Single line order closing Interlocutory Appeal No. 880/2023 in consequence of an order passed in the main case CRP(IO)/93/2023.
Closed the Interlocutory Appeal No. 880/2023.
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010068672023
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP(IO)/93/2023
NEERUJ CHOUDHURY
W/O DR. ASWINI KUMAR CHOUDHURY, D/O LATE BOLINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH,
R/O TRANS ELITE, APT 2A, LAMB ROAD, UZAN BAZAR, GUWAHATI, ASSAM, PIN- 781001.
ALSO ARESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO, P.O.- NORTH GUWAHATI, P.S.- NORTH GUWAHATI, DIST.- KAMRUP, ASSAM, PIN- 781030.
VERSUS
NILIMA BAROOAH AND 39 ORS. WIFE OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH,
2:KUMARIKA BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
7:RUMI BARUAH
WIFE OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
8:DR. PRAJJALENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
Page No.# 2/15
SON OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
9:KRISHNENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH SON OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH
RESPONDENT NO- 1 TO 9 ARE THE RESIDENTS OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030. 10:DIPA DAIMARI WIFE OF MUKUL DAIMARI RESIDENT OF ABHAYAPUR POLICE STATION- KAMALPUR DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM. 11:DALIMI PATHAK WIFE OF PRADIP PATHAK RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI (KATABAZAR) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781031. 12:PAREN GAYARI SON OF GIRIN GAYARI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-KATABAZAR POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781031. 13:DAISY DAS WIFE OF RATUL MAHANTA DAUGHTER OF LATE KISHORI PRASAD DAS RESIDENT OF JALUKBARI G.U CAMPUS QTR NO- 65(B) GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781014
Page No.# 3/15
14:DIPALI RAMCHIARI WIFE OF LATE ASHOK RAMCHIARI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- NORTH GUWAHATI (KATABAZAR) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI IN THE DISTRICT OF KAMRUP ASSAM
15:KUSUM BALINDRA CHINTABATI TRUST
REPRESENTED BY DR. PRAJJALENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH AND OTHERS RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030
16:ROYAL ENTERPRISES REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNER NAMELY SRI BASANT KUMAR JAIN SON OF LATE BABOO LAL JAIN AND SMTI SWATI JASRASARIA WIFE OF SRI GIREESH JASRASARRIA HAVING OFFICE AT B.R. ARCADE 21 JANAPATH LANE ULUBARI GUWAHATI KAMRUP (M) ASSAM.
17:ROHIT KUMAR MORE SON OF LATE OM PRAKASH MORE RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 6 PRERNA CHOWKIDINGHEE POST OFFICE- C.R BUILDING POLICE STATION- DIBRUGARH ASSAM PIN- 786003
18:PRITHVI RAJ JAIN SON OF AJAY KUMAR JAIN RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 118 M.G ROAD NEAR AXIS BANK POST OFFICE AND POLICE STATION- FANCY BAZAR GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN- 781001
Page No.# 4/15
19:VIKASH AGARWAL SON OF SRI MOHANLAL AGARWAL RESIDENT OF 15 DIPTI COMMERCIAL COMPLEX OPPOSITE POLICE RESERCE A.T ROAD POST OFFICE PANBAZAR GUWAHATI- PIN- 781001 20:SANDEEP KUMAR VERMA SON OF SRI VINOD KUMAR VERMA RESIDENT OF JHNWAR ROAD NAYA BASS SUJANGARH CHURU RAJASTHAN PIN- 331507 21:MANISH AGARWAL SON OF SRI SUSHIL AGARWAL RESIDENT OF ASSAM RIFLES BAZAR MAWSHBUTT EAST KHASI HILLS HAPPY VALLEY MEGHALAYA PIN- 793007 22:AJAY KUMAR JAIN SON OF SRI RATAN LAL JAIN RESIDENT OF H. RYMBAL COTTAGE LUMDIENGSOH LOWER MOTINAGAR NONGTHYMMAI SHILLONG PIN- 793014. 23:AMAN PASSARI SON OF SRI BASANT PASSARI RESIDENT OF CRPF NES IG OFFICE BISHOP COTTON ROAD NEAR SHILLONG MUNICIPAL OFFICE OAKLAND SHILLONG PIN- 793001 24:SHAMIT BANSAL SON OF SRI NIKHIL KUMAR BANSAL RESIDENT OF BARUN APARTMENTS LOWER MOTINAGAR
Page No.# 5/15
BEHIND PANTALOONS FIRE BRIGADE SHILLONG PIN- 793001 25:ANUJA SINGHANIA WIFE OF SRI NAREN SINGHANIA RESIDENT OF CARE OF R.G.S MANOR 069 LOWER LACHUMIERE OPPOSITE ADVOCATE S.P. MAHANTO SHILLONG G.P.O SHILLONG PIN- 793001 26:SHYAM SUNDER AGARWALA SON OF SRI SOHAN LAL AGARWALA RESIDENT OF ANJANEE AREA SHILLONG G.P.O SHILLONG PIN- 793001 27:SANGITA AGARWAL WIFE OF SRI RAKESH AGARWALA RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 39A FLAT NO- 2C PIYALI PHUKAN ROAD PUNNYAPRAVA APARTMENT ULUBARI GUWAHATI PIN- 781007
28:RABIRAM BORO SON OF LATE SANTI RAM BORO RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- RAHDHALA (MULUKHATOL) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI KAMRUP ASSAM- 781031
29:ALAKA KALITA WIFE OF NIRANJAN KALITA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- SIMLABARI POST OFFICE- NAYABASTI POLICE STATION- BARBARI BAKSA ASSAM
Page No.# 6/15
30:NISHANT AGARWAL SON OF JAGDISH PRASAD AGARWALA RESIDENT OF FLAT NO- 2-B 2ND FLOOR HAVELIA REGENCY A.K. DEB ROAD DHIRENPARA POST OFFICE AND POLICE STATION- FATASIL AMBARI GUWAHATI PIN- 781025 31:SOMAISHRI BASUMATARY DAUGHTER OF RABINDRA BRAHMA
32:MADAN BASUMATARY SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA
33:HEMEN BORO SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA
34:DHIRESWAR BORO
SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA
RESPONDENT NO- 31 TO 34 ARE THE RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- ABHOYPUR SILA SINDURI GHOPA NORTH GUWAHATI KAMRUP ASSAM
35:KRIPANJALI SAIKIA DAUGHTER OF LATE PANKAJ KUMARI SAIKIA RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI COLLEGE NAGAR DISTRICT-KAMRUP ASSAM
36:EESHANKUR SAIKIA SON OF LATE PANKAJ KUMARI SAIKIA RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI COLLEGE NAGAR DISTRICT-KAMRUP ASSAM
37:SAROJ BAROOAH
DAUGHTER OF LATE BOLINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF BENUDHAR RAJKHOWA PATH AMOLAPATTY RAILWAY GATE DIBRUGARH
Page No.# 7/15
PIN-786001
38:SANKAR MONI BORAH SON OF LATE SAILAJ BORAH RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 303 RANGMAHAL GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781030 39:BALLAV MONI BORAH SON OF LATE SAILAJ BORAH RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 303 RANGMAHAL GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781030 40:KANAUJ DUTTA HAZARIKA DAUGHTER OF LATE BALINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 26 MOUNTAIN PASS ROAD HOPEWELL JUNCTION NY-12533 US
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR R SENSUA
Advocate for the Respondent :
Linked Case : I.A.(Civil)/880/2023
NEERUJ CHOUDHURY WIFE OF DR. ASWINI KUMAR CHOUDHURY DAUGHTER OF LATE BOLINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF TRANS ELITE
Page No.# 8/15
