICT.

¶15

BY ADV. SRI.K.P.SUJESH KUMAR

¶16

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS/4TH PLAINTIFF AND DEFENDANT NOS.3 TO 7,10,11,13,20,28,29,30,31, LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES OF DEFENDANT NOS.17 AND 19:

¶17

1 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER THAMLEEHA,

¶18

PADINJARE MULLIAZHIKOM, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶19

2 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER MOHAMMED MOOSA, KALLAM VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶20

3 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER JALALUDEEN, KALLAM VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶21

4 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER KAMALUDEEN, KALLAM VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶22

RSA.No. 190 of 2009 2

¶23

5 UMMER UMMAL EREEM KALLAM VEEDU THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶24

6 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER KAMALUDEEN, KALLAM VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶25

7 MOHAMMED IBRAHIM AAMINA, RESIDING AT KAVINTETHEKKATHIL VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶26

8 MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADER SULEKHA, AGED 60, PADINJARE MULLIAZHIKOM,, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶27

9 MOHAMMED ALI JALALUDEEN, RESIDING AT KRISHNAZHIKATHU VEEDU ALSO CALLED AS, AELAPPIYAZHIKOM THEKKUMBHAGOM, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶28

10 MOHAMMED HANEEFA ABOOTHALIB ANEEYAZHIJKATHU VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY,, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶29

11 SAFARULLAKHAN, S/O.LATE RAFEEKA BEEVI KRISHNAZHIKATHU VEEDU ALSO CALLED ELAPPAZHIKOM,, THEKKUMBHAGOM CHERRY, KOTTAPPURAM VILLAGE,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶30

12 THAHEERKHAN, S/O.MOHAMMED MOOSA, RESIDING AT PUTHAYAM PURAYIDOM ALSO CALLED, THEEPATTI OFFICE, THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O., PARAVOOR,, KOLLAM.

¶31

13 ARIFA BEEVI THAHIRA BEEVI, RESIDING AT PUTHAYAM PURAYIDOM ALSO CALLED THEEPATTI OFFICE,, THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O., PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶32

14 PATHUMMAL NABEESA BEEVI, D/O.PATHUMMAL RESIDING AT PLAVARAKIZHAKKATHIL, VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O., PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶33

15 PATHUMMAL SAFIYATH BEEVI, D/O.PATHUMMAL RESIDING AT SAFIYA MANZIL ALSO CALLED, THANDANZHIKOM PEETHTHUVILA, NEERAVIL,, PERINADU, KOLLAM.

¶34

16 MOHAMMED NOOHU ASLAM, RESIDING AT AELAPPIYAZHIKATHU VEEDU, ALSO CALLED, KRISHNAZHIKOM VEEDU, THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O.,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶35

RSA.No. 190 of 2009 3

¶36

17 SHAHUL HAMMED, S/O.MOHAMMED RESIDING AT MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU, SITHARA JUNCTION,, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶37

18 NAJEEMA, RESIDING AT MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU SITHARA JUNCTION, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶38

19 RAMLA, RESIDING AT MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU SITHARA JUNCTION, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶39

20 NOORJAHAN, MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU SITHARA JUNCTION, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶40

21 SHAKEELA, RESIDING AT MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU SITHARA JUNCTION, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶41

22 RAJEESA, RESIDING AT MUKKIL PUTHEN VEEDU, SITHARA JUNCTION, KOTTIYAM EAST, KOLLAM.

¶42

23 KASSIM, RESIDING AT VELATHODIYIL VEEDU MYLAKKADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶43

24 FAZIL HUK, S/O.KASSIM RESIDING AT VELATHODIYIL VEEDU, MYLAKKADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶44

25 VAHAB, S/O.KASSIM RESIDING AT VELATHODIYIL VEEDU, MYLAKKADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶45

26 JAHANGEER, S/O.KASSIM RESIDING AT VELATHODIYIL VEEDU, MYLAKKADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶46

27 BEENA BEEVI, D/O.UMMU NAMEEM RESIDING AT VELATHODIYIL VEEDU, MYLAKKADU P.O.,, KOLLAM.

¶47

28 MOHAMMED HANEEFA BEEVI, RESIDING AT AANEEYAZHIKATHU VEEDU, FROM KALIYAZHEEKATHU, (MUKKANNAMKAVUPURAYIDOM), THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O.,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶48

