Appeal dismissed because the first respondent in the underlying C.M.A. died and the appellant failed to appear or take steps to implead legal heirs.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT :
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR
TUESDAY, THE 11TH MARCH 2008 / 21ST PHALGUNA 1929
SA.No. 672 of 1994(E)
--------------------AS.80/1988 of ADDL.SUB COURT,ATTINGAL OS.70/1984 of MUNSIFF'S COURT,VARKALA
APPELLANT: APPELLANT NO.4/DEFENDANT 77:
------------------------------------------------------------------------
MOHAMMAD KASSIM MOHAMMAD YOUSUFF, MUSLIM, MUTTIYAN VILA VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, EDAVA VILLAGE.
BY ADV. SRI.A.K.CHINNAN
RESPONDENTS: APPELLANT 3/RESPONDENTS 1 TO 32, 34 TO 83 LRS OF APPEAL NO.1 AND 2 AND R33. DEFENDANT NO. 71, PLAINTIFFS 1 TO 5, DEFENDANTS 1 TO 27-29-31 TO 46-49 TO 55-57 TO 64, 66 TO 70-72 TO 83 AND LRS OF DECEASED DEFENDANTS 30, 56 AND 28.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. MOHAMMED ABDUL KHADAR SALMA BEEVI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, POTHIVILAKATHU VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, EDAVA VILLAGE.
3. MOHAMMAD ABDUL KHADAR BASHEER, MUSLIM, ...DO...DO...
4. MOHAMMAD ABDUL KHADAR KHAYARUNNISA BEEVI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ...DO....DO.....
5. MOHAMMAD ABDUL KHADAR KHADIJA BEEVI, MUSLIM, FEMALE OF ...DO...DO....
6. MOHAMMAD ABDUL KHADAR AYSHA BEEVI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, OF ...DO..DO....
Kss
..2/-
..2....
S.A.NO.672/1994
7. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM ABEERATHU BEEVI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, PORUTHAVILAKATHU VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, EDAVA VILLAGE.
8. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM SOUDA BEEVI, MUSLIM FEMALE, ...DO..DO....
9. MOHAMMED IBRAHIM FATHIMA KUNJU, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ...DO..DO.....
10. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM FAROOK, MUSLIM, OF ..DO..DO...
11. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM JUMAILATH, MUSLIM, FEMALE ..DO..DO..
12. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM SIDDIQ, MUSLIM, ..DO..DO...
13. MOHAMMAD IBRAHIM AZEEZA, MUSLIM,...DO..DO...
14. ALIYYARKUNJU SAINUDEEN, MUSLIM, CHUNDIVILAKAM VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, EDAVA VILLAGE.
15. ALIYYAARKUNJU KAMALUDEEN, MUSLIM, ..DO..DO..
16. ALIYAARKUNJU IMAMUDEEN, MUSLIM, ..DO..DO....
17. ALIYAARKUNJU IAUHARATHU, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ..DO..DO....
18. ALIYAARKUNJU SABIRATH, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ..DO..DO....
20. ALIYAARKUNJU SUBAIRATH, MUSLIM, FEMALE, DO..DO...
21. ALIYAARKUNJU RUBY, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ...DO...DO...
22. MARIYAM KUNJU SABEEDA, MUSLIM, FEMALE, THULAVARCHAVILA VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, EDAVA VILLAGE.
23. THAJUDEEN ARSHAAD, MUSLIM,...DO..DO...
24. THAJUDEEN ROBI, MUSLIM, FEMALE,..DO..DO...
Kss
..3/-
...3....
