Allowed

Ms Mobile Shopee v. Bank of Baroda

DRT19 Dec 2024SA/323/2022

Case brief

AI extract

What is this about?

This judgment addresses the issue of estoppel regarding a department's system of honouring cheques. The court holds that a department cannot deny a practice inherent in a fixed salary system.

What did the court decide?

The petition was allowed, and the negative observation regarding the cheque on the basis made earlier was vacated. The department was estopped from denying the system of accepting cheques due to the p

Ms Mobile Shopee versus Bank of Baroda — Cheque Dishonour | DRT (2024)

¶1

¶2

Vfl.^(. frt -ezs/zozz

¶3

u-q^q{{fr orBo-wr \rl6lslg( fi.r.w uds-1q {rw)

¶4

(ft-dxft{ 3Tffi -^qTT+q +fr rrq ft-qm q}d)

¶5

Ys..^;i{t -aze/zozz

¶6

1 M NE cfft^qu-s ered, arr Mei M^gdr sFr^3Trflvr g,ffq wtr{r sFr ss o-fu +z q$,

¶7

2 ,ffi \r*qrT srl cfu g,fu qrtr( grl ss 6fi-q 73 s{ (.nq-cr),

¶8

J ffi orcrril-fl^grq gfr rs=ftq wtr( sFr, ss o-ftq 40 s$ (qn"et), trtfr Frfl1fr^{q.i. gsz qrd} ie-r +r ffi o--sfi=Sd +f, g,f (u.,r astoot)............. ...sTrt@-rfrrt-ur t

fr--s-€

t-r ofr'w.^q-<r EqdT fr"s, zB RTs-{rq^{qq-iilfufi qfrs{ qr} E-<-{irTE-d drz-d d^{qtr{ gq-f,T} ft-dri fq-dT 5rf (u.T) er?rYr$-w orrht{ri , fu-dT^qftrrfi grf F.T) 4e1oo1,

¶13

3 n-flftf,-{ll fu-dT g,f (u.r.) asroor,

¶14

.,?

¶15

2 gs. q. ix -szs/zozz

¶16

¶17

qYdq-( qdq ntft Grer"r 6 fl-r ffi rzs, srg iq{ so, tw cRI ..fld cnT d.frw. gif fu-f,r gif (u.T) verrqrfirg t

¶18

3rrtffi^qe{ d lfrq sft nrfui 3i-6T( erBq-ffir t

¶19

sn {rfr +-o d ftq fr 4q-n gt erfuq-ffir t

¶20

erq vorqrfrrrur or oY{ sfrfrk€ =r€tr

¶21

3TT t YI

¶22

(kqio fi.tz.zozq d eifr-d)

¶23

qrfq-{rrur srr friro rz.oa.zozz o\ u-rgn Tfr\d^rlttqq t na-o: fr.r Wtrit fd:ir6^2s.o1.2ozz, oilfu[fl W+cr k{io 30.0s.2022 o-} erqrr< frr} qri dI ri-orirdr d srer er< ergniFr-o is-6rqdr^gq erm ffi oT sr-gtq fu-qr^rrqr I ir.f,wqrfl Tfrl-q d^qnqq t fuf,r^qfuTi" g,f^gnT cIRf, sIrtYT friro ts.os. zozs \ti ffi rp-lt ktio 24.01.2024 d ergs-<rr n sqq^ql T{ ffi oTffi ftqt-fi ze.oz.zoz+ \ti En ffi d^qRoffi { ncn ftrn Td^q\o wrERde o\ 3ilrn<r frd^q.d o1 worcror il$ .r{ t r 2. srr'dq-r^qs of fri t u-go ftd^,r$ gfl.g. oT trelq^qr+ u-6N tr{flrfua t of ernflT"r i vmr-qrfr d-o t emd rlqfu ssc' T{r 7u /4 e}Tw-d o.osz t{e{

¶24

¶25

Vfl.^g. nqt -32s/2022

¶26

Rero o-sQ-Se eTrEct T'R fu-dT grf^qq Hrq^qtrfi qfuo ot 366soooo/-(ftq s-is fuq-fld drcr^qqrcr rqn) vqS ffiq s6rq-aT srw fu'qr, fu-g B-<rqsrfr +-fr d^grr enil{fi-rror or atc -6-r$u-d vc.ft.q. sftq-f, o-q frfuo crqqn\ oI vd.q{ o--{i gq^+itrr ra++r o1 m-ffi frri R-fl^tiwo rrqfu or sIIBciq s-6"r si{i &^fu* 30.03.2022 o't (\i@i \ / 1) +t t;d{r e-o-rRrd at^{.T{, q-qfu} Vfu-d derm ffi ft--s-€ t, ffi erqB wqrq e\ g+t t r

¶27

o',1^qfuow t sft 3nfU-fi €--o-e d' orq-{E d^grr olfrt srRr rnqr o1 T$ t, fr,t fi otfu-s rg^{qarqrft qfr} cRReft^qr fuqR frrt ft-iT sf,{srfr d-o. d ErT Srfq-rT g-fio entro-,t t A ftw rr{ffi '{e d 3inrff, ETffi tr{flrFfd o-r fr^.r{, q-qfu srr'trq-o qer i eilfl qg ftfl-sr ft{;6 re.or. zozz (gifl{ /2) d^qr-qra vorqrft d-o t d-r g-fir$ue o\ R@{ frrt qfi tg 3rqTaqq ldlo zr. 01.2022 (qt@i^q,/3) e-{g( frrq1, fu-{ Bffirqrfr t-fi d am ot{^q-ar{ T€t fuqrrqr t,^qfro eniEo^qer @rili-fi-q rifuTF d s-gd-( 300-q d efffi otqfr rrqfu A frw fr sm 3rffii o-r sdqq mri gv oTffi 3rlR-d of^,r$ 'q frrr rpm R-rio 2s.o1.2ozz Fl-e*^{q,/4) iB-d a1 T$, ffi} fr-$-€ srilffi^qeT i sil-qfu srlqfffi^qrn 13 (g-q) Brffi v{d d srqqTqrgr{ri 1q-i@r q/s)^q-rg( fuqT, fu-g vf,{qrft

¶28

¶29

gfl. q. iqt 4zs/zozz

¶30

qeT HRr 3nfuqs ti of oTffi qkTfua o-q fr .r$ {qE 3il-Bq.q Wd{r o1 asrflIfr, tw utDTTrt, qfurrf, drffi ot o-rffi r& qff ,r{ I

¶31

,,1^qft-ow t of fi-{q e (r) (z) (5) (6)^(?) rl-6q"8f, ftqq e Bi$S vtre 2oo2 d vrqErii o-r set,iq{ orfr gv dc 'fi-rso-c of ew.fr.err$. d frcr frtYil d ffid '{.fr.q. s,trq-( oq^qqd flffi \ s-{f,rfud e1 T{.* t'q E)q' g$ n-ffi t^qrq 6l^qupl of T$ t fufld eilErN^q{ UEq^{qrfuo qfuee} g,f d rrqeT oTrilfi c-rE( or Ets Wi sniyr fti.rf, $.o3.zoz3 ww frrqr^.rqr t,^{q. ftq-<l-{^q}.q c.€t t r €cNri d qnaq r\ orBfiQrc frri .rd oeal d ei-g{{n erilro qa ffif, *^{q qr$Iflr} o-d or 3r-Jtq o-{t € fr-i fi ls-m-{qrfr d-o d sM ('i@r /6)^q Efq yyf GrrtpT slw o-r frqr^.rqr t nipr fr oerq fu-qr^.Tqr t ot srqq^{7p] .r$} ft-flfr 6rzffi $-d t t gc armt w qifuo sarqm or er5du fuqr rrqT t t}

