Disposed

On the Death of Rashid Ahmed His Legal Heirs and Ors, v. State of Assam and 7 Ors.

Gauhati HC2 Aug 2023I.A.(Civil)/670/2023

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This order substitutes the legal representatives of Petitioner No. 1 who expired during the pendency of a writ petition concerning land acquisition compensation. The court impleads the family members as new petitioners and disposes of the application.

What did the court decide?

Petitioner No. 1 replaced by his legal heirs; the interlocutory application stands disposed.

On the Death of Rashid Ahmed His Legal Heirs and… — Succession and Inheritance | Gauhati HC (2023)

¶1

Page No.# 1/17

¶2

GAHC010019382023

¶3

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)

¶4

Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/670/2023

¶5

ON THE DEATH OF RASHID AHMED HIS LEGAL HEIRS and ORS, S/O SAFAR ALI, BAKRIHAWAR PART-I, PANCHGRAM-788802, DISTHAILAKANDI, ASSAM

¶6

1.1: MUSSTT NAZMUN NEHAR BEGUM W/O LATE MD. RASHID AHMED BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶7

1.2: MD. SAHIN AHMED

¶8

S/O LATE MD. RASHID AHMED BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶9

1.3: MD. JAHID AHMED

¶10

S/O LATE MD. RASHID AHMED BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM.

¶11

1.4: MD. MARUF AKTAR

¶12

S/O LATE MD. RASHID AHMED BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶13

Page No.# 2/17

¶14

1.5: MD. NUMAN AHMED S/O LATE MD. RASHID AHMED BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM 2: MD. ABDUL NOOR S/O SAFAR ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 3: MD. MUJIBUR RAHMAN S/O LATE MAHMOOD ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 4: MD. AZIR UDDIN S/O LATE ABDUL LATIF BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶15

5: MD. RABIZUL HAQUE

¶16

S/O LATE MAHMOOD ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶17

6: MD. ALI HUSSAIN S/O NURUZ ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶18

7: MUSSTT. RAZMA BEGUM W/O LATE ANWAR HUSSAIN

¶19

BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802

¶20

Page No.# 3/17

¶21

DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶22

8: MUSSTT. KULCHUMA BIBI

¶23

W/O LATE NEKRUL ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶24

9: MD. SURMAN ALI SHEK S/O LATE MAKRAM ALI SHEK BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶25

10: MD. JUNAB ALI

¶26

S/O LATE MASADDAR ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 11: MD. SAJIB UDDIN S/O LATE MORAI MIA BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶27

12: MD. ABDUL MANNAF S/O LATE MAKRAM ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶28

13: MD. SUKKUR ALI S/O LATE MAKRAM ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶29

14: MD. USMAN ALI

¶30

Page No.# 4/17

¶31

S/O LATE MAKRAM ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶32

15: MD. ABDUL MANNAN S/O LATE FITRAT ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶33

16: SHRI HARIBHUSAN ACHERJEE S/O HIRENDRA ACHARJEE BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶34

17: SHRI HARASUNDAR ACHARJEE S/O LATE HARENDRA ACHARJEE BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶35

18: SHRI HIRANMOY ACHARJEE S/O LATE HARENDRA ACHARJEE BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶36

19: SHRI BIJOY KANTI DAS S/O LATE BIRENDRA CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶37

20: SHRI SHYMAL CHANDRA DAS S/O LATE HIRENDRA CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶38

Page No.# 5/17

¶39

21: SHRI KARUNA DAS S/O LATE KIRTHIMONI DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 22: SHRI SUBHAS BHUIYAN S/O LATE SHIVNATH BHUIYAN BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶40

23: SHRI MADHUSUDAN DAS S/O LATE HARMOHAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 24: SHRI NISHI KANTA DAS S/O LATE HARAMOHAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶41

25: SHRI HARENDRA CHANDRA DAS S/O LATE HARMOHAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 26: SHRI MODHAN MOHAN DAS S/O LATE HARAMOHAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶42

27: SHRI BIRESH DAS

¶43

S/O LATE KRIPESH CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI

¶44

Page No.# 6/17

¶45

ASSAM

¶46

28: SHRI RANJIT DEY S/O LATE RADHAVALLAB DEY BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶47

29: MD. SHRI MANIK DAS

¶48

S/O LATE KUMUD DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶49

30: MD. MTURFAN ALI

¶50

S/O LATE LOYAI MIA BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶51

31: MD. RIYAZ ALI

¶52

S/O LATE AZFAR ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶53

32: SHRI RAMA KANTA DAS

¶54

S/O LATE RABINDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶55

33: SHRI SUJIT KUMAR DAS

¶56

S/O LATE SATYENDRA CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶57

Page No.# 7/17

¶58

34: SHRI BENU MOHAN DAS S/O LATE KIRTIMONI DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶59

