The judgment text is entirely corrupted with character encoding errors and symbols. No substantive legal content, parties, or court holdings could be extracted.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
�
������������������������������ ����������������
������������������� ��������������������
������
���������������������������������
����������������������������������������� ���
��������
�� ��� !"#!#�� �$%��%&�#''#��%(#)&*
�+,���--��,#�
�..����%%*�,
�� �""#/&�#"# �$%���� !"#!#����%(#)&* �+,�������,#�
�..����0&1,"0
2� 3#"�'#((# �$%���%&�#''#��%(#)&* �+,���4-��,#� �..�����*
�**�#�,��$%��#"1!���#+#����%/#1/#00���%��))#)%0��%#1���%#/&�5-�2���
�����//,**#"0
6�'������# #7#�#8����3#0!���17%.#0,9
����
�� �#:(�"#�#'#" �$%�;,")#0�#%��%�#"0#*#
�
�+,���-���,#� �..���<��7#0,��,�7�., �0$<% 0�����$�52����!#7#"��<,0! �%*#/&�5-�2����
�� �!,���#".!�3#"#+,� �,=��"1�#�� &�#".,��%(/#"'��01� �������%"0��%#1����8#/&�5>?4����
2� 3��������11, ! �$%��#"&(#"0#//# �%"1#1#��%#1���//���,,�, !=#���,(/*, �#7#"#+,�,5>������
-� �!,���#".!�3#"#+,� �������%(@#�1��,"���" &�#".,��%���01� �//% �0,�<%*'0,.!"�.��"+���%**,+, ��8#/&���#+#*)%0��%#1����8#/&�5>?4����
�����, /%"1,"0
6�'�����3#"7,"1�#��,11'���17%.#0,�A%����B ����������#*@&�+����17%.#0,�A%���-B �%0�.,�0%����C��2�� �1� /," ,1�=�0! ;$%�1#0,1��4��-����?9
�!� �3� .,**#",%& ���� 0��//,#�� �A�,1�&"1,� �,.0�%"���26�9�%A�3%0%��;,!�.*, ��.0��/�#'�"+�0%�(%1�A' 0!,��(/&+",1�8&1+(,"0�#"1�#=#�1�1#0,1���5�45���> /# ,1� @'� 0!,� 3���� �%�;��� ;�8#'/&�� �"� 3;� �%��>2�$�����
�!� �#//,#�� �.%(�"+�%"�A%��#1(� �%"��0!� �1#'� 0!,�.%&�0�1,�7,�,1�0!,�A%**%=�"+�
2
��������
�!,�#//,**#"0 $.#�(#"0 �#�,��"�#//,#� ,,)�"+ ,"!#".,(,"0�%A�.%(/," #0�%"�+�#"0,1�&"1,��8&1+(,"0 #"1�#=#�1,1�1#0,1�����4����>��"�3;���%��>2�$����� %"�0!,�A�*,�%A�3�����%�;��#0�;�8#'/&��
�� �!,�,�� �"%�1� /&0,�=�0!��,+#�1�0%�0!, #..�1,"0�#"1�0!,��#@��0'�A�:,1�@'�0!,����@&"#����!, +�%&"1�A%��,"!#".,(,"0�%A�.%(/," #0�%"�@'�0!, .#�(#"0�� �0!#0�0!,����@&"#*�%&+!0�0%�!#7,�0#)," �".%(,�%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1�#0�� �4�>��$5�/,��(%"0!��" 0,#1 %A�� �-�>��$5�/,��(%"0!�
2� �&�0!,�� 0!,� ,#�",1� .%&" ,� A%�� 0!,
#//,**#"0 � &@(�0 �0!#0�0!,����@&"#�=# �"%0���+!0��" 1,1&.0�"+��$2�1 �0%=#�1 �/,� %"#�#"1��7�"+�,:/," , �%A 0!,�1,.,# ,1�#"1�!,� &@(�0 �0!#0�0!,����@&"#�%&+!0�0% !#7,�1,1&.0,1��$-0!� # �0!,�,�#�,�A%&��1,/,"1,"0 �
-� �!,�,#�",1�.%&" ,�A%��0!,��, /%"1,"0
&@(�0 �0!#0�0!,�.%(/," #0�%"�+�#"0,1�@'�0!,����@&"#* � �8& 0�#"1�/�%/,��#"1� &@(�0 �0!#0�0!,�,�� �"%�",,1�0% �"0,�A,�,�=�0!�0!,�8&1+(,"0�#"1�#=#�1�/# ,1�@'�0!, ���@&"#*�
� �#�(#"0��%���� �!& @#"1��.#�(#"0��%�2��
1#&+!0,��%A�1,.,# ,1��=!,�,# �.#�(#"0��%�-�� �(%0!,�5 �"5#=�%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1����#�(#"0��%���1�,1� &@ ,D&,"0 0%�/# �"+�%A�0!,�#=#�1�#"1�@,A%�,�A��"+�0!,�/�, ,"0 #//,#����!,����@&"#��"�0!,�#@ ,".,�%A�#"'�(#0,��#�0% �"1�.#0,�0!,��".%(,�%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1��!# �0#),"�0!, "%0�%"#��".%(,�#0�� �-�>��$5�/,��(%"0!�# ��".%(,�%A 0!,�1,.,# ,1����!� ��%&�0�#"1�0!,��%)��1##0!�=!�, ,00*�"+�0!,�.%(/," #0�%"��"�3%0%��;,!�., ��..�1,"0 .# , �� �0#)�"+�"%0�%"#��".%(,�A%��0!,�#..�1,"0 �%A�0!, ',#�������#0�� �4�>��$5�/,��(%"0!����"�0!,�.# ,�%" !#"1�#* %��"�0!,�#@ ,".,�%A�#"'�(#0,��#*�%"��,.%�1�0% �"1�.#0,�0!,��".%(,�%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1���0�� �#//�%/��#0,�0%
0#),�"%0�%"#*��".%(,�%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1�#0�� �4�>��$5�/,� (%"0!�
4� ��0!��,+#�1�0%�0!,�.%"0,"0�%"�%A�0!,�,#�",1 .%&" ,�A%��0!,�#//,#"0 �0!#0�0!,����@&"#�%&+!0�0% !#7,�0#),"��$-0! �1,1&.0�%"�0%=#�1 �/,� %"#�,:/," , %A�0!,�1,.,# ,1�� ��#@,�0%�@,��,8,.0,1����!,����@&"# !# ���+!0'�0#),"��$2�1 �1,1&.0�%"�0%=#�1 �/,� %"#* ,:/," , �%A�0!,�1,.,# ,1��# �.#�(#"0��%�-��0!,�(%0!,�5 �"5#=�.#""%0�@,�.%" �1,�,1�# �1,/,"1,"0�%"�0!, 1,.,# ,1����&�0!,���0�� �"%0�.,1�0!#0�0!,����@&"#�!# +�#"0,1�� �2�����$5�%"�.%"7,"0�%"#�!,#1 ��=!,�,# 0!,�.#�(#"0 �=%&1�@,�,"0�0,1�0%�(#:�(&(�%A � �������$5� %"� .%"7,"0�%"#� !,#1 ��� �!& �� 0!, .#�(#"0 � =%&1� @,� ,"0�0,1� A%�� 0!,� (%1�A�,1 .%(/," #0�%"�%"�0!,�!,#1�%A�E% �%A�1,/,"1,".'F�# A%**%= ��5
� �4�>��$5�5��$2�1 �G-�22-�:����:��4�G�?�2����?$5
4
�� �&�0!,��# � 0#0,1�#@%7,��0!,�.*#�(#"0 �#�,
,"0�0*,1�0%�� �������$5�%"�.%"7,"0�%"#*�!,#1 ��" 0,#1�%A
� �-�����$5�#=#�1,1�@'�0!,����@&"#����!,�.#�(#"0 =%&1�@,�,"0�0,1�A%��,"!#".,1�.%(/," #0�%"�%A � ���?4���?$5��=�0!�?H��"0,�, 0�A�%(�0!,�1#0,�%A�/,0�0�%" 0�**��,#*�I#0�%"�
�&0�%A�0!,�,"!#".,1�.%(/," #0�%"��.#�(#"0��%�� =%&1�@,�,"0�0,1�A%��� ���������$5����#�(#"0��%�2 =%&1�@,�,"0�0,1�A%��� ���������$5����!,�@##"., #(%&"0� !#**�@,�/#�1�0%�.#�(#"0��%�-�
��0!�0!,�#@%7,��0!,�#//,#*�� �1� /% ,1�%A�
��!�" �����
��<
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
