Disposed
Jadumoni Borah and 52 Ors. v. the Union of India and 4 Ors.
Gauhati HCI.A.(Civil)/346/2020
Case brief
from the order text
What is this about?
GAHC010031112020 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT…
What the court decided
AI extract
GAHC010031112020 THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT…
This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.
Page No.# 1/13
GAHC010031112020
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : I.A.(Civil) 346/2020 in WP(C) 5824/2019
1:JADUMONI BORAH AND 52 ORS.
S/O - LATE THAGIRAM BORAH, VILLAGE - NO 1 CHINTAMONI GARH, PO - CHINTAMONI GARH, DIST - SIVASAGAR, PIN-785640
2: BIDYUT GOGOI S/ O- TANKESWAR GOGOI VILLAGE - DIKSHU MOUT GAON PO - DIKSHU DIST- SIVASAGAR PIN-785640 DOB - 01/07/1986 AGE-33 YEARS
3: REKHA BARUAH D/ O- BISWA KANTA BARUAH VILLAGE - NAKHANA KHANIKOR GAON PO - NAKHANA PIN - 785664 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 30/06/1984 AGE- 35 YEARS
4: RANJIT PHUKAN S/O - PADMESWAR PHUKAN VILLAGE - REBATI GAON PO - LIGIRI PHUKHURI PS - NAZIRA PIN- 785664 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 01/08/1971 AGE-48 YEARS
Page No.# 2/13
5: AKHOY JYOTI HANDIQUE S/O - HARESH HANDIQUE VILLAGE - DEMOW A NAGAR PO - DEMOW PIN - 785662 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 01/03/1977 AGE-42 YEARS
6: LAKHI KUMAR KALITA S/O- SOMESWAR KALITA VILLAGE - MICHAJAN PS - NAMTI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785684 DOB - 31/10/1975 AGE- 44 YEARS
7: SURJYA SAIKIA S/O - BHOLOCK SAIKIA VILLAGE - ROGHUBARI PO - DIKHOWMUKH DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785664 DOB - 01/02/1982 AGE- 37 YEARS
8: SULTANA SHRIREEN ZAMAL D/O - LATE BODIUZ ZAMAL VILLAGE - ARJUNGURI PS - SIVASAGAR DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN-785640 AGE - 38 YEARS
9: MANASHI CHETIA D/O- LATE BUDURAM CHETIA. VILLAGE - BOKATA GOHAIN GAON. P.S- NEMUGURI. P.O- NEMUGURI. DIST- SIVASAGAR. PIN- 785674. DOB- 13/06/1978
Page No.# 3/13
AGE-41 YEARS
10: MRIDYUT KAKOTY S/O - THANURAM KAKOTY VILLAGE - NAMTI CHARIALI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785685 DOB - 01/01/1987 AGE- 32 YEARS
11: LAKHI PRASAD BORBARUAH S/O - KUMUD CH BORBARUAH VILLAGE - GELEKI HANDIQUE GAON P.O - PIYALI PHUKAN DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785685 DOB - 25/12/1987 AGE- 32 YEARS
12: MOUSUMI SABHAPANDIT D/O- LATE MAKHAN CH SABHAPANDIT VILLAGE - KENDUGURI PO - RAMANI ALI PIN 785686 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 25/01/1987 AGE- 32 YEARS
13: SANJEEV KUMAR MAHANTA S/O- GIRINDRA KUMAR MAHANTA VILLAGE - NAKHANA BEZGAON PO - NAKHANA PIN - 785664 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 28/08/1989 30 YEARS
14: BHARATI GOGOI D/O- MOHENDRA GOGOI VILLAGE - LAKHIMI NAGAR PO - CHEREKAPAAR PS - SIVASAGAR PIN-785640
Page No.# 4/13
DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785640 AGE - 42 YEARS
15: ARCHANA BORTHAKUR D/O- LATE RATNESWAR BORHAKUR VILLAGE - OLD AMULAPATTY WARD NO - 11 P.O - SIVASAGAR PIN-785640 P.S- SIVASAGAR AGE-29 YEARS
16: NAYANMONI CHETIA D/O - PITHURAM CHETIA VILLAGE - RAJAPOOL GOHAIN GAON PO - RAJAPOOL PS - NAZIRA PIN - 785685 DOB - 31/05/1982 AGE- 37 YEARS
17: JULI BORAH MECH D/O - DIJEN BORAH VILLAGE - GARGAON PO - GARGAON PS - SIMALUGURI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785685 DOB - 31/03/1986 AGE-33 YEARS
18: BIJAY CHANDRA DAS S/O - LATE HARAKANTA DAS VILLAGE - RUDRASAGAR DIST. - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785665 DOB - 31/11/1975 AGE-44 YEARS
19: CHIRANJIT GOGOI S/O - GOLAP CH GOGOI VILLAGE - DULAKAKHARIA
Page No.# 5/13
PO - DULAKAKHARIA PIN 785696 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 31/12/1989 AGE-30 YEARS
20: SAYEDA IRFAN SHAHIN D/O - LATE SAYED ABDUL MASLIN VILLAGE - NO MATI PO - NAZIRA PIN 785685 DOB 19/11/1989 AGE- 30 YEARS
21: GAYATRI PHUKAN D/O- BIPIN PHUKAN VILLAGE - SUNPURA GOHAIN GAON PO - GARGAON PS - SIVASAGAR PIN 785685 DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB 03/03/1985 AGE- 34 YEARS
22: ABHISEKH CHETIA S/O - GOPI CHETIA VILLAGE - GELEKI HANDIQUE GAON PO - PIOLI PHUKAN DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785685 DOB - 31/08/1982 AGE-37 YEARS
23: DEBAJANI GOGOI W/O - PRASHANTA PHUKAN VILLAGE - DEMOW MADHUPUR PO - DEMOW DIST- SIVASAGAR PIN 785662 AGE- 30 YEARS
24: UPASANA BORGOHAIN D/O- LATE ARUN BORGOHAIN
Page No.# 6/13
VILLAGE - OLD AMULAPATTY NA - ALI DIST- SIVASAGAR PIN 785640 AGE- 29 YEARS
25: NILUPALA BHUYAN H/O - SURAJ JYOTI BARUAH VILLAGE - TEOK DIST - JORHAT ASSAM AGE-32 YEARS PIN - 785112
26: SIMA BARUAH PHUKAN D/O -- SUKUMAR BARUAH VILLAGE - HATIMURIA . P.S - AMGURI PIN-785662 P.O-CHARINGIA PUKHURI. DIST- SIVASAGAR . AGE-32 YEARS.