S.A.NO.672/1994
**25. THAJUDEEN AMBILI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, DO..DO... 26. THAJUDEEN AMMINI, MUSLIM, FEMALE, ..DO..DO... ***27. *ABDUL AZEEZ ABDUL KHALAAM, MUSLIM, PADINJAATAY BHAGOM VEEDU, OF ..DO..DO...(DIED) LR'S IMPLEADED:
28. ABDUL AZEEZ ABDUL SAMAD, MUSLIM, OF ..DO..DO...
29. ABDUL AZEEZ SIBILI, MUSLIM, OF ..DO..DO... 30. ABDUL AZEEZ RAFEEKA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO... 31. ABDUL AZEEZ BIJILI, MUSLIM OF ..DO..DO.... 32. ABDUL AZEEZ RAHAMATHUMMA, FEMALE OF...DO..DO... 33. ABDUL AZEEZ NABEESA BEEVI, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO.... 34. BEEVI KUNJU NABEESA KUNJU, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO... 35. ASUMA BEEVI SHAREEFA BEEVI, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO... 36. MOHAMMAD KUNJU NAZIRUDEEN OF ..DO..DO.... 37. MOHAMMAD KUNJU SHARAFUDEEN OF ..DO..DO... 38. MOHAMMAD KUNJU SAIFUDEEN OF ..DO..DO..
39. MOHAMMAD KUNJU SHIHAB, OF ..DO..DO....
40. MOHAMMAD KUNJU NUJUM, OF ..DO..DO.... 41. HANSA KUNJU NADEERA, FEMALE THUNDATHIL VEEDU,DO..DO.. 42. HAMSA KUNJU THAHIRA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO... 43. HAMSA KUNJU BABU, OF ..DO..DO...
44. HAMSA KUNJU RAZEENA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO..
45. ABDUL HAMEED JALEELA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
Kss
..4/-
...4....
S.A.NO.672/1994
46. HAMSA KUNJU RONY, OF ..DO..DO...
47. HAMSA KUNJU SONY OF ..DO..DO....
48. MOOSA KUNJU RILAL, HIRDAS VEEDU FROM VILAYIL VEEDU OF ..DO..DO...
49. MOOSAL K UNJU NAJUMNISA, FEMALE OF DO..DO...
50. MOOSA KUNJU RUBI, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
51. PAKEER MOHAMMAD ABDUL RAHIM, MUTTIYANVILA VEEDU, OF ..DO..DO...
52. SALKA BEEVI ASHYA UMMAL, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO....
53. SALKA BEEVI AYISHA BEEVI, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
54. SAFIYA BEEVI BASHEERA, FEMALE, KIZHAKKEBHAGATHU VEEDU, OF ...DO..DO....
55. MOHAMMAD ABDULLA MANAAF, OF .DO...DO....
56. MOHAMMAD ABDULLA MUBAANA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO... 57. RUKHAYYA UMMAL KHADIJAKUTTY, FEMALE, AAZHAANTHAVILA VEEDU, ...DO..DO....
58. MOHAMMAD HANEEFA SALAAHUDEEN OF ..DO..DO...
59. MOHAMMAD HANEEFA SHAMSUDEEN, OF ..DO..DO...
60. RUKHIYA UMMAL AYISHAKUTTY, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO...
61. RUKHIYA UMMAL ABIDA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO.....
62. RUKHIYA UMMAL ARIFA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO....
63. RUKHIYA UMMAL SHAANITHA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO....
64. RUKHIYA UMMAL, MAJIDA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO....
65. RUKHIYA UMMAL JAMEELA, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO...
Kss
..5/-
......5.....