APT 2A LAMB ROAD UZAN BAZAR GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN- 781001 ALSO A RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 VERSUS NILIMA BAROOAH AND 39 ORS. WIFE OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 2:KUMARIKA BAROOAH DAUGHTER OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 3:UTPALA BAROOAH DAUGHTER OF LATE RAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 4:CHAYANIKA BAROOAH DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM
Page No.# 9/15
PIN- 781030 5:MALA DAS BARUAH DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 6:SAGARIKA HAZARIKA DAUGHTER OF LATE ARABINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 7:RUMI BARUAH WIFE OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 8:DR. PRAJJALENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH SON OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 9:KRISHNENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH SON OF LATE BAJENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 10:DIPA DAIMARI WIFE OF MUKUL DAIMARI RESIDENT OF ABHAYAPUR POLICE STATION- KAMALPUR DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM 11:DALIMI PATHAK
Page No.# 10/15
WIFE OF PRADIP PATHAK RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI (KATABAZAR) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781031 12:PAREN GAYARI SON OF GIRIN GAYARI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE-KATABAZAR POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781031 13:DAISY DAS WIFE OF RATUL MAHANTA DAUGHTER OF LATE KISHORI PRASAD DAS RESIDENT OF JALUKBARI G.U CAMPUS QTR NO- 65(B) GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781014 14:DIPALI RAMCHIARI WIFE OF LATE ASHOK RAMCHIARI RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- NORTH GUWAHATI (KATABAZAR) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI IN THE DISTRICT OF KAMRUP ASSAM 15:KUSUM BALINDRA CHINTABATI TRUST REPRESENTED BY DR. PRAJJALENDRA KUMAR BAROOAH AND OTHERS RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 16:ROYAL ENTERPRISES REPRESENTED BY ITS PARTNER NAMELY SRI BASANT KUMAR JAIN SON OF LATE BABOO LAL JAIN AND SMTI SWATI JASRASARIA WIFE OF SRI GIREESH JASRASARRIA HAVING OFFICE AT B.R. ARCADE 21 JANAPATH LANE ULUBARI GUWAHATI
Page No.# 11/15
KAMRUP (M) ASSAM. 17:ROHIT KUMAR MORE SON OF LATE OM PRAKASH MORE RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 6 PRERNA CHOWKIDINGHEE POST OFFICE- C.R BUILDING POLICE STATION- DIBRUGARH ASSAM PIN- 786003 18:PRITHVI RAJ JAIN SON OF AJAY KUMAR JAIN RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 118 M.G ROAD NEAR AXIS BANK POST OFFICE AND POLICE STATION- FANCY BAZAR GUWAHATI ASSAM PIN- 781001 19:VIKASH AGARWAL SON OF SRI MOHANLAL AGARWAL RESIDENT OF 15 DIPTI COMMERCIAL COMPLEX OPPOSITE POLICE RESERCE A.T ROAD POST OFFICE PANBAZAR GUWAHATI- PIN- 781001 20:SANDEEP KUMAR VERMA SON OF SRI VINOD KUMAR VERMA RESIDENT OF JHNWAR ROAD NAYA BASS SUJANGARH CHURU RAJASTHAN PIN- 331507 21:MANISH AGARWAL SON OF SRI SUSHIL AGARWAL RESIDENT OF ASSAM RIFLES BAZAR MAWSHBUTT EAST KHASI HILLS HAPPY VALLEY MEGHALAYA PIN- 793007 22:AJAY KUMAR JAIN SON OF SRI RATAN LAL JAIN RESIDENT OF H. RYMBAL COTTAGE LUMDIENGSOH LOWER MOTINAGAR NONGTHYMMAI
Page No.# 12/15
