Allowed

Tabuk MIbang v. the State of Ap

Gauhati HC20 Nov 2020IA(C)/81/2020

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

The Gauhati High Court, Itanagar Bench, considered an interlocutory application seeking corrections to a connected writ petition regarding land compensation. The court held that the proposed changes would not alter the matter's nature and allowed the amendment of the writ petition (WP(c)273/AP/2017).

What did the court decide?

The prayer for amendment of the writ petition WP(c)273(AP)2017 by incorporating necessary corrections is allowed. The applicants are directed to file an amended writ petition.

Tabuk MIbang Vs the State of Ap — Writ and Judicial Review | Gauhati HC (2020)

¶1

Page No.# 1/11

¶2

GAHC040004902020

¶3

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) (ITANAGAR BENCH)

¶4

Case No. : IA(C) 81/2020

¶5

1:Tabuk MIbang

¶6

S/O TABUK MIBANG, S/O SHRI TAYEK MIBANG, P/R/O VILLAGE LOKPENG, PO PANGIN, DIST. SIANG DIST. AP.

¶7

2: TAPENG SAROH S/O TAJIR SAROH P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶8

3: TANYONG SAROH S/O SHRI TANGIR SAROH P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶9

4: SMTI. YAPI GAMMENG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶10

5: TAGET SAROH C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶11

Page No.# 2/11

¶12

6: SHRI TAE GAMMENG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶13

7: SHRI TATI MUANG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶14

8: SHRI TOKOT PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶15

9: SHRI TASHI PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶16

10: GAGAM PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶17

11: TANYONG GAMMEG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶18

Page No.# 3/11

¶19

12: DANIEL SAROH C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶20

13: TANING MIBANG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶21

14: TAMA MUANG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶22

15: SHRI TATEM GOI C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP. 16: ARUNA TATIN C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP. 17: TALING PANOR C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP.

¶23

Page No.# 4/11

¶24

18: TAGO PANGGAM C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP. 19: TALOKO TAPAK S/O SHRI TALING TAPAK P/R/O VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DIST. SIANG AP VERSUS

¶25

1:THE STATE OF AP REPRESENTED THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY, GOVT. OF AP. 2:THE COMMISSIONER PWD-CUM-TRANS-ARUNACHAL HIGHWAY GOVT. OF AP CIVIL SECRETARIAT ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR.

¶26

3:THE COMMISSIONER-CUM-SECRETARY DEPTT. OF LAND MANAGEMENT GOVT. OF AP ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR. 4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER SIANG DIST. HEADQUARTER PANGIN PO PANGIN AP. 5:THE DISTRICT LAND REVENUE AND SETTLEMENT OFFICER SIANG DIST. PANGIN PO PANGIN AP. 6:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PWD EASTERN ZONE TRANS ARUNACHAL HIGHWAY GOVT. OF AP MOWB-II ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR.

¶27

Page No.# 5/11

¶28

7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DOIMUKH HIGHWAY DIVISION AAPWD YUPIA PAPUM PARE DIST. PO DOIMUKH AP.

¶29

8:THE GENERAL MANAGER (PROJECT) NATIONAL HIGHWAY AND INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION LIMITED (GOVT. OF INDIA UNDER TAKING) BRANCH OFFICE ITANAGAR NEAR DURGA MANCIR VIP ROAD NITI VIHAR ITANAGAR PO-ITANAGAR DIST. PAPUM PARE AP.

¶30

9:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED THROUGH THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAY GOVT. OF AP INDIA TRANSPORT BHAWAN PARLIAMENT STREET NEW DELHI. 10:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED THROUGH THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF DEFENCE GOVT. OF INDIA NEW DELHI. 11:THE COMMANDANT 44 BRTF C/O 99 APO WEST SIANG DIST. AALO PO AALO AP

¶31

Advocate for the Petitioner : Tayum Son Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP) D Kamduk SC(Land Management)

¶32

Page No.# 6/11

¶33

Linked Case : WP(C) 273/2017 1:SHRI TABUK MIBANG S/O SHRI TAYEK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTT. SIANG DISTRICT AP. M- 9402770472 2: SHRI TAPENG SAROH S/O TAJIR SAROH PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTT. SIANG AP. 3: SHRI TANYONG SAROH S/O SHRI TANGIR SAROH PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTT. SIANG AP. 4: SMTI. YAPI GAMMENG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTT. SIANG AP. 5: SHRI TAGET SAROH C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 6: SHRI TATE GAMMENG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 7: SHRI TATI MUANG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN

¶34

Page No.# 7/11

¶35

DISTRICT SIANG AP. 8: SHRI GAGAM PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 9: SHRI TANYONG GAMMEG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 10: SHRI DANIEL SAROH C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 11: SHRI TANING MIBANG C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 12: SHRI TALOKO TAPAK C/O SHRI TALING TAPAK PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 13: SHRI DAMLIN YONGGAM C/O TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 14: SHRI ARUNA TATIN C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG

¶36

Page No.# 8/11

¶37

PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 15: SHRI TATEM GOI C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 16: SHRI TALING PANOR C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 17: SHRI TAGO PANGGAM C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 18: SHRI TASHI PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. 19: SHRI TOKOT PAJING C/O SHRI TABUK MIBANG PERMANENT RESIDENT OF VILL. LOKPENG PO PANGIN DISTRICT SIANG AP. VERSUS 1:THE STATE OF A.P. REPRESENTED THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY GOVT. OF AP CIVIL SECRETARIAT ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR.

¶38

Page No.# 9/11

¶39

2:THE COMMISSIONER PWD-CUM-TRANS ARUNACHAL HIGHWAY GOVT. O FAP CIVIL SECRETARIAT ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR. 3:THE COMMISSIONER-CUM-SECRETARY DEPTT. OF LAND MANAGEMENT GOVT. OF AP ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR. 4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER SIANG SUBANSIRI DISTT. HEADQUARTER PANGIN PO PANGIN AP. 5:THE DISTRICT LAND REVENUE and SETTLEMENT OFFICER SIANG DISTT. PANGIN PO PANGIN AP. 6:THE CHIEF CHEF ENGINEER PWD EASTERN ZONE TRANS-ARUNACHAL HIGHWAY GOVT. O FAP MOUB-II ITANAGAE PO ITANAGAR. 7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DOIMUKH HIGHWAY DIVISION AAPWD YUPIA PAPUM PARE DISTT. PO DOIMUKH AP. 8:THE GENERAL MANAGER PROJECT NATIONAL HIGHWAY and INSFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT COOPERATION LIMITED A GOVT. OF INDIA UNDERTAKING BRANCH OFFICE ITANAGAR NEAR DURGA MANDIR VIP ROAD NITI VIHAR ITANAGAR PO ITANAGAR DISTT. PAPUM PARE AP.

¶40

Page No.# 10/11

¶41

9:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED THROUGH THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF ROAD TRANSPORT AND HIGHWAYS GOVT. OF INDIA TRANSPORT BHAWAN PARLIAMENT STREET NEW DELHI-110001.

¶42

10:THE UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED THROUGH THE SECRETARY MINISTRY OF DEFENCE GOVT. OF INDIA NEW DELHI. 11:THE COMMANDANT 44 BRTF C/O 99 APO WEST SIANG DISTT. AALO PO AALO AP.

¶43

Advocate for the Petitioner : Mr T Son Advocate for the Respondent : MrR Saikia

¶44

BEFORE

¶45

HONBLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHIVJYOTI SAIKIA

¶46

ORDER

¶47

Date : 20-11-2020

¶48

Heard Mr. Tayum Son, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the applicants/writ petitioners. Also heard Mr. Subu Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate, appearing on behalf of Respondents No. 1 & 4.

¶49

By this interlocutory application, the applicants/writ petitioners intends to make some necessary corrections in the connected writ petition being WP(c)273(AP2017.

¶50

It appears that the aforesaid writ petition relates to payment of compensation in lieu of procurement of

¶51

land.

¶52

Page No.# 11/11

¶53

After hearing the learned counsels appearing for the parties; in my considered opinion, the intended corrections to be made by the applicants/writ petitioners as reflected by them in this interlocutory application, would not, in any way, change the nature and character of the matter in its entirety.

¶54

In view of the above, the prayer for amendment of the writ petition being WP(c)273(AP)2017 by incorporating the necessary corrections as reflected by the applicants/writ petitioners in this interlocutory application, is hereby allowed.

¶55

The applicants/writ petitioners shall accordingly file an amended writ petition in lieu of the writ petition i.e. WP(c)273(AP)2017 already laid before this Court.

¶56

With the above directions, the interlocutory application stands allowed and accordingly stands disposed

¶57

of.

¶58

JUDGE

¶59

Comparing Assistant

Tabuk MIbang v. the State of Ap

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Tabuk MIbang v. the State of Ap

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Minken Tasar Vs Ms. Nitu Tsering Glow

Minken Tasar Vs The State of Ap and Others

M/S Chukhu Sera Enterprise Vs the State of Ap

M/S G R Enterprise Vs The State of Ap and 3 Ors.

Goi Yangfo Vs the State of Ap

Sobo Pertin Vs the State Election Commission Arunachjal Pradesh