¶32

s. Tiyilw GIrn({^qr$.!. zozs,/zozt I ffaq t 3rBfisn fu-qr^rrqr t^q,t ffi 6r-ffi frqrfi za.oz. zozq d T{ ori<-fi^qa o\ so ftdrs oft q+tr u-<n T€l ot^rT{, Efu ftqq e rl{Sffi sR{ 2oo2 d Hsqni oT scds;r ord gV ffi 61ffi of^,r$ t r

¶33

vtr{qffi t-f,^gRI ft-{if, 2s.11.2024 o) T{TilBd gs.q. m-r^q6mr s-{g( a-{i gq GIftoQl-t frrqFrqr* of fr,r ia++ ft=iro 2s.01.2022 1gi@T

¶34

¶35

gfl. q. tq< -szs/zozz

¶36

oTx/i) d frs-q u-qa frri^,r$ Grlqr+sq ol uqti pqqio zs.os.zozz (gifl{ qR/z) }fud o-{i d crqrfl oil-fuc-q tau-rt ft-rio 30.03.2022 (vt@y 3rR,/3)^qt1 qfurrd dffirfr, T{q-rflfr, tqi e-6lqrc 1q-i@i sTtt / 4), ('ifl€Iri/ u), e-i@{ slri // 6),d ergr+n four .rqr t't HrRr qtrm fl dtso[ q, (\i-@i srx/7), {apJ g 31fopem ftrqr rrqr t of 6ifus rg rarqrft d dlTq sf,t-qrfr t-r t em.fr.err{.d ftnT td:r d ergrm 3rris-6 seT FTer fi Trtfrq fuqr t, fu-g enfro va or otc -{-rsu-e frrtrXd o-{i aY.q r€t^{qt, qfu g{.} qq s.fi-E-d oq orffi 3fl'tfhd ?fr, fu{rd ffT qf.T r5+lr ifuo of^.T{, fuflfiT^qroc rS e}i w^qqo rlqfu or enfuqiq fuqr^.rqr t nlq fr ERtr{^qfuez grf d^qrrllcrrr t frfu $qo entcI ftito ts.os.zozs srq fu-qr^.rfl t t

¶37

vcrqrfr fo or eTBfial-c^g uX sYS€ g€ zooz d^qrqETrfi \d frqq e (r) saqBo ftqq^g Hidffi sffi 2002 d^qrsqn) o-r^rrleFr or-i gq sqli oTffi rrqq a1^.r{ t t gc ailq-tt^qr 3r-t(o vei gr-il e-t3d gfl.q.ft{tr ftrn qd ot ergtrq fr-qr rrqr Br

¶38

vrFI seT d erffi d^yq1rT d ftq wq ffiqd:-

¶39

¶40

Tfl.^q. tx -eze/zozz

¶41

(r),- eqr frl rAult foqt6 zs.or.zozz (gtfl{ snr,/1) dE Wf drm-q e{crfl fu,} rnri q}'qt?

¶42

(z):- rw sTIBq-iq r{-d{r ft-{io 30.03.2022 (\i-@i snr,/3) ds Wi *ov erqrw frri qdq}'qB?

¶43

(s)'-^qqr fu-dT cfrrqc g.f am crRd Gl-irT frqisrs.os.zoze (\i@i /6) errrrftT frrn rnri fr.q t ?

¶44

(a):- rw ffi r{-d{r ffi-6 1a.e1.2024 g-drYn frqio z+.ot.zoz+ slE {tt d-{T oTtIrkT frrn^{qri q}.q} t ?

¶45

(s):-wr frqio zs.oz.zozq d e-{flrfuf, ffi orffi lqB W sfu-qr d fr-s-€ d'i d o-nur 3rrrr<r frrn^qd dFq B ?

¶46

(o):- varu-or Vq^qq Z

¶47

qK qFT + fin fue-+ t,-

¶48

e. vf,rqrfr t-fi d Er{r fuim oaiz.zozq d rqo fu$ Ti fufu( ild d^qrqq t silqfu fr Ti t d^qrilfr rarr Hro 24.01.2024 o1 silE)fr--ir frrq qri or ot{ eTftqq-{ w.q. fr T€f fu-qT .rqr t c fr ffi qtm u-<Rto^{qft ..T{} t, e-c arrA-q-{^qer o\ q1{q sqf,q qrqrers 6 Eeio (zorr) e gs.fr.fr. +so d s-otvl t w{ ftq-q t 6t lTarrar^qri o-r Efi

¶49

¶50

gfl. q. iq< -szs/zozz

¶51

Tfr t I Hrer fr m.r q++r, effiq-e q+cr, fq-dl qfuQe Srf gm clfud slri., +f,Fft tafir, vwc g{ ffi oTffi at Atrf,r o-r rrqet{ o-rd gq r{df, {-iqrar^{sfrilfi (sro.t'e751} \rfctc^{t cdtE.} l-{-rsu-c^(voJu-e7o) d^erSwn Edgqz^{f+st gm} Bqri ffi {rRT ftqi-6^j2.03.2024 @\ s+aaarco/-(d-{ o-fi$ ffii{ orv er.eotfr rwv sro rt) v.ri Eiqrfl ti or oes {qd gq wg( Ts.. ft{w frrt^qri or Grgitl fu-qr^.rqr t r

¶52

frc:-^qrfr ffiq er-n o-) rfl-nfu-( w t frd-.rcl tt +f,-i ftq.d t{qr w ra t :-

¶53

ua E-wnfuf, frE t fu^qe xoft^qeT oTkfi-{'l d vqer^qnl 17 (1)^q-ffi \rqe 2oo2 d slqtTni d Gir.fd Grr-iqc c-qo o{ vcrqrfr *o^gm unr re (a) oTam err{r r+ rs-sfrrfr gqe 2oo2 d Gff-( of fg orffir of 3rreifuf, o-ror t, Ts sf,{qr-ft^tio w^qe. qqrc-fl-0 cirfr B o1 qs qqrft( o.t of frfufi srqtrri\ d ugo^e^qquf 6dq8^{qqq qJ ,r$} t Erfr EBo}"r r\ srq {s srn{uT^ri Etirt-(r f,sq)^{qq qrorNt} or qfrer"r 3iltl&..fl t t

¶54

sf,rqrfr t-fi^gr-*t e-tro frtd Tn trfltr ftqio zg.oo.zozz d wrer fr.r Wqfl fur'm 2s.01.2022 of eft (\i-@i oil-r/1)iiam of G B, d ct{t-d ffid fu{io 22.0i.2022 d ergvm trd^qilfr 61 ift-a fu-qr^qrrT r{infufl t tio ffid d erSsx ft-+o

¶55

¶56

vs.^q. iq< -azt/zozz

¶57

28.01.2022 oi wd d NeY gt< un o\ m,r qan Mfl g$ I erns-o gft un o1^qfurrf, qzr+ r+ aot^qfu rf,tr^qn vq r-o erq d^.ft ln RfrC d 3rgwii ffi6 za.or.zozz d^+ii',r q+tr a1 f,tffi E)-{r crqT^qrflr t t

¶58

srrnco ceT t ,TD-qf, GTRf,Ffr d 'TH w Fiffi^{sn</z) or silqfu orqrnfi x"ft q-d} vq \r!li(1ql( gi{ BTr of asw ri erRgifr;o }&f, fu-qr, fr vf,rqrfr t-fi d^qqrq d 3i-grai trq zq.os.zozz d^qFil Esn, fusol voq fuiro 2s.0s.2022 ffi gro ftqio zl.oi..2o22 d qrtqq 1i s{ d ffier oi ifuf, fuqT^.rqr t, d wfr iro eriffi^qa of uzra sncfu t^qfi m.T qan fuiro 2s.01.2022^q,1 frB-{d drffi oir-a-{6.^{qeT q{} r-e E-$,^qa enqfu {ffi C',q rS t vq erqfu GFqfffi o-T {rrrr {fiqr d eTCi f,fl-o-tuT^tnq moft^qer o) rtlfid frri^q.ri d erBrx cr ifuf, fr-l ra+rr frB vrqo erTFra etft B r

