Disposed

P.P.Muhammed Haris, v. the Special Tahsildar

Kerala HC22 Jul 2019CO/117/2019

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

Compensation for garden and semi garden lands acquired for university headquarters was enhanced, with semi garden land valued at half the garden land rate. The State's appeal was dismissed, the claimants' appeals allowed and cross objections partly allowed, with statutory benefits and proportionate costs.

What did the court decide?

Enhanced land value with statutory benefits and proportionate costs; interest excluded for periods specified in delay-condonation orders.

P.P.Muhammed Haris, Vs the Special Tahsildar — Land Acquisition | Kerala HC (2019)

¶1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶2

PRESENT

¶3

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶4

¶5

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶6

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶7

LA.App..No.175 of 2018

¶8

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 167/2010 of THE SUBORDINATE JUDGES COURT, THALASSERY DATED 31-01-2013

¶9

APPELLANTS/CLAIMANT & SUPPL.CLAIMANTS 2 TO 9:

¶10

1 A.P.M.SALIM AGED 55 YEARS, S/O LATE. K. SAVANKUTTY, C.P HOUSE,SAIDAR PALLI, THALASSERY-2.

¶11

2 ACHARATH PARAKKATTU MUTTERIYIL HARIS AGED 53 YEARS, S/O LATE. K.SAVANKUTTY, "MUBARAK MANZIL,P.O THAVAKKARA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶12

3 ACHARATH PARAKKATTU MUTTERIYIL KUNHAMINA AGED 60 YEARS, D/O LATE. K SAVANKUTTY, "MUBARAK MANZIL,P.O THAVAKKARA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶13

4 ACHARATH PARAKKATTU MUTTERIYIL SUHARA AGED 57 YEARS, D/O LATE. K.SAVANKUTTY,"MUBARAK MANZIL,P.O THAVAKKARA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶14

5 ACHARATH PARAKKATTU MUTTERIYIL ASHRAF AGED 43 YEARS, S/O LATE. ACHARATH PARAKKATTU MUTTERIYIL JAMEELA, "MUBARAK MANZIL,P.O THAVAKKARA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶15

6 K.P HASNA

¶16

AGED 67 YEARS, W/O LATE MAHAMOOD A.P.M, "HASNAS", POST MUZHAPPILANGAD, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶17

7 K.P SABITHA AGED 47 YEARS, D/O LATE. MAHAMOOD A.P.M, "HASNAS", POST MUZHAPPILANGAD, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶18

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶19

¶20

8 K.P SHAHITHA

¶21

AGED 45 YEARS, D/O LATE MAHAMOOD A.P.M, "HASNAS", POST MUZHAPPILANGAD, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶22

9 FIRNAS ALI K.P AGED 43 YEARS, D/O LATE MAHAMOOD A.P.M, "HASNAS", POST MUZHAPPILANGAD, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶23

BY ADVS. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SMT.K.BINCY MOL SMT.N.B.FATHIMA SULFATH SRI.ANIL GEORGE SRI.K.S.SUMEESH

¶24

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:

¶25

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR[LA], THALASSERY THALASSERY-670101.

¶26

2 THE REGISTRAR

¶27

KANNUR UNIVERSITY, MANGATTUPARAMBA, KANNUR-670567.

¶28

3 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,KANNUR670002.

¶29

R1 & R3 BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM R2 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶30

THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014 & LA.App..174/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶31

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶32

¶33

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶34

PRESENT

¶35

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶36

¶37

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶38

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶39

CO.No.115 of 2019 IN LA.App.107/2014

¶40

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LA.App. 107/2014 IN LAR NO.400/2011 of THE SUBORDINATE JUDGES COURT, THALASSERY DATED 31-03-2013

¶41

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENT NO.9 IN LAA

¶42

ABDUL NIZAR, AGED 58 YEARS S/O. V. IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT “SHABEENAS”, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANNUR-2, NOW RESIDING AT VP HOUSE, NEAR RAILWAY STATION ROAD, PAPPINISSERY, KANNUR TALUK.

¶43

BY ADVS. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SRI.ANIL GEORGE

¶44

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 8, 10 TO 37 IN LAA:

¶45

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA), THALASSERY.

¶46

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR.

¶47

3 P.K. PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶48

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶49

¶50

4 P.K. ASOKAN, AGED 60 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶51

5 P.K. SUNDARAN, AGED 54 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶52

6 P.K. PAVITHRAN, AGED 45 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶53

7 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR.

¶54

8 PREETHY, AGED 56 YEARS, W/O. DR.SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT “KEERTHI”, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT “PRASI VILLA”, P.O. THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶55

9 M.P. MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶56

10 M.P. MUHAMMED HAROON, AGED 55 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶57

11 M.P. NASEEBA, AGED 53 YEARS, D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶58

12 M.P. MUHAMMED NISSAR, AGED 51 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶59

13 M.P. SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS, D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶60

14 M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶61

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶62

¶63

15	M.P. MUHAMMED ASHIQUE, AGED 42 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.
16	M.P. MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 40 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.
17	K. JAYASREE PRABBU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE-3.
18	P.K. RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIYAMPURAYIL HOUSE, P.O., CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT.
19	P.K. SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679123.
20	P.K. SAJITH, AGED 38 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679123.
21	K. ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O. K. ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE- 3.
22	VAZHAYIL USMAN, AGED 69 YEARS, S/O. LATE P. MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS, NALUVAYAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003.
23	DR. JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O. RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU.
24	PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O. WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM.
25	P. MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O.,KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.
26	P. MUHAMMED NASEER,

¶64

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶65

¶66

AGED 52 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶67

27 P. MUHAMMED NOUSHAD,

¶68

AGED 49 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶69

28 P. MUHAMMED ANWAR,

¶70

AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶71

29 P. UMAIBA,

¶72

AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶73

30 P. MUHAMMED NAVAS,

¶74

AGED 40 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶75

31 B. ZAHIRA,

¶76

AGED 50 YEARS, W/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶77

32 SHEHZED ASHRAF,

¶78

AGED 30 YEARS, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶79

33 SHABANAM ASHRAF,

¶80

AGED 26 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶81

34 ZIANA ZUHARA,

¶82

AGED 24 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶83

35 AMEEN MUHAMMED,

¶84

S/O. LATE MOHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT670012.

