Mahesh Acharya v. Asset Care and Construction Enterprise Ltd.

DRT4 Jan 2024SA/909/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

GONTD. ORDER.SHEET

PAGE No

CASE No

DATE DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REi'ARK
909 2023
04.01. 0243Trdq-o'celdfuqfr^qftd-63utflcT sTBq-ffirI vffi-qrfr6qi61dfuq*sfud +'ArffrsTfu{ffirI 1.V+Frsero\a-oqerqr3rdfien$^q. 4s76/2023d^qrprfuot^q-qffi{rqg{ grrcrR-d3])_{qrfuroA.o}.2o1tdfr-s-q qifu-d3ffiqsgrirdrdfr-€q{$rrrptt t'r
2.Torq arGi-e-frfi{fo-qr^rrqrI 3.Grr-il{6cer^grusr{T17^(1)q{Sffi g{e2oo2dsrqqrddGHn16oltilfi ftirozz.oz.zozso)slBf,-tqd^qqe{frT Efir^{'ssnfuTiqq-drrA HIeTfuf,r} srqffi{rqg{^grttcrRdoil-tcrfu{io 14.08.2017^gS+dr-frq++fuirO06.0e.2023 o\erqrwfr-t^qdofsorcrorfuuqo fu-qr^rrqrt,vrqfrWiEqR^qenfuih o-rqqfrri^qrior fttcr^{qrar rrqr}B,v+rp; frerq^sr5siFrorraErdrorfi^ergtufu-w .rqrtt
4.gqsur+f,rderqffiqsuqend ff( ffi gtr+ fuirooo.os.zozsG ortomtaou14.08.2017oTftqrEareTFrf, frrn^qrior^,frergtufo-q^.rqrBt s.trorurrqoo-{i^qgVft-o<o<sup>erqr frtn^qfitgg"roffiq3Tlilqq{f,c-o-rul o<sup>qrPTu-qoorigverStufuqr^rrqrB fuoil-iq-o.^qeTffia w tfr#tor grril-q oror16rt.fr{fidsWfilffit

¶5

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

¶6

PAGE No

¶7

CASE No

Mahesh Acharya versus Asset Care and Construction Enterprise Ltd. — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REilARK
	\r6]-su-d v{ q TEIIgS sTrftTsq{fl,fr-qq+flatfrfuqqdrffi TSof^.r$,qfuE)sWfdrffiderq_{E sTr'de6ser3,47,460l-(d-{orsffis 6qR^qRd^qro)FTift-qfrqiqi^qT ffitorgrrf,Fm-flt{Sonurfrrrqqqr df{s-€silcfuorqfffie-qf,T€tfu-fl, ft{ft^qfqWirrftd*scsrfrri{erd gRI3TrBTsW+fuiro04.05.2017c-6,frra o-rfr^rr{t
	6.sr-tffisero-r16fioTftqfiB'fu fu-f,r^q@zsr+gsGaEfto-sRv+gvd wqereniq-6^qeTitltnrfluqtrerior srqfri^qrio-r^,frsr-g+Tfu-qr,HRrfr 4,sl,s3s/-(qxdrErGr€rtmuonfrdr q'fi-s)$qiqrnrfrfu-qrteie-o:vFswgw vQ-cRorvcrco-qfrftfr	sdsRr smi:srfroqioIo)d{\r{-rsu-eFigwt or frq^qqT,frsrranefl-t{f,cael ffi q+crfuiro06.0e.2023d^qruqqt $TI,^{ilqoil-ieoqqT}
	7.sflrqrfroqioro1fri tfuflq erqrGIdfioryQmt^qqrqu-qf,oGEq srilc{o-rcftfl-Efu-qr^.rqrtIsfuqno-r emmBsfffrT q++GenBqcq Wq+ orril{ocendfl-{tsrrrtfr,fu-g w-o fiqrdsiwori<-ocaifr.rq-dflys sTrErfl q-d{ro)g-{tfrTfrftqr,srprfr cFd{rq^g6^qffEova^qmftqE-d-fl,r-6 s@^qrq-dqdsqerfrsqRsrd gq,fu-ifr

¶12

DATE DESCR]PTION OF THE ORDER sflqSflS' Gr{ifildr^qffi*Trqg{^gt-rr crRdsil-+sT"fg+Ac-$ftfl{€eTrETrti q{rrfr-irq st-qBqrkd+tofsTrqfud o-trigqsffif, sarrilo-Ifufrrfr;qrrqr tr
8.^gerrkT:fuoqerqrGnd-fi61ftqrf,{q fu-qr^qr16rtI e.B-f,t-qrfrceToffri+rqdfrrnTt 3TffifimTq++('iffisTr-{1/2) ftqioo+^q-i-{ftzorztEEiiE-ot,fu{-+t
tr€-f,fr$-efuiro.21.01.2017fuRqYC q-q1-sdqrer€o,-rt1nieTrETcq{qiT (qiwrsrx1/3)fu{io02.0s.2017t-o. RtrCdsrsTridr{ ttcarqgeqrfu ftctCtfrrrq+rG3TrETsq++r ot orffisqqrR-dof^qrtftteiltrciqqfir ortwscFRFr,ffi{fld,s€oq^q{zott
1's+F^dfto-f,vr+grt^o+q$zorz frdTsoiffi^qf,{-t^qr-ior€a-rt,
T{q[.Ffro-rErqrfu{€drqt,t-qd
ffi d.i-q-corerffio€o.cB,_oIQrtd fr.rq++GsnftTsg++oforffi sr1-{os&r^rNcrc[qr^qrort\dGTrE[fl q++tdsrrErx^q{qirwrq(gfloritg^q-E o-rq^q-$zorz^tisqq5
ra++ro)gitftttfunowu-qof+ qrBqerT,fu-g16trfr-{ut22.oe.zozeoiss sTBo-iqdtsqmc-qdfu-qr.rqrt,ul^-itr
q++woTrfuTs Eeu^er+Bqrfuot't dfrw^tlverq

¶17

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHEORDER	REI,IARK
	10. ga{ {rqgrErncrfud^3il-i{rft{;5^t+srrrKT2017 at^qft(qtffi/s)^trqnof'r$^t. ffi 6F-so-rad^erqdfi-qqse^Bafr moftceno\g+^orfi-ddi^wxfrcet dftN^qff{ffird^{qrtqqt{scReTfrd et} ,ri, fuE3il-tatolffi temrieo^qer scRrdc-€t8il,^{e-ogr+r$g$orertu} crfudfuqr.rqrt,^{erqtogrrqqero)}Ec-{d oroFNRto-r^{crRfl sr-t{rd}T+fr^titg qIEo-t-tq3il-tcrcIR-dietro14srrl-KT zorztssqfqr^{qIiTqr}{r, fr-SEH} 3rtcro\Tffititg^srrls-{qeTt^fuirf, 2z.os.zozso1^{q-fi'(qs-Eafou}t,^3lqtf, fuors-srffi^{Tqg{gmclRf,3r-tq'} ft{16r+^GrrrKT2017d^gd-frtttgfr s-qf,s-{-rq^{erqBertrdB t} 11.orq^q6ftqnuftqt'fu^{'eqrefl-iffi qs} ofoirtTqdfuf,q^{HrIruri-et3rd.}. $ta/zozsffio.ri^{6{fuf,qeFIIorrmrur} X"r^<\vqrE-{r^{qr soort"t}
	12.s6td?F^qm5^{TqlqT3fiftqq01} cr+qdrorcrct^t ^{qmftq BEkrrIarqlEl-q} ENT ^ei-qq{Hr^{frs-{ llul (zoro) r+vs.S.tfi.} sr+^ticffi{d^{sTBqdd ergun}Td^srEtrf, fr^qm5Tqtfl^{oTfuF-qqd qrqErnsrmwc-€t} drtBvs ^{qrffiqTdfr6dqd erq f+sq} sfisEtrgqr T.I3rq gfl.S.fr.arrot o.trs+T 62i^{qmftqvqilqqrrlTcrqd am} cRrcrkdolftqdd^q-6rqt^{qr*ttz(1)st$ffi} gqd2oo2doiil,id u-qndi^qrds-6'tq^o-r trut{^qq-ERqrqrdqd^trqflq.c.d'+ crqEr=itdrffi(ao^{erffiarfrqr+re-oi}

¶21

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER ^d *
	c-trdili^qrqrEq,6rorB,eterld
	3llilq-6 celErtre-qdrEs-6-rurTdsrET,d ssq^?FTt,ftil-sq^qrql5^qqfflefiftrqa cFEnqsrqlwc-sBI
	1s.^gsdqrqfr^qn-+q$@trr^qrqroqd sxroffigls fus-€ frRiqd fucrcte I 7Vs. ff.fr.rog^ticffi{dolftqdds-sTqrnfrcts oTDftqqdffdcffi{dfttqsrqftqrd
	H-<.f^qqqkrsTEftqqrsosot^qms d
	ttFrrqsqiiEToTq-qftfud^qrdd\d^qrqrmq o.)lqtEsTfufuqqdoio-.fdsFqETrF-flsrq frqTdf{trrR-ds-{i^qfferffiorrfr*ftr
	14.?i-q^q6icr6^rrTrTrz(r)wrfrft^gfe zoozdsiffis-qd*isrdrfi{"it^ttqms o1cr+qdrirrcwrB,wfrq.qt^qrrftq $qils^qMrdqtrrtlERrt6^gTrID,qgtErrq
	ry^{f{s-€qrs{frdrdqr$wftrqE cr$c} ftft
	ffiq 1006of^qibolrr Sirzfi^qfrT$
	qrsqrdcr$srtsrNT5TqfqroTfufuqqd
	qrrEnqsrfwc-€ttrgs-dsrqfrgSs<d
	fr^{q6ftqrrEFHgErrqFlelrr}Ot^q-sfi-dtrM
	ionrifrffirTd^qrfAeftfte-sf{s-q
	orpxrf,wsilfuq{Etrsq-ct-ooiffrrqW
	srq^qlfuolEqt6'312s1/zo.tcrftdsTrt{r
	ffitoos.oe.2ols cmftq?Fa6<rGI
	Rrrlndqatq-sq-ddamorerf,o-qRt{d
	cr$ieftTfr&^gierqffi'qoqqrro,rff\s
	sralwl fi.=i{r1s1/2ooo^qcrRdoTrt$
	ftcioeo.o4.zoro,^affi{Eid2olow.fr.fr.
	mqdrf,{^IrEFFRTIrsol\d^qmftqfusq
	qrqrmqSem d.fr.q+co.Y{ro.dEErscsrdr
	erailsfgcradcft$-{ Etr6i.rctiriqrEtffir

¶26

OATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	RE]UIARK
	E.r{tqqfrfr-g2o1svs.dt.d}^€fiqdrfi *tarzszzz t,fui-d^rilEzrqt^qE frfugreTrfudot'rgtfu^qr-o17⁽¹⁾siffr Vfe^{2oo2d 3iil.fd e-gd}i^qrdroqurd Er,s^qqf.,oTgftqqdcrqtrnarrlrSe}it 1s.BqtfrTTsrr fqEsif,sq'i^qttfta-fird qraroerD-o-rurEqM,qqui+crBot sTrilq-fi^qerERr^q-qdolrnfi^qaiaofr-q q-d{Ifofr617E=ltrft2017GenftqeWtrcr ftq15oz.os.zo17vti fudr^qWetrqg{aRI crRdoTrtcrftqior+.0e.2017tsqfudB, q_qBqrkdt\dffi q+<rdfrs-qt sffic-{rfr^qeTtrMfr^rr{qr;rorfrds-61-cri oTrtcrckolftqioat.to.2oi:dorSwnfl+s der,Trq^qffi61ffi^cNTtF-eT€t,^oTef-d ffi $q{rfu{i606.0e.2023dfrsq^qqr$ rr$wuqarenqqnm.dgo1tt 16.^gqqRfutfoittercailil{ocelarr e-qd^q6s-6'{orolrtetMfuo ftoiEri tg ts^q.€tTE^{qrf,Iqtiq-qfuqrE-oq-o-ror}t oTril{o^qeTo'tot$eidftqsE:r{rdtfic-ff{T€t of^qrsofrt 17.^qRunqswerieo^{rrfl gr{Ig-qd}vg.q. orqfu^{qrkd gqr}ftqfRdorigv^gSwqw F-ffifuqr^qrartt
	18.Blrrt^rTeI3Tq-qI^{sTrl-ilqqg-f,{}ottt
	qRq-Hd fuqr qmg1.;;qiVrftdrerqr{rI qr61g-frtul ffi{srffi S.enq.fr(r.uv+Ed-gtT6)

Mahesh Acharya v. Asset Care and Construction Enterprise Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Bank of India versus M/S Dash Paper Plast Pvt. Ltd.

Modern Steel Traders versus Canara Bank

M/S Rana Greens versus Uco Bank

Ms Surya Trading Company versus State Bank of India

Mahesh Acharya v. Asset Care and Construction Enterprise Ltd.

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Bank of India versus M/S Dash Paper Plast Pvt. Ltd.

Modern Steel Traders versus Canara Bank

M/S Rana Greens versus Uco Bank

Ms Surya Trading Company versus State Bank of India

State Bank of India versus M/S Anju Shree Vishwakarma Agro

Tek Singh Bhadoriya versus Dcb Bank Limited