¶59

w Ewrft-o frE t at frilfr^rfr etr6 Hqfu of ffi offi eFrRf,^zF-{i d q{ sfl rlqfu or Gnfuq-iq^qT d ft{q e (1) (z) vt+ffi ver zooz d qTsqr+rgsx oTQrt[ qrrr r+ rnffi vqe d ffn nerq Grffi gxr^qftf, srTtcT d Fqreq t^qtw fuqr^qmr G{ftqld ttVqr s-o-{or d ffi orffi l]qq d t, q\ I].h-f, 1-S, frrg fudT qmc S,f il{r qIRd 3il-+qr ft{io is.03.2023 d frqrfi fr eErm^qqfu or

¶60

¶61

¶62

Vfl.^{q. iq<} -szs/zozz

¶63

sil-Bcr.q wq ffi^qri or et$ oerr+o c-fr t, dq F-qq I (1) d crrq^if onDv-e qmr iBo o< "srflft,^{tqiutFTqFI dqIEFI tdrfi s-qfu} or enBcfl frrn^qfi o1^{znrffi q-1 qflur} d-{r sTrqq{fi t t

¶64

or-{rn{fi sef^gm oTrEq€ v1qrr a1^qfr giffi en{,/3) ftqt6 so.os.zozz io.c d^,r$ * t orBErdr i1;++ d Gi-g{ry^tierfi r{qfu gilq^qn d r-$$T^qn d rrrsr-Tflq ffi orq-qxr sFi vq ffi e-gtr rurft-s di sqfu t, 3larfd ft-{t rig_ff rnrfut @\ sr'fuqg qm ol^qfu.rf, il-ffi^t6t f,sq e11F1-6 o-ri or Erqfu sm-{qrft t-o^qq t t^gr s<{ n sm-<urft ilo^grr u-tgo frri^.ri Xo s-qrq d r+rpr +o-c +sd ftrfu fr{ie. 30.03.2022 d uwx gdr qFr, 3rrrril-r{ sn, rr$-qn sn o) ilE{ nkd fuqr qrqT rrn-fun t, fu-g in RctC d ergwx gi< un gs {f,flr qn o\ ftqio sr.og.zozz d sro offi-a d, fo-g erorrn ren t tt-RiB-( GnCf6-i{ rinr^qn o\ Hd-€{ fu-qr^qnr t-r Rcti d crgrm s-'re +flr t, orqld oil-i{fi ca e1^qs enqfu Brttrri rfr t o1 Giltkor^q-qio s srtl-rrrr qn o) 3ilBq--.q rp++ ot qkrrd ffi q-S of .r$ t r

¶65

\Jil6r eE {srflft o-r dQzr t sft (Vi@T 3il{,/6) d w it Ts1-qrft^q-t 3iTIII fue u-sgm fu-+r qrcr rwrfuf, t, fu-g vs Erfl fua or erq-oto-q o{ <....

¶66

¶67

's.^q. iqt -azs/zozz

¶68

T6 crgqrr o6 ftoror^qT R$flT of frtfl ftiluF o) q-d{r of atqm,ft o1^.r$ t *i u-gd ftd .ri wqrs fr^.fr wr frsq t^cfr sf,r-qTfr^qs i we oel{ T€l fuqr o1 fu-s ffi-6^qi "aqTTrft^{oTffi a1 .d,} u-qfu 3il-il<o cel i srri Grftq-q-r fr o-€t^q-6 do-R T€t fu-qr et vcnrqrfr d-fi d^gM oilBvrq qa-<r ero t+qk. d Ew srrT^qr o'fi .fr^qrqT fu-qT t,^qfu ftd^qa o-o of vf,rql,fi +-fi t frfuo Hsqr{i oT qlcFi frtn ft-rT rfn) 1qi@i /1) d qtzFr t qTBq-iq +i q,t otffi e-{flfrf, or frqr, erertf, oqqTc d snqx^{qr q-6} FEF{ TS F-fiTdr v.rS,n o1 G[]<o gir un gq €fiT stl s{ ftqio sr.og.zozz e\ 3il-fuTiq rptmr of^qfu.-'rd il-ftd d er.{ fr "wrflrfr^{oTffi of ,r$ Enfr, q-{fu enteo qer i} erra-{r o1 o-F-sf,r s.zo it rqe erft-qa{ frrqr t ot qicm.ft oTffi frri ft-rT ftqq e (1) (z) n-r$ffi rd{ 2002^q;r sts=r ord gv s{Tt^q,t orffi ot .r$ tr

¶69

el^q-c e-otqrfr d'o^gm u-rgo ur+r fua (qi-@r Gil-i,/6) tt^qo ei-gfln o6 ftorm^qT rstnfl of fu-q frqio d fu-n^qeTrq w^qrq-flft e-tffi ot .r$ gs vf,wrft qe{ gM u-tEo eft+a-l t ,fr gtt rlql+^rt ot{ orq re t, E-qfu ft={q e (r) rrq$qfr $Rl 2002 d^qrqqTq erElrdto B, fu x"ft^qeT w n^qfrilTf, drffi d snBrs qalr of^qrsq-tv

¶70

¶71

Vfl.^{q. cq<} -szs/zozz

¶72

Hrer^qraT dqo uqfu d Ew^{rnq q{} tw u-6rcn d [d^{q-*vrrTft srM} t^{aq sm-rrrffifi sqrur $ 3mrrq} d^{qa qqrFrd} rS t et ftqio os.oa.zoz2^{q ftd^yq erffi rrqraR^qa t eilEcs q++ noiRro o-ri^q' Xd^{qrr-o qqfu d} Ew^{srrT q{ srTfuqiq qfir a.{qr} of Ti^lft, aq tq{ mrqn et olffi X@-6h Ef qrfrBr}

¶73

ftqq e (1) (2) Hffi $d{ 2oo2 qrqqFr vgo fr we t fu-c-t oti r{RqET r-ff t, Grarff, sFi-fl oq t yem ilt sn ot{ srcrerflT Tfr t, o-ai or il-dd t of eem Hqfu or eilBre +i at qfu-qr ilfr Wi qrfr qd-rfr, qq wrqfu d r{,fr wrfrdi w enfuqiq i1+lr afi^Eqfurrd drffi erTFIa *i d rnpr fr Gfl'fuTs r{Ir tv d^qrc-q i^qq-o rrqfu w qrn of T{ dr, \d qfurra drfi-S qs q{qrflrfr i z fu{fl d oiqr tq{ fr^q-6rRra ft1 Tg d fur{it tt t.o nE^qrqr o-r d t {s ctnwl^{tl qqo} rtqfu + tr,fr wrfut w erertd ffi eroqnr^{qFr rN} s6t 3il-Bkq rp+ri o1^qfu.rf, drffi^qqrFrd re t, s-St snil<-fi gir un vs r-f,flr sFi c{ drffi fr rrp1-$tv ffi ft-{io d^qr tcr^qtnrcn d z ftcq $^qq-o Brqfu d' Ew strr^rR Gfl-fuq.q r1++r o1 arsrl.rft or osa fi Tfl'Frf,^q-S t, oralff,^qrilfr @rffir wnrfua ilt d W^{qq-{ rrqfu or ftfu tlqo affi tF-{q e (1) (z)}