¶85

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶86

¶87

36 THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY.

¶88

R1 & R2 BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM R36 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶89

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶90

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶91

¶92

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶93

PRESENT

¶94

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶95

¶96

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶97

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶98

CO.No.117 of 2019 IN LA.App.. 107/2014

¶99

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT, THALASSERY DATED 30-03-2013

¶100

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENTS 26 TO 35

¶101

1 P.P.MUHAMMED HARIS AGED 60 YEARS, S/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶102

2 P.MUHAMMED NASEER AGED 52 YEARS, S/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶103

3 P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 49 YEARS, S/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶104

4 P.MUHAMMED ANWAR, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶105

5 P.UMAIBA, AGED 40 YEARS, D/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶106

6 P.MUHAMMED NAVAS, AGED 40 YEARS, S/O LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA

¶107

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶108

¶109

P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶110

7 B.ZAHIRA,

¶111

AGED 50 YEARS, W/O LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶112

8 SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS, S/O LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶113

9 SHABANAM ASHRAF

¶114

AGED 26 YEARS, D/O LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶115

10 ZIANA ZUHARA

¶116

AGED 24 YEARS, D/O LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT “SHAZZ”, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶117

BY ADVS.

¶118

SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SRI.ANIL GEORGE

¶119

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 25,36 & 37 IN LAA:

¶120

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR, THALASSERY-670101.

¶121

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR-670002.

¶122

3 P.K.PREMATHI,

¶123

AGED 62 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR-670303.

¶124

4 P.K.ASOKAN,

¶125

AGED 60 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR-670303.

¶126

5 P.K.SUNDARAN AGED 54 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL

¶127

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶128

¶129

HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-676542.

¶130

6 P.K.PAVITHRAN, AGED 45 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT-576542.

¶131

7 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR.

¶132

8 PREETHY,

¶133

AGED 56 YEARS, W/O. DR.SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT KEERTHI, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT PRASI VILLA, P.O. THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670007.

¶134

9 ABDUL ABDUL NIZAR, AGED 58 YEARS, S/O. V.IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT SHABEENAS, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANNUR-670002.

¶135

10 M.P. MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶136

11 M.P. MUHAMMED HAROON, AGED 55 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶137

12 M.P.NASEEBA, AGED 53 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶138

13 M.P. MUHAMMED NISSAR, AGED 51 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶139

14 M.P.SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶140

15 M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶141

16 M.P. MUHAMMED ASHIQUE,

¶142

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶143

¶144

AGED 42 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶145

17	M.P. MUHAMMED	NOUSHAD,
	AGED 40 YEARS	, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA
	COTTAGE, K.T.	WARD, KANNUR-670002.

¶146

18	K.JAYASREE PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE-3, PIN-575003.
19	P.K.RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIYAMPURAYIL HOUSE, P.O. CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT-673017.
20	P.K.SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679123.
21	P.K.SAJITH, AGED 38 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679123.
22	K.ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O.K. ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE- 3, PIN-575003.
23	VAZHAYIL USMAN, AGED 69 YEARS, S/O. LATE P. MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS, NALUVAYAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003.
24	DR. JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O. RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU-560008.
25	PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O. WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM-682001.
26	AMEEN MUHAMMED, S/O. LATE MOHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003.
27	THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY, PIN-670567.

¶147

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶148

¶149

BY ADVS. R1 & R2 GOVERNMENT PLEADER SYAMJI RAM R27 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶150

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶151

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶152

¶153

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶154

PRESENT

¶155

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶156

¶157

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶158

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶159

CO.No.121 of 2019 IN LA.App.. 107/2014

¶160

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT, THALASSERY DATED 30-03-2013

¶161

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT IN LA.App. 107/2014 of HIGHCOURT

¶162

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENTS 2 TO 4,6,19 TO 21:

¶163

1 P.K.PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS D/O.LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶164

2 P.K.ASOKAN, AGED 60 YEARS

¶165

S/O.LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶166

3 P.K.SUNDARAN, AGED 54 YEARS S/O.LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶167

4 P.K.PAVITHRAN, AGED 45 YEARS

¶168

S/O.LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR,

¶169

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶170

¶171

MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶172

5 P.K.RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS D/O.LATE P.K.KUHIMATHA, CHATTIYAMPURAYIL HOUSE, P.O.CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT.

¶173

6 P.K.SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS D/O.LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD- 679123.

¶174

7 P.K.SAJITH, AGED 38 YEARS S/O.LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD- 679123.

¶175

BY ADV. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY

¶176

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1,5, 7 TO 18,22 TO 37 IN LAA:

¶177

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA) THALASSERY-670 001.

¶178

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR-670 002.

¶179

3 P.K. DEVI, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR [DIED]

¶180

4 P K SUMATHI [DIED] 5 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR-670 002.

¶181

6 PREETHY S.KUMAR, AGED 56 YEARS W/O.DR.SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT KEERTHI, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT PRASI VILLA, P.O.THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670 017.

¶182

7 ABDUL NIZAR, AGED 58 YEARS S/O.V.IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT SHABEENAS, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANNUR-2, NOW RESIDING AT V.P.HOUSE, NEAR RAILWAY STATION ROAD,

¶183

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶184

¶185

PAPPINISSERRY, KANNUR TALUK-670 002.

¶186

8 M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR-670 002.

¶187

9 M.P.MUHAMMED HAROON,
AGED 55 YEARS
S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
KANNUR-670 002.

¶188

10	M.P.NASEEBA,
	AGED 53 YEARS
	D/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
	KANNUR-670 002.

¶189

11	M.P.MUHAMMED NISSAR,
	AGED 51 YEARS
	S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
	KANNUR-670 002.

¶190

12	M.P.SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS D/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR-670 002.
13	M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR-670 002.
14	M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE, AGED 42 YEARS S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR-670 002.
15	M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 40 YEARS S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR-670 002.
16	K.JAYASREE PRABBU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE-3.
17	K.ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O.K.ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE- 575 003.