29 MOHAMMED HANEEFA ABOOTHALIB, RESIDING AT AANEEYAZHIKATHU VEEDU, FROM KALIYAZHEEKATHU, (MUKKANNAMKAVUPURAYIDOM), THEKKUMBHAGOM P.O.,, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶49

30 SAINULABDEEN, S/O.SULAIMAN KUNJU RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶50

31 SHIHABDEEN, S/O.SAINULABDEEN RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A

¶51

RSA.No. 190 of 2009 4

¶52

WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶53

32 NOUSHAD, S/O.SAINULABDEEN RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU, MARUNTHAL A WARD,, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶54

33 VAVAD, S/O.SAINUL ABDEEN RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU, MARUNTHAL A WARD,, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶55

34 BABY SAINUL ABDEEN, D/O.SHERIFA BEEVI RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶56

35 NAZEERKHAN, D/O.SHERIFA BEEVI RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶57

36 ANSARKHAN, S/O.SAINUL ABDEEN RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶58

37 LIBA BEEGAM, D/O.SHERIFA BEEVI RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MARUNTHAL A WARD, PERINAD, ANCHLUMMOODU.

¶59

38 AMINA BEEVI, W/O.MOHAMMED HUSAIN RESIDING AT VILAYAIL MANGALATHU BUNGALOW,, MURUNTHAL B.WARD, PERINADU P.O.,, THRIKKADAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶60

39 ROOBINNISA, D/O.AMINA BEEVI ELAPPAZHIKAM VEEDU, ALSO CALLED AS, VADAKKEKRISHNAZHIKAM, THEKKUMBHAGAM CHERRY,, KOLLAPPURAM VILLAGE, PARAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶61

40 ANSARKHAN, S/O.MOHAMMED HUSSAIN RESIDING AT VILAYAIL MANGOLATHU BUNGALOW,, MURUNTHAL B.WARD, PERINADU P.O.,, THRIKKADAVOOR, KOLLAM.

¶62

41 A.SHAMEENA, S/O.SHAFI MEENATHIL PERIMANATHU MUKKU, NEENDAKARA P.O., CHAVARA,, KOLLAM.

¶63

42 SAINULABDEEN, S/O.SULAIMAN KUNJU RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MURUNTHAL A.WARD, THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE,, PERINADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶64

43 RUBY, W/O.ABDUL RASHEED RESIDING AT

¶65

RSA.No. 190 of 2009 5

¶66

KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU, MURUNTHAL A WARD,, THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE, PERINADU P.O., KOLLAM.

¶67

44 RIHAN ,MINOR, S/O.ABDUL RASHEED RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU,, MURUNTHAL A.WARD, THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE,, PERINADU P.O., KOLLAM REPRESENTED BY GUARDIAN, SAINULABDEEN, RESIDING AT KADAPPA VAKKATHIL VEEDU, MURUNTHAL A. WARD THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE, PERINADU PO, KOLLAM.

¶68

45 RIHANA, MINOR D/O.ABDUL RASHEED RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAJKKATHIL VEEDU,, MURUNTHA A.WARD, THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE,, PERINAD P.O., KOLLAM REPRESENTED BY GUARDIAN, SAINULABDEEN, RESIDING AT KADAPPA VADAKKATHIL VEEDU, MURUNTHAL A.WARD THRIKKADAVOOR VILLAGE, PERINADU PO, KOLLAM.

¶69

BY ADVS. SMT.V.RENJU SRI.E.K.NANDAKUMAR (SR.) SRI.P.ANIYAN SRI.VAKKOM N.VIJAYAN

¶70

THIS REGULAR SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 07.02.2019, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶71

RSA.No. 190 of 2009 6

¶72

JUDGMENT

¶73

The delay not condoned. Nobody impleaded as the legal representatives of deceased respondents 2 and 28. The appeal as against R2 and R28 stood as abated. The appeal is not filed within time, hence stood as barred by limitation and hence dismissed.

Sd/-

P.SOMARAJAN

JUDGE

//TRUE COPY//

P.A. TO JUDGE

MSP

Nazeemudeen v. Mohammed Abdul Khader

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Nazeemudeen v. Mohammed Abdul Khader

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Lakshmikutty Vs Damodharan

Ullattil Imbichikoya Vs Kottayattil Parayi

Babu Vs Alias and Others

Radhakrishnan Vs Padmaja

Abraham Chacko Vs Union of India

Gopalan Vs Padmanabhan