SA.NO.672/1994
66. ABDUL KHADAR ABDUL MAJEED, POTHIVILAKATHU VEEDU, ..DO..DO....
67. ABDUL KHADAR ISHAAK, OF ...DO..DO...
68. ABDUL KHADAR ISSUDEEN OF ..DO..DO.... 69. HAJIRA UMMAL SAINABA BEEVI, FEMALE, KOCHUMUTTIYANVILA, OF ..DO..DO...
70. MOHAMMAD NOOHU ABDUL HAMEED, OF ..DO..DO...
71. MOHAMMAD NOOHU JAMEELA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
72. MOHAMMAD NOOHU JALEELA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
73. MOHAMMAD NOOHU JAMEEL, OF ..DO...DO... 74. ASUMA BEEVI ALEEMA BEEVI, FEMALE, MUTTIYAANVILA, OF ..DO..DO...
75. ASUMA BEEVI RAHUMA BEEVI, FEMALE, OF ..DO..DO...
76. ASUMA BEEVI RAZIYA BEEVI, FEMALE OF ...DO...DO....
77. ABDUL KHARIM SAUDA BEEVI, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO....
78. ABDUL KHAREEM FAZEELA, FEMALE OF ..DO...DO....
79. ABDUL KHAREEM FAAZIL, OF ...DO...DO....
80. ABDUL KHARREEM LAILA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO.....
81. ABDUL KHAREEM JALEELA, FEMALE OF ..DO..DO...
82. FATHIMA MOHAMMED, FAJIR, VENKULAM, EDAVA, VARKALA. 83. NAGEENA, DAUGHTER OF FATHIMA, SARITH, VENKULAM, EDAVA, VARKALA.
84. SHAMEENA, SAPHIRE, VATTATHARA, MALACKAL P.O., MADAVOOR, PALLICKAL.
85. JABEENA, P.O.BOX NO.10783, DUBAI.
Kss
..6/-
..6....
S.A.NO.672/1994
86. AFSAL, INAYATIA, P.O.BOX NO.224, CONSOLIDATED CONTRACTORS COMPANY, ABUDHABI.
87. RAFEEKKA SHAFIKUTTY, SUKANYA HOUSE, VENKULAM, EDAVA P.O.
88. SHAFIKUTTY NAJEENA OF ...DO...DO....
89. SHAFIKUTTY RAFFY OF ...DO...DO....
90. SHAFIKUTTY SURIYA OF ...DO...DO.....
91. SHAFIKUTTY SAREENA OF ...DO...DO...
92. SHAFIKUTTY RAJEENA OF ...DO...DO....
93. BEEVI KUNJU SALIM, THULAVARCHAVILA OF ..DO..DO...
94. BEEVI KUNJU ANSARI OF ..DO....DO....
95. BEEVI KUNJU AZAD OF ..DO...DO...
96. BEEVI KUNJU ASHARAF OF ..DO..DO....
97. BEEVI KUNJU AZILAM OF ..DO..DO.....
98. ABIDA BEEVI, ZAMEERA MANZIL, PARAYIL, VARKALA.
99. ASHEER, ...DO...DO.....
100. ZAMEERA OF ..DO...DO...
101. ASSEES OF ...DO...DO....
102. SAMEENA OF ..DO..DO...
103. UNNI OF ...DO..DO......
Kss
..7/-
....7......
S.A.NO.672/1994
104. REHUMA BEEVI, W/O.ABDUL KHALAM, MUTTIYAM VILA VEEDU, EDAVA DESOM, VARKALA.
105. NAJEEB, MUTTIYAM VILA VEEDU, OF ..DO...DO...
106. SOFIYA OF ...DO..DO.....
107. SHYMOON OF ..DO..DO....
108. NAZEEMUDEEN OF ...DO...DO....
109. SAJITH OF ...DO...DO....
**(*ADDL.RESPONDENTS R104 TO 109 ARE IMPLEADED AS LR'S OF DECEASED 27TH RESPONDENT AS PER ORDER DTD. 7/03/2008 ON C.M.P.NO.341/1996)
BY ADV. SRI.M.A.MANHU ) SRI.M.FAZLUL HAQ ) SRI.M.A.FAYAZ ) R3
THIS SECOND APPEAL HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON 11/03/2008, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
Kss
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR,J.
C.M.P.NO.1427 OF 1994 AND S.A .NO. 672 OF 1994
Dated 11th March 2008
J U D G M E N T
It is submitted by the learned counsel
appearing for respondents that respondent No.14 is no more. Learned counsel appearing for appellant submitted that in spite of the notice appellant did not turn up to take steps. Hence C.M.A.1427/994 is dismissed. Consequently appeal is also dismissed.
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR, JUDGE.
uj.
=============================
M.SASIDHARAN NAMBIAR,J.
JUDGMENT
S.A.NO.672 OF 1994
11th March 2008
============================
Mohammad Kassim Mohammad Yousuff
Mohammad Abdul Khadar Salma Beevi
Mohammad Abdul Khadar Basheer
Mohammad Abdul Khadar Khayarunnisa Beevi
M.Sasidharan Nambiar
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
