Batch appeal and writ petitions over grant of annual increments for contractual service; court held the issue was settled by its recent judgment in Narayan Dutt Sharma's case and extended the same directions and benefits to all petitioners.
Benefits per Narayan Dutt Sharma judgment to be extended to petitioners within four months.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
2024:HHC:11319
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA
| LPA No.370 of 2024 a/w CWP Nos. 5255, 5258, |
|---|
| 5262, 5308, 5309, 5310, 5313, 5315, 5318, |
| 5322, 5352, 5355, 5359, 5361, 5369, 5390, |
| 5424, 5426, 5429, 5432, 5435, 5437, 5438, |
| 5440, 5441, 5444, 5445, 5447, 5455,5456, |
| 5458, 5463, 5476, 5477, 5478, 5482, 5483, |
| 5486, 5487, 5506, 5510, 5520, 5522, 5530, |
| 5532, 5533, 5534, 5535, 5540, 5547, 5550, |
| 5552, 5559, 5561, 5563, 5574, 5577, 5579, |
| 5582, 5588, 5589, 5609, 5613,5616, 5619, |
| 5634, 5640, 5658, 5660, 5664, 5667, 5700 |
| 5713, 5734, 5788, 5792, 5864, 5868, 5869, |
| 5872, 5883, 5938, 6006, 6013, 6015, 6044, |
| 6077, 6081, 6090, 6094, 6095, 6098, 6138, |
| 6143, 6144, 6150, 6151, 6152, 6155, 6156, |
| 6159, 6162, 6163, 6167, 6168, 6190, 6193, |
| 6194, 6239, 6242, 6258, 6734, 6873, 6874, |
| 6887, 6888, 6889, 6897, 6898, 6899, 6971, |
| 6974, 6977, 6985, 7082, 7089, 7092, 7197, |
| 7198 of 2021, 122, 1343, 1420, 1424, 1434, |
| 1507,1508 of 2022, 6963 & 11559 of 2024. |
Date of decision : 13.11.2024.
State of H.P. & others ….Respondents
State of H.P. & others ….Respondents
State of H.P. & others ….Respondents
2024:HHC:11319
| Anita Kumari | ...Petitioner. | |
|---|---|---|
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 5. | CWP No. 5308 of 2021 Mast Ram |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 6. | CWP No. 5309 of 2021 Leshlee Malhotra |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 7. | CWP No. 5310 of 2021 Umesh Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 8. | CWP No. 5313 of 2021 Krishan Baldev |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 9. | CWP No. 5315 of 2021 Ram Kali |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 10. | CWP No. 5318 of 2021 Anita Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 11. | CWP No. 5322 of 2021 Mamta Thakur |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 12. | CWP No. 5352 of 2021 | |
|---|---|---|
| Poonam Sharma | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus |
||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 13. | CWP No. 5355 of 2021 Rajender Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus |
||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 14. | CWP No. 5359 of 2021 Narendra Anand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 15. | CWP No. 5361 of 2021 Anamika |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 16. | CWP No. 5369 of 2021 Bhagat Chand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 17. | CWP No. 5390 of 2021 Sanjeev Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 18. | CWP No. 5424 of 2021 Kuldeep Chand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 19. | CWP No. 5426 of 2021 | |
| Sapna |
...Petitioner. | |
| Versus |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
|---|---|---|
| 20. | CWP No. 5429 of 2021 Upasna Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 21. | CWP No. 5432 of 2021 | |
| Sushma Devi | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 22. | CWP No. 5435 of 2021 Sudesh Kumari Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 23. | CWP No. 5437 of 2021 Hirawati |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 24. | CWP No. 5438 of 2021 Rohit Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 25. | CWP No. 5440 of 2021 Virender Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 26. | CWP No. 5441 of 2021 | |
| Meena Sharma | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 27. | CWP No. 5444 of 2021 | |
| Daisy Reeta | ...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| Versus | ||
|---|---|---|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 28. | CWP No. 5445 of 2021 | |
| Desh Raj | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 29. | CWP No. 5447 of 2021 Kanchan Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 30. | CWP No. 5455 of 2021 Anuja Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 31. | CWP No. 5456 of 2021 Bharti Nayyar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 32. | CWP No. 5458 of 2021 Harjinder Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 33. | CWP No. 5463 of 2021 Bharti Chauhan |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 34. | CWP No. 5476 of 2021 Rakesh Puri |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 35. | CWP No. 5477 of 2021 | |
|---|---|---|
| Yog Raj Dhiman | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 36. | CWP No. 5478 of 2021 Abha Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 37. | CWP No. 5482 of 2021 Surender Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 38. | CWP No. 5483 of 2021 Rakesh Kumar Katna |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 39. | CWP No. 5486 of 2021 Anup Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 40. | CWP No. 5487 of 2021 Dev Raj |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 41. | CWP No. 5506 of 2021 Kamla Devi |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 42. | CWP No. 5510 of 2021 Minu Sharma Versus |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
|---|---|---|