¶74

1,2

¶75

's.^{q. tq<} -azs/zozz

¶76

qvs{ft t-f,{ 2oo2 d urotn+qrm 3ilfuq-cu flw ffi q.ri of ,6qT sqrFrd r& t t

¶77

Gi-q^q-6r n-6 ftdffi 6rd-{r$ a1 dqor or src t, {$ rr<d^it sflrqrft cer^gM frRfi 3rrqfu B-drfr^rr{ t of srks"n d erqrq^tt Gr-a-q-o^qeT ffi raalr fuiro 24.0i.2024 1 g+-fr ti or ao rS {scII I gs umfu d s<+f t seffiq oeq t of^qr e-o-{q^ri oil-n{fi ceT^gxr riyinn Grr+q-{ ftqio zo.o+. zoz+ en$.q. 267s/zoz4 d mqq r) ffi W+cT ftiro z+.or.zozq d 3i-grJ{ur t wqq of T$ {-flft orffi ftqf6 ze.oz.zozq d sndfro o-{i tg {SErr fu-qr^rrqr B r nrpr fr t-d r+rEfrrd-e ftrw or rlqfu or enBqs g{-tarTfr-d frt}^qlt o1 rrarcor^{qt.S .r$} t t l-qfr Grktr fu{flri f4-o $ntrq GrrA-fi^q 4erfr orffi d frElrq ds oT^q"h r-fr t, fu-g rerm or'dd[-{ sd.g. rzrsl2024 ffir' 20.02.2024 d ffaq t 3rkfi-{q d sqer erqfu m^,T{ t of nqq e^gs e qr$ffi t-ctr 2oo2 fl vrqo ort gv ffi otffi er{Tfr-( of Ti t, uo r3rvrfuo frB t^q1 sq ffi sTkoqq lt.ft.fi. d vrqqT-r)^q ftziko n& E)-dr,^qfro ffi{^qrq Rrqio ET ci-gtrrq o< ercrfr vfu-q^etq-+ e-m-ar t, irq sflw[fr seT^{znr qa} ad r+mr{i^q},s Tfr t at orF-q-fi d snrH fr ffi ryn vo ffi o.rffi^qX dtror o.T oaq cfreror fr'q T& t I^gq qRqqMi t Gilil<-{ qeT o\ qmfiq sakr-rr qTqtdq

¶78

¶79

Vfl. . tx -ezs/zozz

¶80

d^qrcgqia zorr^(e) \q@ r\ B-erflT fr--s-€^qrflr ffi t !@ @ otqTfud l.S fu-qr^qr rro-ar I

¶81

're. o\ u-c aTrfffi ver t u-rgo {aryri * *ichm srA-{il d^qrtqq t ffi Wq-{r^{fr=im zq.ot.zozq d} 3rgrJwr t wq.q ftt T$ ffi oTffi ftqiq za.oz. zozq d srrtf&-d fu-qT t, flq sdrqt-ft d.o w^{zt-E qR} t of ffi Etffi sfr Aq-dr 6-r^(Qs ErT,ra q-t<rNl d qpqq t yfl'Fm of r '{fu sffirqTfr d-f, d anr refl-i 3i-rt(fi d^q-qrq fufo zs.z.zozs d qqq t srQrqr dd d +irc q6 da4 c-St {rc.I .rqr.B sn wflrfua ffi eTffi cc-qrd-q-ff^pi, trc^aEq-rc F-6-rdT^qrtTr o1 krro 2s.02.2024 o'r wq-q of T{ ffi +Tffi s?rq m^t6rffi?fr, fu-s t-g E"t ca o) ftq-q 6 G) E-i$qfr t-tr 2oo2 d vreurrrgrm qTdq eo k{fl $ ffi r1a-+ of^qfurd drffi GrFrqd tr vrpt fr effi TnM A fty fi ffi rI-diT oTffir fu{io t 30 fuq-fl T{ e-frrRrfl dlT stffi B.r W EM"T t ffi Wqqr friro rs.or.zozq fr dffirfr^q{qrflft gs^qo.trrc oT oea^{qfreT"t q}.q} t I

¶82

errt@ ceT^gmr wfl-1 silt{i ftt'1+ zo. 02.2024 d ffaq t we eTrqk B-dtfr^,T{ t o1 3l1ilq-6^rru1 c{ ffi ra++ o1^qfu'rf, fl-ffi T& dqfrffiv1a-rTot orrq-e of T$,

¶83

¶84

vs.^q. iq< -szs/zozz

¶85

ererid ffi rp-rr o1 crfd \ri Tsrc-rft o-r^(Q4 ffi{f, fu-qr^rrqr t t W Rqlf^q s-crqrfr cm^gmr ftq6 zs.oz.zozq d u-qo fui^{.rt qqrq} d^qqq t u(Krnq u-go fr;i^.ri d, sr-d 3r-q-et*.-{ r}^qrqr qrar t +t fu{ qmt d flq q{ ffi W++r^neo gi B-+ ra+rr offi-a rfr g$^{qfu qY.{€tq} d rm qr<-fi-df + vi-ll d sw"d-F.-c" o1 Ac qd or si-fi qrqc{ at .r{ yq -o-Rqi-i d er5vm ffi zo.ot.zozq oi^qe ffi si-o ffiqq o-{i tg^q-dr} T} yFs qr qEqr, nq qrw-mat q-6i Tfr fr-mr, qfu ie-+ q'alr fri^y$-tr de gtm^qn vq ifuo ero ivo o)^qrqqr or fr Ti, d?16 d $TE t o1^g{r's-*rrrr d f,!fr qer o\ ffi q-d{r a1^qfrtrm ilffi T& gi t r

¶86

or-neo va t x-qn Tfl.q. t erciT u.) gs^oFi-o fuq t,^{B-ift q-ifl q.c.} asz^{qrff+g +r} ffi o-i{fi-S6 til-fi g,f 4eoo1^{q{ q)-{<tq} ftnT 20.01.204 d flfirfr tg cgdT, oc ar-t{fi^{qa q-a} edi TS fr--flr,^qA cqrprf, o-Ei or oeq t, \ilqfu GilA-{fi ceT i reFH srrle{ ftt'm zo.oz.zozq d vn'er erffeo gili srt or "il yrtr?d q-{ .i6rq fuql, Bst fi TS gs^oFfo t d sn.q.^{d'ei.q er}-d fr t sq^fuim 22.04.2024 @\ rstfi 3rra-{q d wq ua^{ti ..ff} gilt sFr er -tsr ffi orrfi=St +fi sFfd t,^GTQIIa qR sntrq-o qel vf,{fl-fr d-o' e1 qfr-d frt} BlT ytsr t-q os fuqr +dT, d alffi ftq1-6 zo.or.zozq d

¶87

¶88

Vs.^{q. ;i{t} -323/2022

¶89

qr-urn e-qd frri rr} yTqer qil { otg €i-q vFs +f,r, ftrrrqrr sil.Trs t \ii B-f,q-qrfr t-{ of oiri t^gs frEq t ot{ drn^yqr"r rqo rfr fu-qr^rrqr B fu f,rffi tr qm{fl or eqt + fr\ zot qa i q-Ftr tq tnt fuqr t, e-q^qR vfi^qr-{ +rt:iq^q-drn Tn cfr w iTrffi tg cgsT^gs swm-dt T& ft-dr, nq^qd ci-gqn ,6 ftoror uil vf,-f,I of vl<-fi-df^qn-{fl ot olffi d^q-qor {6r t E-Efu i-r RdrC d ergvn ftqi6 zo.or. 2024 s'l drffi 6r \rfi^{ql-r q-ilr-q} fu-qlrq B t cl(^tlYrl lcl sr?F^qFNr os fr Tg t

