Sudarshan Deco Pvt. Ltd. v. Icici Bank Limited

DRT5 Jun 2024SA/372/2024

A compact analysis

This page shows the compact analysis of this judgement. The full analysis — procedural history, issue-by-issue holdings with ratio and obiter, advocates, and paragraph-level evidence for every claim — is being added to the record in batches and will appear here when this judgement has been through it.

PAGE No

CONTD. ORDER^.SHEET

CASE No

DATE gfl.q 05.06	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER geeiq tm'rerfilcfufrts frsq enrg.m.oil{.m.cir-{.il6Werq 72/2024 zoz4GrTt{6se{dfuqfrEtsflfu-6uq-sl eifurmrt sn{qrftt-6dftr+ft^qrgdgtuDqmt 1.Bxrqs&To'rfdffierflerli({^eil-$.q. 2242/zoz+^tt-{IgflrrqTI 2.rt.Fwls-rei-{dtfirTfuqT^rrr[ I	REMARK
	3.orrtroseTHRr^qrrrfi(1@{ftV{e 2oo2der+rT-rIdci-a.i(f{fl.Fzs.os.2oz+^qt} gfl.q.q-qdo(gRqqfuffqmet+mamr qrftdBil-eqlfoil62s.os.2o2soieilTt-FTfrd qfift1sgrrrildHIgIHTsI{-[q-tr{I W etTtsq@rfl{rGilrr<rfrtqrnfiofrrarqor "-rS .r$tr
	4.rDwI^qrgdo{i tgqfuffiCerqt ftr$^qriig wy?rnGntEr-{fuito 2244/zozq{s^GTTEIT-{q{e-{ddfuqT^.rqrtot grcq^q-fufrqfuCetqrrrd^qrqroqr\B-+ etiqil{sTkTrfrg{,^qfua-ufto--qxHRT Gil.fuqrqttetorffi&nfrn +E-nfurrtn 08.01.2024tsnAyrs-tEr=IEc[r,flq^qsrrrfl: qm+qs@qlqldqdsrreTqIEET@qr6 ztzl/zozqlrqdfuql^yorenfiqGlkf,fiTt qrqdtqt€rqrFdorfu{io07.02.2024o} fr{trosfr^.dB^gqeTk{ffirdanr funq t^qrrfl-ftkS^qdfr^Eqft-agonrfitqerril qY.qtr

PAGE No

CONTD. ORDER.SHEET

GASE No.

Sudarshan Deco Pvt. Ltd. versus Icici Bank Limited — DRT (2024) — LawSathi Research

DATE	DESCRIPTIONOFTHE ORDER	REMARK
	s.Bd{flfisH^grgrfr-ffi^{SFIIglT-il{qm-r} I f,{rq^q-r1f,61^{eil-ilqqtnrqfu{rEfuqT}'*^t,i fuflorgrcq^GTIEINt^{qfiq.l-fufiT@qm} ] 2T2s/zozqfuirfi01.02.2024^{o\nrgf,of.r$,} cilftHffi07.02.2024o-rftwfl ofwT"t^?ft gqqR silnffisqTa\srTarT^?Fl5l-;Tf+im 08.01.2024dE\Tor^{er,dc[Hrlrl{fuId eiil} {fl^{GTEo-rurd vlrteTrDwIll-tgdmrFIIan,} fuEfr.ffitutrrplu-rgofrri^.ilfiorot$ 1adqsqool-{urrfrtr^{g-sorrETNqtfrdq} flrrTsil-ilenfr{wfttn^{qfim-tGrJttTfuqT} .rqrtt
	6.^{gsl-rkl:qr+ftqq.q.s@qFIIFTTIguGft-d} Ed{^{dlmelq-{gdqrEror2728}/^{zoz+q qTRd} Gil-tpTftlffi07^q{qft2oz4frt sftd ei-{dtfiEt^qrqrqrf,Ttfu^sil-nroqeTt5Eq qrproffe fursHRr^rTKrr+^vrs$ffiS-+e zoo2dHqETF\d^{ci-d'ff,qrRdfrtnTSsnteT} fuiro2s.03.202s^uh\g+fttitg^qTFrfiT q-qdfrt.rieft,q\qrftqB@^qlrilTrrld HRrWq^{qrfuoqffieC ETrrr14H<srft} -dd^{zoo2q ercqrq\d s-d'idsniqTqftd} o{t&v+qs+{Ifr'qfRfl^{zF{tgvft-ts<or} ftqT^.rqrtt
	7.^qgfusfl^GIkfir-To\fttq^tftqrRa erTeqrfttdErdro-t^.rftaqe-{tatetffim t'r{sEM"rt^srFIqftqTo-rXur^dEq-{ ye-qfr{fi-{urq}'.qtI L^qsftffio tof^gcoqftoffiu furflHRI^{qrfuden&rq-6qetq3n+ql-}t,^crq

