Smt Narmada Bai Ben v. Aadhar Housing Finance

DRT13 Mar 2024SA/794/2023

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

PAGE No.

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

CASE No.

DESGRIPTION OF THE ORDER DATE	REMARK
3[al f{sq sTrErRErsRi.r^.Frftsvferq Tfl..^rcq/^2oz3
onnffiseTdftIq *ft?t-&{r^ETqt erBqffirt sn{q-rftt-odfufrfrtrgffi. eilYrmrr 1.srrlseTat^oilrttrqf,frd'r$ Tfl.q.^{dfrEh{flrd frsqqq}EqT^rrflI 2.^gth-trro-r^{erqotmqfrtqrrrr[I} 3.ffil-tr1s.ol.zo2s^{o\3il-nemqflgRI} qmfi(1)s{+ffigdd2oo2dH-otrn} dstrT^qErfi-{ut^qi-rEd{r^dsIsT Gilfuqg{q-{rft{ro0e.08.202s^o\sttTrKT frrt^qrtd^qrelfr^{qsr?r-{-qrfrfrfts-q} e}fudfrtt^qfia1^sEEraTqr$'d^t HIstfrrqdfttt^TnffiqwitTq sIlilfiseel/zozsd^qltqqtWq qrfu-6frz s{f,gq^{gr$qrRf,sntvr} frrrlfios.lo.zoze^{drg+fttitgggtE[q} sItfis-qf,^frtqrq-qltw^{n3ffiq GTrilfis252/^{zozsiftrfi25102023A} qrEz-qtsmenelFflsntsr^ftHr6oe'10' zozter^{fuqr-qqfiTQrFrafrtnqris-t} Grjtqfttqrrqrt^t 4.B-f,.{rfi^sH6Rr{a^3il-ilfio-t f,{rq^{qq-flfu-qTqrg-ort t} 5 qd 6 fr ^grfll qeT e\ sntgr ^qBrr 1 lffr6 I 12.2023 ^{_</sup> cn 3n-5qN sTq ^{gfl dr} 13.03}

DESGRIPTION OF THE ORDER
DATE

REMARK

3[al
f{sq
sTrErRErsRi.r^.Frftsvferq
Tfl..^rcq/^2oz3

onnffiseTdftIq *ft?t-&{r^ETqt
erBqffirt
sn{q-rftt-odfufrfrtrgffi.
eilYrmrr
1.srrlseTat^oilrttrqf,frd'r$ Tfl.q.^{dfrEh{flrd frsqqq}EqT^rrflI
2.^gth-trro-r^{erqotmqfrtqrrrr[I}
3.ffil-tr1s.ol.zo2s^{o\3il-nemqflgRI}
qmfi(1)s{+ffigdd2oo2dH-otrn}
dstrT^qErfi-{ut^qi-rEd{r^dsIsT
Gilfuqg{q-{rft{ro0e.08.202s^o\sttTrKT
frrt^qrtd^qrelfr^{qsr?r-{-qrfrfrfts-q}
e}fudfrtt^qfia1^sEEraTqr$'d^t
HIstfrrqdfttt^TnffiqwitTq
sIlilfiseel/zozsd^qltqqtWq
qrfu-6frz
s{f,gq^{gr$qrRf,sntvr}
frrrlfios.lo.zoze^{drg+fttitgggtE[q}
sItfis-qf,^frtqrq-qltw^{n3ffiq
GTrilfis252/^{zozsiftrfi25102023A}
qrEz-qtsmenelFflsntsr^ftHr6oe'10'
zozter^{fuqr-qqfiTQrFrafrtnqris-t}
Grjtqfttqrrqrt^t
4.B-f,.{rfi^sH6Rr{a^3il-ilfio-t
f,{rq^{qq-flfu-qTqrg-ort t}
5
qd
6
fr ^grfll
qeT e\ sntgr ^qBrr
1
lffr6
I 12.2023 ^{_</sup>
cn
3n-5qN sTq ^{gfl dr}
13.03}