¶90

Grrr rlRI 27^{qqrdqdr+q yf,c} d yrqqmrgqm crw-srdi qd qt c ffi, * q gfoo olffi^{qrfr qffi} t, fu-d uq frrfi^qfrn or vn+1 rrqfu w rcfuTF A offin^qtw dqrfu{ ro d {rreTuT 6l^qe=I Eltl^q{ d, aq vo^qn c-q[g d 3ilqR q{ silEntro q,qqri\ 6 sr-{tqr o.-{i d fuq drtrr of sqtnqun^qrqtrd fr sfuf,^qfr rft, 6rrq of F=qq e (o) wrdft sN 2oo2 d erSwx ;nut^qk w ffi iltrcr o1^qfu.r-d drffi uru-6o t t

¶91

V's-d^EreT fr^erq vf,i-qrfr^q&T sRr ffi ga-+ of^qrqrrft, tw s-6-ryrq d oeq qi tsr^qrq a) (qi-ffi en{.ern./z)d w t^qssrqrft d uiqr fre \idrq frrn^.rA d, sil ts-i t tqT e-fi-a d-dr t dt^qfu rym wrt d^{q-qo tt} Rerfr gor<, 'il w. un. ffi d clq of t, w^q-w-rflrfr offi of T{,

¶92

¶93

Vs.^q. iq< -gze/zozz

¶94

d TqT stm golt sfl^{yf,{ur qfi qqfi'} T{qk, q-c1t1fuo t1fr, ro-r qw{r iw zat/q d-{sd o.ogz tft:{ +w.F-fl0-grd en<st TrR dorqr$ ilf,$-f, fr-f,r grf of wqfu, E\ g'qi^qn, ffi Gm-rINI^qFI vq qrFs srr d rig-ff {sTft-s of t, or qrq t r gqr oeq o.r^yqlur ElrT sG,^q-qfu 3trns-r cer i ffi rg+tr +1 etrfi r{Ecfu w^qEqr+ft ftrn qri d oea si ffi fu-qr B, eplio l+ori^orfr fu-qT t, frrg s-ffiwrft ce{^gxr nqn ftri^,t-i .n-fls ftqiq zg.oz. zozq I {fl frw i oti vqe^qri-{ Tfr fuqT^.rqi t, fud^g.r+r fr oer^.rqr B o1 (vi@-i en{erx,zz) ffi qa-rr ffio fi.01.2024 Mrg rrY-. d gtq srll' c{^q*q fu-qrrqr, d^qq-o nqfr of^qrqm rffi d ft\ c-qiq r-fr t r

¶95

ffi v{q-{r oT^qtrpr"r frrn^qri t H*ifu.d rfirqn^qe o1 urqr cfr (yi-@y en{.ent/g) vs (qiffi en$sil-i,/+) wgd t, fur-d erq-oto-q t {d c-Te r& 6tdT fu fu-tr wqrqrs^{q={ znr qrrT} t t^qqfr E-{i-d-s fr ft=fr T{sn.lx^q" i Cfi-fi^lTrs-r frnrfi z+. o1.2oz4^yq eiffi TrrrrETN c-fl i s edqr^{Griq. gtr€qT} ftii-fi za.or.zoza fuq^,rqr t, fu-S rfl frqq t^gn srkfi-irr gxr^qrR-d frri Td telrq eneyr ftil-fi 11.03. zozq dl^o.Fso-r rz r) zr d^qtq of T{ ftE-ut d qrtqq t sf,<-qrfr to or qq Gil-+ff-a ord gq ofi-sfrr-2i i nqrqrr^qe d o1 rrFrqor w

¶96

¶97

vfl.^q. iqt -ezs/zozz

¶98

aq 6-{t Eq sffwrfr t-6 t{^{qtr'rrffifi qrw q-{gf,} ori^q,t erieTr at T$ t, fu-s fi o.lorf, v+qmn^qii of sryt vfr rqo o-{ vs riftrurf,r o\ q< o-Ei or qqx{ Tfr fu-qr rrqr t t gsfr ror oFsor-zo ffi r1-+<r of "wrflft d frs-q il fi frquft o-rt gq^orieiT at T$ fr of sc-sqrfr t-o ez16 deq vqBps 6-wr drTr at ffi rlaqr of T{qr;r,fr oTffi fu-s fr-{i$ o\ trqq +t^.d, fu-{ Err frqq t fr ot$ sftR-ff oerFrfi c-S t t

¶99

zs.^qc uot ceT ffi q+tr .i ffi orffi of tror ffi s-{ {61 t, e-q u-d--o tg grrrrd (rorffi d qruqq t eqrFrf, dmr 3{rnkd t r scrqrfr do i frcip. oo.rz.zozq d til fufuf, n-d s-rgo fu-fl, wrd v+rel^.fr W of^,Tifr "rqrflft^d urqr fta, tw s-m-rqn d urqr frz *iirq frrn Tn, fur-d frsq n Td fr fr srqqiw Eti o1 frqfr $T GrDo{rr dnr^q'trd sil-+RT frirf, 1i.03.2024 d^qrqq t of^qr g+1, utrrff, s-mi-{rft t-o gnr GIrAyr fuio 11.03.2024 d^qeqro ffi{a fr-€oli d ftsq t W @ti slfrR-ff Hres^q-r1f, T€t at^q-i A Grfu-o.q"i fr1i6 rr.os.zozq I e1 T{ frrTuft t ft-q^qd rrrc o-r qIdT I

¶100

26.^qq vtrrqrfr t-o^qe ?F-f,fl "TEcT^{B qfr} G-i@t^er-{cTri/z) ffi qa-+ of cfr dgrfi^qqfu q{ qsFr,ft d urqr fu, t, aq ftfuf, e-d fuiro oo

¶101

¶102

gfl. q. iqt -szs/zozz

¶103

12.2024^+t srqi*-, d w d ild d ga6 oqitn se * u6 $^qw rte'c Erqr fra ererqr frrio zg.oz.zozq d refl-{ o[ifi d^q-qrq d rwl (\i-@r en$.erx.,zz) d w^{iI grr q-qrq} d gE e-qio az ri +s d^qw fia..'i urqi fue tierfi Trqfu w aqqri-rft d urqr fu, krilrT "TRq,^{fu-g rerrq snffi d srfls d gw e.qTq- $,} 44 vq +s t^{q orqr fua d6rq ftri .ri t, s-ct^gTIv rs (+) d eiffi o-qr +i A frsq it enq fft o) ilrtrErri o-{i sff qcr-{r zRqr t t s-m rflar qr.srn. df,$ d cH o1 g-or-r d sl--r^{qr qwr} o1^,r$ t I q-qfu y€ c-qTr' 42 g.q 44 qr ltr qrrf, iq{ d vn?d ffi rI-q-+ or urqr fue t, fu-d aqq^yflvr yq srfr"{q-{ d ern+rq fr el-gflq rfr ft-mrdT^qT rrmr ot esrfi Trqfu d geu sFT s{ ffi oTffi R=im 28.02.2024 r\ so frry{ fd +om rpr+ of "wmrfr o-{ ETqT fu{ fr-qr^.Isr t I^g{{ r{6^{q q-di} fu€q or-ffi d Td^qrTo $qk or^qidfto sTDqiq +i at tnrffi frft vrqo eqrFra l-fr g{ t, ca ffi oTffi r\ so kry{ Td "o Bqfu d gcq^{qr,I q{} ffi ilau d^q{qrflt el deq^rft ftaq{Tftq nt+ fr eqTFrd r€t t t}

