The High Court of Karnataka, in an interim order in Regular Second Appeal No. 336 of 2019 concerning succession rights, adjourned the matter granting two weeks to comply with office objections. A subsequent note declared the appeal dismissed for non-compliance.
Appeal dismissed for failure to comply with office objections.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF SEPTEMBER, 2021
BEFORE
THE HON' BLE MR. JUSTICE E.S.INDIRESH
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL NO.336 OF 2019
BETWEEN
W/O LATE NARAYANA SHETTY
AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, PADUBIDRI (POST) UDUPI (T). D K
D/O LATE NARAYANA SHETTY AGED ABOUT 36 YEARS, HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, PADUBIDRI (POST) UDUPI (T) DK
…2
2
RSA NO. 336/2019
HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE,
PADUBIDRI (POST), UDUPI (T). D K
… APPELLANT/S
(SRI/SMT CHETAN.B.ANGADI, PUTTARAJ T.V. AND NAVEEN KUMAR FOR ANGADI LAW ASSOCIATES ADVOCATES )
AND
ADULT, D/O KALYANI SHEDTHI, R/O BETUGUTHU HOUSE, PADUPERAR VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST BUJPE, D K
….3
3
RSA NO. 336/2019
3. JEEVARAJ
ADULT, S/O SHAMBAVI S MADA R/O BETUGUTHU HOUSE, PADUPERAR VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST BUJPE D K
ADULT, S/O SHAMBAVI S MADA R/O BETUGUTHU HOUSE, PADUPERAR VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST BUJPE D K
ADULT, D/O SHAMBAVI S MADA R/O BETUGUTHU HOUSE, PADUPERAR VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST BUJPE D K
…4
RSA NO. 336/2019
4
ADULT, D/O LATE VENKAMMA @ BIYALU SHEDTHI, R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE, KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE, KARKALA TALUK
10. SMT GANGU SHEDTHI
ADULT, R/O MANJORGUTHU ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
ADULT, D/O MANJORGUTHU, R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
ADULT, D/O GANGU SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU ULEPADY VILLAGE,
MANGALORE TALUK POST ELINJE D K
ADULT, S/O JAYANTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE,
MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
…5
RSA NO. 336/2019
5
14. SHAKUNTHALA
ADULT, D/O JAYANTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE, D K
15. HARISH
ADULT, S/O JAYANTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
16. CHANDRASHEKAR
ADULT, S/O JAYANTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE,
MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
17. SURESH
ADULT, S/O JAYANTHI SHEDTHI
R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
ADULT, S/O SUGUNA SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK,
POST ELINJE D K
….6
6
RSA NO. 336/2019
19. THRIVENI
ADULT, D/O KIRTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
20. BHARATHI
ADULT, D/O KIRTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
21. THULASI
ADULT, D/O KIRTHI SHEDTHI R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE, MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
22. KIRAN
ADULT, S/O KIRTHI SHEDTHI
R/O MANJORGUTHU, ULEPADY VILLAGE,
MANGALORE TALUK, POST ELINJE D K
23. SHANKAR SHETTY
ADULT, S/O LATE VENKAMMA @ BIYALU SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE,
KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
…7
RSA NO. 336/2019
7
24. SHEENA SHETTY
ADULT, S/O LATE VENKAMMA @ BIYALU SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE, KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
25. RAMESH SHETTY
ADULT, S/O APPI SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE, KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
26. USHA SHEDTHI
ADULT, D/O APPI SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE, KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
27. JEETHENDRA SHETTY
ADULT, S/O APPI SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE,
KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
28. GOPINATHA SHETTY
SINCE DECEASED
ADULT S/O USHA SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE,
KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
…8
8
RSA NO. 336/2019
AGED ABOUT 16 YEARS
BOTH ARE CHILDREN OF GOPINATHA SHETTY AND PRATHIMA SHETTY 28(b) AND (C) ARE REPRESENTED BY THEIR MOTHER PRATHIMA SHETTY
ALL ARE RESIDING UNDER CARE OF RAMESH TALUK OFFICE ROAD, JODURASTHE, KARKALA
29. GEETHA
ADULT, D/O USHA SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE, KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
ADULT, D/O USHA SHEDTHI R/O VASANTHA VILLA, NEAR TALUK OFFICE,
KARKALA KASBA VILLAGE KARKALA TALUK
…9
9
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, D/O LATE GIRIYAMMA SHETHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
33. SMT SHARADA SHEDTHI
ADULT, D/O LATE SANJEEVI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI D K
34. SHARATH SHETTY
ADULT, S/O SANJEEVI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, S/O PREMA SHEDTHI
R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
….10
10
RSA NO. 336/2019
36. KUSHA
ADULT, S/O PREMA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
37. RAJANI
ADULT, D/O PREMA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
38. SHAILA
ADULT, D/O PREMA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
39. SUDHA
ADULT, D/O PREMA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
40. NAVEEN
ADULT, S/O SHARADA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK ,POST PADUBIDRI, D K
….11
11
RSA NO. 336/2019
41. KALPANA
ADULT, D/O SHARADA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
42. PRAVEENA
ADULT, S/O SHARADA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, S/O SHARADA SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
….12
12
RSA NO. 336/2019
50 YEARS
44 YEARS
ALL ARE RESIDING AT KARLLOTTU HOUSE, SHIRVA VILLAGE AND POST, UDUPI TALUK AND DISTRICT
45. RAGHAVA SINCE DECEASED
