This order permits the withdrawal of an interlocutory application filed by the applicants. The court grants liberty to the applicants to file a fresh application if legally advised.
Application permitted to be withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh application if so advised.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/24
GAHC040008992023
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) (ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : IA(C)/119/2023
Antosha Tindya and 37 Ors. S/o Shri Babumso Tindya, R/o Village Loiliang, PO/PS Tezu, Lohit District, AP 2: Gunemso Tindya Age: Occupation :
3: Babumso Tindya Age: Occupation :
4: Mantila Tindya Age: Occupation :
5: Goiso Tindya Age: Occupation :
6: Juniso Tindya Age: Occupation :
7: Sose Tindya Age: Occupation :
8: Sonkhraaainlum
Page No.# 2/24
Age: Occupation :
9: Sopanso Tindya Age: Occupation :
10: Shantiso Tindya Age: Occupation :
11: Basilum Tamai Age: Occupation :
12: Prasanso Tamai Age: Occupation :
13: Bawhilum Tamai Age: Occupation :
14: Brami Tamai Age: Occupation :
15: Junratso Tamai Age: Occupation :
16: Teso Tamai Age: Occupation :
17: Kedenso Tamai Age: Occupation :
Page No.# 3/24
18: Gangaram Kathak Age: Occupation :
19: Sahaing Kathak Age: Occupation :
20: Pikalum Kathak Age: Occupation :
21: Bathamso Kathak Age: Occupation :
22: Badamso Kathak Age: Occupation :
23: Chazalum Kathak Age: Occupation :
24: Bazalum Kathak Age: Occupation : 25: Bafolum Kathak Age: Occupation :
26: Bagremso Kathak Age: Occupation : 27: Micky Kathak Age:
Page No.# 4/24
Occupation :
28: Bamki Kathak Age: Occupation :
29: Dangresha Kathak Age: Occupation :
30: Najamlum Kathak Age: Occupation :
31: Najamlum Kathak Age: Occupation :
32: Bawe Tayang Age: Occupation :
33: Thorolum Tayang Age: Occupation :
34: Tholangsa Tayang Age: Occupation :
35: Bachaklum Tayang Age: Occupation :
36: Thalelum Tayang Age: Occupation :
Page No.# 5/24
37: Novem Tayang Age: Occupation :
38: Mojimsai Yun Age: Occupation
VERSUS
THE STATE OF AP and 27 Ors. Represented by the Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Civil Secretariat, Itanagar, PS and PO Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh 791111 2:the Secretary (Land Management) Age: 0 Occupation :
3:the Director (Land Management) Age: 0 Occupation :
4:the Deputy Commissioner Age: 0 Occupation :
5:Bisaiso Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation :
6:Sojangso Yun Age: 0 Occupation :
7:Vikhelum Bellai Age: 0 Occupation :
8:Bathalum Yun Age: 0 Occupation :
Page No.# 6/24
9:Lobiso Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation :
10:Moso Chiba Age: 0 Occupation :
11:Behemso Tayang Age: 0 Occupation :
12:Santilu Nilang Age: 0 Occupation :
13:Soplai Tayang Age: 0 Occupation :
14:Khodelum Tayang Age: 0 Occupation :
15:Thayem Mepo Age: 0 Occupation :
16:Solo Musu/Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation :
17:Sutik Krisikro Age: 0 Occupation :
18:Bakhrim Chikro Age: 0
Page No.# 7/24
Occupation :
19:Chojum Boo Age: 0 Occupation : 20:Bayenso Drai Age: 0 Occupation : 21:Batu Kathak Age: 0 Occupation : 22:Bafringlu Tai Age: 0 Occupation : 23:Basalum Boo Age: 0 Occupation : 24:Bakli Drai Age: 0 Occupation : 25:Nilalum Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : 26:Khogen Boo Age: 0 Occupation : 27:Soti Tayang Age: 0 Occupation :
Page No.# 8/24
28:the Commandant Age: 0 Occupation
Advocate for the Petitioner : Sunil Mow
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP)
Linked Case : WP(C)/252/2022
Antosha Tindya and 37 Ors. Age: 29 Occupation : Address:S/o Shri Babumso Tindya Resident of Village Loilang PO/PS Tezu DIst Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 2: Gunemso Tindya Age: 43 Occupation : Address:S/o Babumso Tindya Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 3: Babumso Tindiya Age: 65 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. N. Tindya Resident of Village Loiliang
Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 4: Mantila Tindya Age: 65 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. B. Tindya
Page No.# 9/24
Resident of Village Tafragram
PO/PS Tezu Dist Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
5: Goiso Tindya Age: 47 Occupation : Address:S/o Mantila Tindya
Resident of Village Tafragram
PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
6: Juniso Tindya Age: 32 Occupation : Address:S/o Mantila Tindya
Resident of Village Tafragram
PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
7: Sose Tindya Age: 59 Occupation : Address:S/o Balakhi Tindya
Resident of Village Bekhuliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 8: Sonkhraainlum Age: 59 Occupation : Address:S/o Mabralum Tindya
Resident of Village Bekhuliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
Page No.# 10/24
9: Sopanso Tindya Age: 60 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Tindya
Resident of Village Chagliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 10: Shantiso Tindya Age: 60 Occupation : Address:S/o Sopanso Tindya Resident of Village Changliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 11: Basilum Tamai Age: 48 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Thaolum Tamai Resident of Village Loilliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
12: Prasanso Tamai Age: 27 Occupation : Address:S/o Basilum Tamai Resident of Village Loilliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
13: Bawhilum Tamai Age: 41 Occupation : Address:S/o Deyalum Tamai
Resident of Villlage Loilliang PO/PS Tezu
Page No.# 11/24
Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 14: Brami Tamai Age: 33 Occupation : Address:S/o Deyalum Tamai Resident of Village Loilliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 15: Junratso Tamai Age: 34 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Deyalum Tamai Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 16: Teso Tamai Age: 67 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Kapolung Tamai Resident of Villlage Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 17: Kedenso Tamai Age: 35 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Deyalum Tamai Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 18: Gangaram Kathak Age: 48 Occupation : Address:S/o Sokhelum Kathak
Page No.# 12/24
Resident of Village Loilang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 19: Sahaing Kathak Age: 58 Occupation : Address:S/o Sokhelum Kathak Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 20: Pikalum Kathak Age: 49 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Karampom Kathak Resident of Village Mekailiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 21: Bathamso Kathak Age: 58 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Garampom Kathak Resident of Village Makailiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 22: Badamso Kathak Age: 36 Occupation : Address:S/o Garampom Kathak Resident of Villlage Mekailiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 23: Chazalum Kathak Age: 37 Occupation :
Page No.# 13/24
Address:S/o Lt. Garampom Kathak Resident of Village Mekailang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 24: Bazalum Kathak Age: 36 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Pehenlum Kathak Resident of Village Railiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 25: Bafolum Kathak Age: 33 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Pehelum Kathak Resident of Village Railiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 26: Bagremso Kathak Age: 37 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Pehenlum Kathak Resident of Village Pohayuliang PO/PS Khupa Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 27: Micky Kathak Age: 30 Occupation : Address:S/o Thawelum Kathak Resident of Village Railiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 28: Bamki Kathak
Page No.# 14/24
Age: 32 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Matanglum Kathak Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 29: Dangresha Kathak Age: 47 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Thanu Kathak Resident of Village Railiang PO Hayuliang PS Khupa Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 30: Najamlum Kathak Age: 39 Occupation : Address:S/o Sokhekum Kathak Resident of Village Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 31: Bawe Tayang Age: 54 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. T. Tayang Resident of Village Tafragram
PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 32: Thorolum Tayang Age: 38 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Brapamso Tayang
Resident of Village Tafragram PO/PS Tezu
Page No.# 15/24
Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 33: Tholongsa Tayang Age: 47 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. S. Tayang Resident of Village Tafragram PO/PS Tezu. Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh.
34: Premanso Tayang Age: 38 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. B. Tayang Resident of Village Tafragram PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 35: Bachaklum Tayang Age: 36 Occupation : Address:LT. C. Tayang Resident of Village Tafragram PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 36: Thalelum Tayang Age: 33 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. S. Tayang Resident of Village Tafragram PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 37: Novem Tayang Age: 36 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. S. Tayang
Page No.# 16/24
Resident of Village Tafragram
PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. 38: Mojimsai Yun Age: 45 Occupation : Address:W/o Lt. S. Yun Resident Village of Huchuliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh. VERSUS THE STATE OF AP and 26 Ors. Age: 0 Occupation : Address:Represented by the Chief Secretary to the Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Civil Secretariat Itanagar PS and PO Itanagar Arunachal Pradesh 791111 2:The Secretary Age: 0 Occupation : Address:(Land Management) Department of Land Management Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh Itanagar PO and PS Itanagar Arunachal Pradesh PIN 791111 3:The Director Age: 0 Occupation : Address:of Land Management Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh ESS Sector Itanagar Arunachal Pradesh PIN 791111
4:The Deputy Commissioner
Page No.# 17/24
Age: 0 Occupation : Address:Tezu PO and PS Tezu Lohit District Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001
5:Bisaiso Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Sotha Chaitom Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh Pin 792001
6:Sojangso Yun Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Sokosu Yun. Vill Loiiang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 7:Vikhelum Bellai Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. L. Bellai PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh Pin 792001
8:Bathamlu Yun Age: 0 Occupation : Address:W/o Lt. Sokai Yun Vill. Loiliang PO/PS Tezu
Page No.# 18/24
Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh Pin 792001
9:Lobiso Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Kayam Chaitom Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 10:Moso Chiba Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Thakjum Chiba Vill Rock Line PO/PS Tezu Town Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 11:Behemso Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Soti Tayang Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 12:Santilu Nilang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:W/o Sambu Chai Vill. Chai Colony PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001
Page No.# 19/24
13:Soplai Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. C Tayang Vill Tafaragam Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 14:Khodelum Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. B. Tayang Vill. Tafragam PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 15:Thayem Mepo Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Kanupin Mepo Vill. Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001
16:Solo Musu/Chaitom Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Saloku Musu Vill Yealing PO/PS Sunpura Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 17:Sutik Krisikro Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Mayapso Krisikro
Vill. Telluliang
Page No.# 20/24
PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 18:Bakhrim Chikro Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. T. Chikro Vill 19th Mile PO/PS Sunpura Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 19:Chojum Boo Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Barum Boo Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 20:Bayengso Drai Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. S. Drai Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 21:Batu Kathak Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. B. Kathak Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001
Page No.# 21/24
22:Bafringlu Tai Age: 0 Occupation : Address:W/o Bomju Tai Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001
23:Basalum Boo Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Yualum Boo Vill. Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 24:Bakli Drai Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Bachong Drai Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 25:Nilalum Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Klelum Tayang Vill Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 26:Khogen Boo Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. Sogen Boo
Page No.# 22/24
Vill. Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 27:Soti Tayang Age: 0 Occupation : Address:S/o Lt. G. Tayang Vill. Loiliang PO/PS Tezu Dist. Lohit Arunachal Pradesh PIN 792001 -----------Advocate for : Sunil Mow Advocate for : GA (AP) appearing for THE STATE OF AP and 26 Ors.: Advocate ,
, , , , , ,
,
Page No.# 23/24
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
, appearing for 2,
3,
4,
5,
6,
7,
8,
9,
10,
11,
12,
13, 14,
15,
Page No.# 24/24
16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, respectively.
BEFORE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE NANI TAGIA
ORDER
Date : 10.07.2023
As prayed for by Ms. K. N. Maling, learned counsel for the applicants; this interlocutory application is permitted to be withdrawn with liberty granted to the applicants to file a fresh application, if so advised.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
Antosha Tindya and 37 Ors.
The State of AP and 27 Ors.
NANI TAGIA
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