¶191

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶192

¶193

18	VAZHAYIL USMAN, AGED 69 YEARS S/O.LATE P.MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS, NALUVAYAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670003.
19	DR.JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O.RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU.
20	PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O.WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM-682 001.
21	P.MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
22	P.MUHAMMED NASEER, AGED 52 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
23	P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 49 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
24	P.MUHAMMED ANWAR, AGED 43 YEARS
	S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
25	P.UMAIBA, AGED 40 YEARS D/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
26	P.MUHAMMED NAVAS, AGED 40 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.

¶194

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶195

¶196

27	B.ZAHIRA, AGED 50 YEARS W/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
28	SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS S/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
29	SHABANAM ASHRAF, AGED 26 YEARS D/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
30	ZIANA ZUHARA, AGED 24 YEARS D/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670012.
31	AMEEN MUHAMMED, S/O.LATE MOHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT- 670003.
32	THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY – 670 567.
R1 & R2 R32	BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶197

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶198

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶199

¶200

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶201

PRESENT

¶202

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶203

¶204

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶205

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶206

CO.No.123 of 2019 IN LA.App.. 107/2014

¶207

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AN DECREE IN LAR NO.400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT, THALASSERY

¶208

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENT NO.36 IN LAA

¶209

AMEEN MUHAMMED

¶210

S/O. LATE MOHAMMED VAZHAYIL,RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670 003

¶211

BY ADV. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY

¶212

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 35 & 37 IN LAA:

¶213

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA) THALASSERY,PIN-670 001

¶214

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR,PIN 670 002

¶215

3 P.K.DEVI MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOMM NO.II, THAYYIL MANNUR [DIED]

¶216

4 P.K.PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI,KANNUR TALUK,

¶217

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶218

¶219

KANNUR,PIN-670 303

¶220

5 P.K.ASHOKAN AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI,KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR,PIN-670 303

¶221

6 P.IK.SUNDARAN, AGED 54 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT,PIN-676 542

¶222

7	P.K.SUMATHI [DIED]
8	P.K.PAVITHRAN,
	AGED 45 YEARS
	S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS,
	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT
	NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR,
	MALAPPURAM DISTRICT,PIN-676 542

¶223

9 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES,KANNUR,PIN-670 002

¶224

10	PREETHY,
	AGED 56 YEARS
	W/O. DR.SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT KEERTHI, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT PRASI VILLA, P.O.THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT,PIN-670 002
11	ABDUL NIZAR, AGED 58 YEARS S/O. V.IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT SHABEENAS, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA,KANUR-2,PIN 670 002
12	M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS
	S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002
13	M.P.MUHGAMMED HAROON AGED 55 YEARS
	S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002

¶225

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶226

¶227

14	M.P.NABEESA, AGED 53 YEARS
	D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
15	M.P.MUHAMMED NISSAR, AGED 51 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
16	M.P.SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
17	M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
18	M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE, AGED 42 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
19	M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD AGED 40 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, KANNUR,PIN -670 002	SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
20	K.JAYASREE PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN P CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANG	AI HALL, NAVA BHARATH ALORE-3,PIN-575 003
21	P.K.RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, P.O.CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBA CALICUT DISTRICT,PIN-673	CHATTIAYAMPURAYIL HOUSE , LAM, 017
22	P.K.SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS D/O. LATE P.K.GOPLAN, RES SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALA	IDING AT SREESADANAM, KKAD-679 123
23	P.K.SAJITH AGED 38 YEARS
	S/O. LATE P.K.GOPLAN, RES	IDING AT SREESADANAM,
	SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALA	KKAD-679 123

¶228

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶229

¶230

24	ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O. ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PILAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODAI BAIL, MANGALORE- 3,PIN 575 003
25	VAZHAYIL USMAN AGED 69 YEARS S/O. LATE P.MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS ,NALUVAYAL P.O, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003
26	DR.JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O. RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU,PIN-560 008
27	PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O. WICKYRAJ,KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM,PIN-682 031
28	P.MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012
29	P.MUHAMMED NASEER, AGED 52 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012
30	P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 49 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012
31	P.MUHAMMED NAVAS, AGED 40 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012
32	B.ZAHIRA, AGED 50 YEARS W/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012

¶231

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶232

¶233

33 SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012

¶234

34 SHABANAM ASHRAF AGED 26 YEARS D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012

¶235

35 ZIANA ZUHARA, AGED 24 YEARS D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012

¶236

36 AMEEN MUHAMMED, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670 003

¶237

37 THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY,PIN-672 001

¶238

R1 & R2 BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM R37 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶239

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶240

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶241

¶242

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶243

PRESENT

¶244

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶245

¶246

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶247

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶248

CO.No.127 of 2019 IN LA.App.. 107/2014

¶249

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT,THALASSERY DATED 30.03.2013

¶250

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENTS NO.7,8,24 & 25 IN LAA

¶251

1 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR.

¶252

2 PREETHY, AGED 56 YEARS

¶253

W/O. DR. SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT “KEERTHI”, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT “PRASI VILLA”, P.O., THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶254

3 DR. JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O. RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU.

¶255

4 PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O. WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM.

¶256

BY ADVS.

¶257

SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SRI.ANIL GEORGE

¶258

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 6,9 TO 13 & 26 TO 37 IN LAA:

¶259

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA), THALASSERY-670002.

¶260

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR, PIN - 670 002.

¶261

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶262

¶263

3	P.K. DEVI, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYI, MANNUR (DIED).
4	P.K.PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR, PIN-670 303.
5	P.K.ASOKAN , AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR, PIN-670 303.
6	P.K.SUNDARAN, AGED 54 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-670 542.
7	P.K. SUMATHI, (DIED)
8	P.K.PAVITHRAN, AGED 45 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-670 542.
9	ABDUL NIZAR, AGED 58 YEARS, S/O. V.IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT “SHABEENAS”, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANUR-2, PIN - 670 002.
10	M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS , S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002.
11	M.P.MUHGAMMED HAROON , AGED 55 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,

¶264

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶265

¶266

KANNUR,PIN -670 002.