27: JYOTIMONI BORAH DUTTA D/O -- GANESH CHANDRA BORAH. VILLAGE - KATHALBARI. P.O-KALUGAON PIN-785660 P.S - SIVASAGAR. AGE -38 YEARS
28: NILAKSHI PHUKAN D/O- LATE MUNINDRA NATH PHUKAN VILLAGE - DIMOW KONWER DEHINGIA P.S - DEMOW. P.O- DEMOW. PIN -785662 DIST- SIVASAGAR AGE - 29 YEARS
29: PURBALI BARUAH D/O - MR. SURENDRA NATH BARUAH. WARD NO -14
Page No.# 7/13
P.O AND P.S - SIVASAGAR DIST -SIVASAGAR PIN- 785640 DOB - 31/12/1984 35 YEARS
30: SONI KHANIKOR CHETIA D/O - KHAGESWAR KHANIKOR VILLAGE - NAKHANA KHANIKOR PO - NAKHANA PS - GAURISAGAR DIST - SIVASAGAR DOB - 31/10/1982 AGE- 37 YEARS
31: GEETARTHI BHUYAN NEOG H/O - JIBON NEOG VILLAGE - NA DECIAL GAON PO - SILPUKHURI PS - GAURISAGAR PIN-785662 DIST - SIVASAGAR 33 YEARS
32: MUNMI MOHAN W/O - HOREN RAKHOWA VILLAGE - CHALAPATHER GAON PO - LAKWA PIN - 785685 DIST - CHARAIDEO AGE - 34 YEARS
33: RITUMONI BARUAH D/O - GIRIN BARUAH VILLAGE - LAKWA CHARIMUTHIA KONWAR GAON PO - SILAKUTI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785698 AGE- 40 YEARS
34: BORSHA BORUAH D/O - PULIN BORUAH
Page No.# 8/13
VILLAGE - MOGORAHAT CHANGMAI GAON PO - MOGORAHAT DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 7856666 DIST - SIVASAGAR AGE- 34 YEARS
35: SINU BORPATRA GOHAIN D/O- KHAGEN BORPATRAGOHAIN VILLAGE - JAYSAGAR . JAYANAGAR PIN 785665 DIST SIVASAGAR AGE- 34 YEARS
36: RUNJUNMONI BORAH D/O - SUSHIL KR BORAH R/O-JAYANAGAR PO - JAYSAGAR DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785665 AGE-39 YEARS
37: CHANDANA BORPATRA GOHAIN D/O- BHABESH BORPATRAGOHAIN VILLAGE - DIMUAL GAON PO - DHITAI PHUKHURI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785685 AGE- 43 YEARS
38: JOON MONI CHUTIA D/O- MOHAN CHANDRA CHUTIA VILLAGE - CHARING BARUATI GAON DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785661 AGE - 34 YEARS
39: JUTIKA SENSUA D/O - BHUPEN SENSUA VILLAGE - DEOPANI GOHAIN GAON PO - DEOPANI PIN 785684 DIST SIVASAGAR
Page No.# 9/13
AGE- 28 YEARS
40: MINAKSHI BARUAH D/O - UPEN BARUAH P.O - CHEREKAPAAR PIN-785684 PS - CHEREKAPAAR AGE- 44 YEARS
41: MOUCHUMI BORAH D/O- KHILESWAR BORAH VILLAGE - BETBARI DAWGAON PO - MITHAPUKHRI DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN 785697 AGE- 34 YEARS
42: CHANDAN PHUKAN S/O - HOREN PHUKAN VILLAGE- GAURISAGAR BEZGAON PO - GAURI SAGAR PS - GAURI SAGAR DIST - SIVASAGAR PIN - 785664 DOB - 11/08/1992 AGE- 27 YEARS
43: ANANTA BORGOHAIN S/O - PADMESWAR BORGOHAIN VILLAGE - GARALI PO - RAJAPOOL PS - NAZIRA DIST - SIVASAGAR AGE- 35 YEARS
44: ARUNIMA BARUAH GOGOI D/O - KANAK BARUAH VILLAGE - LALIMCHIGA PO - LALIM CHIGA PIN - 785680 DIST - SIVASAGAR AGE- 33 YEARS
Page No.# 10/13
45: PURABI CHETIA D/O - SUNESWAR CHETIA METEKA LAIMEKURI GAON P.O - METEKA SIVASAGAR PIN - 785640 AGE- 29 YEARS
46: SHOBNAM AHMED D/O - LATE RAHMAT ALI VILLAGE - MEZENGA KETEKIBARI PO - MEZENGA PIN - 785685 DIST - SIVASAGAR AGE- 30 YEARS
47: NABASMITA GOGOI D/O - PRABIN CH GOGOI VILLAGE - PHUKON PHODIA BEZGAON GAURISAGAR PO - NAKHANA PIN - 785664 AGE- 29 YEARS
48: SHYMALIMA BORAH D/O - LATE HEMAKANTA BORAH VILLAGE - KHATUAL PO - CHINTAMONI DIST - JORHAT PIN - 785682 AGE- 37 YEARS
49: MAMONI BORAH D/O - LATE BAPURAM BORAH VILLAGE - KHANAMUKH GHARPHALIA PO - KHANAMUKH DIST - JORHAT PIN - 785682 AGE- 47 YEARS
50: MONMAYURI GOGOI
Page No.# 11/13
D/O- RANJIT GOGOI
R/O- DEMOW DEHINGIA GAON
P.O- DEMOW P.S- DEMOW PIN-785662.
51: ARPAN PHUKAN S/O- LATE PABITRA PHUKAN. R/O-CHARING BARUATI GAON