35: MUSSTT. ACHIYA BEGUM

¶60

W/O LATE ALIM UDDIN BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶61

36: SHRI ARUN KUMAR DAS

¶62

S/O LATE UMESH CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶63

37: SHRI PARITOSH DAS

¶64

S/O LATE MONORANJAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶65

38: SHRI KULENDRA DAS

¶66

S/O LT. MANINDRA CHANDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶67

39: SHRI ADHIR DAS S/O LATE RAGURAM DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶68

40: SHRI BALARAM DAS

¶69

Page No.# 8/17

¶70

S/O LATE NALINI KANTA DAS. BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶71

41: SHRI SWAPAN ACHERJEE S/O LATE NALINI KANTA ACHARJEE BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶72

42: MD. JAMIR UDDIN

¶73

S/O LATE MOIN UDDIN BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶74

43: MD. MAKRAM ALI

¶75

S/O LATE SARAFAT ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶76

44: SHRI KRISHNA MOHAN DAS

¶77

S/O LATE KRIPESH DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶78

45: MD. JAHIR UDDIN

¶79

S/O LATE SIDDEK ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶80

46: MD. TAJ UDDIN S/O LT. SIDDEK ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I

¶81

Page No.# 9/17

¶82

PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶83

47: SHRI SANJU DAS

¶84

S/O LATE BRAJENDRA DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM.

¶85

48: SHRI RATAN CHAKRABORTY

¶86

S/O LATE ROSHARAJ CHAKRABORTY BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶87

49: SHRI CHURAMONI DAS

¶88

S/O LATEW HARMOHAN DAS BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶89

50: MD.ABDUL LATIF CHOUDHURY

¶90

S/O LATE WATIR ALI CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶91

51: NORTH KANCHANPUR IDDGAHA REP. BY MD. ABDUL KADIR CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶92

52: MD.SAMSUL HAQUE CHOUDHURY

¶93

S/O LATE MUSBBIR ALI CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802

¶94

Page No.# 10/17

¶95

DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 53: MASQUE

¶96

REP. BY THE SECRETARY TO THE SAID MASQUE MD. ABDUL KADIR CHOUDHURY S/O LATE MAYAB ALI CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 54: MD. SALIM UDDIN S/O LATE JAMAL UDDIN NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶97

55: MD. ABDUL MALIK CHOUDHURY

¶98

S/O LATE MAJOR ALI CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶99

56: MD. SAMSUL HAQUE CHOUDHURY

¶100

S/O LATE IDRIS ALI NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶101

57: MD. MASQUE AHMED CHOUDHURY S/O LATE MAJAR ALI NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 58: MUSSTT. MAYARUN NESSA

¶102

D/O LATE MAJOR ALI NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802

¶103

Page No.# 11/17

¶104

DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 59: MD. FARIZ UDDIN BARBHUIYA S/O LATE MAZAID ALI BARBHUIYA NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 60: MD. AZAR UDDIN S/O LATE KALARAJA MIA NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶105

61: SHRI SUNIL DAS

¶106

S/O LATE ABHAY CHARAN DAS NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 62: MD. FAKRUL ISLAM MAZUMDER S/O LATE ABDUL MUKIT MAZUMDER NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-78802 DIST. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶107

63: MUSST. BILATUN NESSA CHOUDHURY

¶108

W/O LATE HATIM RAJA CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶109

64: MD. ABDUL MATIN CHOUDHURY S/O LATE HAMID RAJA CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶110

Page No.# 12/17

¶111

65: MD. ABUBAKKAR CHOUDHURY S/O LATE SIKKANDRA ALI CHOUDHURY NORTH KANCHANPUR PART-II PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶112

66: SRI BINOD CHANDRA MALAKAR

¶113

S/O LATE UMESH CHANDRA MALAKAR VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 67: SHRI NIRMAL DAS S/O LATE JATINDRA MOHAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 68: SHRI ANUPOM DAS S/O LATE JATOINDRA MOHAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶114

69: HIMNAGSHU SHEKAR DAS

¶115

S/O LATE HIRENDRA MOHAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 70: SHRI KANCHAN DAS S/O LATE DAYAL RANJAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶116

71: SHRI PRABHAS DAS

¶117

S/O LATE DAYAL RANJAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR

¶118

Page No.# 13/17

¶119

PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 72: SHRI PRABANNA SINGHA S/O LATE NARENDRA SINGHA VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM 73: SMTI SHAKUNTALA MALAKAR W/O LATE GURUNG MALAKAR VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶120

74: SHRI RANJIT DAS S/O LATE MONORANJAN DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶121

75: SHRI VIVEKANANDA MALAKAR S/O LATE BIRENDRA MALAKAR VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶122

76: SHRI RAMANANDA SINGHA

¶123

S/O LATE DHIRENDRA SINGHA VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶124

77: SHRI BANAMALI MALAKAR

¶125

S/O LATE JOGESH MALAKAR VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶126

Page No.# 14/17

¶127

78: SHRI BINANDAN MALAKAR

¶128

S/O LATE PULIN MALAKAR VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶129

79: SHRI SAJAY DAS

¶130

S/O LATE DHANANJOY DAS VILLAGE POLARPAR PANCHGRAM-788802 DISTRICT HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶131

VERSUS

¶132

STATE OF ASSAM and 7 ORS, REP. BY THE PRINCIPAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, LAND and REVENUE DEPTT., DISPUR, GHY-6

¶133

2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY LAND AND REVENUE ASSAM LAND AND REVENUE DEPARTMENT ASSAM DISPUR GUWAHATI-6.