¶267

12	M.P.NASEEBA,
	AGED 53 YEARS,
	D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD,
	KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶268

13	M.P.MUHAMMED NISSAR, AGED 51 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.
14	M.P.SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS, D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002.
15	M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.
16	M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE, AGED 42 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.
17	M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD , AGED 40 YEARS , S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.
18	K.JAYASREE PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE-3, PIN-675 003.
19	P.K.RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIAYAMPURAYIL HOUSE , P.O.CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT, PIN-670 317.
20	P.K.SINDHU,
	AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K.GOPLAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679 123.
21	P.K.SAJITH ,
	AGED 38 YEARS
	S/O. LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM,

¶269

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶270

¶271

SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679 123.

¶272

22 ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O. ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE3, PIN 575 003.

¶273

23 VAZHAYIL USMAN , AGED 69 YEARS S/O. LATE P.MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS ,NALUVAYAL P.O, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003.

¶274

24 P.MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶275

25	P.MUHAMMED NASEER,
	AGED 52 YEARS,
	S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR
	MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK,
	KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶276

26	P.MUHAMMED AGED 49 YE	NOUSHAD, ARS,
	S/O. LATE MUNICIPAL KANNUR DIS	PARAMBATH QUARTERS, TRICT-6700	SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, 12.
27	P.MUHAMMED AGED 43 YE S/O. LATE MUNICIPAL KANNUR DIS	ANWAR, ARS, PARAMBATH QUARTERS, TRICT-6700	SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, 12.
28	P.UMAIBA,
	AGED 40 YE D/O. LATE	ARS, PARAMBATH	SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR
	MUNICIPAL KANNUR DIS	QUARTERS, TRICT-6700	THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, 12.

¶277

29	P.MUHAMMED NAVAS,
	AGED 40 YEARS,
	S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR
	MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK,
	KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶278

30 B.ZAHIRA,

¶279

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶280

¶281

AGED 50 YEARS W/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶282

31 SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶283

32 SHABANAM ASHRAF , AGED 26 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶284

33 ZIANA ZUHARA, AGED 24 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶285

34 AMMEN MUHAMMED, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670 003.

¶286

35 THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY, PIN-670 567.

¶287

R1 & R2 BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM R35 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶288

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶289

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶290

¶291

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶292

PRESENT

¶293

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶294

¶295

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶296

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶297

CO.No.138 of 2019 IN LA.App.107/2014

¶298

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR NO.400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT, THALASSERRY DATED 30.03.2013.

¶299

CROSS OBJECTORS/RESPONDENTS 10 TO 17 IN LAA:

¶300

1 M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL AGED 47 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD,KANNUR.

¶301

2 M. P. MUHAMMED HAROON AGED 55 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD,KANNUR.

¶302

3 M. P. NASEEBA AGED 53 YEARS D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD,KANNUR.

¶303

4 M. P. MUHAMMED NISSAR AGED 51 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD,KANNUR.

¶304

5 M. P. SAHIDA AGED 49 YEARS

¶305

S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR.

¶306

6 M. P. FOUSIYA AGED 43 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.

¶307

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶308

¶309

WARD, KANNUR.

¶310

7 M. P. MUHAMMED ASHIQUE AGED 42 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR. 8 M. P. MUHAMMED NOUSHAD AGED 40 YEARS S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T. WARD, KANNUR. BY ADVS. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SRI.ANIL GEORGE

¶311

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 9, 18 TO 37 IN LAA:

¶312

1 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR(LA) THALASSERY.

¶313

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR.

¶314

3 P. K. PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS D/O. LATE P. K. KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶315

4 P. K. ASOKAN, AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE P. K. KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR.

¶316

5 P. K. SUNDARAN, AGED 54 YEARS S/O. LATE P. K. KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶317

6 P. K. PAVITHRAN, AGED 45 YEARS S/O. LATE P. K. KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT.

¶318

7 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR.

¶319

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶320

¶321

8 PREETHY, AGED 56 YEARS W/O. DR. SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT 'KEERTHI', THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT PRASI VILLA, P.O. THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶322

9 ABDUL NIZAR S/O. V. IBRAHIM, VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT 'SHABEENAS', NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANNUR - 2.

¶323

10 K. JAYASREE PRABHU INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE - 3.

¶324

11 P. K. RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS D/O. LATE P. K. KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIYAMPURAYIL HOUSE, P.O. CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT.

¶325

12 P. K. SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS D/O. LATE. P. K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD - 679 123.

¶326

13 P. K. SAJITH, AGED 38 YEARS D/O. LATE. P. K. GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD - 679 123.

¶327

14 K. AKSHATHA PRABHU D/O. K. ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE - 3.

¶328

15 VAZHAYIL USMAN, AGED 69 YEARS S/O. LATE P. MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT 'DAFFODILS', NALUVAYAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 003.

¶329

16 DR. JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O RAGHAV REDDY LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU.

¶330

17 PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ W/O. WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM.

¶331

18 P. MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶332

19 P. MUHAMMED NASEER, AGED 52 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR

¶333

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶334

¶335

DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶336

20 P. MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 47 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶337

21 P. MUHAMMED ANWAR, AGED 43 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶338

22 P. UMAIBA, AGED 40 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶339

23 P. MUHAMMED NAVAS, AGED 40 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶340

24 B. ZAHIRA, AGED 50 YEARS W/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶341

25 SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶342

26 SHABANAM ASHRAF, AGED 26 YEARS D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶343

27 ZIANA ZUHARA, AGED 24 YEARS S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 012.

¶344

28 AMEEN MUHAMMED S/O. LATE MUHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 003.

¶345

29 THE REGISTRAR KANNUR UNIVERSITY.

¶346

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶347

¶348

R1 & R2 BY ADVS.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM R29 M SASINDRAN. SC KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶349

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶350

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶351

¶352

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶353

PRESENT

¶354

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶355

¶356

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶357

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶358

CO.No.153 of 2019 IN LA.App.. 107/2014

¶359

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT,THALASSERY DATED 30-03-2013

¶360

CROSS OBJECTOR/RESPONDENT NO.23 IN LAA:

¶361

VAZHAYIL USMAN, AGED 69 YEARS

¶362

S/O. LATE P. MUHAMMED, RESIDING AT DAFFODILS, NALUVAYAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670003.

¶363

BY ADV. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY

¶364

RESPONDENTS/APPELLANTS & RESPONDENTS 1 TO 22, 24 TO 37 IN LAA:

¶365

1 THE SPECIAL TAHASILDAR(LA), THALASSERY - 670101.

¶366

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA, REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR, PIN - 670 002.