¶104

Tsfr {s s-f,irr t^{qlfud oil-Acl} frqio zqoz. zozs d^qrtqq t 6000000,/-^(nro aru) tqi^q-qr o-{i of crd w fu-dT^q@c g,i Erir^{qrRf, or-esr} ftqm rs.os.zozs^qI frqre{ TarFH fu-qr rqr^en,

¶105

¶106

Vs.^q. iqt -ezs/zozz

¶107

frr-{^{qTtsT qPrrqrr} fri.rfi r.03.2024 o1 ofe-or-rr i s-m-qrfr t-o sm A^{.r{ qrq-o,ft} fr^qff Ti ftqot d GrTsri sTitr{dr^qa i er-tRrfl^{qrRr qqr q-fr 'fu-qr} t {s orsq vorqfr +fi o) ffi df,r d ceT t ffi oTffi ftqio za.oz.zozq d^qR'qrq fr +f, rflruftt-d-c s-{H frri^qri at rqdErflr fr^.T{ t, fu-g sf,{qrft t-fi d sM s"6^qqrfrra i-& fuqT^.rqr t et ffi r{-qrr ft=irfi rc.01.2024 trorRro o-{i d $ s-m'wrfr t-r t fuin^qffie S,f iln^{qrRd orTtcr} ftilo rs.og. 203^qI frqrr^?F-{i Eq^qslm {rqk o-t or-Bq.q slK tx fuqr {6I dt G ffi qaqt ft=iro fi.01.2024 1q-i@r^en$.siri /z)^{C rern GiliEq d wqn ft--itfi} 23.02.2024^q €drq o1 T{, ffi qfr frfuf, a-d d {fl.rt^q6t €Iqt"e -r d w t ridrq t,^fi frtn^.d' q"fq d si-T{TTr B-mrdrfr d-fi i 3r'Bq.q ta++ R=no 3o.os.zo22 d enerrr w^tierfi Bqfu or enDqeq d-rr q-qe o-{fr Eq ffi oT{qT-S^qKTfuf, 6q sqq fu-q1 B, A-g wttmryn a1^.ri frnq-rT d s-mTsT fr 3rkf,-wr gw ftq{^{q-{ qg4flr} t o1 B-m-.qrfr d-n d axr^tiqo Rqfu d w,fr EE ilqtffit o)^silfuqiq {ds-iT of^qfu'rfl flffi i-S fuqT q.i eilBq-.q rT-diT .ht w{Tmrft oTffi ( tql ctnyt=i q,1 sfu-qr fi frE a1q6^yqBpq re gi t, 3rQrif, ffi .Frffi d Td ft-{q & e-{f,rF{a at^{.rg quo qqfu} ear ftB nqo d0d t sf,rqrfr to am GilBq-s u-a"r ftri qri or

¶108

¶109

vs. . fr* -aze/zozz

¶110

das fi^qqTFrf, r-e t, E-{fu F-qq e (o) st$ffi t-w 2ooz d eiiltrf,^{iigrfi qqkqfr} ffi otffi q-{flrfua o-{t d Td fisq a (r) (z) qa$ffi rffi 2oo2 orarq'i^qrrr ra stffi \rqd 2oo2 d ffd^qTR-d entcr d Aq're{ d^qRqrq fi^tisro $qfu or Grfiqe, B-f,rqrfr t-fi d F{rq d dm Giltrrqtn t, fug E-*T s-m{"r i^tierf, 1Tqfu or srfuEriq frlS srrro dffi fr sf,{qrfr t-o. d ft-drur^q d-fl eqrFrf,^q *i r\ e-{flIfud et T$ frmrfr oTffi mrrc{ t{ fr q&f, cr{ qlfr tr

¶111

28.^qqB sfl{qrfr ilfi d^gRr e-qd frrS^,rS frfu-a nd 6irf, 06.12.2024 $ ryaq r\ Xercm qfrA-qq ftiio st.os.zozg srqiue-s sfr qq"i cfr q-{gf, tn-i fr ,r$ t, fuir-d qrrqq * sf,.qTfr ceT qE qor,tl sre-flr t of qrerq W{rm-fi Efrfrql sxqErq r)-@r +^gM ETflrf,^qfu-qr o-r 3qTflur^{q-q qum'} qqfu oT dfu{ frfteroT or T@ro-r ufrilcq P- ,Tqr t, ftnl-d ergvx Md-q-f, i-q sraaoooo/-(fii o-trs +id rnq si-Rt rwn) vri furtR-d 01^,T{, s-e rrRr ffi rp*i n 3{rifuf, Xe rtofto mr ffi @Tffi r{qq of^.r$ t^qqfr ffi df,r i onifkf, aw^{ts-€t olkfi 34s88700 (fi-{ o-tts ffinors} 3r-dT-{rfr EqTq Hrfl C F.d Xe u-rofto fuqT, fu-{ wq ffi affi cmp{ t $-f, t ,aq ernTfrfl 3Trifu'-d 6u r\ orDo. ffi qrRr qrw E\ u-d qra t

¶112

¶113

Tfl.^q. iqr -szt/zozz

¶114

ffi o-rffi ol a-q c-fr dflrfi^qr sm-f,r, fu{ sffiq dQq^{q6 ,fr} t^{qq q-6} caTrr ffi pfr , oq X3qio-o^{ilT fufR-d Erwn} T@^{aaezzoool- (fti} o-rte s-+qr-r m-Er Encfi rwn) vwi erfd-o ae. t{qtfud c-& frtn uri or o:r$ E-diqq-r-o^.F.l-tuI EcrrrIT urqr^qTR, orq et^{q-fttrT til"r} W oi-q fud-€ +qf, t-6 dw vtrsq^(z ore) z s.fr.fr.ror d r+r"r fi q!-fi-q v@clq qlrllclq Er{I qrqrarrl w q-a frfuo qrfu.q Grrtn-f, fu-qr rrq..r $ .hl ;qrurou u-cfo qql^q stl^qra trrgw E,^{s-dqn qrox} {fl d^er$iq ffi yrRT e-{flrfuf, g{ t E11 EM'r t .ft ft-s or q-o t of qerq m oTffi if sf,wrfr to arr fril ot$ s.fuo orur l-.re ft-t smn T@ d el.5-w GrYltrf, Xe u-tarfuo r or Mfrqd Tw^qr ffi ertTfud of T$^{q\ qmfi=q} vqilq^qrqrf,q + sqt-ff -qlqtlcld d ergw r€i a-&^qr lro-ft 1 gs oxor fi ffi aTffi ftex rd ud^{q}.q q-€l} B r

¶115

2s.^qa ao fu-dT^qrez g.f iliT^q'R-d sntcr ftiro rs.os.zozt fr itror or^qfi t of errtffi^q'er i Tftrq sil-nfi rc06/2023 ftiro rg.o+.2s23 fr^qp4q fi crkd 3il-taT foirf, 1s.03.2023 *\ g-+fr td gq {o sntqr o\ 3rrrr{fl frrd qri o1 warqor or ergtu fu-+r t, fu-ir-d eio,ff, sri{<-o.^qfl o-r 3rft-f,rn t of^qriT ra $rfift we^q sFfd cfuqr o-r^qleFr m fufl fr0rn eirqrq-ootert o1 yF ii H-gE gv fu+ 3r-tcr cftd

