Writ petition dismissed as withdrawn by the petitioners. Liberty granted to file a fresh petition if advised.
Liberty granted to file a fresh petition if so advised.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC020000172024
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH
Case No. : WP(C)/3/2024
SHRI NIWOTO H. CHOPHY AND 83 ORS S/O LATE HEVIQHE CHOPHY R/O UNB-B, BURMA CAMP, DIMAPUR NAGALAND
2: JAGDISH SAHA S/O SITA RAM SAHA R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
3: MD. ZAKIR HUSSAIN S/O ABDUL QADIR R/O H/NO. 279 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
4: MD. NIZAM UDDIN S/O TAJAJJUL ALI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
5: JABED AKTER S/O LT. HARRIS UDDIN R/O H/NO. 43 ZELIANGRONG VILLAGE DIMAPUR NAGALAND
6: DADA ALI HALDER S/O LT. KOBAD ALI HALDER R/O H/NO. 738 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
7: ANIL HAQUE S/O YOUNUS ALI
Page No.# 2/11
R/O H/NO 3461 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 8: SHAHID UDDIN S/O LT MOYNAMIA R/O H.NO. 409 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 9: JANAL AHMED S/O LT. HARICH UDDIN R/O H.NO. 26-D NEW MARKET DUMAPUR NAGALAND 10: AINUL HOQUE S/O ENUS MIA R/O H.NO. 396 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 11: DURGA THAKUR S/O BHOLA THAKUR R/O H.NO. 341 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 12: ABDUL HAFIZ S/O HAZI ABDUL BAIS R/O H.NO. 40 T ZHIMO COLONY SIGNAL BASTI DIMAPUR NAGALAND
13: MUJIBUR RAHMAN CHOUDHURY S/O JAMALUDDIN CHOUDHURY R/O H.NO. L3 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
14: GULZAR HUSSAIN S/O LT. NAZRUL ISLAM R/O H.NO U-2 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
15: CHANDESHWAR PRASAD
Page No.# 3/11
S/O SUBEDARI SATI R/O H.NO. 20 MIDLAND COLONY DI9MAPUR NAGALAND 16: NURUL HUDA S/O BASIR AHMED R/O H.NO. 06 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 17: BINAY KUMAR GUPTA S/O LAXMAN PRASAD R/O H.NO. 108 MIDLAND DIMAPUR NAGALAND 18: JASHIM UDDIN S/O SUBIBUB RAHMAN R/O H.NO. 153 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 19: RAVI SHANKAR S/O DASHRATHSAH R/O H.NO. 79 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
20: SHIHAB UDDIN S/O ABDUS SAMAD R/O H.NO. 84 D ZAKEISATO COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND 21: RAUSHAN KUMAR S/O PRAKASH KUMAR R/OH.NO. 2 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
22: DILIP DAS S/O S.K. DAS R/O H.NO. 314 SIGNAL BASTI DIMAPUR NAGALAND 23: MD. BILAL UDDIN S/O LT. MD. WAKIB ALI
Page No.# 4/11
R/O H.NO. 104 CITY TOWER DIMAPUR NAGALAND 24: AZIR UDDIN S/O FORJAN ALI R/O H.NO. 220 BEHIND BREEZE RASTAURANT DIMAPUR NAGALAND 25: ANWAR HUSSAIN S/O MOIN UDDIN ALI R/O H.NO. 374 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 26: MD. EBADUR RAHMAN S/O LT. SAMED ALI R/O H.NO. 412 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 27: MD. LUBAD UDDIN S/O LT. KUTUB ALI R/O H.NO. 399 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 28: MD. MOINIL HAQUE S/O LT. SAMSUDDIN R/O H.NO. 23 ZELIANGRONG VILLAGE DIMAPUR NAGALAND 29: BADRUL ISLAM S/O ABDUL NOOR R/O H.NO. 7 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 30: ANIL YADAV S/O LT. SURRENDER YADAV R/O H.NO. 110 MIDLAND COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND
31: TAHIR AHMED S/O ABDUL HAMID
Page No.# 5/11
R/O H.NO. 132 RIO COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND 32: NAZRUL HOQUE S/O LT. SAMS UDDIN R/O H.NO. 32 MASJUID ROAD NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 33: SIDDIWUE ALI R/O H.NO. 186 NEAR BREEZE RASTAURANT CHUCH ROAD DIMAPUR NAGALAND 34: ASRAFUL ALAM S/O ABDUL MAZID R/O H.NO. 28 C NST COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND 35: JAMAL AHMED CHOUDHARY S/O MUSLIM UDDIN CHOUDHARY R/O H.NO. 392 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 36: MD. NURUL HOQUE S/O LT. ABDUL HOQUE R/O H.NO 01/19 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 37: RAJ KUMAR JAYSWAL S/O KISHORI PRASAD JAYSWAL R/O H.NO. 38 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 38: MONIKA PAUL D/O BHIM PAUL R/O H.NO 43 KHERMAHAL DIMAPUR NAGALAND
39: AJIT PAL
Page No.# 6/11
S/O TAPAN PAL R/O H.NO. 300 NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 40: PRAMOD BHOWMICK S/O BRAJALAL BHOWMICK R/O H.NO. 158 WEST YARD COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND 41: BAIJU PRASAD S/OM LT. RAJA RAM PRASAD R/O H.NO. LHOMITHI COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND
42: SANTOSH PRASAD S/O DWARIKA PRASAD R/O H.NO. 76 ZELIANGRONG COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND
43: VINAY THAKUR S/O LT SANKAR THAKUR R/O H.NO. 318 LHOMITHI COLONY DIMAPUR NAGALAND