P.O- CHARING PIN- 785661. DIST- SIVASAGAR ASSAM.
52: PRANJAL SAIKIA S/O- BASANTA SAIKIA R/O-DULAKAKHORIA P.O- DULAKAKHORIA. P.S- GALEKY DIST- SIVASAGAR PIN-785696.
53: SABITA BARUAH W/O-DIPJYOTI SHARMA R/O-HABIRAM BORA PATH
WARD NO.11 PIN-785640 DIST- SIVASAGAR ASSAM
VERSUS
1:THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE MINISTRY OF HUMAN RESOURCE AND DEVELOPMENT, DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION AND LITERACY, NEW DELHI-1.
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM REPRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
Page No.# 12/13
ELEMENTARY EDUCATION DEPARTMENT DISPUR GHY-06.
3:THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM EDUCATION DEPARTMENT DISPUR GHY-06.
4:THE AXOM SARBA SIKHA ABHIJAN/ AXOM SAMAGRA SIKHA ABHIJAN MISSION REPRESENTED BY ITS MISSION DIRECTORATE. KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI-19.
5:THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION ASSAM KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI-1
Advocate for the Petitioner : MR. B P BORAH
Advocate for the Respondent :
BEFORE
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE N. KOTISWAR SINGH
ORDER
10.02.2020
Heard Mr. P.K. Goswami, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. B.P. Borah, learned
counsel for the applicants. Also heard Mr. D. Saikia, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. R. Mazumdar, learned standing counsel, appearing for the State respondents.
2. The present application has been filed for seeking certain clarification as regards the
Notice issued under No.EAA/SIU/125/2018/376 relating to recruitment to the post of teachers in LP and UP School. According to the learned Senior counsel for the applicants, the said
Page No.# 13/13
Notice does not mention anything about the interim order passed by this Court on 22.08.2019 in WP(C) No.5824/2019 and as such the applicants apprehend that their interest would be adversely affected if the interim order passed by this Court on 22.08.2019 is not taken into consideration while proceeding with the matter under the said Notice by the State Government.
3. Learned Senior counsel for the State Mr. D. Saikia however submits that the applicants need not feel any apprehension, as the said interim order(s) passed in WP(C) No.8824/2018 and other similarly situated cases, namely, WP(C) Nos.5824/2019, 4914/2019, 7631/2019, 7519/2019 and 9480/2019 to the effect that the authority will ensure by keeping a proportionate number of vacancies in the Elementary Department to be kept unfilled and which may not be filled without the leave of this Court, still subsist and not yet vacated.
4. Learned counsel for the State accordingly submits that so long as the interim orders
passed by this Court in the aforesaid writ petitions subsist and not yet vacated, the said interim orders will be given effect to even though these are not specifically mentioned in the Notice under No.EAA/SIU/125/2018/376.
5. In view of the aforesaid submission made by Mr. Saikia, learned Senior counsel for the
State, no further clarification is required.
6. Accordingly, this application is closed.
Sd/- N. Kotiswar Singh JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
1:JADUMONI BORAH AND 52 ORS.
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS.
N. Kotiswar Singh
As recorded by the court registry
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court