¶116

¶117

yfl. q. iqt -ezt/zozz

¶118

fu-qr^rrqr t,^q-qfu snr 14 si$ffi Tfe 2oo2 d ff( sifu-f, e ft-geif d vrqaT^.ra d 3rgvq dpqt 6T eiftoqq r€t fuqr^rrqr, fr-{^,fr sil-Aqr^qrRo o.q fuqr Tqr I^qqB sf,rqrfr ceT^gItI 91gf, wqr-q ftq-6 zs.o+. zozs I^qrurq t rffifi srfie{^{g qft-q-m} frrd T} nsa\ o-r cPd-qrq fo-+r^rr+r t, GTerfd^qrsq futqFrT{fr srMt d e-f,I-cT^q tqt^qrq d^{qrqr qror} t o1 zfr ceT g=Hri d +i1-q scR'ard c-& g.Trt ilq5qTq gtr cetq oTffi qfi qFrx 3ntcr crR-d fu-qr {qr t, e6r^q-6 o.q^qEsTgi. d^qror t o1^"eqr B-mr-qrfr t-f, d^qTEef, srffi t srflfu-fi oeai d 3i-gvq e fr-Seri ol^{yrrar q{} e-{ET fuqT", ffi wge *o< ftffiT^qm" g,f aq sfuo w t^qrfun ftfo or s-q)-,T or or-tyT clftd fu-qr^rTqr B r^gcl irEd fr furo 22.06.2023 o1 srff{fi^{qeT gr-{} erq-c d s'pr wgd qcflr#r t 3n-6-r{ Rrd eTD-q( 3{ffi al{r Rnrfi rs gor$ zozz o-r ffi^grir 1T.qrft-a 6 fr-goir d^q-cq -?.{11..{lsii.{ t q-a of cfr t, C fudl qme g,f d M frq1-{d^{yffr .h{} d x"r^g1rgFr6n A 3ffif, dem' at T$ Hqfu^qq-tr rq{ 781 / 4 Yfrfl o.osz t€i err-ftf^qrr< otorcT$^g.f fl^{dft-f,Gil-fur.s} ffi Ed tg s-ggf,^qrA-<n d^{vrqef{ ti} wgd^fuqr Tqr t, ffil o--€t fr Trfr seT^{q{ 3rT'qqc ai!ft} fu{iq,^G{arqr frrr rpn d ffaq^{tr fr.r of T$ {rRr} or sds rfr t^gq oF-sot's^{q orftoerq fu-fl rqT}

¶119

¶120

yii. q. f'q< -aze/zozz

¶121

t^{zn1 ,it'r} qfir d fu$-€ uuft^{qfr gxr} ot$^snck, 3{arqr srn[rilqn sflrqrfr t-fi d elmut5wx cIw r€t goir, c-qfu^qe ftffi{o des t at fr-'r Wqr kci-o 2s.01.2022 d frtE 3rrd-<-o' cq i Gilqfu^3r}q-tn{i rqo fu-+r W sf,wrfr d6 d^{grtl q-{} ft{;q zs.os. zozz d^qrurq r\ GrMfu srlqrifi or ft*rotol o{d aq roft^qa o\ ftrt Ti Flq{ t^{lgiI, -d ''fr fuqr} .rqr, ffi qfr qqrs d r+re{ *iflq of .l-$ t, fu-g sTBqd 3Tffi t^{q'qq q:} d^qrqq t rtr frv-q i omriq oerq fuq fu zfr cqi 6Kr frrr tf+l-r d fr_w t e'r{ srrcfu ertqrd-fi rtgo rS frrw^rrql

¶122

sf,t-qrfr d-f, d 3{kf,ffir^gM ild r-ql^rr-qT B fr^q-e u-qo eruff<l or frrrorq^gw t, ae eil-a-c-{^qeT o-r frfi-o ro eqrfua rfr E n yq^g*l sEd^q rTTfrq^{q.c.v@qFrrFI gril} Esif, zors⁽¹⁾ gq.ft.w.d. 3rkfl fusdr ET-+rs fus-q dq-ic gfuqTq elq fr qr+ftq va-oq qrqrrq fl-{r M vf, g's d Er-sRiT sT-ft{ fufr}s fus-€ .fuqd s# W^{erq n qffi} R,r€tdt d riEffif, fu-fl r-qr B, fu-{ EH fis or^q-n t at w Eftgo rfuee g,f d *ro s-oEqrfr^qer i sqRqo ++a ot{ oea rS {sr, GTQrld fuf,r^qftrez g,f d vrqeT^q6 oe.q^q-.re r€l fu-qr^rrqr of s-orqrfr t-o^gm iRa of^.r$ *'r r1a-+r d neai o1 zot ceT i {+ori r€t fuqT B, qfu GTrqfu u-rgf, fu-qr t, e-c fuf,r qme grf d

¶123

24 gfl.q.iqt -eze/zozz

¶124

6ru^qfl EM"T t^ontvtqTR-d frqr^.rqr t of utt qs i eu-iqeT w t frq qqcr d'qrwq t m.T sfr T$ rrRr o1 w{rq-fl-fr ffif,ri m T{ B, erqarr oil-qfu orrqfffi rgn ffi^qri or des^y.re fu-qT^.rqr EtdT, d^gr srqFf{r t rors r€r fu-qr ET B?Ff,T of fudT qffie g,t fliT ft-l' EM"T orrlqrrr q[ vrfr-flT qr I

¶125

d srq wfu-qn 3rffi i fuflr^qfuee g,t d^qqq u-{gf, ftd^{.rt q'car qe} i^qm ra (l) rrffi \rqe^2oo2 d cafi Trg-qa fr sifu-f, e frSGir d s?rc R-S d crgr{{ orrtfi e-tgfr ft-{io of^qorfi Grar+f frr at^rT{ e-iT 1iftr oT s"f{ T& t Vq R-S e.l.lq t d er5vm dfu rg+n A fr--s-€ 3rqrilfi crw dri G fr{r6{q o-s arft ca o\ H-qh( frrn^{q.d qr} {rer sTftoerc^q-& t, ilc^qrRf, enicr en$iq^q-car c, d GTIEI{^{q{ q"R-d} +iT^{qnr qr}rr,} dr frE rlqo enisr d-or ftex {d crt^qY,q c-€l a-6r^qT 1rcFf,I r

¶126

Gnilfir^qeT t {fl noror i ftiro ro.oz.zozs o\ ed.q. sosl/2023^qrr 1e3^{qr.s.fr. qraqbo} sao (1) E.c.H. tr$9f, .F'{ eTe-qf, sIffi + fr-{-q quglcqcf, oTffi 6 ftvo i iifl-i ftd qri q,T Gr-Jirr fu-qr^.rqr B t ra'fr' sf,{qrfr cer trM^gfl 3rilfi ot ot$ frfu( sqrs !Ng(^;r€t fu-qr^rrqr, fu-g w<ro rrq-rflT t^qfl nos { sTkm{ur^qfteTor o-ror, dr tqT Te^{qFII qrf,T} t 01^qlB-q-d slfffi i zrot ceT o) eTh orkd o-{i d t ur+qu ov