¶367

3 P.K.PREMATHI, AGED 62 YEARS D/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, MANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR, PIN-670 303.

¶368

4 P.K.ASHOKAN , AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT LAKSHAM VEEDU COLONY, PAHZHAYANGADI,

¶369

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶370

¶371

KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR, PIN-670 303.

¶372

5 P.K.SUNDARAN,

¶373

AGED 54 YEARS, S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-670 542.

¶374

6 P.K.PAVITHRAN,

¶375

AGED 45 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL, KANNUR NOW RESIDING AT NILAMBUR GOVERNMENT HOSPITAL QUARTERS, NILAMBUR, MALAPPURAM DISTRICT, PIN-670 542.

¶376

7 PRANIYIL BHASKARAN, VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR-670002.

¶377

8 PREETHY,

¶378

AGED 56 YEARS, W/O. DR. SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, RESIDING AT KEERTHI, THOTTADA, KANNUR, NOW RESIDING AT PRASI VILLA, P.O., THOTTADA, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670007.

¶379

9 ABDUL ABDUL NIZAR,

¶380

AGED 58 YEARS, S/O. V.IBRAHIM VALIYAPEEDIKAYIL, RESIDING AT SHABEENAS, NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMA, KANUR-2, PIN - 670 002.

¶381

10 M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL, AGED 47 YEARS , S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002.

¶382

11 M.P.MUHGAMMED HAROON , AGED 55 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002.

¶383

12 M.P.NASEEBA, AGED 53 YEARS, D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶384

13 M.P.MUHAMMED NISSAR, AGED 51 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶385

14 M.P.SAHIDA, AGED 49 YEARS, D/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR,PIN -670 002.

¶386

15 M.P.FOUZIYA, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA

¶387

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶388

¶389

COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶390

16 M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE, AGED 42 YEARS, S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶391

17 M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD , AGED 40 YEARS , S/O. LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN, SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR, PIN -670 002.

¶392

18 K.JAYASREE PRABBU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE-3, PIN-675 003.

¶393

19 P.K.RADHIKA, AGED 46 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K. KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIAYAMPURAYIL HOUSE , P.O.CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT, PIN-673017.

¶394

20 P.K.SINDHU, AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE P.K.GOPLAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679 123.

¶395

21 P.K.SAJITH , AGED 38 YEARS S/O. LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREESADANAM, SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD-679 123.

¶396

22 K.ASKHATHA PRABBU, D/O. K.ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE3, PIN 575 003.

¶397

23 DR. JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY, W/O. RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR, BANGALOORU-560008.

¶398

24 PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ, W/O. WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI, ERNAKULAM-682001.

¶399

25 P.MUHAMMED HARIS, AGED 60 YEARS S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶400

26 P.MUHAMMED NASEER, AGED 52 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶401

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶402

¶403

27 P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD, AGED 49 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶404

28 P.MUHAMMED ANWAR, AGED 43 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶405

29 P.UMAIBA, AGED 40 YEARS, D/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶406

30 P.MUHAMMED NAVAS, AGED 40 YEARS, S/O. LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶407

31 B.ZAHIRA, AGED 50 YEARS W/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶408

32 SHEHZED ASHRAF, AGED 30 YEARS, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶409

33 SHABANAM ASHRAF , AGED 26 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶410

34 ZIANA ZUHARA, AGED 24 YEARS, D/O. LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF, RESIDING AT SHAZZ, NEAR MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, THANA P.O., KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670012.

¶411

35 AMMEN MUHAMMED, S/O. LATE MUHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN, NALUVAUAL P.O., KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK, KANNUR DISTRICT-670 003.

¶412

36 THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY, PIN-670 567.

¶413

BY ADVS.

¶414

R1 & R2 GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM

¶415

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶416

¶417

R36 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶418

THIS CROSS OBJECTION/CROSS APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶419

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶420

¶421

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶422

PRESENT

¶423

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶424

¶425

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶426

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶427

LA.App..No.107 of 2014

¶428

AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE IN LAR 400/2011 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT,THALASSERY DATED 30-03-2013

¶429

APPELLANTS/RESPONDENTS 1 & 3:

¶430

1 SPECIAL TAHSILDAR (LA), THALASSERY.

¶431

2 THE GOVERNMENT OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY DISTRICT COLLECTOR, KANNUR.

¶432

BY ADV. GOVERNMENT PLEADER SRI SYAMJI RAM

¶433

RESPONDENTS/CLAIMANTS & 2ND RESPONDENT:

¶434

1	P.K. DEVI
	MUNICIPAL HEAD QUARTERS, - 673 328	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL,MANNUR
2	P.K.PREMATHI MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, - 673 328	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL,MANNUR
3	P.K.ASHOKAN MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, - 673 328.	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL,MANNUR
4	P.K.SUNDRAN MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, - 673 328	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL,MANNUR
5	P.K.SUMATHI DIED
6	P.K.PAVITHRAN MUNICIPAL HEADQUARTERS, - 673 328	ROOM NO.II, THAYYIL,MANNUR

¶435

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶436

¶437

7	PRANIYIL BHASKARAN VASAVA TYRES, KANNUR 670001
8	PREETHI W/O.DR.SWATHANTHRAKUMAR, KEERTHI, THOTTADA,KANNUR - 670001
9	ABDUL NIZAR VALIYAPEEDIKA, SHABEENAS NEAR MALAYALA MANORAMAKANNUR - 2.
10	M.P.MUHAMMED FAIZAL SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR - 670001
11	M.P.MUHAMMED HAROON SULEKHA COTTAGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR - 670001
12	M.P.NASEEBA SULEKHA COTTEGE K.T.WARD KANNUR 670001
13	M.P.MUHAMMED NISAR SULEKHA COTTEGE K.T.WARD KANNUR 670001
14	M.P.SAHIDA SULEKHA COTTEGE, K T WARD, KANNUR - 670001
15	M.P.FOUZIYA SULEKHA COTTEGE, K.T.WARD, KANNUR - 670001
16	M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE SULEKHA COTTEGE K.T.WARD KANNUR - 670001
17	M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD SULEKHA COTTEGE K.T.WARD, KANNUR - 670001
18	K.JAYASREE PRABHU INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAI HALL, NAVA BHARATHCIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL, MANGALORE - 3.
19	P.K.RADHIKA D/O.LATE P.K.KUNHIMATHA, CHATTIAMPURAYIL HOUSE,P.O.CHEVAYOOR, CHEVARAMBALAM, CALICUT DISTRICT -673 017
20 21	P.K.SINDHU D/O.LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREE SADANAM,SHORNUR, GANESHGIRI, PALAKKAD - 679 123. P.K..SAJITH

¶438

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶439

¶440

D/O.LATE P.K.GOPALAN, RESIDING AT SREE SADANAM,SHORNUR, GANESH GIRI, PALAKKAD - 679 123.