| 43. | CWP No. 5520 of 2021 Vinod Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 44. | CWP No. 5522 of 2021 Kiran Bhanot |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 45. | CWP No. 5530 of 2021 Kaushalya |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 46. | CWP No. 5532 of 2021 Ringchen Mendup |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 47. | CWP No. 5533 of 2021 Vijay Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 48. | CWP No. 5534 of 2021 | |
| Salochna | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 49. | CWP No. 5535 of 2021 | |
| Karuna Devi | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 50. | CWP No. 5540 of 2021 | |
| Pramod Chauhan | ...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| Versus | ||
|---|---|---|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 51. | CWP No. 5547 of 2021 Alka Rana |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 52. | CWP No. 5550 of 2021 Balak Ram |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 53. | CWP No. 5552 of 2021 Vijay Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 54. | CWP No. 5559 of 2021 Rakesh Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 55. | CWP No. 5561 of 2021 Satya Prakash |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 56. | CWP No. 5563 of 2021 Pankaj Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 57. | CWP No. 5574 of 2021 Sudiksha Gaur |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 58. | CWP No. 5577 of 2021 | |
|---|---|---|
| Ashok Kumar | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 59. | CWP No. 5579 of 2021 Bimla Devi |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 60. | CWP No. 5582 of 2021 Chaman Lal Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 61. | CWP No. 5588 of 2021 Sunil Mandla |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 62. | CWP No. 5589 of 2021 Anjana Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 63. | CWP No. 5609 of 2021 Pramod Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 64. | CWP No. 5613 of 2021 | |
| Prem Gupta | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 65. | CWP No. 5616 of 2021 Dr. Desh Raj |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
|---|---|---|
| 66. | CWP No. 5619 of 2021 Jaswant Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 67. | CWP No. 5634 of 2021 Dharma Nand Shukla |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 68. | CWP No. 5640 of 2021 Urvashi Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 69. | CWP No. 5658 of 2021 Bandna Bizalwan |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 70. | CWP No. 5660 of 2021 Babita Puri |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 71. | CWP No. 5664 of 2021 Sumer Chand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 72. | CWP No. 5667 of 2021 | |
| Rama Mehta | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 73. | CWP No. 5700 of 2021 Nitu Pathania |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| Versus | ||
|---|---|---|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 74. | CWP No. 5713 of 2021 Raj Kumar Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 75. | CWP No. 5734 of 2021 Sangeeta |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 76. | CWP No. 5788 of 2021 Dheeraj Kapoor |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 77. | CWP No. 5792 of 2021 Santosh Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 78. | CWP No. 5864 of 2021 Tara Thakur |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 79. | CWP No. 5868 of 2021 Versha Rani |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 80. | CWP No. 5869 of 2021 Nisha Devi |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 81. | CWP No. 5872 of 2021 | |
|---|---|---|
| Hem Sharan | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 82. | CWP No. 5883 of 2021 Jeewan Dass |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 83. | CWP No. 5938 of 2021 Sunder Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 84. | CWP No. 6006 of 2021 Parveen Kumari Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 85. | CWP No. 6013 of 2021 Naresh Bhadwaj |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 86. | CWP No. 6015 of 2021 Leela Dhar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 87. | CWP No. 6044 of 2021 Neelam Gupta |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 88. | CWP No. 6077 of 2021 | |
| Santosh Kumari Versus |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
|---|---|---|
| 89. | CWP No. 6081 of 2021 Rita Saini |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 90. | CWP No. 6090 of 2021 Usha Devi |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 91. | CWP No. 6094 of 2021 Parveen Chambiyal |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 92. | CWP No. 6095 of 2021 Madan Lal Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 93. | CWP No. 6098 of 2021 Pushpa Chandel |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 94. | CWP No. 6138 of 2021 Suresh Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 95. | CWP No. 6143 of 2021 Meena Verma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 96. | CWP No. 6144 of 2021 Ved Ram |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| Versus | ||
|---|---|---|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 97. | CWP No. 6150 of 2021 | |
| Satpal | ...Petitioner. | |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 98. | CWP No. 6151 of 2021 Deep Prakash |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 99. | CWP No. 6152 of 2021 Tulsi Ram |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 100. | CWP No. 6155 of 2021 Ushal Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 101. | CWP No. 6156 of 2021 Praveen Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 102. | CWP No. 6159 of 2021 Mati Dhar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents | |
| 103. | CWP No. 6162 of 2021 Anita Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | ||
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 104. CWP No. 6163 of 2021 Navneet Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
|---|---|
| Versus |
|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 105. CWP No. 6167 of 2021 Pawan Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 106. CWP No. 6168 of 2021 Rajinder Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 107. CWP No. 6190 of 2021 Gurmeet Kaur |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 108. CWP No. 6193 of 2021 Manohar Lal |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 109. CWP No. 6194 of 2021 Nisha Jhalta |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 110. CWP No. 6239 of 2021 | |
| Priyambda | ...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 111. CWP No. 6242 of 2021 Chhayanand Sharma Versus |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
|---|---|
| 112. CWP No. 6258 of 2021 Chetna Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 113. CWP No. 6734 of 2021 Ravinder Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 114. CWP No. 6873 of 2021 Ashwani Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 115. CWP No. 6874 of 2021 Brij Bala |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 116. CWP No. 6887 of 2021 Madan Lal |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 117. CWP No. 6888 of 2021 Sonu Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 118. CWP No. 6889 of 2021 Renu Malhotra |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 119. CWP No. 6897 of 2021 Raman Kanta |
...Petitioner. |
2024:HHC:11319
| Versus | |
|---|---|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 120. CWP No. 6898 of 2021 Sanjeevan Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 121. CWP No. 6899 of 2021 Sonal Thakur |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 122. CWP No. 6971 of 2021 Bharti Indu |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 123. CWP No. 6974 of 2021 Rakesh Chand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 124. CWP No. 6977 of 2021 Budhi Chand |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 125. CWP No. 6985 of 2021 Kuldeep Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 126. CWP No. 7082 of 2021 Sunila Rani |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
2024:HHC:11319
| 127. CWP No. 7089 of 2021 Sunita Chauhan |
...Petitioner. |
|---|---|
| Versus |
|
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 128. CWP No. 7092 of 2021 Ramesh Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 129. CWP No. 7197 of 2021 Gayatri Gupta |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 130. CWP No. 7198 of 2021 Savita Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 131. CWP No. 122 of 2022 Manju Madan |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 132. CWP No. 1343 of 2022 Girdhari Lal |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 133. CWP No. 1420 of 2022 Shanti Devi |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 134. CWP No. 1424 of 2022 | |
| Sunil Kumar | ...Petitioner. |
| Versus |
2024:HHC:11319
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
|---|---|
| 135. CWP No. 1434 of 2022 Lakshmi Sharma |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 136. CWP No. 1507 of 2022 Meena Kumari |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 137. CWP No. 1508 of 2022 Sudershan Singh |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 138. CWP No. 6963 of 2024 Chander Mohan Bragta |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
| 139. CWP No. 11559 of 2024 Pawan Kumar |
...Petitioner. |
| Versus | |
| State of H.P. & others |
….Respondents |
Coram:
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Tarlok Singh Chauhan, Acting Chief Justice.
The Hon’ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?1 No For the petitioner(s) : Mr. J.L.Bhardwaj, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sanjay Bhardwaj, Advocates, for the petitioner(s) in CWP Nos.5582, 6138, 6090, 5869, 5390, 5310, 5309,5535, 5640, 5634,
1 Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
2024:HHC:11319
5369, 5308, 5532, 5540, 6190 of 2021 and CWP No.6963 of 2024.
Mr. Dewa Nand, for the petitioner(s) in all the petitions except CWP Nos.5582, 6138, 6090, 5869, 5390, 5310, 5309,5535, 5640, 5634, 5369, 5308, 5532, 5540, 5616, 6190 of 2021, 6963 & 11559 of 2024.
Mr. Pradeep Kumar Sharma, Advocate, for the petitioner in CWP No.5616 of 2021.
Mr. Shivom Vashista, Advocate, for the petitioner in LPA No.370 of 2024 & CWP No.11559 of 2024.
For the respondents : Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr.Rakesh Dhault, Mr. Gobind Korla, Mr.Sushant Kaprate, Additional Advocates General, Ms.Priyanka Chauhan, Mr.Arsh Rattan and Mr. Sidharth Jalta, Deputy Advocates General, for the respondents-State.
Satyen Vaidya, Judge: (Oral)
Heard.
2024:HHC:11319
(Tarlok Singh Chauhan) Acting Chief Justice
(Satyen Vaidya) 13th November, 2024 Judge (vt)
1 issue framed by the court
Whether contractual service of the appellants/petitioners is liable to be considered for grant of benefit of annual increments?
Colour shows how this judgement treated each authority
Narayan Dutt Sharma vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & othersRelied on
LPA No.338 of 2024, Narayan Dutt Sharma vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & others
Daulat Ram & others
Manju Sharma
Sudesh Kumari
State of H.P.
Tarlok Singh Chauhan
Satyen Vaidya
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