¶134

3:THE COMMISSIONER and SECRETARY PWDNH DIVISION. PWDNATIONAL HIGHWAY DIV DISPUR GUWAHATI-6.

¶135

4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PWD NH DIV. PWD NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION CHANDMARI GUWAHATI-3.

¶136

5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER HAILAKANDI. DY COMMISSIONER OFFICE HAILAKANDI P.O. HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶137

Page No.# 15/17

¶138

6:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD NH DIV. PWD NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIV P.O and DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM.

¶139

7:THE UNION OF INDIA. THE SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT and HIGHWAY NEW DELHI.

¶140

8:THE SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT and HIGHWAY MINISTRY OF ROAD and HIGHWAY NEW DELHI

¶141

Linked Case : WP(C)/3560/2015

¶142

MD. RASHID AHMED and 78 ORS

¶143

S/O SAFAR ALI BAKRIHAWAR PART-I PANCHGRAM-788802 DIST- HAILAKANDI ASSAM

¶144

VERSUS STATE OF ASSAM and 5 ORS

¶145

REP. BY THE PRINCIPAL SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM LAND and REVENUE DEPTT. DISPUR GHY-6 2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY LAND AND REVENUE ASSAM LAND AND REVENUE DEPARTMENT ASSAM DISPUR GUWAHATI-6. 3:THE COMMISSIONER and SECRETARY PWDNH DIVISION. PWDNATIONAL HIGHWAY DIV

¶146

Page No.# 16/17

¶147

DISPUR GUWAHATI-6. 4:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PWD NH DIV. PWD NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIVISION CHANDMARI GUWAHATI-3. 5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER HAILAKANDI. DY COMMISSIONER OFFICE HAILAKANDI P.O. HAILAKANDI ASSAM 6:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD NH DIV. PWD NATIONAL HIGHWAY DIV P.O and DIST- KARIMGANJ ASSAM. 7:THE UNION OF INDIA. THE SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT and HIGHWAY NEW DELHI. 8:THE SECRETARY TO GOVT. OF INDIA MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT and HIGHWAY MINISTRY OF ROAD and HIGHWAY NEW DELHI.

¶148

For the Applicants : Mr. T.U. Laskar, Advocate.

¶149

For the Respondents :

¶150

BEFORE

¶151

HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH

¶152

ORDER

¶153

02.08.2023

¶154

The instant writ petition was filed by 79 writ petitioners being aggrieved by the actions of the Respondent Authorities in not making payment of compensation for acquisition of other properties over the homestead land belonging to them.

¶155

During the pendency of the instant writ petition, the Petitioner No. 1

¶156

Page No.# 17/17

¶157

expired on 29.10.2022 leaving behind the following legal representatives :-

¶158

1(a) Musstt. Nazmun Nehar Begum,

¶159

Wife of Late Md. Rashid Ahmed, 1(b) Md. Sahin Ahmed,

¶160

Son of Late Md. Rashid Ahmed, 1(c) Md. Jahid Ahmed,

¶161

Son of Late Md. Rashid Ahmed,

¶162

1 (d) Md. Maruf Aktar,

¶163

Son of Late Md. Rashid Ahmed,

¶164

1 (e) Md. Numan Ahmed,

¶165

Son of Late Md. Rashid Ahmed,

¶166

Village- Bakrihawar Part-1, P.O. Panchram-788802, District – Hailakandi, Assam.

¶167

Taking into account that the cause of action still survives upon the legal representatives of the Petitioner No. 1, this Court substitutes the above mentioned legal representatives of the Petitioner No. 1 and impleads them as Petitioner Nos. 1(a), 1(b), 1(c), 1(d) & 1(e) respectively.

¶168

The Registry shall make necessary correction in the records on the basis of the instant order as well as also upload the same in the CIS.

¶169

The Interlocutory Application accordingly stands disposed.

¶170

JUDGE

¶171

Comparing Assistant

On the Death of Rashid Ahmed His Legal Heirs and Ors, v. State of Assam and 7 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

On the Death of Rashid Ahmed His Legal Heirs and Ors, v. State of Assam and 7 Ors.

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Ajit Kumar Khatoniar Vs Oil India Limited and Ors.

Roll NO.B-1077 Kanakeswar Sinha and Anr. Vs the State of Assam and Ors.

Smt. Anita Haldar Vs the State of Assam and Ors.

Pallabi Baruah Vs the Assam Power Distribution Co. Ltd. (Apdcl) and 5 Ors.

Girish Nath Vs the State of Assam and 4 Ors.

Sambhu Das Vs Commercial Tax Officer and 4 Ors.