¶441

22 K.ASKHATHA PRABHU

¶442

D/O.K.ASHOKA PRABHU, INLAND ELITE 203, RAMAN PAIHALL, NAVA BHARATH CIRCLE, KODIAL BAIL,MANGALORE - 3.

¶443

23	VAZHAYIL USMAN S/O.LATE P.MUHAMMED RESIDING AT 'DAFFODILS',NALUVUAL, P.O.KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK,KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 003.
24	DR.JALAJA RAGHAV REDDY W/O.RAGHAV REDDY, LAKSHMIAS, REDDY ROAD, ULSOOR,BANGALORE.
25	PRAVEENA VICKYRAJ W/O.WICKYRAJ, KODER HOUSE, POWER ROAD, FORT KOCHI,ERNAKULAM.
26	P.MUHAMMED HARIS AGED 54 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS.
27	P.MUHAMMED NASEER AGED 48 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS
28	P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD AGED 44 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS
29	P.MUHAMMED ANWAR AGED 40 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS
30	P.UMAIBA
	AGED 37 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS
31	P.MUHAMMED NAVAS AGED 35 YEARS S/O.LATE PARAMBATH SUHARA, OCCUPATION BUSINESS
32	B.ZAKIRA AGED 43 YEARS W/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF PARAMBATH, OCCUPATION,NIL
	RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUJICIPAL
	QUARTERS,P.O.THANA, KANNUR - 670 012.

¶444

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶445

¶446

33 SHEHZAD ASHRAF AGED 25 YEARS S/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF PARAMBATH, OCCUPATIONNIL RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUJICIPAL QUARTERSP.O.THANA, KANNUR - 670 012

¶447

34 SHABNAM ASHRAF AGED 23 YEARS D/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF PARAMBATH, OCCUPATIONNIL RESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUJICIPAL QUARTERS,P.O.THANA, KANNUR - 670 012.

¶448

35 ZIANA ZUHRA AGED 19 YEARS D/O.LATE MUHAMMED ASHRAF PARAMBATH, OCCUPATION NILRESIDING AT 'SHAZZ', NEAR MUJICIPAL QUARTERS,P.O.THANA, KANNUR - 670 012.

¶449

36 AMEEN MOHAMMED

¶450

S/O.LATE MOHAMMED VAZHAYIL, RESIDING AT ZAIN,NALUVAUL, P.O. KANNUR CITY, KANNUR TALUK,KANNUR DISTRICT - 670 003.

¶451

37 THE REGISTRAR KANNUR UNIVERSITY - 670001.

¶452

BY ADVS. R1 to R4, SRI.SERGI JOSEPH THOMAS R6,R7 TO SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY R17, R19 TO R21, R23 TO R36 R2 TO R4, SRI.ANIL GEORGE R6,R8, R10 TO 17, R19 TO 21, R26 R 37 SRI.M.SASINDRAN, SC, KANNUR UNIVERSITY

¶453

THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..174/2018, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶454

¶455

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶456

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

¶457

PRESENT

¶458

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE C.K.ABDUL REHIM

¶459

¶460

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE R. NARAYANA PISHARADI

¶461

MONDAY, THE 22ND DAY OF JULY 2019 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1941

¶462

LA.App..No.174 of 2018

¶463

AGAINST THE ORDER AND DECREE IN LAR 170/2010 ON THE FILES OF THE SUBORDINATE JUDGE'S COURT,THALASSERY DATED 29.02.2012

¶464

APPELLANTS/CLAIMANTS:

¶465

1 M.P.MUHAMMED HAROON

¶466

AGED 55 YERS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶467

2 M.P.NUSEEBA

¶468

AGED 53 YEARS, D/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶469

3 M.P.MUHAMMED NISSAR AGED 51 YEARS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶470

4 M.P.SAHIDA

¶471

AGED 49 YEARS, D/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶472

5 M.P.MUHAMMED FAISAL AGED 47 YEARS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶473

¶474

M.P.FOUSIYA

¶475

AGED 43 YEARS, D/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶476

7 M.P.MUHAMMED ASHIQUE

¶477

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶478

¶479

AGED 42 YEARS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶480

8 M.P.MUHAMMED NOUSHAD AGED 40 YEARS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAHIMAN,RESIDING AT "SULAIKHA COTTAGE",K.T.WARD, KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶481

9 CHALIL MARIYUMMA

¶482

AGED 85 YEARS, W/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANIL",THAYATHERU P.O.,KANNUR CITY, KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶483

10 CHALIL HARIFA

¶484

AGED 66 YEARS, D/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶485

11 CHALIL BALKEES

¶486

AGED 63 YEARS,D/O.LAE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶487

12 CHALIL AFSATH

¶488

AGED 61 YEARS, D/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶489

13 CHALIL SUHARA

¶490

AGED 59 YEARS, D/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶491

14 CHALIL NASEEMA

¶492

AGED 57 YEARS, D/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶493

15 CHALIL ABDUL RASHEED AGED 55 YEARS, S/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶494

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶495

¶496

16 CHALIL ABDUL BASHEER AGED 54 YEARS, S/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶497

17 CHALIL RASIYA AGED 52 YEARS, D/O.LATE MOOSAFI ABDULLAKKUNHI,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶498

18 P.K.THAHIRA AGED 58 YEARS, W/O.LATE ABDUL RAFEEQUE,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶499

19 P.K.SHAMSEENA AGED 37 YEARS, D/O.LATE ABDUL RAFFEEQUE,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶500

20 P.K.SHAMSEER AGED 35 YEARS,S/O.LATE ABDUL RAFEEQUE,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶501

21 P.K.SHANJITH AGED 33 YEARS, S/O.LATE ABDUL RAFEEQUE,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶502

22 P.K.SHANJISHA AGED 29 YEARS, D/O.LATE ABDUL RAFEEQUE,RESIDING AT "RAFFEEQUE MANZIL",THAYATHERU P.O., KANNUR CITY,KANNUR DISTRICT.

