Sri Nagaraju v. Sri N H Bhaskar Reddy
Case brief
What is this about?
Karnataka HC (Bengaluru), M.I. Arun J., WP No. 7183 of 2014 (SCST-), decided 10.07.2026 — PTCL Act S.5 locus/maintainability; co-heir of 1928 grantee lacking standing where vendors were other heirs; sale deeds 22.04.2002, 16.09.2004, 18.05.2008 to respondent no.1; alleged 1948 sales a disputed question of fact; non-alienation period admitted expired; permission under S.4 PTCL Act contended; delay/laches in 2012 application; Deputy Commissioner's order dated 07.12.2013 in No.SC.ST(A)/20/2012-13 challenged; Assistant Commissioner's suo motu power discussed; Shivajyothi and Amruth Township's Welfare Association (R5); writ petition dismissed.
What did the court decide?
Even if the petitioner's contention is accepted, his right (if any) in respect of the property has not been alienated in favour of the purchasers by the impugned sale deeds, since the vendors were other legal heirs of the original grantee and the petitioner asserts an independent share.