¶127

¶128

qs. q. i,qt -azs/zozz

¶129

or*rer oaFr fuqr t, frt( dI crqaT^qa 3rkfi{q A o.*1 ffi ' sffifrd i fu-qr q;or {rT s-o-ior d e-qf, fu-fl^rrqr t,^q6 {fl srkf,-rq d erri ot .nrffi t', enri( lroror i fi6Fq frtfi (t+rfq @1 o-e rq=IT ol de{ c +m-r erqa frd^,T-i oeIq d frs-q t s-an frrn^qd or 3r-gtq fu-qr^rrqr t t^qfl rtqf i^qr+ftq BEkrrI^{qrq[f,q grqr go-ql-f,} RiE rwre .q erq frw fi-flrft^{qrqrg gs} GrdI 2oos \rfl. fr.fi.^(fuft-+a) ,,0, t cffia slftqd or-g$i,fiq t, orQrtfl {fl fts^qr ro t' of t$^qITd fr enieo^qeT rrflq^{qrqrdq ii} vqo,^qRsK o-{i d 6q r{ilq t t w^{efi-{-{q dr {isn} +i^{of oil-q{q?DdTT€i B} t^qc{ ftqot d rflrq sTrdqo seT^gTrt tr{{-d sTr-$q. 3osa/2023 ftilAa fo-qr utET t t 33. frft^gs aeqi at^rqrcqr o-r sTBf,-{sr EH M^{qI q-g-q-f,r} t^qfi nBf, frrr qu+r frts wrq-o e)-fi ReN Td^{qrt qtq} t, fu-g 3rTfuq-s qmr foiro 30.03.2022 ffi qtrtr fuiro fisi.2024 gs qfl ftf,iift r1-++ d sryiiiur i vrqq al .r$ ffi oTffi fuiffi 28.02.2024, srq fr fu-f,r qmz g,f ETvr crRd 3Tr-tyr ftqio. rs.oe.zoza frB G^qfu-n d ffia o1^.r$ oTffir eqrFra *i {t q$-d d-oa 3ilTrsr frri^qrt frrq t I 34. {qD sflqrft d-o sm rqo fu-i Ti fufuf, ild d^qnqq t m^{.d qrqE.ft} d' 3r-gr{ri ffi dtrT

¶130

¶131

Tfl.^q. frt -eze/zozz

¶132

d^qeT t +a srEfu-Se frn^qr To.r t, fu-g w+ $Eqq'qi Tg ffi 6rffi fsfi G sfu-n d frqftd Et{a $-d eqrFm g$ t <q urrr^'r7 (s)^(q) (fr) $-ffi gqe 2oo2 A 3iil.fd Mrd dfter sM of^.d ETffi d ordq elBf, o-^qro Hqfu o-r 3rTfucrcq x"ft^qfu d cs{^q g-{-terTBd ftrn^qri ot eiffior oTko-i'T o\ c-fl-{ ot r{^g * u.n s-<f i^qmftq vqtrq^;qrqrd.q d^gm erertrf,w sTrstflr qRq-{ qt6{$-q fo. fr-s-€ srsil-6' crft-d (zoog) a g{T. fr.fr. soo^ti cffiT srft-q( or-Jirwfrq t, fus-d orsrlq sTBwur^q. strftfre o1 erqrfl o-{i^q,1 erErorR-dr w*or t r

¶133

3s. rT) u6r vcrqrfr tt-o-^gmr iRd oilfuqcq quli Hro 30.03.2022 (q-i@{ Giir,/3) $-ir eqrFm g$ t t Hr2{ A ffi Wqfl^{fucio 18.01.2024 aq} s-6-f{r{ frqio z+.or.zozt d ci-gsiur d lnsrq of^,r$ {mft orffi ftqro za.oz.zoz+ fi sqTFro E{ t, dnr ilq {s $-d EIffi d^qR'orrq fr $trc ffi B-ffiwrfr^q.qTT- at^qtflr-( sdq^ril-fr d^qa n ft-qr rrqr fuo-q r,il-oT q;t Reri rfr {sT qT lr-m-f,r, efu silTrftI or ffi fdr o) urqr rrRT siil{qrfr d'o r) s cftyrf,^qlq r{Bf, srqs frf,[qr u'ril frB wqo^gq sfq-d t, fuE nfu oTr-ildr-m csT at dr$ Sfq-rT u-.rd r-S EY-fr^ys saffi ffi 6Tffi $o^qTfr.T-i t, w{

¶134

Ts.^(. iqt -ezs/zozz

¶135

oTinr errf{fi ceT t ffi ddr o} eTffi ffi qri or o)-$ no-qq rdi ffif,r I

¶136

oifuq sTrtqr

¶137

frffir d^{q-{Tcr q qtiEo} va griT s-sgf, gfl.q. frrr q++r ft-rio 2s.01.2022 (qi-@i erx / t) d fr-$-€^{qifuo q-arqflr} tg ftrw o-"d Sg ts ffi'f,ri oc frq5r+ri Gifuq Gil-t$ e<r< fu-qr^qrar t,'1:- frT r1+rr fuiro 2s.01.2022 1q-i@I erx,zr) d' fryq^ti u-rgo^g*r.q. fi-ni of^qrft B't

¶138

2:- Gil-Bc-s rpr+ furo 3o.o3.zo2z 1q-t@I erx,/e) frB fu{-€ \q (Bf, eqFK *oq eiqrw ot qrfr tr

¶139

3:- ffi q+cl fuiro fi.01.2024, ccFl-cFI frTrm 24.o1.zozt F^qfl q-d{r d ergr*"r fr t+qq of T$ ffi orffi ffilq 2s.s2.2s2a frB rs cfu-qr d ffif,^qq'Fra Et*r $-d Eti t erqrr< o1 qifr t'r

¶140

4i- ffi oTdqrfr fu{io 2s.02.2024 d qRqtq it sf,t-qrfr q-qio + qr6qE vrffq .lrfr d qeT { c-{rc fo-qr^rrqr 1-a wEfu-d-e 3rdu^{qq yqrq} &q eqrFrf, *i * 3ilrmfl fuqr^qrn t t

¶141

5:- fuf,r^qffie g.f dr-n^qRf, GTrtcT ft{16 rs.os.zozg frD fr--s-q d--+q ftq-fi^qtq n di t erqrr< fu-qr^qrnr t t

¶142

¶143

vs.^{q. tq<} -szs/zozz

¶144

6:-^{riqfi qqfu} ssn ltis 7a1/4^qlTw-f, o.oe7 tqe( d-w o_{rfi-Sd endsr^q'R ffi f,-f,$ra \rs fuf,r grt tnt or-fuTs^qem oaf,zsrilro.rq d^qe{ fr s-{tqrB-d frrq^qral B r

¶145

7:- 3{rn{f,ruT d^qxr re (a) wr$qfr Tf,d zooz d ffT dwn Hlqfu titro drqc o.r Efi^qrq fr.n a-<r+tgx t sTTi 5q E-r sqdm o-{i tg E-d-, d, erqer sf,wrfr to grrar eo kfl{ s{qkr^qr{r rc (+) wffi^gqe 2002 \d ftqq e (1) (z) irr$Rfr sel 2oo2 d crqilii^{q1 q-o}rcn} Xfro^qr-f,{ o-{i gs d-tt^qdyTq r)fu nfrf, or ent o1 o.rffi ot TscErAT YrW eYrft I

¶146

a:- siil{qrfr *o o) orTtRrd fu-qr^qror t o1 +drfr dor 6q16 4^gm wn of^{.T$ q"M} ffi nftr^qff ft-{i6 t e^{qfrsrd qrq} sBo vmrqifr qqTq- q oi sil-Tffi 3e 6rd fufl{ + eiqq qrqir 6-{ fr wqt

¶147

GilArT g.d^qrqrtrq t eno ftqrfi rs.rz.zoz+ o) slBd fuqr t

¶148

q!-dg{ ffi:-tg.tz.zozq

¶149

)-\ (rrqF-{rs (ffiq orDroffi) $.otx.E.^q. c'., vq uffis.ra

¶150

Ms Mobile Shopee v. Bank of Baroda

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

Ms Mobile Shopee v. Bank of Baroda

Case brief

What is this about?

What did the court decide?

What the court decided

A compact analysis

Issues for consideration

Statutes considered

Parties & counsel

Coram

Case details

Similar cases

Idbi Bank versus Navratna Jain

Icici Bank Limited versus Bolbum Aloo Bhandar

Sagar Automobiles versus Union Bank of India

Idbi Bank versus Surendra Kumar

Zuber Khan versus Bank of Baroda

Chidambara Estate Developers versus Prudent Arc Limited