¶12

DATE DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK
onarT6-r^q6frqRsrrdtr^q&TCfl"I^mqE3[I q-5+6@$1 e.Wq^q-fu.fiqmefurn^dsrur errfrf,fl{t{rflo<sup>3il-erT61ftqts^{frt} qrt} tgs"BqdfuqT^r-qtt,^{f,qoil-nffiseTgrt} q-qdfrt$.r$faqerqronf{qGvrqar^q, d^qnqqtasfra-fl{t_{rnHRt^}Rd+Er{ ftmo08.01.2024A^{oilEtrtrNGntqroTET;T} *idEet=I^{q{sTfdg{rso{tfi-lot$o-Nut} TSB,^qqfrsTa-ffi^qaC^{asfuqqrd el-fl} {s^{erktr-{tTd rrrtqTFFwIrqdo{tat} 31ffi6r^eft,fuE^gil-ncfrd^{grsrqmftqq.q.} s@^qrilErqeu€ftdE+ d^{q+rTq{fd=lT-tr} 01.02.2024e<sup>qlfufi-I Eqi-fr2728/ZO.Zqq-qd ofT$,s\f+qro^{07.02.2024o\frwfloafr} T{,drf{qro01.02.2024t^{07.02.2024d ff4} oT^gEFIyerfiostcqr^{qTq,aqfietfu66qsa} qdzozqrossGTBo-{,TdsqsxFwIs-t1d d^qrqrqrBqe{rt 10.Tfi-{qfu{to^{2s.03.2024e\s-{gf,fuqT} q-qrB,dtenqBqlfuaBreilclsTtE6s&To-t q\ildfttqqrftqoTkqffir+^gMqrtrET ftrwdri^{tht qITfirer}fuo^$o3.20246\fr T$,eprff,^qTfrrfiTfrw{^{EYifuiTfrt 07-02-} zo24t$.03.2024d^{fta of3i-qEoTB{ffiT} Hr{t^{qr{orftq-SktErtA oTIEINq{Y%n} frri^qrior^{eq<Mfttqrrqtt,fuEveDd} olfr-{ffirorot{^{YI-tTQrqaenfeqd v+pl€41-ra} TSt,furrwt^{qEqrrilEFIltrqrs6aqrflI} of^{qrwqtiGlDrq-ffir}aRr^{3rd{6qaC rrrrr} {dt^qfrrorfr{ffE}t^at{{qnq.frfr'r$ t Tqfrvn{qrft^{qaatgilqt 3rmfrnm T{t}

DATE
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER

REMARK

onarT6-r^q6frqRsrrdtr^q&TCfl"I^mqE3[I
q-5+6@$1
e.Wq^q-fu.fiqmefurn^dsrur
errfrf,fl{t{rflo<sup>3il-erT61ftqts^{frt} qrt}
tgs"BqdfuqT^r-qtt,^{f,qoil-nffiseTgrt}
q-qdfrt$.r$faqerqronf{qGvrqar^q,
d^qnqqtasfra-fl{t_{rnHRt^}Rd+Er{
ftmo08.01.2024A^{oilEtrtrNGntqroTET;T}
*idEet=I^{q{sTfdg{rso{tfi-lot$o-Nut}
TSB,^qqfrsTa-ffi^qaC^{asfuqqrd el-fl}
{s^{erktr-{tTd rrrtqTFFwIrqdo{tat}
31ffi6r^eft,fuE^gil-ncfrd^{grsrqmftqq.q.}
s@^qrilErqeu€ftdE+ d^{q+rTq{fd=lT-tr}
01.02.2024e<sup>qlfufi-I Eqi-fr2728/ZO.Zqq-qd
ofT$,s\f+qro^{07.02.2024o\frwfloafr}
T{,drf{qro01.02.2024t^{07.02.2024d ff4}
oT^gEFIyerfiostcqr^{qTq,aqfietfu66qsa}
qdzozqrossGTBo-{,TdsqsxFwIs-t1d
d^qrqrqrBqe{rt
10.Tfi-{qfu{to^{2s.03.2024e\s-{gf,fuqT}
q-qrB,dtenqBqlfuaBreilclsTtE6s&To-t
q\ildfttqqrftqoTkqffir+^gMqrtrET
ftrwdri^{tht qITfirer}fuo^$o3.20246\fr
T$,eprff,^qTfrrfiTfrw{^{EYifuiTfrt 07-02-}
zo24t$.03.2024d^{fta of3i-qEoTB{ffiT}
Hr{t^{qr{orftq-SktErtA oTIEINq{Y%n}
frri^qrior^{eq<Mfttqrrqtt,fuEveDd}
olfr-{ffirorot{^{YI-tTQrqaenfeqd v+pl€41-ra}
TSt,furrwt^{qEqrrilEFIltrqrs6aqrflI}
of^{qrwqtiGlDrq-ffir}aRr^{3rd{6qaC rrrrr}
{dt^qfrrorfr{ffE}t^at{{qnq.frfr'r$ t
Tqfrvn{qrft^{qaatgilqt 3rmfrnm T{t}