¶6

¶7

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

DESGRIPTION OF THE ORDER DATE	REMARK
3[al f{sq sTrErRErsRi.r^.Frftsvferq Tfl..^rcq/^2oz3
onnffiseTdftIq *ft?t-&{r^ETqt erBqffirt sn{q-rftt-odfufrfrtrgffi. eilYrmrr 1.srrlseTat^oilrttrqf,frd'r$ Tfl.q.^{dfrEh{flrd frsqqq}EqT^rrflI 2.^gth-trro-r^{erqotmqfrtqrrrr[I} 3.ffil-tr1s.ol.zo2s^{o\3il-nemqflgRI} qmfi(1)s{+ffigdd2oo2dH-otrn} dstrT^qErfi-{ut^qi-rEd{r^dsIsT Gilfuqg{q-{rft{ro0e.08.202s^o\sttTrKT frrt^qrtd^qrelfr^{qsr?r-{-qrfrfrfts-q} e}fudfrtt^qfia1^sEEraTqr$'d^t HIstfrrqdfttt^TnffiqwitTq sIlilfiseel/zozsd^qltqqtWq qrfu-6frz s{f,gq^{gr$qrRf,sntvr} frrrlfios.lo.zoze^{drg+fttitgggtE[q} sItfis-qf,^frtqrq-qltw^{n3ffiq GTrilfis252/^{zozsiftrfi25102023A} qrEz-qtsmenelFflsntsr^ftHr6oe'10' zozter^{fuqr-qqfiTQrFrafrtnqris-t} Grjtqfttqrrqrt^t 4.B-f,.{rfi^sH6Rr{a^3il-ilfio-t f,{rq^{qq-flfu-qTqrg-ort t} 5 qd 6 fr ^grfll qeT e\ sntgr ^qBrr 1 lffr6 I 12.2023 ^{_</sup> cn 3n-5qN sTq ^{gfl dr} 13.03}

Smt Narmada Bai Ben versus Aadhar Housing Finance — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

¶10

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE qrExrFwr3il-aqr&gRero fuqTTqI, fdE^qrRd3il-tqrfril-6os.o1.2024d 3i-gql{vf,cqrftseTgms6rfr^.d ffi+orofe1q6dnorsr^ti$ilrc-rfr seTo\snt[WoTmsrqd^tn{tch-t fdrTttgsF6-{wt<fu{ fuu^q-qrvq ft{rfr$.02.2024dtgt,B-f,{qrfrsflo-l crcrlqtrqdEiq[t d^qrqtdsQTrkT: ffiqordfr-g^q{g-{r^.rqrtI	REMARK
	6.GTBo--{'Tdsqaffiq fug16t +1^{"enfro qfl}HRIs-qf,GrilfiX"reN wgt^qrttg^qlqutq$"I
	7.stTilffi^{qm grsr}frr$TtGTfufl{+ GrgsrcorTifuroEn6raffildqT^qT{ tqdfuoq^.rrR+@{/1)Sergun eq-fi'HqfuatTqRfrtwstTil{o oqio2GEq"qEtfu{rfr11.0r.2017 1qtffi/2)^{dorggnsfiTrlqfuo-r} qwrfundmtr
	8.^qTteTFrQrqtatsf,.{rftffiq firarrtdEqftr6 o'rBmqqkq{ 1o,oo,ooo/-(cs drs)sq-So-rxar dqdfuq[,^qqfueil-il{ort-uTt6lftfi sqrrrrqfuo)eqoorzLTtsrqort orenilmTSfuqr,qfusTikfiToqrf, rt(yi@(/3)dergnrvTdtTn.fi. eTr$srqEtBr51qtr$tEtTqfuq QtrT,v.wnlTrnqorfl{rnt,fuEsrTaEF qeTo)q6Era$no1sf,ETfitfid HRrlffrfr0e.08.2023 m) qfiqlftqe{qqrqsrTa1 ('tffi/4) T$t,^qqfu