ADULT, S/O SUNDARI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
AGED ABOUT 72 YEARS
W/O RAGURAM HEGDE
56 YEARS
…13
13
RSA NO. 336/2019
52 YEARS
(b) to (g) ARE CHILDREN OF RAGHURAM SHETTY, ALL ARE RESIDING AT KARLOTTU HOUSE, SHIRVA VILLAGE AND POST UDUPI TALUK AND DISTRICT
46. SMT RATHNAVATHI
(SINCE DECEASED) ADULT, D/O SUNDARI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE , NADSAL VILLAGE,
UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K
AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS
DAUGHTER OF RATHNAVATHI SHEDTHI, KARLLOTTU HOUSE, SHIRVA VILLAGE AND POST, UDUPI TALUK AND DISTRICT
….14
14
RSA NO. 336/2019
R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE,
UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
a). SUSHEELA SHETTY, 70 YEARS
b). UMAVATHI , 65 YEARS
c). SHAKUNTHALA , 60 YEARS
d). SAROJINI, 56 YEARS
e). KANTHI SHEDTHI, 51 YEARS
f). DINESH SHETTY, 47 YEARS
g). POORNIMA, 46 YEARS
ALL ARE CHILDREN OF GULABI SHEDTHI, ALL ARE RESIDING AT KUNTADI MANE, “DEVI PRASAD”, THELLAR POST, KARKALA TALUK
ADULT, D/O SUNDARI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, D/O SUNDARI SHEDTHI R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK
POST PADUBIDRI, D K
….15
15
RSA NO. 336/2019
| 52. | SMT SAKKU SHEDTHI |
|---|---|
| ADULT, D/O GULABI SHEDTHI | |
| R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, | |
| UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D K |
| 53. | SMT SAROJINI SHEDTHI |
|---|---|
| ADULT, D/O GULABI SHEDTHI | |
| R/O HIREBETTU HOUSE, NADSAL VILLAGE, | |
| UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI D K |
…..16
16
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, D/O LATE PUTTAMMA SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, D/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, D/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
…17
17
RSA NO. 336/2019
62. SMT SHANTHA
ADULT, D/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI D K
ADULT, S/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
64. DODDAMMA
ADULT, D/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
65. SMT BABY
ADULT, D/O CHIKKI SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
66. DIWAKAR SHETTY
ADULT, S/O SAMPA SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
67. VASANTHI
ADULT, D/O SAMPA SHEDTHI R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
…..18
18
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, D/O SAMPA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D.K.
ADULT, S/O SUSHEELA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D.K
70. BHARATHI
ADULT, D/O SUSHEELA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
71. DIVAKARA
ADULT, S/O SUSHEELA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
72. YOGINI
ADULT, D/O SUSHEELA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
73. ASHA
ADULT, D/O SUSHEELA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
…..19
19
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, D/O SHARADA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
75. SUJATHA
ADULT, D/O SHANTHA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
76. YASHODA
ADULT, D/O SHANTHA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
77. NAGARAJA
ADULT, S/O SHANTHA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K.
78. BHASKARA
ADULT, S/O BABY SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
79. GEETHA
ADULT, S/O BABY SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
….20
20
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, D/O LATE NAGU SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
ADULT, S/O GULABI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
82. GANESH SHETTY
ADULT, S/O GULABI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
83. NARAYANA SHETTY
ADULT, S/O KAMALA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
84. DDOOJA SHETTY
ADULT, S/O KAMALA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
85. PADMAVATHI SHEDTHI
ADULT, D/O KAMALA SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
…..21
21
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, S/O PADMAVATHI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
88. CHITTA SHETTY
ADULT, S/O PADMAVATHI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
89. SANTHOSH
ADULT, S/O NALINI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
90. RESHMA
ADULT, D/O NALINI SHEDTHI, R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK POST PADUBIDRI, D K
91. SUSHMA
ADULT, S/O NALINI SHEDTHI,
R/O NADSAL VILLAGE, UDUPI TALUK, POST PADUBIDRI, D.K.
….22
22
RSA NO. 336/2019
ADULT, W/O LATE BHARATH SHEDTHI, C/O JAGANNATHA SHETTY, SUJATHA NILAYA, VISHNUMOORTHY NAGAR, NITTOR POST, NITTOR, UDUPI.
… RESPONDENTS
REGULAR SECOND APPEAL FILED UNDER SECTION 100 OF CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 05.04.2018 PASSED IN R.A.NO.78/2012 ON THE FILE OF THE II ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC,, UDUPI, DISMISSING THE APPEAL AND CONFIRMING THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 02.04.2012 PASSED IN OS NO.175/1997 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, UDUPI.
This Regular Second Appeal coming on for Orders, this day the Court made the following Order:-
….23
23
RSA NO. 336/2019
ORDER
Two weeks time is granted to comply with the office objections, failing which, the appeal shall stand dismissed without reference to the Bench.
Sd/- JUDGE
NOTE : Vide Court Order dated 06.09.2021, office objections
are not complied with, hence appeal shall stand dismissed.
COPY
Sd/I/C ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
T By: SV R By: PH C By: HKV SO : DS Ty Date: 10.08.2022 C Date: 12.08.2022
SMT RAMA SHEDTHI AND OTHERS
SMT KALYANI SHEDTHI AND OTHERS
E.S. INDIRESH
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