¶16

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER ^fi
	fusrk{ffirofZtrfuf,qerrnftr}^qo-r oilErRTSE)rro.ft IEflfuSw^rrrcft{flrTfi6 qfuqTEfuqrrrqrtI
	11.otrf{o.GrBqffir^gr{-fucrqerqrfrrt^qd tg^qmftqvffi-q^q-qrnqd^qrqEETdW[ tfr wen-qfusqErstrq\qen-qfrtq^qaqfr qrfuorftfra)=iw1266s/zorgfrqtRd
	fofqft{io02Grfd2024,^qFrfrqdrdr Eda'rCtrRT1TS€T ^qsTffi-6frsa^grr.Grr.
	.irqrd?Dur{qrq(stLft.(o)F.281/zozzt
	dfuoftrsfqfuio.zz.oz.zozz ^wqFrfrqrT.s.
	w[Rrr{na-qHTI^qrfuor w.ft.oqio,
	^' ssz+^"^qoTF{tqfri6frrqs[r{.fr.c[r$.fr.
	3rr$.tfi t^qrRfrsTrtqTfufro-o3.ol.2024
	ffino{iggfrdqnn.frd^qfio-rrd TsIttwgf,^qr+{ErdqrT{TvrqFrr.rc 6{igq{sfrd^ch.rftTtfu{srnwrfr Gl-ilffiseT^q6erTrFrf, cD{qrt^qTftT{6 ci-{rrDdErt'fu^qm+qrr.q.6r$ds"sft-d g<)tHI-grqtfrmo-qr62t2B/zoz+qqrRf, srTayrfuffioz^qrqfr2024o-rflqenleoqer o)u6-frer<fu{rfi1s.03.2024o\gGTl{s onqfuiro07.02.2024t$.03.2024d^quzr o1 erqgol^qmrM^qqfErsrEfrqqdord-ld
	yaro.T& fuqr^qrtrndTI{soxqeniroqa o\u-qeruugerilt{fls-fir"r^qdnilfud qfrfuqTqrBcndrtqqfusflsrBoipTo) ql=rftq q.s.wtqrsncqd qr+qeidffi
	furqg{fuqrfdiFq{.hfif{,sfrQ'Eftsqrgd
	![qfdirqsq.ft.=iqq202/zozqfr^Eilfud
	frufqffii-o.12.02.2024Se?D-RrfiAa* tffiI
	sr-ilfio-rx"r dET{frrter"ro{tftt n-

¶21

DATE	DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER	REMARK:
	erffi6$,frt{fisn}ffi^qeTo\frf,qHqT ftrn^qfi&lddq^tnrr{frww;roHq.rrftw TqfK^{.F-,wrqcil-{r}fr+irTt,fu-qoTfu {s scnwrternrqtf 12.srq^qHCg-{-i+^qwtcTgr etBowt o-rrf,tfueiltEq-^qmRqrfi04^qrd2024t fu{r628^qTd2024d^qtzltfr-dqol-^.h)-$ fiolqq+OogqIFreTS^cRslTFrt,^GTQrta strilEoseT^gr{ttrqf,frffierflsltqq Tffi q).qrStt
	13.^rFa-trr$qs-{gf,^err$q 2244/zozq silurrfi.{^qdgvftKfuqT^qraTtt'q^qE fuil.fud^p-{tEgfusil-nffiseTil-{I^q-{dd ecnwrcn-qE^qrB-dt,GntxurCv^q{Et^qt-{ qtq=rStrq-{gdq6Tfl.q.yz/zo22cn-qE ilftdfuriRiro{igv$ft{n{^qtfr.rwfuqT qrortt 14.V+tq^qeTsTrr;TT-3ilrqT^qqqFTot)^r
	15.^qRunqd drrr6wlsTffisrqxt g{fudwr^qr$ t ffi S.em.EFqGE@ q-@ FH

Sudarshan Deco Pvt. Ltd. v. Icici Bank Limited

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Shri Sanjay Awasthi versus Cholamandalam Investment and Finance Company Ltd.

Rajendra Singh Rajput versus Aspire Home Finance Corporation Ltd.

Smt Abbu Wo Shri Genda Lal versus Uco Bank

Bank of India versus Shyam Hare Sahu S/O Bhijram Sahu

Sudarshan Deco Pvt. Ltd. v. Icici Bank Limited

A compact analysis

Case details

Similar cases

Shri Sanjay Awasthi versus Cholamandalam Investment and Finance Company Ltd.

Rajendra Singh Rajput versus Aspire Home Finance Corporation Ltd.

Smt Abbu Wo Shri Genda Lal versus Uco Bank

Bank of India versus Shyam Hare Sahu S/O Bhijram Sahu

Idbi Bank versus Shyam Manohar Pachori

Ms Goyal Metallics Private Limited versus Union Bank of India