¶503

BY ADVS. SRI.JOBY JACOB PULICKEKUDY SMT.K.BINCYMOL SMT.N.B.FATHIMA SULFATH SRI.ANIL GEORGE SRI.K.S.SUMEESH

¶504

RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS:

¶505

1 THE REGISTRAR, KANNUR UNIVERSITY MANGATTUPARAMBA, KANNUR - 670 567.

¶506

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶507

¶508

2 GOVERNMENT OF KERALA REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR,KANNUR - 670 002.

¶509

3 THE SPECIAL TAHSILDAR L.A. THALASSERY - 670 101.

¶510

R1 BY ADV. SRI.M.SASINDRAN R2 & BY GOVT.PLEADER SRI SAYMJI RAM R3

¶511

THIS LAND ACQUISITION APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 22.07.2019, ALONG WITH CO.153/2019, LA.App..107/2014, CO.115/2019, CO.117/2019, CO.121/2019, CO.123/2019, CO.127/2019, CO.138/2019, LA.App..175/2018, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

¶512

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶513

¶514

C.K. ABDUL REHIM

¶515

& R. NARAYANA PISHARADI, JJ.

¶516

L.A.A No. 107 of 2014 with Cross.Obj.Nos. 115,117,121,123, 127,138 & 153 of 2019 and L.A.A Nos. 174 & 175 of 2018

¶517

----------------------------------------------- Dated this the 22^nd day of July, 2019

¶518

JUDGMENT

¶519

Abdul Rehim,J

¶520

All the above land acquisition appeals pertain to the very same acquisition, made for the purpose of 'construction of the Head Quarters of Kannur University'. Properties covered under all the cases are situated within the same Village of Kannur-I. The acquisition was through a same notification published under Section 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Act, on 30.08.2006. Therefore all the appeals and cross objections are considered together and disposed of through this common judgment.

¶521

L.A.A No.107/2014 is an appeal filed by the Land Acquisition Officer along with the State Government. The 7 cross objections are filed by various claimants who are the respondents in the appeal. Property acquired in the cases were broadly classified by the Land Acquisition Officer in to “Garden land” and “Nancha

¶522

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶523

¶524

land” (wet land) and awarded land value at the rate of Rs.39,754/per cent for the Garden land and Rs.16,933/- per cent for the 'Nancha' land. In the reference made under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, the Subordinate Judge's Court, Thalasserry in L.A.R No. 400/2011 enhanced the land value with respect to the Garden land to Rs.69,794/- per cent. The reference court found that the land categorized as “Nancha” are actually 'Semi Garden Land' having improvements of grown up coconut trees of the age of 30 years and above, along with other grown up trees. But at the same time it was noticed that the land remains classified as 'Nancha' in the revenue records. Therefore such lands are re-classified as 'semi garden land'. The reference court granted enhancement with respect to the 'semi garden land' at Rs.33,933/- per cent. The extent of property covered in the said case was found to be 312.45 cents of 'garden land' and 268.10 cents of 'semi garden land'.

¶525

L.A.A No. 174/2018 arise out of judgment of the same reference court in LAR No. 170/2010. In the said case, the Land Acquisition Officer awarded compensation by fixing the land value with respect to the 'garden land' at Rs.39,811/- per cent. With respect to the land categorised as 'Nancha'. The land value awarded was Rs.17,000/- per cent. In the said case also the reference court re-classified the property described as 'Nancha' as 'semi garden

¶526

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶527

¶528

land' and re-fixed the land value with respect to an extend of 76½ cents of 'garden land' at the rate of Rs.69,811/- per cent. With respect to 3 Acres and 31.98 cents of 'semi garden land', the land value was re-fixed at Rs.33,000/- per cent.

¶529

L.A.A No. 175/2018 arises out of the judgment in L.A.R No.167/2010, the land value fixed by the Land Acquisition Officer with respect to the land acquired, which is included in the category of 'garden land', was at Rs.39,794/- per cent. The reference court enhanced the land value and refixed the same at Rs.69,794/- per cent.

¶530

In L.A.A No. 107/2014, the Acquisitioning Authority is challenging the judgment by contending that the enhancement granted is excessive and unreasonable. On the otherhand, the cross objectors are claiming enhancement of the compensation awarded by the reference court. In L.A.A No. 174 & 175/2018, the claimants are in appeal seeking enhancement of the compensation awarded.

¶531

We take note of the judgment of this Court in L.A.A No. 359/2014 dated 25.05.2018, to which one among us (Justice C.K.Abdul Rehim) is a party. The case dealt with therein is with respect to the same acquisition for the very same purpose, with respect to a land situated in the very same Village. The categorisation of the land covered under L.A.A No. 359/2014, is

¶532

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶533

¶534

'garden land'. This Court found that, the reference court in the judgment impugned therein had wrongly discarded the evidence adduced by the claimants through Exts.A1 to A4, which are comparable sale instances, the comparability of which was proved through the commission reports marked. This Court also found that, apart from producing Ext.R1, which is the basic documents relied upon by the Land Acquisition Officer, the Acquisitioning Authority or the Requisitioning Authority has not succeeded in proving that the land covered under the basic document is similar in nature and similarly situated, with equal prominence as that of the acquired property. On the otherhand, the claimants were successful in proving that the land covered under Ext.R1 is a land inferior in quality, remaining at a distance of 3 km from the acquired property. This Court considered that, among Exts.A1 to A4, Ext.A1 is the most suitable exemplar which can be relied upon for fixing the land value in that case. Therefore the compensation awarded with respect to the land value was revised and refixed at Rs.1,04,000/- per cent.

¶535

There is no much contention dispute that the 'garden land' covered under the above appeals are inferior in quality, in any manner, than the property covered under L.A.A No. 359/2014. Since the properties covered under these appeals and the property with respect to which this Court had decided L.A.A No. 359/2014

¶536

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶537

¶538

are acquired for the very same purpose through the very same notification and are situated within the very same Village, the appellant/claimants in L.A.A Nos.174 & 175/2018 or the Cross Objectors in the Cross Objections in L.A.A No. 107/2014 has no case that any other better exemplar than Ext.A1 mentioned in L.A.A No. 359/2014, is available for the purpose of fixing the land value with respect to the 'garden lands' involved in the above cases. Therefore we find it totally justifiable to refix the land value with respect to the garden land in the acquired properties involved in the above appeals and cross objections at the rate of Rs.10,4000/per cent.

¶539

With respect to the 'semi garden land' involved in the above cases, we take note of the fact that no comparable sale instances are produced in evidence before the reference court, in any of the cases. Therefore, for the purpose of refixing the land value with respect to the semi garden land, we are inclined to adopt a comparative valuation method. It is noticed that in all the judgments impugned above, the Land Acquisition Officer as well as the reference court had fixed the land value of the semi garden land (or 'Nancha' land) more or less around 50% of the value given to the garden land. Therefore we think it appropriate and safe to follow the same ratio in deciding refixation of the land value with respect to the 'semi garden land'.

¶540

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶541

¶542

With respect to the above conclusion, Sri. Joby Jacob Pulickakkudy, learned counsel appearing for the appellants in L.A.A Nos. 174 & 175/2018 and for the cross objectors in the other appeals, raised vehement contentions. It is pointed out that the Land Acquisition Officer had fixed a reduced value on the basis that the property categorised as 'Nancha' is totally a wet land, which cannot be utilised for any other purposes. It is pointed out that the reference court had reversed the finding on appreciating the factual matrix that, even according to the mahazar the land in question was remaining not as a wet land as such. But it was found that there exists grown up Coconut trees and other trees of the age of more than 30 years. Therefore, the reference court had reclassified the land in question as 'semi garden land'. But a proportionate increase in the value was not given by the reference court. Therefore it is contended that a reduction of the value by 50% from the value re-fixed for garden land may not be reasonable.

¶543

In support of the above contention the learned counsel had placed reliance on a decision of the Honourable Supreme Court in Special Land Acquisition Officer and Another v. M.K. Rafiq Saheb (AIR 2011 SC 3178). But on the facts of the said judgment, we notice that it is with respect to the land which ceased to be an agricultural land which can be utilised for other purposes and which is situated by the side of a residential locality and was in

¶544

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶545

¶546

the midst of a highly developed industrial locality. It was categorically found that the land was capable of being used for nonagricultural purposes and should be considered as non-agricultural land in determination of the compensation.

¶547

Learned Standing Counsel appearing for the requisitioning authority had pointed out that, with respect to the 'semi garden land' acquired for the purpose of the University, they could not utilise the same for construction of any building, because the Revenue Divisional Officer had issued an order of restrainment with respect to utilisation of the said land for any purposes other than agricultural operations.

¶548

From the rival contentions it can be seen that, the properties classified as 'semi garden land', even though ceased to be remaining as wet land, is not having the very same qualities of a garden land for the purpose of utilisation. So many statutory restrainments are there for utilising such properties for commercial purposes or for building construction. Of course, such utilisation may be available after obtaining necessary clearance and permits. But we have to take into consideration of the situation prevailed at the time of acquisition, in order to arrive at what exactly was the reasonable market value prevailed at the time of the acquisition. Therefore we are of the opinion that the reduction of 50% from the

¶549

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶550

¶551

value of the 'garden land', based on the proportion adopted by the Land Acquisition Officer as well as the reference court, is quite reasonable and justifiable.

¶552

In the result, the above Land Acquisition Appeals and the Cross Objections are disposed as follows:

¶553

(i). L.A.A. No.107 of 2014 filed by the State is hereby dismissed.

¶554

(ii).Cross Objection Nos.115, 117, 121, 123, 127, 138 and 153 of 2019 are allowed in part.

¶555

(iii) The Cross objectors/claimants will be entitled for re-fixation of land value at the rate of Rs.1,04,000/- per cent with respect to the extent of 'garden land' acquired in the said cases which is having a total extent of 312.45 cents and the cross objectors will be entitled for re-fixation of land value at the rate of Rs.52,000/-per cent with respect to 'semi garden land' acquired in the cases which is having a total extent of 268.10 cents.

¶556

(iv) L.A.A. No.174 of 2018 is allowed. The appellants/claimants are entitled for re-fixation of the land value at the rate of Rs.1,04,000/- per cent for the garden land acquired having an extent of 76½ cents and at the rate of Rs.52,000/- per cent for the semi garden land acquired having

¶557

LA.App..No.175 of 2018 & connected cases

¶558

¶559

an extent of 3 Acres 31.98 cents.

¶560

(v) L.A.A. No.175 of 2018 is allowed. The

¶561

appellants/claimants will be entitled to get enhanced land value at the rate of Rs.1,04,000/- per cent for the land acquired.

¶562

The appellants/claimants and the cross

¶563

objectors/claimants will be entitled for all statutory benefits on the enhanced compensation as provided under Sections 23(1A), 23(2) and 28 of the Land Acquisition Act, along with proportionate cost. The interest payable on the enhanced compensation shall be exempted with respect to the period for which specific orders to that effect is issued by this court while condoning delay occurred in filing the appeals.

¶564

Sd/-C.K. ABDUL REHIM, JUDGE .

¶565

Sd/-R. NARAYANA PISHARADI, JUDGE .

¶566

lsn

P.P.Muhammed Haris, v. the Special Tahsildar

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

P.P.Muhammed Haris, v. the Special Tahsildar

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Cases cited

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

O.K.Santhakumari Vs Government of Kerala

R.K.Pankajakshan Nambiar Vs Government of Kerala

O.K.Mohanan Nambiar Vs the Government of Kerala

Vazhayil Usman, Vs the Special Tahasildar(La)

Abdul Nizar, Vs the Special Tahsildar (La)

M.P.Muhammed Faizal Vs the Special Tahsildar(La)