Dismissed
Aditya Bhatnagar v. Punjab National Bank
DRTSA/1037/2023
What the court decided
AI extract
Outcome
Dismissed
Issue for consideration
Whether the present Special Appeal is barred by the principle of res judicata as a previous Special Appeal on the same cause of action was finally decided on 22.10.2024.
¶1
CONTD. ORDER-SHEET
¶2
PAGE No
¶3
CASE No.......
¶4
| DATE | DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER | REMARK |
|---|---|---|
| sA1037 06n2124 3 |
NonefortheApplicant ShriManojShah,AdvfortheRespondent Bankjointhrough V.C |
|
| OnmatterbeingtakenRespondent Counselapprisedthatonsame causeof actiontheApplicantextoleducation societyhasfiledanotherSANo.67l22 whichhasalreadybeenfinallydecided by orderdated22102124andSAhasbeen allowed. RespondentCounselfurthersubmitsthat familymemberApplicantAditiya Bhatnagar hasfieldthis SAatsamecause ofactionwhichisnotmaintainable onthe ground praysfordismissalof thisSA. |
||
| AsobjectionraisedbyRespondent Counsel, perusalofrecorditrevealsthat allgroundshavealready beentakenon 02102124onrecord. |
||
| SinceApplicant sideisabsentandon objectionraisedbytheRespondentsideit revealsthatonsame causeofaction earlierSANo.67122hasalreadybeen decidedthissubsequentSAgovernedby principalofresjudicataforthereason in opinionofthisBenchobjectionraisedby theRespondentCounselislegaloneand tenable therctbrethis SAbeingdismissed forwantofprosecutionaswellasbarred asperprincipalofresjudicata. |
¶5
PAGE No
¶6
CONTD. ORDER-SHEET
¶7
CASE No.
¶8
| DATE | DESCRTPTION OFTHE ORDER | REMARK |
|---|---|---|
| Recordbeconsignedtothe record room. | ||
| asPatel) idingOfficer DRT:JABALPUR (M.P.&C.G.) |
Issues for consideration
2 issues framed by the court
AI extract
Whether the present Special Appeal is barred by the principle of res judicata as a previous Special Appeal on the same cause of action was finally decided on 22.10.2024.
Whether the Special Appeal should be dismissed for want of prosecution given the Applicant's absence and the valid objection raised by the Respondent.
Parties & counsel
AI extract
- applicant
Applicant
- respondent
Respondent
Case details
As recorded by the court registry
All orders in this case
2 orders share this CNR
- Order 1 · Sh.ram Niwas Patel
- Order 2 — this page · Sh.ram Niwas Patel
Similar cases
Judgements on the same questions, provisions and authorities, from every court