#�� %��65��;6@1��3��$"$��D40�;1860<1;12�9A� �4286;6��/;4?��3?6.1��<4<635��4286;6�:3;�<=1�4:3;10462� 3::15.10�40�484650<�<=1�71<6<6351;0�=1;165�35�<=1�94060�3:� <=1�:6;0<�65:3;@4<635�24<12��"!�$"$��;1.16>12�:;3@� �=6>F45<=�'��3?6.1��/9��5071.<3;�4<<4.=12�<3��4286;6��/;4?� �3?6.1��<4<635��4286;6��:<1;�.3@7?1<635�3:�65>10<684<635� .=4;81�0=11<�=40�9115�:6?12�484650<�<=1�71<6<6351;0�:3;�<=1� 4:3;10462� 3::15.10�� =1� <;64?� �3/;<� =4>658� <4F15� .3856G45.1�3:�<=1�.=4;81�0=11<12�3::15.10�=40�600/12� 0/@@350�<3�<=1�4../012�71;0350��40046?658�<=1�0462� 7;3.1126580�<=1�71<6<6351;0�4;1�91:3;1�<=60��3/;<��

¶45

�� 14;512�.3/501?�:3;�<=1�71<6<6351;�0/9@6<0�<=4<� <=1�4??184<635�484650<�<=1�71<6<6351;0�60�493/<�.3@@6<<658� <=1:<�3:�0452�452�<=1;1:3;1��73?6.1�.3/?2�53<�=4>1� ;1860<1;12�4�%��484650<�<=1�71<6<6351;0�35�<=1�94060�3:�<=1� :6;0<�65:3;@4<635�0/9@6<<12�9A�<=1��3?6.1��/9'�5071.<3;��

¶46

��

¶47

¶48

�1�0/9@6<0�<=4<�<=1�7;3>606350�3:��6510�452��651;4?0� )�1>1?37@15<�452��18/?4<635*��.<�):3;�0=3;<�B��.<C*�� +�81<0�4<<;4.<12�65�<=1�@4<<1;�452�6<�60�35?A�<=1� 4/<=3;6G12�3::6.1;��D=3�.45�:6?1�4�.3@7?465<�40�7;3>6212� /521;��1.<635�$$�3:�<=1��.<��1�4?03�0/9@6<0�<=4<� 65�>61D�3:��1.<635�#"��3:�<=1�4.<�35?A�071.64?��3/;<�.45� <4F1�.3856G45.1�3:�<=1�4??1812�3::15.10�/521;�<=1�� .<�� +�452�<=1��4860<;4<1�.3/?2�53<�=4>1�<4F15� .3856G45.1��

¶49

�� 1;�.35<;4�?14;512��68=��3/;<��3>1;5@15<�

¶50

�?1421;�=40�3773012�<=1�71<6<635��

¶51

H�� 1;/04?�3:�<=1�:6;0<�65:3;@4<635�65�<=1�7;1015<� .401�D3/?2�;1>14?�<=4<�<=1�<6771;�?3;;A�914;658�;1860<;4<635� �3��' �'�%'� !��91?358658�<3�4../012��3�$�3:�D=6.=�<=1� 4../012��3��D40�4�2;6>1;�D40�65<1;.17<12�35��"!�$"$�� 9A�<=1�:6;0<�65:3;@45<�452�6<�D40�:3/52�<=4<�<=1�4../012� 71;0350�D1;1�<;45073;<658�0452�91?358658�<3�<=1��<4<1� �3>1;5@15<�65�<=1�0462�<6771;�?3;;A��5�>1;6:6.4<635�6<�D40� :3/52�<=4<�<=1�4../012�71;0350�262�53<�=4>1�45A�?6.15.1�3;�

¶52

��

¶53

¶54

71;@6<�16<=1;�<3�E/4;;A�<=1�0452�3;�<3�<;45073;<�<=1�04@1��

¶55

�<�60�65�<=60�94.F8;3/52�%��=40�9115�;1860<1;12�484650<� 4../012�71;0350�:3;�3::15.1�7/560=49?1�/521;��1.<635� #"#)$*�3:��$"$#��

¶56

+�� 52607/<12?A��<=1�3::15.10�7/560=49?1�/521;�<=1� ��.<�� +�=4>1�53<�9115�65>3F12�40�484650<� 4../012�71;0350�65�<=1�7;1015<�.401��=1�7;3>606350�3:� ��.<�� +�@3;1�03��1.<6350�$$�452�#"��3:�<=1�0462� 4.<0�91.3@10�477?6.49?1�35?A�65�<=1�1>15<�<=1�7154?� 7;3>606350�3:�<=1�0462�4.<0�4;1�65>3F12�484650<�<=1�4../012� 71;0350��5�<=1�7;1015<�.401��%��D40�;1860<1;12�35?A�:3;� 3::15.1�7/560=49?1�/521;��1.<635�#"#)$*�3:��452�1>15� .=4;81�0=11<�=40�9115�:6?12�4:<1;�65>10<684<635�35?A�:3;�<=1� 0462�3::15.1��=1;1:3;1��<=1�?14;512��4860<;4<1�D40�:/??A� I/0<6:612�65�<4F658�.3856G45.1�3:�<=1�.=4;81�0=11<�3::15.10� 452�600/658�0/@@350�<3�<=1�71<6<6351;0��23�53<�:652�45A� 6??184?6<A� 3;� 6;;18/?4;6<A� 65� <=1� 6@7/8512� .;6@654?� 7;3.1126580�D=6.=�51120�65<1;:1;15.1�9A�<=60��3/;<�65� 1J1;.601�3:�6<0�1J<;43;2654;A�73D1;0�/521;��1.<635� $!�3:�

¶57

¶58

��

¶59

��$"$#��=1;1:3;1��23�53<�:652�45A�8332�8;3/520�<3� 15<1;<465�<=60�71<6<635��..3;2658?A��71<6<635�60��

¶60

�,+�� '��%��&�"��!*� "��

¶61

�� 60<��3��?��3��

Shankar and Anr. v. the State of Karnataka and Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Shankar and Anr. v. the State of Karnataka and Anr.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

Issues for consideration

Procedural history

Case details

Similar cases

Venkatrao Vs Srinivas

Laxmikant and Anr. Vs the State of Karnataka and Anr.

Ravikumar C H Vs the State of Karnataka and Anr.

Badesab and Ors. Vs the State and Anr.

Bihsop Namdev Lakshman Karkare and Anr. Vs State of Karnataka and Anr.

Saleem Vs the State and Anr.