¶14

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	gq{ {{{r Grarqrsil-Bqiqqil{rfttf,lffi^qfrof'T-i \rq^{eil-itfqqTTuftsTelqlesrfiodiqk} Tfrt,fu{fi^{GttqqqqeTth1sqffr?Fl} oilBqqtiorrqNTfrtqr^qI{EItt^gft 3ilErR^q{{dsrTt{qs-qdfrtqrrqlI^lsTsT frw-qrn-{ffffiq gil-nEqcil{q. ssgt/2oz3d^qTtz[rlt5€q^q-fufr qmes{6ag.{HRrziE{RiE,^qqorR{e Wvq^{durftd frs-qqxtM qtr$ffi} T{e^{zoozd et-f,.fdqrRdsrTarTfuirff} os.1o.2ozsdf+nfitg^fu{m06.12. 2023a\ffiffi^oil-nfiW^ss-dTd fu{i-fizs:o.2oz3o<sup>Tsr{rq3nilfitrq( fuqT^.rqrt,dfu'N6^{eiFooB t}
	e.vf,wrftffiq^dranfttoil{t trqf,frd^.rtsrqd^{qFzFTt qfrqrE} frrqr^q-qlto1^?ifiRl-6w^qrrf,tt{ grrrqdfrtn Tn m"l3lTtfiwffi q.{funo21.0s.2018dcn-g-flRelT-{r$u ffi9,oo,os2/-^{(q\drsfuqrfldrqnd} H)^qr+{)vqtdqf,^{frrolrrqr, ftrfl+1} Eqflr&^{mrftqsi elzrf,qqfus{NI} =iqr^s7/r^{yqssq{ftffif,rr{qR€rf,} dqrgEr.ftilefrn^{rTrrxd frqqq} dilfl-qr^{qfuf,frtqr IHIeTfr}W^froqqa ftHro2s.o3.zo1s^{gqftrofrm-qq1ft{ro} o1.o7.2ooz^(qtffi\rfi.q./z)^trqdfrtqr, fuEzuoft^seTd^{grtf,rTqdrtq{et} .r${6 donqr^rrTqftotffi ,trffiof^T$t,^{qqfu3rl-n{o'qe{e</sup> ffiq€rQn^grrrwrhf, .dxrT}

¶18

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	tF-T frfuo.Efi' srkrrStI{sorTErtt^q{TEd rfi-{urfr$KfrrS^qdstGi-Jr)tr fuqT rrfltt
	10.^qqsil-il<ro^qeTq6oERErtoft ffiqf,xnrT1t1-a1tr6pd,E"tEqk GTQtttT^qflTtilt,olQtt[rqsrfi-firfqfrt, ctqsltcns&re)^qqqEsq[ q6rrrd qsTrSrno1erfi'qqfuwenfroqa orfrffidnEo'\qwrftFotr
	11.sITi@^qeTdeTftqfiWffil-ffir o'rtsrBrrId(rsqi/1)+{IdTdd qFrqrffifl fuo-q^q.{full-601.07. 2oo2^qfiErflsftt,ftffi-dqpq-qt ffiil{rdrTsfr{rwqtcTT{&q{r{r q.r{T/ to-re}ewezooqrfrttefrqTdrd m)fuo-qfuqTI(\ri@{/2)T{qTqr$ il{dgMYrr.{t wrrEStdrdsq{fr Rrme.01.2022aMcofro-qer5q*T q,t,ffi fltqqt^grqqJsssnqqq s7/rolfuo-qfrrSqriorugetrfuqr rrilt wvfi-3i-qfuoq3TBfl-{E{ ffrro11.12.2012of sfrH-flr{trsreTfr fiudldETTigrtrrqq,trEdfu-qr.rqr tfurdGEHIIfr-trnrnfttT.gfunfi 0612z01rd +fl rwto t,lqvmT .nfr'fiHm1s.01.2021o)ouqr.rqrtt
	12. BdrqTfrilfi atoiyts-qf, GIkffiqT^qqfifu-6 HRrwgaxur oil-ififfiT-oos.o2.2o1l(wq,/r)tr
	%rrffi qrfu{ro.21qrd20fid
	Hrerdqsm$"ddsst+gldrd t-{