SHILLONG PIN- 793014. 23:AMAN PASSARI SON OF SRI BASANT PASSARI RESIDENT OF CRPF NES IG OFFICE BISHOP COTTON ROAD NEAR SHILLONG MUNICIPAL OFFICE OAKLAND SHILLONG PIN- 793001 24:SHAMIT BANSAL SON OF SRI NIKHIL KUMAR BANSAL RESIDENT OF BARUN APARTMENTS LOWER MOTINAGAR BEHIND PANTALOONS FIRE BRIGADE SHILLONG PIN- 793001 25:ANUJA SINGHANIA WIFE OF SRI NAREN SINGHANIA RESIDENT OF CARE OF R.G.S MANOR 069 LOWER LACHUMIERE OPPOSITE ADVOCATE S.P. MAHANTO SHILLONG G.P.O SHILLONG PIN- 793001 26:SHYAM SUNDER AGARWALA SON OF SRI SOHAN LAL AGARWALA RESIDENT OF ANJANEE AREA SHILLONG G.P.O SHILLONG PIN- 793001 27:SMTI SANGITA AGARWAL WIFE OF SRI RAKESH AGARWALA RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 39A FLAT NO- 2C PIYALI PHUKAN ROAD PUNNYAPRAVA APARTMENT ULUBARI GUWAHATI PIN- 781007 28:RABIRAM BORO SON OF LATE SANTI RAM BORO RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- RAHDHALA (MULUKHATOL) POST OFFICE- COLLEGE NAGAR POLICE STATION- CHANGSARI KAMRUP
Page No.# 13/15
ASSAM- 781031 29:ALAKA KALITA WIFE OF NIRANJAN KALITA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- SIMLABARI POST OFFICE- NAYABASTI POLICE STATION- BARBARI BAKSA ASSAM 30:NISHANT AGARWAL SON OF JAGDISH PRASAD AGARWALA RESIDENT OF FLAT NO- 2-B 2ND FLOOR HAVELIA REGENCY A.K. DEB ROAD DHIRENPARA POST OFFICE AND POLICE STATION- FATASIL AMBARI GUWAHATI PIN- 781025 31:SMTI SOMAISHRI BASUMATARY DAUGHTER OF RABINDRA BRAHMA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- ABHOYPUR SILA SINDURI GHOPA NORTH GUWAHATI KAMRUP ASSAM 32:MADAN BASUMATARY SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- ABHOYPUR SILA SINDURI GHOPA NORTH GUWAHATI KAMRUP ASSAM 33:HEMEN BORO SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- ABHOYPUR SILA SINDURI GHOPA NORTH GUWAHATI KAMRUP ASSAM 34:DHIRESWAR BORO SON OF RABIRAM BRAHMA THE RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- ABHOYPUR SILA SINDURI GHOPA NORTH GUWAHATI KAMRUP ASSAM 35:KRIPANJALI SAIKIA DAUGHTER OF LATE PANKAJ KUMARI SAIKIA
Page No.# 14/15
RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI COLLEGE NAGAR DISTRICT-KAMRUP ASSAM 36:EESHANKUR SAIKIA SON OF LATE PANKAJ KUMARI SAIKIA RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI COLLEGE NAGAR DISTRICT-KAMRUP ASSAM 37:SAROJ BAROOAH DAUGHTER OF LATE BOLINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF BENUDHAR RAJKHOWA PATH AMOLAPATTY RAILWAY GATE DIBRUGARH PIN-786001 38:SANKAR MONI BORAH SON OF LATE SAILAJ BORAH RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 303 RANGMAHAL GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781030 39:BALLAV MONI BORAH SON OF LATE SAILAJ BORAH RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO- 303 RANGMAHAL GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP (M) ASSAM PIN- 781030 40:KANAUJ DUTTA HAZARIKA DAUGHTER OF LATE BALINDRA KUMAR BAROOAH RESIDENT OF RESIDENT OF NORTH GUWAHATI SILSAKO POST OFFICE- NORTH GUWAHATI POLICE STATION-NORTH GUWAHATI DISTRICT- KAMRUP ASSAM PIN- 781030 PRESENTLY RESIDING AT 26 MOUNTAIN PASS ROAD HOPEWELL JUNCTION NY-12533 USA -----------Advocate for : MR R SENSUA Advocate for : appearing for NILIMA BAROOAH AND 39 ORS.
Page No.# 15/15
BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K. SEMA
ORDER
Date : 21-04-2023
In view of order passed today in CRP(IO) No. 93/2023, the present I.A.(Civil) No. 880/2023 stands closed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
NEERUJ CHOUDHURY
NILIMA BAROOAH AND 39 ORS.
K. SEMA
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court