44: SANU KUMAR S/O JAI KUMAR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
45: LAXMAN SHAH S.O ROBIN SHAH R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
46: MUNNI S/O MD.ALI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
47: D. ALI
S/O ANWAR HUSSAIN R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
Page No.# 7/11
48: MANNI S/O MD. MOHAMMAD R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND 49: JAINAL ABEDIN S/O ALI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
50: M RAHMAN CHAUDHURY S/O AKASH CHAUDHURY R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
51: ALAM S/O HABIJUR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
52: AJIT S/O JAI PRASAD R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
53: SHIHOTO CHOPHY S/O ABOTO R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
54: BINDESHWARI YADEV S/O RAMESH YADEV R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
55: SHRI MAZAMMIL ALI S/O HAIDER ALI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
56: CHOTTILAL PRASAD S/O YADEV PRASAD R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
57: RAI JI S/O ASHOK R/O NEW MARKET
Page No.# 8/11
DIMAPUR NAGALAND
58: SANDHYA S/O SUBHASH R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
59: CHIRANJIT S/O KAPHIL R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
60: RAM DERIS RAI S/O AMIT RAI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
61: IRFAN ALI S/O KAMAL ALI R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
62: RAJU S/O RAJ R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
63: ALTAB DEWAN S/O HUMASH R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
64: AJIT PAL S/O SUDIP PAL R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
65: SANJAY MISHRA S/O HEMASH MISHRA R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
66: RABINDRA THAKUR S/O RAHIM THAKUR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
67: SAMSUL HAQUE
Page No.# 9/11
S/O SAKHIR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
68: ABDUL ITAFIR S/O YAMBA ITAFIR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
69: M. RAHMAN CHY S/O KABIR CHY R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
70: MD. ZAKIR HUSSNI S/O MOSOR HUSSIN R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
71: JAINAL AHEDIN S/O ALI AHMED R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
72: NIRANJAN KUMAR S/O MANI KUMAR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
73: ROHIT PRASAD S/O ARUN PASAD R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
74: DEVI D/O SUMAN R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
75: SAIDULLA S/O AMARTULLA R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
76: AHADUR RAHMAN S/O JAKUR HUSSAIN R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
Page No.# 10/11
77: NAJRUL ISLAM S/O LT NAZIM R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
78: RAMESH S/O LT UMESH KUMAR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
79: SHOIPUE ISLAM S/O BAHARUL R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
80: VINESH S/O LAL DAS R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
81: AFTHAR S/O MOZUBUR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
82: N ISLAM S/O FAQUR R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
83: SALMAN S/O RAHMAN R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAND
84: MUNI S/O BIRBAL R/O NEW MARKET DIMAPUR NAGALAN
VERSUS
THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 3 ORS REPRESENTED BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND KOHIMA NAGALAND
2:THE JOINT SECRETARY
Page No.# 11/11
MUNICIPAL AFFAIRS DEPT. KOHIMA NAGALAND
3:THE ADMINISTRATOR DIMAPUR MUNICIPAL COUNCIL DIMAPUR NAGALAND
4:THE SUB-DIVISIONAL OFICER DIMAPUR MUNICIPAL COUNCIL DIMAPUR NAGALAN
Advocate for the Petitioner : P SURIEN
Advocate for the Respondent : GOVT ADV NL
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NELSON SAILO
ORDER
08.02.2024
Mr. Pakinrichapbo, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that since the rival parties are attempting out of Court settlement he has instructions to withdraw this writ petition. He further submits that liberty may be granted for filing a fresh petition if so advised.
Mr. N. Angami, learned Senior Government Advocate has no objection to the prayer.
In view of above, writ petition stands dismissed as withdrawn. However, liberty is granted to file afresh, if so advised.
Sd/-
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
SHRI NIWOTO H. CHOPHY AND 83 ORS
THE STATE OF NAGALAND AND 3 ORS
NELSON SAILO
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