¶22

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	gKr gtT 25.03.2018 drffid\q rtrqnfd6q^q,fttsfr (\ri-ffi/z)+^qTeTftitrtn^gcdI ft-trflafrf,rfr{erclrdd^seTfr{rGrT sftqrflq^gRIrgar-$2oo2e\fuTfff 1'o^{rtftqd@-qfu-ql,ofsft$6rq$ I} 13.errtffi^{qeTsrqt 3Tftqfiq}{s^oeg o-r^tn-S,ftsdsr€f^{frtqTofzt6B1"} d=nqwRiro^{2s.03.2018o-rfroqq,} 6q^qfrr{^qRReTffiifr^frdnrfi{rdrn t{d^qFrq{Mff gqffi-q-d$nt 14.^{gr+ltKT:3lTilffiqe{q6ffilfrao1;IT} qrfintofftTnrnt{fttT.gffiro 06.12.201ro\d^.defrt^ilqwq-roat frfUfrHrfi^{20o3.2018o\ftrrdIdil{d} q1qq{ffid fr--6q^q.{qz^{Frrdt, fdE{sfrsqt^{eil-nffisnC wE} 3Tqqfiosil+qTW^{qflqqrrilEFId} sqeT^gsfro-q^{w{o\q5<qtBaoarqT} *tnt
	1s.{s^{oTDewro'rderfiffii-ilq\o1} se#TEEq-rserf,I^{o-tqftwro-{ia1} orrq{rrrf,IWerffiort,^ds[-E'ft qk dfiRrdtqd^qFIq{fu{rtr zs.os.zo1aa<sup>egr6+t'd^qrqfud q*hoErftfirdrf,t{frf,T^ftqardlEr tqdE1qTMtr^{qq.tfrqofreqTr} yqftftrfido.q^qaofXa^{uftd qnqqt} qifuTsqkor^qgroqrrlTSfrffi^otuft qfrflgrrdlqfuqT^q-qtt,^(qsrtrF f,rfi^qBnd^{qerfrM{aqqqfrqn} frg-q^w{ ^fr{rf 2s.o3.2olBe<sup>qerq

¶26

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
	qr6N qFilEEIHMYIq rF{ f{qT"ilkrr,ctcrffiF{fffrEqqrefidq-f,r ofswn*unat^qr}.ft
	16.s6iilFBn-ilrosflHRrrqdfrr$ .rtTqrrTrurE{o.rsFTt,Tqo-r qift-qqfr-nfrfi.11.2021 zhiOqqrrrqrt, q}x.ftqfuqfifu-6oi TqrEr=T frd^qdd^q.arnoffrfutqqkat, dwqmFsflT.gFil-urqrofAuf,rat ffi^rFT,sflT.grrnqErdFFRrfr m"ft^qfuqHfrEdseTfrffin fre-q^tr,fttdtrdTdfrsqfrqr$HerrT .q IqTcl{I o-rM r&GTI^qTclT,Tqil6 olTildm^qeTHnIyqirffiTSTqyqrur T,doTTETR^q{trftqd <KlilqqneilAq qrqfirot$TdSsrfl{q{qfrfnqr ffiFdTI 17.{flfidE-tqf,t.h1s[qEm'gqfu d ffirE-rEtriilwrsqqEEqruft qfuqetfu6dseTfrTdErft S-{ttnnn{HMffin W^q-$ftqil fuoq^qrlftio24.03.2018drrlrfrEt To.r^{t,rqsnilkfi-rqdETqr$}GTrqrr{Er ed\gerqdHRTfrqlF{f,ugsuqrd GrtETt-tq{s1-iffi@qrf,2vna{rwTrE
	S+dT^o-rq6rnwrrqomrtHrfi 1s.08.2023e)Bmqe]-fiHqfus{Nr
	qw37/1qtse-IqFqToti ffirW trafrtrf,EtqrqAqrqrqT.rr,Tq sTrA-{o-TTuro}Bm.{rftffiqs{atTd
	sRIxrft^qfudfusqrffirfunofT{
	mq^qq-frftTffio) g{tfttiftt ofi

Smt Narmada Bai Ben v. Aadhar Housing Finance

A compact analysis

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

M/S Pawan Oil Industries versus State Bank of India

Sardar Swarn Singh versus Hdfc Bank

Niwas Shekchhanik Avum Samajik Vikas Samiti and Others versus Au Finance Bank Ltd.

Ms Shree Ram Cotex versus Bank of Baroda

Smt Narmada Bai Ben v. Aadhar Housing Finance

A compact analysis

Case details

All orders in this case

Similar cases

M/S Pawan Oil Industries versus State Bank of India

Sardar Swarn Singh versus Hdfc Bank

Niwas Shekchhanik Avum Samajik Vikas Samiti and Others versus Au Finance Bank Ltd.

Ms Shree Ram Cotex versus Bank of Baroda

Usha Kiran versus Motilal Oswal Home Finance Ltd.

Ms Vasunil Chemicals Pvt. Ltd. versus Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited